Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shir HaShirim · Maamar 3
לריח שמניך טובים שמן תורק שמך על כן עלמות אהבוך
For Fragrance, Your Oils Are Good
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
Contemplation, the “wine” of the Torah, moves only a heart that can be moved; but the Torah itself, the “oil” drawn from G‑d’s supernal wisdom and higher still, reaches even a sealed heart, so that “the maidens,” too, come to love G‑d.
The maamar in brief
The Torah is called both wine and oil. Wine is contemplation of how G‑d continually creates the world: it reveals the hidden “secret” and produces love and awe, making the Jewish people a “bride” who receives G‑d’s light. But some hearts stay sealed; these are the “maidens.” For them the remedy is oil, the Torah itself. Like oil poured from an upturned vessel, the Torah has come down into physical letters, stories and laws, yet its lowest elements have the highest root. Its letters are “horses” that carry a person upward, though G‑d wants the mind engaged, or at least a humble longing for Him. In the laws of the Oral Torah the very essence of supernal Chochmah is present (“oil poured forth”), while the letters and narratives of Scripture, and the secrets of Kabbalah, give a “fragrance” from a level higher still. The maamar maps this onto the three thirds of study, Scripture, Mishnah and Talmud, and concludes that both levels are needed. Because the Torah’s source is so high, it can engrave itself even in the animal soul and the physical heart.
Outline
- Wine: contemplation and the brideContemplation of G‑d’s kingship reveals the hidden G‑dliness and produces love and awe; the “maidens” are those whose hearts stay sealed.¶1
- Oil poured forth: the letters of the TorahThe Torah, like an upturned vessel, descended into letters whose root is highest; the letters are “horses” that lift a person when the mind is engaged.¶2–3
- Longing for G‑d’s kindnessOne unmoved by contemplation should humble himself and long for G‑dliness; that longing, and even bare faith, draw down G‑d’s kindness.¶3–4
- Supernal Chochmah in the lawsThe very essence of G‑d’s wisdom is clothed in the practical laws, the “beard” onto which the anointing oil runs down; its root is so high it is also “fragrant oil.”¶5–6
- Betrothal and marriageFollowing the Midrash, fragrance is an external flow and poured oil an inner one; through accepting G‑d’s kingship, every Jew receives both in Torah study.¶7–8
- Why oil reaches the sealed heartOil stands above wine, as supernal Chochmah above Binah; the higher the level, the lower it reaches, even into the physical heart.¶9
- Scripture, Mishnah and TalmudMishnah and Talmud, whose wisdom is grasped, are poured oil; Scripture and Kabbalah, known only as fragrance, come from a higher source; both are needed.¶10
Key concepts
- Wine and oilיין ושמן
- Two images of the Torah: wine is contemplation (Binah), which reveals what is hidden; oil is the Torah itself, rooted in supernal Chochmah and above.
- One whose heart is sealedמי שלבו אטום
- A person whom contemplation does not move to love and awe; the “maidens” (alamos) of the verse.
- Oil poured forthשמן תורק
- Oil poured from an upturned vessel: the highest essence comes down into the lowest place, the laws and letters of the Torah.
- Fragranceריח
- A glimmer that reaches one without being grasped, as in reading Scripture or studying Kabbalah; it comes from an even higher level, the “fragrant oil.”
- Bride and bridegroomכלה וחתן
- The Congregation of Israel (and the Oral Torah) receiving from G‑d (and the Written Torah); betrothal is an external flow, marriage an inner one.
- Letters as horsesאותיות נקראו סוסים
- The letters of Torah and prayer carry a person far beyond his own level, though G‑d wants the mind engaged as well.
- Supernal Chochmahחכמה עילאה
- G‑d’s own wisdom, whose very essence is clothed in the practical laws of the Torah.
Wine: contemplation and the bride ¶1
“For fragrance, your oils are good; your name is oil poured forth; therefore the maidens love You.”
The maamar opens with Song of Songs 1:3, which it will read as a description of two ways the Torah reaches a person: as “fragrance” and as “oil poured forth.” The closing phrase, “therefore the maidens love You,” is the goal: that even those not yet stirred should come to love G‑d.
(רבות בשה״ש ע״פ זה ובפסוק שובי שובי השולמית3 ור״פ לך לך ויקרא ספ״ג נשא פי״ג בקרבן נחשון גבי בלולה בשמן ור״פ תבא) הנה פעמים נקרא התורה יין ופעמים שמן4 כי טובים דודיך מיין.5
(See the Midrash Rabbah on the Song of Songs on this verse, and on the verse “Return, return, O Shulamite”; and at the beginning of Lech Lecha; Vayikra [Rabbah], end of chapter 3; Naso, chapter 13, on the offering of Nachshon, regarding “mixed with oil”; and at the beginning of Tavo.) Now, sometimes the Torah is called wine and sometimes oil: “for Your love is better than wine.”
The parenthesis lists places in the Midrash that discuss this verse and the image of oil. The Midrash on the Song of Songs likens the Torah both to wine and to oil, and the Alter Rebbe will show that these are two different ways the Torah works on a person.
הענין דכתיב (זכרי׳ ט׳ י״ז) ותירוש ינובב6 בתולות ובגמ׳ פ״ק דב״ב (די״ב) מי שלבו אטום כו׳ היין מפקחו נכנס יין יצא סוד7 השמחה שהי׳ בהסתר מתגלה כו׳.
The matter [is this]. It is written (Zechariah 9:17), “and new wine makes the maidens flourish”; and in the Gemara, first chapter of Bava Basra (12b): “one whose heart is sealed” etc., “wine opens him”; “wine enters, the secret comes out”: the joy that was hidden is revealed, etc.
Wine is a revealer: it opens a closed heart and brings out what was hidden. The Talmud plays on the fact that the Hebrew words for “wine” (yayin) and “secret” (sod) both have the numerical value seventy, so when wine goes in the secret comes out; here the hidden “secret” is an inner joy.
ובעבודת ה׳ כי טובים דודיך מיין פי׳ דודיך אהוי״ר בהתלהבות הבא מהתבוננות שהוא בחי׳ יין בינה להתבונן איך שמלכותך עלמא דאתגלייא הוא בחינת התגלות מאין ליש מחיה בחי׳ מקום וזמן וממשלתך בכל דור ודור8 כו׳.
And in the service of G‑d, “for Your love is better than wine” means: “Your love” is love and awe with fervor that comes from contemplation, which is the level of wine, Binah (understanding): to contemplate how “Your kingship,” the revealed world, is the level of revelation, [bringing] something from nothing, giving life to the dimensions of space and time, “and Your dominion is in every generation,” etc.
In divine service, “wine” stands for Binah, careful contemplation. One reflects on how G‑d’s kingship, the “revealed world,” constantly brings everything into being from nothing, including space and time themselves, and from this reflection comes fervent love and awe, “Your love.”
וזהו בחי׳ הסוד המוסתר בתוך העולמות עד שנדמה העולם ליש בפני עצמו. והדחילו והרחימו שנולד מזה ההתבוננות יצא הסוד הנ״ל כאלו נראה בחי׳ האלקות איך דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב9 ממש כידוע כו׳.
And this is the level of the secret that is hidden within the worlds, to the point that the world seems to be a thing existing in its own right. And the awe and love born of this contemplation are “the secret comes out” mentioned above, as though the level of G‑dliness were seen, how “all before Him is considered as truly nothing,” as is known, etc.
The “secret” is the G‑dliness hidden inside creation, so well hidden that the world seems to exist on its own. When contemplation produces love and awe, that secret “comes out”: a person feels, as if seeing it, that everything is as nothing before G‑d.
(וזהו ענין מי גילה לבני רז זה10 מי היינו בינה והוא ענין גילוי החסדים המכוסים ביסוד אימא היינו גילוי האהוי״ר כו׳).
(And this is the meaning of “Who revealed this secret to My children?”: “Who” (Mi) is Binah; and it is the revelation of the concealed kindnesses (chasadim) in the Yesod of Imma, that is, the revelation of love and awe, etc.)
The Talmud records G‑d’s question “Who revealed this secret to My children?” The word “Who” (Mi) is a Kabbalistic name for Binah; the “concealed kindnesses” in the Yesod of Imma are the love and awe latent in understanding, which contemplation brings into the open.
וידוע שכנ״י נק׳ כלה והוא בהיות שהסוד יצא בהתגלו׳ שמאיר אור אלקות בנשמות ישראל. וזה נק׳ כד קבילת דכר
And it is known that the Congregation of Israel is called “bride,” and this is when the secret comes out into revelation, so that the light of G‑dliness shines in the souls of Israel. And this is called “when she has received the male”
The Jewish people as a whole are called the “bride” of G‑d. They become a bride in this full sense when the hidden G‑dliness is revealed and shines in their souls, which the Zohar calls “when she has received the male.”
(בזהר בא דל״ח ע״ב וע׳ בזהר הרקיע שם ובסה״מ ד״ט ע״א סי׳ כ״א) שהקב״ה נק׳ חתן.
(in the Zohar, Bo, 38b; and see the Zohar HaRakia there, and the work abbreviated Seh”m, folio 9a, section 21), for the Holy One, blessed be He, is called “bridegroom.”
The Zohar calls G‑d the “bridegroom” who gives to the Congregation of Israel, His bride. The parenthesis gives the Zohar’s place and two further references on the passage.
וכלה לית לה מגרמה כלום כ״א מה שנותנים לה מלמעלה כי בועליך עושיך כו׳ וכבוד ה׳ עליך זרח11
And a bride has nothing of her own, only what is given her from above: “for your Husband is your Maker,” etc., and “the glory of G‑d has shone upon you,”
A bride, in this image, has nothing of her own; all her light is given from above. The verses from Isaiah say that her Husband is her Maker and that G‑d’s glory has shone upon her: her light comes from Him.
כי אשב בחושך12 ה׳ אור לי ואתקרי׳ בחי׳ נערה בה׳ ה׳ גבורות דדכורא שנותן לה בביאה ראשונה שהם דודיך הנ״ל עיקרם מעלמא דאתכסייא
“though I sit in darkness, G‑d is a light for me.” And she is called the level of na’arah (maiden) with a hei: the five Gevuros of the male, which he gives her at the first union; these are “Your love” mentioned above, whose essence is from the hidden world,
The verse from Micah adds that even in darkness her light is G‑d. The Kabbalists read the word na’arah (maiden), written with a final hei, as hinting at the “five Gevuros” the male gives her; these are identified with the “love” of the verse, which originates in the hidden world above.
אלא שיוצאים דרך נוק׳ כו׳ (וע׳ בפע״ח שער ק״ש שעל המטה פי״א ד״ה לקוטים ופרק ו׳ ובמק״מ ר״פ צו)
except that they come out by way of Nukva, etc. (And see Pri Etz Chaim, Gate of the Shema at Bedtime, chapter 11, the section beginning “Likkutim,” and chapter 6; and Mikdash Melech at the beginning of Tzav.)
Though the five Gevuros originate above, they reach revelation only through Nukva, the receiving feminine level. The parenthesis points to where the Arizal’s Pri Etz Chaim and the Zohar commentary Mikdash Melech discuss this.
ועד לא קבילת שעדיין לא זרח אור אלקות בתוכה ונק׳ נער בלא ה׳ גבורות הנ״ל והוא מי שלבו אטום כבתולה13 שלא נתפעל בדו״ר מענין התבוננות עלמא דאתגלייא הנ״ל ונקרא עלמות
And before she has received, when the light of G‑dliness has not yet shone within her, she is called na’ar, without the hei, [that is,] without the five Gevuros mentioned above. And this is one whose heart is sealed, like a virgin, who has not been stirred to awe and love by the contemplation of the revealed world mentioned above; and [these] are called “maidens” (alamos).
Before the bride has received that light she is called na’ar, written without the hei, as the word appears in parts of Deuteronomy. In a person this is the one “whose heart is sealed,” unmoved by contemplation, and such people are the “maidens” (alamos) of the verse.
(ועמ״ש ע״פ עיני כל שאז נק׳ כל חסר ה׳ דכלה ה״ג דדכורא כו׳ ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה יחיינו מיומים כו׳ ועמ״ש ע״פ וארשתיך לי כו׳ וע״פ ואשה כי תדור כו׳ וע״פ כי תצא כו׳ ואח״כ תבא אליה כו׳ וע״פ טוב לחסות):14151617
(And see what is written on “The eyes of all,” that then she is called kol (all), lacking the hei of kalah (bride), [which is] the five Gevuros of the male, etc.; and see what is written about this in the maamar beginning “He will revive us after two days,” etc.; and see what is written on “I will betroth you to Me,” etc., and on “And if a woman vows,” etc., and on “When you go out,” etc., “and afterward you shall come to her,” etc., and on “It is good to take refuge.”)
This parenthesis sends the reader to several other maamarim that develop the same idea. One of them notes that kalah (bride) without its hei is just kol (all): a bride who has not yet received the five Gevuros of the male.
The first paragraph introduces the verse and the first image, wine: contemplation of how G‑d creates and rules the world produces love and awe, and through this the Jewish people become a “bride” who has received G‑d’s light. It then defines the problem the maamar will solve: the “maidens,” whose hearts stay sealed and unmoved by such contemplation.
The five Gevuros that the male gives at the “first union” are a theme of the Arizal (Pri Etz Chaim, Gate of the Shema at Bedtime): they are what make the feminine a complete receiver. The play between na’ar and na’arah, and kol and kalah, reads the missing or present letter hei as the presence or absence of that gift.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2לריח שמניך טובים שמן תורק שמך על כן עלמות אהבוך · Song of Songs 1:3
- 3
- 4פעמים נקרא התורה יין ופעמים שמן · Shir HaShirim Rabbah 1:9
- 5כי טובים דודיך מיין · Song of Songs 1:2
- 6
- 7נכנס יין יצא סוד · Sanhedrin 38a:3–4
- 8וממשלתך בכל דור ודור · Psalms 145:13
- 9דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב · Zohar, Introduction 20:188–22:199
- 10מי גילה לבני רז זה · Shabbat 88a:8
- 11וכבוד ה׳ עליך זרח · Isaiah 60:1
- 12כי אשב בחושך ה׳ אור לי · Micah 7:8
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- 17
Oil poured forth: the letters of the Torah ¶2–3
2והעצה שיהי׳ אף בחי׳ עלמות אהבוך הוא בחי׳ שמן לריח שמניך1 טובים2. והתורה נק׳ שמן תורק שהורק מכלי אל כלי שמה שלמטה בא למעלה
And the counsel so that there be also the level of “the maidens love You” is the level of oil: “for fragrance, your oils are good.” And the Torah is called “oil poured forth” (shemen turak), [oil] that is poured from vessel to vessel, so that what was below comes above,
The remedy for the sealed heart is the second image, oil, which stands for the Torah itself. The phrase “oil poured forth” describes oil poured from one vessel into another, where the vessel is turned upside down.
שהוא מתהפך כו׳ אז עולה הריח משולי הכלי הראשון ובמלואו משמן הי׳ הריח למטה כנ״ל כו׳
for it is turned over, etc.; then the fragrance rises from the bottom of the first vessel, whereas while it was full of oil the fragrance was below, as mentioned above, etc.
When a vessel of oil is full, its fragrance stays down at the level of the oil. When it is emptied by being turned over, the fragrance rises from the bottom of the first vessel: what was lowest is now on top.
והנמשל שהתורה נשתלשלה בעניני גשמיות וסיפורי מעשיות ואותיות גשמיות ה׳ בחכמה יסד ארץ3 אבא יסד ברתא4 שמתהפך מה שלמטה למעלה ומה שלמעלה למטה כו׳.
And the point of the analogy is that the Torah came down, step by step, into physical matters, narratives of events and physical letters: “G‑d founded the earth with wisdom”; “Abba founded the daughter”; so that what is below is turned upward and what is above downward, etc.
The Torah likewise came down from G‑d’s wisdom into physical things, stories and written letters. The verse “G‑d founded the earth with wisdom” and the Zohar’s “Abba (Chochmah) founded the daughter (Malchus)” say that the highest level is lodged in the lowest, so the order is inverted.
וזהו שמן תורק שמך כל התורה הם שמותיו של הקב״ה56 אז לריח שמניך כו׳ ואותיות נקראו סוסים שבאים מהשתלשלות רבות מעלמא דדכורא בחי׳ שמן כו׳
And this is “your name is oil poured forth”: the whole Torah is the Names of the Holy One, blessed be He; then [comes] “for fragrance, your oils,” etc. And the letters are called “horses,” for they come through many stages of descent from the masculine world, the level of oil, etc.
The whole Torah is made of G‑d’s Names, and so it is “your name is oil poured forth.” The letters are called “horses” because, though they come down through many stages, they carry a person back up; their source is the “masculine world,” the level of oil.
(And it is called “oil poured forth,” which is turned over, etc., because the letters, although they are below intellect and the emotive attributes (middos), and are called “stones” in Sefer Yetzirah, being the level of the inanimate,
Letters seem to be the lowest part of thought and speech, below intellect and feeling. Sefer Yetzirah calls letters “stones,” like inanimate objects that have no life of their own.
אבל שרש האותיות והדומם מקורם למעלה מהשכל אלא שהוא כחותם המתהפך910 כו׳ ועמ״ש ע״פ מזמור שיר חנכת הבית מענין אותיות ואבנים כו׳ וע״פ ויגש אליו יהודה כו׳.
yet the root of the letters and of the inanimate has its source above intellect, only it is like an inverted seal, etc. And see what is written on “A psalm, a song for the dedication of the House,” concerning letters and stones, etc., and on “And Yehudah approached him,” etc.
Yet the source of the letters, as of the inanimate, is above intellect; like a seal, what is highest ends up lowest when it is impressed. The parenthesis names two maamarim that discuss letters and stones.
וזהו לריח שמניך שנמשכין משמן המריח שהוא בחי׳ ומדרגת שמן המשחה. ועמ״ש מענין אפרסמונא דכיא בביאור ע״פ מי יתנך כו׳ ועמ״ש מענין שמן המשחה)
And this is “for fragrance, your oils,” which are drawn from the fragrant oil, which is the level and rank of the anointing oil. And see what is written concerning “pure balsam” in the explanation on “O that you were [as my brother],” etc.; and see what is written concerning the anointing oil)
The “fragrance of your oils” comes from the fragrant oil, which is compared to the anointing oil of the Temple, a level above ordinary oil. The parenthesis points to other places on the “pure balsam” and the anointing oil.
(later on), in Parshas Naso, on “This was the dedication of the altar on the day it was anointed,” etc.; and in the Ramaz on Parshas Emor (89), regarding “that supernal oil,” etc.
The reference continues: a maamar in Parshas Naso on the dedication of the altar “on the day it was anointed,” and the Ramaz, a commentary on the Zohar, which speaks of a “supernal oil.”
וע׳ באגה״ק ד״ה ויעש דוד בענין שרש האותיות שמקורן הוא משכל הנעלם וקדמות השכל כו׳
And see Iggeres HaKodesh, the section beginning “And David made,” concerning the root of the letters, whose source is the hidden intellect and the beginning of intellect, etc.
Iggeres HaKodesh, the fourth part of Tanya, explains that the letters are rooted in the “hidden intellect” and in the “beginning of intellect,” a level above revealed thought. This supports the claim that the lowly letters come from very high.
ועמ״ש ס״פ מקץ בד״ה נר חנוכה14 מצוה כו׳ שאותיות התורה שרשן למעלה מעלה מבחי׳ התורה כו׳
And see what is written at the end of Parshas Miketz, in the maamar beginning “The Chanukah lamp is a mitzvah,” etc., that the letters of the Torah are rooted far, far above the level of the Torah [itself], etc.
In Torah Ohr, in the maamar on the Chanukah lamp, the Alter Rebbe teaches that the letters of the Torah are rooted even higher than the Torah’s content. The written form is thus not a mere container for ideas.
וע״ש שבתורה נאמר ותורה אור15 והאותיות שרשן מבחי׳ אויר שהוא מקור האור כו׳ ואויר היינו רוח.1617181920212223242526272829
And see there, that of the Torah it is said “and the Torah is light,” while the letters are rooted in the level of air (avir), which is the source of light (or), etc.; and air is ruach (breath).
The Torah is called “light” (or), but the letters are rooted in “air” (avir), which is or with an added yud, the source of light. Air is breath, ruach, and this leads to the next paragraph’s link between ruach and rei’ach, fragrance.
The second paragraph introduces oil as the remedy for the sealed heart: the Torah is “oil poured forth,” descended into physical letters and stories, yet like an inverted vessel its lowest part, the letters, has the highest root. That high root is what the “fragrance of your oils” refers to.
The image of the inverted seal, where the beginning is wedged in the end, is a principle from the Pardes of Rabbi Moshe Cordovero and Sefer Yetzirah that the Alter Rebbe uses in Iggeres HaKodesh: the lowest levels have the highest roots. It explains why physical letters and objects can carry a person higher than intellect can.
Marei mekomos
- 1לריח שמניך · באור התורה שה״ש ע׳ לא עם הגהות אחרות. שם ע׳ נד הגהות לד״ה לריח שמניך הראשון.
- 2
- 3ה׳ בחכמה יסד ארץ · Proverbs 3:19
- 4אבא יסד ברתא · זח״ג רנו, ב. [ובח״ב (קמה, ב). — כ].
- 5כל התורה הם שמותיו של הקב״ה · Zohar II, 87a
- 6כל התורה הם שמותיו של הקב״ה · Zohar, Yitro 23:409–421
- 7ונק׳ אבנים בס״י · פ״ד, מי״ב.
- 8ונק׳ אבנים בס״י · Sefer Yetzirah 4:12
- 9כחותם המתהפך · ל׳ הפרדס להרמ״ק ז״ל ג״פ. א׳ ש׳ [יא] הצחצחות (רפ״ז). הב׳ ש׳ [יג] השערים (ספ״ו). הג׳ ב[ש׳ כג] ערכי הכנויים ערך אמת יעו״ש. וע׳ איוב (לח, יד). ובאגה״ק (סי׳ כ — קלא, א). [כ].
- 10כחותם המתהפך · Job 38:14
- 11שו״ה ע״פ — (לקמן) · בבוך 1101 תרפח, ב. בגוכתי״ק הצ״צ בלי סוגריים. וכ״ה בלקו״ת דפוס זיטאמיר תר״כ. ואולי במהדו״ק הי׳ הכוונה להעמיד מאמר זה בין מאמרי פסח. בבוך 753 פג, א רשום על ד״ה הנ״ל (שנדפס באוה״ת שה״ש ע׳ לא) — נאמר בפסח שנת תקצ״ח — ובאוה״ת שם רשום: פ׳ נצבים. וראה לעיל האזינו עג, ג ובהנסמן שם.
- 12פ׳ נשא · בגוכתי״ק (1101) פ׳ בהעלותך.
- 13
- 14בד״ה נר חנוכה · תו״א מב, ג.
- 15תורה אור · Proverbs 6:23
- 16פעמים נק׳ התורה יין ופעמים שמן · שהש״ר א ע״פ כי טובים דודיך. ההפרש בין יין לשמן נתבאר באמרי בינה שער הק״ש פרק נד ואילך.
- 17כי טובים דודיך מיין · Song of Songs 1:2
- 18דכולא קמי׳ כלא חשיב · Zohar I, 11b
- 19מי גילה לבני רז זה · Shabbat 88a:8
- 20גילוי החסדים המכוסים · ע׳ ד״ה ושאבתם מים הא׳ פ״ג (עט, ג). וש״נ. [כ].
- 21בזהר בא דל״ח ע״ב · ראה לעיל פ׳ צו ט, ד שמציין לכאן.
- 22כי בועליך עושיך · Isaiah 54:5
- 23וכבוד ה׳ עליך זרח · ישעי׳ (רס״י ס). [כ].
- 24כי אשב בחשך · מיכה (ז, ח).
- 25ע״פ עיני כל · לעיל פ׳ מטות פה, ב ואילך. וראה בס׳ הנחות הר״פ ע׳ פה. ובאוה״ת שה״ש כרך א ע׳ לה.
- 26בד״ה יחיינו מיומיים · לעיל ר״ה סג, ג ואילך.
- 27ע״פ וארשתיך · לעיל פ׳ במדבר.
- 28וע״פ ואשה כי תדור · לעיל פ׳ מטות.
- 29וע״פ כי תצא · לעיל כי תצא לז, ד.
Longing for G‑d’s kindness ¶3–4
And this is the meaning of “for fragrance, your oils,” for fragrance (rei’ach) and spirit (ruach) are one matter, as is explained elsewhere, and as our Sages said on “My pleasing fragrance” (rei’ach nichochi): “a gratification of spirit (nachas ruach) before Me,” etc.
The Hebrew for fragrance, rei’ach, and for spirit or breath, ruach, share a root. The Sages read the Torah’s phrase for an offering’s “pleasing fragrance” as G‑d’s “gratification of spirit,” so fragrance is a matter of spirit, and it connects to the “air” in which the letters are rooted.
ולכן נק׳ האותיות סוסים שמגביהים מאד למעלה וכל העלאות ממטה למעלה ע״י האותיות דהרהור לא עביד מידי כו׳
Therefore the letters are called “horses,” for they lift very high upward, and all ascents from below to above are by means of the letters, for “thought accomplishes nothing,” etc.
Because the letters are rooted so high, they can carry a person upward, which is why they are called “horses.” Every ascent is made through letters actually spoken, since mere thought, without words, does not accomplish anything.
ועיין במבוא שערים ש״ג ח״ג פ״ג בענין מפיו דעת3 כו׳ והרוכב על הסוס הסוס ישאנו למקום רחוק שלא היה יכול להגיע ברגלים כו׳.
And see Mevo She’arim, Gate 3, Part 3, chapter 3, on “from His mouth [come] knowledge,” etc. And [as with] one who rides a horse: the horse will carry him to a distant place that he could not have reached on foot, etc.
The Arizal’s Mevo She’arim is cited on the verse “from His mouth [come] knowledge and understanding,” which links divine speech to knowledge. The analogy follows: a rider reaches, on horseback, places he could never reach on foot.
וכמ״כ עד״מ בשומו כל מחשבתו באותיות מגביהים ומעלים אותו למקום גבוה (וכמ״ש מזה לקמן סד״ה לסוסתי כו׳) אבל כתיב לא בגבורת הסוס יחפץ4 לא בשוקי האיש ירצה.5
So too, by way of analogy, when he puts all his thought into the letters, they lift him and raise him to a high place (as written on this later, at the end of the maamar beginning “To My mare,” etc.). But it is written: “He does not desire the strength of the horse, nor take pleasure in the legs of a man.”
In the same way, a person who puts all his thought into the letters of the Torah or of prayer is lifted by them far beyond his own level. But the verse warns that G‑d does not delight in the horse’s strength or the rider’s legs, a warning explained in the next part.
פי׳ כשאינו מעמיק חב״ד שלו בהאותיות כ״א מחשבתו בלבד הרי זה כרכיבת הסוס בלבד שרגליו לבד דבוקים בסוס והסוס רץ והוא אינו עושה כלום כו׳
Meaning: when he does not immerse his Chochmah, Binah and Daas in the letters, but only his thought, this is like mere horse-riding, where only his legs cling to the horse, and the horse runs while he does nothing, etc.
If a person only keeps his thought on the words without engaging his intellect (Chochmah, Binah and Daas), he is like a rider who only sits on the horse. The horse runs; the rider himself does nothing.
כ״א רוצה ה׳ את יראיו את המיחלים לחסדו6 פי׳ שיעמיק חב״ד שלו בהתבוננות גדולת ה׳ עם דיבוק מחשבתו בהאותיות
Rather, “G‑d takes pleasure in those who fear Him, in those who hope for His kindness”: meaning, that he immerse his Chochmah, Binah and Daas in contemplating the greatness of G‑d, together with the cleaving of his thought to the letters
What G‑d wants, says the next verse, is “those who fear Him.” That means joining real contemplation of G‑d’s greatness, with one’s whole mind, to the attachment of thought to the letters.
(ועמ״ש בפ׳ בשלח בד״ה לסוסתי וע״פ אז ישיר) וישים בלבו ענין עצה היעוצה כשרואה שהוא רחוק מאד מהתפעלות הלב והתלהבות מהתבוננות כו׳
(and see what is written in Parshas Beshalach, in the maamar beginning “To My mare,” and on “Then [Moshe] sang”). And he should take to heart the well-counseled counsel when he sees that he is very far from being stirred in his heart and from fervor [born] of contemplation, etc.:
The parenthesis points to two maamarim in Torah Ohr on the horse imagery. Then comes practical advice for someone who finds that contemplation leaves his heart unmoved.
ומשפיל א״ע בתכלית לאמר מה אני כי יה יה לי התלהבות כי לבי אטום היות
he should humble himself utterly, saying: “What am I, that I should have fervor, for my heart is sealed, since
Such a person should humble himself completely and say that he has no right to expect fervor, since his heart is sealed. This is the “maiden” of paragraph 1, speaking honestly about himself.
כי אני מרוחק בתכלית הריחוק מה׳ אחד רק זאת בידו לבקש על נפשו לחפוץ לדבקה בה׳ והוא ענין המיחלים לחסדו שמצפים ומשתוקקים בתשוקה רבה שיהיה התגלחת אלקות כו׳.
I am utterly, utterly distant from the One G‑d?” Only this is in his power: to plead for his soul, to desire to cleave to G‑d. And this is “those who hope for His kindness”: they wait and long with great longing for the revelation of G‑dliness, etc.
He should admit how far he is from G‑d, and do the one thing in his power: plead and long to cling to G‑d. This longing is “those who hope for His kindness”: waiting with great desire for G‑dliness to be revealed to him.
Paragraph 3 explains why the letters, called “horses,” lift a person upward, and warns that saying words without engaging the mind is only riding. For someone whose heart stays unmoved, it prescribes humility and longing: to be among “those who hope for His kindness.”
The horse image recurs in the Alter Rebbe’s maamarim on “To My mare” in Torah Ohr, Beshalach: the letters carry the soul the way a horse carries its rider, beyond his own strength. The teaching that ascents come only through spoken letters follows the Arizal’s principle that thought alone does not effect change above.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2ריח ניחוחי נחת רוח לפני · Numbers 28:2
- 3מפיו דעת · Proverbs 2:6
- 4
- 5לא בגבורת הסוס יחפץ לא בשוקי האיש ירצה · Psalms 147:10
- 6רוצה ה׳ את יראיו את המיחלים לחסדו · Psalms 147:11
4ואני איני רוצה להיות נפרד כו׳. זהו פירוש לחסדו ח״ס דלי״ת התגלות אלקות. וזהו לצפירת תפארה למצפים תפארתו1 והדר גאונו ומזה יוכל להמשיך חסד ה׳ עליו שיתפעל לבו כו׳.
“And I do not want to be separated,” etc. This is the meaning of “His kindness” (chasdo): chas dalet, [pity on the dalet,] the revelation of G‑dliness. And this is “a diadem of beauty” (tzefiras tif’arah): for those who await (metzapim) His beauty and the splendor of His majesty. And from this he can draw G‑d’s kindness upon himself, so that his heart will be stirred, etc.
The person’s plea continues: he does not want to be separated from G‑d. The word chesed is read as chas dalet, pity on the dalet, the “poor” letter that stands for the receiver who has nothing of its own; G‑d’s kindness is revealing G‑dliness to the one who lacks it. The Talmud reads Isaiah’s “diadem of beauty” (tzefiras) as “those who await (metzapim) His beauty”: longing itself draws down G‑d’s kindness, until the heart is stirred.
וכן בענין לימוד התורה שבע״פ התגלות רצונו ית׳ בזה העולם הגשמי טהור טמא ומותר אסור כו׳
And so too regarding the study of the Oral Torah, the revelation of His blessed will in this physical world: pure and impure, permitted and forbidden, etc.
The same applies to studying the Oral Torah, where G‑d’s will is revealed in the details of this world, what is pure and impure, permitted and forbidden. Through such study too, one who longs for G‑d can draw His kindness upon himself.
ומי שאין לו אפי׳ בחי׳ המיחלים לחסדו הנ״ל עליו כתיב זכר חסדו ואמונתו2 לבית ישראל בחי׳ נוק׳ כו׳ על ישראל אמונתו. ולבית ישראל ממשיך גם אמונה כו׳:34
And one who does not have even the level of “those who hope for His kindness” mentioned above: of him it is written, “He remembered His kindness and His faithfulness to the house of Israel,” the level of Nukva, etc.; “upon Israel, His faithfulness.” And to the house of Israel He draws down faith as well, etc.
For someone who lacks even the longing, the verse says G‑d “remembered His kindness and His faithfulness to the house of Israel.” The “house of Israel” is Nukva, the receiving level, and G‑d draws down to it faith, a bond with Him that does not depend on the person’s own feeling.
Paragraph 4 completes the practical advice: the longing of “those who hope for His kindness” draws G‑d’s kindness down until the heart is stirred. Even one without such longing receives faith through G‑d’s remembering “the house of Israel.”
Malchus is called dalet because, like the poor (dal), it “has nothing of its own” (compare the bride in paragraph 1). Reading chesed as chas dalet makes G‑d’s kindness exactly the gift of light to the one who lacks it.
Marei mekomos
- 1לצפירת תפארה למצפים תפארתו · Megillah 15b:3
- 2זכר חסדו ואמונתו · Psalms 98:3
- 3
- 4
Supernal Chochmah in the laws ¶5–6
5ולתוספת ביאור ענין שמן תורק הוא עפמ״ש במ״א פי׳ הזהר (בראשית דכ״ז ע״ב) בענין משנה אתתא דההוא נער כו׳
To explain further the meaning of “oil poured forth”: it is according to what is written elsewhere explaining the Zohar (Bereishis, 27b) on “the Mishnah is the wife of that youth,” etc.,
Here the maamar deepens the meaning of “oil poured forth.” It draws on a Zohar passage that calls the Mishnah the “wife” of “that youth” (the angel Metatron), an image of Oral Torah as a receiving, feminine level.
שבדיני התורה הנגלית שלפנינו מלובש ונמשך בזה עצמיות ח״ע מה שאין גילוי זה אפי׳ בעולמות העליונים
that in the laws of the revealed Torah before us, the very essence of supernal Chochmah is clothed and drawn down, a revelation that does not exist even in the higher worlds,
The claim is striking: in the practical laws of the Torah, the very essence of G‑d’s supernal wisdom is present. Such a revelation does not exist even in the higher spiritual worlds.
כי גם בג״ע מאיר רק זיו השכינה והארה לבד מח״ע כו׳ וכמ״ש הטעם לזה במ״א (גבי פורים בד״ה כי אברהם לא ידענו)1 ממשל הארי כו׳
for even in the Garden of Eden only the radiance of the Shechinah shines, and a mere glimmer of supernal Chochmah, etc. And the reason for this is explained elsewhere (regarding Purim, in the maamar beginning “For Avraham did not know us”) from the analogy of the lion, etc.:
Even in the Garden of Eden, the souls perceive only a radiance of the Shechinah and a glimmer of supernal Chochmah. The reason is explained in a Purim maamar in Torah Ohr using the image of the lion in Ezekiel’s vision.
פני אריה אל הימין2 כו׳ וכמו כן הארת ח״ע מוכרח להתלבש במקום היותר נמוך דהיינו עניני הלכות טמא כשר כו׳
“the face of a lion on the right,” etc.; and likewise the glimmer of supernal Chochmah must necessarily be clothed in the lowest place, namely in the laws of impure and fit, etc.
In Ezekiel’s vision the lion’s face is on the right, the side of Chesed; the maamar referred to explains that the higher a thing is, the lower it must descend. So supernal Chochmah is clothed specifically in the lowest place: laws about what is impure and what is kosher.
ע״ש והוא ג״כ עד״מ הנזכר באגה״ק קרוב לסופו3 ועוד זאת שהרי הדבור כו׳ רק הארה כו׳ משא״כ הטפה נמשך בה גם ממהות הנפש ועצמותה ע״ש.4
See there. And it is also like the analogy mentioned in Iggeres HaKodesh near its end: “Moreover, speech,” etc., is only a glimmer, etc., whereas in the drop [of seed] there is drawn also from the very being and essence of the soul; see there.
Iggeres HaKodesh gives an analogy: speech carries only a glimmer of a person’s mind, but the seed of a child carries the essence of the parent’s soul. So too the laws of the Torah carry G‑d’s wisdom itself, not just a reflection of it.
Paragraph 5 explains why the Torah’s laws are “oil poured forth”: the very essence of G‑d’s wisdom is drawn into the practical halachah, more than in any higher world. Like a seed that carries the parent’s essence, the lowest expression carries the highest content.
The analogy of speech and seed appears in the Kuntres Acharon of Tanya (in the essay beginning “To understand what is written in Pri Etz Chaim”), where it explains why the study of halachah reaches the essence of Chochmah while knowledge of the higher worlds reaches only its glimmer. The same principle, that the highest descends lowest, underlies the “inverted seal” of paragraph 2.
Marei mekomos
- 1בד״ה כי אברהם לא ידענו · תו״א צג, ג.
- 2פני אריה אל הימין · Ezekiel 1:10
- 3באגה״ק קרוב לסופו · בקו״א ד״ה להבין מ״ש בפע״ח (קנז, א). [כ].
- 4
And see further there, the section beginning “In the Raaya Mehemna, Parshas Naso.” And this is the meaning of “oil poured forth”: the very essence of the oil itself is poured out and drawn down below.
Iggeres HaKodesh has a further letter on the same theme. “Oil poured forth” means that the very essence of the oil, not just its scent, is poured out and reaches below.
וזהו מה שלמעלה בא למטה דייקא כנ״ל. וענין שמן תורק שמך הנה נת׳ הפי׳ למעלה דהיינו כמארז״ל כל התורה היא שמותיו של הקב״ה2 כו׳
And this is [how] what is above comes specifically below, as mentioned above. And as for “your name is oil poured forth,” the meaning was explained above, namely as our Sages said, “the whole Torah is the Names of the Holy One, blessed be He,” etc.
This is the principle already stated: what is highest comes specifically to the lowest place. “Your name” refers to the Torah, which the Sages describe as made entirely of G‑d’s Names.
ועמ״ש מזה ע״פ ואלה שמות בנ״י3 ובפ׳ יתרו בד״ה משה ידבר4 איך דכל מעשה המצות הן לאתקנא רזא דשמיה כו׳ ע״ש.
And see what is written on this on “And these are the names of the children of Israel,” and in Parshas Yisro, in the maamar beginning “Moshe spoke,” how all the performance of the mitzvos is “to perfect the mystery of His Name,” etc.; see there.
Two maamarim in Torah Ohr develop this: all the mitzvos serve “to perfect the mystery of His Name,” completing G‑d’s Name, as it were. The Torah and mitzvos are thus the channel of the Name.
ובזהר פ׳ צו (דל״ד ע״א) פי׳ שמך היינו מל׳ שבה הורק ונמשך השמן דח״ע ע״ש
And in the Zohar, Parshas Tzav (34a), “your name” is explained as Malchus, into which the oil of supernal Chochmah is poured and drawn; see there.
The Zohar reads “your name” as Malchus, G‑d’s kingship, into which the oil of supernal Chochmah is poured. In the terms of this maamar, the highest wisdom flows into the lowest divine attribute.
(ועיין בזהר פ׳ יתרו דפ״ז ע״ב ע״פ טוב שם משמן טוב5 ובזהר ח״א דצ״ו סע״א) והיינו כמ״ש בזהר פ׳ תרומה (דקמ״ה ע״ב) ירותא דאבא ירתא ברתא6 כו׳
(And see the Zohar, Parshas Yisro, 87b, on “A good name is better than good oil,” and the Zohar, volume 1, end of 96a.) And this is as written in the Zohar, Parshas Terumah (145b): “The inheritance of the father, the daughter inherits,” etc.
The Zohar also links oil and “name” through the verse “A good name is better than good oil.” Its saying that “the daughter inherits the father” means that Malchus (the daughter) receives directly from Chochmah (the father).
והיינו כנודע מענין בחכמה יסד ארץ7 דייקא משא״כ כונן שמים בתבונה וכמ״ש מזה בפ׳ בראשית בד״ה
And this is as is known concerning “with wisdom He founded the earth,” specifically, unlike “He established the heavens with understanding”; and as written on this in Parshas Bereishis, in the maamar beginning
The verse says the earth, which stands for Malchus, was founded specifically “with wisdom” (Chochmah), whereas the heavens were established “with understanding” (Binah). Chochmah reaches directly into the lowest level.
“To understand the reason,” etc., and on “And [G‑d] formed the man [of] dust,” etc. Now the level of Malchus [is] “the mouth: the Oral Torah we call her,” etc.
The references are to maamarim in Torah Ohr, Bereishis, including one on the formation of man from dust. The Tikkunei Zohar says Malchus is the “mouth” and is called the Oral Torah, which is why the laws of the Oral Torah receive supernal Chochmah.
וע׳ מ״ש לקמן בד״ה שחורה אני בענין ערבים עלי דברי סופרים כו׳ שהן למעלה מבחי׳ ספר הוא בחי׳ תשב״כ כו׳
And see what is written later, in the maamar beginning “I am black,” on “The words of the Scribes are dearer to Me,” etc., that they are above the level of “book,” which is the level of the Written Torah, etc.;
A later maamar in this parsha explains why the Sages’ words are “dearer” than the Written Torah: they stem from a level above the “book.” The Oral Torah, though lower in appearance, is higher in root.
see there. And see Iggeres HaKodesh, the section beginning “He and His life-force,” on what is written there: “only it is like an inverted seal, and their beginning is wedged in their end,” etc.
Iggeres HaKodesh explains the same point with the “inverted seal,” and with Sefer Yetzirah’s phrase that the beginning is wedged in the end. The lowest level is bound to the highest.
וזהו שמן תורק שמך. שבההלכות תשבע״פ נמשך מבחי׳ עצמיות השמן שהוא גבוה מאד נעלה היינו כמ״ש כשמן הטוב14 על הראש יורד על הזקן זקן אהרן כו׳
And this is “your name is oil poured forth”: into the laws of the Oral Torah there is drawn from the level of the essence of the oil, which is exceedingly high and exalted; that is, as it is written, “Like the good oil upon the head, running down upon the beard, the beard of Aharon,” etc.
This is the full meaning of “your name is oil poured forth”: the laws of the Oral Torah receive from the essence of the oil, from a very high source. The Psalm describes this oil running down from the head of Aharon onto his beard.
וכמ״ש (לקמן) בד״ה בהעלותך1516 את הנרות שבחי׳ דיקנא דכהנא רבא בחי׳ שערות אלו הלכות כו׳ וע״ז יש בחי׳ שמן מלמעלה כו׳
And as written (later) in the maamar beginning “When you kindle the lamps,” that the level of the beard of the High Priest is the level of hairs, which are the laws, etc., and upon this there is the level of oil from above, etc.;
A maamar in Beha’aloscha explains that the hairs of the High Priest’s beard stand for the laws of the Torah. The oil from above, supernal Chochmah, comes down upon those laws.
ע״ש ומ״ש ב״פ הזקן זקן17 י״ל עפמ״ש לקמן בד״ה שחורה אני שההלכות שבמצות עשה שהן מבחי׳ חסד נמשכים מבחי׳ דיקנא עילאה
see there. And as for its saying “the beard” twice, “the beard, the beard [of Aharon],” one may say [it is] according to what is written later, in the maamar beginning “I am black,” that the laws in the positive commandments, which are from the level of Chesed, are drawn from the level of the supernal beard,
The Psalm says “the beard” twice, and a maamar later in this parsha explains why. The laws of the positive commandments come from Chesed, from the “supernal beard.”
שהוא בחי׳ לבנונית כתלג חיוור ועמר נקא18 וההלכות שבמצות ל״ת נמשכים מבחי׳ קווצותיו תלתלים שחורות19 וכו׳ עיין באדרת נשא (דקל״ב תחלת ע״א).20
which is the level of whiteness, “white as snow” and “like pure wool”; and the laws in the negative commandments are drawn from the level of “his locks are curled, black,” etc.; see the Idra of Naso (beginning of 132a).
That supernal beard is described with images of whiteness, like snow and pure wool, from Daniel’s vision. The laws of the prohibitions come from the “black locks” of the Song of Songs, the side of restraint; the Zohar’s Idra in Naso describes both.
וזהו ענין לריח שמניך טובים21 כי בחי׳ כשמן הטוב כו׳ יורד על הזקן כו׳ שרשו גבוה מאד נעלה.
And this is the meaning of “for fragrance, your oils are good”: for the level of “like the good oil,” etc., “running down upon the beard,” etc., has its root exceedingly high and exalted.
Now “for fragrance, your oils are good” can be understood. The oil that runs down onto the beard, that is, into the laws, has its root extremely high.
ולכן נק׳ שמן המריח וזהו ענין תליסר נהרוותא דמשחא אפרסמון דכיין22 (בגמרא תענית דכ״ ה ע״א) שהוא בחי׳ גבוה יותר מסתם שמן וכמ״ש במ״א בפ׳ תרומה סד״ה
Therefore it is called “fragrant oil,” and this is the meaning of “thirteen rivers of pure balsam oil” (in the Gemara, Taanis 25a), which is a higher level than plain oil; and as written elsewhere, in Parshas Terumah, at the end of the maamar beginning
Because its root is so high, it is called “fragrant oil.” The Talmud’s “thirteen rivers of pure balsam oil” promised to the righteous refer to this level, which is higher than plain oil.
הנה כתיב23 ועמך כולם צדיקים כו׳ ועיין בזהר ר״פ אמור (דפ״ח ע״ב) וע׳ בזהר ר״פ תרומה (דקכ״ז ע״ב).
“Now it is written, ‘And your people are all righteous,’” etc. And see the Zohar, beginning of Emor (88b), and see the Zohar, beginning of Terumah (127b).
The references are to a maamar in Torah Ohr, Terumah, and to two Zohar passages. They discuss the higher, fragrant oil further.
וע׳ מענין לריח שמניך בזהר פ׳ אחר (דנ״ח סע״ב) ובפ׳ בהעלותך (דק״נ ע״א) ובפ׳ צו (דל״ה סע״א) ור״פ וירא (דצ״ו א׳) ובהרמ״ז שם:24
And see concerning “for fragrance, your oils” in the Zohar, Parshas Acharei (end of 58b), and in Parshas Beha’aloscha (150a), and in Parshas Tzav (end of 35a), and at the beginning of Parshas Vayera (96a), and in the Ramaz there.
Further Zohar passages that discuss “for fragrance, your oils” are listed, with the Ramaz, a commentary on the Zohar. They are given for readers who wish to study the theme in the sources.
Paragraph 6 shows that “your name is oil poured forth” means supernal Chochmah is poured into Malchus, the Oral Torah, whose laws are the “beard” onto which the oil of Aharon runs down. Because this oil’s root is so high, it is also “fragrant oil,” the higher level of “for fragrance, your oils are good.”
The pairing of the “supernal beard” (white, Chesed) with the “black locks” (Gevurah) follows the Idra Rabba in Naso, where the configurations of Arich Anpin and Z’eir Anpin are described with the images of Daniel’s vision and the Song of Songs. The Alter Rebbe maps them onto the positive commandments and the prohibitions.
Marei mekomos
- 1ד״ה בר״מ פ׳ נשא · והוא באגה״ק (סי׳ כו). [כ].
- 2כל התורה היא שמותיו של הקב״ה · Zohar, Yitro 23:421–24:431
- 3ע״פ ואלה שמות בנ״י · תו״א מט, ד.
- 4בד״ה משה ידבר · תו״א סז, ד.
- 5
- 6ירותא דאבא ירתא ברתא · Zohar, Terumah 31:353–362
- 7בחכמה יסד ארץ · Proverbs 3:19
- 8בד״ה להבין הטעם כו׳ ובענין וייצר · תו״א ד, א-ג.
- 9וייצר כו׳ את האדם עפר · Genesis 2:7
- 10מלכות פה תושבע״פ קרינן לה · ת״ז בהקדמה (פתח אלי׳).
- 11מלכות פה תשבע״פ קרינן לה · Tikkunei Zohar 17a:16–17
- 12באגה״ק ד״ה איהו וחיוהי · סי׳ כ דף קלא, א. וראה לעיל פ׳ אמור לד, ג.
- 13ונעוץ תחלתן בסופן · Sefer Yetzirah 1:7
- 14כשמן הטוב · Psalms 133:2
- 15וכמ״ש (לקמן) בד״ה בהעלותך · וכ״ה בבוך 1101 תרפו, א גוכתי״ק הצ״צ. וראה לעיל ב, ד.
- 16בד״ה בהעלותך · לעיל שם ל, ג.
- 17ומ״ש ב״פ הזקן זקן · ראה גם יהל אור ע׳ תקה בשם מד״ר פ׳ ויקרא ספ״ג.
- 18כתלג חיוור ועמר נקא · Daniel 7:9
- 19קווצותיו תלתלים שחורות · Song of Songs 5:11
- 20עיין באדרת נשא (דקל״ב תחלת ע״א) · Zohar, Idra Rabba 11:112–13:123
- 21
- 22תליסר נהרוותא דמשחא אפרסמון דכיין · Taanit 25a:14
- 23וכמ״ש במ״א בפ׳ תרומה סד״ה הנה כתיב · תו״א פא, א.
- 24
Betrothal and marriage ¶7–8
7עוד יש לומר בפי׳ לריח שמניך כו׳ ושמן תורק כו׳ ע״ד משמעות פי׳ המדרש שיר השירים דמפרש שמן תורק הוא מדרגה גבוה יותר מן לריח שמניך שאינו
One may further say, in explaining “for fragrance, your oils,” etc., and “oil poured forth,” etc., following the plain sense of the explanation of the Midrash on the Song of Songs, which explains that “oil poured forth” is a higher level than “for fragrance, your oils,” which is
A second reading follows the plain sense of the Midrash on the Song of Songs. There “oil poured forth” is a higher level than “the fragrance of your oils.”
אלא כעין ריח בעלמא מהשמן אבל שמן תורק היינו כאדם שמריק מכלי לכלי1 חבירו שנותן לו השמן בעצמו.
only a kind of mere fragrance from the oil; but “oil poured forth” is like a person who pours from a vessel into his friend’s vessel, who gives him the oil itself.
Fragrance is only the scent that reaches a person from the oil. Pouring oil into a friend’s vessel gives him the oil itself.
והוא עפמ״ש במ״א (בד״ה תורה צוה לנו כו׳ בפ׳ הברכה) שבההמשכה מתשב״כ שהיא בחי׳ חתן לתשבע״פ שהיא בחי׳ כלה יש ב׳ בחינות ומדרגות.
And this is according to what is written elsewhere (in the maamar beginning “Moshe commanded us the Torah,” etc., in Parshas VeZos HaBerachah), that in the flow from the Written Torah, which is the level of the bridegroom, to the Oral Torah, which is the level of the bride, there are two levels and ranks.
A maamar on “Moshe commanded us the Torah” explains that the Written Torah is the “bridegroom” and the Oral Torah the “bride.” The flow between them has two levels.
הא׳ ע״ד נובלות חכמה שלמעלה תורה2 ונקרא אירוסין שהוא המשכה חיצוניות וזהו ענין לריח שמניך.
The first is in the manner of “the fallen fruit of the supernal wisdom is Torah,” and it is called erusin (betrothal), which is an external flow; and this is “for fragrance, your oils.”
The first level is like the Midrash’s saying that the Torah is the “fallen fruit” of supernal wisdom: something that falls away from the tree, not its core. This is betrothal (erusin), an external connection, and it corresponds to “the fragrance of your oils.”
וכמ״ש בלק״ת בתלים3 ע״פ ויקם עדות ביעקב4 כו׳. וזהו שאינו אלא כעין ריח בעלמא הארת יסוד אבא ולא מהותו ועצמותו ממש.
And as written in Likkutei Torah on Tehillim, on “He established a testimony in Yaakov,” etc. And this is why it is only a kind of mere fragrance: a glimmer of the Yesod of Abba, and not its very being and essence.
The Arizal’s Likkutei Torah on Psalms is cited for this. At this level only a glimmer of the Yesod of Abba (the channel of Chochmah) comes through, not its essence.
אמנם הבחי׳ הב׳ הוא שיומשך מבחי׳ חתן לכלה מבחי׳ פנימיות תשב״כ והוא ענין נשואין ויחוד חתן וכלה ע״ש. וזהו שמן תורק שמך שנמשך עצמיות השמן דח״ע בבחי׳ מל׳ תשבע״פ כו׳:
However, the second level is that there be drawn from the level of the bridegroom to the bride, from the level of the inner dimension of the Written Torah; and this is nisu’in (marriage) and the union of bridegroom and bride; see there. And this is “your name is oil poured forth”: the essence of the oil of supernal Chochmah is drawn into the level of Malchus, the Oral Torah, etc.
The second level is marriage (nisu’in), the full union of bridegroom and bride, drawn from the inner dimension of the Written Torah. This is “your name is oil poured forth”: the essence of supernal Chochmah comes into Malchus, the Oral Torah.
Paragraph 7 offers a second reading based on the Midrash: “fragrance” is a lower, external flow from the Written to the Oral Torah (betrothal), and “oil poured forth” is the inner, essential flow (marriage).
Betrothal and marriage as two stages of the union of Z’eir Anpin and Nukva is a Kabbalistic theme: betrothal gives an external “glimmer” (from Yesod of Abba), marriage gives the inner essence. Note that this reading reverses paragraph 6, where fragrance came from a higher root; paragraph 10 will reconcile the two.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2נובלות חכמה שלמעלה תורה · Bereshit Rabbah 17:5
- 3בלקו״ת בתלים · להאריז״ל. ראה לעיל א, ד.
- 4ויקם עדות ביעקב · Psalms 78:5
Now the verse’s conclusion, “therefore the maidens love You,” is explained. The Zohar reads alamos (maidens) as olamos (worlds), the worlds of Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, which receive from Malchus, their source.
(דנ״ח סע״ב) ח״ב קמ״ד ב׳ (וע׳ עוד ח״א צ״ח א׳ ח״ג נ״ט א׳ ע״א ב׳)
(end of 58b), volume 2, 144b (and see further volume 1, 98a; volume 3, 59a, 71b).
These are the Zohar passages that read alamos as the worlds. They are listed for further study.
וכן מבחי׳ מל׳ דאצי׳ נמשך להיות גילוי למטה בכל א׳ מישראל ע״י שמקבלים עליהם עול מלכות שמים
And likewise from the level of Malchus of Atzilus there is drawn a revelation below in each and every one of Israel, through their accepting upon themselves the yoke of the kingship of Heaven.
In the same way, from Malchus of Atzilus a revelation reaches every Jew. It comes through accepting the yoke of Heaven’s kingship, which is receiving Malchus.
ואזי בעסק התורה נמשך בו ג״כ מבחי׳ לריח שמניך כו׳ ושמן תורק כו׳ והיינו ג״כ ע״ד ב׳ בחי׳ הנ״ל דאירוסין ונישואין
And then, in the study of Torah, there is drawn into him as well from the level of “for fragrance, your oils,” etc., and “oil poured forth,” etc.; and this too is in the manner of the two levels mentioned above, betrothal and marriage;
Having accepted the yoke, a person who studies Torah receives both “fragrance” and “oil poured forth.” These are the two levels, betrothal and marriage, described in paragraph 7.
והיינו להיות נקלט ונתפס במוח ובלב אור ה׳ דאורייתא וקב״ה כולא חד2 כו׳ ושתכנס ההתבוננות בקרב איש ולב עמוק3 כו׳
that is, that the light of G‑d be absorbed and grasped in the mind and in the heart, [for] “the Torah and the Holy One, blessed be He, are entirely one,” etc., and that the contemplation enter “within a man, and a deep heart,” etc.
The aim is that G‑d’s light be grasped in both mind and heart, since the Torah and G‑d are one. The contemplation should enter a person’s inner depths, the “deep heart” of the Psalm.
וכמארז״ל המאור שבה מחזירו למוטב4 וכמ״ש סד״ה בהעלותך5 בענין כשמן הטוב כו׳ שיורד ע״פ מדותיו6 כו׳ ושמן ימינו יקרא78 כו׳ ע״ש.910
And as our Sages said, “the light within it brings him back to the good”; and as written at the end of the maamar beginning “When you kindle,” on “like the good oil,” etc., that runs down “according to his attributes,” etc., and “the oil of his right hand calls out,” etc.; see there.
The Sages said that the light within the Torah returns a person to the good. The maamar on Beha’aloscha explains that the oil comes down “according to his attributes,” reaching each person’s emotions, and the proverb “the oil of his right hand calls out” speaks of its effect.
Paragraph 8 draws the conclusion: the “maidens” are the lower worlds and every Jew who receives from Malchus by accepting the yoke of Heaven; through Torah study they receive both the “fragrance” and the “oil poured forth,” until G‑d’s light enters mind and heart.
The Zohar’s reading of alamos as olamos ties the individual’s acceptance of G‑d’s kingship to the cosmic structure: Malchus of Atzilus is the source of the lower worlds, and a person who accepts its yoke becomes a receiver like them. “The light within it brings him back to the good” is the classic statement that Torah study itself transforms a person.
Marei mekomos
- 1על כן עלמות אהבוך · Song of Songs 1:3
- 2דאורייתא וקוב״ה כולא חד · ראה הערת כ״ק אדמו״ר בס׳ המאמרים ה׳ש״ת ע׳ 66.
- 3בקרב איש ולב עמוק · Psalms 64:7
- 4המאור שבה מחזירו למוטב · פתיחתא לאיכה רבתי בתחילתה. וראה תו״א צא, א. ריש פיתחא דאיכ״ר כגי׳ הירושלמי [פ״א, ה״ז] בחגיגה בכת״י, יעו״ש. [כ].
- 5סד״ה בהעלותך · לעיל בהעלותך ל, ד.
- 6שיורד ע״פ מדותיו · Psalms 133:2
- 7ושמן ימינו יקרא · Proverbs 26:16
- 8ושמן ימינו יקרא · Proverbs 27:16
- 9
- 10
Why oil reaches the sealed heart ¶9
9וזהו דמתחלה אמר כי טובים דודיך מיין1 יין הוא ההתבוננות בעלמא דאתגלייא שמזה ההתבוננות נמשך להיות בחי׳ כלה כו׳ כנ״ל.
And this is why it first says “for Your love is better than wine”: wine is contemplation of the revealed world, and from this contemplation comes about the level of the bride, etc., as mentioned above.
The maamar now ties the two verses together. The earlier verse, “Your love is better than wine,” describes the way of contemplation, through which one becomes a “bride” who receives G‑d’s light.
אך כדי שיהי׳ אף בחי׳ עלמות אהבוך דהיינו אפילו מי שלבו אטום ולא נתפעל מהתבוננות הנ״ל.
But so that there be also the level of “the maidens love You,” that is, even one whose heart is sealed and who has not been stirred by the contemplation mentioned above,
The later verse addresses a different person: the “maiden” whose heart is sealed and whom contemplation has not moved. The question is how such a person can also come to love G‑d.
הנה הוא ע״י עסק התורה שהיא בחי׳ שמן כנ״ל שהיא בחי׳ אשר אנכי מצוך כו׳
this is through occupation with Torah, which is the level of oil, as mentioned above, which is the level of “that I (Anochi) command you,” etc.,
The answer is Torah study, the “oil.” The Torah is the word of “I” (Anochi), G‑d’s own self, in the phrase “that I command you.”
דלית מחשבה תפיסא ביה כלל2 ולפי שהוא מבחי׳ עליונה מאד ע״כ יוכל לעשות חקיקה וכלי גם במי שלבו אטום כו׳
which no thought can grasp at all; and because it is from a very lofty level, therefore it can make an engraving and a vessel even in one whose heart is sealed, etc.
That level is beyond all thought, as the Tikkunei Zohar says. Precisely because it is so high, it can engrave itself and form a “vessel” even in a heart that nothing else moves.
וכענין משנ״ת בפ׳ בחקתי (ד״ה מבואר בע״ח)3 שעי״ז נעשה חקיקה מבפנים בנה״ב כו׳ וזהו ענין באר חפרוה שרים4 כו׳
And [this is] like what is explained in Parshas Bechukosai (the maamar beginning “It is explained in Etz Chaim”), that through this an engraving is made from within in the animal soul, etc.; and this is the meaning of “a well that princes dug,” etc.;
A maamar in Bechukosai explains that Torah study engraves itself even within the animal soul, from the inside. The verse “a well that princes dug” describes such digging down to a hidden source of water.
see there. And [it is] like what is explained further elsewhere (in the maamar beginning “I will betroth you to Me”) concerning “my heart and my flesh sing to the living G‑d,” for
A maamar on “I will betroth you to Me” makes a similar point with the verse “my heart and my flesh sing to the living G‑d.” The explanation follows in the next parts.
הנה הלב והבשר לפי שהם כלים גשמיים כו׳ אינם נכספים לחצרות ה׳ שהוא מקור וחיי הנפש וכענין בחי׳ ההתבוננות בעלמא דאתגלייא הנק׳ יין כנ״ל
the heart and the flesh, because they are physical vessels, etc., do not yearn for “the courts of G‑d,” which are the source and life of the soul, like the level of contemplation of the revealed world, which is called wine, as mentioned above,
The heart and flesh are physical and do not naturally yearn for the “courts of G‑d,” the spiritual source of the soul’s life. Contemplation of the revealed world, “wine,” belongs to that level and so may not move them.
כי אם כאשר ירננו אל אל חי בעצמו ובכבודו כו׳ שכל מה שהיא בחי׳ עליונה יותר יכולה היא לירד ולהתפשט למטה יותר ועי״ז באה ונגעה עד הלב ובשר כו׳ ע״ש באריכות.
but only when they sing to the living G‑d Himself, in His glory, etc.; for the higher a level is, the more it can descend and spread further below, and through this it comes and reaches the heart and flesh, etc.; see there at length.
They are moved only by “the living G‑d” Himself. The principle is that the higher a level is, the lower it can reach, so the very highest touches even the physical heart and flesh.
ועד״ז הוא כאן דלפי שבחי׳ ריח שמניך ושמן תורק הוא המשכה מבחי׳ עליונה הרבה יותר ממדרגת היין ושמן צף ע״ג יין7 כו׳.
And so it is here: because the level of “the fragrance of your oils” and “oil poured forth” is a flow from a level far higher than the rank of wine, and oil floats on top of wine, etc.
The same applies here: “fragrance” and “oil poured forth” come from a level far above wine. The physical fact that oil floats on top of wine illustrates this.
ובגמ׳ פ״ק דשבת (ד״ה ע״ב) שנחלקו רבנן ורבי יוחנן בן נורי אי הוה חיבור זה לזה
And in the Gemara, first chapter of Shabbos (5b), where the Sages and Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri disagree whether they count as joined to one another,
The Talmud records a dispute whether oil floating on wine counts as “joined” to it for purposes of ritual purity. The dispute shows that oil stays apart from and above the wine.
והיינו מפני שהשמן הוא גבוה מאד בבחי׳ חכמה עילאה דכולא כמ״ש בזהר פ׳ צו (דל״ד ע״א)89 ולכן הוא לעיל׳ לעילא מבחינת היין כו׳
and this is because oil is very high, at the level of “the supernal Chochmah of all,” as written in the Zohar, Parshas Tzav (34a), and therefore it is far, far above the level of wine, etc.
The reason is that oil corresponds to “the supernal Chochmah of all,” as the Zohar says. It therefore stands far above wine, which corresponds to Binah.
ולכן יוכל להפעיל גם במי שלבו אטום שיחוק לבו ע״י דברי תורה שיהי׳ גם עלמות אהבוך כו׳ וכענין ועברתי בארץ מצרים10 אני ולא מלאך כו׳:
And therefore it can take effect even in one whose heart is sealed, that his heart be engraved through words of Torah, so that there be also “the maidens love You,” etc.; and like “I will pass through the land of Egypt: I and not an angel,” etc.
For this reason the Torah can affect even the sealed heart and engrave itself there, so that the “maidens” too will love G‑d. It is like the Exodus, where G‑d Himself, “I and not an angel,” came down to the lowest place.
Paragraph 9 answers the maamar’s question: contemplation (“wine”) moves only those capable of being moved, but Torah (“oil”) comes from a level so high, supernal Chochmah and G‑d’s own “I,” that it can reach and engrave even a sealed heart.
The principle that “the higher a level, the lower it reaches” runs throughout Chabad teaching: the essence, not a glimmer, is what penetrates the physical. The comparison to the Exodus, where G‑d Himself and not an angel came to Egypt, applies the same principle.
Marei mekomos
- 1כי טובים דודיך מיין · Song of Songs 1:2
- 2דלית מחשבה תפיסא ביה כלל · Tikkunei Zohar 17a:10–12
- 3בפ׳ בחקתי (ד״ה מבואר בע״ח) · לעיל בחקותי מז, ג.
- 4באר חפרוה שרים · Numbers 21:18
- 5בד״ה וארשתיך לי · Numbers 8:2
- 6לבי בושרי ירננו אל אל חי · Psalms 84:3
- 7ושמן צף ע״ג יין ובגמרא פ״ק דשבת · נתבאר בארוכה באמרי בינה שער הק״ש פ׳ נד ובמ״מ לשם.
- 8כמ״ש בזהר פ׳ צו דל״ד ע״א · מובא לעיל בפ׳ בהעלותך לב, ג ”דשמן שריא בגו חכמה עילאה דכולא”.
- 9חכמה עילאה דכולא כמ״ש בזהר פ׳ צו (דל״ד ע״א) · Zohar, Tzav 29:187–30:193
- 10ועברתי בארץ מצרים · Exodus 12:12
Scripture, Mishnah and Talmud ¶10
10ב עוי״ל בפי׳ לריח שמניך כו׳ ושמן תורק כו׳ ע״ד המדרש הנ״ל שזהו ענין לעולם ישלש אדם תלמודו1 שליש במקרא שליש במשנה ושליש בתלמוד.
(2) One may further say, in explaining “for fragrance, your oils,” etc., and “oil poured forth,” etc., following the Midrash mentioned above, that this is the matter of “A person should always divide his study into three: a third in Scripture, a third in Mishnah and a third in Talmud.”
This opens a second section of the maamar with a further reading of the verse. It is linked to the Talmud’s instruction to divide one’s study time into three parts: Scripture, Mishnah and Talmud.
והנה בלימוד המצות משנה ותלמוד משיג ותופס המהות חכמתו ית׳2 מאחר שנתלבשה בדברים גשמיים שהן רצונו וחכמתו ית׳ ממש.
Now in studying the mitzvos, Mishnah and Talmud, one comprehends and grasps the very being of His blessed wisdom, since it has been clothed in physical matters, which are truly His blessed will and wisdom.
When one studies the laws of the mitzvos in the Mishnah and Talmud, one actually understands G‑d’s wisdom, because that wisdom has been clothed in physical matters one can grasp. Those laws are G‑d’s will and wisdom themselves.
וזהו ענין שמן תורק כו׳ משא״כ בסיפורי מעשיות שבתנ״ך שאינו מושג כלל חכמתו ית׳ המלובשת בתיבות וצירופי אותיות.
And this is “oil poured forth,” etc. This is not so with the narratives of Tanach, where His blessed wisdom, clothed in the words and combinations of letters, is not comprehended at all.
This grasp of the essence is “oil poured forth.” The narratives of the Bible are different: the divine wisdom clothed in their words and letters cannot be understood at all.
וכמ״ש בזהר בהעלותך (דקנ״ב ע״א) שפשטיות המובן מן הסיפור מעשיות שבתורה נקרא לבושא דאורייתא וביאר הרמ״ז שם
And as written in the Zohar, Beha’aloscha (152a), that the plain sense understood from the narratives of the Torah is called “the garment of the Torah”; and the Ramaz explained there
The Zohar says that the plain story of the Torah is only its “garment.” The Ramaz, a commentator on the Zohar, gives an example, explained in the next part.
כמו עד״מ פ׳ ואלה כו׳ בארץ אדום3 כו׳ שודאי מעשה היה כך היה ואין יוצא מידי פשוטו4 אבל אין כוונת ה׳ בו בעצם
that, for example, [in] the section “And these [are the kings]…in the land of Edom,” etc., certainly the event happened as it happened, and [the verse] does not depart from its plain meaning, but G‑d’s intent in it is not [the event] itself;
The list of the kings of Edom in Genesis records events that really happened, and the verse keeps its plain meaning. But G‑d’s real intent in including it is not the history itself.
אבל בה נגוזו סודות עולם התהו כו׳ ע״ש ובזהר שם (דקמ״ט ע״ב)5 שהאריך בזה. ובפרדס שער כ״ז פ״א6 האריך בביאור מאמר הזהר הנ״ל וכתב וז״ל.
rather, in it are hidden the secrets of the World of Tohu, etc.; see there; and in the Zohar there (149b), which elaborates on this. And in the Pardes, Gate 27, chapter 1, he elaborates in explaining the above Zohar statement, and writes as follows:
Hidden in that list, according to the Kabbalists, are the secrets of the World of Tohu, the “chaos” that preceded the ordered worlds. Rabbi Moshe Cordovero’s Pardes explains the Zohar’s statement at length and is quoted next.
אבל כאשר יבוא האדם ללמוד בתורה צריך שיהי׳ כוונתו שהוא לומד הענין ההוא במה שהם דברים אלהיים שנעלם ממנו עוצם פנימיותם וכו׳ ועם היות שהוא לא ישכיל בה
“But when a person comes to study the Torah, his intent must be that he is studying that matter as being divine words, whose immense inwardness is hidden from him, etc.; and even though he understands nothing of it
The Pardes says that one who studies the Torah should intend that he is learning divine words, whose depths are hidden from him. This holds even if he understands only the surface.
כי אם פשטיות הסיפור ואין צריך לומר זה אלא אפי׳ מי שלא יבין כלל כו׳ גם יש לו שכר טוב עכ״ל
but the plain sense of the narrative, and needless to say this one, but even one who does not understand at all, etc., he too has a good reward.” End of quote.
The quote concludes that even one who understands only the plain story, and even one who understands nothing at all, has a good reward. Reading the Torah’s words is itself of value.
ולכן האותיות התורה ופשטיות הסיפור נק׳ ריח שמניך כי עם היות שאינו מובן ומושג כלל פנימיות חכמתו ית׳ הגנוזה ומלובשת בסיפור מעשה ואותיות ההם
Therefore the letters of the Torah and the plain sense of the narrative are called “the fragrance of your oils”: for even though the inwardness of His blessed wisdom, hidden and clothed in that narrative and those letters, is not understood or comprehended at all
This is why the letters and plain stories of the Torah are called “the fragrance of your oils.” The wisdom hidden in them is not understood.
(משא״כ בהשכלת פשט הדינים והמצות כמו שבאו בביאור המשנה והגמ׳ שגם הפשטיות המובן נק׳ גופי תורה ולא לבושא לבד ע״ש בזהר ובפרדס)
(unlike grasping the plain sense of the laws and mitzvos as they come in the explanation of the Mishnah and Gemara, where even the plain, understood sense is called “the bodies of the Torah” and not merely a garment; see there in the Zohar and in the Pardes),
The parenthesis contrasts the laws, whose plain sense is called the “bodies” of the Torah, not merely its garment. With the laws, what one understands is the substance itself.
עכ״ז האותיות ופשטיות הסיפור הן הן ריח שמניך שבהם ועל ידם ממשיך הקורא במקרא ריח והארה מבחי׳ שמן משחת קדש7
nevertheless the letters and the plain sense of the narrative are themselves “the fragrance of your oils,” for in them and through them the one who reads Scripture draws down a fragrance and glimmer from the level of “the oil of holy anointing,”
Even so, the letters and stories are “the fragrance of your oils”: through reading them a person draws a scent and glimmer from the “holy anointing oil.” The high source reaches him, though not in understood form.
וכמו עד״מ שמריחים ריח הטוב אע״פ שאינו טועם אותו בפיו כלל ואע״פ שהוא רחוק ממנו כו׳
just as, by way of analogy, one smells a good fragrance even though he does not taste it in his mouth at all, and even though he is far from it, etc.
The analogy is smell: one can enjoy a fragrance without tasting it, and even from a distance. So too a reader of Scripture receives something from the divine wisdom without grasping it.
ואדרבה הריח הזה נמשך ממקום עליון ביותר שהוא בחי׳ שמן המריח שלמעלה מבחי׳ שמן סתם ח״ע כו׳
On the contrary, this fragrance is drawn from an exceedingly high place, which is the level of the fragrant oil, which is above the level of plain oil, supernal Chochmah, etc.
On the contrary, the fragrance comes from a higher place than plain oil, which is supernal Chochmah. It comes from the “fragrant oil,” a level above it.
ולפי שהוא גבוה יותר במעלה לא יכול לבא בהתגלות בבחי׳ קירוב בבחי׳ טעם כענין שמן תורק כו׳
And because it is higher in rank, it cannot come into revelation in a manner of closeness, in the manner of taste, like “oil poured forth,” etc.,
Because it is so high, it cannot be revealed close up, as “taste,” the way the laws are grasped. That kind of closeness belongs to “oil poured forth.”
אלא בבחי׳ ריח לבד כו׳ (וכמ״ש בביאור ע״פ אלה מסעי בנ״י בענין ירדן יריחו) וז״ש בזהר בהעלותך (דקמ״ט ע״ב)
but only in the manner of fragrance, etc. (as written in the explanation on “These are the journeys of the children of Israel,” concerning “the Jordan at Jericho”). And this is what is said in the Zohar, Beha’aloscha (149b):
It can reach a person only as fragrance. A maamar on “These are the journeys” connects this with Jericho (Yericho), whose name resembles rei’ach, fragrance; the Zohar is then quoted.
דההוא מלה דההוא ספור לאו לאחזאה על גרמיה בלבד קא אתי אלא לאחזאה על ההוא כללא קאתי8 כו׳ ע״ש.
“That word of that narrative does not come to show about itself alone, but comes to show about that general principle,” etc.; see there.
The Zohar says that each word of a Torah story comes not only to tell its own event but to point to a larger principle. The narrative is a sign of something higher than itself.
ואעפ״כ יש ג״כ מעלה יתירה ועצומה בבחי׳ שמן תורק שהוא המשכת עצמיות ח״ע ולא ריח והארה לבד כו׳ ושניהם כאחד טובים.9
Nevertheless there is also an additional, immense advantage in the level of “oil poured forth,” which is the drawing down of the essence of supernal Chochmah, and not merely fragrance and a glimmer, etc.; and both alike are good.
Still, “oil poured forth,” the laws, has its own great advantage: it brings down the essence of supernal Chochmah, not just a scent of it. Each has its advantage, and both are good.
והנה לימוד הזהר וכהאריז״ל10 הוא בכלל שליש במקרא. וכמ״ש במ״א בפי׳ הזוהר דבראשית (דכ״ז ע״ב) הנזכר למעלה הטעם לזה.
Now the study of the Zohar and of the Arizal is included in “a third in Scripture.” And the reason for this is written elsewhere, in explaining the Zohar on Bereishis (27b) mentioned above.
Now a question: under which third does studying the Zohar and the Arizal’s writings fall? The Alter Rebbe says it belongs to “a third in Scripture,” as explained in his treatment of the Zohar passage cited in paragraph 5.
וקיצור הענין דהרי מדרש הזהר וכן מדרש רבה ושאר המדרשות הן פי׳ המקרא ופירש״י בפ״ק דברכות (די״א ע״ב) שמדרש הוא קרוב למקרא11 כו׳ ע״ש
In brief: the Midrash of the Zohar, and likewise Midrash Rabbah and the other Midrashim, are commentary on Scripture; and Rashi explained in the first chapter of Berachos (11b) that Midrash is close to Scripture, etc.; see there.
In brief, the Zohar, like Midrash Rabbah and other Midrashim, is a commentary on Scripture. Rashi notes that Midrash is close to Scripture.
ואף שבהלכות ת״ת12 מבואר דמדרש תורה שהוא ספרא וספרי וכה״ג הן בכלל שליש במשנה היינו עכ״פ מפני שהן פי׳ דיני וגופי התורה כמו המשנה ממש.
And although in Hilchos Talmud Torah it is explained that the Midrash of the Torah, that is, Sifra and Sifrei and the like, is included in “a third in Mishnah,” that is at any rate because they are the explanation of the laws and bodies of the Torah, just like the Mishnah itself.
The Alter Rebbe’s own Laws of Torah Study count halachic Midrash, like the Sifra and Sifrei, under “Mishnah.” That is because they explain the laws, like the Mishnah itself.
אבל בלימוד סודות הזהר אין השגה אפילו לגדולי החכמים רק ידיעת המציאות מההשתלשלות ולא השגת המהות כלל וה״ז כעין לימוד המקר׳
But in studying the secrets of the Zohar there is no comprehension even for the greatest of sages, only knowledge of the existence of the chain of descending worlds, and no comprehension of the essence at all; and this is like the study of Scripture,
The secrets of the Zohar are different: even the greatest sages can know only that the levels of the chain of worlds exist, not what they are in essence. This is similar to reading Scripture.
שהוא קורא בשמותיו של הקב״ה אע״פ שאינו משיג כלל עצמיות הגנוז בהן כנ״ל וכעין זה הוא בלימוד הזהר וע״ח.13
where one reads the Names of the Holy One, blessed be He, even though he does not comprehend at all the essence hidden in them, as mentioned above; and similar to this is the study of the Zohar and Etz Chaim.
A reader of Scripture reads the Names of G‑d without grasping the essence hidden in them. The study of the Zohar and Etz Chaim is similar.
ולכן הוא בכלל שליש במקרא (ומתורץ בזה מ״ש הר״ן14 ספ״ק דע״ז שהרי המשנה חמורה מן המקרא כו׳ ולמה צריך שליש היום למקרא)
Therefore it is included in “a third in Scripture.” (And this resolves what the Ran writes at the end of the first chapter of Avodah Zarah: “since Mishnah is weightier than Scripture,” etc., “why is a third of the day needed for Scripture?”)
So Kabbalah is counted under “Scripture.” This also answers the Ran’s question: if Mishnah is weightier, why give a full third of the day to Scripture? Because it contains what the Mishnah does not, the “fragrance” from a higher source.
ולכן ג״ז נקרא לריח שמניך שידיעת המציאות היא כמו ריח בעלמא לגבי השגת מהות חכמתו ית׳ שבמשנה ותלמוד.
Therefore this too is called “for fragrance, your oils,” for knowledge of the existence is like mere fragrance compared to comprehension of the essence of His blessed wisdom that is in Mishnah and Talmud.
Knowing that the higher levels exist, without grasping their essence, is like a mere fragrance. That is why this study, too, is called “the fragrance of your oils.”
וע״ד שנתבאר באגה״ק קרוב לסופו15 שבלימוד סדר ההשתלשלות אף אם השיג16 המציאות לא עדיף מצד עצמו כלימוד המצות שמשיג ותופס המהות כו׳
And [this is] along the lines of what is explained in Iggeres HaKodesh near its end, that in studying the order of the chain of descent, even if one has comprehended the existence, it is not in itself superior to the study of the mitzvos, in which one comprehends and grasps the essence, etc.,
Tanya makes a similar point: knowing the order of the worlds is not in itself better than studying the laws, where one grasps the essence. Its value lies elsewhere, as the next part says.
אלא מצד שידיעת המציאות הוא ג״כ מצוה רבה17 ונשאה ואדרבה עולה על כולנה כמ״ש וידעת היום18 דע את אלקי אביך19 כו׳ ומביאה ללב שלם.
but rather in that knowledge of the existence is also a great and exalted mitzvah, and indeed surpasses them all, as it is written, “Know this day,” and “Know the G‑d of your father,” etc., and it brings to a whole heart.
Knowing that G‑d exists and how He relates to the worlds is itself a great mitzvah, even the greatest, as in “Know this day” and “Know the G‑d of your father.” It leads to serving G‑d “with a whole heart.”
ועוד שגם הריח וידיעת המציאות הוא הארה מבחי׳ פנימיות התורה כו׳ (וע׳ בזהר פ׳ אחרי דע״ג20 א׳ תלת דרגין כו׳ וכל חד דרגא על דרגא סתים וגליא כו׳ ע״ש ועמ״ש מזה ע״פ כי קרוב אליך21 הדבר)
Moreover, the fragrance and the knowledge of the existence are also a glimmer from the level of the inner dimension of the Torah, etc. (And see the Zohar, Parshas Acharei, 73a: “three levels,” etc., “and each level upon level, hidden and revealed,” etc.; see there; and see what is written on this on “For the thing is very near to you.”)
Moreover, even this knowledge of existence is a glimmer of the Torah’s inner dimension. The Zohar speaks of three levels, each both hidden and revealed.
Therefore there must be both levels, “for fragrance, your oils,” etc., and “oil poured forth,” etc.; and from this follows “therefore the maidens love You,” as mentioned above.
Therefore both levels are needed, fragrance and poured oil, Scripture and Kabbalah as well as Mishnah and Talmud. From both together comes “therefore the maidens love You”: even sealed hearts come to love G‑d.
Paragraph 10 maps the verse onto the three parts of Torah study: Mishnah and Talmud, whose wisdom is grasped, are “oil poured forth,” while Scripture and Kabbalah, whose depths are not grasped, are “fragrance,” which comes from an even higher source. Both are needed, and together they bring even the “maidens” to love G‑d.
The placement of Zohar and Etz Chaim under “a third in Scripture” is argued at length in Likkutei Torah, Vayikra 5c, where Kabbalah is said to be in Atzilus and therefore known only as to its existence, while Mishnah and Talmud are clothed in Beriah and Yetzirah and so grasped in essence. The Kuntres Acharon of Tanya similarly holds that knowledge of the chain of descent is a separate, very great mitzvah, bringing to a whole heart.
Marei mekomos
- 1לעולם ישלש אדם תלמודו · Kiddushin 30a:10–11
- 2משיג ותופס . . חכמתו ית׳ · ראה תניא פרק ה. ובליקוט פירושים ומ״מ — חיטריק שם.
- 3ואלה כו׳ בארץ אדום · Genesis 36:31
- 4ואין יוצא מידי פשוטו · Shabbat 63a:14–15
- 5ובזהר שם (דקמ״ט ע״ב) · Zohar, Beha'alotcha 4:20–6:29
- 6ובפרדס שער כ״ז פ״א · Pardes Rimmonim 27:5
- 7שמן משחת קדש · Exodus 30:31
- 8דההוא מלה דההוא ספור לאו לאחזאה על גרמיה בלבד קא אתי אלא לאחזאה על ההוא כללא קאתי · Zohar, Beha'alotcha 3:13–4:20
- 9ושניהם כאחד טובים · Ecclesiastes 11:6
- 10והנה לימוד הזהר וכהאריז״ל · Leviticus 5:3
- 11ופירש״י בפ״ק דברכות (די״א ע״ב) שמדרש הוא קרוב למקרא · Rashi on Berakhot 16b:1–18a:1
- 12ואף שבהלכות ת״ת · לאדה״ז פ״ב ה״א.
- 13וה״ז כעין לימוד המקרא . . בלימוד הזהר וע״ח · בלקו״ש ח״ל ע׳ 173 בהערה 43 מבאר ”שאפשר להיות ג״כ לימוד פנימיות התורה ע״ד לימוד הלכות פסוקות שבמשנה ותלמוד — שליש במשנה”.
- 14ומתורץ בזה מ״ש הר״ן · Leviticus 5:3
- 15באגה״ק קרוב לסופו · בקו״א ד״ה להבין מ״ש בפע״ח (קנו, ב). [כ].
- 16השיג · בקו״א שם ”משיג”.
- 17מצוה רבה · וכ״ה בקו״א שם, אבל לעיל ויקרא ה ”רמה” וראה בהערות ותיקונים לכ״ק אדמו״ר לקו״א, ובליקוט פירושים ומ״מ — חיטריק לשם.
- 18וידעת היום · Deuteronomy 4:39
- 19דע את אלקי אביך · I Chronicles 28:9
- 20וע׳ בזהר פ׳ אחרי דע״ג א׳ תלת דרגין · Zohar, Achrei Mot 49:296–50:305
- 21ע״פ כי קרוב אליך · לעיל נצבים מו, א.
- 22לריח שמניך · מאמר זה נאמר בשבת פ׳ כי תצא שנת תקס״ג — ראה רשימת המאמרים בסה״מ תקס״ג ח״ב (מס׳ 131). הנחת כ״ק אדהאמ״צ ממאמר זה נמצא בס׳ מאמרי אדה״ז — על נ״ך ע׳ יח, ובע׳ נ. המאמר עם הגהות אחרות במאמרי אדה״א נ״ך ע׳ רב ומיוסד על מאמר זה.
- 23
- 24
- 25
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
A person who contemplates G‑d’s greatness and feels nothing should not despair: he should humble himself, admit how far he is, and long to cling to G‑d, and above all keep studying Torah, both the laws he can grasp and the Scripture and inner teachings he cannot, because the Torah’s source is high enough to engrave itself even in a sealed heart.
Questions for discussion
- Why can contemplation (“wine”) move some people but not others, and why can Torah (“oil”) reach even a sealed heart?
- How does the image of oil poured from an upturned vessel explain the high root of the Torah’s letters and laws?
- What is the difference between riding the “horse” of the letters and engaging one’s Chochmah, Binah and Daas in them?
- In paragraph 6 fragrance comes from a higher source than poured oil, while in paragraph 7 it is a lower, external flow. How does paragraph 10 reconcile the two readings?
- Why does the Alter Rebbe place the study of the Zohar and Etz Chaim under “a third in Scripture,” and what value does he give to knowing only the existence of the higher levels?
Key terms in this maamar
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- The two 'wings' of divine service.
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×2
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- Nukva (the feminine / Malchus)נוקבא
- Malchus as the receiving configuration.
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×4
- The emotive attributes (middos)מדות
- Love, awe, compassion and the rest. ×1
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Deep connection to an idea, bridging intellect and emotion. ×1
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving. ×2
- Willרצון
- Desire; in G‑d, the level above intellect.
- The Shechinah (Divine Presence)שכינה
- G‑d's presence as it dwells in the world. ×1
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- Kingship: the level through which G‑d's word creates and rules the worlds. ×3
- The inner dimension (pnimiyus)פנימיות
- The innermost core of a level. ×3
- The World of Beriah (Creation)בריאה
- The first world of separate existence.
- The World of Yetzirah (Formation)יצירה
- The world of the angels and emotions.
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest world, including our physical one.
- The World of Atzilus (Emanation)אצילות
- The highest world, still one with G‑d.
- Accepting the yoke (kabbalas ol)קבלת עול
- Submission to G‑d's will beyond understanding.
- The animal soulנפש הבהמית
- The soul that animates the body and its drives.
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The step-by-step descent of divine light from the highest level down to this world. ×3
- Yesod (foundation)יסוד
- The channel that connects and transmits. ×2
- The outer dimension (chitzoniyus)חיצוניות
- The external, expressive aspect. ×1