Torah Ohr · Parshas Mikeitz · Maamar 3
ענין חנוכה
The subject of Chanukah
The Rebbe on this maamar
The Rebbe opens from it in this maamar of his: ד״ה מאי חנוכה דת״ר בכ״ה בכסליו (5747)
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
Love of G‑d has two sources, both from above: the power to kindle it at all (“when Aharon kindles”) and the added love that enlarges it beyond human measure (“when he tends”). A person reaches both through the mitzvos, which, like the oil of a lamp, are dark to the mind yet draw down G‑d Himself.
The maamar in brief
Chanukah is marked with lights, not a feast, because under the Greeks Israel was not exiled from its land: theirs was an exile of the Torah, not of the body; and the verse calls a mitzvah a lamp and the Torah light. The mitzvah is like oil: it has no light of its own, yet from it the light of Chochmah, the Oral Torah, is drawn. The Alter Rebbe then asks why the verse calls the Menorah’s morning service “tending” and its evening service “kindling”. The Menorah is the collective soul of Israel, and its seven lamps are the seven shepherds, among them Aharon, who kindles Israel’s love for G‑d. A person can build love by contemplating G‑d’s kingship over countless worlds; yet all that kingship is only G‑d’s “Name” and His humility, while G‑d, the Singular One, is beyond the worlds. Realizing this, the soul longs to leave the worlds and cleave to Him. Even this longing is G‑d’s gift, “kindling”, given to a soul that is dark like evening; the love from above that enlarges it is “tending”, the morning quality of Avraham’s kindness. Both come through the mitzvos, the King’s limbs: grasping one draws the King Himself. The question raised at the start about “the way of life” is not taken up in the maamar as printed.
Outline
- Why Chanukah is kept with lightsThe Greek oppression was an exile of the Torah, not of the body, so the commemoration is “a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah light”; what, then, is the “way of life”?¶1
- The mitzvah as oil; tending and kindling the MenorahThe mitzvah, like oil, is dark in itself yet feeds the light of Torah wisdom. Why is the morning service “tending” and the evening service “kindling”? The Menorah is the soul of Israel.¶2
- Aharon and the love from aboveAharon, one of the seven shepherds, kindles Israel’s love; without G‑d’s help no physical person could love Him. The “ordinary fire” is the love gained from contemplating G‑d’s kingship.¶3–4
- One and Singular: kingship as humility“One” is G‑d in relation to the worlds; “Singular” is G‑d beyond them. Life-force, kingship and praise belong only to His Name, and His greatness over the worlds is His humility.¶5–8
- Kindling, tending, and the mitzvosThe soul longs to go beyond the worlds; G‑d gives the power to love (kindling) and enlarges it (tending), and both are reached through the mitzvos, the King’s limbs.¶9
Key concepts
- A mitzvah is a lampנר מצוה
- The mitzvah is compared to the oil of a lamp: it has no light of its own that the mind can grasp, yet the light of Torah comes from it.
- Tending and kindlingבהטיבו ובהעלות
- The verse’s verbs for the Menorah’s morning service (cleaning the lamps) and its evening service (lighting them): kindling is G‑d’s gift of the very power to love; tending is the added love from above that enlarges it.
- Groomsman of the Matronitaשושבינא דמטרוניתא
- The Zohar’s title for Aharon, who prepares the Congregation of Israel for union with G‑d by kindling their love.
- One and Singularאחד ויחיד
- “One” is G‑d’s unity as the worlds are nullified before Him; “Singular” is G‑d as He is in Himself, beyond any relation to worlds.
- The ordinary fireאש של הדיוט
- The love a person produces himself by contemplating G‑d’s kingship, like the fire the priests brought to the altar alongside the fire from heaven.
- The King’s limbsרמ״ח אברין דמלכא
- The 248 positive commandments; grasping one of them draws G‑d Himself to the person, as grasping a king’s limb draws the king.
For children · ages 9–13
The lamp, the oil and the love of G‑d
The big idea
Our love for G‑d is His gift, both the spark that lights it and the help that makes it grow, and we reach Him through the mitzvos, like a lamp that shines from its oil.
Why do we remember Chanukah with lights and not with a feast? Because the Greeks tried to take away the Torah, not to hurt Jewish bodies, and the verse says “a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light.” A mitzvah is like oil: oil has no light of its own, yet the flame burns from it. So too the mitzvos, even when we do not understand them, feed the light of Torah. The Menorah in the Beis HaMikdash is like the soul of the Jewish people, and Aharon the Kohen, who lit it, helps light the love of G‑d in every Jew. A person can think about how great G‑d is, King over countless worlds, and come to love Him. Yet all the worlds together are as nothing before G‑d Himself, and when the soul understands this it longs to come close to Him alone. Even this longing is G‑d’s gift: He “kindles” it in the evening, when the soul feels dark, and in the morning He “tends” it, making the love grow larger. We reach Him through the mitzvos.
The mashal
A person who takes hold of a king by one of his arms draws the whole king along, because the king’s life is in every part of him. The mitzvos are called the “limbs of the King,” so when we take hold of a mitzvah, we take hold of G‑d Himself.
Questions for the Shabbos table
- Why does the maamar say that the love we feel for G‑d is also His gift?
- Oil has no light of its own, yet the flame burns from it. How is a mitzvah like oil?
- Which mitzvah can you do this week while remembering that you are “taking hold” of G‑d through it?
Explanation © likuteitorah.com, CC BY-NC 4.0: retold for children from our translation and explanation, with AI assistance; not yet reviewed by a human editor.
The Rebbe’s maamarim on this maamar · 1
AI summaries Written by AI from each maamar and checked against it by a second AI reader; no person has reviewed them yet, so check the maamar itself before relying on a detail. See something to correct?
The Rebbe built this maamar (5747) on the Alter Rebbe’s. Open one for a summary, for what it adds paragraph by paragraph, and its lesson. All of them, by parsha.
1.5747Opens from itד״ה מאי חנוכה דת״ר בכ״ה בכסליו
The Rebbe opens from this maamar’s question of why the miracle was set in lights, and from the verse “ki ner mitzvah.” His main content, the four elements of the lamp and mesirus nefesh joining oil and flame, comes from the other Chanukah maamarim in Torah Ohr Miketz (33b ff., 38b, 39b) and from Likkutei Torah Re’eh. The transcript given has a gap in the middle.
Summary
The Rebbe opens from the Gemara’s account of the cruse of oil and from a question raised in the maamarim of the Rebbeim: why was the commemoration of Chanukah set with lights? The main miracle was the military victory over the Greeks, as the Al HaNissim prayer stresses (“You delivered the mighty into the hands of the weak”). The miracle of the oil does not explain it either, since many miracles happened in the Beis HaMikdash, such as the ten miracles listed in Avos, and none was given a commemoration. So the oil miracle must be bound up with the victory itself.
His explanation: the lamp stands both for the soul (“the lamp of Havayah is the soul of man”) and for Torah and mitzvos (“a mitzvah is a lamp”). A lamp has four elements: oil, wick, and a flame with two hues, white light and dark light. These match the four letters of Havayah, which were drawn into every Jew at Sinai. What joins oil to flame is mesirus nefesh, “na’aseh” before “nishma,” a service beyond measure. The Rebbe suggests this should be the soul’s level all day, and he links it to the Shemitah year. The four elements divide into two motions, drawing down from above and raising up from below. These are the “goings” of the haftarah and the two views of Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel on how many lights to kindle. The miracle was that the lamp could be lit in full perfection in all these respects. The transcript then has a gap. It closes by saying that in a person’s avodah Beis Shammai’s view of weighing one’s ways may even be primary, and with the hope for the lights that “are never annulled”: seven in the Mikdash, eight on Chanukah, and ten in the time to come.
What the Rebbe adds
- ¶1
The Alter Rebbe asks why Chanukah is marked with lights rather than with eating, as on Pesach and Purim. He answers that the Greek decree was an “exile of the Torah,” not a bodily one. The Rebbe sharpens the question from a different side. Al HaNissim puts the stress on the war, and other Temple miracles were never given a commemoration. He concludes that the commemoration of the oil miracle was established because it is connected with the victory in the war against the Greeks.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה קבעו הנס בנרות. משא״כ בשאר נסים
The Rebbe
מדוע קבעו זכרון הנס בנרות. דהרי עיקר הנס הוא נצחון המלחמה
- ¶2
In the Alter Rebbe’s maamar the lamp image is built on one contrast: dark oil (the mitzvah) produces light (the wisdom of the Oral Torah). The Rebbe widens the image to four elements: oil, wick, white flame and dark flame. He applies it to the soul as well (“ner Havayah nishmas adam”) and matches the four elements to the four letters of Havayah given at Sinai.
The Alter Rebbe
כמו שהנר נקרא על שם השמן
The Rebbe
וכשם שבנר יש ד׳ ענינים, השמן והפתילה והאור שיש בו ב׳ גונים
- ¶2
For the Alter Rebbe, the mitzvah being above reason is what makes it like oil, the source of the light. The Rebbe, drawing on the related Chanukah discourses, names what joins oil and flame: mesirus nefesh, “na’aseh before nishma,” a service beyond measure. He adds that this must be the soul’s constant state, not only the moment of doing a mitzvah. He illustrates it with Shemitah, where both refraining from work and sowing itself demand faith beyond reason.
The Alter Rebbe
הגם שהוא רצון המלך בלי שום טעם ודעת ואין בה שום השגה
The Rebbe
וי״ל הכוונה בזה שזהו לא רק בשעת קיום המצוות אלא שכ״ה דרגת הנפש כל היום
- ¶9
The Alter Rebbe divides the Menorah’s service in two: “be-haalos” is the arousal from below, and “be-heitivo” is the love from above that enlarges it. The Rebbe likewise divides the lamp into drawing down and raising up, though in his own terms. He applies the pair to the halachic dispute: drawing down follows Beis Hillel (ascending in holiness), and raising up follows Beis Shammai (decreasing). He adds that in personal avodah Beis Shammai’s view, weighing and measuring one’s ways, may even be the main thing.
The Alter Rebbe
וע״י אתערותא דלתתא זו יחול עליו אור האהבה מלמעלה
The Rebbe
ובכללות הנה ד׳ ענינים אלו שבנר נחלקים לב׳, המשכה מלמעלה למטה והעלאה מלמטה למעלה
The lesson
The Rebbe suggests that mesirus nefesh beyond measure is the soul’s level all day, not only during mitzvah observance. A person should also judge himself regarding bodily excesses, consider what is necessary for his soul, and give the rest to tzedakah.
AI summary
The full maamar: read or print it free at Lahak Hanochos (lahak.org)
AI summary Written by Claude Opus 5.5 reading each of the Rebbe’s maamarim, from the scan corrected by AI, beside the Alter Rebbe’s maamar and our translation; not yet reviewed by a human editor: check the maamar itself before relying on a detail. The Hebrew words are quoted exactly. The full text of the Rebbe’s maamarim is published by Vaad Hanochos B’Lahak, free to read and print on lahak.org, and in print by Kehot. This page gives only short summaries and brief quotes.
In the Rebbe’s light · 10
AI research Found by AI reading every place in the Rebbe’s works that cites this maamar, and checked against each source by a second AI reader, the less certain by a third. Only what rated high is shown: the Rebbe’s own words, about this very passage. No person has reviewed it yet, so check the place itself before relying on a detail. See something to correct?
The maamar in the Rebbe’s light
The Rebbe takes up this maamar’s opening question, why the miracle was fixed in lights, and answers it in two ways. His Chanukah 5731 letter concludes that the war itself was over the lights, the soul and the mitzvah; a sicha of Shabbos Mikeitz 5726 and 5734, that after the spiritual miracle the victory, though its cause, has no standing. His notes for Chanukah 5696 give the maamar’s reason half for half, the Torah’s light against „להשכיחם תורתך” (“to make them forget Your Torah”), the mitzvah’s lamp against „ולהעבירם” (“to make them transgress”); a letter of Shushan Purim 5706 cites it: Purim rescued body and soul together, Chanukah the soul alone. He deepens the „גלות התורה” (“exile of the Torah”) from the Rebbe Rayatz’s maamarim (“explained in many places”): the Greeks fought not Torah study but its being G‑d’s Torah (Erev Chanukah 5739); and since that darkness was of the spirit, Israel’s self-sacrifice came wholly from themselves, the receivers, as the Mitteler Rebbe’s Shaarei Orah puts it (the Zos Chanukah sicha, 5733 and 5740). He answers the question the maamar leaves open: „דרך חיים” (“the way of life”) is teshuvah, light out of darkness, which the Chanukah lights carry (Likkutei Sichos 30). Perhaps, read with him, the maamar’s Aharon, one of the seven shepherds, has his counterpart in every Jew (his letter of Behaaloscha 5724).
Paragraph by paragraph
- ¶1
The Rebbe explains
In an edited sicha on Parshas Mikeitz (from talks of Shabbos Mikeitz 5741 and Shabbos Eikev 5728), explaining the brothers’ confession “we are guilty” and Reuven’s reply, the Rebbe shows that true teshuvah comes from a person’s own free choice (בחירה חפשית), where „אין מי שמעכב על ידו” (“none can stop him”), and then ties this to Chanukah, part of which always falls in the week of Mikeitz.
This paragraph ends with a question the maamar never answers: what “way of life” does the verse add beyond the mitzvah (the lamp) and the Torah (the light)? The Rebbe quotes the question word for word and answers, sending the reader to the Mitteler Rebbe’s Shaarei Orah, that „ודרך חיים תוכחות מוסר” (“the way of life, the reproofs of discipline”) is the service of teshuvah: „על ידי תשובה שלימה מעומק הלב מתגלים חיים מפנימיות הנשמה” (complete return from the depth of the heart reveals life from the inwardness of the soul), which is bound up with G‑d. The Chanukah lights hold this too, for they are „האור הבא מתוך החושך דוקא” (light that comes out of darkness), kindled by the Hasmoneans’ self-sacrifice, which rose from that inwardness and is higher than „נר מצוה ותורה אור” (“a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light”).
The Alter Rebbe
ולהבין ענין פסוק זה וגם סיפא דקרא דכתיב ודרך חיים וגו׳. צריך ביאור איזה דרך חיים הוא מלבד התורה והמצות
The Rebbe
אלא ש״דרך חיים” קאי על עבודת התשובה . . שעל ידי תשובה שלימה מעומק הלב מתגלים חיים מפנימיות הנשמה
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ל, p. 203 · משיחות ש״פ מקץ תשמ״א, ש״פ עקב תשכ״ח
- ¶1
The Rebbe explainsThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
In an edited Chanukah sicha (from Shabbos Mikeitz–Chanukah 5726 and 5734) that asks why Al HaNissim never mentions the oil while the Gemara’s „מאי חנוכה” (“What is Chanukah?”) never mentions the war, the Rebbe starts from the known question why the festival was fixed on the oil and not on the victory.
The Rebbe first gives the known answer, listing this maamar among its sources: the main Greek decree was not against Jewish bodies but against the religion, so the commemoration was fixed on the oil, a miracle tied to the Temple lamps, which allude to all of Torah and mitzvos, „נר מצוה ותורה אור” (“a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light”). He then adds why light in particular: of all created things light is „הכי רוחני” (the most spiritual), less caught in matter than sound or smell, so spiritual things are named “light” and the Menorah’s light is a vessel for the light of the Shechinah (אור השכינה). Once that spiritual light shone, the physical victory, though it came first and made the lights possible, has no standing beside it.
The Alter Rebbe
לפיכך קבעו בנרות על שם הפסוק (משלי ו) כי נר מצוה ותורה אור
The Rebbe
ומהאי טעמא ווערט רוחניות באַצייכנט מיטן נאָמען אור — ווייל צווישן אַלע דברים גשמיים שבעולם, איז אור דער נברא הכי רוחני
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כה, p. 237–241 · משיחות ש״פ מקץ, שבת חנוכה – תשכ״ו, תשל״ד
- ¶1
A question the Rebbe raisesThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
The Rebbe’s general letter for Chanukah 5731 opens with this maamar’s own words, "ענין חנוכה — קבעו הנס בנרות" (his note: „ראה ד״ה זה בתורה אור”, “see this dibbur hamaschil in Torah Ohr”), and in a note on those words he raises a difficulty with them.
The letter for Chanukah 5731 opens with this maamar’s words, “the subject of Chanukah: they fixed the miracle in lights”, and in his note to them the Rebbe asks: Chanukah also had the miracle of the victory, „מסרת גבורים ביד חלשים” (“You delivered the mighty into the hands of the weak”); without it there could have been no miracle of the lights, and even without the lights the victory alone would have redeemed Israel from the Greek exile. He concludes that the war itself must have been over the lights, „נר הנשמה ונר מצוה” (the lamp of the soul and the lamp of the mitzvah). In a talk to the children of Tzivos Hashem on 25 Kislev 5741 (Likkutei Sichos 20 p. 463, note 38) he grounds this in this paragraph’s own reason: the war and the victory were mainly spiritual, „להשכיחם תורתך” (“to make them forget Your Torah”), and so they too concerned the lights.
The Alter Rebbe
ענין חנוכה. הנה קבעו הנס בנרות. משא״כ בשאר נסים
The Rebbe
והרי בחנוכה הי׳ גם הנס דמסרת גבורים ביד חלשים כו׳ ובלעדו א״א נס הנרות
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ה, p. 445 · ימי חנוכה ה׳תשל״א (letter)
- ¶1
The Rebbe explains
In the maamar he said on Motzaei Shabbos Vayeishev, the night of Erev Chanukah 5739 (an unedited transcript), the Rebbe opens with this maamar’s question: why was the Chanukah miracle fixed in lights, „שהו״ע רוחני” (a spiritual thing), and not in feasting like Purim and the festivals?
The Rebbe sets out the Alter Rebbe’s answer in his own words: Purim and Pesach were bodily rescues, so they, and the festivals bound up with the Exodus, are kept with feasting, while on Chanukah Israel dwelt on its land, the Temple stood, and „היונים לא רצו לנגוע בגופם של ישראל” (the Greeks did not want to touch Jewish bodies). He adds a precision “explained in many places” (the editors point to maamarim of the Rebbe Rayatz) in „להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם מחוקי רצונך” (“to make them forget Your Torah and transgress the statutes of Your will”): the Greeks did not forbid studying Torah or doing mitzvos, only studying Torah as G‑d’s Torah and keeping the statutes as „רצון ה׳ שלמעלה מהטעם” (His will, above reason). So the decree was spiritual even within Torah and mitzvos, and it is answered with lights, a spiritual thing.
The Alter Rebbe
משא״כ בחנוכה שהיו ישראל שרוים על אדמתם ולא גלו מארצם רק גלות התורה
The Rebbe
שגזירת היונים לא היתה שלא ילמדו תורה ושלא יקיימו את המצוות כ״א להשכיח ח״ו את ישראל שהתורה היא תורתך
Sefer HaMaamarim 5739 (unedited), vol. תשל״ט, p. נז–נח · מוצאי ש״פ וישב, מבה״ח טבת, אור לערב חנוכה ה׳תשל״ט
- ¶1
The Rebbe explains
In his notes for Chanukah 5696 in Paris (part of them said in a synagogue there), the Rebbe goes phrase by phrase through the Gemara’s „מאי חנוכה” (“What is Chanukah?”), which he reads as a dilemma: if the festival marks the oil it should have been called the festival of lights, and if it marks the victory it should be kept with feasting, as Purim is.
In his notes for Chanukah 5696 the Rebbe answers this paragraph’s question, why lights and not feasting as on Purim, with its reason in its own terms, and matches the halves: the Sages instituted „נר ואור” (“lamp and light”) on account of „להשכיחם תורתך” (“to make them forget Your Torah”), answered by “the Torah is light”, and „ולהעבירם” (“to make them transgress…”), answered by „נר מצוה” (“a mitzvah is a lamp”). So each half of the verse the Alter Rebbe quotes stands against one half of the decree he cites.
The Alter Rebbe
להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם חוקי רצונך לפיכך קבעו בנרות על שם הפסוק (משלי ו) כי נר מצוה ותורה אור
The Rebbe
תקנו נר ואור. ע״ש להשכיחם תורתך, תו״א, ולהעבירם וכו׳, נר מצוה.
Reshimos, vol. חוברת קכה, p. 8 · חנוכה תרצ״ו (Paris)
- ¶1
Background from the Rebbe
In a talk of Shabbos Chanukah 5725 on what joins 19 Kislev and Chanukah, both bound up with tzedakah, a note sources the duty of kindness („גמ״ח בממון וגוף”) on Chanukah in the Pri Megadim and draws from his words an answer to why Chanukah seemed to have nothing against the Greeks’ seizing of Jewish property; then, from the Rebbe’s own reshimah, it sets every Greek deed in Rambam’s list against its reversal in Chanukah.
Rambam opens the Laws of Chanukah with the list of what the Greeks did. The Rebbe’s note sets against each item its reversal among the Chanukah observances: against their decrees („גזרו גזירות”), Hallel, „שענינו חירות” (whose theme is freedom); against „בטלו דתם” (“they abolished their religion”), thanksgiving; against „ולא הניחו אותם לעסוק בתורה ובמצות” (“they did not let them engage in Torah and mitzvos”), the lights, “because of the verse ‘for a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light’”, citing this maamar; against their hand on Jewish property and daughters, tzedakah and the women’s duty to light; against the breached and defiled Heichal, „באו בניך לדביר ביתך” (“Your children came to the Sanctuary of Your House…”) and „וטהרו את מקדשך” (“and purified Your Temple”). So this paragraph’s reason for the lights is one line in a complete reversal of the decree.
The Alter Rebbe
רק גלות התורה להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם חוקי רצונך לפיכך קבעו בנרות
The Rebbe
ולא הניחו אותם לעסוק בתומ״צ (שלכן קבעו הנס בנרות, ע״ש הפסוק כי נר מצוה ותו״א. תו״א רד״ה ענין חנוכה)
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ה, p. 443 · שבת חנוכה ה׳תשכ״ה (note 15, marked "רשימת כ״ק אדמו״ר שליט״א")
- ¶1
Background from the Rebbe
In an edited sicha on why the last day is called “Zos Chanukah” (from Shabbos Mikeitz 5733 and 5740), the Rebbe contrasts Purim, whose miracle came while there were prophets, with Chanukah, which came wholly from Israel below.
Citing this paragraph in his note 52, the Rebbe restates its contrast: the Purim decree was against Jewish bodies, as the Levush puts it („שהיתה הגזירה להרוג ולהשמיד את הגופות”), while on Chanukah the religion was abolished, a spiritual darkness in which the light of Torah, „נר מצוה ותורה אור” (“a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light”), did not shine openly, „גלות התורה” (“the exile of the Torah”). From this he draws, with the distinction the Mitteler Rebbe makes in the introduction to Shaarei Orah (his note 54: on Purim the self-sacrifice came from the side of the giver, on Chanukah „מצד המקבל” (from the side of the receiver)), that on Chanukah the self-sacrifice came wholly from Israel, the receivers, with no prophets as there were in the days of Mordechai and Esther, so the festival came by the Sages’ enactment, and its lights are the receiver lighting up the darkness.
The Alter Rebbe
שהיו ישראל שרוים על אדמתם ולא גלו מארצם רק גלות התורה
The Rebbe
ס׳איז געווען אַ מצב פון חשך רוחני, ווען דער אור התורה (נר מצוה ותורה אור) האָט ניט מאיר געווען בגלוי, ”גלות התורה”
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כה, p. 249 · משיחות ש״פ מקץ תשל״ג, תש״מ
- ¶1
Background from the Rebbe
In a letter of Shushan Purim 5706, sent with the newly printed Toras Shalom (the Rebbe Rashab’s sichos), the Rebbe explains in Chassidus why Purim requires „שתי מנות לאיש אחד ומתנות לאביונים שתי מתנות לשני בני אדם” (two portions to one friend and gifts to two poor people), and begins from the difference between the Purim and Chanukah rescues.
Citing this maamar, and the Levush brought in the Taz, the Rebbe writes that the Purim miracle rescued „הגוף והנפש גם יחד” (body and soul together), while Chanukah was only „הצלה מגלות רוחני” (a rescue from a spiritual exile). Israel earned the Purim rescue by self-sacrifice, cleaving to G‑d „בבחי׳ רצון פשוט שלמעלה מהשכל והשגה” (with a simple will above reason), for had they been willing to convert Haman would have done them nothing, his decree being only on Jews, as the Chassidic discourses on Purim explain. Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) this is the force of “also” in this paragraph’s „הגלות שהיה ג״כ גופני” (“the exile, which was also bodily”): Purim reached body and soul together, Chanukah the soul alone.
The Alter Rebbe
בפורים ימי משתה ושמחה כנגד הגלות שהיה ג״כ גופני
The Rebbe
ידוע אשר בפורים הי׳ נס בהצלת הגוף והנפש גם יחד (משא״כ בחנוכה שלא היתה אלא הצלה מגלות רוחני
Igros Kodesh, vol. ב, p. קז · שושן פורים תש״ו
- ¶3
A question the Rebbe raises
Answering a correspondent who asked for the source of this paragraph’s statement (and Likkutei Torah Behaaloscha’s) that „אהרן הוא מז׳ רועים” (Aharon is one of the seven shepherds), although the Talmud’s list in Sukkah 52b leaves him out, the Rebbe gives the sources and then raises a further difficulty he calls „והוא העיקר” (“the main one”).
After citing the Zohar Chadash for Aharon, the Rebbe asks: Torah Ohr and Likkutei Torah explain the seven shepherds as those „שמשפיעים אלקותו לכנס״י” (who bestow G‑dliness on the Congregation of Israel), as this paragraph does, so „מה ענין שת ומתושלח בזה” (what have Shes and Mesushelach, who are in the Talmud’s list, to do with that)? He suggests the two lists follow the Tzemach Tzedek’s two readings of “we shall raise up against him seven shepherds” (Michah 5:4), against Ashur (the Talmud) or over Israel (the Zohar Chadash). But TO 33d and the Tzemach Tzedek’s Sefer HaMitzvos copy the Talmud’s list and still explain the shepherds this way, and he leaves it „ועצ״ע” (“requiring further study”).
The Alter Rebbe
דהנה אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא הוא אהרן כהן לאל עליון משבע׳ רועים המפרנסים ומשפיעים אלהותו ית׳ בכנסת ישראל
The Rebbe
והנה עוד יש להקשות בזה, והוא העיקר . . ואינו מובן כלל מה ענין שת ומתושלח בזה
Igros Kodesh, vol. יח, p. תקנג · ימי הסליחות תשי״ט
- ¶3
Background from the Rebbe
In his letter for Motzaei Shabbos Behaaloscha 5724, drawing hints from „בהעלותך את הנרות” (“when you kindle the lamps”), the Rebbe writes of lighting every Jewish soul, even one who for now is „נדח” (“driven away”).
Blessing each Jew to do all this in all his affairs, so that „יאירו אל מול פני המנורה” (they shine toward the face of the Menorah), even those who for now are “driven away”, the Rebbe asks that it be done „ברעותא דלבא, אופן עבודת אהרן, ובחי׳ אהרן שבכל אחד, שהרי אהרן הוא משבעה הרועים” (“with the will of the heart, in the manner of Aharon’s service, and the Aharon in each person, for Aharon is one of the seven shepherds”), and his note to those words cites this paragraph. In a letter of Rosh Chodesh Tammuz 5722 (Igros Kodesh 22 p. רס) his note adds that every soul has in it something of the seven shepherds (Tanya ch. 42). Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) this is the inner side of this paragraph: the supernal Aharon who kindles Israel’s love has a counterpart in every Jew.
The Alter Rebbe
דהנה אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא הוא אהרן כהן לאל עליון משבע׳ רועים
The Rebbe
ויעשה זה ברעותא דלבא, אופן עבודת אהרן, ובחי׳ אהרן שבכל אחד, שהרי אהרן הוא משבעה הרועים
Igros Kodesh, vol. כג, p. רט–רי · מוצש״ק פרשת בהעלותך ה׳תשכ״ד
Short quotes only, with the place of each so it can be read in full. The Rebbe’s sichos, letters and maamarim are published by Kehot and by Vaad Hanochos B’Lahak (lahak.org).
Why Chanukah is kept with lights ¶1
1ענין חנוכה.1 הנה קבעו הנס בנרות.2 משא״כ בשאר נסים בפסח ביציאת מצרים תאכלו מצות בפורים ימי משתה ושמחה3 כנגד הגלות שהיה ג״כ גופני במצרים בחומר ובלבנים4 ובימי המן בקש להשמיד כו׳ ושללם לבוז5
The subject of Chanukah. Now, [the Sages] established [the commemoration of] the miracle with lights. This is not so with the other miracles: on Pesach, [commemorating] the Exodus from Egypt, “you shall eat matzos”; on Purim, “days of feasting and joy” — corresponding to the exile, which was also physical: in Egypt, “with mortar and with bricks”; and in the days of Haman, he sought “to destroy…” and “to take their spoil for plunder.”
The maamar opens by noting that each festival commemorates its miracle in a fitting way. Pesach and Purim are marked with eating and feasting, because those exiles threatened the Jews’ bodies: slavery in Egypt, and Haman’s decree to destroy them and plunder their property. Several manuscripts, the Kehot note records, date the maamar to Shabbos Chanukah 5560 (1799).
משא״כ בחנוכה6 שהיו ישראל שרוים על אדמתם ולא גלו מארצם רק גלות התורה7 להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם חוקי רצונך לפיכך קבעו בנרות על שם הפסוק (משלי ו) כי נר מצוה ותורה אור8 ודרך9 חיים תוכחות מוסר.
This is not so with Chanukah, when Israel dwelt on their own land and were not exiled from their country; there was only an exile of the Torah, “to make them forget Your Torah and to make them transgress the statutes of Your will.” Therefore [the Sages] established [the commemoration] with lights, on account of the verse (Proverbs 6), “For a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light, and the reproofs of discipline are the way of life.”
Under the Greek decrees Israel was not driven from its land, and its exile was not a bodily one like the slavery in Egypt or Haman’s decree; it was an exile of the Torah, aimed at making Jews forget it and abandon its laws. So the rescue is marked with lights, since the verse in Proverbs calls a mitzvah a lamp and the Torah light. A Kehot note brings the Rebbe’s answer to why the victory in battle is not what is commemorated: the war itself was over the lights, the lamp of the soul and the lamp of the mitzvah.
ולהבין ענין פסוק זה וגם סיפא דקרא דכתיב ודרך חיים וגו׳. צריך ביאור איזה דרך חיים הוא מלבד התורה והמצות האמורה למעלה בפסוק.
And [we need] to understand the meaning of this verse, and also the end of the verse, where it is written, “and the way of life…”. It requires explanation: what “way of life” is there besides the Torah and the mitzvos mentioned earlier in the verse?
The Alter Rebbe raises a question on the rest of the verse. If the lamp is the mitzvah and the light is the Torah, what further “way of life” does the verse add? The maamar as printed does not return to this question.
The paragraph explains why Chanukah is kept with lights rather than with a meal: the Greek oppression was spiritual, aimed at Torah and mitzvos, which the verse calls lamp and light. It then asks what the verse means by the “way of life” it adds.
Kehot’s note cites the Rebbe’s observation that Chanukah also had the military victory, the “mighty delivered into the hands of the weak”; he concludes that the war itself was about the lights, the lamp of the soul and the lamp of the mitzvah.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In an edited sicha on Parshas Mikeitz (from talks of Shabbos Mikeitz 5741 and Shabbos Eikev 5728), explaining the brothers’ confession “we are guilty” and Reuven’s reply, the Rebbe shows that true teshuvah comes from a person’s own free choice (בחירה חפשית), where „אין מי שמעכב על ידו” (“none can stop him”), and then ties this to Chanukah, part of which always falls in the week of Mikeitz.
This paragraph ends with a question the maamar never answers: what “way of life” does the verse add beyond the mitzvah (the lamp) and the Torah (the light)? The Rebbe quotes the question word for word and answers, sending the reader to the Mitteler Rebbe’s Shaarei Orah, that „ודרך חיים תוכחות מוסר” (“the way of life, the reproofs of discipline”) is the service of teshuvah: „על ידי תשובה שלימה מעומק הלב מתגלים חיים מפנימיות הנשמה” (complete return from the depth of the heart reveals life from the inwardness of the soul), which is bound up with G‑d. The Chanukah lights hold this too, for they are „האור הבא מתוך החושך דוקא” (light that comes out of darkness), kindled by the Hasmoneans’ self-sacrifice, which rose from that inwardness and is higher than „נר מצוה ותורה אור” (“a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light”).
The Alter Rebbe
ולהבין ענין פסוק זה וגם סיפא דקרא דכתיב ודרך חיים וגו׳. צריך ביאור איזה דרך חיים הוא מלבד התורה והמצות
The Rebbe
אלא ש״דרך חיים” קאי על עבודת התשובה . . שעל ידי תשובה שלימה מעומק הלב מתגלים חיים מפנימיות הנשמה
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ל, p. 203 · משיחות ש״פ מקץ תשמ״א, ש״פ עקב תשכ״ח
The Rebbe explainsThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
In an edited Chanukah sicha (from Shabbos Mikeitz–Chanukah 5726 and 5734) that asks why Al HaNissim never mentions the oil while the Gemara’s „מאי חנוכה” (“What is Chanukah?”) never mentions the war, the Rebbe starts from the known question why the festival was fixed on the oil and not on the victory.
The Rebbe first gives the known answer, listing this maamar among its sources: the main Greek decree was not against Jewish bodies but against the religion, so the commemoration was fixed on the oil, a miracle tied to the Temple lamps, which allude to all of Torah and mitzvos, „נר מצוה ותורה אור” (“a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light”). He then adds why light in particular: of all created things light is „הכי רוחני” (the most spiritual), less caught in matter than sound or smell, so spiritual things are named “light” and the Menorah’s light is a vessel for the light of the Shechinah (אור השכינה). Once that spiritual light shone, the physical victory, though it came first and made the lights possible, has no standing beside it.
The Alter Rebbe
לפיכך קבעו בנרות על שם הפסוק (משלי ו) כי נר מצוה ותורה אור
The Rebbe
ומהאי טעמא ווערט רוחניות באַצייכנט מיטן נאָמען אור — ווייל צווישן אַלע דברים גשמיים שבעולם, איז אור דער נברא הכי רוחני
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כה, p. 237–241 · משיחות ש״פ מקץ, שבת חנוכה – תשכ״ו, תשל״ד
The Rebbe explains
In the maamar he said on Motzaei Shabbos Vayeishev, the night of Erev Chanukah 5739 (an unedited transcript), the Rebbe opens with this maamar’s question: why was the Chanukah miracle fixed in lights, „שהו״ע רוחני” (a spiritual thing), and not in feasting like Purim and the festivals?
The Rebbe sets out the Alter Rebbe’s answer in his own words: Purim and Pesach were bodily rescues, so they, and the festivals bound up with the Exodus, are kept with feasting, while on Chanukah Israel dwelt on its land, the Temple stood, and „היונים לא רצו לנגוע בגופם של ישראל” (the Greeks did not want to touch Jewish bodies). He adds a precision “explained in many places” (the editors point to maamarim of the Rebbe Rayatz) in „להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם מחוקי רצונך” (“to make them forget Your Torah and transgress the statutes of Your will”): the Greeks did not forbid studying Torah or doing mitzvos, only studying Torah as G‑d’s Torah and keeping the statutes as „רצון ה׳ שלמעלה מהטעם” (His will, above reason). So the decree was spiritual even within Torah and mitzvos, and it is answered with lights, a spiritual thing.
The Alter Rebbe
משא״כ בחנוכה שהיו ישראל שרוים על אדמתם ולא גלו מארצם רק גלות התורה
The Rebbe
שגזירת היונים לא היתה שלא ילמדו תורה ושלא יקיימו את המצוות כ״א להשכיח ח״ו את ישראל שהתורה היא תורתך
Sefer HaMaamarim 5739 (unedited), vol. תשל״ט, p. נז–נח · מוצאי ש״פ וישב, מבה״ח טבת, אור לערב חנוכה ה׳תשל״ט
The Rebbe explains
In his notes for Chanukah 5696 in Paris (part of them said in a synagogue there), the Rebbe goes phrase by phrase through the Gemara’s „מאי חנוכה” (“What is Chanukah?”), which he reads as a dilemma: if the festival marks the oil it should have been called the festival of lights, and if it marks the victory it should be kept with feasting, as Purim is.
In his notes for Chanukah 5696 the Rebbe answers this paragraph’s question, why lights and not feasting as on Purim, with its reason in its own terms, and matches the halves: the Sages instituted „נר ואור” (“lamp and light”) on account of „להשכיחם תורתך” (“to make them forget Your Torah”), answered by “the Torah is light”, and „ולהעבירם” (“to make them transgress…”), answered by „נר מצוה” (“a mitzvah is a lamp”). So each half of the verse the Alter Rebbe quotes stands against one half of the decree he cites.
The Alter Rebbe
להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם חוקי רצונך לפיכך קבעו בנרות על שם הפסוק (משלי ו) כי נר מצוה ותורה אור
The Rebbe
תקנו נר ואור. ע״ש להשכיחם תורתך, תו״א, ולהעבירם וכו׳, נר מצוה.
Reshimos, vol. חוברת קכה, p. 8 · חנוכה תרצ״ו (Paris)
A question the Rebbe raisesThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
The Rebbe’s general letter for Chanukah 5731 opens with this maamar’s own words, "ענין חנוכה — קבעו הנס בנרות" (his note: „ראה ד״ה זה בתורה אור”, “see this dibbur hamaschil in Torah Ohr”), and in a note on those words he raises a difficulty with them.
The letter for Chanukah 5731 opens with this maamar’s words, “the subject of Chanukah: they fixed the miracle in lights”, and in his note to them the Rebbe asks: Chanukah also had the miracle of the victory, „מסרת גבורים ביד חלשים” (“You delivered the mighty into the hands of the weak”); without it there could have been no miracle of the lights, and even without the lights the victory alone would have redeemed Israel from the Greek exile. He concludes that the war itself must have been over the lights, „נר הנשמה ונר מצוה” (the lamp of the soul and the lamp of the mitzvah). In a talk to the children of Tzivos Hashem on 25 Kislev 5741 (Likkutei Sichos 20 p. 463, note 38) he grounds this in this paragraph’s own reason: the war and the victory were mainly spiritual, „להשכיחם תורתך” (“to make them forget Your Torah”), and so they too concerned the lights.
The Alter Rebbe
ענין חנוכה. הנה קבעו הנס בנרות. משא״כ בשאר נסים
The Rebbe
והרי בחנוכה הי׳ גם הנס דמסרת גבורים ביד חלשים כו׳ ובלעדו א״א נס הנרות
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ה, p. 445 · ימי חנוכה ה׳תשל״א (letter)
Background from the Rebbe
In a talk of Shabbos Chanukah 5725 on what joins 19 Kislev and Chanukah, both bound up with tzedakah, a note sources the duty of kindness („גמ״ח בממון וגוף”) on Chanukah in the Pri Megadim and draws from his words an answer to why Chanukah seemed to have nothing against the Greeks’ seizing of Jewish property; then, from the Rebbe’s own reshimah, it sets every Greek deed in Rambam’s list against its reversal in Chanukah.
Rambam opens the Laws of Chanukah with the list of what the Greeks did. The Rebbe’s note sets against each item its reversal among the Chanukah observances: against their decrees („גזרו גזירות”), Hallel, „שענינו חירות” (whose theme is freedom); against „בטלו דתם” (“they abolished their religion”), thanksgiving; against „ולא הניחו אותם לעסוק בתורה ובמצות” (“they did not let them engage in Torah and mitzvos”), the lights, “because of the verse ‘for a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light’”, citing this maamar; against their hand on Jewish property and daughters, tzedakah and the women’s duty to light; against the breached and defiled Heichal, „באו בניך לדביר ביתך” (“Your children came to the Sanctuary of Your House…”) and „וטהרו את מקדשך” (“and purified Your Temple”). So this paragraph’s reason for the lights is one line in a complete reversal of the decree.
The Alter Rebbe
רק גלות התורה להשכיחם תורתך ולהעבירם חוקי רצונך לפיכך קבעו בנרות
The Rebbe
ולא הניחו אותם לעסוק בתומ״צ (שלכן קבעו הנס בנרות, ע״ש הפסוק כי נר מצוה ותו״א. תו״א רד״ה ענין חנוכה)
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ה, p. 443 · שבת חנוכה ה׳תשכ״ה (note 15, marked "רשימת כ״ק אדמו״ר שליט״א")
Background from the Rebbe
In an edited sicha on why the last day is called “Zos Chanukah” (from Shabbos Mikeitz 5733 and 5740), the Rebbe contrasts Purim, whose miracle came while there were prophets, with Chanukah, which came wholly from Israel below.
Citing this paragraph in his note 52, the Rebbe restates its contrast: the Purim decree was against Jewish bodies, as the Levush puts it („שהיתה הגזירה להרוג ולהשמיד את הגופות”), while on Chanukah the religion was abolished, a spiritual darkness in which the light of Torah, „נר מצוה ותורה אור” (“a mitzvah is a lamp and the Torah is light”), did not shine openly, „גלות התורה” (“the exile of the Torah”). From this he draws, with the distinction the Mitteler Rebbe makes in the introduction to Shaarei Orah (his note 54: on Purim the self-sacrifice came from the side of the giver, on Chanukah „מצד המקבל” (from the side of the receiver)), that on Chanukah the self-sacrifice came wholly from Israel, the receivers, with no prophets as there were in the days of Mordechai and Esther, so the festival came by the Sages’ enactment, and its lights are the receiver lighting up the darkness.
The Alter Rebbe
שהיו ישראל שרוים על אדמתם ולא גלו מארצם רק גלות התורה
The Rebbe
ס׳איז געווען אַ מצב פון חשך רוחני, ווען דער אור התורה (נר מצוה ותורה אור) האָט ניט מאיר געווען בגלוי, ”גלות התורה”
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כה, p. 249 · משיחות ש״פ מקץ תשל״ג, תש״מ
Background from the Rebbe
In a letter of Shushan Purim 5706, sent with the newly printed Toras Shalom (the Rebbe Rashab’s sichos), the Rebbe explains in Chassidus why Purim requires „שתי מנות לאיש אחד ומתנות לאביונים שתי מתנות לשני בני אדם” (two portions to one friend and gifts to two poor people), and begins from the difference between the Purim and Chanukah rescues.
Citing this maamar, and the Levush brought in the Taz, the Rebbe writes that the Purim miracle rescued „הגוף והנפש גם יחד” (body and soul together), while Chanukah was only „הצלה מגלות רוחני” (a rescue from a spiritual exile). Israel earned the Purim rescue by self-sacrifice, cleaving to G‑d „בבחי׳ רצון פשוט שלמעלה מהשכל והשגה” (with a simple will above reason), for had they been willing to convert Haman would have done them nothing, his decree being only on Jews, as the Chassidic discourses on Purim explain. Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) this is the force of “also” in this paragraph’s „הגלות שהיה ג״כ גופני” (“the exile, which was also bodily”): Purim reached body and soul together, Chanukah the soul alone.
The Alter Rebbe
בפורים ימי משתה ושמחה כנגד הגלות שהיה ג״כ גופני
The Rebbe
ידוע אשר בפורים הי׳ נס בהצלת הגוף והנפש גם יחד (משא״כ בחנוכה שלא היתה אלא הצלה מגלות רוחני
Igros Kodesh, vol. ב, p. קז · שושן פורים תש״ו
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה מאי חנוכה דת״ר בכ״ה בכסליו, 5747
The Alter Rebbe asks why Chanukah is marked with lights rather than with eating, as on Pesach and Purim. He answers that the Greek decree was an “exile of the Torah,” not a bodily one. The Rebbe sharpens the question from a different side. Al HaNissim puts the stress on the war, and other Temple miracles were never given a commemoration. He concludes that the commemoration of the oil miracle was established because it is connected with the victory in the war against the Greeks.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה קבעו הנס בנרות. משא״כ בשאר נסים
The Rebbe
מדוע קבעו זכרון הנס בנרות. דהרי עיקר הנס הוא נצחון המלחמה
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsNer mitzvahChinuchSimchah+2
- Ner mitzvah נר מצוה
- Chinuch חינוך
- Simchah שמחה
Marei mekomos
- 1ענין חנוכה · ראה לעיל בציונים לכ״ק אדמו״ר זי״ע. בכמה כת״י מצוין ”שבת חנוכה תק״ס”. ראה ברשימת המאמרים שבסו״ס מאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ תרכד הערה 159. לכללות המאמר ראה אוה״ת בראשית כרך ז ע׳ תתתא, ב ואילך. נ״ך כרך א ע׳ תקעו.
- 2קבעו הנס בנרות · והרי בחנוכה הי׳ גם הנס דמסרת גבורים ביד חלשים כו׳ ובלעדו א״א נס הנרות (אבל גם לולא נס הנרות — הי׳ נגאלים מגלות יון ע״י הנס דמסרת) — ועכצ״ל שגם המלחמה היתה בענין הנרות (נר הנשמה ונר המצוה). — (ממכתב כ״ק אדמו״ר זי״ע ימי החנוכה תשל״א) לקו״ש ח״ה ע׳ 445. ראה אוה״ת בראשית כרך ה תתקסו, ב. ובכרך ז תתקס, א בהקושיא למה קבעו בנרות הלל והודאה ולא במשתה ושמחה כמו ביו״ט. וראה שם תתתמ, ב. ובד״ה מאי חנוכה תשמ״ז. דהרי עיקר הנס הוא נצחון המלחמה וכנוסח תפלת על הנסים ובפרט לפי הנוסח ”ועל המלחמות”. ראה פלח הרמון בראשית ק, א. בלקו״ת קרח נד, ד מציין לד״ה זה בענין שמעשה המצות נק׳ נר מצוה.
- 3
- 4בחומר ובלבנים · Exodus 1:14
- 5ושללם לבוז · Esther 8:11
- 6שו״ה להשמיד — משא״כ בחנוכה · בבוך 167 נוסף: בגלות יוון.
- 7שו״ה אדמתם — התורה · בבוך 167 הנ״ל נוסף: שרצו.
- 8לפיכך קבעו בנרות על שם הפסוק . . כי נר מצוה ותורה אור · Shabbat 23b
- 9
The mitzvah as oil; tending and kindling the Menorah ¶2
2והענין כי מה שהמשיל המצוה לנר1 והתורה לאור הוא מובן שכמו שהנר נקרא על שם השמן2 כלשון רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] נר של שמן נר של שעוה.
The explanation is this. That [the verse] likens the mitzvah to a lamp and the Torah to light is understood: just as the lamp is named after the oil, as in the language of our Sages, of blessed memory, “a lamp of oil, a lamp of wax,”
The verse likens the mitzvah to a lamp, and the Alter Rebbe explains why. In the Sages’ language a lamp is named after its fuel (“a lamp of oil, a lamp of wax”), so “lamp” means the fuel. A later maamar in Torah Ohr (Miketz 38b) names the lamp after the wick instead, since the wick joins the light to the oil; Sefer HaMaamarim 5643, cited in the Kehot note, says both readings have one intent.
הנה אע״פ [אף על פי] שהשמן אין בו אור מצד עצמו ואדרבה הוא מכבה את אור הנופל לתוכו מ״מ ממנו ועל ידו נמשך להב שלהבת האור הנאחז בפתילה במעט שמן הנמשך אחר הפתילה
then, although the oil has no light of its own, and on the contrary, it extinguishes a light that falls into it, nevertheless from it and through it is drawn the blaze of the flame of light that takes hold on the wick, by the little oil that is drawn up after the wick.
Oil gives no light of itself; pour it on a flame and it puts the flame out. Yet it is from the oil, and through it, that the flame holding on the wick burns, fed by the little oil drawn up the wick.
שהרי בכלות השמן נכבה האור.
For indeed, when the oil runs out, the light goes out.
The proof is that when the oil is gone the flame dies: the light depends on the oil.
ככה ממש היא המצוה הגם שהוא רצון המלך בלי שום טעם ודעת ואין בה שום השגה מ״מ ממנה ועל ידה נמשך ונתגלה אור החכמה
Exactly so is the mitzvah: although it is the will of the King, without any reason or understanding, and there is no comprehension in it at all, nevertheless from it and through it the light of Chochmah is drawn down and revealed.
The mitzvah is like the oil. It is the King’s will, with no reason in it that the mind can grasp, yet from it and through it the light of Chochmah is drawn down and revealed.
זו תורה שבע״פ [שבעל פה] דאורייתא מחכמה נפקת3 והחכמה והבנה בתורה שבעל פה הוא רק להבין ולהשיג פי׳ וטעם המצות כל מסכת לפי ענינה.
This is the Oral Torah, for “the Torah issues from Chochmah”; and the Chochmah and understanding in the Oral Torah are only to understand and comprehend the explanation and reason of the mitzvos, each tractate according to its subject.
That light is the Oral Torah, for the Zohar says “the Torah issues from Chochmah,” and the whole wisdom of the Oral Torah is to explain the reasons of the mitzvos, each tractate of the Talmud those of its own subject. So the “light” of Torah is drawn from the “lamp” of the mitzvah.
וביאור ענין זה דרך פרט בעבודת ה׳.
And [now for] the explanation of this matter in detail, in the service of G‑d.
The Alter Rebbe now turns to how this works in a person’s service of G‑d.
הנה כתיב (שמות ל) בבקר בבקר בהטיבו את הנרות יקטירנה4 ובהעלות5 אהרן את הנרות בין הערבים יקטירנה6. ולהבין למה גבי בבוקר כתיב בהטיבו7 ובבין הערבים בהעלות.
Now it is written (Exodus 30), “Every morning, when he tends (be-heitivo) the lamps, he shall burn it [the incense]; and when Aharon kindles (be-haalos) the lamps at dusk, he shall burn it.” We need to understand why regarding the morning it says “when he tends,” and regarding dusk “when he kindles.”
In the Torah’s command about the incense, the morning service of the lamps, when the priest cleaned them and set them in order, is called hetavah, “tending” or “making good”, and the evening service, when he lit them, haalaah, “raising up” or “kindling”. The question is why the two times are described with different verbs.
¶9 Hold this question about tending and kindling: paragraph 9 answers it.
הנה כנסת ישראל מקור נשמות ישראל נקרא׳ [נקראת] בשם מנורה והיא מקשה שכל ישראל הם באחדות והיא מתחלקת לשבעה נרות.
Now, the Congregation of Israel, the source of the souls of Israel, is called by the name “Menorah.” It is [made] of one hammered piece, for all Israel are in unity, and it divides into seven lamps.
The Congregation of Israel, the collective source of all Jewish souls, is the Menorah. The Menorah was hammered from a single piece of gold, which shows that all Jews are one; yet it branches into seven lamps.
כי דרך פרט יש ששים רבוא נצוצו׳ כלליי׳ שכל ניצוץ מתחלק לששים רבוא נצוצות פרטיות כמבואר בתניא8 ודרך כלל נכללו בשבעים נפש שירדו אבותינו למצרים.9
For in particular, there are six hundred thousand general sparks, each spark dividing into six hundred thousand particular sparks, as is explained in Tanya; and in general, they are included in the seventy souls with which our forefathers went down to Egypt.
Souls divide into 600,000 general sparks, each subdividing into 600,000 particular ones. More generally they are contained in the seventy souls of Yaakov’s family who went down to Egypt.
The paragraph explains the lamp-and-light image: the mitzvah is like oil, dark in itself, yet the source of the light of Torah wisdom. It then opens the question of the Menorah’s morning tending and evening kindling, and introduces the Menorah as the collective soul of Israel.
Torah Ohr later in Miketz (38b) gives a different emphasis, naming the lamp after the wick, which joins the light to the oil. Both readings keep the point that the light cannot shine without the fuel of the mitzvah.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה מאי חנוכה דת״ר בכ״ה בכסליו, 5747
In the Alter Rebbe’s maamar the lamp image is built on one contrast: dark oil (the mitzvah) produces light (the wisdom of the Oral Torah). The Rebbe widens the image to four elements: oil, wick, white flame and dark flame. He applies it to the soul as well (“ner Havayah nishmas adam”) and matches the four elements to the four letters of Havayah given at Sinai.
The Alter Rebbe
כמו שהנר נקרא על שם השמן
The Rebbe
וכשם שבנר יש ד׳ ענינים, השמן והפתילה והאור שיש בו ב׳ גונים
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה מאי חנוכה דת״ר בכ״ה בכסליו, 5747
For the Alter Rebbe, the mitzvah being above reason is what makes it like oil, the source of the light. The Rebbe, drawing on the related Chanukah discourses, names what joins oil and flame: mesirus nefesh, “na’aseh before nishma,” a service beyond measure. He adds that this must be the soul’s constant state, not only the moment of doing a mitzvah. He illustrates it with Shemitah, where both refraining from work and sowing itself demand faith beyond reason.
The Alter Rebbe
הגם שהוא רצון המלך בלי שום טעם ודעת ואין בה שום השגה
The Rebbe
וי״ל הכוונה בזה שזהו לא רק בשעת קיום המצוות אלא שכ״ה דרגת הנפש כל היום
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
TermsNer mitzvahKlos hanefeshAchdus HashemRapach nitzotzin+11
- Ner mitzvah נר מצוה explained hereHere, the lamp is named for its oil: the mitzvah, like oil, has no light, being the King’s will beyond reason, yet through it Chochmah, the Oral Torah, shines.
שכמו שהנר נקרא על שם השמן כלשון רז״ל נר של שמן נר של שעוה
- Klos hanefesh כלות הנפש
- Achdus Hashem אחדות השם
- Rapach nitzotzin רפ״ח ניצוצין
- Knesses Yisrael כנסת ישראל
- Torah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al peh תורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה
- Hasagah השגה
- Avodas Hashem עבודת ה׳
- Daas דעת
- Binah בינה
- Ratzon רצון
Marei mekomos
- 1מה שהמשיל המצוה לנר · ראה באוה״ת נ״ך משלי ע׳ תקעו.
- 2שהנר נקרא על שם השמן · מובא באוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ תקעו. ראה לקמן לח, ב: ענין הנר הוא שקרוי ע״ש הפתילה כי הוא עיקר הנר. — וראה ד״ה ענין חנוכה סה״מ תרמ״ג ע׳ לו שיש בנר ב׳ פי׳ ושניהם הם כוונה אחת. ע״ש.
- 3דאורייתא מחכמה נפקת · Zohar II, 121a
- 4בבקר בבקר בהטיבו את הנרות יקטירנה · Exodus 30:7
- 5שו״ה בהטיבו — ובהעלות · בבוך 167 הנ״ל: וכתיב ובהעלות.
- 6
- 7גבי בבוקר כתיב בהטיבו . . בהעלותך · Song of Songs 5:4
- 8כמבואר בתניא · פרק לז. [בבוך 167 הנ״ל: בלק״א].
- 9בשבעים נפש שירדו אבותינו למצרים · Deuteronomy 10:22
Aharon and the love from above ¶3–4
3וכלל מן הכלל נק׳ בשם שבעה נרות דהנה אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא123 הוא אהרן כהן לאל עליון4 משבע׳ רועים56 המפרנסים ומשפיעים אלהותו ית׳ בכנסת ישראל שיאירו באור האהבה להתלהט אליו ית׳
And the most general [division] of the general is called by the name “seven lamps.” For Aharon, “the groomsman of the Queen (Matronita),” is “Aharon, priest of G‑d Most High,” one of the seven shepherds who sustain and bestow His G‑dliness, may He be blessed, upon the Congregation of Israel, so that they shine with the light of love, to blaze up toward Him, may He be blessed,
The seventy souls are gathered, most generally, into seven lamps, which correspond to the seven “shepherds” who channel G‑dliness to the Jewish people. Aharon, called in the Zohar the “groomsman of the Queen (Matronita),” who brings the bride, the Shechinah with the Congregation of Israel, to the King, is one of them, and his task is to make them shine with love that blazes up toward G‑d. The Talmud’s list of seven shepherds (Sukkah 52b) does not name Aharon; the Rebbe, in a letter cited in the Kehot note, finds the source in the Zohar Chadash, which lists Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, Adam, Aharon, David and Shlomo.
בכלות הנפש כשלהבת העולה מאליה7 ולקיים מצות ואהבת8 שמקבלים עליהם בק״ש [בקריאת שמע] שיהי׳ [שיהיה] כך באמת לאמתו תקוע בלב כל אחד ואחד מישראל שהאדם מצד עצמו מאחר שהוא מגושם ומלובש בענינים גשמיים לא היה יכול לולי הקב״ה עוזרו.9
with the expiring of the soul, like a flame that rises of itself; and to fulfill the mitzvah of “You shall love,” which they take upon themselves in the Shema, so that it be so in utmost truth, fixed in the heart of each and every one of Israel. For a person on his own, since he is corporeal and clothed in physical matters, would not be able [to do so] were it not that the Holy One, blessed be He, helps him.
The love blazes “with the expiring of the soul” (kelos ha-nefesh), a longing so strong that the soul would leave itself for G‑d, like the flame “that rises of itself,” the Sages’ standard for kindling the Menorah. Every Jew accepts the command to love G‑d in the Shema, but a person clothed in a physical body could not truly feel it without G‑d’s help. The wording echoes the Talmud (Kiddushin 30b), where Rabbi Shimon ben Levi teaches that a person’s evil inclination grows stronger against him every day and seeks to kill him, and that were it not for the help of the Holy One, blessed be He, he could not withstand it. The maamar applies the same dependence on G‑d’s help to the positive task of true love, preparing its answer that the power to kindle this love is itself G‑d’s gift.
The paragraph identifies the seven lamps with the seven shepherds, and above all with Aharon, whose role is to kindle love of G‑d in Israel’s souls. It adds that such love is beyond a physical person’s own power without G‑d’s help.
The Rebbe’s letter cited in the notes discusses why Aharon is counted among the seven shepherds though the Talmud’s list omits him. He finds the source in the Zohar Chadash, which lists Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, Adam, Aharon, David and Shlomo.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
A question the Rebbe raises
Answering a correspondent who asked for the source of this paragraph’s statement (and Likkutei Torah Behaaloscha’s) that „אהרן הוא מז׳ רועים” (Aharon is one of the seven shepherds), although the Talmud’s list in Sukkah 52b leaves him out, the Rebbe gives the sources and then raises a further difficulty he calls „והוא העיקר” (“the main one”).
After citing the Zohar Chadash for Aharon, the Rebbe asks: Torah Ohr and Likkutei Torah explain the seven shepherds as those „שמשפיעים אלקותו לכנס״י” (who bestow G‑dliness on the Congregation of Israel), as this paragraph does, so „מה ענין שת ומתושלח בזה” (what have Shes and Mesushelach, who are in the Talmud’s list, to do with that)? He suggests the two lists follow the Tzemach Tzedek’s two readings of “we shall raise up against him seven shepherds” (Michah 5:4), against Ashur (the Talmud) or over Israel (the Zohar Chadash). But TO 33d and the Tzemach Tzedek’s Sefer HaMitzvos copy the Talmud’s list and still explain the shepherds this way, and he leaves it „ועצ״ע” (“requiring further study”).
The Alter Rebbe
דהנה אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא הוא אהרן כהן לאל עליון משבע׳ רועים המפרנסים ומשפיעים אלהותו ית׳ בכנסת ישראל
The Rebbe
והנה עוד יש להקשות בזה, והוא העיקר . . ואינו מובן כלל מה ענין שת ומתושלח בזה
Igros Kodesh, vol. יח, p. תקנג · ימי הסליחות תשי״ט
Background from the Rebbe
In his letter for Motzaei Shabbos Behaaloscha 5724, drawing hints from „בהעלותך את הנרות” (“when you kindle the lamps”), the Rebbe writes of lighting every Jewish soul, even one who for now is „נדח” (“driven away”).
Blessing each Jew to do all this in all his affairs, so that „יאירו אל מול פני המנורה” (they shine toward the face of the Menorah), even those who for now are “driven away”, the Rebbe asks that it be done „ברעותא דלבא, אופן עבודת אהרן, ובחי׳ אהרן שבכל אחד, שהרי אהרן הוא משבעה הרועים” (“with the will of the heart, in the manner of Aharon’s service, and the Aharon in each person, for Aharon is one of the seven shepherds”), and his note to those words cites this paragraph. In a letter of Rosh Chodesh Tammuz 5722 (Igros Kodesh 22 p. רס) his note adds that every soul has in it something of the seven shepherds (Tanya ch. 42). Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) this is the inner side of this paragraph: the supernal Aharon who kindles Israel’s love has a counterpart in every Jew.
The Alter Rebbe
דהנה אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא הוא אהרן כהן לאל עליון משבע׳ רועים
The Rebbe
ויעשה זה ברעותא דלבא, אופן עבודת אהרן, ובחי׳ אהרן שבכל אחד, שהרי אהרן הוא משבעה הרועים
Igros Kodesh, vol. כג, p. רט–רי · מוצש״ק פרשת בהעלותך ה׳תשכ״ד
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsShushvina dematronisaKlos hanefeshKnesses YisraelKrias Shema+2
- Shushvina dematronisa שושבינא דמטרוניתא
- Klos hanefesh כלות הנפש
- Knesses Yisrael כנסת ישראל
- Krias Shema קריאת שמע
Marei mekomos
- 1אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא · Zohar I, 266b
- 2אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא · Zohar, Addenda, Volume I 50:362–373
- 3אהרן שושבינא דמטרוניתא · Zohar, Vayikra 47:334–49:342
- 4כהן לאל עליון · Genesis 14:18
- 5אהרן . . משבעה רועים · ראה בלקו״ש ח״כ ע׳ 643 המקור לזה (ממכתב ימי הסליחות ה׳תשי״ט), וז״ל: לשאלתו המקור למש״כ בתו״א (לב, ב). ובלקו״ת בהעלותך (כט, ג) דאהרן הוא מז׳ רועים, דבסוכה (נב, ב) לא נזכר. וכהנ״ל הוא בעוד מקומות בתו״א — כמצוין במפתח. והמקור ע״ז י״ל בשנים: א) בז״ח (בסופו. תיקונים קד, א): קם רע״מ על רגלוי ואמר רעיין קדישין אברהם יצחק ויעקב ואדם קדמאה ואהרן ודוד ושלמה. ועפ״ז מתורץ ג״כ: 1) בתו״א (פב, א) — דאברהם הוא הרועה הראשון ובסוכה — אדה״ר. 2) בתו״א (לג, ג) משמע דגם יצחק בכלל הרועים. ב) בזח״ב (כו, ב): הוא (ל׳ יחיד) אהרן ומשה — לאכללא דא בדא. להעיר מתענית ט, א. וי״ל דלכן בהנ״ל לא נמנה רק א׳ מהם — העיקרי באותו ענין. וק״ל. והנה עוד יש להקשות בזה, והוא העיקר. בתו״א ולקו״ת מפרש ענין הז״ר שמשפיעים אלקות לכנס״י כו׳ ואינו מובן כלל מה ענין שת ומתושלח בזה? והנה הצ״צ עה״פ במיכה (ה, ד) מדייק דשני פי׳ בתיבת והקימונו: א) על אשור. ב) על בנ״י (כפי׳ התרגום) — ובדרך ממילא ינוצח אשור. ועפ״ז נ״ל ליישב כהנ״ל — דבסוכה הוא לפי פי׳ הא׳. ובז״ח ע״פ פי׳ הב׳. ולולא דמסתפינא הייתי אומר לבדוק בדפוסים הראשונים של הז״ח אולי צ״ל במקום אדה״ר — יוסף. וע״ד האושפיזין דחה״ס. אבל עומד לנגד ביאור זה מה שבתו״א (לג, ד) ובסהמ״צ להצ״צ מצות חנוכה מעתיק מסוכה הנ״ל ומפרש ענין הרועים כנ״ל. אבל יעוין שם שמביא מהז״ר רק אברהם יעקב ומשה. ועצ״ע. ואכ״מ.
- 6משבע׳ רועים · Sukkah 52b:13
- 7כשלהבת העולה מאליה · Shabbat 21a:9
- 8ואהבת · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 9לולי הקב״ה עוזרו · Kiddushin 30b
4והעזר הוא אהבה הבאה מלמעלה להמשיכו אליו. וזהו בחי׳ בהעלות ובהטיבו. כי הנה אמרו רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] אע״פ [אף על פי] שהאש יורד מן1 השמי׳ מצוה להביא מן ההדיוט.2
And the help is a love that comes from above, to draw him to Him. This is the level of “when he kindles” and “when he tends.” For our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “Although the fire comes down from heaven, it is a mitzvah to bring [fire] from an ordinary [source].”
G‑d’s help comes as a love sent from above that draws the person to Him; this is what the two verbs, “kindling” and “tending”, refer to. The Sages taught that although fire came down from heaven onto the altar, there is a mitzvah to bring ordinary fire as well.
פי׳ הדיוט3 הוא האהבה שאדם לוקח מחמת העולמות מבחי׳ מלכותו ית׳ שהוא מלך גדול ונורא על כל העולמות עליונים ותחתונים
Explanation: the “ordinary” [fire] is the love a person acquires on account of the worlds, from the level of His sovereignty, may He be blessed, that He is a great and awesome King over all the worlds, higher and lower.
The “ordinary” fire stands for the love a person generates himself, by contemplating G‑d’s sovereignty: He is the great and awesome King over all the worlds, higher and lower. Likkutei Torah, Shemini Atzeres, refers back to this maamar for this definition of the “ordinary” fire and contrasts it with the great love of “His right hand embraces me.”
וכל צבא השמים4 לך משתחוים ואלף אלפין ורבו רבבן קדמוהי5 כו׳ לב, גכמבואר בגמרא6 ובזוהר בביאור ענין רבוי העולמות וגדולתו.
And “all the host of heaven bow down to You,” and “a thousand thousands [serve Him] and ten thousand times ten thousand [stand] before Him…,” as explained in the Gemara and in the Zohar, in explaining the multitude of the worlds and His greatness.
Contemplating the vast number of worlds and hosts that bow before G‑d, as described in the Talmud and Zohar, brings a person to love Him. This is a love he can reach by his own effort.
The paragraph distinguishes two kinds of love, like the two fires on the altar: love from above, G‑d’s gift, and “ordinary” love that a person builds by contemplating G‑d’s kingship over countless worlds.
The heavenly fire and the fire brought by the priest correspond to an arousal from above and an arousal from below. Likkutei Torah on Shemini Atzeres refers back to this passage for the definition of the “ordinary” fire.
Marei mekomos
- 1אע״פ שהאש יורד מן השמים מצוה להביא מן ההדיוט · Eruvin 63a:15
- 2אע״פ שהאש יורד מן השמי׳ מצוה להביא מן ההדיוט · Mishneh Torah, Daily Offerings and Additional Offerings 2:1
- 3פי׳ הדיוט · בבוך 167 ליתא תי׳ ”הדיוט”.
- 4צבא השמים · Nehemiah 9:6
- 5ואלף אלפין ורבו רבבן קדמוהי · Daniel 7:10
- 6כמבואר בגמרא · Chagigah 12a
One and Singular: kingship as humility ¶5–8
5וע״ד זה תקנו חז״ל [חכמינו זכרונם לברכה] לומר בשכמל״ו [ברוך שם כבוד מלכותו לעולם ועד]12 לפני ואהבת. כי הנה אנו אומרים יחיד חי העולמים3 מלך משובח ומפואר עדי עד שמו הגדול כו׳. פי׳ יחיד הוא למעלה מבחי׳ אחד.
Along these lines our Sages, of blessed memory, instituted saying “Blessed be the name of the glory of His kingdom forever and ever” before “You shall love.” For we say, “Singular One, life of the worlds, King, praised and glorified forever and ever is His great Name….” Explanation: “Singular” (Yachid) is higher than the level of “One” (Echad).
The Sages instituted the silent line “Blessed be the name of the glory of His kingdom” before “You shall love” for the same reason: to prompt the love that comes from contemplating G‑d’s kingship. The morning prayer calls G‑d “Singular” (Yachid), which is higher than “One” (Echad).
כי אחד היינו כמאמר רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] שהוא אחד בשמים ובארץ4 ובד׳ רוחות העולם כי כל העולמות עליוני׳ [עליונים] אינם תופסים מקום להיות יש ודבר נפרד בפני עצמם וכולא קמי׳ [קמיה] כלא וכאין נגדו חשיבי ממש ואין עוד מלבדו.5
For “One” means, as our Sages, of blessed memory, said, that He is One in the heavens and on earth and in the four directions of the world; for all the higher worlds occupy no place [of their own], to be an entity and a thing separate in its own right, and “all before Him are as nothing,” and they are truly accounted as naught before Him, and there is nothing else besides Him.
“One” means that G‑d is one throughout heaven, earth and the four directions: the worlds exist, but they are nothing before Him and have no existence of their own. This is the unity of G‑d as it relates to creation.
לכן נקרא אחד והיינו כשמעריכין אותו נגד העולמות. אבל יחיד פי׳ הוא יחיד ומיוחד בפני עצמו והוא לבדו הוא ואינו בגדר העולמות כלל.
Therefore He is called “One,” and this is when He is measured against the worlds. But “Singular” means that He is singular and unique in Himself, He alone, and not within the category of worlds at all.
“One” still describes G‑d in relation to the worlds. “Singular” describes Him as He is in Himself, beyond any relation to worlds at all.
The paragraph links the blessing “Blessed be the name…” to the love born of contemplating G‑d’s kingship, and distinguishes “One”, G‑d’s unity in relation to the worlds, from “Singular”, G‑d as He is, beyond them.
“One” corresponds to the worlds’ self-nullification before G‑d, where they exist but are “as nothing”; “Singular” is beyond the worlds entirely. The next paragraph shows that kingship, life-force and praise all belong only to the “Name”, not to the essence.
TermsEchad and yachidKrias Shema
- Echad and yachid אחד ויחיד explained hereOn the words “Singular, Life of the worlds, King”: Yachid is above Echad. Echad means He is one in the heavens, on earth and in the four directions, since the worlds take up no place and are as nothing before Him; that is, when He is set against the worlds. Yachid means He is alone, singular in Himself, not in the category of worlds at all.
פי׳ יחיד הוא למעלה מבחי׳ אחד
- Krias Shema קריאת שמע
Marei mekomos
- 1תקנו חז״ל לומר בשכמל״ו · Pesachim 56a:8–9
- 2תקנו חז״ל לומר בשכמל״ו · Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chayim 61:13–14
- 3יחיד חי העולמים · ראה לקמן מ, ג.
- 4שהוא אחד בשמים ובארץ · Berakhot 13b:18
- 5ואין עוד מלבדו · Deuteronomy 4:35
6וחי העולמים מלך פי׳ שכל חיות העולמות שמחיה את כולם ומהווה את כולם עליונים ותחתונים אינו אלא בשביל שהוא מלך וכולם מקבלים חיות מבחי׳ מלכותו ית׳ בעבור היותו מלך עליהם.
And “life of the worlds, King” means that all the life-force of the worlds, by which He gives life to them all and brings them all into being, higher and lower, is only because He is King, and they all receive life-force from the level of His sovereignty, may He be blessed, because He is King over them.
“Life of the worlds, King” means that G‑d gives the worlds life and existence only as their King. Kingship is a relationship to others, so the life-force of all worlds comes from G‑d’s Malchus, not from His essence.
וכן מה שמשובח ומפואר דהיינו השבח מחמת שמשיגים גדולתו הוא עדי עד כי לגדולתו אין חקר1 ולמעלה יש שבח אחר שבח ועילוי אחר עילוי עד אין קץ ואין תכלית והכל הוא בעבור שמו הגדול
So too, that He is “praised and glorified” — that is, the praise [that comes] because they grasp His greatness — is “forever and ever,” for “His greatness is unsearchable,” and above there is praise after praise and elevation after elevation without end and without limit; and all this is because of “His great Name.”
The creatures’ praise of G‑d, based on how much of His greatness they grasp, never ends, since there is always a higher level to grasp. Yet all of it is praise of “His great Name”, not of Him.
כי להיות נקרא שמו ומלכותו עליהם בלבד הוא ואינו יכול לנגוע לבחי׳ עצמותו ומהותו כלל
For [all this is] only so that His Name and His sovereignty be called upon them; and it cannot touch the level of His essence and being at all,
The purpose of all this is that G‑d’s Name and kingship should rest upon the worlds. None of it reaches His essence; a later maamar in Torah Ohr (Miketz 40c) explains likewise that the worlds come from G‑d’s kingship, an outward radiance that does not touch the King Himself, and that “Blessed be the name” speaks of the level of a name alone.
כי לית מחשב׳ תפיס׳ [תפיסא] בי׳ [ביה] כלל2 שהוא יחיד ומיוחד ונשגב שמו לבדו3 כדכתיב מלכותך מלכות כל עולמים.4
for “no thought can grasp Him” at all, since He is singular and unique, and “His Name alone is exalted,” as it is written, “Your kingdom is a kingdom of all worlds.”
No thought can grasp G‑d, since He is singular and His Name alone is exalted. So the verse says “Your kingdom is a kingdom of all worlds”: His kingdom relates to the worlds, while He Himself is beyond them.
The paragraph explains the rest of the prayer’s words: the worlds’ life and all their praise come only from G‑d’s kingship and “Name”, which never reach His essence.
This follows the Chabad teaching that Malchus is only an outward radiance of G‑d, like a name or reputation, and that all the worlds are created from it.
TermsIbbur and leidahAtzmus u’mahusMalchus+1
- Ibbur and leidah עיבור ולידה
- Atzmus u’mahus עצמות ומהות
- Malchus מלכות
Also Chayus
Marei mekomos
- 1לגדולתו אין חקר · Psalms 145:3
- 2לית מחשב׳ תפיס׳ בי׳ כלל · Tikkunei Zohar 17a:10–12
- 3ונשגב שמו לבדו · Psalms 148:13
- 4מלכותך מלכות כל עולמים · Psalms 145:13
7וזהו במקום שאתה מוצא גדולתו1 שם אתה מוצא ענותנותו.2 כדכתיב המשפילי לראות3 בשמים ובארץ שאצלו ית׳ נחשב זאת להשפלה ולענוה להחיות רוח שפלים.4
This is [the meaning of] “In the place where you find His greatness, there you find His humility,” as it is written, “Who lowers Himself to look upon the heavens and the earth”: for to Him, may He be blessed, this is accounted a lowering and humility, “to revive the spirit of the lowly.”
The Sages taught that wherever G‑d’s greatness is mentioned, His humility is mentioned too. Even looking upon heaven and earth is, for G‑d, a lowering of Himself, done in order to give life to the lowly.
וכן מה שכתוב סומך נופלים ורופא חולים וזוקף כפופים5 וכל הממלכה נקרא בשם ארץ להיות כארץ הלזו השפלה6 שירדה ממקום כבודה להיות מלך שמו נקרא.7
So too what is written, “He supports the fallen, heals the sick and raises the bowed.” And the whole [level of] kingship is called by the name “earth,” being like this lowly earth: it has descended from its place of glory so that He be called by the name “King.”
G‑d’s kingship is called “earth,” the lowest level, because ruling the worlds is a descent from His glory: He lowers Himself so that “King is His name proclaimed,” as the hymn Adon Olam says. In Likkutei Torah, Bamidbar, the Alter Rebbe explains that Malchus is called “earth” as the lowest level, the one that relates to a people, and refers to this passage.
The paragraph shows that G‑d’s greatness over the worlds is really His humility: to be King and give life to creatures is a descent for Him.
Malchus is called “earth” because it is the lowest of the Sefiros and the source of the worlds; Likkutei Torah on Bamidbar refers to this maamar for that image.
Marei mekomos
- 1במקום שאתה מוצא גדולתו · נסמן לעיל לא, ד.
- 2במקום שאתה מוצא גדולתו שם אתה מוצא ענותנותו · Megillah 31a:12–13
- 3המשפילי לראות · Psalms 113:6
- 4להחיות רוח שפלים · Isaiah 57:15
- 5זוקף כפופים · Psalms 146:8
- 6להיות כארץ הלזו השפלה · ראה לקו״ת במדבר ה, ב. אוה״ת פ׳ לך לך תשכה, א.
- 7מלך שמו נקרא · פיוט אדון עולם.
8ולכן זאת יבין כל יציר בשומו אל לבו וירחיב דעתו בגדולתו ית׳ ונפלאות מעשיו ברבוי העולמות עד אין חקר הנה ישכיל שזהו ענותנותו ית׳ ואין ערוך אליו שאינו בגדר עלמין כלל.
Therefore every creature will understand this: when he takes it to heart and broadens his mind in His greatness, may He be blessed, and the wonders of His works in the multitude of the worlds without limit, he will grasp that this is His humility, may He be blessed, and there is no comparison to Him, for He is not within the category of worlds at all.
Anyone who reflects deeply on G‑d’s greatness in the countless worlds will realize that all of it is only His humility. G‑d Himself cannot be compared to it at all, since He is beyond the worlds entirely.
The paragraph draws the conclusion for the person contemplating: the vastness of creation reveals only G‑d’s humility, and He Himself is beyond comparison with the worlds.
Kindling, tending, and the mitzvos ¶9
9והוא השוה ומשוה קטן וגדול ממילא תתלהט ותתלהב נפש ולב לאור באור האהבה בכל נפשך1 ממש לצאת מגדר העולמות כמ״ש מי לי בשמים ועמך לא חפצתי בארץ2 כלה שארי ולבבי.3
And He is “the One Who is equal and makes equal small and great.” As a result, the soul and heart will blaze and flame up to shine with the light of love, “with all your soul” in truth, to go out of the confines of the worlds, as it is written, “Whom do I have in heaven [but You]? And besides You I desire nothing on earth; my flesh and my heart yearn.”
G‑d is “the One Who is equal and makes equal small and great” (a line of the High Holiday prayers), so the person who realizes that all the worlds are only His humility will want to leave their confines altogether, loving “with all your soul.” This is the Psalmist’s cry, wanting nothing in heaven or on earth but G‑d until “my flesh and my heart yearn (kalah),” the same word as the soul’s “expiring” (kelos ha-nefesh) in paragraph 3.
וזהו ואהבת את ה׳ אלקיך כי אהבה משרש אבה שהוא מלשון חפץ ורצון.4
This is [the meaning of] “You shall love Havayah your G‑d”: for ahavah (love) is from the root avah, which means desire and will.
The Alter Rebbe reads “You shall love” through the root of ahavah, avah, which means “to want.” In Likkutei Torah, Nasso, he explains this as a person’s will, with all his heart and soul, that G‑d’s unity be revealed in the world and in his soul.
דהיינו רעותא דלבא שיהי׳ [שיהיה] ה׳ אלקיך ולדבקה בו ממש וע״י אתערותא דלתתא זו יחול עליו אור האהבה מלמעלה להגדיל מדורת אש האהבה בלבו יותר מכדי כח אנושי ושרש נשמתו שהיא בגדר וגבול ונברא
That is, the will of the heart that Havayah be “your G‑d,” and to cleave to Him in truth. And through this arousal from below, the light of love from above will rest upon him, to enlarge the blaze of the fire of love in his heart beyond the measure of human strength and [of] the root of his soul, which is within limit and boundary and created,
Love, then, is the heart’s desire that Havayah truly be “your G‑d,” and to cleave to Him. When a person awakens this desire from below, a love from above comes to rest on him and makes the fire in his heart greater than any human being, or even his soul’s root, could produce, for even the soul’s root is created and limited.
לקרבה אל ה׳ ממש וביטול אליו במציאות ממש ע״י בחינת אהרן כהנא רבא
so as to draw near to G‑d in truth, and [to] self-nullification (bittul) before Him in actual existence, through the level of Aharon the High Priest.
The love from above, given through the supernal Aharon, the High Priest, lets a person truly draw near to G‑d and set aside his very existence before Him.
כי ואהבת בגמטריא ב׳ פעמים אור ונקרא׳ [ונקראת] בחינה זו בהטיבו שמטוב וחסד עליון משפיע על רוח שפלים5 להטיב ולהגדיל את האהבה שלמטה.13
For ve-ahavta (“you shall love”) equals in numerical value twice or (“light”). And this level is called “when he tends (be-heitivo),” for from the supernal goodness (tuv) and kindness He bestows upon the spirit of the lowly, to make good (leheitiv) and to enlarge the love below.
The numerical value of ve-ahavta (414) is twice that of or, “light” (207), hinting at two lights of love, one from below and one from above; the Kehot note gives the source in the Arizal’s intentions for the Shema (Shaar HaKavanos; Pri Etz Chaim). The love from above is “tending” (be-heitivo), read as from tov, “good,” since it comes from G‑d’s goodness to the lowly and makes the love below better and greater.
אך הנה באמת גם אתערותא דלתתא כנ״ל אשר יחפוץ האדם לדבקה בו ממש גם זאת מתת אלקים היא לא לפי כח נפש האדם ומזגו ותכונתו
But in truth, the arousal from below too, as [explained] above, that a person should desire to cleave to Him in truth, this too is a gift of G‑d, not according to the strength of the person’s soul, his temperament and his nature.
The Alter Rebbe adds a further point: even the arousal from below, the person’s own wish to cleave to G‑d, is also “a gift of G‑d,” not the product of his temperament or strength.
ונקרא׳ [ונקראת] בחינת ובהעלות אהרן שאהרן העליון הוא הנותן כח בכנסת ישראל לעורר את האהבה זו.
And this is called the level of “and when Aharon kindles (be-haalos),” for the supernal Aharon is the one who gives strength to the Congregation of Israel to awaken this love.
This is called “kindling” (be-haalos, literally “raising up”), because the supernal Aharon gives Israel the power to raise up their own love.
וזהו בין הערבים שהוא מדת ערב ולילה וחשך מצד עצמו שאין בו אור. אבל מדת בוקר שהוא מדת אברהם איש החסד כמ״ש וישכם אברהם בבקר67 הוא בחינת בהטיבו.
This is “at dusk,” which is the attribute of evening, night and darkness, which of itself has no light. But the attribute of morning, which is the attribute of Avraham, the man of kindness, as it is written, “And Avraham rose early in the morning,” is the level of “when he tends.”
Evening stands for the person on his own, dark with no light of himself, so the service then is “kindling”: Aharon lights what has no light. Morning is Avraham’s attribute of kindness, and the service then is “tending,” making good a light that is already there: the added love that comes from above.
¶2 This answers the question from paragraph 2 about tending and kindling.
(ועמ״ש לקמן בד״ה רני ושמחי8 בענין רננא ברמשא ושמחה בצפרא) והנה מי זה האדם שיגיע עד הלום שיגיע אליו בחי׳ אהרן העליון. אך הוא ע״י תורה ומצות.
(And see what is written below in the maamar beginning “Sing and rejoice,” on the subject of “song in the evening and joy in the morning.”) Now, who is the person who can reach this far, that the level of the supernal Aharon should reach him? But it is through Torah and mitzvos.
The text refers to a later maamar, “Sing and rejoice” (Torah Ohr, Miketz 37a), where “song in the evening” is the longing of Malchus when it has descended far into the lower worlds, and “joy in the morning” comes when it receives the lights from above, a pairing parallel to kindling and tending. It then asks how an ordinary person could reach the point where the supernal Aharon’s help comes to him, and answers: through Torah and mitzvos.
כי נר מצוה שהמצות נמשכין ממקום גבוה מאד נעלה. ולפיכך אין בהם השגה כלל כמשל השמן הנ״ל שאין נכנסים בפנימיות נפשם רק בבחי׳ מקיף עליהם מלמעלה
For “a mitzvah is a lamp,” since the mitzvos are drawn from a very high and exalted place. Therefore there is no comprehension in them at all, like the analogy of the oil above; for they do not enter the inwardness of their soul, but only as something encompassing them from above,
The mitzvos are called a “lamp” because they come from a place so high that the mind cannot grasp it. Like the oil, they do not enter the soul’s understanding but surround it from above.
כמ״ש שום תשים עליך מלך9 כמו מלך המושל על עמו והוא גבוה עליהם והם עושין רצונו בלי טעם ודעת כי מצות המלך היא ולב מלכים אין חקר10 ההשגה שבעבורם נצטוו
as it is written, “You shall surely set a king over you”: like a king who rules over his people and is high above them, and they do his will without reason or understanding, for it is the command of the king, and “the heart of kings is unsearchable”: [so is] the understanding for whose sake they were commanded.
The Torah’s command to set a king over oneself shows the relationship: subjects obey the king’s orders without understanding them, since the king’s reasons are beyond them. So too a Jew does the mitzvos as the King’s will, even though he cannot grasp the reasons.
רק מ״מ הוא ע״ד משל כאדם שתופס את המלך באחד מאבריו וממשיכו אליו הנה גם חיותו שבקרבו נמשך אחריו כך כתיב וימינו תחבקני.1112
Yet nevertheless it is, by way of analogy, like a person who grasps the king by one of his limbs and draws him to himself: the king’s life-force within him is drawn along after him too. So it is written, “and His right hand embraces me.”
Yet whoever grasps a king by one of his limbs draws the whole king to himself, since the king’s life is in each limb. So a person who does a mitzvah draws G‑d Himself close, as the verse says, “His right hand embraces me”.
כי הנה לב, דרמ״ח מ״ע [מצות עשה] הם רמ״ח אברין דמלכא וע״י המשכת המצות ממילא נמשך אחריו בחי׳ יחודו ית׳ בעצמו ובכבודו בבחינת יחודו כנ״ל:
For the 248 positive commandments are the 248 limbs of the King; and through drawing down the mitzvos, there is drawn after it, as a matter of course, the level of His unity, may He be blessed, in His own Self and glory, in the level of His unity, as [explained] above.
The 248 positive commandments are called the 248 “limbs” of the King. By doing the mitzvos a person draws down G‑d’s own unity, which, as explained, is beyond all the worlds.
The paragraph answers the maamar’s question about “tending” and “kindling”: “kindling” is the power G‑d gives a person to arouse love at all, and “tending” is the added love from above that enlarges it. Both are reached through the mitzvos, which, like oil, are beyond understanding yet draw G‑d Himself to the person.
The gematria of ve-ahavta as twice or comes from the Arizal’s intentions for the Shema, cited by Kehot from Shaar HaKavanos and Pri Etz Chaim. The mitzvos as the King’s 248 limbs explains why a mitzvah, though beyond understanding, connects a person to G‑d’s essence, more than comprehension alone could.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה מאי חנוכה דת״ר בכ״ה בכסליו, 5747
The Alter Rebbe divides the Menorah’s service in two: “be-haalos” is the arousal from below, and “be-heitivo” is the love from above that enlarges it. The Rebbe likewise divides the lamp into drawing down and raising up, though in his own terms. He applies the pair to the halachic dispute: drawing down follows Beis Hillel (ascending in holiness), and raising up follows Beis Shammai (decreasing). He adds that in personal avodah Beis Shammai’s view, weighing and measuring one’s ways, may even be the main thing.
The Alter Rebbe
וע״י אתערותא דלתתא זו יחול עליו אור האהבה מלמעלה
The Rebbe
ובכללות הנה ד׳ ענינים אלו שבנר נחלקים לב׳, המשכה מלמעלה למטה והעלאה מלמטה למעלה
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
TermsNer mitzvahRe’usa deliba248 limbs of the KingChesed olam+18
- Ner mitzvah נר מצוה explained hereThe mitzvos come from a very high place, so they cannot be grasped at all, like the oil; they do not enter the soul inwardly but encompass it from above, a king’s command done without reason. Yet as one who grasps a limb of the king draws the king himself, the 248 mitzvos, the King’s limbs, draw His very unity.
כי נר מצוה שהמצות נמשכין ממקום גבוה מאד נעלה. ולפיכך אין בהם השגה כלל כמשל השמן הנ״ל
- Re’usa deliba רעותא דלבא
- 248 limbs of the King רמ״ח אברים דמלכא
- Chesed olam חסד עולם
- Achdus Hashem אחדות השם
- Deveikus דביקות
- Knesses Yisrael כנסת ישראל
- Simchah שמחה
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Hasagah השגה
- Daas דעת
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Elokim אלקים
- Chesed חסד
- Pnimiyus פנימיות
- Ratzon רצון
Also NeshamahChayusBittulTorah and mitzvosHaalaah vehamshachahTorah
Marei mekomos
- 1בכל נפשך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 2מי לי בשמים ועמך לא חפצתי בארץ · Psalms 73:25
- 3כלה שארי ולבבי · Psalms 73:26
- 4כי אהבה משרש אבה שהוא מלשון חפץ ורצון · בלקו״ת נשא כו, ב מפרש ”והכוונה שיהיה רצון האדם וחפצו ובקשתו בכל לב ונפש להיות גילוי אלקותו ויחודו ית׳ בעולם ונפש” ע״ש. ראה ספר החקירה להצ״צ צב, א בשרש ישע. וראה גם לקו״ת מסעי פח, ד. ואתחנן ט, ב.
- 5רוח שפלים · Isaiah 57:15
- 6וישכם אברהם בבקר · Genesis 25:3
- 7וישכם אברהם בבקר · Genesis 22:3
- 8לקמן בד״ה רני ושמחי · לז, א.
- 9שום תשים עליך מלך · Deuteronomy 17:15
- 10ולב מלכים אין חקר · Proverbs 25:3
- 11וימינו תחבקני · Song of Songs 2:6
- 12וימינו תחבקני · Song of Songs 8:3
- 13ואהבת בגימט׳ ב׳ פעמים אור · שער הכוונות כוונת ק״ש. פע״ח שער הק״ש פכ״ג וכ״ה.
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Each Rosh Chodesh the names of those learning here are brought to the Ohel. Add your name, and mark what you learn so it is counted.
In one’s avodah
Contemplate how G‑d’s greatness over all the worlds is only His humility, until the heart longs for G‑d Himself; know that even this longing is His gift, and reach Him through doing the mitzvos, whose reasons are beyond understanding.
Questions for discussion
- Why does a spiritual decree call for a commemoration with lights rather than with feasting?
- How can oil, which puts out a flame poured on it, be the source of the lamp’s light, and what does this say about mitzvos whose reasons we do not understand?
- What is the difference between “One” and “Singular”, and why does it lead to love that wants to leave the worlds?
- If even the arousal from below is a gift from above, what is left for the person to do?
- How does grasping a king by one limb explain the power of a single mitzvah?
Key terms in this maamar
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first Sefirah of revelation: a single point of insight (koach mah, the yud of Havayah) that comes from the “nothing” above it; being bittul, Or Ein Sof rests in it, and Binah expands it. ×3Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- Aramaic, “the Holy One, blessed be He”: G‑d as holy, set apart from the worlds, paired with Shechinteh, His indwelling; read as sovev kol almin, Z’eir Anpin, Atzmus, and sometimes memalei kol almin. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- G‑d’s kingship: the lowest Sefirah, His “speech” and the revealed world, through which all worlds come into being from nothing and live, without touching His essence (“there is no king without a people”). ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Life-forceחיות
- Life-force: the G‑dly vitality that brings each creation into being and keeps it alive, drawn to each according to its level and renewed from nothing, as the soul enlivens the body. ×3Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Name meaning “He brings into being”: by contraction and expansion, its four letters, He brings all worlds into being while Himself unchanged; was, is and will be are one to Him. Elokim conceals it.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Self-nullification before G‑d, the condition for the Or Ein Sof to rest. Its lower degree is a “something” that bows; its higher, Chochmah’s “what are we,” takes up no place at all. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Knowledge as felt recognition: the intellect bound into the soul until it is felt as if seen. Daas unites Chochmah with Binah and spreads into the middos as their inner life; the middos follow it. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- The Sefirah of kindness (the right arm; Avraham): giving that comes from its nature to do good, spreading from highest to lowest like water. Gevurah, its opposite, limits it; in tikkun each includes the other. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- An arousal from belowאתערותא דלתתא
- A stirring that begins with the person (love and awe won by toil, self-nullification, the deed of the mitzvos) which, “as water reflects a face,” awakens a matching arousal from above. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Willרצון
- Will, which rules the middos: a lower will born of intellect, and the Supernal Will above intellect (Keser, Gulgalta), which covers a hidden reason and delight and is the root of the mitzvos. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The inner dimension (pnimiyus)פנימיות
- The inner dimension: the part of anything that turns toward and cleaves to its source (from panim, face), its depth and chief will. Its partner, chitzoniyus, goes out to others; the inner does not descend. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently