Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shir HaShirim · Maamar 6
שחורה אני ונאוה בנות ירושלים כאהלי קדר כיריעות שלמה
“I Am Black, yet Comely, O Daughters of Jerusalem”
Begin the maamar Download PDFPDF · 610 KB
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
The soul that has descended into a body is “black”: it receives G‑d’s wisdom as the dark mass of halachic detail and the rabbinic fences around the prohibitions, and it lives among worldly business. Yet this very blackness makes it more beautiful than the souls that never came down: tzedakah given from hard-earned money exalts the whole animal soul and draws a revelation of the Infinite Light into it, and the prohibitions join it to the light that surrounds all worlds, which no positive deed can reach and which will be revealed in the future.
The maamar in brief
“The daughters of Jerusalem” are the souls before their descent, still one with G‑d and so possessed of complete awe (yirah shalem), beyond anything angels can attain. The souls in bodies are the “bride,” Knesses Yisrael, into whom G‑d, the groom, drew His infinite wisdom at Sinai. The bride says: I am black, yet more comely than you. Her blackness is the halachos, the “black locks” of the Song. White hairs, from G‑d’s kindness, are the laws of the positive commandments, which elevate the physical; black hairs are the laws of the prohibitions, which “cruelly” reject even what holds a divine spark. She is also black through tzedakah, bound up with business, yet it exalts the whole animal soul and draws down revelation and the “four hands” of divine help. The words of the Scribes are the hidden source of the Torah’s light, and the prohibitions, rooted in the hidden half of the Name, reach the surrounding light through negation. So the animal soul, rooted in the ofanim, rises above the seraphim in thirst for G‑d’s very self, and in the future that light will be revealed.
Outline
- The daughters of Jerusalem and the brideThe souls above are the daughters of Jerusalem, of complete awe; the souls below are the bride, into whom the groom drew His infinite wisdom at Sinai, each soul receiving its letter of the Torah.¶1–2
- Black locks and white hairThe bride’s blackness is the halachos. Hairs are far-reaching channels of G‑d’s kindness: white for the positive commandments, which lift the physical into holiness; black for the prohibitions, which separate evil from good.¶3–5
- The raven’s cruelty, and tzedakahThe prohibitions reject even what holds a divine spark, and a person must be “cruel” to himself with fences. Tzedakah, bound up with worldly business, is also black, yet it exalts the whole animal soul.¶6
- A fifth to Pharaoh: revelation and the four handsGiving a fifth to tzedakah brings revelation (paroh) into the soul, as in the blessing over every mitzvah, and draws down the four hands: kindness that awakens teshuvah, help against the evil inclination, elevation to love, and the embracing arm, all sown now in exile.¶7–8
- The words of the Scribes and the higher root of the prohibitionsThe Oral Torah, the “scribe,” is the hidden source of the Written Torah’s light. The prohibitions, from the hidden Yud-Hei, join the soul to the surrounding light through “not,” which no positive deed can reach.¶9
- Ofanim above seraphimThe animal soul, rooted in the ofanim, rises above the seraphim in a fiery thirst for G‑d’s very “I,” beyond His outer glory; this foreshadows the future, when the Infinite Light present in space, time and soul will be revealed.¶10–13
- Black, and therefore comelyThrough the blackness of keeping the prohibitions, the surrounding light will be revealed in the future; in this the descended soul is more beautiful than the daughters of Jerusalem.¶14
Key concepts
- Daughters of Jerusalemבנות ירושלים
- The souls before their descent, still included in G‑d; read as yirah shalem, complete awe.
- The bride (kallah)כלה
- Knesses Yisrael, the souls that have descended into bodies, into whom G‑d, the groom, draws His Infinite Light and wisdom.
- Black locks and white hairקוצותיו תלתלים שחורות / שער רישיה כעמר נקא
- Hairs are far-reaching channels of divine flow: the white are the laws of the positive commandments, the black the laws and fences of the prohibitions.
- The words of the Scribesדברי סופרים
- The Oral Torah and rabbinic enactments, the “scribe” above the “book,” the hidden source of the Written Torah’s light.
- Yud-Hei and Vav-Heiי״ה / ו״ה
- The hidden and revealed halves of the Name Havayah: the 365 prohibitions and the 248 positive commandments.
- The surrounding lightסובב כל עלמין
- Divine light beyond the bounds of the worlds, reached now only through negation and revealed in the future.
- Paroh as revelationפרעה
- From the root meaning “uncovered”: tzedakah brings an open revelation of the Infinite Light into the soul.
In the Rebbe’s light · 10
AI research Found by AI reading every place in the Rebbe’s works that cites this maamar, and checked against each source by a second AI reader, the less certain by a third. Only what rated high is shown: the Rebbe’s own words, about this very passage. No person has reviewed it yet, so check the place itself before relying on a detail. See something to correct?
The maamar in the Rebbe’s light
The Rebbe returns to this maamar through the Rebbe Maharash’s Sukkos discourse HaOseh Sukkaso 5635, set out with his additions on Sukkos 5719 and 5728, and through his edited maamar Ach BeGoral (16 Tammuz 5735). With the Rebbe Maharash he asks how the soul can be „טהורה היא” (“pure”) before its creation, and sharpens the answer: beyond even the possibility of impurity, like sechach. He joins the two blacknesses, the descent and the black locks of halachah, by the rule that a service must come „מיני׳ ובי׳” (“from the thing itself”). On the raven’s cruelty he adds that a forbidden thing is “bound” in the outside forces, and that teshuvah still raises the sparks the Torah pushes away (Vayikra 5740); with the Rebbe Maharash he finds cruelty even in tzedakah, grounding it in „צדקה ומשפט” (“tzedakah and judgment”) as the Alter Rebbe explains it and adding the spark left unraised when one fasts before Torah and prayer; and, after Likkutei Torah, he reads „החמישית לפרעה” (“a fifth to Pharaoh”) as the level uniting all levels (eve of 13 Shevat 5746). Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) the blackness is not only the cost of the descent but the form of the service that makes the soul more comely than the daughters of Jerusalem, who, as Ach BeGoral adds, lend it the strength.
Paragraph by paragraph
- ¶1
The Rebbe explains
On the second day of Sukkos 5719 (dibbur hamaschil Chassidim V’Anshei Ma’aseh), explaining how the teshuvah of Tishrei, hidden on Rosh HaShanah and Yom Kippur, is revealed in the joy of Sukkos, the Rebbe turns to “I am black, yet comely” and first asks who the daughters of Jerusalem are and who speaks to them. From here he follows the Rebbe Maharash’s discourse HaOseh Sukkaso 5635, as the editors’ note 14 says.
Our paragraph reads the morning blessing “the soul You gave me is pure; You created it” as two stages: „כי טהורה פי׳ שעדיין היא בבחי׳ אין” (“pure” while the soul is still nothing, ayin), then „אתה בראתה” (created) as a something. The Rebbe Maharash had asked how a soul can be called pure before it was created, and answered that “pure” is the soul in Atzilus, before it descends into Beriah, where creation from nothing begins. Setting this out, the Rebbe adds what “pure” means here: not merely clean of dirt, but „שאי אפשר ולא שייך כלל שיהי׳ בה איזה לכלוך” (beyond any relation to dirt at all), as sechach must be something that cannot become impure.
The Alter Rebbe
ונקרא טהורה היא כי טהורה פי׳ שעדיין היא בבחי׳ אין ואח״כ אתה בראתה יש מאין כו׳
The Rebbe
וכמו״כ הוא הפירוש דטהורה היא, שאי אפשר ולא שייך כלל שיהי׳ בה איזה לכלוך
Sefer HaMaamarim 5719 (bilti muga, new edition), p. לא–לב (secs. ב–ג; the quote on p. לב) · יום ב׳ דחג הסוכות, ה׳תשי״ט (unedited)
- ¶1
Background from the Rebbe
In the edited maamar Ach BeGoral (Wednesday of Parshas Pinchas, 16 Tammuz 5735), on how the division of the Land by lot reflects levels in the soul and its service, the Rebbe takes from the maamarim of 12–13 Tammuz three levels in Israel, “a garden spring,” “a well of living water” and “flowing from Lebanon.” Reading the first as the souls above and the second as the souls in bodies, he comes to „שחורה אני ונאוה בנות ירושלים” (“I am black, yet comely, O daughters of Jerusalem”), and his note 25 sends the reader to this maamar (LT Shir 6c ff.).
Our paragraph reads Yerushalayim as „יראה שלם” (yirah shalem, “complete awe”), without saying where the reading comes from. The Rebbe gives the source: Tosafos (Taanis 16a, as his note 24 places it) says „שירושלים נקרא על שם יראה ועל שם שלם” (the city is named for awe, yirah, and for wholeness, shalem), which is also why no yud is written between the lamed and the mem. So the souls above, who stand in complete awe, bear the name “daughters of Jerusalem.”
The Alter Rebbe
שמקבלים עליהם בחי׳ יראה שלם דהיינו שלימות היראה
The Rebbe
ואז הם נק׳ בשם בנות ירושלים, שירושלים מורה על שלימות היראה, וכדאיתא בתוספות שירושלים נקרא על שם יראה ועל שם שלם
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קמא (sec. ד; the Rebbe’s note 24 gives Tosafos, his note 25 cites this maamar) · יום ד׳ פ׳ פינחס, ט״ז תמוז, ה׳תשל״ה (edited by the Rebbe, who added the notes)
- ¶1
Background from the Rebbe
In a talk on the eve of 20 Marcheshvan 5742, the birthday of the Rebbe Rashab, as his 122nd year and so Psalm 122 („ירושלים הבנוי׳ כעיר שחוברה לה יחדיו”, “Jerusalem, built as a city joined together”) began, the Rebbe draws from the psalm lessons on unity among Jews and explains the Sages’ saying that G‑d will not enter the Jerusalem above until He enters the Jerusalem below (Taanis 5a).
Quoting this paragraph’s definition, „בנות ירושלים נק׳ הנשמות שעדיין לא ירדו לעולם הזה להתלבש בגוף” (that the daughters of Jerusalem are the souls that have not yet come down into a body), the Rebbe draws a consequence: when the souls descend, „הרי הן יורדות מירושלים של מעלה לירושלים של מטה” (they go down from the Jerusalem above to the Jerusalem below), and their descent is a mission, to make the world below a “Jerusalem below.” Among the souls themselves, he adds, “your heads, your tribes” belong to the Jerusalem above and „וחוטב עציך ושואב מימיך” (“your woodchoppers and water-drawers”) to the Jerusalem below, and the verse “a city joined together” asks that the two be one.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה בנות ירושלים נק׳ הנשמות שעדיין לא ירדו לעולם הזה להתלבש בגוף
The Rebbe
ועפ״ז מובן שכאשר הנשמות (”בנות ירושלים”) יורדות למטה, הרי הן יורדות מירושלים של מעלה לירושלים של מטה
Toras Menachem, Hisvaaduyos 5742, vol. 1, p. 407 (sec. יד) · אור ליום ג׳, כ׳ מרחשון ה׳תשמ״ב (unedited; heading on p. 399)
- ¶3
The Rebbe explains
In the same edited maamar, Ach BeGoral of 16 Tammuz 5735, having read the well of living water as the soul in the body, the Rebbe explains “I am black, yet comely” and why the soul says it to the daughters of Jerusalem; his note 25 on the verse cites this maamar (LT Shir 6c ff.).
Our paragraph has the bride, the source of the descended souls, tell the daughters of Jerusalem that she is black yet more comely than they („הריני נאוה יותר מבנות ירושלים”), without saying why she tells them. The Rebbe gives a reason: the soul in the body draws its strength „לברר את השחרות” (to refine its blackness) and become comely as help from its own root above, which is called “daughters of Jerusalem.” Drawing on the Tzemach Tzedek’s Or HaTorah on the Song of the Well, he compares the descent to a well, whose water passes through the concealing veins of the earth and becomes „מים חיים” (“living water”), which purifies where a spring cannot; so the soul, through its descent, rises above what it was as a daughter of Jerusalem.
The Alter Rebbe
אומרת לבנות ירושלים הן הנשמות שלא ירדו שעדיין הן בבחינ׳ טהור׳ היא
The Rebbe
שהכח להנשמה שבגוף לברר את השחרות וכו׳ ולהיות ונאוה הוא ע״י הסיוע שנמשך (להנשמה שבגוף) משרשה שלמעלה הנק׳ בנות ירושלים
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קמא (sec. ד; the Rebbe’s notes 25 and 29) · יום ד׳ פ׳ פינחס, ט״ז תמוז, ה׳תשל״ה (edited by the Rebbe, who added the notes)
- ¶3
The Rebbe explains
On the second day of Sukkos 5728 (dibbur hamaschil HaOseh Sukkaso Tachas HaIlan), asking why a sukkah under a tree is invalid when the mitzvah repays Avraham’s “rest under the tree,” the Rebbe explains that the sechach comes from the incense cloud of Yom Kippur, and to explain that he expounds “I am black, yet comely,” following the Rebbe Maharash (the editors’ note 2) and his own Sukkos 5719 maamar (note 20).
Our paragraph first calls the soul black because of its descent into a body, then says the blackness is the „קוצותיו תלתלים שחורות כעורב” (“black locks”), the halachos. The Rebbe reads “I am black” both ways and joins them. The descent itself darkens: below, „אין צדיק בארץ אשר יעשה טוב ולא יחטא” (“there is no righteous man who does good and does not sin”) (chet as “lack,” a sense of the word found in Likkutei Torah, which the Rebbe Maharash applies to this verse), and even a perfect tzaddik is never wholly nullified (Tanya ch. 35, 37). And since a service must come „מיני׳ ובי׳ אבא לשדי׳ בי׳ נרגא” (“from the tree itself”; Sanhedrin 39b), a soul in a black state must serve in a black way: the black hairs of the prohibitions, “as Rabbeinu HaZaken explains in Likkutei Torah.”
The Alter Rebbe
עם היות כי שחורה אני מחמת ירידתי לעוה״ז והתלבשותי בגוף הגשמי הריני נאוה יותר מבנות ירושלים
The Rebbe
דכיון שהעבודה צריכה להיות באופן דמיני׳ ובי׳ אבא לשדי׳ בי׳ נרגא, לכן בהיות הנשמה למטה במעמד ומצב דשחורה אני, צריכה להיות גם עבודתה בבחי׳ שחרות
Sefer HaMaamarim 5728 (bilti muga, new edition), p. כו–כח (sec. ג; the quote on p. כז) · יום ב׳ דחג הסוכות, ה׳תשכ״ח (unedited)
- ¶6
The Rebbe explains
On Shabbos Chol HaMoed Sukkos 5728, continuing the maamar of the second day, the Rebbe sums up “I am black, yet comely” and repeats ¶5–6 of this maamar almost word for word (the editors’ note 23: LT Shir 6d) before adding to it.
Our paragraph calls the black hairs „אכזריות” (“cruel”) because a forbidden thing holds a G‑dly spark that gives it life, yet the prohibition sends the spark outside instead of raising it. The Rebbe sharpens this with the inner meaning of asur, “forbidden”: it also means „קשור” (“bound”), the spark held bound in the hands of the outside forces (Tanya ch. 7, which the editors cite). So the ruling does not just leave the spark where it was; instead of rising to holiness, it stays bound.
The Alter Rebbe
רק נדחה לחוץ והרי זה כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו
The Rebbe
ובפרט ע״פ הפירוש הפנימי בתיבת ”אסור”, שהוא אסור וקשור בידי החיצונים, הרי מובן ביותר גודל האכזריות על הניצוץ האלקי
Sefer HaMaamarim 5728 (bilti muga, new edition), p. לג–לד (sec. ב; the quote on p. לד; the editors’ notes 23 and 25) · שבת חול המועד סוכות, ה׳תשכ״ח (unedited; continues the second-day maamar)
- ¶6
A question the Rebbe raises
In the second-day maamar of Sukkos 5728, after setting out the raven’s cruelty “as Rabbeinu HaZaken explains in Likkutei Torah,” the Rebbe asks whether the positive commandments, the “white hairs,” have this cruelty too.
Our paragraph also calls the positive commandments “black,” summed up in tzedakah, because tzedakah is bound up with physical money and with business. The Rebbe Maharash had found in tzedakah the raven’s cruelty itself: to stint one’s own food and clothing so as to give to the poor is cruelty to oneself. The Rebbe grounds it in „לעשות צדקה ומשפט” (“to do tzedakah and judgment”), as the Alter Rebbe explains it: a person first judges how much is due to himself and gives the rest. And he adds a case of his own: one who holds back from eating and then learns and prays leaves the spark in the food unraised, „אכזריות על הניצוץ שבמאכל” (a cruelty toward it).
The Alter Rebbe
וגם שחורה אני בבחי׳ קיום המצות מעשיות שהן בדברים המלובשים בגשמיות ממש וכללותן היא צדקה
The Rebbe
אבל כאשר כופה את עצמו ואינו אוכל, אזי לא מתברר הניצוץ ע״י התורה והתפלה, וא״כ, הרי זה ענין של אכזריות על הניצוץ שבמאכל
Sefer HaMaamarim 5728 (bilti muga, new edition), p. כז–כח (sec. ג; the quote on p. כח); also Shabbos Chol HaMoed 5728, p. לד · יום ב׳ דחג הסוכות, ה׳תשכ״ח (unedited)
- ¶6
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on Rashi’s first comment (the Torah opens with Creation so that if the nations say “you are robbers,” Israel can answer), the Rebbe asks why the nations’ claim has any hold at all, and finds it in the sparks of forbidden things, which by the Torah are not in a Jew’s domain.
The Rebbe takes this paragraph’s rule as the Torah’s own order: the spark in a forbidden thing „לא יעלה הניצוץ אלקי שבו . . . רק נדחה לחוץ” (“will not rise… only pushed outside”) (his note 32 quotes it), so by the Torah alone such sparks cannot be refined and are as if outside a Jew’s domain. Teshuvah, given by G‑d Himself, who is above the Torah, does reach them: „תשובה מאהבה” (teshuvah out of love) turns willful sins into merits, and so these sparks too are raised. Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) the “cruelty” of our paragraph is then the rule of the Torah’s order, not the end of the spark.
The Alter Rebbe
ועכ״ז לא יעלה הניצוץ אלקי שבו לרצון לפני הוי׳ להתכלל באורו וקדושתו ית׳ רק נדחה לחוץ
The Rebbe
מצד תורה קענען די ניצוצות פון דברים האסורים ניט נתברר ווערן, איז אָבער מצד ”הקב״ה” אליין (שלמעלה מתורה) געגעבן געוואָרן דער כח אויף תשובה
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כ, p. 4–5 (the sicha, Bereishis א, is pp. 1–6; note 32 is on p. 4, the quote in sec. ו on p. 5) · adapted from a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Vayikra 5740 (the sicha’s closing line)
- ¶6
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Shemini 5725 on Rashi’s comment to the parsha’s last verse, “to separate between the impure and the pure” (between a windpipe cut half-way and one cut for the most part, a hair’s breadth apart), the Rebbe asks what so fine a line has to do with the parsha’s name, Shemini, the eighth, a level above the order of the world.
The Rebbe shows how the “cruelty” of this paragraph can be turned into an argument of the evil inclination: everything G‑d sets before a person is there so that he raise its spark, so how can you refuse this food over a mere doubt and „מדחה זיין דעם ניצוץ אלקי וואס אין אים” (push its divine spark away)? His note 47 cites our page for it: separating from forbidden things is „כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו” (like cruelty toward the divine spark in them). What withstands the argument is the level of “Shemini,” a will above reason that will not give up a hair of the supernal will.
The Alter Rebbe
והרי זה כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו
The Rebbe
ווי האָסטו דאָס רעכט — טענה׳ט דער יצה״ר — ניט צו באַנוצן זיך מיט דעם מאכל און מדחה זיין דעם ניצוץ אלקי וואָס אין אים
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ז, p. 65–73 (the sicha, Shemini ב, begins on p. 65; the quote and note 47 on p. 73) · adapted from a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Shemini 5725
- ¶7
Background from the Rebbe
Speaking to guests at a general yechidus on the eve of 13 Shevat 5746, as they were about to go home, the Rebbe asks them to carry the unity of their days together back with them, and in a note finds unity also in the parsha of the week of the Rebbe Rayatz’s passing, Bo (“come to Pharaoh”).
In a note the Rebbe cites this page, with LT Shir 24d, for a reading of „החמישית לפרעה” (“the fifth to Pharaoh”): the “Pharaoh” of holiness, „דאתפריעו ואתגליין מיני׳ כל נהורין” (“from whom all lights are uncovered and revealed”; Zohar I 210a), is the fifth, „המקיף המאחד את כל הדרגות” (the encompassing level, makif, that unites all the levels). Our paragraph reads Pharaoh as the revelation drawn down by giving a fifth, from which the “four hands” follow; in his talk of Shabbos Bo that year he spells out that the fifth includes and unites the four levels below it, „וארבע הידות יהי׳ לכם” (“the four hands shall be yours”).
The Alter Rebbe
וזהו ונתתם חמישית לפרעה שע״י הצדקה שנותן חומש מיגיעו נעשה בחי׳ פרעה הוא בחי׳ גילוי
The Rebbe
ש״פרעה” (”בא אל פרעה”) דקדושה (”דאתפריעו ואתגליין מיני׳ כל נהורין”) קאי על בחי׳ החמישית, ”החמישית לפרעה” בחי׳ המקיף המאחד את כל הדרגות
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כו, p. 351, note 16 (the talk begins on p. 349) · a talk at a general yechidus for guests, Wednesday of Parshas Beshalach, eve of 13 Shevat 5746 (translated from Yiddish; the same talk in Sichos Kodesh 5746 vol. 2 p. 571)
Short quotes only, with the place of each so it can be read in full. The Rebbe’s sichos, letters and maamarim are published by Kehot and by Vaad Hanochos B’Lahak (lahak.org).
The daughters of Jerusalem and the bride ¶1–2
1שחורה אני ונאוה1 בנות ירושלים כאהלי קדר כיריעות שלמה. הנה בנות ירושלים נק׳ הנשמות שעדיין לא ירדו לעולם הזה להתלבש בגוף
“I am black, yet comely, O daughters of Jerusalem, as the tents of Kedar, as the curtains of Shlomo.” Now, “the daughters of Jerusalem” is the name given to the souls that have not yet descended into this world to be enclothed in a body
The maamar opens with Song of Songs 1:5, where the maiden speaks to “the daughters of Jerusalem.” The Alter Rebbe first identifies these daughters: they are the souls that have not yet come down into this world to be clothed in a body.
ונפש הבהמית ועודן כלולות במאצילן ב״ה בבחי׳ אין ממש ונקרא טהורה היא כי טהורה פי׳ שעדיין היא בבחי׳ אין ואח״כ אתה בראתה2 יש מאין כו׳.
and an animal soul, and are still included in their Emanator, blessed be He, at the level of utter nothingness (ayin). And [the soul] is called “pure is she,” for “pure” means that it is still at the level of ayin; and afterwards, “You created it,” something from nothing, etc.
Before its descent, a soul is still included within G‑d, its Emanator, in a state called ayin, “nothing”: it has no existence of its own apart from Him. He reads the morning blessing “the soul You placed in me is pure; You created it” as a sequence: “pure” is the soul while it is still ayin, and “You created it” is its later coming into being as a separate “something.”
לפי שכל נשמות טרם ירידתם לעוה״ז הן עומדות שם בביטול והתכללות ממש באור א״ס ב״ה.
For all souls, before their descent into this world, stand there in self-nullification (bittul) and in actual inclusion within the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He.
Bittul here means that the soul does not experience itself as a separate being at all; it is wholly absorbed in the Infinite Light. This is the state of every soul “there,” above, before it is born.
וכמ״ש באליהו חי ה׳ אשר עמדתי לפניו345 ולא אליהו בלבד אלא כל נשמות קודם ירידתן והתלבשותן בגוף ונפש הבהמית
As it is written of Eliyahu, “As Havayah lives, before whom I have stood.” And not Eliyahu alone, but all souls, before their descent and their enclothing in a body and an animal soul;
The prophet Eliyahu swears “as Havayah lives, before whom I have stood,” describing himself as one who stands before G‑d. The Alter Rebbe applies the phrase to every soul before its descent: each one stood before G‑d in complete bittul.
ואזי נקראו בנות ירושלים (בפרדס בערכי הכינויים ערך בנות ירושלים הביא בשם הזהר פרשת ויחי שני פירושים בזה והפי׳ הראשון הוא כדפי׳ כאן ע״ש בפ׳ ויחי דרמ״ב ע״א)6
and then they are called “the daughters of Jerusalem (Yerushalayim).” (In the Pardes, in the Erchei HaKinuyim, under the entry “the daughters of Jerusalem,” he cites two interpretations of this in the name of the Zohar, Parshas Vayechi, and the first interpretation is as it has been explained here; see there, in Parshas Vayechi, page 242a.)
In that state the souls are called “the daughters of Jerusalem.” The parenthesis is a scholarly note: the Pardes (Pardes Rimonim, R. Moshe Cordovero’s classic work of Kabbalah), in its section defining Kabbalistic terms, quotes two Zohar readings of the phrase, and the first of them is the reading given here.
שמקבלים עליהם בחי׳ יראה שלם דהיינו שלימות היראה כי היראה הוא מבחינת מלכותו ית׳ מלכות כל עולמים7 למעלה עד אין קץ ולמטה עד אין תכלית
For they take upon themselves the level of a complete awe (yirah shalem), that is, the completeness of awe. For awe stems from the level of His sovereignty, may He be blessed, “a kingship over all worlds,” upward without end and downward without limit,
The name Yerushalayim (Jerusalem) is read as yirah shalem, “complete awe.” Awe of G‑d comes from His Kingship, and Psalms calls that Kingship “a kingship over all worlds,” boundless both upward and downward, that is, infinite.
שהיא בחי׳ א״ס ובהשתלשלות המדרגות בנבראים אין בהם כח לקבל יראה זו בשלימות וכמ״ש להודיע לבני האדם גבורותיו8 וכבוד הדר מלכותו שכבוד הדר
which is the level of the Infinite. And in the chain of descending levels (hishtalshelus) among created beings, they have no power to receive this awe in its completeness. As it is written, “To make known to the sons of man His mighty deeds, and the glorious splendor of His kingdom”: the glorious splendor of
Because the Kingship is infinite, no created being within the descending order of levels can take on the full measure of awe that it calls for. A verse from Psalms shows how awe does reach creatures: through “His mighty deeds” and “the glorious splendor of His kingdom.”
מלכותו הוא מה שהמלאכים מקבלים עליהם עול מלכות שמים מחנה מיכאל באהבה ומחנה גבריאל כו׳ אלף אלפים וריבוא רבבות כו׳9 ולגדודיו אין מספר.10
His kingdom is that the angels take upon themselves the yoke of the kingdom of Heaven, the camp of Michael with love and the camp of Gavriel, etc., “a thousand thousands and ten thousand myriads,” etc., and “His troops are beyond number.”
“The glorious splendor of His kingdom” is the angels’ acceptance of G‑d’s rule. The camp of the angel Michael serves with love and the camp of Gavriel (the text breaks off with “etc.”) in its own way, and their numbers are vast, “a thousand thousands” and beyond counting.
שכל זה הוא יקר ותפארת גדולת מלכותו ית׳ ולהודיע לבני האדם אין זה אלא בבחי׳ גבורותיו הן בחי׳ הצמצומים רבים ושונים שבהשתלשלות המדרגות משא״כ הנשמה טרם בואה
For all this is the glory and splendor of the greatness of His kingship, may He be blessed; and “to make known to the sons of man” is only through the level of “His mighty deeds,” which are the many and varied contractions (tzimtzumim) in the chain of descending levels. But the soul, before it comes
All this angelic service is the glory of G‑d’s Kingship, yet it is made known to creatures only through “His mighty deeds” (gevuros), which the Alter Rebbe reads as the many contractions (tzimtzumim) that limit the light at each step of the descent. Created beings therefore receive awe only in a limited, contracted form.
לעוה״ז להתלבש בגוף שהן בחי׳ אין ממש הם מקבלים עליהם עול מלכות שמים בשלימות כמו שהוא בבחי׳ א״ס ממש ונקראו בנות ירושלים בבחי׳ בתולות אחריה רעותיה מובאות לך11
into this world to be enclothed in a body, [the souls] being at the level of utter nothingness, take upon themselves the yoke of the kingdom of Heaven in completeness, as it is at the level of the Infinite itself. And they are called “the daughters of Jerusalem,” at the level of “virgins, her companions following her, are brought to you.”
The souls before their descent are ayin, with no self of their own, so they accept G‑d’s Kingship in its full, infinite measure. That is why they are “the daughters of Jerusalem,” of complete awe, and they are also the “virgins, her companions” of the Psalm, who follow the bride.
(עיין בזח״ב [בזהר חלק ב׳] קצ״ז ב׳ דרל״ה א׳ רל״ח12 א׳ ובמק״מ [ובמקדש מלך] שם וצ״ל דהוא לפירוש השני שבפרדס וממילא מובן דלפי׳ הראשון יש לפרש גם זה כמ״ש כאן ועיין עוד בפ׳ משפטים דק״ה סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב] ובפ׳ אחרי דס״ז ע״ב)13
(See Zohar II, 197b, page 235a and 238a, and the Mikdash Melech there. And it must be said that this follows the second interpretation in the Pardes; and consequently it is understood that according to the first interpretation this too can be explained as written here. See further in Parshas Mishpatim, page 105, end of side b, and in Parshas Acharei, page 67b.)
A second scholarly parenthesis points to passages of the Zohar on the verse of the “virgins” and to the Mikdash Melech commentary on them. It notes that those passages follow the Pardes’s second interpretation, but that according to the first interpretation they too can be read as they are here.
ונקראו ג״כ עלמות כמ״ש עלמות אהבוך.14 והנשמות שירדו ונתלבשו בגוף ונפש הבהמי׳ [הבהמית] בעוה״ז היא נקרא כנסת ישראל היא מקור נשמות ישראל בשם כלה
They are also called alamos (maidens), as it is written, “the maidens love You.” And the souls that have descended and been enclothed in a body and an animal soul in this world, [collectively] called Knesses Yisrael, which is the source of the souls of Israel, are called by the name “bride” (kallah),
“The maidens (alamos) love You” gives these unborn souls another name. The souls that have descended are called, as one whole, Knesses Yisrael, the “community of Israel” understood as the source of all Jewish souls, and she is called “the bride.”
because the Holy One, blessed be He, is called, in relation to them, by the name “groom” (chasan), from the expression chaus darga (descending a level), which is the drawing down of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, into the souls.
G‑d is “the groom” (chasan), a word the Alter Rebbe links to the Aramaic chaus darga, “going down a step,” as a man goes down a step to take a wife. The groom’s descent to the bride is the drawing down of the Infinite Light into the souls.
The paragraph introduces the two parties of the verse: the “daughters of Jerusalem” are the souls before their descent, still one with G‑d and so possessed of complete awe, while the “bride” is Knesses Yisrael, the souls that have come down into bodies and into whom G‑d, the groom, draws His Infinite Light.
The Kehot note on Eliyahu’s oath observes that the verse (I Kings 17:1) reads “G‑d, the G‑d of Israel,” and points to the same phrase in the mouth of Elisha (II Kings 5:16). The contrast between the angels, whose awe comes through the gevuros and tzimtzumim, and the soul in its source, whose awe is as it is in the Infinite, prepares the maamar’s claim that the soul’s descent brings it to something higher still.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
On the second day of Sukkos 5719 (dibbur hamaschil Chassidim V’Anshei Ma’aseh), explaining how the teshuvah of Tishrei, hidden on Rosh HaShanah and Yom Kippur, is revealed in the joy of Sukkos, the Rebbe turns to “I am black, yet comely” and first asks who the daughters of Jerusalem are and who speaks to them. From here he follows the Rebbe Maharash’s discourse HaOseh Sukkaso 5635, as the editors’ note 14 says.
Our paragraph reads the morning blessing “the soul You gave me is pure; You created it” as two stages: „כי טהורה פי׳ שעדיין היא בבחי׳ אין” (“pure” while the soul is still nothing, ayin), then „אתה בראתה” (created) as a something. The Rebbe Maharash had asked how a soul can be called pure before it was created, and answered that “pure” is the soul in Atzilus, before it descends into Beriah, where creation from nothing begins. Setting this out, the Rebbe adds what “pure” means here: not merely clean of dirt, but „שאי אפשר ולא שייך כלל שיהי׳ בה איזה לכלוך” (beyond any relation to dirt at all), as sechach must be something that cannot become impure.
The Alter Rebbe
ונקרא טהורה היא כי טהורה פי׳ שעדיין היא בבחי׳ אין ואח״כ אתה בראתה יש מאין כו׳
The Rebbe
וכמו״כ הוא הפירוש דטהורה היא, שאי אפשר ולא שייך כלל שיהי׳ בה איזה לכלוך
Sefer HaMaamarim 5719 (bilti muga, new edition), p. לא–לב (secs. ב–ג; the quote on p. לב) · יום ב׳ דחג הסוכות, ה׳תשי״ט (unedited)
Background from the Rebbe
In the edited maamar Ach BeGoral (Wednesday of Parshas Pinchas, 16 Tammuz 5735), on how the division of the Land by lot reflects levels in the soul and its service, the Rebbe takes from the maamarim of 12–13 Tammuz three levels in Israel, “a garden spring,” “a well of living water” and “flowing from Lebanon.” Reading the first as the souls above and the second as the souls in bodies, he comes to „שחורה אני ונאוה בנות ירושלים” (“I am black, yet comely, O daughters of Jerusalem”), and his note 25 sends the reader to this maamar (LT Shir 6c ff.).
Our paragraph reads Yerushalayim as „יראה שלם” (yirah shalem, “complete awe”), without saying where the reading comes from. The Rebbe gives the source: Tosafos (Taanis 16a, as his note 24 places it) says „שירושלים נקרא על שם יראה ועל שם שלם” (the city is named for awe, yirah, and for wholeness, shalem), which is also why no yud is written between the lamed and the mem. So the souls above, who stand in complete awe, bear the name “daughters of Jerusalem.”
The Alter Rebbe
שמקבלים עליהם בחי׳ יראה שלם דהיינו שלימות היראה
The Rebbe
ואז הם נק׳ בשם בנות ירושלים, שירושלים מורה על שלימות היראה, וכדאיתא בתוספות שירושלים נקרא על שם יראה ועל שם שלם
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קמא (sec. ד; the Rebbe’s note 24 gives Tosafos, his note 25 cites this maamar) · יום ד׳ פ׳ פינחס, ט״ז תמוז, ה׳תשל״ה (edited by the Rebbe, who added the notes)
Background from the Rebbe
In a talk on the eve of 20 Marcheshvan 5742, the birthday of the Rebbe Rashab, as his 122nd year and so Psalm 122 („ירושלים הבנוי׳ כעיר שחוברה לה יחדיו”, “Jerusalem, built as a city joined together”) began, the Rebbe draws from the psalm lessons on unity among Jews and explains the Sages’ saying that G‑d will not enter the Jerusalem above until He enters the Jerusalem below (Taanis 5a).
Quoting this paragraph’s definition, „בנות ירושלים נק׳ הנשמות שעדיין לא ירדו לעולם הזה להתלבש בגוף” (that the daughters of Jerusalem are the souls that have not yet come down into a body), the Rebbe draws a consequence: when the souls descend, „הרי הן יורדות מירושלים של מעלה לירושלים של מטה” (they go down from the Jerusalem above to the Jerusalem below), and their descent is a mission, to make the world below a “Jerusalem below.” Among the souls themselves, he adds, “your heads, your tribes” belong to the Jerusalem above and „וחוטב עציך ושואב מימיך” (“your woodchoppers and water-drawers”) to the Jerusalem below, and the verse “a city joined together” asks that the two be one.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה בנות ירושלים נק׳ הנשמות שעדיין לא ירדו לעולם הזה להתלבש בגוף
The Rebbe
ועפ״ז מובן שכאשר הנשמות (”בנות ירושלים”) יורדות למטה, הרי הן יורדות מירושלים של מעלה לירושלים של מטה
Toras Menachem, Hisvaaduyos 5742, vol. 1, p. 407 (sec. יד) · אור ליום ג׳, כ׳ מרחשון ה׳תשמ״ב (unedited; heading on p. 399)
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsTiferesKnesses YisraelYesh me’ayinNefesh habahamis+12
- Tiferes תפארת
- Knesses Yisrael כנסת ישראל
- Yesh me’ayin יש מאין
- Nefesh habahamis נפש הבהמית
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Tzimtzum צמצום
- Malachim מלאכים
- Ein Sof אין סוף
- Yesh and ayin יש ואין
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
- Malchus מלכות
- Hiskallelus התכללות
Marei mekomos
- 1שחורה אני ונאוה · Song of Songs 1:5
- 2טהורה היא ... אתה בראתה · Berakhot 60b:4
- 3חי ה׳ אשר עמדתי לפניו · מ״א יז, א. ושם ה׳ ”אלקי ישראל”. וראה מ״ב ה, טז (באלישע). וכ״ה לעיל חוקת סד, ד. ובסידור רסג, ב.
- 4
- 5חי ה׳ אשר עמדתי לפניו · I Kings 17:1
- 6הביא בשם הזהר פרשת ויחי ... דרמ״ב ע״א · Zohar, Vayechi 65:661–66:673
- 7מלכות כל עולמים · Psalms 145:13
- 8להודיע לבני האדם גבורותיו · Psalms 145:12
- 9אלף אלפים וריבוא רבבות כו׳ · Daniel 7:10
- 10ולגדודיו אין מספר · Chagigah 13b:13
- 11בתולות אחרי׳ רעותי׳ מובאות לך · Psalms 45:15
- 12בזח״ב קצ״ז ב׳ . . רל״ח א׳ · הלשון ביהל אור ע׳ קעו.
- 13ובפ׳ אחרי דס״ז ע״ב · Zohar, Achrei Mot 33:203–207
- 14עלמות אהבוך · Song of Songs 1:3
- 15כי הקב״ה נקרא אצלם בשם חתן · ראה גם אוה״ת ויצא ריד, א. תלה, א. כרך ג תקמח, ב. דברים ע׳ לז. ספר החקירה עד, א.
- 16חתן מלשון חות דרגא · Yevamot 63a
- 17
2והיינו במ״ת [במתן תורה] דכתי׳ [דכתיב] ביום חתונתו שאז הוא זמן הנשואין שכמו הנשואין עד״מ בחי׳ הזווג והיחוד הוא המשכת הטפה הנמשכת מן המוח של המשפיע בבחי׳ המקבל כו׳.4
And this is [what took place] at the Giving of the Torah, of which it is written, “on the day of his wedding,” for that is the time of the marriage. For just as in marriage, by way of analogy, the union and joining is the drawing down of the drop that is drawn from the brain of the giver into the recipient, etc.,
The Mishnah reads “on the day of his wedding” in Song of Songs as the Giving of the Torah at Sinai: that was the wedding of G‑d and Israel. The analogy is marital union, in which (in the older physiology the text assumes) a drop drawn from the brain of the giver passes to the recipient.
כך התורה היא בחי׳ חכמתו ורצונו ית׳ בבחי׳ א״ס ב״ה ממש חכים ולא בחכמה ידיעא כו׳
The “drop” in this analogy is the Torah, which is G‑d’s own wisdom and will as they are in the Infinite itself. The classic Kabbalistic phrase “wise, but not with a knowable wisdom” stresses that G‑d’s wisdom is unlike any wisdom we could grasp.
והמשכה זו בבחי׳ א״ס ממש היא נתפסת ונקלטת בנשמות ישראל ס״ר אותיות התורה1 הן ס״ר המשכות לס״ר נשמות ישראל
And this drawing down, at the level of the Infinite itself, is grasped and absorbed in the souls of Israel: the six hundred thousand letters of the Torah are six hundred thousand channels of flow to the six hundred thousand souls of Israel.
This infinite wisdom is received and “absorbed” by Jewish souls, as a seed is absorbed and takes hold. The Torah is said to contain six hundred thousand letters, matching the six hundred thousand root souls of Israel, so that each soul has its own letter as its channel.
ולכן ארז״ל [אמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] שמלמדין את התינוק בבטן אמו2 את כל התורה כו׳ כדי להיות נתפס ונקלט בנשמתו אור וחיות מאותיות התורה שהן הארת אור א״ס ב״ה חכים ולא בחכמה ידיעא כו׳
Therefore our Sages, of blessed memory, said that the infant in its mother’s womb is taught the entire Torah, etc., so that light and life-force (chayus) from the letters of the Torah be grasped and absorbed in its soul; for they are a radiance of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, “wise, but not with a knowable wisdom,” etc.
The Talmud teaches that an unborn child is taught the entire Torah in the womb. The Alter Rebbe explains its purpose: so that the light of the Torah’s letters, a radiance of the Infinite, takes hold in the soul from the very start.
ואזי נקרא נשמות ישראל בשם כלה שמקבלת הטפה כו׳ ועיין באדרא זוטא3 (דף ר״צ ע״ב):
And then the souls of Israel are called by the name “bride,” for she receives the drop, etc. See the Idra Zuta (page 290b).
Because the souls receive this “drop” of divine wisdom, they are called “the bride.” The text refers the reader to the Idra Zuta, the concluding section of the Zohar, for this theme.
The paragraph explains why the descended souls are the “bride”: at Sinai, the wedding day, G‑d’s infinite wisdom, the Torah, was drawn down into them like the seed of a groom, each soul receiving its own letter.
The correspondence of six hundred thousand letters and six hundred thousand souls is cited by the Kehot note from Megaleh Amukos, and the Rebbe discusses it in a note in Sefer HaMaamarim 5708. The key terms here, “grasped and absorbed” (nispas veniklat), come from the language of conception and will return later in the maamar, where a soul that fails to hold on to its Torah is compared to a woman who does not conceive.
TermsKiddushin / erusin and nisuinSupernal WillYichudEin Sof+8
- Kiddushin / erusin and nisuin קדושין ונשואין
- Supernal Will רצון העליון
- Yichud יחוד
- Ein Sof אין סוף
- Osiyos אותיות
- Ratzon רצון
Also NeshamahChayusOr Ein SofChochmahHaalaah vehamshachahTorah
Marei mekomos
- 1בנשמות ישראל ס״ר אותיות התורה · מגלה עמוקות אופן קפו. עיין הערת כ״ק אדמו״ר בספר המאמרים תש״ח ע׳ רמא.
- 2שמלמדין את התינוק בבטן אמו · Niddah 30b:21–22
- 3ועיין באדרא זוטא · ראה לקמן ח, ג. אוה״ת בראשית כרך ז ד״ה ויתן לי מערת המכפלה.
- 4במ״ת דכתיב ביום חתונתו · Song of Songs 3:11
Black locks and white hair ¶3–5
3ב והנה בחי׳ כלה זו שהיא בחי׳ מקור לנשמות שירדו ונתלבשו בגוף אומרת לבנות ירושלים הן הנשמות שלא ירדו שעדיין הן בבחינ׳ [בבחינת / בבחינה] טהור׳ היא שהן כלולות במאצילן בבחי׳ אין ממש.
2. Now, this level of “bride,” which is the source of the souls that have descended and been enclothed in a body, says to the daughters of Jerusalem, that is, the souls that have not descended and are still at the level of “pure is she,” being included in their Emanator at the level of utter nothingness:
The second section begins. The “bride,” the source of the souls that have descended into bodies, now speaks to the “daughters of Jerusalem,” the souls that remain above, still “pure” and included in G‑d.
עם היות כי שחורה אני מחמת ירידתי לעוה״ז והתלבשותי בגוף הגשמי הריני נאוה יותר מבנות ירושלים כי
Though “I am black” because of my descent into this world and my enclothing in the physical body, I am nevertheless more comely than the daughters of Jerusalem. For
Her claim is paradoxical: she has been darkened by her descent into a physical body, yet she is more beautiful than the souls that never descended. The rest of the maamar explains how the blackness itself is the source of her beauty.
¶14 Why is the black bride more comely? Paragraph 14 completes the answer.
הנה ענין שחורה אני בבחי׳ כלה הוא כמ״ש קוצותיו תלתלים שחורות כעורב1 תלתלים תלי תלים של הלכות2 שהן ו, דקוצותיו בחי׳
the meaning of “I am black” at the level of the bride is as it is written, “His locks are curled (taltalim), black as a raven”: taltalim [means] tilei tilim (heaps upon heaps) of halachos, which are “his locks,” the level of
Song of Songs describes the beloved’s locks as “curled, black as a raven.” The Talmud reads taltalim, “curled,” as tilei tilim, “heaps upon heaps”: from every stroke of the Torah’s letters, heaps of laws can be derived. So the “black locks” are the vast body of halachic detail.
שערות ונימין הנמשכות מן המוח בריבוי התחלקות וכך הן תלי תלים של הלכות המשכות מחכמה עילאה חכים ולא בחכמה ידיעא כו׳. הן בבחי׳ שחורות.
hairs and strands drawn from the brain in great subdivision. And so too, the heaps upon heaps of halachos are channels drawn from the Supernal Wisdom (Chochmah Ila’ah), “wise, but not with a knowable wisdom,” etc. They are at the level of “black.”
Hair grows out of the head and divides into countless strands; so the laws of the Torah branch out from G‑d’s Supernal Wisdom into endless details. These branches of halachah are what the verse calls “black.”
The bride tells the souls above that her blackness makes her more beautiful than they are, and the Alter Rebbe begins to define that blackness: the multitude of halachos, which branch out from G‑d’s wisdom like black hair from the head.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In the same edited maamar, Ach BeGoral of 16 Tammuz 5735, having read the well of living water as the soul in the body, the Rebbe explains “I am black, yet comely” and why the soul says it to the daughters of Jerusalem; his note 25 on the verse cites this maamar (LT Shir 6c ff.).
Our paragraph has the bride, the source of the descended souls, tell the daughters of Jerusalem that she is black yet more comely than they („הריני נאוה יותר מבנות ירושלים”), without saying why she tells them. The Rebbe gives a reason: the soul in the body draws its strength „לברר את השחרות” (to refine its blackness) and become comely as help from its own root above, which is called “daughters of Jerusalem.” Drawing on the Tzemach Tzedek’s Or HaTorah on the Song of the Well, he compares the descent to a well, whose water passes through the concealing veins of the earth and becomes „מים חיים” (“living water”), which purifies where a spring cannot; so the soul, through its descent, rises above what it was as a daughter of Jerusalem.
The Alter Rebbe
אומרת לבנות ירושלים הן הנשמות שלא ירדו שעדיין הן בבחינ׳ טהור׳ היא
The Rebbe
שהכח להנשמה שבגוף לברר את השחרות וכו׳ ולהיות ונאוה הוא ע״י הסיוע שנמשך (להנשמה שבגוף) משרשה שלמעלה הנק׳ בנות ירושלים
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קמא (sec. ד; the Rebbe’s notes 25 and 29) · יום ד׳ פ׳ פינחס, ט״ז תמוז, ה׳תשל״ה (edited by the Rebbe, who added the notes)
The Rebbe explains
On the second day of Sukkos 5728 (dibbur hamaschil HaOseh Sukkaso Tachas HaIlan), asking why a sukkah under a tree is invalid when the mitzvah repays Avraham’s “rest under the tree,” the Rebbe explains that the sechach comes from the incense cloud of Yom Kippur, and to explain that he expounds “I am black, yet comely,” following the Rebbe Maharash (the editors’ note 2) and his own Sukkos 5719 maamar (note 20).
Our paragraph first calls the soul black because of its descent into a body, then says the blackness is the „קוצותיו תלתלים שחורות כעורב” (“black locks”), the halachos. The Rebbe reads “I am black” both ways and joins them. The descent itself darkens: below, „אין צדיק בארץ אשר יעשה טוב ולא יחטא” (“there is no righteous man who does good and does not sin”) (chet as “lack,” a sense of the word found in Likkutei Torah, which the Rebbe Maharash applies to this verse), and even a perfect tzaddik is never wholly nullified (Tanya ch. 35, 37). And since a service must come „מיני׳ ובי׳ אבא לשדי׳ בי׳ נרגא” (“from the tree itself”; Sanhedrin 39b), a soul in a black state must serve in a black way: the black hairs of the prohibitions, “as Rabbeinu HaZaken explains in Likkutei Torah.”
The Alter Rebbe
עם היות כי שחורה אני מחמת ירידתי לעוה״ז והתלבשותי בגוף הגשמי הריני נאוה יותר מבנות ירושלים
The Rebbe
דכיון שהעבודה צריכה להיות באופן דמיני׳ ובי׳ אבא לשדי׳ בי׳ נרגא, לכן בהיות הנשמה למטה במעמד ומצב דשחורה אני, צריכה להיות גם עבודתה בבחי׳ שחרות
Sefer HaMaamarim 5728 (bilti muga, new edition), p. כו–כח (sec. ג; the quote on p. כז) · יום ב׳ דחג הסוכות, ה׳תשכ״ח (unedited)
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsSe’arosOlam HaZehHigher Chochmah and the lower ChochmahYesh and ayin+3
- Se’aros שערות
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Higher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah חכמה עלאה וחכמה תתאה
- Yesh and ayin יש ואין
- Hiskallelus התכללות
Marei mekomos
- 1קווצותיו תלתלים שחרות כעורב · Song of Songs 5:11
- 2תלתלים תלי תלים של הלכות · Eruvin 21b:23–25
4והענין יובן בהקדים לבאר כי הנה כתיב ושער רישי׳ [רישיה] כעמר נקא1 שהשערות הן בבחי׳ לבנונית וכתיב קוצותיו תלתלים שחורות2 כו׳.
The matter will be understood by first explaining that it is written, “And the hair of His head was like pure wool,” [meaning] that the hairs are in a state of whiteness; and it is written, “His locks are curled, black,” etc.
Daniel sees the “Ancient of Days” with hair “like pure wool,” that is, white hair, while the Song of Songs speaks of black locks. The Alter Rebbe will explain why the “hairs” are sometimes white and sometimes black.
אך הענין כי הנה בחי׳ השערות הן המשכות שהן מבחי׳ חסד ורב חסד3 שנמשך ונתפשט עד למטה כמשל השערות שנמשכות באורך
But the explanation is that the level of the hairs is channels of flow that stem from the level of Chesed and “abundant in kindness,” which is drawn and spreads down below, like the analogy of the hairs that extend to a great
In Kabbalah, “hairs” stand for channels of divine flow that extend far from their source, just as hair grows far out from the head. These channels come from Chesed, G‑d’s kindness, which reaches down even to the lowest levels, and from “abundant in kindness,” one of the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy.
רב והן תלי תלים של הלכות ודקדוקי סופרים4 שבכל מצוה כמ״ש (משלי ד׳) סלסלה ותרוממך5. פי׳ סלסלה כמארז״ל [כמאמר רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] (ר״ה [ראש השנה] כ״ו ב׳) קא מהפך בשעריה6 כו׳.
length. And they are the heaps upon heaps of halachos and the fine points of the Scribes that are in every mitzvah, as it is written (Proverbs 4), “Extol her (salseleha), and she will exalt you.” The meaning of salseleha is as our Sages, of blessed memory, said (Rosh HaShanah 26b), “[a man who] was turning over his hair,” etc.
These long, many-stranded channels are the heaps of halachos and the fine rabbinic details in every mitzvah. In Proverbs salseleha plainly means “extol her” (wisdom), but the Sages learned its sense from Rebbi’s maidservant, who asked a man turning over his hair, “How long will you be mesalsel (curling) your hair?” So to “extol” the Torah is to turn it over and over, like curling hair, into every detail.
אך יש שערות שנמשכות ומתלבשות בבחי׳ לבנונית הוא בחי׳ חסד שהן ההלכות רבות שבמ״ע [שבמצות עשה] בקרבנות ותרומות ומעשרות וציצית ותפילין ושבת כו׳. איך תהי׳ [תהיה] המצות נעשית בקרבן להיות עולה לרצון לפני הוי׳ וריח ניחוח כו׳.
But there are hairs that are drawn down and enclothed in the level of whiteness, which is the level of Chesed: these are the many halachos in the positive commandments, concerning sacrifices, terumos, tithes, tzitzis, tefillin, Shabbos, etc.: how the mitzvah is to be done with a sacrifice so that it ascend favorably before G‑d and as a pleasing fragrance, etc.
Some “hairs” are white: the many laws of the positive commandments, such as sacrifices, terumah, tithes, tzitzis (the fringes on the corners of a garment), tefillin and Shabbos. They teach how to perform the mitzvah, for example how to offer a sacrifice so that it is “accepted before G‑d” and becomes a “pleasing fragrance,” in the language of the laws of the offerings in Leviticus.
The paragraph lays the groundwork for the image of hair: hairs are far-reaching channels of G‑d’s kindness, the details of halachah, and those that belong to the positive commandments are the “white” hairs of Daniel’s vision.
TermsRei’achChesed olamSe’arosKorbanos+4
Also Torah and mitzvos
Marei mekomos
- 1ושער רישי׳ כעמר נקא · Daniel 7:9
- 2קוצותיו תלתלים שחורות · Song of Songs 5:11
- 3ורב חסד · Exodus 34:6
- 4תלי תלים של הלכות ודקדוקי סופרים · ראה אוה״ת בראשית כרך ז תתשפג, ב.
- 5
- 6
5וכן בשאר כל המצות שהן המשכות חכמה עילאה בבחי׳ חסד להעלות הדברים הגשמיי׳ [הגשמיים] בעשייתן כמצותן ולקשרם באור ה׳ וקדושתו והן השערות הנמשכות מבחי׳ שער רישיה כעמר נקא1 שהוא לובן העליון וחסד עליון דאקרי רב חסד2 כו׳
And so too with all the other mitzvos, which are channels of the Supernal Wisdom through the level of Chesed, to elevate physical things through their being performed according to their commandment, and to bind them to the light of G‑d and His holiness. These are the hairs drawn from the level of “the hair of His head was like pure wool,” which is the supernal whiteness and the supernal Chesed that is called “abundant in kindness,” etc.
Every positive mitzvah is a channel of G‑d’s Supernal Wisdom through Chesed, and doing it properly raises the physical objects it uses (the wool of tzitzis, the parchment of tefillin) and binds them to G‑d’s holiness. These are the “white hairs” of Daniel’s vision, from the supernal whiteness that is G‑d’s kindness.
אבל השערות השחורות הן הלכות שנמשכו ונתפשטו במצות ל״ת [לא תעשה] להפריד הרע מן הטוב ולדחותו מן הקדושה שאינו עולה ונכלל באור ה׳ וקדושתו.
But the black hairs are the halachos that were drawn and spread into the prohibitive commandments, to separate the evil from the good and to push it away from holiness, since it does not ascend and become included in the light of G‑d and His holiness.
The “black hairs” are the laws of the prohibitions. Their work is the opposite of elevation: they separate evil from good and push it away from holiness, because what is forbidden cannot be raised up and included in G‑d’s light.
The paragraph completes the contrast: the positive commandments are white hairs, which lift the physical world into holiness, and the prohibitions are black hairs, which reject and push away what cannot be lifted.
TermsLoven ha’elyonChesed olamSe’arosHigher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah+5
- Loven ha’elyon לובן העליון explained hereThe positive mitzvos, which raise physical things and bind them to G‑d’s light, are the white hairs drawn from “the hair of His head like pure wool,” the supernal whiteness and supernal Chesed called “abundant in kindness”; the black hairs are the halachos of the prohibitions, which separate evil from good.
שער רישיה כעמר נקא שהוא לובן העליון וחסד עליון דאקרי רב חסד
- Chesed olam חסד עולם
- Se’aros שערות
- Higher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah חכמה עלאה וחכמה תתאה
- Chesed חסד
- Hiskallelus התכללות
Marei mekomos
- 1שער רישיה כעמר נקא · Daniel 7:9
- 2דאקרי רב חסד · Exodus 34:6
The raven’s cruelty, and tzedakah ¶6
6וע״ז נאמר שחורות כעורב.1 פי׳ כעורב שהוא אכזרי כך יש בבחי׳ שערות הללו בחי׳ אכזריות שהרי גם בדבר האסור ופסול כו׳
And of this it is said, “black as a raven.” The meaning of “as a raven” is: just as the raven is cruel, so in the level of these hairs there is an element of cruelty. For even in a thing that is forbidden or unfit, etc.,
The raven was proverbially cruel (the Talmud, Eruvin 22a, speaks of one who for the sake of Torah study makes himself “cruel to his children and his household, like a raven”), so “black as a raven” hints that these “black hairs” contain an element of cruelty. The Alter Rebbe explains the cruelty by looking at what is forbidden.
נמשך נצוץ וחיות אלקי המחיה ומהווה אותו שבלעדי ניצוץ וחיות אלקי לא יתקיים כלל ועכ״ז [ועם כל זה] לא יעלה הניצוץ אלקי שבו לרצון לפני הוי׳ להתכלל באורו וקדושתו ית׳ רק נדחה לחוץ
there is drawn a divine spark and life-force that gives it life and brings it into being, for without the divine spark and life-force it would not exist at all; and nevertheless the divine spark within it does not ascend favorably before G‑d, to be included in His light and holiness, may He be blessed, but rather is pushed outside.
Nothing can exist without a divine spark that gives it life, so even a forbidden thing has one. Yet the prohibition means that this spark cannot be raised up into holiness through use; the spark is simply rejected, pushed outside.
והרי זה כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו גם צריך האדם להתנהג בנפשו במדת אכזריות להיות סר מרע בבחינת אתכפייא כו׳ בכמה גדרים וסייגים דקדוקי סופרים קדש א״ע [את עצמו] במותר לך2 כו׳
And this is like cruelty toward the divine spark within it. A person, too, must conduct himself toward his own soul with the attribute of cruelty, turning away from evil in the manner of iskafya (subjugation), etc., through many fences and safeguards, the fine points of the Scribes: “Sanctify yourself in what is permitted to you,” etc.
Rejecting a thing that holds a divine spark is a kind of cruelty toward that spark. A person must show the same “cruelty” toward himself: iskafya, subduing his own desires, and adding rabbinic fences, as the Talmud says, “sanctify yourself in what is permitted to you.”
ולכן נקרא בבחי׳ שחורות כעורב (וע׳ בזהר ח״ג [חלק ג׳] קל״ב א׳ ק״מ ע״א ע״ט ב׳ קכ״ז ב׳. ח״ב [חלק ב׳] קי״ו א׳)
Therefore it is called the level of “black as a raven.” (See Zohar III, 132a, 140a, 79b, 127b; Zohar II, 116a.)
This is why the laws of prohibition are called “black as a raven.” The parenthesis lists passages of the Zohar; the first two (132a and 140a) are in the Idra Rabba of Parshas Nasso, which speaks of the black hairs and contrasts them with the white.
וע״ז נאמר שחורה אני שמקבלת בחי׳ הטפה היא בחי׳ ח״ע [חכמה עילאה] בבחי׳ שחורה דהיינו בבחי׳ ההלכות ודקדוקי סופרים שהן קוצותיו תלתלים שחורות כעורב כנ״ל.
And of this it is said, “I am black”: for she receives the drop, which is the Supernal Wisdom (Chochmah Ila’ah), in the manner of “black,” that is, in the form of the halachos and the fine points of the Scribes, which are “his locks are curled, black as a raven,” as explained above.
Now the verse “I am black” can be read: the bride, the descended soul, receives the “drop” of G‑d’s Supernal Wisdom in its “black” form, the details of halachah and the rabbinic safeguards that are the “black locks” described above.
וגם שחורה אני בבחי׳ קיום המצות מעשיות שהן בדברים המלובשים בגשמיות ממש וכללותן היא צדקה
And also, “I am black” in the fulfillment of the practical mitzvos, which are done with things enclothed in actual physicality; and the sum of them all is tzedakah (charity),
A second sense of “I am black”: the practical mitzvos are done with physical things, and all of them are summed up in tzedakah, charity.
שהיא בגשמיות ממש וחיובה הוא ע״י עסק האדם בעוה״ז שעוסק בפרקמטיא ומרויח בה שעי״ז נתחייב בצדקה. ובשעה שהוא עוסק בפרקמטיא נמצא שהוא מלובש בעניני עוה״ז ממש.
which is in actual physicality, and whose obligation comes through a person’s involvement in this world: he engages in business and profits from it, and through this becomes obligated in tzedakah. And while he is engaged in business, he is thus enclothed in the matters of this world itself.
Tzedakah is “black” because it is bound up with physical money, and a person becomes obliged to give it only because he is busy earning a living. While he does business, he is immersed in the affairs of this world.
עכ״ז [עם כל זה] ונאוה שבצדקה כתיב וצדקה תרומם גוי3 שע״י שנותן צדקה לעני מעמלו ויגיעו חיי נפשו הוא מעלה ומרומם את כל נפש הבהמית וחיותה:4
Even so, “yet comely”: for of tzedakah it is written, “Tzedakah exalts a nation”; for by giving tzedakah to a poor person from his toil and labor, the very life of his soul, he elevates and exalts his entire animal soul and its life-force.
Yet tzedakah makes the soul “comely,” because “tzedakah exalts.” Money earned by effort holds a person’s very life, so giving it away lifts up the animal soul and all the life-force it spent earning it.
The paragraph explains why the laws of prohibition are the “black,” cruel hairs, since they reject even what holds a divine spark, and gives a second meaning of “I am black”: tzedakah, bound up with worldly business, which nevertheless raises up the whole animal soul.
The later passage in Likkutei Torah to which the Kehot note points quotes the Idra of Nasso: the black locks belong to the “lower beard” and the white hair to the “upper beard,” and the Torah was given as black fire on white fire. It adds that the laws of the prohibitions come from the hairs of Z’eir Anpin, and those of the positive commandments from the white hairs of Arich Anpin (the “Long Face,” the configuration of Keser, the level of will above intellect).
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
On Shabbos Chol HaMoed Sukkos 5728, continuing the maamar of the second day, the Rebbe sums up “I am black, yet comely” and repeats ¶5–6 of this maamar almost word for word (the editors’ note 23: LT Shir 6d) before adding to it.
Our paragraph calls the black hairs „אכזריות” (“cruel”) because a forbidden thing holds a G‑dly spark that gives it life, yet the prohibition sends the spark outside instead of raising it. The Rebbe sharpens this with the inner meaning of asur, “forbidden”: it also means „קשור” (“bound”), the spark held bound in the hands of the outside forces (Tanya ch. 7, which the editors cite). So the ruling does not just leave the spark where it was; instead of rising to holiness, it stays bound.
The Alter Rebbe
רק נדחה לחוץ והרי זה כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו
The Rebbe
ובפרט ע״פ הפירוש הפנימי בתיבת ”אסור”, שהוא אסור וקשור בידי החיצונים, הרי מובן ביותר גודל האכזריות על הניצוץ האלקי
Sefer HaMaamarim 5728 (bilti muga, new edition), p. לג–לד (sec. ב; the quote on p. לד; the editors’ notes 23 and 25) · שבת חול המועד סוכות, ה׳תשכ״ח (unedited; continues the second-day maamar)
A question the Rebbe raises
In the second-day maamar of Sukkos 5728, after setting out the raven’s cruelty “as Rabbeinu HaZaken explains in Likkutei Torah,” the Rebbe asks whether the positive commandments, the “white hairs,” have this cruelty too.
Our paragraph also calls the positive commandments “black,” summed up in tzedakah, because tzedakah is bound up with physical money and with business. The Rebbe Maharash had found in tzedakah the raven’s cruelty itself: to stint one’s own food and clothing so as to give to the poor is cruelty to oneself. The Rebbe grounds it in „לעשות צדקה ומשפט” (“to do tzedakah and judgment”), as the Alter Rebbe explains it: a person first judges how much is due to himself and gives the rest. And he adds a case of his own: one who holds back from eating and then learns and prays leaves the spark in the food unraised, „אכזריות על הניצוץ שבמאכל” (a cruelty toward it).
The Alter Rebbe
וגם שחורה אני בבחי׳ קיום המצות מעשיות שהן בדברים המלובשים בגשמיות ממש וכללותן היא צדקה
The Rebbe
אבל כאשר כופה את עצמו ואינו אוכל, אזי לא מתברר הניצוץ ע״י התורה והתפלה, וא״כ, הרי זה ענין של אכזריות על הניצוץ שבמאכל
Sefer HaMaamarim 5728 (bilti muga, new edition), p. כז–כח (sec. ג; the quote on p. כח); also Shabbos Chol HaMoed 5728, p. לד · יום ב׳ דחג הסוכות, ה׳תשכ״ח (unedited)
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on Rashi’s first comment (the Torah opens with Creation so that if the nations say “you are robbers,” Israel can answer), the Rebbe asks why the nations’ claim has any hold at all, and finds it in the sparks of forbidden things, which by the Torah are not in a Jew’s domain.
The Rebbe takes this paragraph’s rule as the Torah’s own order: the spark in a forbidden thing „לא יעלה הניצוץ אלקי שבו . . . רק נדחה לחוץ” (“will not rise… only pushed outside”) (his note 32 quotes it), so by the Torah alone such sparks cannot be refined and are as if outside a Jew’s domain. Teshuvah, given by G‑d Himself, who is above the Torah, does reach them: „תשובה מאהבה” (teshuvah out of love) turns willful sins into merits, and so these sparks too are raised. Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) the “cruelty” of our paragraph is then the rule of the Torah’s order, not the end of the spark.
The Alter Rebbe
ועכ״ז לא יעלה הניצוץ אלקי שבו לרצון לפני הוי׳ להתכלל באורו וקדושתו ית׳ רק נדחה לחוץ
The Rebbe
מצד תורה קענען די ניצוצות פון דברים האסורים ניט נתברר ווערן, איז אָבער מצד ”הקב״ה” אליין (שלמעלה מתורה) געגעבן געוואָרן דער כח אויף תשובה
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כ, p. 4–5 (the sicha, Bereishis א, is pp. 1–6; note 32 is on p. 4, the quote in sec. ו on p. 5) · adapted from a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Vayikra 5740 (the sicha’s closing line)
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Shemini 5725 on Rashi’s comment to the parsha’s last verse, “to separate between the impure and the pure” (between a windpipe cut half-way and one cut for the most part, a hair’s breadth apart), the Rebbe asks what so fine a line has to do with the parsha’s name, Shemini, the eighth, a level above the order of the world.
The Rebbe shows how the “cruelty” of this paragraph can be turned into an argument of the evil inclination: everything G‑d sets before a person is there so that he raise its spark, so how can you refuse this food over a mere doubt and „מדחה זיין דעם ניצוץ אלקי וואס אין אים” (push its divine spark away)? His note 47 cites our page for it: separating from forbidden things is „כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו” (like cruelty toward the divine spark in them). What withstands the argument is the level of “Shemini,” a will above reason that will not give up a hair of the supernal will.
The Alter Rebbe
והרי זה כמו אכזריות על הניצוץ אלקי שבו
The Rebbe
ווי האָסטו דאָס רעכט — טענה׳ט דער יצה״ר — ניט צו באַנוצן זיך מיט דעם מאכל און מדחה זיין דעם ניצוץ אלקי וואָס אין אים
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ז, p. 65–73 (the sicha, Shemini ב, begins on p. 65; the quote and note 47 on p. 73) · adapted from a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Shemini 5725
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsTzedakahSe’arosIskafya and is’hapchaNefesh habahamis+8
- Tzedakah צדקה explained hereTzedakah, the sum of the practical mitzvos, is wholly physical, and the obligation to give comes through a person’s business in this world. Yet by giving the poor from his toil, the life of his soul, he raises the whole animal soul and its life: “tzedakah exalts a nation.”
שע״י שנותן צדקה לעני מעמלו ויגיעו חיי נפשו הוא מעלה ומרומם את כל נפש הבהמית וחיותה
- Se’aros שערות
- Iskafya and is’hapcha אתכפיא ואתהפכא
- Nefesh habahamis נפש הבהמית
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Higher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah חכמה עלאה וחכמה תתאה
- Ratzon רצון
Marei mekomos
- 1שחורות כעורב · Song of Songs 5:11
- 2קדש א״ע במותר לך · Yevamot 20a:15
- 3וצדקה תרומם גוי · Proverbs 14:34
- 4בזח״ג קל״ב א׳ · ראה לקמן ט, ב הלשון.
A fifth to Pharaoh: revelation and the four hands ¶7–8
7וזהו ונתתם חמישית לפרעה1 שע״י הצדקה שנותן חומש מיגיעו נעשה בחי׳ פרעה הוא בחי׳ גילוי מלשון כי פרעה אהרן2 שנמשך גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה ממש על נפשו
And this is [the meaning of] “you shall give a fifth to Pharaoh (Paroh)”: through the tzedakah, in which he gives a fifth of his labor, there comes about the level of paroh, which is the level of revelation, from the expression “for Aharon had exposed them (pera’o)”: a revelation of the Infinite Light itself, blessed be He, is drawn down upon his soul.
Yosef told the Egyptians to give a fifth of their harvest to Pharaoh (Paroh). The Alter Rebbe reads Paroh by its root, as in “Aharon had exposed them (pera’o),” meaning uncovering and revelation: giving a fifth of one’s earnings to tzedakah brings a revelation of the Infinite Light upon one’s soul. A fifth is the fullest measure of tzedakah because the Sages enacted at Usha (Kesubos 50a) that one who gives generously should not give away more than a fifth, lest he himself come to need others. The maamar finds this measure in Yosef’s “fifth.”
לכן אומרים קודם כל מצוה ברוך אתה הוי׳ אלקינו שברוך ונמשך אור א״ס ב״ה מעולם ועד עולם בבחי׳ אתה
Therefore, before every mitzvah we say, “Blessed are You, Havayah, our G‑d”: that the Infinite Light, blessed be He, be “blessed,” [that is,] drawn down, “from world to world,” at the level of “You,”
This is the meaning of the blessing said before every mitzvah. “Blessed” (baruch) is read as “drawn down”: the mitzvah draws the Infinite Light down from the highest world into this one, to be addressed as “You.”
דהיינו בבחי׳ גילוי כאלו הוא לנוכח להיות הוי׳ אלקינו ממש להיות נתפס ונקלט אלקותו ית׳ בנפש ממש
that is, at the level of revelation, as if He were face to face, so that Havayah be truly “our G‑d”: that His G‑dliness, may He be blessed, be grasped and absorbed in the soul itself.
“You” is how one speaks to someone present, face to face, so the blessing asks that G‑d be revealed. “Havayah, our G‑d” means that the transcendent G‑d becomes truly ours, His G‑dliness taken in by the soul itself.
ועל זה אמרו רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] אשרי מי שבא לכאן ותלמודו בידו3 דהיינו שיהא נתפס ונקלט בו בחי׳ תלמודו שהוא בחי׳ חכמה עילאה
And of this our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “Fortunate is he who comes here with his learning in his hand”; that is, that his learning, which is the Supernal Wisdom, be grasped and absorbed in him,
The Talmud says: “Fortunate is he who comes here (to the World to Come) with his learning in his hand.” “In his hand” means the learning has truly been absorbed and held, since what one learns is the Supernal Wisdom.
כמו האשה שקולטת הטפה עד״מ שאם אינו נתפס ונקלט בבחי׳ נשמתו אור התורה הרי זה
like a woman who absorbs the drop, by way of analogy. For if the light of the Torah is not grasped and absorbed in his soul, this is
Holding on to one’s learning is compared to conception, in which the seed takes hold. A soul in which the Torah’s light does not take hold is like a woman who does not conceive.
כמו האשה הפולטת כו׳ (עמ״ש מענין קליטה גבי שמיני עצרת בד״ה ה׳ לי בעוזרי ובד״ה טוב לחסות וגם בשאר דרושים שם)
like a woman who discharges [it], etc. (See what is written on the subject of absorption regarding Shemini Atzeres, in the discourse beginning “Havayah is for me among my helpers” and in the discourse beginning “It is better to take refuge,” and also in the other discourses there.)
The parenthesis sends the reader to the discourses for Shemini Atzeres in Likkutei Torah, “Havayah is for me among my helpers” and “It is better to take refuge.” There atzeres is read as kelitah, “absorption”: Knesses Yisrael absorbs the drop of Supernal Wisdom, the Torah, when a person learns it, reviews it and holds it firmly in memory (Shemini Atzeres 7:1).
וזהו ונתתם חמישית לפרעה4 שנעשה בחי׳ פרעה וגילוי בנפשו ממש (עמ״ש על פסוק זה בע״ח [בעץ חיים])5 (שער ל״א פ״ז [פרק ז׳])6 ובלק״ת [ובלקוטי תורה (להאריז״ל)] פ׳ ויגש ומזה נמשך להיות וארבע הידות7 יהי׳ [יהיה] לכם כי
And this is “you shall give a fifth to Pharaoh”: that the level of paroh, revelation, comes about in his soul itself. (See what is written on this verse in Etz Chaim) (Sha’ar (Gate) 31, chapter 7), and in Likkutei Torah [of the Arizal], Parshas Vayigash. And from this there follows “and the four hands (yados) shall be yours,” for
The verse of “a fifth to Pharaoh” therefore means revelation within one’s very soul, and the text notes that Etz Chaim and the Arizal’s Likkutei Torah on Parshas Vayigash also interpret this verse. Its next words, “four parts shall be yours,” literally “four hands,” describe what follows from that giving.
הנה בחי׳ ארבע הידות הן יד הגדולה יד החזקה יד רמה וזרוע הנטויה. יד הגדולה הוא מ״ש וירא ישראל את היד הגדולה8 אשר עשה ה׳ במצרים.
the four hands are the great hand, the strong hand, the high hand and the outstretched arm. The great hand is as it is written, “And Israel saw the great hand that Havayah had wrought in Egypt.”
The four “hands” are four expressions of divine power named in the Torah: the great hand, the strong hand, the high hand and the outstretched arm. The great hand is the one that Israel “saw” at the Splitting of the Sea.
פי׳ שאפילו בבחינת מצרים יש בחי׳ המשכת והתפשטות בחי׳ היד הגדולה שנמשכה ז, אונתפשטה עד למטה מאד אפילו בבחינת מצרים
Meaning: even in the level of Egypt there is a drawing down and spreading of the level of the great hand, which was drawn and spread very far down, even into the level of Egypt;
“The great hand that Havayah had wrought in Egypt” shows that G‑d’s kindness reached even into Egypt, the lowest place. The Alter Rebbe reads Egypt as a spiritual state, the lowest levels of the soul.
דהיינו שנמשך חסד עליון כ״כ [כל כך] שאפילו בבחינת נפש השפלה ממדרגות תחתונות שבעשיה ומלובשת בגשמיות ממש נופלין הרהורי תשובה.
The great hand is the supernal Chesed that reaches so far down that thoughts of teshuvah come even to a lowly soul sunk in physicality. Such a thought is not the person’s own achievement; it “falls” into him from above.
Tzedakah draws a revelation of the Infinite Light into the soul, as the blessing over every mitzvah asks, and from that revelation come the “four hands,” the first of which, the great hand, is G‑d’s kindness that awakens teshuvah even in the lowest soul.
The Kehot note on the Etz Chaim reference observes that “Sha’ar (Gate) 31” follows the Shklov 1800 printing, and in current editions it is Sha’ar (Gate) 32. The Alter Rebbe’s reading of Paroh as revelation turns a verse about tribute to an Egyptian king into a statement about divine disclosure within the soul.
Explained elsewhere AI research
Explained by the Alter Rebbe and the Rebbe
After „ונתתם חמישית לפרעה” (“a fifth to Pharaoh”) the verse goes on, „וארבע הידות יהי׳ לכם” (“four hands shall be yours”). Here the Alter Rebbe reads the four hands as four kinds of divine help drawn down by tzedakah. A reader who knows Tanya will remember that the Alter Rebbe reads the same pair differently there, and our commentary does not mention it.
Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) compare Tanya, ch. 34, where the Alter Rebbe reads the same verse another way: the fifth given to tzedakah „הרי החומש מעלה עמו כל הארבע ידות לה׳” (“raises with it all four hands to G‑d”), lifting the rest of one’s earnings into holiness. In his short notes on Tanya the Rebbe links that line to this maamar. Here the four hands are kinds of divine help that the tzedakah draws down; in Tanya they are the four parts of one’s money that the fifth carries up.
the Alter Rebbe: Tanya (Likkutei Amarim), p. ch. 34 (43b in the standard edition)
ואף שאינו נותן אלא חומש הרי החומש מעלה עמו כל הארבע ידות לה׳ להיות מכון לשבתו ית׳
the Rebbe: Reshimos: Ma’arei Mekomos, Hagahos ve-He’aros Ketzaros on Tanya, p. ריא (on ch. 34)
חומש כו׳ ארבע הידות: ע״ד בראשית מז, כד (”חמישית גו׳ וארבע הידות”). להעיר מלקו״ת שה״ש ד״ה שחורה אני הב׳ ס״ב
Where the maamar leaves something unexplained, found by AI in the library and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
Background from the Rebbe
Speaking to guests at a general yechidus on the eve of 13 Shevat 5746, as they were about to go home, the Rebbe asks them to carry the unity of their days together back with them, and in a note finds unity also in the parsha of the week of the Rebbe Rayatz’s passing, Bo (“come to Pharaoh”).
In a note the Rebbe cites this page, with LT Shir 24d, for a reading of „החמישית לפרעה” (“the fifth to Pharaoh”): the “Pharaoh” of holiness, „דאתפריעו ואתגליין מיני׳ כל נהורין” (“from whom all lights are uncovered and revealed”; Zohar I 210a), is the fifth, „המקיף המאחד את כל הדרגות” (the encompassing level, makif, that unites all the levels). Our paragraph reads Pharaoh as the revelation drawn down by giving a fifth, from which the “four hands” follow; in his talk of Shabbos Bo that year he spells out that the fifth includes and unites the four levels below it, „וארבע הידות יהי׳ לכם” (“the four hands shall be yours”).
The Alter Rebbe
וזהו ונתתם חמישית לפרעה שע״י הצדקה שנותן חומש מיגיעו נעשה בחי׳ פרעה הוא בחי׳ גילוי
The Rebbe
ש״פרעה” (”בא אל פרעה”) דקדושה (”דאתפריעו ואתגליין מיני׳ כל נהורין”) קאי על בחי׳ החמישית, ”החמישית לפרעה” בחי׳ המקיף המאחד את כל הדרגות
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כו, p. 351, note 16 (the talk begins on p. 349) · a talk at a general yechidus for guests, Wednesday of Parshas Beshalach, eve of 13 Shevat 5746 (translated from Yiddish; the same talk in Sichos Kodesh 5746 vol. 2 p. 571)
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsAtzeresChesed olamTzedakahTeshuvah+11
- Atzeres עצרת
- Chesed olam חסד עולם
- Tzedakah צדקה
- Teshuvah תשובה
- Higher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah חכמה עלאה וחכמה תתאה
- Berachah ברכה
- Asiyah עשיה
- Chesed חסד
Also NeshamahHavayahOr Ein SofTorah and mitzvosChochmahHaalaah vehamshachahTorah
Marei mekomos
- 1ונתתם חמישית לפרעה · Genesis 47:24
- 2כי פרעה אהרן · Exodus 32:25
- 3אשרי מי שבא לכאן ותלמודו בידו · Pesachim 50a:7–8
- 4ונתתם חמישית לפרעה · על״ק (כד, ד). וש״נ. [כ].
- 5עמ״ש על פסוק זה בע״ח · Sefer Etz Chaim 32:7:1
- 6שער ל״א פ״ז · בדפוס שקלאוו תק״ס. לפננו הוא ש׳ ל״ב. [כ].
- 7וארבע הידות יהי׳ לכם · Genesis 47:24
- 8וירא ישראל את היד הגדולה · Exodus 14:31
And this is the matter of the great hand. But it is known that “one nation shall be stronger than the other nation,” and “G‑d has made one opposite the other,” and “were it not that the Holy One, blessed be He, helps him,” etc.
After the great hand comes the need for help. Holiness and its opposite are balanced (“G‑d made one opposite the other”), and when one side grows strong the other weakens, like the two nations in Rivkah’s womb. The Talmud says that a person’s evil inclination would overpower him “were it not that the Holy One, blessed be He, helps him.”
ועזר זה וסיוע זה נקרא יד החזקה לנצח ולכבוש כו׳ ויד רמה היינו לרומם ולקשר נפשו בקיום ואהבת בכל לבבך4 כו׳
And this help and this assistance is called the strong hand, to prevail and to conquer, etc. And the high hand is to exalt and bind his soul in the fulfillment of “And you shall love… with all your heart,” etc.
That divine help, which lets a person win his inner struggle, is the “strong hand.” The “high hand” lifts the soul higher still, binding it to the love of G‑d “with all your heart.”
וזרוע הנטויה הוא ג״כ בחי׳ יד שביד יש ג׳ פירקין העליונה נקרא זרוע היא בבחי׳ נטויה שהיא פשוטה למטה מטה בבחי׳ וימינו תחבקני5 כאדם החובק כו׳. שלא להיות בבחי׳ נפרד ח״ו [חס ושלום] כו׳.
And the outstretched arm is also the level of a hand, for the hand has three sections, and the uppermost is called the arm. It is “outstretched,” extended far, far downward, in the manner of “and His right hand embraces me,” like a person who embraces, etc., so that there not be a state of separation, G‑d forbid, etc.
The arm, the upper section of the limb, is the fourth “hand”: it is “outstretched,” reaching far downward to embrace, as in “His right hand embraces me.” This embrace keeps the soul from being separate from G‑d.
וכ״ז [וכל זה] הוא נמשך ע״י הצדקה שע״י זה וארבע הידות יהי׳ [יהיה] לכם לזרע השדה6 שבזמן הגלות הכל הוא רק בבחינת זריעה אור זרוע לצדיק7 כו׳ כמ״ש במדרש:
And all this is drawn down through tzedakah, for through it “the four hands shall be yours, as seed for the field”; for in the time of exile everything is only in the manner of sowing, “Light is sown for the righteous,” etc., as stated in the Midrash.
All four hands are drawn down through tzedakah, as the verse continues, “as seed for the field.” In exile everything is only “sown,” as the verse says, “Light is sown for the righteous”; what is sown now will sprout and be revealed in the future.
The paragraph completes the four “hands” that tzedakah draws down: divine help against the evil inclination, the lifting of the soul to love G‑d, and the embrace that keeps it from separation, all “sown” now in exile to flourish in the future.
TermsZeh le’umas zehZeriahTzedakahTzaddik+1
- Zeh le’umas zeh זה לעומת זה
- Zeriah זריעה
- Tzedakah צדקה
- Tzaddik צדיק
- Elokim אלקים
Marei mekomos
- 1שלאום מלאום יאמץ · Genesis 25:23
- 2וזה לעומת זה עשה אלקים · Ecclesiastes 7:14
- 3ואלמלא הקב״ה עוזרו · Kiddushin 30b:7
- 4ואהבת בכל לבבך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 5וימינו תחבקני · Song of Songs 2:6
- 6לזרע השדה · Genesis 47:24
- 7אור זרוע לצדיק · Psalms 97:11
The words of the Scribes and the higher root of the prohibitions ¶9
9ג ובבחי׳ התורה שהיא בבחי׳ שחורה והלכות ודקדוקי סופרים שבמצו׳ ל״ת [לא תעשה] שהן בבחינת שחורות כעורב הנ״ל.
3. And as for the aspect of the Torah that is at the level of “black,” [namely] the halachos and the fine points of the Scribes in the prohibitive commandments, which are at the level of “black as a raven” mentioned above:
The third section begins. The Alter Rebbe returns to the “black” side of the Torah, the rabbinic laws and fences around the prohibitions, and now shows why it is in fact superior.
הנה אמרו ז״ל [זכרונו לברכה / זכרונם לברכה] ערבים עלי ד״ס יותר מיינה של תורה.12 והענין כי הנה בשלשה דברים ברא הקב״ה את עולמו בספר וסופר וסיפור.34
Our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “The words of the Scribes are sweeter (arevim) to me than the wine of the Torah.” The explanation is that the Holy One, blessed be He, created His world with three things: sefer, sofer and sippur (book, scribe and telling).
The Talmud (Avodah Zarah 35a) reads “your love is better than wine” as Knesses Yisrael telling G‑d that the words of His beloved ones, the Sages, are sweeter to her than the “wine” of the Torah; here they are “the words of the Scribes.” The word arevim (“sweet”) echoes orev, the raven of the verse just cited. To explain the teaching he cites Sefer Yetzirah: the world was created with sefer, sofer and sippur, “book, scribe and telling.”
ספר זו תורה שבכתב וסופר למעלה מבחי׳ ספר היא בחי׳ תורה שבעל פה כי לכן נקרא דברי חכמים דברי סופרים שהן למעלה מבחי׳ ספר
Sefer (book) is the Written Torah; and sofer (scribe), which is above the level of sefer, is the level of the Oral Torah. For this is why the words of the Sages are called “the words of the Scribes (soferim)”: they are above the level of sefer.
He maps these terms onto the two Torahs: the “book” is the Written Torah, and the “scribe,” who stands above the book because he writes it, is the Oral Torah. This is why the Sages’ words are called “the words of the Scribes.”
(ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה זה שמי וד״ה לבך יהגה אימה איה סופר ובמ״א על פסוק ושאבתם מים בששון) הוא בחי׳ תורה שבכתב שמח״ע [שמחכמה עילאה] שהוא בחי׳ נר מצוה ותורה אור.5
(See what is written on this in the discourse beginning “This is My Name,” and in the discourse beginning “Your heart will meditate in awe: Where is the scribe?”, and elsewhere on the verse “And you shall draw water with joy.”) [Sefer] is the level of the Written Torah, which is from the Supernal Wisdom (Chochmah Ila’ah), the level of “a mitzvah is a lamp, and the Torah is light.”
The parenthesis sends the reader to other discourses that develop the same idea. The Written Torah comes from G‑d’s Supernal Wisdom and is called “light,” as in the verse “a mitzvah is a lamp, and the Torah is light.”
והנה אור הנר המאיר הוא מגוון הסמוך לפתילה אבל הגוון לבן המקיף עליו הוא אינו מאיר בעצמו
Now, the illuminating light of the lamp comes from the hue that is close to the wick; but the white hue that surrounds it does not itself illuminate;
An analogy from the flame of a lamp: the light that actually illuminates comes from the part of the flame near the wick. The white hue that surrounds it does not itself give light.
אלא הוא מקור האור שממנו נמשך ומתפשט האור המאיר וכך הם דברי חכמים נק׳ דברי סופרים
rather, it is the source of the light, from which the illuminating light is drawn and spreads. And so it is with the words of the Sages, called “the words of the Scribes,”
Yet that surrounding white hue is the source from which the illuminating light is drawn. The words of the Scribes are like it.
שמהם נמשך להיות בחי׳ הספר היא בחי׳ תורה אור והם הם בבחי׳ מקור האור בחי׳ המקיף שהוא בחי׳ ישת חשך סתרו6
from which the level of the sefer, the level of “the Torah is light,” comes to be drawn; and they themselves are the level of the source of the light, the level of the makif (the surrounding), which is the level of “He made darkness His hiding place.”
The rabbinic words are the hidden source from which the “light” of the Written Torah emerges. They are a makif, a “surrounding” level too high to shine openly, described by the verse “He made darkness His hiding place”: their “darkness” is higher than revealed light, and that is why they are “black.”
ולכן רוב דקדוקי סופרים הם במצות לא תעשה ששם הרבה גדרים וסייגים לתורה יותר מבמצות עשה כי בחי׳ מצות ל״ת [לא תעשה] יש בהן יתרון ומעלה יתירה מבמצות עשה.
Therefore most of the fine points of the Scribes are in the prohibitive commandments, where there are many more fences and safeguards for the Torah than in the positive commandments; for the prohibitive commandments have an advantage and a superiority over the positive commandments.
This is why most rabbinic fences surround the prohibitions rather than the positive commandments. The prohibitions, as he will now show, have a higher root.
כמארז״ל [כמאמר רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] זכרי עם7 ו״ה רמ״ח שמי עם י״ה שס״ה שהל״ת [שהלא תעשה] הם בבחינת י״ה שהוא למעלה מו״ה כי המ״ע [המצות עשה] הם בבחי׳ שם ו״ה עלמא דאתגליא
As our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “‘My remembrance’ with Vav-Hei [equals] 248; ‘My Name’ with Yud-Hei [equals] 365.” The prohibitions are at the level of Yud-Hei, which is higher than Vav-Hei; for the positive commandments are at the level of the Name Vav-Hei, the revealed world (alma de’isgalya).
The verse “This is My Name forever, and this is My remembrance” is read by the Zohar numerically: shmi (“My Name”) plus the letters Yud-Hei equals 365, the number of prohibitions, and zichri (“My remembrance”) plus Vav-Hei equals 248, the number of positive commandments. Yud-Hei, the first half of the Name Havayah, is the higher, hidden half; Vav-Hei is the lower half, “the revealed world.”
כי רמ״ח פיקודין רמ״ח אברים דמלכא8 שהן כלים ומשכן להחיות הנמשך ומתפשט בהם מעצם הנפש שהחיות מתלבש בהם ממש להיות האברים נשמעים לרצונו כו׳.
For “the 248 commandments are the 248 limbs of the King”: they are vessels and a dwelling for the life-force that is drawn and spreads into them from the essence of the soul, the life-force being truly enclothed in them, so that the limbs obey its will, etc.
The Tikkunei Zohar calls the 248 positive commandments “the 248 limbs of the King.” Just as the soul’s life-force is openly clothed in the body’s limbs so that they do its will, the positive commandments are vessels that openly hold G‑d’s light.
אבל הל״ת [הלא תעשה] הם בבחינת י״ה שהוא בבחי׳ עלמא דאתכסייא שאין החיות ואור א״ס מבחי׳ זו מתלבש בגילוי הנפש
But the prohibitions are at the level of Yud-Hei, the level of the hidden world (alma de’iskasya), for the life-force and the Infinite Light from this level are not enclothed in the soul in a revealed way,
The prohibitions belong to “the hidden world”: the light that comes through them does not enter the soul in a revealed, felt way.
אלא בבחי׳ העלם בבחי׳ ואתה משמרה בקרבי9 לפי שאין בנפש כלי ומשכן להשראת אור א״ס ב״ה בבחי׳ זו להיות בבחי׳ גילוי בהתלבשות ממש
but in concealment, in the manner of “and You guard it within me”; because the soul has no vessel or dwelling for the Infinite Light, blessed be He, to rest [in it] at this level so as to be revealed in actual enclothing,
That light is present in the soul only in concealment, as the morning blessing says of the soul, “You guard it within me.” The soul simply has no vessel that could hold this level openly.
אלא בבחי׳ שלילה בחי׳ לא כמ״ש בארץ לא זרועה10 שהוא זרועה בבחי׳ לא כו׳ וכמ״ש במ״א שזהו ענין דביקת הנפש באלקות למעלה בשרשה בבחינת סובב ישת חושך סתרו כו׳
but only in the manner of negation, the level of “not,” as it is written, “in a land not sown”: it is “sown” in the manner of “not,” etc. And as explained elsewhere, this is the soul’s cleaving to G‑dliness above, in its root, at the level of sovev, “He made darkness His hiding place,” etc.,
It is received only through negation, by not doing. Jeremiah’s phrase “a land not sown” is read as a land “sown with not”: the prohibitions, whose form is “do not,” plant this light in the soul and join it to G‑d in its root, at the level of sovev, the light that surrounds all worlds.
בחי׳ חושך ולא אור נגלה כו׳ שא״א להגיע לבחי׳ זו בבחי׳ מעשה המצות אשר יעשה אותם האדם אלא בבחי׳ ל״ת [לא תעשה] שהוא בחי׳ שלילה ולא כו׳.
the level of darkness and not of revealed light, etc.; for it is impossible to reach this level through the deed of the mitzvos that a person performs, but only through the prohibitions, which are the level of negation and “not,” etc.
“Darkness” here means a light too high to be revealed. No positive deed can reach it; only refraining, the “not” of the prohibitions, connects the soul to it.
The paragraph shows that the “black” side of the Torah is higher than the “white”: the words of the Scribes are the hidden source of the Written Torah’s light, and the prohibitions, rooted in the hidden half of the Name, join the soul to the surrounding light that no positive deed can reach.
The Kehot note gathers many places in the Zohar and Tikkunei Zohar that give the numerical reading of “My Name” and “My remembrance.” Tanya, chapter 4, to which the note points, explains that the soul’s 613 “limbs” are clothed in the 613 mitzvos and that love is the root of the 248 positive commandments.
TermsDivrei sofrimYashes choshech sisro248 limbs of the KingNer mitzvah+13
- Divrei sofrim דברי סופרים explained hereOn “sefer, sofer, sippur”: the scribe is above the book. Like the white light that surrounds a candle’s shining flame and is its source, the words of the Sages are the source and makif from which the “book”, the Torah of light, is drawn. So most rabbinic fences are in the negative commandments, which are of yud-hei, the hidden world.
וכך הם דברי חכמים נק׳ דברי סופרים שמהם נמשך להיות בחי׳ הספר
- Yashes choshech sisro ישת חשך סתרו
- 248 limbs of the King רמ״ח אברים דמלכא
- Ner mitzvah נר מצוה
- Hidden world and the revealed world עלמא דאתכסיא ועלמא דאתגליא
- Torah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al peh תורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה
- Higher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah חכמה עלאה וחכמה תתאה
- Lights and vessels אורות וכלים
- Yud-hei and vav-hei י״ה ו״ה
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Ratzon רצון
Also HislabshusChayusOr Ein SofTorah and mitzvosChochmahTorah
Marei mekomos
- 1ערבים עלי ד״ס יותר מיינה של תורה · Avodah Zarah 35a:6
- 2ערבים עלי ד״ס יותר מיינה של תורה · Shir HaShirim Rabbah 1:2
- 3בשלשה דברים ברא הקב״ה את עולמו בספר וסופר וסיפור · ס״י פ״א, מ״א. ע׳ ד״ה ושאבתם הב׳ [פ, ב] פ״ב. וע״ז ציין אדמו״ר מס׳ יצירה. [כ].
- 4בשלשה דברים ברא הקב״ה את עולמו בספר וסופר וסיפור · Sefer Yetzirah 1:1
- 5נר מצוה ותורה אור · Proverbs 6:23
- 6ישת חשך סתרו · Psalms 18:12
- 7כמארז״ל זכרי עם ו״ה רמ״ח שמי עם י״ה שס״ה · Zohar I, 24a
- 8רמ״ח פיקודין רמ״ח איברים דמלכא · Tikkunei Zohar, Tikkun 30 · 74a:8
- 9ואתה משמרה בקרבי · Berakhot 60b:4
- 10בארץ לא זרועה · Jeremiah 2:2
Ofanim above seraphim ¶10–13
And through this “a spirit from on high will be poured upon him”: the indwelling in his soul of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin). And through this his animal soul, too, will be elevated. For
Isaiah’s words “a spirit from on high will be poured upon us” describe the result: through the prohibitions, the surrounding light (sovev) comes to rest in the soul. Then even the animal soul is raised up, and he now explains how.
¶12 How is the animal soul elevated? Paragraphs 10–12 explain, through the ofanim.
הנה הנפש הבהמית שרשה מבחי׳ פני אריה פני שור שבמרכבה כו׳ משמרי אופנים שהן למטה מהשרפים כו׳.
the animal soul has its root in the level of “the face of a lion” and “the face of an ox” in the Chariot, etc., from the dregs (shmarei) of the ofanim, which are below the seraphim, etc.
In Ezekiel’s vision of the Chariot, the living creatures have the faces of a lion, an ox, an eagle and a man. The animal soul is rooted in the “lion” and the “ox,” and comes from the dregs (shmarim) of the ofanim (“wheels”), a class of angels lower than the seraphim (the “burning” angels of Isaiah’s vision).
אך הנה כתיב והאופנים ינשאו לעומתם3 והאופנים ברעש גדול כו׳. כי הנה השרפים אומרים קדוש ומובדל כו׳
But it is written, “and the ofanim rise up opposite them,” and “the ofanim, with a great noise,” etc. For the seraphim say, “Holy,” [meaning] separate, etc.,
Yet Ezekiel says that the ofanim “rise up,” and the morning liturgy describes them rising “with a great noise.” The seraphim, by contrast, say “Holy,” which means separate and transcendent.
הוי׳ צבאות אות היא בצבא דילי׳ [דיליה]4 אלף אלפים ורבוא רבבן5 מספר גדוד אחד ולגדודיו אין מספר6 כולם אין מקבלים חיות רק מבחינת אות א׳ מלא כל הארץ כבודו.7
“Havayah Tzevaos”: “He is a sign (os) among His host.” “A thousand thousands and ten thousand myriads” is the number of a single troop, and “His troops are beyond number”; all of them receive life-force only from the level of a single letter (os). “The whole earth is full of His glory”:
The Name Tzevaos (“of Hosts”) is read as “He is a sign (os) among His host (tzava),” and os also means “letter.” All the countless angelic hosts draw their life from one single letter of G‑d’s speech; that is the level of “the whole earth is full of His glory.”
כבודו הוא ל״ב נתיבות החכמה כי אין כבוד אלא תורה89 והיא המתלבשת להיות מלא כל הארץ הלזו התחתונה בבחי׳ כבודו
“His glory” is the thirty-two paths of Chochmah, for “there is no glory but Torah”; and it is [the Torah] that is enclothed so that “the whole earth,” this lowest [earth], is “full” of it at the level of “His glory,”
“His glory” is the Torah (“there is no glory but Torah”), described as the thirty-two paths of Chochmah. This Torah is clothed in the lowest world and fills it, but only as “glory,” an outer radiance. Sefer Yetzirah opens by saying that G‑d created His world “with thirty-two wondrous paths of wisdom” (traditionally the ten sefiros and the twenty-two letters). Calling the Torah by this name identifies it with the wisdom through which creation was formed.
היינו בבחינת זיו והארה בעלמא והאופנים המקבלים מהם ינשאו לעומתם ומרעישים ברעש גדול מחמת עוצם קדושת אור א״ס שכשמו כן ז, בהוא אין לו סוף כו׳.10
that is, at the level of a mere ray and radiance. And the ofanim, which receive from them, “rise up opposite them” and quake “with a great noise,” because of the immense holiness of the Infinite Light, which, like its name, has no end, etc.
The ofanim receive from the seraphim, yet they quake “with a great noise,” because they sense the overwhelming holiness of the Infinite Light, which, as its name says, has no end.
The paragraph begins to explain how the prohibitions elevate even the animal soul: its root is in the ofanim, which stand below the seraphim and yet “rise up” in a great tumult before the infinite holiness of G‑d.
TermsMerkavahZiv haShechinahNefesh habahamisKadosh+6
- Merkavah מרכבה
- Ziv haShechinah זיו השכינה
- Nefesh habahamis נפש הבהמית
- Kadosh קדוש
- Malachim מלאכים
- Sovev kol almin סובב כל עלמין
Marei mekomos
- 1יערה עליו רוח ממרום · ישעי׳ (לב, טז).
- 2יערה עליו רוח ממרום · Isaiah 32:15
- 3והאופנים ינשאו לעומתם · Ezekiel 1:20
- 4אות היא בצבא דילי׳ · ע׳ האזינו (עד ריש ד׳). וש״נ. [כ].
- 5אלף אלפים ורבוא רבבן · Daniel 7:10
- 6ולגדודיו אין מספר · Chagigah 13b:13
- 7מלא כל הארץ כבודו · Isaiah 6:3
- 8אין כבוד אלא תורה · אבות פ״ו, מ״ג.
- 9אין כבוד אלא תורה · Pirkei Avot 6:3
- 10ל״ב נתיבות החכמה · Sefer Yetzirah 1:1
11והנה לא ברעש12 ה׳ ואחר הרעש אש3 בבחינת צמאון ותשוקה בכלות הנפש ממש בבחי׳ ביטול והתכללות באור א״ס ב״ה למעלה מכדי שתוכל נפשם שאת וצמאון ותשוקה זו אינה בבחי׳ כבודו היא בחי׳ זיו והארה בלבד.
Now, “Havayah is not in the noise,” and “after the noise, fire”: in the manner of thirst and longing, an actual expiring of the soul, in a state of self-nullification and inclusion in the Infinite Light, blessed be He, beyond what their soul can bear. And this thirst and longing is not for the level of “His glory,” which is only a ray and radiance,
At Chorev Eliyahu saw that “Havayah was not in the noise” (in the plain sense, the earthquake), and after the noise came fire. The Alter Rebbe reads the “fire” as a burning thirst of the soul to dissolve into G‑d, beyond what it can contain, and says this thirst is not for “His glory,” the outer radiance.
but for the level of “the heavens and the earth I fill,” the level of “I” itself, that is, the indwelling of the Infinite One, blessed be He, that encompasses all worlds, itself.
It is a thirst for G‑d’s very self, the “I” of “Do I not fill the heavens and the earth?” That “I” is the Infinite One Himself, the surrounding light (sovev) that is present everywhere without being contained anywhere.
The paragraph identifies the ofanim’s fiery longing: not for G‑d’s outer glory but for His very self, the surrounding light that the seraphim do not reach.
TermsKlos hanefeshZiv haShechinahEin SofSovev kol almin+3
- Klos hanefesh כלות הנפש
- Ziv haShechinah זיו השכינה
- Ein Sof אין סוף
- Sovev kol almin סובב כל עלמין
- Hiskallelus התכללות
Also BittulOr Ein Sof
Marei mekomos
- 1לא ברעש ה׳ · מ״א יט, יא.
- 2לא ברעש ה׳ · I Kings 19:11
- 3ואחר הרעש אש · I Kings 19:12
- 4את השמים ואת הארץ אני מלא · ירמי׳ (כג, כד).
- 5את השמים ואת הארץ אני מלא · Jeremiah 23:24
12וזהו והאופנים ינשאו שמתנשאים לעומת השרפים למעלה מהם. ומבחינת צמאון זה ותשוקה זו נמשך להיות כמ״ש צמאה לך נפשי כו׳ כן בקדש1 חזיתיך קדש מלה בגרמי׳ [בגרמיה]2 בחי׳ קדש ומובדל חזיתיך להיות גילוי אלקות
And this is “the ofanim rise up”: they are lifted up opposite the seraphim, above them. And from this thirst and this longing comes what is written, “My soul thirsts for You,” etc., “so in holiness I have beheld You”: “holiness” is a word in its own right, the level of holy and separate, [and] “I have beheld You,” so that there be a revelation of G‑dliness,
This is why the ofanim “rise up” above the seraphim: their longing reaches higher. King David’s words “My soul thirsts for You ... so in holiness I have beheld You” describe the same thing, and the Zohar says “holiness” is a word by itself, meaning the separate, transcendent G‑d, who becomes revealed through this thirst.
¶10 This answers the question from paragraph 10.
וכמו שיהיה לעתיד ונגולו כספר השמים3 וכתיב השמים החדשים והארץ החדשה4 שלא יהיו שמים וארץ גשמיים המעלימים ומסתירים כבוד ה׳ להיות יש ודבר בפני עצמו
and as it will be in the future, “and the heavens shall be rolled up like a scroll,” and it is written, “the new heavens and the new earth”: there will not be physical heavens and earth that obscure and conceal the glory of G‑d, so as to be a thing and an entity in its own right.
This revelation is a foretaste of the future, when “the heavens shall be rolled up like a scroll” and there will be “new heavens and a new earth.” Then the physical world will no longer hide G‑d or appear to exist on its own.
שהרי בכל דבר נמשך אור א״ס ב״ה כמ״ש והר סיני עשן כולו5 עולם שנה נפש עולם בחינת מקום ששם נמשך בחי׳ א״ס כמ״ש הנה מקום אתי.6
For in every thing the Infinite Light, blessed be He, is drawn, as it is written, “And Mount Sinai was all in smoke (ashan)”: olam, shanah, nefesh (world, year, soul). Olam is the dimension of space, into which the level of the Infinite is drawn, as it is written, “Behold, there is a place with Me.”
The Infinite Light is already present in everything. The word ashan (“smoke”) at Sinai is read as the initials of olam, shanah, nefesh (world, year, soul): space, time and life. Of space G‑d says “there is a place with Me”: the Infinite is drawn into space itself.
The ofanim’s thirst lifts them above the seraphim and brings a revelation of transcendent G‑dliness, a foretaste of the future when the world will no longer conceal G‑d, because His Infinite Light is present in space, time and soul.
Marei mekomos
- 1צמאה לך נפשי . . כן בקודש · Psalms 63:2–3
- 2קדש מלה בגרמי׳ · Zohar III, 94b
- 3ונגולו כספר השמים · Isaiah 34:4
- 4השמים החדשים והארץ החדשה · Isaiah 66:22
- 5והר סיני עשן כולו · Exodus 19:18
- 6הנה מקום אתי · Exodus 33:21
13וכן בבחינת שנה בבחי׳ זמן מלך מלך וימלוך עבר עתיד הוה הכל הוא בבחי׳ א״ס כו׳.
And so too in the dimension of shanah (year), the dimension of time: “He is King, He was King and He will be King,” past, future and present; all is at the level of the Infinite, etc.
The same holds for time. The liturgical phrase “G‑d is King, G‑d was King, G‑d will be King” spans present, past and future, and all of time is rooted in the Infinite.
וכן בנפש יש הארת אור א״ס וכל החיים יודוך סלה וגן עדן העליון ותחתון ויש גן עדן למעלה מגן עדן עד אין קץ ותכלית בעילוי אחר עילוי כו׳.
And so too in nefesh (the soul) there is a radiance of the Infinite Light: “and all the living shall thank You, Selah,” and the higher and the lower Gan Eden; and there is a Gan Eden above Gan Eden, without end or limit, in ascent after ascent, etc.
The soul, too, holds a radiance of the Infinite Light, as the prayer says, “all the living shall thank You.” The endless ascending levels of Gan Eden, a Gan Eden above every Gan Eden, show that the soul’s dimension also reaches toward the Infinite.
The paragraph completes the triad of world, year and soul: time and life, like space, are drawn from the Infinite, which is why a future revelation of G‑d within them is possible.
Black, and therefore comely ¶14
And in the future, when the world, and its materiality and coarseness, will be refined, then “eye to eye they shall see,” etc. And this is “I am black, yet comely”: for through
In the future the world’s coarseness will be refined away, and then, as Isaiah says, “eye to eye they shall see” G‑d. This lets the Alter Rebbe give the full meaning of “I am black, yet comely.”
בחי׳ שחורה היא בחי׳ דביקת הנפש בקיום ושמירת מצות לא תעשה שהן בבחי׳ שחורות כעורב3 על ידי זה יהיה לעתיד גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה הסוכ״ע
the level of “black,” which is the soul’s cleaving [to G‑d] through fulfilling and observing the prohibitive commandments, which are at the level of “black as a raven,” through this there will be, in the future, a revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin),
The bride’s “blackness” is her cleaving to G‑d by keeping the prohibitions, the “black as a raven” side of the Torah. Precisely this will bring, in the future, the open revelation of the surrounding light (sovev), the light that encompasses all worlds.
שהוא למעלה מגדר עלמין שהוא למעלה מכדי שתוכל הנפש שאת אלא בבחינת שלילה ארץ לא זרועה4 ובבחי׳ זו נאוה יותר מבנות ירושלים כו׳.
which is above the bounds of the worlds, beyond what the soul can bear, except in the manner of negation, “a land not sown.” And at this level she is more comely than the daughters of Jerusalem, etc.
That light is beyond the bounds of the worlds and beyond what any soul can hold, so now it can be received only through negation, “a land not sown.” Because the descended soul reaches it, she is more beautiful than the souls above, who never descended and never kept a prohibition.
¶3 This answers the question from paragraph 3.
(ועמ״ש מענין שחורה אני ונאוה בד״ה קול דודי. דקאי על תשבע״פ [תורה שבעל פה] כו׳ והוא ע״ד שנתבאר למעלה בענין דברי סופרים כו׳ וע׳ בפ׳ בראשית דמ״ט סע״א [סוף עמוד א]56 ובסה״מ [ובספר הדרת מלך] סי׳ קל״ז7 וסוף ח״א [חלק א׳] סי׳ ה׳ ובפ׳ שמות י״ד8 א׳ ובפ׳ אחרי דנ״ט ב׳9 בלק קצ״א א׳):
(See what is written on the subject of “I am black, yet comely” in the discourse beginning “The voice of my beloved,” that it refers to the Oral Torah, etc.; and this is along the lines of what was explained above on the words of the Scribes, etc. And see [the Zohar,] Parshas Bereishis, page 49, end of side a; and Sefer Hadras Melech, section 137, and the end of Part I, section 5; and Parshas Shemos, 14a; and Parshas Acharei, page 59b; [and Parshas] Balak, 191a.)
The closing parenthesis refers to another discourse, on “The voice of my beloved,” which reads “I am black, yet comely” as the Oral Torah, in line with what was said here about the words of the Scribes. It also lists passages of the Zohar and Sefer Hadras Melech, a commentary on the Zohar by R. Shalom Buzaglo, author of the Mikdash Melech; the Kehot note adds that this wording is copied in the Tzemach Tzedek’s Biurei HaZohar.
The maamar concludes: the “blackness” of the descended soul, its keeping of the prohibitions in a coarse world, is what will bring the future revelation of the light that surrounds all worlds, and so it is more beautiful than the souls that never came down.
The Kehot note explains that the Zohar in Parshas Bereishis (1:49a) interprets the “rib” from which Chavah was built as the level of “I am black, yet comely,” and points to the Tzemach Tzedek’s Biurei HaZohar and to the discourse “Min HaMeitzar” of 5660 on this theme.
TermsGasus haruachDivrei sofrimTorah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al pehSovev kol almin+2
- Gasus haruach גסות הרוח
- Divrei sofrim דברי סופרים
- Torah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al peh תורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה
- Sovev kol almin סובב כל עלמין
Marei mekomos
- 1עין בעין יראו · Isaiah 52:8
- 2שחורה אני ונאוה · Song of Songs 1:5
- 3שחורות כעורב · Song of Songs 5:11
- 4ארץ לא זרועה · Jeremiah 2:2
- 5וע׳ בפ׳ בראשית דמ״ט סע״א · בזח״א. דשם מבאר דענין הצלע זהו בחינת שחורה אני ונאוה. ראה ביאוה״צ להצ״צ כרך א ע׳ תקב. וראה גם ד״ה מן המיצר תר״ס ע׳ א.
- 6וע׳ בפ׳ בראשית דמ״ט סע״א · Zohar, Bereshit 80:207–82:215
- 7ובסה״מ סי׳ קלז · הלשון נעתק בביאוה״ז להצ״צ כרך א ע׳ תקב. סה״מ תר״ס ע׳ א.
- 8ובפ׳ שמות י״ד א׳ · Zohar, Shemot 24:231–25:240
- 9ובפ׳ אחרי דנ״ט ב׳ · Zohar, Achrei Mot 9:58–67
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Each Rosh Chodesh the names of those learning here are brought to the Ohel. Add your name, and mark what you learn so it is counted.
In one’s avodah
Do not regard the rabbinic fences and the prohibitions as merely negative: holding back, even being “cruel” to oneself for G‑d’s sake, joins the soul to a light higher than anything positive deeds reveal. And give tzedakah from what you earn with effort, a fifth where possible, for it lifts the whole animal soul and draws G‑d’s revelation into it.
Questions for discussion
- Why do the souls before their descent have a more complete awe of G‑d than the angels, and what then does the descended soul gain?
- How can the laws of the prohibitions, which only say “do not,” connect the soul to a higher light than the positive commandments?
- What is the “cruelty” of the black hairs, both toward the divine spark in forbidden things and in a person’s conduct toward himself?
- Why is tzedakah both “black” and “comely,” and how does it elevate the animal soul?
- How can the ofanim, lower than the seraphim, rise above them, and what does this teach about the animal soul?
Key terms in this maamar
- The animal soulנפש הבהמית
- One of a Jew’s two souls, clothed in the blood to give the body life; from kelipas nogah, mixed of good and evil, with its own intellect and middos; the G‑dly soul must refine it. ×4Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Self-nullification before G‑d, the condition for the Or Ein Sof to rest. Its lower degree is a “something” that bows; its higher, Chochmah’s “what are we,” takes up no place at all. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof)אור אין סוף
- The boundless light radiating from G‑d’s Essence like sunlight from the sun: His “Name,” a revelation, not the Essence. Chiefly the light before the tzimtzum; also that light as clothed in the sefiros.Where it’s explained, stated differently, Sefer HaErchim
- The Infinite One (Ein Sof)אין סוף
- The name for G‑d as without end or limit, beyond all grasp; what is drawn from Him is Or Ein Sof, only a radiance; all revelation comes from Malchus of Ein Sof.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- G‑d’s kingship: the lowest Sefirah, His “speech” and the revealed world, through which all worlds come into being from nothing and live, without touching His essence (“there is no king without a people”). ×3Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The descent of levels from cause to effect, linked like the rings of a chain, from Chochmah downward; each reveals what was hidden in the one above. Or Ein Sof itself is above this order. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- Aramaic, “the Holy One, blessed be He”: G‑d as holy, set apart from the worlds, paired with Shechinteh, His indwelling; read as sovev kol almin, Z’eir Anpin, Atzmus, and sometimes memalei kol almin.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Willרצון
- Will, which rules the middos: a lower will born of intellect, and the Supernal Will above intellect (Keser, Gulgalta), which covers a hidden reason and delight and is the root of the mitzvos. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first Sefirah of revelation: a single point of insight (koach mah, the yud of Havayah) that comes from the “nothing” above it; being bittul, Or Ein Sof rests in it, and Binah expands it. ×6Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Life-forceחיות
- Life-force: the G‑dly vitality that brings each creation into being and keeps it alive, drawn to each according to its level and renewed from nothing, as the soul enlivens the body. ×7Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- The Sefirah of kindness (the right arm; Avraham): giving that comes from its nature to do good, spreading from highest to lowest like water. Gevurah, its opposite, limits it; in tikkun each includes the other. ×7Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Name meaning “He brings into being”: by contraction and expansion, its four letters, He brings all worlds into being while Himself unchanged; was, is and will be are one to Him. Elokim conceals it.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest of the four worlds, corresponding to action: its ten Sefiros are still holy, but below them lies kelipas nogah; this physical world is Malchus of Asiyah, its lowest level. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning the soul, which descended into physical things, to its source and root, to cleave to G‑d; not only leaving sin. Its two levels are the return of the lower and the higher hei. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- G‑d’s light that is not clothed in the worlds: equal in all worlds, above and below, unchanged by them, it gives them life as an encompassing light. Its partner, memalei, is clothed within each world. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Tiferes (beauty)תפארת
- The Sefirah of the middle line (Yaakov’s attribute) between Chesed and Gevurah: it joins and includes them, so Or Ein Sof shines in it constantly. It is mercy and truth, and is rooted in Keser. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Netzach (victory)נצח
- The Sefirah below Chesed on the right line, its branch: giving carried through by resolve after its reason has gone. With its partner Hod it is “outside the body,” yet rooted in Keser. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Name Elokimאלקים
- The Name of contraction and concealment, the shield and sheath over Havayah, through which creation appears separate (yesh) and runs as nature (hateva, numerically Elokim). Relative to a higher revelation, Havayah counts as Elokim. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently