Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shir HaShirim · Maamar 28
הסבי עיניך וגו׳
“Turn Away Your Eyes”
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
The burning love of prayer, the ratzo in which the soul longs to dissolve into G‑d, is a great level but not the goal: G‑d says “Turn away your eyes from Me,” because He wants a dwelling place below, and His truest greatness, His “humility,” shows in the shov, the return to Torah study, charity and kindness in the physical world. The Torah and mitzvos, coming from the level of “face,” have the power to remove the “hair” of worldliness that such engagement might bring.
The maamar in brief
The maamar explains “Turn away your eyes from Me, for they have overwhelmed Me; your hair is like a flock of goats that streamed down from Mount Gilead” (Song of Songs 6:5, 4:1). The face holds life, the back only a spillover: Israel is G‑d’s “face,” while Pharaoh, the “nape,” and Esav, “a hairy man,” draw only from the back. In exile the bride is “lovesick” and asks for the wine of the Torah’s inner dimension, to stay always in ecstatic love. G‑d answers that this ratzo belongs to the hour of prayer; the soul came down for the shov, to make Him a dwelling below. The Levites’ song is ratzo, but they were subordinate to the Kohanim, who draw down. The nations exalt G‑d so highly that they deny His providence; in truth, as sovev kol almin, He is equally present above and below, and this “humility” is His higher greatness. The “hair” of worldly cleverness is “shaved” (galshu, read as “shaved”) by Torah and mitzvos, and fear of sin, which sees every small sin as a mountain, is the mound of Gal-ed that keeps the kelipos away.
Outline
- Face and backThe righteous are G‑d’s eyes; the face holds the life-force and the back only a spillover. Through the Priestly Blessing G‑d gives Israel a “face” toward Him, even when sins have hidden it, while Pharaoh (the “nape”) and Esav (“a hairy man”) draw only from the back.¶1
- The lovesick bride and G‑d’s answerEvery Jew’s will is to cleave to G‑d, but in exile an iron partition makes the bride “lovesick,” and she asks for the wine of the Torah’s inner dimension to stay in constant ecstatic love. G‑d answers “Turn away your eyes”: that love is for the time of prayer, and the soul came down for the shov.¶2
- Ratzo and shovThe service must be “if your heart runs, return to the One”: drawing G‑dliness down through practical Torah study, charity, kindness and prayer. Ratzo alone fixes on G‑d’s greatness, while His will is for a dwelling below; the Levites’ song was ratzo, but they were subordinate to the Kohanim, for the drawing down is the main thing.¶3–4
- His humility is His greatnessThe nations exalt G‑d so far that they deny His providence below, picturing creation as a chain of cause and effect. In truth He is sovev kol almin, above the whole chain, and the highest wisdom and the physical world are equal before Him; this “humility” is His higher loftiness.¶5–6
- The lesson for divine serviceRatzo assumes G‑d’s greatness is above, which is true only from the level of memalei kol almin; at the level of sovev kol almin above and below are equal, so the main service is shov, in actual deed. His holiness, His separateness, is what is revealed in this physical world.¶7
- The hair that is shavedEngaging in worldly matters risks the “hair,” the excess worldly cleverness on which the other side feeds. But the Torah and mitzvos, from the level of “face,” shave it off when a person sets his heart to it, and fear of sin, which sees every small sin as a mountain, is the mound of Gal-ed that keeps the kelipos away.¶8
Key concepts
- Face and back (panim and achorayim)פנים ואחוריים
- The face is where life and attention are concentrated, and the back receives only a spillover. A person has a “face” toward G‑d when his will and longing are turned to Him; the hair of the back of the head stands for what is only an outward extension.
- Ratzo and shov (running and returning)רצוא ושוב
- The two movements of the soul’s service: ratzo, the yearning to rise and be absorbed in G‑d, and shov, the return to the world to carry out His will there. The maamar holds that the shov is the purpose of the soul’s descent.
- A dwelling place among the lower realmsדירה בתחתונים
- G‑d’s purpose in creation: that He be at home in this lowly, physical world. It is fulfilled by the shov, the service in physical matters.
- His humility (anvesanuso)ענותנותו
- G‑d’s coming down to watch over and dwell in the lowest world. The maamar argues that this is a higher greatness than the exaltation that keeps Him above.
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- G‑d as He is beyond the chain of cause and effect, so that above and below are equal before Him. Because of it, His providence reaches every detail of life in the physical world.
- The excesses of the intellect (mosrei mochin)מותרי מוחין
- Cleverness in worldly matters, the “hair” that grows from the “back” when a person engages with the physical world. The Torah and mitzvos have the power to remove it.
- Fear of sin (yiras chet)יראת חטא
- Awe included in love: the fear that sin might sever the bond of love, which makes even a small sin look like a mountain. It is the “mound” (gal-ed) that separates a person from the other side.
Face and back ¶1
1הסבי עיניך12 וגו׳. והענין דהנה הצדיקים נקראו עיני ה׳ כמ״ש עין ה׳ אל יראיו3 וכתיב יצרנהו כאישון עינו.4
“Turn away your eyes,” etc. The explanation: for, behold, the righteous (tzaddikim) are called “the eyes of Havayah,” as it is written, “The eye of Havayah is upon those who fear Him,” and it is written, “He guarded him like the pupil of His eye.”
The maamar opens with the verse in the Song of Songs where the beloved says to the bride, “Turn away your eyes from Me, for they have overwhelmed Me”; in Chassidus the beloved is G‑d and the bride is the Jewish people. To explain what the bride’s “eyes” are, the Alter Rebbe notes that the righteous are called G‑d’s eyes, and he brings two verses: G‑d’s eye rests on those who fear Him, and He guards Israel like the pupil of His eye.
והנה העינים הם בחי׳ פנים ששם עיקר החיות ראיה שמיעה וגם במקום שאדם רואה שם מחשבתו משא״כ בחי׳ אחוריים אין שם רק חיות מועט מה שנלקח מהארה וזיו שבפנים
Now, the eyes are the level of “face” (panim), for there is the main life-force: sight [and] hearing; and also, in the place where a person looks, there is his thought. Whereas in the level of the back (achorayim) there is only a little life-force, that which is taken from the illumination and radiance that are in the face;
The eyes belong to the face, and the face is where a person’s life-force is concentrated: there are sight and hearing, and a person’s thought goes wherever he looks. The back of the head, by contrast, has only a little life-force, a spillover of the light and radiance that fill the face.
והוא ענין השערות שאחורי עורף שהוא רק התפשטות הארה וזיו בלבד מן החיות שבפנים כמ״כ [כמו כן] ענין ישראל שהם בחי׳ פנים ששם ראיה ושמיעה עיני ה׳ משוטטות כו׳
and this is the matter of the hair behind the nape, which is only an extension of mere illumination and radiance from the life-force that is in the face. So too is the matter of Israel, who are the level of “face,” where there are sight and hearing: “the eyes of Havayah roam,” etc.,
The hair at the back of the neck is the image of this lesser life: it is only an outward extension of the radiance of the face. The Jewish people, the Alter Rebbe says, are the “face” in this picture, the place of sight and hearing, and he alludes to the verse about G‑d’s eyes roaming over the whole earth.
כדכתיב יאר ה׳ פניו אליך היינו שה׳ מאיר להם לישראל שיהיה להם בחי׳ פנים ורצון ותשוקה אליו ית׳
as it is written, “May Havayah make His face shine upon you”: that is, that G‑d shines upon them, upon Israel, so that they will have the level of “face,” and will and longing for Him, may He be blessed.
The Priestly Blessing, “May Havayah make His face shine upon you,” is read in this light: G‑d shines upon Israel so that they will have a “face” toward Him. Having a “face” here means a will and a longing turned to G‑d.
(וכמ״ש לך אמר לבי5 בקשו פני שיהיה גילוי פנימית הלב והיינו ע״י את פניך הוי׳ אבקש כמ״ש כמ״א ע״פ כי תצא כו׳ וזהו כמים הפנים לפנים6 כו׳)
(And as it is written, “On Your behalf my heart said, ‘Seek My face’”: that there be a revelation of the inner dimension of the heart; and this is through “Your face, Havayah, I will seek,” as is explained elsewhere on the verse “When you go out,” etc. And this is “As water [reflects] face to face,” etc.)
A parenthesis adds a verse from Psalms: the heart’s call “Seek My face” means that the inner depth of the heart should come into the open, and this happens through “Your face, Havayah, I will seek,” as a fuller discussion on the verse “When you go out” explains. The proverb “As water reflects face to face” expresses the reciprocity: the face a person turns to G‑d is the face reflected back to him.
ומ״ש אח״כ עוד ישא ה׳ פניו היינו אף גם אם לפעמים עוונות מבדילים שאין לנו בחי׳ פנים עכ״ז [עם כל זה] ה׳ בטובו עושה לנו בחי׳ פנים אף בלי דעת כלל וזהו ישא ה׳ פניו אליך כו׳
And what is written afterwards, in addition, “May Havayah lift up His face”: that is, even if at times sins separate, so that we do not have the level of “face,” nevertheless G‑d in His goodness makes for us the level of “face,” even without any awareness at all. And this is “May Havayah lift up His face to you,” etc.
The next phrase of the blessing, “May Havayah lift up His face to you,” addresses a harder case: when sins create a separation, so that we no longer have a “face” toward G‑d. Even then G‑d, in His goodness, gives us that “face,” even when we have no awareness of it at all.
(וכמ״ש במ״א7 שבחי׳ ישא8 הוא העלאה למעלה לבחי׳ שאין שם בחי׳ אחוריים כלל שהוא למעלה מבחי׳ צמצום ולכן משם יומשך יתר שאת9 לישא ולהמשיך בחי׳ פנים אף גם בשעה שאין לנו בחי׳ פנים
(And as is explained elsewhere, that the level of “lift up” (yisa) is an elevation upward, to a level where there is no level of the back at all, which is above the level of tzimtzum (contraction); and therefore from there will be drawn “an excess of loftiness” (yeser se’es), to lift up and to draw down the level of “face” even at a time when we do not have the level of “face,”
A parenthesis explains why “lifting up” can do this: it raises the matter to a level above tzimtzum, the divine self-contraction, where there is no “back” at all. From there comes an extra elevation, the “excess of loftiness” (yeser se’es, from the same root as yisa, “lift up”), which draws down a “face” even at a time when we have none of our own.
וכמאמר פנים אין לנו פניך לחלות10 ובחי׳ ראשונה נמשך ע״י מצות התורה וזהו את פניך הוי׳ אבקש והב׳ ע״י מצות דרבנן כמ״ש בגמרא והם מדקדקים עד כזית11 כו׳)
as the saying goes, “We have no face; [we come] to entreat Your face.” And the first level is drawn down through the commandments of the Torah, and this is “Your face, Havayah, I will seek”; and the second, through the commandments of the Rabbis, as is stated in the Gemara, “And they are exacting [with themselves] down to an olive’s bulk,” etc.)
This is the plea of the piyut Merubim tzorchei amcha, as the Kehot note identifies it: “We have no face; we come to entreat Your face.” The two phrases of the blessing match two kinds of mitzvos: “shine His face” is drawn down through the Torah’s own commandments, and “lift up His face” through the Rabbinic ones, as the Gemara says that G‑d lifts His face to Israel because they are strict with themselves to bless Him even over an olive’s bulk.
והנה פרעה אותיות הערף דהיינו שאין לו בחינת פנים כלל וכל החיות שלו הוא רק מאחוריים כמאן דשדי בתר כתפוי
Now, Pharaoh (פרעה) [has] the letters of ha-oref (הערף), “the nape”: that is, that he has no level of “face” at all, and all his life-force is only from the back, “like one who throws [something] behind his shoulders.”
Pharaoh is the opposite of the “face”: the letters of his name, פרעה, are the letters of הערף, “the nape” (the back of the neck). He has no “face” toward holiness at all; whatever life-force he has comes to him only from the back, like something thrown behind one’s shoulders without turning to face the one who receives it.
וז״ש [וזהו שכתוב] עשו אחי איש שעיר12 אף בהיותו אחי בקבלת הארה וזיו מעט מהקדושה הוא רק מבחי׳ שערות שהוא אחורי עורף ולא בחי׳ פנים כלל.131415
And this is [the meaning of] what is written, “Esav my brother is a hairy man”: even as he is “my brother,” in receiving a little illumination and radiance from holiness, it is only from the level of hair, which is behind the nape, and not the level of “face” at all.
Esav is described the same way. Yaakov calls him “my brother,” and indeed he receives a little light from holiness, but Yaakov also calls him “a hairy man”: his share comes only from the level of hair, the back of the neck, and never from the “face.”
The paragraph sets up the maamar’s central image: the eyes and the face hold a person’s life and attention, while the back of the head and its hair receive only a spillover. Israel is G‑d’s “face,” given a face toward Him through the Priestly Blessing even when sins have hidden it, whereas Pharaoh and Esav draw their life only from the “back.”
The two phrases of the Priestly Blessing work on two levels: “shine” answers a face that we already turn toward G‑d, while “lift up” reaches above tzimtzum, where there is no “back,” and so can give a face even to one who has none. Linking the second to the Rabbinic mitzvos follows the Gemara’s own reasoning: Israel goes beyond what the Torah requires of them, and G‑d lifts His face to them beyond strict judgment.
Marei mekomos
- 1הסבי עיניך · בשינויים באוה״ת שה״ש כרך ג ע׳ תתקכג. וראה שם כרך ב ע׳ תקנט. ראה גם פלח הרמון שה״ש צה, א.
- 2הסבי עיניך · Song of Songs 6:5
- 3עין ה׳ אל יריאיו · Psalms 33:18
- 4יצרנהו כאישון עינו · Deuteronomy 32:10
- 5לך אמר לבי · Psalms 27:8
- 6כמים הפנים לפנים · Proverbs 27:19
- 7כמ״ש במ״א ע״פ כי תצא · לעיל פ׳ תצא לה, ג. לו, ב.
- 8וכמ״ש במ״א שבחי׳ ישא · ראה לעיל נשא כו, ד. כז, ב ואילך.
- 9יתר שאת · Genesis 49:3
- 10פנים אין לנו פניך לחלות · פיוט ”מרובים צרכי עמך”.
- 11והם מדקדקים עד כזית · Berakhot 20b:15
- 12עשו אחי איש שעיר · Genesis 27:11
- 13עיני ה׳ משוטטות · Zechariah 4:10
- 14יאר ה׳ פניו · Numbers 6:25
- 15ישא ה׳ פניו · Numbers 6:26
The lovesick bride and G‑d’s answer ¶2
2וזהו עבדים היינו לפרעה1 כו׳ ויוציאנו כו׳2 בבחי׳ פנים ולכן כ״א [כל אחד / כל אחת] מישראל הרצון שלו תמיד לדבקה בה׳ אחד ואינו רוצה בשום אופן ליפרד ממנו ואף בעת עסקו במו״מ [במשא ומתן] הוא רק בחי׳ שכחה שהוא ג״כ בחי׳ אחוריים.
And this is “We were slaves to Pharaoh,” etc., “and He brought us out,” etc., in the level of “face.” And therefore each one of Israel, his will is always to cleave to the One G‑d, and he does not want in any way to be separated from Him; and even at the time he is occupied in business, it is only the level of forgetfulness, which is also the level of the back.
The Exodus is read the same way: “We were slaves to Pharaoh,” the “nape,” and G‑d brought us out into the level of “face.” Therefore every Jew’s will is always to cleave to the One G‑d and never to be separated from Him; when he is busy with business, that is only forgetfulness, itself a form of the “back,” and not a real turning away.
שהרי אף כשנזכר בעת עסקו על ה׳ אחד יתעורר לבבו מאד לה׳ אחד וזהו ומי כעמך כישראל גוי אחד בארץ3 אף בהיותו בחי׳ ארץ הוא גוי אחד
For indeed, even when he is reminded of the One G‑d at the time he is occupied [in it], his heart will be greatly aroused toward the One G‑d. And this is “And who is like Your people, like Israel, one nation on earth”: even while it is in the level of “earth,” it is “one nation.”
The proof is that even in the middle of his business, the moment he is reminded of G‑d, his heart is stirred toward Him. This is the sense of “one nation on earth”: even while a Jew is in the realm of “earth,” busy with worldly matters, he remains “one,” bound to the One.
(ועמ״ש ע״פ שובה ישראל45 כו׳ בהיותו קרוב6 כו׳ החזרת פב״פ [פנים בפנים]) ומה שנדמה לנו שאינו כן הוא רק מחמת רוח שטות7 כו׳.
(And see what is explained on the verse “Return, O Israel,” etc., [on] “while He is near,” etc., the restoration of “face to face.”) And what seems to us, that it is not so, is only because of a spirit of folly, etc.
The parenthesis refers to the discourse on “Return, O Israel,” and its words on “while He is near,” which deal with restoring the face-to-face relationship. If it seems to us that we are not always bound to G‑d, that impression comes only from a “spirit of folly,” a confusion that hides the truth.
וזהו סמכוני באשישות8 דהנה בזמן הבית היה הקב״ה עמנו פב״פ [פנים בפנים] בלי שום מסך מבדיל (עמ״ש בפסוק כי ההרים ימושו)910 וה״ע [וזהו ענין] אהבה בתענוגים11 משא״כ עכשיו בגלות מחיצה של ברזל מפסקת כו׳
And this is “Sustain me with flagons”: for, behold, in the time of the Temple the Holy One, blessed be He, was with us face to face, without any separating screen (see what is explained on the verse “For the mountains shall depart”), and this is the matter of “love in delights.” Whereas now, in exile, a partition of iron interposes, etc.
Now the bride’s plea “Sustain me with flagons” is explained. In the time of the Temple, G‑d was with Israel face to face, with no separating screen: that was “love in delights.” Now, in exile, a partition of iron stands between them.
ונק׳ חולת אהבה12 שנחלשו חושי האהבה ואומרים על מר מתוק13 מפני שאין לנו טעם וריח כמ״ש טעמו וראו כי טוב14 ה׳ כו׳ טועמיה חיים זכו טוב ה׳ לכל
And it is called “lovesick,” for the senses of love have grown weak, and they call bitter sweet, because we have no taste and scent, as it is written, “Taste and see that Havayah is good,” etc.; “those who taste it merit life”; “Havayah is good to all.”
That is why she calls herself “lovesick”: the senses of love have weakened, so that people call bitter sweet, because we have lost the “taste and scent” of G‑dliness. The phrases about tasting, “Taste and see that Havayah is good” and “those who taste it merit life,” show that closeness to G‑d is meant to be tasted.
ולכן אף שבעת התפלה יש לכל א׳ בחי׳ פנים להשתוק ק מאד לדבקה בה׳ אחד עכ״ז [עם כל זה] בעת עסקו במו״מ [במשא ומתן] הוא בהסתר פנים מה׳ אחד
Therefore, although at the time of prayer everyone has the level of “face,” to long intensely to cleave to the One G‑d, nevertheless at the time he is occupied in business he is in a hiding of the face from the One G‑d.
So although at the time of prayer everyone has a “face,” a strong longing to cleave to G‑d, when he goes about his business he is in a state of “hidden face,” concealed from G‑d.
(וזהו יונתי בסתר המדרגה15 כי יונתי הוא כמ״ש עיניך יונים בחי׳ פנים ועכשיו הוא בסתר המדרגה כו׳)
(And this is “My dove, in the hiding place of the steps”: for “my dove” is, as it is written, “Your eyes are doves,” the level of “face,” and now it is “in the hiding place of the steps,” etc.)
The parenthesis applies the verse “My dove, in the hiding place of the steps”: the dove stands for the eyes, as in “Your eyes are doves,” that is, the “face,” and in exile that face is hidden away.
ואף בלימוד התורה בפשטים גשמיים שנתלבשה התורה בהשתלשלות רבות ושונות ג״כ אין לו בחי׳ פנים ודביקות לה׳ אחד מפני מחיצה המפסקת עתה להיות בחי׳ חולת אהבה
And even in the study of Torah in [its] physical plain meanings, in which the Torah has been enclothed through many and varied stages of descent (hishtalshelus), he likewise has no level of “face” and cleaving to the One G‑d, because of the partition that now interposes, so that it is the level of “lovesick.”
Even Torah study, when it deals with the plain physical meaning of the law, does not by itself give a “face” and cleaving to G‑d, because the Torah has come down through many stages and become clothed in physical subjects. The partition of exile is what turns this into a state of lovesickness.
ולכן מבקשת סמכוני באשישות גרבי יין המשומר שהוא בחי׳ המקיים ומחזק את האהבה בל תמוט
Therefore she asks, “Sustain me with flagons”: jugs of the preserved wine, which is the level that sustains and strengthens the love, so that it shall not falter;
Therefore she asks to be sustained “with flagons,” jugs of “the preserved wine,” which, as the next part explains, is the hidden wine of the Torah’s inner dimension. This is what would hold the love steady so that it does not falter.
(וכמ״ש בד״ה חכלילי עינים מיין1617 ממה שטועם יינה של תורה פנימי׳ [פנימיות / פנימית] התורה נכנס יין יצא סוד18 הוא גילוי בחי׳ אהבה רבה כו׳ ונעשה חכלילי עינים התלהבות האהבה וגם חכלילי חיך הטועם כו׳)
(and as is explained in the discourse beginning “His eyes are red with wine”: from what one tastes of the wine of the Torah, the inner dimension of the Torah, “wine enters, a secret comes out”; this is the revelation of the level of “great love” (ahavah rabbah), etc.; and one becomes “red of eyes,” the fiery passion of love, and also “chachlili”: the palate that tastes, etc.)
The parenthesis refers to the discourse on “His eyes are red with wine”: tasting the wine of the Torah, its inner dimension, works like the saying “wine enters, a secret comes out,” and reveals “great love” (ahavah rabbah). The eyes become “red” with the burning passion of love, and the word chachlili is also read as the palate (chech) that tastes.
רק תמיד יהיה בבחי׳ כלה כלתה נפשי19 לה׳ אחד וזהו בקשת כנס״י [כנסת ישראל] סמכוני באשישות שעי״ז יהי׳ [יהיה] תמיד עיני אל20 ה׳ ולא לעסוק כלל בדברים תחתונים.
but rather that it always be in the level of expiring, “my soul expires,” for the One G‑d. And this is the request of the Congregation of Israel (Knesses Yisrael), “Sustain me with flagons”: that through this it will always be “my eyes toward Havayah,” and not to be occupied at all with lower matters.
What the bride wants is to remain always in the state of “my soul expires” for G‑d, a love so intense that the soul longs to go out of itself toward Him. This is the plea of the Congregation of Israel: through these “flagons” her eyes would always be turned to G‑d, and she would have nothing to do with lower, worldly matters.
וע״ז משיב לה הקב״ה הסבי עיניך2122 וגו׳ (בפ׳ ויחי דרמ״ז א׳ קדושים פ״ד א׳ וברבות בשה״ש [בשיר השירים]) כי עם היות שזהו בחי׳ גדולה
And to this the Holy One, blessed be He, answers her, “Turn away your eyes,” etc. (in Parshas Vayechi, 247a; Kedoshim, 84a; and in the Midrash Rabbah on Song of Songs). For although this is a great level,
To this G‑d answers, “Turn away your eyes from Me,” and the Alter Rebbe gives the Zohar on Vayechi and Kedoshim and the Midrash Rabbah on the Song of Songs as the places where the verse is read this way. He grants that this intense love is a great level.
אבל זה צ״ל רק לפי שעה בשעת התפלה בחי׳ לאסתכלא ביקרא דמלכא אבל אח״כ צ״ל בבחי׳ שוב והוא תכלית הבריאה
yet this must be only for a time, at the time of prayer, the level of “gazing upon the glory of the King”; but afterwards it must be in the level of “returning” (shov), and this is the purpose of creation.
Yet it is meant only for a time, during prayer, when one “gazes upon the glory of the King.” Afterwards a person must turn to shov, “returning” to the world to serve G‑d there, and that is the purpose of creation.
כי בשביל הרצוא בחי׳ חכלילי עינים כו׳ לא היה צריך להיות ירידת והתלבשות הנשמה למטה כי למעלה הרצוא יותר.23
For, for the sake of the “running” (ratzo), the level of “red of eyes,” etc., there would have been no need for the descent and enclothing of the soul below, for above, the ratzo is greater.
For the sake of ratzo, the soul’s “running” toward G‑d with a burning love, the soul would not have needed to come down and be clothed in a body: above, before its descent, its ratzo was even greater. The descent must therefore be for the sake of the shov.
Israel’s true will is always to cleave to G‑d, and only the iron partition of exile makes them “lovesick,” so the bride asks for the wine of the Torah’s inner dimension to keep her in constant, burning love. G‑d answers “Turn away your eyes”: such love belongs to the hour of prayer, but the soul came down for the shov, the return to serve Him in the world.
Ratzo and shov (running and returning) are the two movements of the soul’s service: the yearning to rise beyond the world, and the return to carry out G‑d’s will within it. The argument that the soul had more ratzo before it descended is the basis for the next paragraph’s claim that the purpose of the descent is the shov.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2עבדים היינו לפרעה כו׳ ויוציאנו כו׳ · Deuteronomy 26:8
- 3ומי כעמך כישראל גוי אחד בארץ · II Samuel 7:23
- 4ע״פ שובה ישראל · לעיל שבת שובה סו, ד.
- 5שובה ישראל · Hosea 14:2
- 6בהיותו קרוב · Isaiah 55:6
- 7רוח שטות · Sotah 3a:4–5
- 8סמכוני באשישות · Song of Songs 2:5
- 9עמ״ש בפסוק כי ההרים ימושו · לעיל פ׳ תצא מ, א.
- 10כי ההרים ימושו · Isaiah 54:10
- 11אהבה בתענוגים · Song of Songs 7:7
- 12משא״כ עכשיו בגלות . . ונק׳ חולת אהבה · Zohar III, 39a
- 13ואומרים על מר מתוק · נתבאר באוה״ת שה״ש ע׳ ריא ואילך.
- 14טעמו וראו כי טוב ה׳ · Psalms 34:9
- 15יונתי בסתר המדרגה · Song of Songs 2:14
- 16בד״ה חכלילי עינים מיין · תו״א מז, א ואילך.
- 17חכלילי עינים מיין · Genesis 49:12
- 18נכנס יין יצא סוד · Eruvin 65a:19–20
- 19כלתה נפשי · Psalms 84:3
- 20תמיד עיני אל ה׳ · Psalms 25:15
- 21הסבי עיניך · Zohar, Vayechi 75:771–781
- 22הסבי עיניך · Zohar, Kedoshim 10:71–12:78
- 23טוב ה׳ לכל · Psalms 145:9
Ratzo and shov ¶3–4
3ואין זה תכלית העבודה וכמ״ש במ״א ע״פ כי תבואו אל ארץ מושבותיכם.1 אלא צ״ל בחינת רצוא ושוב אם רץ לבך שוב2 לאחד34
And this is not the purpose of the [divine] service, as is explained elsewhere on the verse “When you come into the land of your dwellings.” Rather, there must be the level of ratzo and shov (running and returning): “If your heart runs, return to the One.”
Burning love by itself is not the goal of serving G‑d, as the Alter Rebbe explains elsewhere on the verse “When you come into the land of your dwellings.” The service must be ratzo and shov, “running and returning,” as in the teaching “If your heart runs, return to the One”: the soul’s run toward G‑d must be followed by a return.
דהיינו כשמתעורר אהוי״ר [אהבה ויראה] ורצון להדבק בה׳ אחד שוב לאחד להיות לו דירה בתחתונים להמשיך אלהות
That is, when love and awe and a will to cleave to the One G‑d are aroused, “return to the One,” so that He may have a dwelling place among the lower realms, to draw down G‑dliness
When love and awe and the wish to cleave to G‑d are aroused, a person must “return to the One”: turn back toward the world, so that G‑d may have a dwelling place among the lower realms. The aim of the return is to draw G‑dliness down.
בזה העולם דוקא ע״י לימוד התורה בענינים הגשמיים באו״ה [באיסור והיתר] ודיני ממונות ומעשה הצדקה וגמ״ח [וגמילות חסדים] ותפלה בכוונה עד״ז יהיה עיקר העבודה ולא בבחי׳ רצוא בלבד.
into this world specifically, through the study of Torah in the physical matters, in [the laws of] the forbidden and the permitted and monetary laws, and the practice of charity and acts of kindness (gemilus chassadim), and prayer with intent; in this way shall the main [part of the] service be, and not in the level of ratzo alone.
G‑dliness is to be drawn into this world specifically, through Torah study that deals with physical matters, such as the laws of the forbidden and the permitted and monetary law, through actual charity and acts of kindness, and through prayer with intent. This, and not ratzo alone, is to be the main part of the service.
וזהו הסבי עיניך שלא להיות הכל בבחי׳ רצוא בלבד וזהו מנגדי כמבואר בפ׳ אחרי (דע״ט ב׳) בענין שרפים עומדים ממעל לו.56
And this is “Turn away your eyes”: that not all should be in the level of ratzo alone. And this is “from opposite Me” (minegdi), as is explained in Parshas Acharei (79b) concerning “Serafim stood above Him.”
This is G‑d’s answer, “Turn away your eyes”: not everything should be ratzo. The word “from Me” (minegdi), the Alter Rebbe adds, is explained in the Zohar on Parshas Acharei, in its discussion of “Serafim stood above Him.”
And see what is explained in the discourse beginning “And Yaakov sent,” concerning Ben Azzai. “For they have overwhelmed Me” (hirhivuni): the meaning is an expression of greatness, as it is written, “And I will magnify Myself,” etc.
He also refers to his discourse on “And Yaakov sent,” on Ben Azzai, the Sage who gazed into the mysteries and died, an example of ratzo without return. The next words of the verse, hirhivuni, “they have overwhelmed Me,” express greatness, as in “And I will magnify Myself.”
כי בחי׳ רצוא הנ״ל נמשך מההתבוננות בגדולת ה׳ איך שלגדולתו אין חקר9 וכולא קמי׳ [קמיה] כלא חשיבי10 ולכן ירצה ויחפוץ להתכלל למעלה ולא להיות למטה.
For the level of ratzo mentioned above is drawn from contemplating the greatness of G‑d: how “His greatness is unsearchable” and “all before Him is considered as nothing.” And therefore he will want and desire to be absorbed above, and not to be below.
Ratzo comes from contemplating G‑d’s greatness: “His greatness is unsearchable,” and before Him everything is as nothing. A person who dwells on this wants to be absorbed into G‑d above and not to remain below.
אך רצונו ית׳ דוקא להיות לו דירה בתחתונים כי במקום גדולתו שם אתה מוצא ענותנותו11 משא״כ בחי׳ רצוא לבד הוא בחי׳
But His will, may He be blessed, is specifically to have a dwelling place among the lower realms, for “in the place of His greatness, there you find His humility.” Whereas the level of ratzo alone is the level of
But G‑d’s own will is to have a dwelling place among the lower realms, as the Sages say, “In the place of His greatness, there you find His humility”: His greatness shows itself in His coming down to what is lowly. Ratzo by itself, by contrast, corresponds to “they have overwhelmed Me,” as the next part explains.
הרהיבוני בחי׳ גאה וגדלות להתעלות למעלה מבלי שיהיה בחי׳ הדירה בתחתונים הנק׳ ענותנותו וכמ״ש אשירה לה׳12 בחי׳ רצוא כי גאה גאה13 בחי׳ רוממות כו׳.
“they have overwhelmed Me” (hirhivuni), the level of exaltation and greatness, to rise upward without there being the level of the dwelling place among the lower realms, which is called “His humility.” And as it is written, “I will sing to Havayah”: the level of ratzo; “for He is exalted, exalted”: the level of loftiness, etc.
Ratzo alone is “they have overwhelmed Me”: a sense of G‑d’s exaltation and greatness that seeks only to rise upward, without the dwelling below that is called His “humility.” The Song at the Sea shows the same: “I will sing to Havayah” is the ratzo, and “for He is exalted, exalted” is the loftiness it is drawn to.
Burning love is not the goal: the service must be ratzo followed by shov, the return to draw G‑dliness into this world through Torah study of practical law, charity, kindness and prayer. Ratzo alone fixes on G‑d’s greatness (“they have overwhelmed Me”), while His will is for a dwelling below, which expresses His humility.
“In the place of His greatness, there you find His humility” turns the usual picture around: G‑d’s greatness is shown not only by His distance from the world but by His care for the lowest. The next paragraphs develop this into the claim that shov reveals more of His true greatness than ratzo does.
Marei mekomos
- 1כי תבואו אל ארץ מושבותיכם · Numbers 15:2
- 2אם רץ לבך שוב · Sefer Yetzirah 1:8
- 3אם רץ לבך שוב לאחד · ת״ז בהקדמה ז, א. ובס״י פ״א, מ״ז: שוב למקום. ראה לעיל . . .
- 4אם רץ לבך שוב לאחד · Tikkunei Zohar 7a:3
- 5שרפים עומדים ממעל לו · Isaiah 6:2
- 6שרפים עומדים ממעל לו · Zohar, Achrei Mot 72:405–75:413
- 7והתגדלתי · יחזקאל (סוס״י לח). [כ].
- 8והתגדלתי · Ezekiel 38:23
- 9לגדולתו אין חקר · Psalms 145:3
- 10וכולא קמי׳ כלא חשיבי · Zohar, Introduction 20:188–22:199
- 11במקום גדולתו שם אתה מוצא ענותנותו · Megillah 31a:12–13
- 12אשירה לה׳ כי גאה גאה · Exodus 15:1
- 13אשירה לה׳ . . כי גאה גאה · Exodus 15:15
And this is the level of “And the Levite shall serve—he” (ve’avad haLevi hu): to rise from the revealed world (alma de’isgalya) to the hidden world (alma de’iskasya), which is called “He” (hu), the level of “You are He, Havayah, alone.”
The Levites embody ratzo. The verse “And the Levite shall serve—he” is read on the word hu, “he”: their service was to rise from the revealed world to the hidden world, which is called hu, “He,” the word used for G‑d as He is hidden, as in “You are He, Havayah, alone.”
ולכן היה עבודת הלוים לשורר כו׳ אבל הלוים היו כפופים לכ הנים כמ״ש וילוו עליך וישרתוך3
Therefore the service of the Levites was to sing, etc. But the Levites were subordinate to the Kohanim (priests), as it is written, “And they shall be joined to you and minister to you.”
That is why the Levites’ service was song, which lifts the soul upward. Yet the Levites were subordinate to the Kohanim, as G‑d tells Aharon that the Levites will “be joined to you and minister to you.”
כי העיקר הוא ההמשכה שאח״כ בחי׳ שוב כו׳ וגם ניגון הלוים היה בבחי׳ רצוא ושוב4
For the main thing is the drawing down that comes afterwards, the level of shov, etc. And the melody of the Levites, too, was in the level of ratzo and shov.
The Levites, whose song is ascent, were subordinate to the Kohanim because the main thing is the drawing down that follows the ascent: the shov. Even the Levites’ melody itself had both movements, ratzo and shov.
ולכן והניף אותם אהרן56 כו׳ להמתיק הגבורות בחסדים.7 כי בחי׳ השוב זהו אמיתית גדולתו יותר וכמאמר וענוה גדולה מכולם.8
Therefore, “And Aharon shall wave them,” etc., to sweeten the Gevuros (forces of restraint) with the Chassadim (kindnesses). For the level of shov is, even more, the truth of His greatness, as the saying goes, “And humility is greater than all of them.”
That is why Aharon, the Kohen, waved the Levites: to sweeten the Gevuros, the forces of restraint associated with the Levites, with the Chassadim, the kindness associated with the Kohanim. For shov is the truer expression of G‑d’s greatness, as the Sages say, “And humility is greater than all of them.”
The Levites, whose service was song, embody ratzo, the rise to the hidden world; they were subordinate to the Kohanim because the drawing down that follows, the shov, is the main thing. Shov is the truer greatness, as humility is the greatest of the virtues.
In Chassidus, “He” (hu), said of one who is not present, speaks of G‑d as hidden, while “You” (atah) speaks of Him as present and revealed. The Levites’ ascent “to the hidden world” is thus a movement away from revelation toward what cannot be grasped, and the Kohanim bring it back into the downward flow.
Marei mekomos
- 1ועבד הלוי עבד · Numbers 18:23
- 2אתה הוא ה׳ לבדך · Nehemiah 9:6
- 3וילוו עליך וישרתוך · Numbers 18:2
- 4וגם ניגון הלוים היה בבחי׳ רצוא ושוב · נתבאר בביאוה״ז להצ״צ כרך ב ע׳ תרפט ואילך.
- 5והניף אותם אהרן · Numbers 18:11
- 6והניף אותם אהרן · Numbers 8:11
- 7להמתיק גבורות בחסדים · ראה מאמרי אדה״ז — אתהלך לאזניא ע׳ קנג.
- 8וענוה גדולה מכולם · Avodah Zarah 20b:11
His humility is His greatness ¶5–6
And you may know that it is so, for indeed it is said, “High above all,” etc., “Who is like Havayah our G‑d,” etc., “who lowers [Himself],” etc.
To show that shov is the higher greatness, the Alter Rebbe turns to Psalm 113: “High above all nations is Havayah… Who is like Havayah our G‑d, who is enthroned on high, who lowers Himself to look upon heaven and earth.”
פי׳ שעכו״ם [שעובדי כוכבים ומזלות] מנשאים3 ג״כ אותו ומפני רוב התנשאותם אותו דקרו ליה אלהא דאלהיא4 הגבה למעלה הם ממעטים המשכת אלהותו בזה העולם כי אומרים שזהו השפלה אצלו להשגיח למטה.
The meaning is: the idolaters also exalt Him, and because of how greatly they exalt Him, for they call Him “the G‑d of gods,” exalted on high, they diminish the drawing down of His G‑dliness into this world; for they say that it is a lowering for Him to watch over [what is] below.
The idolaters, too, exalt G‑d; as the Talmud records, they call Him “the G‑d of gods.” But because they place Him so high, they limit the drawing of His G‑dliness into this world, for they say it would be a lowering for Him to watch over what happens below.
אבל באמת מי כה׳ אלקינו המגביהי לשבת יותר מן הרוממות שהם מחשבים כי הם סוברים שההתהוות ממנו ית׳ ע״ד עילה ועלול ושיש רבוי השתלשלות עילה ועלול כך כך עד שנתהוה עולם השפל.
But in truth, “Who is like Havayah our G‑d, who is enthroned on high,” more than the loftiness that they reckon. For they hold that coming into being from Him, may He be blessed, is in the manner of cause and effect, and that there are a great many links in the chain (hishtalshelus) of cause and effect, so and so many, until the lowly world came into being.
But in truth, “Who is like Havayah our G‑d, who is enthroned on high”: He is higher than the loftiness they imagine. Their mistake is that they picture creation as a chain of cause and effect, with many links one after another, until this lowly world came into being.
Psalm 113 is brought as proof: the idolaters exalt G‑d so highly that they deny His providence below, because they picture creation as a long chain of cause and effect. The psalm answers that He is higher still than the loftiness they imagine.
In the view described here the world comes from G‑d only through a long chain of intermediate causes, so the lower world is far from Him. The next paragraph answers that G‑d, as sovev kol almin, stands beyond the whole chain, so that the highest and the lowest are equally before Him.
Marei mekomos
- 1רם על כל גוים · Psalms 113:4
- 2מי כה׳ אלקינו · Psalms 113:5
- 3פי׳ שעכו״ם מנשאים · ראה ד״ה הטה אלקי תרצ״ד (בסה״מ קונטרסים ח״א) ובכ״מ. וראה ספר הערכים-חב״ד (כרך ב) ע׳ אומות העולם ס״ג — לקו״ש לפ׳ ואתחנן תשמ״ו.
- 4דקרו ליה אלהא דאלהיא · Menachot 110a:5–6
6ולכן הוא השפלה לעילה וסבה ראשונה להשפיל א״ע [את עצמו] כ״כ [כל כך] למטה ועל כן סוברים שאינו משגיח למטה כו׳
And therefore it is a lowering for the First Cause and Reason to lower Himself so far down; and therefore they hold that He does not watch over [what is] below, etc.
If the world comes from G‑d through a chain of causes, it would seem a lowering for the First Cause to come down so far. So they conclude that He does not watch over what happens below.
אבל באמת שהוא ית׳ למעלה מעלה מבחי׳ זו דעילה ועלול כי הוא ית׳ בחי׳ סכ״ע [סובב כל עלמין] ואצלו תית׳ הח״ע [החכמה עילאה] ועשייה גשמיות שניהן שוין א״כ
But in truth He, may He be blessed, is far, far above this level of cause and effect, for He, may He be blessed, is the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin), and with Him, may He be blessed, the higher Chochmah (Chochmah Ila’ah) and the physical World of Asiyah (Action) are both equal. If so,
In truth, G‑d is far above the whole order of cause and effect, for He is sovev kol almin, the light that encompasses all worlds and is not one of the links in their chain. Before Him, the highest wisdom (Chochmah Ila’ah) and the physical world of action are equal.
כמו שמשגיח בח״ע [בחכמה עילאה] כך ממש משגיח בעשיה הגשמיות ובכל מעשה האדם הלוכו ושבתו וקומו וכל צרכיו כו׳
just as He watches over the higher Chochmah, so exactly does He watch over the physical Asiyah, and over all the doings of man: his walking, his sitting and his rising, and all his needs, etc.
Therefore He watches over the physical world exactly as He watches over the higher Chochmah, down to every detail of a person’s life: his walking, his sitting, his rising and all his needs.
וזהו וענוה גדולה מכולם והיינו כי גאה גאה שרוממותו יותר מבחי׳ גאה וגדולה והיינו המשפילי לראות בשמים ובארץ.1
And this is “And humility is greater than all of them.” And this is [the meaning of] “for He is exalted, exalted”: that His loftiness is more than the level of exaltation and greatness. And this is [the meaning of] “who lowers [Himself] to look in heaven and on earth.”
This is “humility is greater than all of them,” and this is “for He is exalted, exalted”: His true loftiness is above mere exaltation and greatness. That is why “He lowers Himself to look in heaven and on earth,” on both alike.
G‑d is above the chain of cause and effect altogether, as sovev kol almin, so the highest wisdom and the physical world are equal before Him and His providence reaches every detail of human life. His looking upon earth as upon heaven is the higher greatness, His “humility.”
The doubled “exalted, exalted” is read as two levels: a greatness that is merely higher than the world, and a loftiness so far beyond it that higher and lower make no difference to it. It is this second level that makes providence over the lowest things possible.
Marei mekomos
- 1המשפילי לראות בשמים ובארץ · Psalms 113:6
The lesson for divine service ¶7
7ומזה נשכיל ג״כ בדרך העבודה שאם העבודה רק בבחי׳ רצוא לבד להתכלל למעלה זהו שהם הרהיבוני שגדולתו ית׳ למעלה ואין זה
And from this we will understand, too, regarding the way of [divine] service: that if the service is only in the level of ratzo alone, to be absorbed above, this is “for they have overwhelmed Me”: that His greatness, may He be blessed, is above. And this is not [so]
From this follows a lesson for divine service. A service of ratzo alone, seeking to be absorbed above, is “they have overwhelmed Me”: it assumes that G‑d’s greatness is found above.
רק מצד בחי׳ ממכ״ע [ממלא כל עלמין] והשתלשלות עילה ועלול בבחי׳ זו שייך לומר כן שגדולתו מתגלה למעלה יותר
except from the perspective of the level of the light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin) and the chain (hishtalshelus) of cause and effect; in this level it is applicable to say so, that His greatness is revealed more above,
That assumption holds only from the standpoint of memalei kol almin, the light that fills each world according to its measure, and of the chain of cause and effect. At that level one can indeed say that His greatness is more revealed above.
אבל באמת בבחי׳ סוכ״ע מעלה ומטה שוין ולכן עיקר העבודה דוקא בבחי׳ שוב בלימוד התורה בענינים גשמיים וצדקה וגמ״ח [וגמילות חסדים] בפועל ממש
but in truth, in the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin), above and below are equal. And therefore the main [part of the] service is specifically in the level of shov: in the study of Torah in physical matters, and charity and acts of kindness (gemilus chassadim) in actual deed.
But at the level of sovev kol almin, the light that encompasses all worlds, above and below are equal. Therefore the main service is shov: Torah study that deals with physical matters, and charity and acts of kindness in actual deed.
וזהו מאמר הקב״ה לכנ״י [לכנסת ישראל] שלא תהיה רק בבחי׳ רצוא לבד רק הסבי עיניך מנגדי ותהי׳ [ותהיה] עבודתך בדברים תחתונים להמשיך אלהות למטה וזהו ואל אישך תשוקתך והוא ימשול בך1
And this is the statement of the Holy One, blessed be He, to the Congregation of Israel (Knesses Yisrael): that she should not be only in the level of ratzo alone, but rather “Turn away your eyes from Me,” and let your service be in lower matters, to draw down G‑dliness below. And this is “And to your husband shall be your longing, and he shall rule over you.”
This is what G‑d says to the Congregation of Israel: do not be only in ratzo; “Turn away your eyes from Me,” and let your service be in lower matters, to draw G‑dliness down. So too “And to your husband shall be your longing, and he shall rule over you”: Israel’s longing for G‑d is to be governed by His will for the world below.
וזהו יתגדל ויתקדש כו׳ בעלמא די ברא כו׳ שלפי שהוא ית׳ קדוש ומובדל מכל העולמות ע״כ יומשך גילוי אלקותו בעוה״ז הגשמי כו׳
And this is “Magnified and sanctified,” etc., “in the world that He created,” etc.: that because He, may He be blessed, is holy and separate from all the worlds, therefore the revelation of His G‑dliness will be drawn down into this physical world, etc.
The Kaddish says the same: “Magnified and sanctified… in the world that He created.” Because G‑d is holy, separate from all the worlds, the revelation of His G‑dliness can be drawn down into this physical world.
וכמ״ש במ״א בפי׳ המלך הגדול והקדוש בשמים ובארץ המלך הגדול היינו בחי׳ ממכ״ע [ממלא כל עלמין] אבל הקדוש הוא סוכ״ע ולכן הוא בשמים ובארץ בהשואה א׳:
And as is explained elsewhere on the meaning of “the great and holy King in heaven and on earth”: “the great King” is the level of the light that fills all worlds, but “the holy” is the light that encompasses all worlds; and therefore He is in heaven and on earth in one equality.
So too the words of the prayers “the great and holy King in heaven and on earth”: “the great King” is memalei kol almin, while “holy,” the separate and transcendent, is sovev kol almin. Being above all, He is in heaven and on earth equally.
Ratzo alone assumes that G‑d’s greatness is found above, which is true only at the level of memalei kol almin; at the level of sovev kol almin above and below are equal, so the main service is shov, Torah study of practical matters and deeds of charity and kindness. This is G‑d’s “Turn away your eyes,” and it is why His holiness, His transcendence, is what is revealed in this world.
The paradox is that holiness, which means separation, is what lets G‑d be present in the lowest world: only what is beyond every level is not bound to any of them, and so can be present in each equally.
Marei mekomos
- 1ואל אישך תשוקתך והוא ימשול בך · Genesis 3:16
The hair that is shaved ¶8
8שערך כעדר העזים.1 פי׳ אם תאמר איך יתכן הדרך הזה לעסוק בעבודה בדברים תחתונים הלא ח״ו [חס ושלום] בהעמיק מחשבתו בדברים תחתונים ישאר בלא שום
“Your hair is like a flock of goats.” The meaning: If you will say, how is this path possible, to be occupied in [divine] service in lower matters? Surely, G‑d forbid, when one’s thought delves deeply into lower matters, one will remain without any
The maamar turns to the next words of the verse, “Your hair is like a flock of goats,” and raises an objection: how can a person serve G‑d by engaging in lower matters? If he immerses his thoughts in worldly things, he may be left, G‑d forbid, without any cleaving to G‑d or holiness at all.
דביקות וקדושה כלל לה׳ אחד וע״ז אמר שערך כעדר העזים ששערות הם מותרות הגוף לא עצמיות הגוף ולכן איתא בזהר2 שבשערות העזים יש יניקה לחיצונים.
cleaving and holiness at all toward the One G‑d. And about this He said, “Your hair is like a flock of goats”: for hairs are the excess of the body, not the essence of the body; and therefore it is stated in the Zohar that in the hairs of goats the external forces draw nourishment.
The verse itself voices this concern: “Your hair is like a flock of goats.” Hair is the body’s excess, not its essence, and the Zohar says that the external forces, the powers opposed to holiness, draw nourishment from goats’ hair.
(וכך כשעוסק בדברים תחתונים נופל מבחי׳ פנים הנז׳ [הנזכר] לעיל בבחי׳ אחוריים שמשם נמשך השערות והמותרות והוא ההתחכמות בעניני העולם ונק׳ מותרי מוחין והוא בחי׳ כעדר העזים משא״כ מבחי׳ פנים אין מקום לשערות אלו כנ״ל וא״כ איך אמר הסבי עיניך כו׳
(And so too, when one is occupied with lower matters, one falls from the level of “face” mentioned above into the level of the back, from which the hairs and the excesses are drawn; and this is cleverness in worldly matters, and it is called “the excesses of the intellect” (mosrei mochin), and this is the level of “like a flock of goats.” Whereas from the level of “face” there is no place for these hairs, as mentioned above. And if so, how did He say, “Turn away your eyes,” etc.,
A parenthesis spells this out: engaging in lower matters makes a person fall from the “face” into the “back,” the source of hairs and excesses. This is cleverness in worldly affairs, called “the excesses of the intellect” (mosrei mochin), the “flock of goats”; from the “face” no such hairs grow, so the question returns: how could G‑d say, “Turn away your eyes”?
שלא להיות בבחינת רצוא כו׳ כ״א בבחי׳ שוב בעבודה בדברים תחתונים והלא מזה יוכל להיות נמשך בחי׳ שערך כו׳ דעם היות התומ״צ [התורה ומצות] הם אדרבה תכלית בחי׳ פנים כמ״ש באור פניך נתת לנו כו׳
not to be in the level of ratzo, etc., but rather in the level of shov, in service in lower matters? Surely from this there can be drawn the level of “your hair,” etc. For although Torah and mitzvos are, on the contrary, the ultimate level of “face,” as it is written, “For by the light of Your face You gave us,” etc.,
That is, how could He tell Israel to leave ratzo for shov, serving Him in lower matters, when this can bring on the “hair”? True, Torah and mitzvos are the very height of “face,” as the prayer says, “By the light of Your face You gave us” the Torah.
אך כיון שנתלבשו בענינים גשמיים אשר הענינים גשמיים אלו הם בחי׳ אחוריים א״כ יוכל להיות נמשך אחר גשמיות הענינים ולכן אמרו האומר אין לי אלא תורה3 אפילו תורה אין לו ועמ״ש סד״ להבין ענין הברכות4 בענין חותם בברוך)
yet since they have been enclothed in physical matters, and these physical matters are the level of the back, if so, one can be drawn after the physicality of the matters. And therefore they said, “One who says, ‘I have nothing but Torah,’ does not have even Torah.” And see what is explained at the end of the discourse beginning “To understand the matter of the blessings,” concerning concluding with “Blessed” (baruch).)
Yet since they are clothed in physical matters, which are the “back,” a person can be drawn after the physicality of those matters. That is why the Sages said that one who says he has only Torah does not have even Torah; the Alter Rebbe also refers to his discussion of why every blessing concludes with “Blessed.”
אך ע״ז אמר שגלשו מהר גלעד5 גלישא תרגום קרחת גלישתא ובזהר פ׳ ויחי (דרי״ז) מאן דגליש כו׳ ועמ״ש בד״ה כי תצא6 גבי וגלחה את ראשה.7
But about this He said, “that streamed down (galshu) from Mount Gilead.” Gelisha: the Targum of “baldness” (karachas) is glishta; and in the Zohar, Parshas Vayechi (217), “One who shaves,” etc. And see what is explained in the discourse beginning “When you go out,” regarding “and she shall shave her head.”
The answer lies in the verse’s next words, “that streamed down (galshu) from Mount Gilead,” which the Alter Rebbe reads as “that were shaved”: the Targum renders “baldness” as glishta, and the Zohar on Vayechi speaks of one who shaves. He refers as well to his discourse on “When you go out,” on the captive woman who “shall shave her head.”
והיינו שאדרבה ע״י עסק התורה ומצות שהם עצמן מבחי׳ פנים לכן אף שנתלבשו בענינים גשמיים יש בכחן לדחות ולהעביר המותרי מוחין כשישים לבו לזה.
That is: on the contrary, through occupation with the Torah and mitzvos, which are themselves from the level of “face,” therefore, even though they have been enclothed in physical matters, they have the power to push away and remove the excesses of the intellect, when one sets his heart to this.
The point is that Torah and mitzvos are themselves from the level of “face,” so even when clothed in physical matters they have the power to push away and remove the excesses of the intellect, when a person sets his heart to it. The very occupation that seemed to bring on the “hair” is what shaves it off.
וזה נמשך מהר הגלעד פי׳ שזה כבר נעשה בימי יעקב ולבן ששמו גלעד מחיצה8 הפסקת כדכתיב עד הגל הזה9 אם נסתר כו׳ שלא יתקרבו הקליפות להקדושה כשיתראה הגל הזה.
And this is drawn from Mount Gilead. The meaning: this was already done in the days of Yaakov and Lavan, who set up Gal-ed as an interposing partition, as it is written, “This mound is witness,” “if [one] is hidden,” etc., so that the kelipos (husks) will not draw near to holiness when this mound is seen.
This power comes from “Mount Gilead.” Yaakov and Lavan set up a mound, Gal-ed, as a boundary between them (“This mound is witness” that neither would cross it to harm the other), and in the same way the kelipos cannot come near holiness once this mound is seen.
(והוא בחי׳ המסך המפסיק בין הקדושה לסט״א [לסטרא אחרא] בחי׳ חשמ״ל ושרשו מהמסך המפסיק בין אצי׳ לבריאה שע״י מסך זה לא יוכלו הקליפות להתקרב לקדושת האצילות שהוא אור התומ״צ [התורה ומצות])
(And this is the level of the screen that interposes between holiness and the sitra achra (the other side), the level of Chashmal; and its root is from the screen that interposes between the World of Atzilus (Emanation) and [the World of] Beriah (Creation), for through this screen the kelipos cannot draw near to the holiness of Atzilus, which is the light of the Torah and mitzvos.)
A parenthesis identifies the mound with the screen between holiness and the sitra achra, called Chashmal, whose root is the screen between Atzilus and Beriah. Because of that screen the kelipos cannot approach the holiness of Atzilus, which is the light of the Torah and mitzvos.
וענין הגל הזה בעבודה ומה שנק׳ הר הגלעד הוא מ״ש רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] רשעים נדמה להם כחוט השערה10 וצדיקים נדמה להם כהר ועמך כולם צדיקים11 פי׳ שכל איסור קטן נדמה להם כהר ומסך מבדיל בינו לבין קונו
And the matter of this mound in [divine] service, and that it is called Mount Gilead, is what our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “To the wicked it seems like a hair’s thread, and to the righteous it seems like a mountain”; and “Your people are all righteous.” The meaning: that every small prohibition seems to them like a mountain and a screen that separates between him and his Maker.
In a person’s service, this mound is the outlook the Sages describe: to the wicked it seems like a hair’s thread, to the righteous like a mountain; and “Your people are all righteous.” Every small prohibition seems to a Jew like a mountain, a screen separating him from his Maker.
(וזה בא ונמשך מבחי׳ יראת חטא וענין יראת חטא הוא בחי׳ יראה הכלולה באהבה שמצד עוצם האהבה מתיירא מן החטא שלא ינתק חבל האהבה כו׳ ולכן נדמה לו כהר ומסך מבדיל ונקרא הר הגלעד שהוא מחיצה המפסקת כו׳.
(And this comes and is drawn from the level of fear of sin (yiras chet); and the matter of fear of sin is the level of awe that is included in love: that because of the intensity of the love, one is afraid of sin, lest the cord of love be severed, etc. And therefore it seems to him like a mountain and a separating screen, and it is called Mount Gilead, which is an interposing partition, etc.
This outlook comes from fear of sin, which is awe included in love: because the love is so strong, a person fears that sin might sever the cord of love. So even a small sin looks to him like a mountain and a dividing screen, and this is “Mount Gilead,” a partition that keeps the other side out.
או הר הוא אהבה וחסד דקדושה שמזה נמשך יראת חטא להיות גל עד ומחיצה מפסקת בינו לסט״א [לסטרא אחרא] ועמ״ש מענין יראת חטא בד״ה ויקח קרח12 ובד״ה ראשי המטות ובד״ה אלה מסעי)
Or: “mountain” is the love and Chesed (kindness) of holiness, from which fear of sin is drawn, to be a gal-ed (a mound of witness) and an interposing partition between him and the sitra achra. And see what is explained on the matter of fear of sin in the discourse beginning “And Korach took,” and in the discourse beginning “The heads of the tribes,” and in the discourse beginning “These are the journeys.”)
Alternatively, the “mountain” is the holy love and Chesed (kindness) from which fear of sin is drawn, so that it becomes a gal-ed, a mound of witness and a partition between the person and the sitra achra. The Alter Rebbe refers to his discussions of fear of sin in the discourses on “And Korach took,” “The heads of the tribes” and “These are the journeys.”
וממילא כשישים אל לבו כל הנל שהוא בחי׳ הר ומחיצה מפסקת אפילו עבירה קלה שבקלות ממילא לא ישאר ח״ו [חס ושלום] בעניני גשמיים בלי כוונת הלב המשכת אלהות בזה הדבור
And consequently, when he takes to heart all that was said above, that even the lightest of light transgressions is the level of a mountain and an interposing partition, then of itself he will not remain, G‑d forbid, in physical matters without the heart’s intent: the drawing down of G‑dliness in this speech.
So when a person takes to heart that even the lightest transgression is a mountain and a partition, he will not, G‑d forbid, remain caught in physical matters without the heart’s intent. Even while dealing with them, he will intend to draw G‑dliness down through his very words.
וזהו גליש למטרוניתא13 עי״ז העבודה כי הוא גלישת השערות דמטרוניתא ועמ״ש סד״ה ביום השמיני שלח14 גבי לפני קרתו15 כו׳.
And this is “he shaves the Matronisa” (gelish leMatronisa) through this service, for it is the shaving of the hair of the Matronisa (the Queen). And see what is explained at the end of the discourse beginning “On the eighth day he sent,” regarding “Before His cold,” etc.
This service is what the Zohar calls “shaving the Matronisa”: it removes the “hair,” the excesses, of the Matronisa, the Queen, a Zohar name for the Shechinah. The Alter Rebbe refers to the end of his discourse on “On the eighth day he sent,” on the words “Before His cold.”
גלעד הוא של אבנים כשהבית נופל ונעשה חורבה נק׳ גל כמ״כ [כמו כן] אבנים הם אותיות16 וכשהצירופי אותיות הם בדברים בטלים נעשה בית חורבה ולכן זהו הר ומסך מבדיל כו׳:
Gal-ed is [a mound] of stones: when a house falls and becomes a ruin, it is called a gal (a heap). So too, stones are letters, and when the combinations of letters are in idle words, a ruined house is made; and therefore this is a mountain and a separating screen, etc.
Finally, the name Gal-ed: it is a mound of stones, and a house that falls into ruin becomes a heap (gal) of stones. Stones are letters, so when the combinations of letters are spent on idle words, a ruined house is made, and that is why the gal is a mountain and a screen that separates a person from his Maker.
The verse’s next words raise the worry that serving G‑d in worldly matters will bring on “hair,” the worldly cleverness on which the other side feeds. The answer is “that were shaved from Mount Gilead”: Torah and mitzvos, which come from the “face,” remove those excesses when a person sets his heart to it, and fear of sin, which makes every small sin look like a mountain, is the mound (gal-ed) that keeps the kelipos away.
The paragraph reads one verse in two directions: “hair” is the danger of the lower world, and “shaved” is the remedy found within the lower world itself, in the Torah and mitzvos clothed in physical matters. The mound of Yaakov and Lavan, rooted in the screen between Atzilus and Beriah, becomes in a person’s service the sensitivity of fear of sin that grows out of love.
Marei mekomos
- 1שערך כעדר העזים · Song of Songs 6:5
- 2איתא בזהר · ע׳ זח״ג (מח, ב). זח״ב (קפה, א-ב). וע״ל אמור (לב, א). וש״נ. מא׳[דמו״ר]. [כ].
- 3האומר אין לי . . תורה · Yevamot 109b:4–5
- 4סד״ה להבין ענין הברכות · תו״א ז, א.
- 5שגלשו מהר גלעד · Song of Songs 4:1
- 6בד״ה כי תצא · לעיל תצא לו, ג.
- 7וגלחה את ראשה · Deuteronomy 21:12
- 8ששמו גלעד מחיצה המפסקת · ראה אוה״ת ויקהל ע׳ ב׳קג.
- 9עד הגל הזה · Genesis 31:52
- 10רשעים נדמה להם כחוט השערה · Sukkah 52a:4
- 11ועמך כולם צדיקים · Isaiah 60:21
- 12ויקח קרח · Numbers 16:1
- 13גליש למטרוניתא · Zohar, Vayechi 17:120–19:134
- 14ביום השמיני שלח · I Kings 8:66
- 15לפני קרתו · Psalms 147:17
- 16אבנים הם אותיות · ראה ס״י פ״ד, מט״ז.
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
Prayer should be a time of burning love and longing for G‑d, but it is meant only “for a time”; afterwards a person must turn back to the world and serve G‑d there, in Torah study that deals with practical matters, in charity and acts of kindness in actual deed, so that G‑d has a dwelling place below. To keep such engagement from dragging him into worldliness, he should take to heart that even the lightest transgression is a mountain that separates him from his Maker, and so remain intent on drawing G‑dliness into whatever he does and says.
Questions for discussion
- Why does G‑d tell the bride to turn her eyes away from Him, when her longing to cleave to Him seems the highest possible love?
- How does the maamar prove that the soul did not descend for the sake of ratzo?
- In what sense is G‑d’s “humility,” His watching over the lowest world, greater than His exaltation above it?
- What is the “hair” that worldly engagement can bring, and how do the Torah and mitzvos “shave” it?
- How does fear of sin, which grows out of love, serve as the mound of Gal-ed between a person and the other side?
Key terms in this maamar
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×4
- Willרצון
- Desire; in G‑d, the level above intellect. ×3
- The inner dimension (pnimiyus)פנימיות
- The innermost core of a level.
- Tzimtzum (contraction)צמצום
- The self-concealment of the Infinite Light that makes room for finite worlds. ×1
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The step-by-step descent of divine light from the highest level down to this world. ×3
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- The two 'wings' of divine service.
- A dwelling place among the lower realmsדירה בתחתונים
- The purpose of creation: that G‑d be at home in this world. ×3
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- Measure, limitation and judgment.
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving. ×1
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- Divine light too great to enter the worlds; it 'surrounds' them and affects them from beyond.
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight.
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest world, including our physical one. ×1
- The light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin)ממלא כל עלמין
- Divine light that enters each world and gives it life according to its measure.
- The intellect (mochin)מוחין
- Chochmah, Binah and Daas as a whole. ×2
- The sitra achra (the other side)סטרא אחרא
- The realm opposed to holiness.
- The World of Atzilus (Emanation)אצילות
- The highest world, still one with G‑d. ×1
- The World of Beriah (Creation)בריאה
- The first world of separate existence. ×2
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Deep connection to an idea, bridging intellect and emotion. ×1