Torah Ohr · Parshas Vayigash · Maamar 1
ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדוני וגו׳
“And Yehudah approached him”
The Rebbe on this maamar
The Rebbe built on it in these maamarim of his: ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳ (5746)ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳ (5748)
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
What is lowest in the present order, the earth and Yehudah who receives, is rooted highest, first in G‑d’s thought, and its self-nullification comes from that root, the selflessness of thought itself. The wooden Mishkan followed today’s order, the giver above the receiver; the stone Beis HaMikdash foreshadowed the future, when Malchus will become “the crown of her husband” and Yehudah will rise above Yosef.
The maamar in brief
The maamar asks why the Mishkan was built mainly of wood, with earth only as its floor, while the Beis HaMikdash was built of stone and earth, with cedar beams only as supports. Of the four kingdoms, inanimate, vegetative, animal and speaking, the inanimate ranks lowest, yet the earth brings forth all growth. The reason is that what is last in deed is first in thought: in creation the heavens came first, but in G‑d’s thought the earth preceded everything. Its lowliness, trodden under every foot, reflects the self-nullification of thought itself, chashav mah. The Mishkan, a temporary dwelling, followed the present order: earth below, wooden walls above, curtains and skins over all. The Beis HaMikdash, a permanent dwelling and a foretaste of the future, was of stone, because then Malchus, the “earth,” will be “the crown of her husband.” Yosef, “addition,” is the growing cedar, Z’eir Anpin; Yehudah, “acknowledgment,” is the self-nullified earth, Malchus. Now Yehudah approaches Yosef to receive; in the future they will be one and Yehudah will rise higher, as Ezekiel’s two sticks and David’s kingship foretell. Yeravam, lacking this humility, refused to follow David.
Outline
- The question: wood and stoneWhy was the Mishkan built mainly of wood, with earth only underfoot, while the Beis HaMikdash was built of stone and earth, with wood only as support?¶1
- Last in deed, first in thoughtThe earth ranks lowest of the four kingdoms yet brings forth all growth, because in G‑d’s thought it came first, though in the act of creation the heavens did.¶2–3
- The Mishkan and the present orderThe temporary Mishkan followed the order of the worlds as they now descend: earth for its floor, cedar walls above, curtains and skins over all; the Beis HaMikdash, G‑d’s permanent home, foreshadowed the future.¶4–6
- The Beis HaMikdash and the future orderThe Beis HaMikdash was of stone because Malchus, the “earth,” will become the crown; the earth’s self-nullification comes from its root in thought, which is why Koresh’s row of wood among the stones was a fault and why the bowing of prayer is “inanimate.”¶7–8
- Yosef and YehudahYosef, the growing cedar, is Z’eir Anpin; Yehudah, the self-nullified earth, is Malchus. Now Yehudah approaches Yosef to receive, but in the future Malchus, founded on Chochmah, will rise above.¶9–12
- The two sticks, Yeravam and the spiesEzekiel’s two sticks foretell the union of Yosef and Yehudah under David; lacking humility, Yeravam would not accept the rise of the “earth,” and the spies felt no need for it.¶13–15
Key concepts
- Inanimate, vegetative, animal and speaking (domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber)דומם צומח חי מדבר
- The four kingdoms present in every world. In the present order each ranks above the one before it, but the inanimate earth has the highest root.
- Last in deed, first in thoughtסוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה
- What is completed last was intended first. The earth, last in creation, was first in G‑d’s thought, while the heavens, first in creation, were last in thought.
- Temporary and permanent dwellingדירת עראי / דירת קבע
- The Mishkan was G‑d’s temporary dwelling and followed the present order; the Beis HaMikdash was His permanent dwelling and a foretaste of the future.
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Setting aside one’s own sense of self. The earth, trodden underfoot, embodies it, and it ranks above the love and awe of the emotions.
- Chashav mah and koach mahחשב מ״ה / כח מ״ה
- Plays on machshavah (thought) and Chochmah (wisdom): both contain mah, “what,” the self-effacement of Moshe’s “And what are we?”
- A woman of valor is the crown of her husbandאשת חיל עטרת בעלה
- Malchus, the receiver, will in the Time to Come rise to be a crown above Z’eir Anpin, the giver.
- Abba founded the Daughterאבא יסד ברתא
- Malchus (“lower awe”) is founded on Chochmah (“higher awe”); in the future it will rise into that source.
The Rebbe’s maamarim on this maamar · 5
AI summaries Written by AI from each maamar and checked against it by a second AI reader; no person has reviewed them yet, so check the maamar itself before relying on a detail. See something to correct?
The Rebbe built these 2 maamarim (5746–5748) on the Alter Rebbe’s. Open one for a summary, for what it adds paragraph by paragraph, and its lesson. All of them, by parsha.
1.5746Built on itד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳
Summary
The Rebbe opens with the Alter Rebbe’s question. In the Mishkan the inanimate (earth) was at the bottom, the vegetative (the standing acacia boards, the main structure) above it, and the animal (curtains and skins) on top, following the order of the world. The Beis HaMikdash, by contrast, was built of stone and earth; even its roof and roof-plaster were of stone and earth, while cedar beams existed but were covered and not visible. The Rebbe frames the difference as the difference between the beginning of avodah and its completion. The Mishkan, a temporary dwelling from Matan Torah onward, was the beginning, where avodah goes from below to above and spirituality is primary. The Mikdash, the eternal house, is the completion, where the superiority of the inanimate is revealed. In a person’s avodah, domem is bittul (“let my soul be like dust to all”), which is yirah. Lower awe comes before avodah as its preparation. Higher awe comes after avodah is complete (“to fear Hashem”). That is why the Mikdash’s roof, too, was of earth and stone.
Two questions follow. First, if the roof means bittul together with avodah in all its details, how can bittul and avodah coexist when they seem to be opposites? The Rebbe answers from Hemshech 5666: the complete servant keeps all his powers, but they are the master’s powers. True bittul does not negate the powers, as in the highest level of shlichus. Second, there was earth in the floor of the Mikdash too, the earth used for the sotah waters. The Rebbe answers that lower awe contains the quality of higher awe, not vice versa. Through teshuvah, the lower bittul lifts even someone who has sinned higher than before (“she will conceive seed”). The same theme runs through Chana, Shmuel and David’s eternal kingship. He then reads Yehudah approaching Yosef as the beginning of avodah. The haftorah, the parshah’s conclusion, was instituted because of the descent of exile and the royal decree, yet presents the completion: "ודוד עבדי נשיא להם לעולם". He closes by saying that becoming a tzaddik and doing teshuvah are available immediately, like cash in the pocket, and enable immediate redemption.
What the Rebbe adds
- ¶4,6–7
The Alter Rebbe explains the Mishkan’s structure by its being a temporary dwelling that follows the present order of hishtalshelus, while the Mikdash anticipates the future. The Rebbe turns this into two stages of avodah. The Mishkan is the beginning of avodah, from below upward, where spirituality is the main thing. The Mikdash is the completion of avodah, where the superiority of the inanimate is revealed.
The Alter Rebbe
שהיה רק דירת עראי של הקב״ה
The Rebbe
כמו ההפרש בין תחילת הענין והעבודה ושלימות הענין והעבודה
- ¶12
The Alter Rebbe treats higher and lower awe as Chochmah and Malchus in the Sefiros. The Rebbe applies the pair to a person’s avodah and to the two buildings. The Mishkan’s earth is lower bittul, a preparation that comes before avodah. The Mikdash’s stone roof is higher awe, a bittul that comes after avodah is complete and stands above it. He proves the sequence from the verse “to do all these statutes, to fear Hashem.”
The Alter Rebbe
כי ח״ע נק׳ ירא׳ עלאה. וח״ת שהיא המל׳ היא יראה תתא׳
The Rebbe
משא״כ במקדש הי׳ ענין יראה עילאה, הביטול שלמעלה מהעבודה
- ¶7
The Alter Rebbe states that even the encompassing roof of the Mikdash was inanimate. The Rebbe reads this as avodah in all its details joined with bittul, and asks how the two can coexist, since bittul denies one’s existence while avodah requires “all your heart.” Drawing on Hemshech 5666, he answers with the complete servant and the highest level of shlichus. The servant’s pleasure, will, intellect and emotions all remain, but they are the master’s. True bittul therefore does not negate the powers.
The Alter Rebbe
שאף הגג והמעזיבה שהיא בחי׳ המקיף נעשה מאבנים ועפר
The Rebbe
איך אפשר שתהי׳ עבודת ה׳ יחד עם ענין הביטול
- ¶5
The Rebbe points to a detail he says goes unnoticed. The earth of the Mishkan floor is the earth of the sotah law, and that applied in the Mikdash as well (Mishnah Sotah). So the completion of avodah also contains lower bittul. He resolves this through the sotah theme. Sin comes from a “spirit of folly,” yet through teshuvah the lower bittul of the floor’s earth leads to the higher bittul of the roof, beyond the level held before the descent (“she will conceive seed”). He connects this to Chana, to Shmuel, and to Shmuel anointing David with a horn, the source of his eternal kingship.
The Alter Rebbe
ורק קרקע המשכן הי׳ מעפר
The Rebbe
שגם במקדש (שלימות העבודה) יש בחי׳ עפר אשר בקרקע המשכן
- ¶13
The Alter Rebbe uses the haftorah to contrast the present order with the future union of Yosef and Yehudah. The Rebbe adds that Yehudah approaching Yosef belongs to the beginning of avodah, while the haftorah, as the conclusion of the parshah, gives its completion: “David My servant will be their prince forever.” He also notes that the haftorah itself was instituted because of exile and a royal decree. Since the nations have no real dominion over Israel, that descent exists only for the sake of the ascent to this completion.
The Alter Rebbe
וזהו מ״ש בהפטרה דפ׳ ויגש קח לך עץ אחד
The Rebbe
בההפטרה שהיא סיום וחותם הפרשה
The lesson
Every Jew can become a tzaddik and do teshuvah immediately; these are available means, like cash already in one’s pocket, through which one can bring the redemption immediately. True bittul does not mean suppressing one’s faculties but using all of them as the Master’s.
AI summary
The full maamar: read or print it free at Lahak Hanochos (lahak.org)
2.5748Opens from itד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳
The Rebbe cites this Torah Ohr maamar for Vayigash as the union of Yehudah and Yosef and for Yosef as ‘addition.’ But the core of his maamar, talmud and maaseh and Yehudah’s speech elevating its contents, builds mainly on Ohr HaTorah Vayigash and on Torah Chaim Vayigash (ch. 10–12), with Hemshech 5666.
Summary
The Rebbe opens with the theme of Vayigash: Yehudah’s approach to Yosef is the union of Yehudah and Yosef. The haftorah gives a parallel prophecy of their union: two sticks, of Yehudah and of Ephraim, under one king, David. Since the Torah is eternal and given as instruction, even a prophecy about the future must teach every Jew something now, in his own service of his Creator. The maamar later raises two further questions, after discussing study and action and their application to prayer: why does the Torah record every detail of Yehudah’s speech, and why did it make Yosef unable to restrain himself, when Yosef already knew most of what Yehudah said?
The Rebbe explains that Yehudah and Yosef are action (maaseh) and study (talmud). Yehudah is the king who rules how to act, and David is called ‘My servant’ because service belongs to deed. Yosef is linked to Talmud, which adds through understanding; Ephraim is separately explained as meaning increase and addition. The goal is that each acts on the other. Study is done with bittul, aimed at the true halachah because practice depends on it. Action needs the understanding of the reasons behind the halachos. Inside the person this is joining the blessing of redemption to the Amidah prayer (semichas geulah letefillah): geulah is Yosef, ‘addition,’ and the Amidah, total bittul, is Yehudah. As for the narrative, Yehudah’s words lifted every event he mentioned, including the sale of Yosef, to its source. That revealed its lofty purpose (‘for sustenance G‑d sent me’). Yehudah’s bittul drew down a light higher even than Yosef’s own lofty level, a light his mind could not contain. That is why he wept and could not restrain himself, up to the revelation of G‑d’s very Essence.
What the Rebbe adds
- ¶9
The Alter Rebbe defines Yosef as growth (the vegetative, the cedar, Z’eir Anpin) and Yehudah as hoda’ah and bittul (the inanimate, Malchus). The Rebbe carries these definitions into avodah: Yosef is Torah study, which adds through understanding, and Ephraim (‘hifrani’) means increase and addition. Yehudah is action: the king rules on practice, and David is ‘My servant’ because service belongs to deed.
The Alter Rebbe
כי יוסף לשון תוספת ורבוי שמתוסף והולך בהגדלה
The Rebbe
שעניני יהודה ויוסף הם ב׳ הענינים דתלמוד (או לימוד) ומעשה
- ¶13
The Alter Rebbe cites the haftorah of the two sticks as Yosef and Yehudah united under David. The Rebbe explains why the stick of Yosef is called Ephraim: Ephraim is Yosef’s main tribe (‘his younger brother will be greater’), and he headed the banner that included Menasheh. He adds that because the Torah is eternal, this prophecy of the future is a present instruction to each Jew.
The Alter Rebbe
קח לך עץ אחד וכתוב עליו ליהודה כו׳
The Rebbe
דאפרים הוא עיקר שבטו של יוסף
- ¶13
In the Alter Rebbe the union mainly means that in the future Yehudah will rise above Yosef. The Rebbe gives the union a two-way content. Action affects study: when the learner knows practice depends on his learning, he becomes fully nullified and aims at the true halachah. Study affects action: one cannot rule in practice without knowing the details and reasons of the halachos.
The Alter Rebbe
יתחברו שניהם יוסף ויהודה ביחד בתכלית היחוד האמיתי
The Rebbe
שתהי׳ פעולת התלמוד בהמעשה ופעולת המעשה בהתלמוד
- ¶8
The Alter Rebbe links the inanimate’s bittul to the bowings of the Shemoneh Esreh. The Rebbe moves the Yosef–Yehudah pair into the person’s own prayer. The Amidah, total bittul, is Yehudah (‘this time I will thank… and she stopped bearing’). The blessing of redemption before it is Yosef, ‘addition,’ especially when the redemption comes ‘in peace.’ Joining the two is the union of Yehudah and Yosef.
The Alter Rebbe
ובתפלה הוא בחי׳ השתחואות שבשמ״ע קול דממה דקה
The Rebbe
וזהו ענין סמיכת גאולה לתפלה, דהיינו יחוד וחיבור יהודה ויוסף
- ¶11,13
The Alter Rebbe reads Yosef’s inability to restrain himself as the union of Yosef and Yehudah, and reads בי אדוני as Yehudah receiving from Yosef. The Rebbe asks why Yehudah’s speech moved Yosef so, when Yosef already knew most of what he recounted. He answers that Yehudah’s bittul lifted the events, including the sale, to their source. It drew down a light beyond even Yosef’s level, which is higher than the Patriarchs. The tears came from an excess of mochin that the mind could not contain. Here the receiver’s bittul brings a new revelation to the giver.
The Alter Rebbe
וז״ש ולא יכול יוסף להתאפק כו׳ בהתודע יוסף אל אחיו
The lesson
Every Jew must join study and action: learn with the bittul of one whose practice depends on it, and act with understanding of the reasons. In prayer, this means joining the blessing of redemption to the self-nullification of the Amidah.
AI summary
The full maamar: read or print it free at Lahak Hanochos (lahak.org)
With the same ד״ה
These 3 maamarim of the Rebbe open with the same words as this one (5725–5734): where each is printed, and the full text free at Lahak.
AI summary Written by Claude Opus 5.5 reading each of the Rebbe’s maamarim, from the scan corrected by AI, beside the Alter Rebbe’s maamar and our translation; not yet reviewed by a human editor: check the maamar itself before relying on a detail. The Hebrew words are quoted exactly. The full text of the Rebbe’s maamarim is published by Vaad Hanochos B’Lahak, free to read and print on lahak.org, and in print by Kehot. This page gives only short summaries and brief quotes.
In the Rebbe’s light · 19
AI research Found by AI reading every place in the Rebbe’s works that cites this maamar, and checked against each source by a second AI reader, the less certain by a third. Only what rated high is shown: the Rebbe’s own words, about this very passage. No person has reviewed it yet, so check the place itself before relying on a detail. See something to correct?
The maamar in the Rebbe’s light
The Rebbe returns to this maamar many times, and in a talk of Shabbos Vayigash 5746 (unedited) he asks the question a reader meets: what does pairing Yosef and Yehudah with the Mishkan and the Beis HaMikdash add, and why does a discourse on Vayigash explain the buildings at all? In „ודוד עבדי” (“VeDavid avdi,” Shabbos Vayigash 5732) he had read that structure as a proof: the stone Mikdash, a foretaste of the future, stands inside a maamar on Vayigash, so Yehudah’s future rise above Yosef is already hidden within his approach; “Vayigash” 5725, building on the Tzemach Tzedek’s „שוה” (“equal”), finds the same hint. In Likkutei Sichos (vol. 6, Shemos) he explains the two buildings: the Mishkan shows the light reaching down, the Mikdash the lowest itself becoming a vessel, for „קבלת ההשפעה” (receiving) goes deeper than giving, and so, as the Mitteler Rebbe’s Torah Chaim on this maamar already sets out, „סוף מעשה” (“last in deed”) reaches above even the start of thought. The same thought explains „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni”) in 5732, a request that the flow be drawn for the receiver’s own sake, and in 5711 (unedited) he reads it as the bond with the tzaddik that makes any request possible. Perhaps (biur b’derech efshar) a reader comes away seeing the buildings and the brothers as one argument about the hidden worth of the receiver.
Paragraph by paragraph
- ¶1
The Rebbe explains
In a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Vayigash 5747, the week after Chanukah, the Rebbe shows why Vayigash rises above the Chanukah reading of „חנוכת המשכן” (the Mishkan’s dedication), and to do so he retells the opening of this maamar.
After retelling this maamar’s contrast between the Mishkan and the Mikdash, the Rebbe says “this is the meaning of „קורות בתינו ארזים” (‘the beams of our houses are cedars’)” and gives two readings. In the first, which the Tzemach Tzedek (Or HaTorah, Shir HaShirim) draws from this maamar, following Rashi, the verse speaks of the cedar Mishkan, while the stone Mikdash is higher. In the second, the Mitteler Rebbe’s (Torah Chaim), following the Targum, it praises „בבהמ״ק דשלמה” (Shlomo’s Temple), where the cedars that were walls in Moshe’s Mishkan „הן רק בחי׳ קורות להחזיק עליהם המעזיבה” (became mere beams holding the plaster), and its last words, „רהיטנו ברותים” (“our rafters are of berosh”), speak of the Temple of the future.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה כתיב קורות בתינו ארזים וגו׳
The Rebbe
ועד לסיום הכתוב, „רהיטנו ברותים”, דקאי על ביהמ״ק דלעתיד לבוא, כפירוש התרגום
Sefer HaSichos 5747, vol. א, p. 220–222 · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשמ״ז (ט׳ טבת)
- ¶2
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on the time of the Exodus and on whether Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel follow what exists in potential (b’koach) or in actuality (b’po’el), the Rebbe finds the same dispute behind the Gemara’s question of whether heaven or earth was created first.
The Rebbe cites Chassidus, this maamar first (note 44: "תו״א ר״פ ויגש", with Torah Chaim putting it a little differently), that in actual creation „שמים נבראו תחלה” (heaven came first) and in thought and intent (מחשבה וכוונה) the earth came first. He then asks, after the Torah Chaim: if so, the two schools speak of two different things and „אין בזה מחלוקת כלל” (are not disputing at all). He answers that they dispute which is first „תחלה במעלה וחשיבות” (in importance): for Beis Hillel the earth, where „עיקר הכוונה” (the intent) lies; for Beis Shammai heaven, where the earth first exists in potential.
The Alter Rebbe
ואלו ואלו דא״ח שבמחשבה ארץ קדמה לשמים וכשברא ברא השמים תחלה
The Rebbe
ס׳איז אָבער ניט מובן: לפי הנ״ל קומט דאָך אויס, אַז ב״ש און ב״ה ריידן וועגן צוויי באַזונדערע ענינים
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 76–77 (Bo, sicha 2, notes 44 and 47; the sicha begins p. 69) · אחש״פ וש״פ קדושים תשכ״ז
- ¶3
The Rebbe explains
In the second sicha on Shemos in Likkutei Sichos vol. 6 (from talks of Shabbos Balak 5724 and Shabbos Shemos 5726), asking why the Egyptians made the Jews build with bricks („עשיית לבנים”), the Rebbe explains from this maamar why the Beis HaMikdash rose above the Mishkan, and in note 57 he sharpens this paragraph’s rule, „סוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה” (“last in deed is first in thought”).
In a note the Rebbe sets the rule of this paragraph, „סוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה” (“last in deed is first in thought”), apart from the saying „נעוץ תחלתן בסופן” (“their beginning is wedged in their end”), a distinction the Mitteler Rebbe already draws in Torah Chaim, his long version of this maamar (chapter 1). In the Rebbe’s words, there the “end” is „לסיום וגמר ההשפעה” (the completion of the giving), rooted in the giving’s start; “last in deed” is „קבלת ההשפעה” (the receiving of the flow), and it reaches “first in thought,” before even the beginning of thought, „למעלה משרש ההשפעה” (above the root of the giving). He cites for this his own maamar of 5724 and Torah Chaim (chapters 2–3), and later in the sicha (note 65) he points to Torah Chaim for the Beis HaMikdash, where the inanimate itself became a vessel, as the place where “last in deed is first in thought” was revealed.
The Alter Rebbe
כי זהו הכלל שהסוף מעשה עולה תחלה במחשבה
The Rebbe
משא״כ „סוף מעשה” הו״ע קבלת ההשפּעה, ובחינה זו מגעת ב„מחשבה תחלה” היינו תחילה אפילו לפני תחלת המחשבה
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 19, note 57 (Shemos, sicha 2; the sicha begins p. 6) · ש״פ בלק תשכ״ד וש״פ שמות תשכ״ו
- ¶5
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on the Rambam’s ruling that the Mikdash stood on rising ground and not on level ground, the Rebbe sets out “in the style of Chassidus” how the Mishkan differs from the Mikdash, citing this maamar (note 39).
Retelling the Mishkan as this maamar describes it, the Rebbe notes: „כ״ה בתו״א. וצ״ע שלא נזכרו שם האדנים שהיו דומם” (“So it is in Torah Ohr, and it needs investigation that the sockets, which were inanimate, are not mentioned there”). Torah Chaim does mention „אדני הקרשים דמשכן מדומם דכסף” (the silver sockets under the boards), and in his own retelling the sockets and the earth floor together are the Mishkan’s inanimate level, below the wooden boards („קרשי המשכן”).
The Alter Rebbe
ולכן כותלי המשכן היו מקרשים שהן בחי׳ צומח. ורק קרקע המשכן הי׳ מעפר
The Rebbe
כ״ה בתו״א. וצ״ע שלא נזכרו שם האדנים שהיו דומם
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כט, p. 76, note 40 (Re’eh, sicha 1; the sicha begins p. 71) · ש״פ מסעי תשד״מ
- ¶6
The Rebbe explains
In the same sicha on the bricks of Egypt, the Rebbe asks why the Mishkan was built of the vegetative (צומח) at all, since it too had earth and G‑d dwelt in it, and answers by explaining the two orders this paragraph describes.
The Rebbe explains why the Mishkan ran „בדרך מלמעלה למטה” (from the top down) and the Mikdash made the inanimate (דומם) its main substance. When G‑dliness reaches the lowest it can show in two ways: „תוקף בלתי מוגבל” (the boundless power) of the light, which reaches even the lowest, like „איש החסד” (a man of kindness) whose good reaches the lowliest; or the lowest itself becoming a vessel that „מכיר גדולתו ית׳” (recognizes G‑d). The Mishkan showed the first, so the light came down level by level and the earth received last; the Mikdash showed the second, so the inanimate came first.
The Alter Rebbe
נמצא שכ״ז נעש׳ כפי סדר מעלת ומדרגת ההשתלשלות בהשתלשלותן ובריאותן מלמעלמ״ט
The Rebbe
איז דאָך מובן, אַז דער עיקר החשיבות איז אין דעם תחתון וואָס „אין תחתון למטה ממנו”. און דערפאַר איז אין ביהמ״ק געווען דומם דער עיקר
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 18–21 (Shemos, sicha 2, sections ו–ט; the sicha begins p. 6) · ש״פ בלק תשכ״ד וש״פ שמות תשכ״ו
- ¶7
The Rebbe explains
In the maamar “Vayigash” of 5736 (edited, with the Rebbe’s notes), explaining „שעכשיו תלמוד גדול הוא לפי שתלמוד מביא לידי מעשה” (that study is “greater” now only because it leads to deed), the Rebbe points in a note to this paragraph.
The Rebbe notes that in the Mikdash „הצומח (כלונסאות של ארז) הי׳ טפל להדומם” (the vegetative, the cedar beams, was subordinate to the inanimate) because the Mikdash was „מעין עוה״ב” (“a foretaste of the World to Come”), when the advantage of the inanimate will be revealed. This subordination, he writes, is not like „גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה” (“study is greater, for it leads to deed”), where the higher serves the lower, but like „מעשה גדול” (“deed is greater”), the rule of the future.
The Alter Rebbe
לכן אף בבהמ״ק שהי׳ מעין עוה״ב נעשה עיקר הבית מאבנים ועפר שהם בחי׳ דומם
The Rebbe
והרי זה שבביהמ״ק הי׳ הצומח טפל להדומם הוא (לא ע״ד גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה, כי אם) ע״ד מעשה גדול
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. ריז, note 29 · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשל״ו
- ¶7
A question the Rebbe raises
In the same sicha, having said that in the Mikdash the cedar was only secondary (טפל) to the stone, the Rebbe raises a difficulty in a note.
The Rebbe asks: the ceiling of the Mikdash had „גבים ושדרות בארזים” (beams and planks of cedar; I Kings 6:9), which is the vegetative. He points toward the answer from the Mishnah (Middos 4:6), that over them lay a plaster (מעזיבה) of stones and lime, and from this paragraph and Torah Chaim, that „הכלונסאות של ארז שהי׳ בתקרה הם היו תמכין לבד לעיקר התקרה הנעשה מבחי׳ דומם” (the cedar beams were “only supports for the main ceiling, which was made of the inanimate”), holding up the plaster alone.
The Alter Rebbe
רק שכלונסאות של ארז שהיה בהתקרה הם היו בחי׳ תמכין לבד לעיקר התקרה הנעשה מבחי׳ דומם
The Rebbe
ולכאורה צע״ק מתקרת ביהמ״ק שהי׳ גבים ושדרות בארזים (מ״א ו, ט) — צומח
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 20, note 62 (Shemos, sicha 2; the sicha begins p. 6) · ש״פ בלק תשכ״ד וש״פ שמות תשכ״ו
- ¶8
The Rebbe explains
In the maamar “VeDavid avdi” of Shabbos Vayigash 5732 (edited, with the Rebbe’s notes), explaining why Malchus is self-nullified, the Rebbe begins from this paragraph’s reason for the earth’s bittul (ביטול).
The Rebbe quotes this paragraph: the earth’s bittul, „שהיא מדרס תחת כפות רגלי הכל” (being trodden beneath everyone’s feet), comes from its root, since „במחשבה ארץ קדמה לשמים” (in thought the earth preceded the heavens); so too the inanimate’s bittul comes from a root above the vegetative’s. In a note he separates the two: „הביטול דדומם הוא שאינו גדל בגובה כהצומח” (the bittul of the inanimate is that it does not grow tall like a plant), it has no quality to show; „הביטול דארץ הוא שהיא מדרס תחת רגלי הכל” (the bittul of the earth is that it is trodden under everyone’s feet).
The Alter Rebbe
והוא בחי׳ הבטול שיש בה שהיא מדרס תחת כפות רגלי הכל משא״כ הצומח שגדלים בגובה והתנשאות כו׳
The Rebbe
הביטול דדומם הוא שאינו גדל בגובה כהצומח (היינו שאין בו מעלה), והביטול דארץ הוא שהיא מדרס תחת רגלי הכל
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רי–ריא, note 26 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
- ¶9
The Rebbe explains
Continuing in “VeDavid avdi” 5732, the Rebbe compares Malchus to speech, which exists „בשביל הזולת” (for another), and finds this bittul in this paragraph’s explanation of Yehudah’s name.
The Rebbe finds the bittul of Malchus hinted in this paragraph’s words that Yehudah, Malchus, is „לשון הודאה וביטול” (a term of acknowledgment and self-nullification): „שהביטול דהודאה הוא שמבטל את עצמו לזה שהוא מודה אליו” (the bittul of hoda’ah is that one sets oneself aside before the one he acknowledges). It is like speech, Malchus of the soul, in which a person goes out of himself for another’s sake; so Malchus „יורדת להחיות ולהוות את הנבראים” (descends to give life to and bring into being the creatures).
The Alter Rebbe
ולכן יהודה ל׳ הודאה ובטול שהדומם יש בו בחי׳ הבטול ביותר
The Rebbe
ויש לומר, דביטול זה שבמלכות מרומז במ״ש בתו״א שיהודה (מלכות) הוא לשון הודאה וביטול, שהביטול דהודאה הוא שמבטל את עצמו לזה שהוא מודה אליו
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רי–ריא · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
- ¶9
A question the Rebbe raises
At the farbrengen of Shabbos Vayigash, 9 Teves 5746 (unedited), right after saying the maamar “Vayigash” built on this one, the Rebbe raised a general question about this discourse and others like it.
The Rebbe asks „מה ניתוסף בהבנת הענינים כאשר יודעים שענינם של יוסף ויהודה מתאימים לענינם של המשכן וביהמ״ק” (what a reader gains from learning that Yosef and Yehudah match the Mishkan and the Mikdash). In the discourses on „יפה שיחתן של עבדי אבות” (“the talk of the fathers’ servants”), which find the union of Mah and Ban in the marriage of Yitzchak and Rivkah, the details of the story teach details of that union; here, he says, the pairing seems to add nothing to the idea itself, „החילוק שבין סדר השתלשלות דעתה לגבי לעת״ל” (the present order against the future). So why explain the details of the Mishkan and the Mikdash in the discourses of Vayigash, when „מקומם בדרושי הפרשיות תרומה תצוה” (their place is in Terumah and Tetzaveh), or in the discourses on the dedication of the House at the end of Likkutei Torah?
The Alter Rebbe
והנה זהו ג״כ ענין יוסף ויהודה. שהוא ג״כ בחי׳ ומדרגת שמים וארץ ובחי׳ צומח ודומם כו׳
The Rebbe
מה מקום לבאר את פרטי החילוק דמשכן וביהמ״ק בדרושי פ׳ ויגש — בדרושי פ׳ ויגש מתאים לבאר את ענינם של יוסף ויהודה
Toras Menachem – Hisvaaduyos 5746 (unedited), vol. ב, p. 268–269, section יט · ש״פ ויגש, ט׳ טבת, ה׳תשמ״ו
- ¶11
The Rebbe explains
In “VeDavid avdi” 5732 the Rebbe raises the question on this sentence that our commentary records from Kehot’s note, and answers it.
The question: Yehudah was asking Yosef, so he should have asked that Yosef draw the flow to him; why „שבו יומשך השפע” (“that in him the flow will be drawn”)? The Rebbe answers from lights and vessels: „ששורש הכלים הוא למעלה משורש האורות” (the vessels’ root is above the lights’), and the giver senses this. Usually Z’eir Anpin gives to Malchus so that its own giving be complete; Yehudah’s „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni”) asked that the flow be drawn for Malchus’s own sake, “in me,” and through this alone Yosef becomes „כמוך כפרעה, עליית ז״א לעצם הכתר” (“like Pharaoh,” rising to the essence of Keser).
The Alter Rebbe
וז״ש ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדני. פי׳ שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק
The Rebbe
אמר יהודה ליוסף בי אדוני, שהמשכת השפע מז״א למלכות תהי׳ (לא בכדי שההמשכה דז״א תהי׳ בשלימות, אלא) בכדי שבהמלכות יומשך השפע
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. ריא–רבי, section ז and note 33 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
- ¶11
The Rebbe explainsThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
“VeDavid avdi” 5732 opens by asking how the haftorah, where David of Yehudah rules („ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם”), fits Vayigash, where Yosef stands above Yehudah; in section ב the Rebbe answers from the structure of this maamar.
The Rebbe asks: since “Vayigash” means Yosef above Yehudah, a maamar opening with Vayigash would not seem the place to explain „שביהמ״ק הי׳ מדומם” (why the Mikdash was of stone). That this maamar does so shows, he says, that though outwardly Vayigash means Z’eir Anpin above Malchus, within it, „בפנימיות ובהעלם, המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א” (inwardly and hidden, lies Malchus’s superiority), like what will be revealed in the future.
The Alter Rebbe
וזהו ע״ד שהיה במשכן הצומח למעלה מהדומם כנ״ל. אבל לע״ל יתעלה יהודה להיות למעלה מבחי׳ יוסף
The Rebbe
דהגם שבגילוי ענין ויגש אליו יהודה הוא שז״א הוא למעלה ממלכות, יש בו (בויגש אליו יהודה), בפנימיות ובהעלם, המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רז–רח, section ב and notes 11–12 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
- ¶11
Background from the RebbeThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
The maamar “Vayigash” of Shabbos Vayigash 5736 (edited; published 5 Teves 5750) opens with the Zohar’s teaching at the start of Vayigash (I, 205b) that Yehudah’s approach is „סמיכת גאולה לתפלה” (“joining redemption to prayer”), as the Rebbe Maharash and the Rebbe Rashab explain it. Our paragraph cites another statement of the Zohar there ("תקרובתא עלמא בעלמא", Kehot: 206a), which this maamar does not take up.
The Zohar calls Yehudah’s approach to Yosef „סמיכת גאולה לתפלה” (“joining redemption to prayer”): redemption is Yesod, Yosef, and prayer is Malchus, Yehudah, as the Rebbe Maharash (5629) and the Rebbe Rashab (5666, 5668, 5675) explain. The Rebbe asks: in Vayigash Yosef is higher, yet when redemption is joined to prayer „שתפלה היא העיקר” (the prayer is the main thing), so „גם בהגשת יהודה ליוסף ניכר המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א” (even Yehudah’s approach shows Malchus’s superiority). He answers that Z’eir Anpin gains by giving to Malchus, as study grows „שמביא לידי מעשה” (by leading to deed), so Malchus’s advantage already shines in part, a prelude to the future.
The Alter Rebbe
אבל לע״ל יתעלה יהודה להיות למעלה מבחי׳ יוסף
The Rebbe
דממ״ש בזהר שהגשת יהודה ליוסף הו״ע סמיכת גאולה לתפלה, משמע, שגם בהגשת יהודה ליוסף ניכר המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רטו–ריט, sections א–ה (pp. רטו–ריח) and the closing paragraph (p. ריט); the quote on p. רטז · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשל״ו
- ¶11
Background from the RebbeThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
The maamar “Vayigash” of Shabbos Vayigash 5725 (edited by the Rebbe and published for 5 Teves 5751) opens with the same question as “VeDavid avdi” 5732: since the haftorah’s „ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם” (“My servant David will be king over them”) is read with Vayigash, Yehudah’s superiority must be in Vayigash too. It quotes this paragraph and answers from the Tzemach Tzedek’s explanation of the verse’s final letters („הסופי תיבות”).
The final letters of "ויגש אליו יהודה" spell „שוה” (shaveh, “equal”; Baal HaTurim), which the Tzemach Tzedek explains as Malchus and Z’eir Anpin, Yehudah and Yosef, being joined as equals, the higher and the lower knowledge „למהוי אחד באחד” (as one). From this the Rebbe draws that Yehudah’s approach holds two things: openly, the receiver coming to the giver, „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni”); and hinted, the future union, and even Malchus rising above Z’eir Anpin, „אשת חיל עטרת בעלה” (“a woman of valor is the crown of her husband”). This, he adds, is what the Zohar means by calling the approach „סמיכת גאולה לתפלה” (“joining redemption to prayer”), where prayer is the main thing.
The Alter Rebbe
ויהודה הוא המקבל. וז״ש ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדני
The Rebbe
ועפ״ז יש לומר, שבויגש אליו יהודה מרומז גם העלי׳ דמלכות שיהי׳ לע״ל, שהמלכות תהי׳ למעלה מז״א, אשת חיל עטרת בעלה
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. ה, p. קכז–קכח · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשכ״ה
- ¶11
Background from the Rebbe
At the farbrengen of Shabbos Vayigash, 7 Teves 5711 (unedited), as the eleven months of kaddish for the Rebbe Rayatz came to an end, the Rebbe spoke of the chassidim’s bond (התקשרות) with the Rebbe Rayatz and found it hinted in Yehudah’s approach to Yosef.
Quoting this sentence, „שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק” (“in him the flow from Yosef the tzaddik will be drawn”), the Rebbe reads Yehudah’s approach as giving himself over to Yosef, „צדיקו של עולם” (“the tzaddik of the world”), to be united with him, and “bi adoni” as asking „שיוסף הוא האדון שלו” (that Yosef be his master), so that all of Yosef’s flow is drawn into him. That is why Yehudah opens with “bi adoni”: only one who is „מקושר אליו ומאוחד עמו” (bound and united) with someone so far above him can ask anything of him at all. He reads „ואל יחר אפך בעבדך כי כמוך כפרעה” (“let your anger not flare … for you are like Pharaoh”) the same way: as G‑d, the Pharaoh of holiness in the Zohar’s reading, is good by nature and does not resent being asked, so too the tzaddik.
The Alter Rebbe
פי׳ שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק
The Rebbe
ולכן מקדים ”בי אדוני”, שתוכנה של הקדמה זו היא שיוסף הוא האדון שלו, היינו, שמקושר אליו ומאוחד עמו
Toras Menachem – Hisvaaduyos 5711 (unedited), vol. א, p. 161–162 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשי״א
- ¶13
The Rebbe explains
In “VeDavid avdi” 5732, having explained „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni,” see ¶11), the Rebbe asks how Yehudah could move Yosef, whose nature is revelation, to give „בשביל המלכות” (for the receiver’s own sake).
He answers from Yehudah’s guarantee, „כי עבדך ערב את הנער” (“for your servant became surety for the boy”). „ערבים לשון מעורבים” (guarantors, arevim, are “intermingled,” me’oravim), but Yehudah’s surety came from something deeper: „שכל ישראל הם עצם אחד ממש” (all Israel are truly one essence). That is why the guarantee was Yehudah’s, for Malchus is rooted in the inwardness of Keser, above all division; and when Yehudah spoke it, this oneness was drawn into Yosef too, „ולכן לא יכול יוסף להתאפק” (“and so Yosef could not restrain himself”).
The Alter Rebbe
וז״ש ולא יכול יוסף להתאפק כו׳ בהתודע יוסף אל אחיו דהיינו שנתחברו יוסף ויהודה בתכלית החבור והיחוד
The Rebbe
נמשך ענין זה (בבחינת מקיף עכ״פ) גם ביוסף, ולכן לא יכול יוסף להתאפק גו׳ והתוודע אל אחיו
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רבי–ריג, section ח · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
- ¶13
The Rebbe explains
In the sicha of Shabbos Vayigash 5747 (see ¶1), after quoting this maamar that now Yosef is above and „לע״ל יתעלה יהודה” (in the future Yehudah will rise), the Rebbe quotes the haftorah as this paragraph does.
Quoting the haftorah that this paragraph quotes, „ונתתי אותם עליו את עץ יהודה” (“and I will place them upon it, with the stick of Yehudah”), the Rebbe glosses “upon it” as „למעלה ממנו” (“above it”), so that the verse itself sets Yehudah’s stick above Yosef’s. He brings the haftorah, „סיום וחותם הקריאה” (“the end and seal of the reading”), as stressing what this maamar says, that now Yosef is above and in the future Yehudah will rise above him.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה אני לוקח את עץ יוסף כו׳ ונתתי אותם עליו את עץ יהודה כו׳
The Rebbe
הנה אני לוקח את עץ יוסף גו׳ ונתתי אותם עליו (למעלה ממנו) את עץ יהודה ועשיתים לעץ אחד גו׳
Sefer HaSichos 5747, vol. א, p. 221 · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשמ״ז
- ¶13
A question the Rebbe raises
In “Tziyon bemishpat tipadeh” of Shabbos Chazon 5735 (edited), the Rebbe quotes Ezekiel’s prophecy of the two sticks as the future rise of Yehudah, the inanimate, above Yosef („יתעלה יהודה (בחי׳ דומם) להיות למעלה מיוסף”), and notes how this maamar quotes it.
In a note the Rebbe observes that Torah Chaim and other places quote the prophecy through „ודוד עבדי נשיא להם לעולם” (“David My servant will be their prince forever”), but this paragraph quotes it only „עד ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם” (“up to ‘and My servant David will be king over them’”). He leaves it as a question: „שזה כבר הי׳ משא״כ נשיא להם לעולם” (David was already king over all Israel, while “their prince forever” is what is new).
The Alter Rebbe
עד ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם
The Rebbe
כן הוא בתו״ח ועוד, אבל בתו״א (מד, סע״א) : קח כו׳ עד ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם. וצ״ע שזה כבר הי׳, משא״כ „נשיא להם לעולם”
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קסב, note 23 · ש״פ דברים, שבת חזון, תשל״ה
- ¶13
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on Yosef’s dreams and his brothers’ jealousy („ויקנאו בו אחיו”), explaining that a sign from above showed „יתרון מעלת העבודה של יוסף” (the advantage of Yosef’s way of service), the Rebbe cites this maamar in a note.
Citing this maamar for „בסדר השתלשלות עתה יוסף הוא למעלה מיהודה” (Yosef standing above Yehudah in the present order), the Rebbe adds that Torah Ohr speaks there of the level of Yosef as against Yehudah, and that is why the ten tribes belong to Yosef; but „בפרטיות הרי בבחי׳ זו ישנן כמה מדריגות (עשר)” (within that level there are, in detail, several grades, ten). So „אליו שייכים עשרת השבטים” (“to him belong the ten tribes”) names a level, within which the tribes still differ.
The Alter Rebbe
כך יוסף אליו שייכים עשרת השבטים
The Rebbe
אלא דשם מדובר בבחי׳ יוסף לגבי יהודה, ולכן עשרת השבטים שייכים ליוסף; אבל בפרטיות הרי בבחי׳ זו ישנן כמה מדריגות (עשר)
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כה, p. 209, note 62 (Vayeshev, sicha 1; the sicha begins p. 204) · ש״פ וישב תשט״ו; ש״פ מקץ תש״מ
Short quotes only, with the place of each so it can be read in full. The Rebbe’s sichos, letters and maamarim are published by Kehot and by Vaad Hanochos B’Lahak (lahak.org).
The question: wood and stone ¶1
1ויגש אליו יהודה1 ויאמר בי2 אדוני וגו׳. הנה כתיב קורות בתינו ארזים3 וגו׳. והנה י״ל [יש לומר] ההפרש בין המשכן לבית עולמים4 שהמשכן הי׳ [היה] מארזים
“And Yehudah approached him and said, ‘Please (bi), my lord,’” etc. Now, it is written, “The beams of our houses are cedars,” etc. Now, it can be said [that] the difference between the Mishkan and the Eternal House (Beis Olamim) [is] that the Mishkan was of cedars,
The maamar opens with the verse in which Yehudah steps forward to plead for Binyamin before Yosef, whom the brothers do not yet recognize; his opening word bi is a word of entreaty, “please,” though literally “in me,” the sense the maamar will draw on in paragraph 11. Beside it the maamar sets a verse from Song of Songs about houses whose beams are cedar, and asks what distinguishes the Mishkan, the portable sanctuary of the desert, from the Beis HaMikdash, the permanent “Eternal House” in Jerusalem, beginning with the fact that the Mishkan was made of wood.
כמ״ש עצי שטים עומדים5 והמכסה הי׳ [היה] מיריעות עזים ועורות אילים ועורות תחשים כו׳ והבהמ״ק [והבית המקדש] הי׳ [היה] מאבנים ועפר דוקא6
as it is written, “acacia wood, standing,” and the covering was of curtains of goats’ [hair] and of rams’ skins and tachash skins, etc.; while the Beis HaMikdash was of stones and earth specifically
The verse “acacia wood, standing” describes the upright boards that formed the Mishkan’s walls; the maamar calls them “cedars,” and the Sages count the acacia among the kinds of cedar. Over the walls lay curtains of goat hair and coverings of rams’ and tachash skins, whereas the Beis HaMikdash was built of stone and earth.
(שאסור לעשות בו עץ בולט7 ואכסדראות של עץ89 כמ״ש הרמב״ם [הרבי משה בן מימון]10 פ״א מהל׳ [מהלכות / מהלכה] בית הבחירה וע׳ בס׳ החינוך מצוה תצ״ב) רק שהיו כלונסאות של ארז1112 בתקרת האולם כו׳
(for it is forbidden to make in it protruding wood or porticoes of wood, as the Rambam writes in chapter 1 of the Laws of the Chosen House; and see Sefer HaChinuch, mitzvah 492), except that there were cedar beams in the ceiling of the Ulam (the Hall), etc.
In a parenthesis the Alter Rebbe notes that the law forbids building the Beis HaMikdash with protruding wood or wooden porticoes, as the Rambam rules and as the Sefer HaChinuch discusses; in Likkutei Torah, V’Zos HaBerachah, he adds that wood sunk into the building, as in its ceilings, is allowed. So the wood the maamar names in the structure is a set of cedar beams in the ceiling of the Ulam, the entrance hall in front of the Sanctuary.
וצ״ל זה מפני מה במשכן היו הארזים עיקר בבנין והעפר הי׳ [היה] רק בקרקע המשכן למטה.13
And this must be understood: why in the Mishkan were the cedars the main part of the structure, and the earth only in the floor of the Mishkan, below?
The maamar’s question is this: why was wood the main material of the Mishkan, while earth appeared only as the ground beneath it?
¶5 Hold this question: paragraphs 4–8 answer it.
ובמקדש נהפוך הוא שהיו האבנים והעפר העיקר שאפי׳ [שאפילו] הגג הי׳ [היה] מהן ולא היו עצים רק כלונסאות של ארז הנ״ל שהיו טפלים לעיקר הבנין.14
And in the Mikdash it was the reverse: the stones and the earth were the main part, so that even the roof was of them, and there was no wood except the cedar beams mentioned above, which were secondary to the main structure.
In the Beis HaMikdash the proportions were reversed. Stone and earth formed the whole building, even the roof, and the cedar beams were merely an accessory to the stone structure.
The paragraph poses the maamar’s question: the Mishkan was built mainly of wood, with earth only underfoot, while the Beis HaMikdash was built of stone and earth, with wood only as a secondary support.
The Kehot notes record two other transcripts of this maamar in Sefer HaMaamarim 5565, one of which begins with “The beams of our houses are cedars,” a verse that, as the Tzemach Tzedek observes, the Targum seems to apply to the Temple of Shlomo. In that transcript, the point that the Mishkan had earth only in its floor is supported by the verse “and of the earth that is on the floor of the Mishkan”; the Rebbe’s maamar “Vayigash” 5746 asks how this proves the point, since that verse belongs to the law of the sotah waters, which applied in the Beis HaMikdash as well. The notes add that the Ra’avad agrees with the Rambam’s ruling against wood in the Beis HaMikdash, as the Kesef Mishneh shows.
Explained elsewhere AI research
Explained by the Rebbe
The parenthesis gives the Rambam and the Sefer HaChinuch for the ban „לעשות בו עץ בולט” (on protruding wood) in the Mikdash but not the verse it comes from.
The ban on wood in the Mikdash has a verse behind it: „לא תטע לך אשרה כל עץ” (“Do not plant for yourself an asherah, any tree, beside the altar”; Devarim 16:21). When the Rebbe retells this maamar („ציון במשפט תפדה”, “Tziyon bemishpat tipadeh,” Shabbos Chazon 5735), he gives this verse for the ban and cites with it the Gemara (Tamid 28b), the Rambam and the Sefer HaChinuch (mitzvah 492), the two named in our parenthesis.
the Rebbe: Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קסב, note 21
ואסור לעשות בו עץ בולט כו׳ כמ״ש לא תטע לך אשרה כל עץ
Where the maamar leaves something unexplained, found by AI in the library and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In a sicha of Shabbos Parshas Vayigash 5747, the week after Chanukah, the Rebbe shows why Vayigash rises above the Chanukah reading of „חנוכת המשכן” (the Mishkan’s dedication), and to do so he retells the opening of this maamar.
After retelling this maamar’s contrast between the Mishkan and the Mikdash, the Rebbe says “this is the meaning of „קורות בתינו ארזים” (‘the beams of our houses are cedars’)” and gives two readings. In the first, which the Tzemach Tzedek (Or HaTorah, Shir HaShirim) draws from this maamar, following Rashi, the verse speaks of the cedar Mishkan, while the stone Mikdash is higher. In the second, the Mitteler Rebbe’s (Torah Chaim), following the Targum, it praises „בבהמ״ק דשלמה” (Shlomo’s Temple), where the cedars that were walls in Moshe’s Mishkan „הן רק בחי׳ קורות להחזיק עליהם המעזיבה” (became mere beams holding the plaster), and its last words, „רהיטנו ברותים” (“our rafters are of berosh”), speak of the Temple of the future.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה כתיב קורות בתינו ארזים וגו׳
The Rebbe
ועד לסיום הכתוב, „רהיטנו ברותים”, דקאי על ביהמ״ק דלעתיד לבוא, כפירוש התרגום
Sefer HaSichos 5747, vol. א, p. 220–222 · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשמ״ז (ט׳ טבת)
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsTorah and mitzvos
Terms Torah and mitzvos
Marei mekomos
- 1ויגש אליו יהודה · ב׳ הנחות אחרות בסה״מ תקס״ה ע׳ קמב ואחד מתחיל ”קורות בתינו ארזים”. ראה לעיל בציונים לכ״ק אדמו״ר זי״ע. וראה אודות מאמר זה רשימת המאמרים שבסה״מ תקס״ז הערה *14. קיצורים נדפסו באוה״ת בראשית כרך ה תתקפה, ב. כרך ו תתשח, א. חלק מהמאמר נעתק בסה״מ תרכ״ט (הוצאת תשנ״ב) ע׳ כב ואילך עם הוספות. לכללות מאמר זה ראה ד״ה ויגש תשמ״ו.
- 2
- 3קורות בתינו ארזים · Song of Songs 1:17
- 4ההפרש בין המשכן לבית עולמים · ראה אוה״ת זכור ע׳ א׳תשפא. שה״ש ע׳ קעה. סה״מ תרכ״ט ע׳ יח. מכאן ואילך בסה״מ תרמ״ד ע׳ ריב עם הגהות. בלקו״ת נשא כד, ב. בלק עד, ד מציין לכאן.
- 5עצי שטים עומדים · Exodus 26:15
- 6והבהמ״ק הי׳ מאבנים ועפר דוקא · ראה לקו״ש ח״ו ע׳ 23 הערה 67 למה הוצרך להיות (לכתחילה) מאבנים דוקא ע״ש. ראה לקו״ת ברכה צט, ד בענין משכן שילה. לקו״ש ח״ד ע׳ 1260. לקו״ש לש״פ מסעי חכ״ח. ודלא כהמשכן שרק קרקע המשכן הי׳ מעפר, דומם, אבל כותלי המשכן היו מצומח, והמכסה שעל המשכן (היריעות) הי׳ מחי — ד״ה ודוד עבדי תשל״ב (סה״מ מלוקט ח״ו ע׳ עז).
- 7עץ בולט · ראה לקו״ש לש״פ מסעי חכ״ח ע׳ 222 הערה 21 בשם ספר הר המורי׳ שמפרש דעץ בולט היינו בולט מן הכותל לאויר. וראה בסידור עם דא״ח ע׳ רא, ג. ובלקו״ת ברכה צט, ד שהאיסור הוא דוקא בבולט ולא בשוקע.
- 8שאסור לעשות בו עץ בולט ואכסדראות של עץ · Mishneh Torah, The Chosen Temple 1:9–10
- 9עץ בולט ואכסדראות של עץ · Sefer HaChinukh 492:2
- 10כמ״ש הרמב״ם · וגם הראב״ד ס״ל כן — ראה כס״מ שם (לקו״ש ח״ו שם הערה 48).
- 11כלונסאות של ארז · ראה לקו״ש שם הערה 62.
- 12כלונסאות של ארז · Mishnah Middot 3:8
- 13והעפר הי׳ רק בקרקע המשכן למטה · בסה״מ תקס״ה ע׳ קמב מביא זה ע״פ הפסוק נשא ה, טז ”וכמ״ש ומעפר אשר בקרקע המשכן”, וע״ז הקשה בד״ה ויגש תשמ״ו דלכאורה צ״ל דהרי פסוק זה הוא דין בדיני מי סוטה שנאמר לא רק במשכן אלא גם במקדש ע״ש.
- 14שהיו טפלים לעיקר הבנין · ראה מדות פ״ג מ״ח (כפי גירסת רוב המפרשים). כסף משנה להרמב״ם הל׳ ביהב״ח פ״א ה״ט. מפרשי המשנה שם בפ״א מ״ו. ועוד (לקו״ש ח״ו שם הערה 63). בסה״מ תרמ״ד ע׳ ריב נמצא כאן הוספה.
Last in deed, first in thought ¶2–3
2והענין כי הנה ידוע שיש בכל עולם ד׳ בחי׳ דצח״מ [דומם צומח חי מדבר] והדומם הוא למטה במדרגה מצומח והצומח למטה מן החי כו׳
The explanation is that, as is known, in every world there are four levels: inanimate, vegetative, animal and speaking (domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber). The inanimate is lower in rank than the vegetative, and the vegetative is lower than the animal, etc.
The answer starts from a well-known division of creation into four kingdoms: the inanimate (minerals and earth), the vegetative (plants), the animal, and the speaking (the human being). Each ranks above the one before it.
והעילוי שבכולם הוא בחי׳ המדבר ולכאורה תמוה דא״כ מפני מה הארץ דוקא תוציא צמחה1 שהצומח יהי׳ [יהיה] גדל ונולד ונמשך מעפר הארץ הלא הצומח הוא למעלה מהדומם שהוא העפר.
And the most elevated of them all is the level of the speaker. At first glance this is puzzling: if so, why is it specifically the earth that “brings forth its growth,” so that the vegetative grows, is born and is drawn forth from the dust of the earth? Is not the vegetative above the inanimate, which is the dust?
The human being, who speaks, is the highest of all. This raises a puzzle: if plants rank above earth, why do they grow out of the earth, the lower level, so that “the earth brings forth its growth”?
¶3 Hold this question: paragraph 3 answers it.
אך הענין דלא ראי זה כראי זה שאע״פ [שאף על פי] שהדומם למטה במדרגה מן הצומח עכ״ז [עם כל זה] יש בו מעלה יתירה מצד שרשו שלמעלה מבחי׳ צומח וחי כו׳.
But the explanation is that the quality of the one is not like the quality of the other: although the inanimate is lower in rank than the vegetative, it nevertheless has an added superiority by virtue of its root, which is above the level of the vegetative and the animal, etc.
The answer is that each level has its own advantage. The inanimate is lower in its revealed rank, yet its root stands higher than the roots of plant and animal life.
דהנה ידוע מחלוקת התנאים2 בגמ׳ [בגמרא] (חגיגה יב.)3 חד אמר שמים קדמו4 לארץ כמ״ש בראשית ברא5 כו׳ את השמים ואת הארץ6
For the dispute of the Tannaim in the Gemara (Chagigah 12a) is well known: one says the heavens preceded the earth, as it is written, “In the beginning [G‑d] created,” etc., “the heavens and the earth.”
To explain this root, the maamar cites a dispute recorded in the Talmud, in tractate Chagigah, over whether the heavens or the earth were created first. One view relies on the Torah’s first verse, which names the heavens before the earth.
וח״א [וחלק א׳] ארץ קדמה כמ״ש ביום עשות7 כו׳ ארץ ושמים ואלו ואלו דא״ח [דברי אלקים חיים] שבמחשבה ארץ קדמה לשמים וכשברא ברא השמים תחלה.8
And the other says the earth preceded, as it is written, “On the day [G‑d] made,” etc., “earth and heavens.” And both these and those are the words of the living G‑d: in thought the earth preceded the heavens, and when He created, He created the heavens first.
The other view relies on a verse that names the earth first. Using the Talmud’s phrase for two opinions that are both true (Eruvin 13b), “these and those are the words of the living G‑d,” the maamar accepts both: in G‑d’s thought the earth came first, while in the act of creation the heavens came first.
The paragraph raises the puzzle that the lowly earth gives rise to the higher plant life, and begins to resolve it with the dispute over whether the heavens or the earth came first: in thought the earth, in deed the heavens.
A Kehot note records that in the transcript printed in Sefer HaMaamarim 5565, the verse “In the beginning” is not cited. Another note observes that Torah Chaim puts the point that the heavens were created first somewhat differently.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on the time of the Exodus and on whether Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel follow what exists in potential (b’koach) or in actuality (b’po’el), the Rebbe finds the same dispute behind the Gemara’s question of whether heaven or earth was created first.
The Rebbe cites Chassidus, this maamar first (note 44: "תו״א ר״פ ויגש", with Torah Chaim putting it a little differently), that in actual creation „שמים נבראו תחלה” (heaven came first) and in thought and intent (מחשבה וכוונה) the earth came first. He then asks, after the Torah Chaim: if so, the two schools speak of two different things and „אין בזה מחלוקת כלל” (are not disputing at all). He answers that they dispute which is first „תחלה במעלה וחשיבות” (in importance): for Beis Hillel the earth, where „עיקר הכוונה” (the intent) lies; for Beis Shammai heaven, where the earth first exists in potential.
The Alter Rebbe
ואלו ואלו דא״ח שבמחשבה ארץ קדמה לשמים וכשברא ברא השמים תחלה
The Rebbe
ס׳איז אָבער ניט מובן: לפי הנ״ל קומט דאָך אויס, אַז ב״ש און ב״ה ריידן וועגן צוויי באַזונדערע ענינים
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 76–77 (Bo, sicha 2, notes 44 and 47; the sicha begins p. 69) · אחש״פ וש״פ קדושים תשכ״ז
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaber
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר explained hereEvery world has these four: the inanimate is lowest, then the growing and the living, and the speaking is the highest. Yet the earth brings forth plants, because the inanimate, though lower in rank, has an advantage in its root, above the growing and the living: in G‑d’s thought the earth came before the heavens.
שיש בכל עולם ד׳ בחי׳ דצח״מ והדומם הוא למטה במדרגה מצומח והצומח למטה מן החי
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2מחלוקת התנאים · ראה בלקו״ש ח״ו ע׳ 78 ובהערה 60.
- 3בגמרא (חגיגה יב) · ע״א. ראה לקו״ת צו יג, ד. ראה כז, ב. שמע״צ עט, ד. סה״מ תקס״ח ח״ב ע׳ שכג. אוה״ת בראשית כרך ג תפז, א. סה״מ תרכ״ז (הוצאת תש״ס) ע׳ כג.
- 4חד אמר שמים קדמו · ראה גם לקמן פט, א. סה״מ תרכ״ט ע׳ כג וע׳ שצח. ובלקו״ש ח״ו ע׳ 76 ואילך.
- 5בראשית ברא · Genesis 1:1
- 6
- 7ביום עשות · Genesis 2:4
- 8וכשברא ברא השמים תחילה · בד״ה כי המצוה הזאת תרס״ו. ובתו״ח כאן באו״א קצת. — וראה בלקו״ש שם.
The explanation is that “last in deed is first in thought.” That is: because the earth is last in deed, therefore its root in thought is in the level of the beginning of thought,
“Last in deed, first in thought” is a line from the Shabbos hymn Lecha Dodi: what is completed last was intended first. The earth, the last stage of creation in deed, therefore has its root at the very beginning of G‑d’s thought.
אבל השמים שהם תחלת המעשה הם אחרוני׳ במחשבה כי זהו הכלל שהסוף מעשה עולה תחלה במחשבה3 ולכך הצומח למעלה מהדומם
whereas the heavens, which are first in deed, are last in thought. For this is the rule: what is last in deed arises first in thought. And therefore the vegetative is above the inanimate,
The heavens, which came first in deed, were last in thought. In the order of deed the higher comes first, and so the vegetative ranks above the inanimate.
וכן החי למעלה מהצומח כו׳ שזהו כפי סדר ההשתלשלות דדצח״מ [דדומם צומח חי מדבר] בעולמות שבחי׳ הדומם ועפר הארץ הוא בחי׳ סוף מעשה וצומח וחי למעלה ממנו במדרגה
and likewise the animal is above the vegetative, etc., for this follows the order of the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) of inanimate, vegetative, animal and speaking in the worlds, in which the level of the inanimate and the dust of the earth is the level of “last in deed,” and the vegetative and the animal are above it in rank.
The animal ranks above the vegetative as well. In the order in which the four kingdoms descend through the worlds, the inanimate dust of the earth is the final stage.
והוא ענין שמים קדמו לארץ. ומ״מ מצד שרשן במחשבה הקדומה הרי ארץ דוקא קדמה לכולם במחשבה.
And this is the meaning of “the heavens preceded the earth.” Nevertheless, from the aspect of their root in the Primordial Thought, it is specifically the earth that preceded them all in thought.
The descending order of the worlds is what “the heavens preceded the earth” means. In the Primordial Thought, however, the earth preceded all the other levels.
לכן דוקא בה יש הכח והיכולת להוציא צמחה4 מצד שרשה הנעלה ולכן הצומח והחי והמדבר כולם מקבלים ממנה כו׳:
Therefore it is specifically in it that there is the power and the ability to “bring forth its growth,” by virtue of its exalted root; and therefore the vegetative, the animal and the speaking all receive from it, etc.
Because of its exalted root, the earth alone has the power to bring forth growth, and plants, animals and human beings all draw their sustenance from it. This answers the puzzle raised in paragraph 2.
¶2 This answers the question from paragraph 2.
The paragraph explains the principle “last in deed, first in thought”: the earth, last in the order of creation, was first in G‑d’s thought, and this hidden root gives it the power to produce the growth that sustains all higher life.
A Kehot note quotes Likkutei Sichos: because the earth arose first in thought, it has the distinction and the power to make things grow from nothing into something, which the heavens lack. Another note cites Sefer HaMaamarim 5644, which explains that what is last in deed is first in thought because the main intent is fulfilled only at the end, as is seen in every physical act of giving.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In the second sicha on Shemos in Likkutei Sichos vol. 6 (from talks of Shabbos Balak 5724 and Shabbos Shemos 5726), asking why the Egyptians made the Jews build with bricks („עשיית לבנים”), the Rebbe explains from this maamar why the Beis HaMikdash rose above the Mishkan, and in note 57 he sharpens this paragraph’s rule, „סוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה” (“last in deed is first in thought”).
In a note the Rebbe sets the rule of this paragraph, „סוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה” (“last in deed is first in thought”), apart from the saying „נעוץ תחלתן בסופן” (“their beginning is wedged in their end”), a distinction the Mitteler Rebbe already draws in Torah Chaim, his long version of this maamar (chapter 1). In the Rebbe’s words, there the “end” is „לסיום וגמר ההשפעה” (the completion of the giving), rooted in the giving’s start; “last in deed” is „קבלת ההשפעה” (the receiving of the flow), and it reaches “first in thought,” before even the beginning of thought, „למעלה משרש ההשפעה” (above the root of the giving). He cites for this his own maamar of 5724 and Torah Chaim (chapters 2–3), and later in the sicha (note 65) he points to Torah Chaim for the Beis HaMikdash, where the inanimate itself became a vessel, as the place where “last in deed is first in thought” was revealed.
The Alter Rebbe
כי זהו הכלל שהסוף מעשה עולה תחלה במחשבה
The Rebbe
משא״כ „סוף מעשה” הו״ע קבלת ההשפּעה, ובחינה זו מגעת ב„מחשבה תחלה” היינו תחילה אפילו לפני תחלת המחשבה
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 19, note 57 (Shemos, sicha 2; the sicha begins p. 6) · ש״פ בלק תשכ״ד וש״פ שמות תשכ״ו
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsSof maaseh bemachshavah techilahMachshavah hakedumahDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaberHishtalshelus
- Sof maaseh bemachshavah techilah סוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה explained hereThe earth, last in deed, is rooted at the beginning of thought, while the heavens, first in deed, are last in thought. In the order of descent the vegetative stands above the inanimate and the animal above the vegetative, yet the earth preceded them all in the primordial thought; so it alone can bring forth growth, and all receive from it.
כי זהו הכלל שהסוף מעשה עולה תחלה במחשבה
- Machshavah hakedumah מחשבה הקדומה explained here“The end of the deed is first in thought”: in the order of the worlds the heavens came first and earth, the inanimate, is lowest, but in their root in the primordial thought earth came before all. So earth has the power to bring forth plants, and the growing, living and speaking all receive from it.
ומ״מ מצד שרשן במחשבה הקדומה הרי ארץ דוקא קדמה לכולם במחשבה
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
Marei mekomos
- 1סוף מעשה במחשבה תחלה · פיוט לכה דודי.
- 2הארץ . . בבחי׳ תחלת המחשבה · בלקו״ש ח״ו שם הערה 50 ”דמצד זה שהארץ עלתה במחשבה תחלה, יש בה (עילוי וחשיבות —) הכח להצמיח מאין ליש (שאינו בשמים)”.
- 3עולה תחלה במחשבה · ובסה״מ תרמ״ד ע׳ ריב: היינו לפי שעיקר המכוון נגמר בסוף, וכמו שאנו רואים למטה בגשמי׳ בכל השפעה שעיקר המכוון נשלם בסוף, ע״ש בארוכה.
- 4לכן דוקא בה יש הכח והיכולת להוציא צמחה · ראה אגה״ק סי׳ כ (קלב, א). אוה״ת ויקרא כרך ב ע׳ תמד.
The Mishkan and the present order ¶4–6
4והנה במשכן לא היה נמצא עדיין תכלית השלימות שהיה רק דירת עראי12 של הקב״ה. כמ״ש ואהיה מתהלך באהל3 ובמשכן כו׳.
Now, in the Mishkan the ultimate perfection was not yet present, for it was only a temporary dwelling of the Holy One, blessed be He, as it is written, “And I have been moving about in a tent and in a Mishkan,” etc.
The Mishkan had not yet reached the ultimate perfection: it was only a temporary dwelling for G‑d, carried from place to place through the desert. G‑d’s words to King David through the prophet Nasan, “I have been moving about in a tent and in a Mishkan,” describe that temporary dwelling.
לכך נעשה כפי אופן סדר השתלשלות העולמות איך שנבראו כסדרן שבזה שמים קדמו לארץ.
Therefore it was made according to the pattern of the order of the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus), the way they were created in their sequence, in which the heavens preceded the earth.
Because it was temporary, the Mishkan was built according to the present order of the worlds, in which the heavens precede the earth.
Since the Mishkan was only G‑d’s temporary dwelling, it was built according to the present order of creation, in which the higher comes first.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5746
The Alter Rebbe explains the Mishkan’s structure by its being a temporary dwelling that follows the present order of hishtalshelus, while the Mikdash anticipates the future. The Rebbe turns this into two stages of avodah. The Mishkan is the beginning of avodah, from below upward, where spirituality is the main thing. The Mikdash is the completion of avodah, where the superiority of the inanimate is revealed.
The Alter Rebbe
שהיה רק דירת עראי של הקב״ה
The Rebbe
כמו ההפרש בין תחילת הענין והעבודה ושלימות הענין והעבודה
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
TermsHishtalshelus
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
Marei mekomos
- 1דירת עראי · Shir HaShirim Rabbah 1:16:3
- 2דירת עראי · Zohar, Pekudei 40:380–390
- 3ואהיה מתהלך באהל · II Samuel 7:6
5ולכן כותלי המשכן היו מקרשים שהן בחי׳ צומח. ורק קרקע המשכן הי׳ [היה] מעפר. שזהו כמו שהוא בהשתלשלות שהצומח למעלה מן הדומם
Therefore the walls of the Mishkan were of boards, which are the level of the vegetative, and only the floor of the Mishkan was of earth. For this is as it is in the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus), where the vegetative is above the inanimate.
The Mishkan’s walls were boards of wood, from the vegetative kingdom, and only its floor was earth. This matches the present order, in which the vegetative ranks above the inanimate.
¶1 This begins answering the question from paragraph 1.
ולכן נעשו הקרשים מארזים שהארז גדל בגובה מאד שזהו בחי׳ העליונה שבצומח כו׳ למעלה מעלה מבחי׳ הדומם שאין בו תוספת וגידול כלל.
And therefore the boards were made of cedars, for the cedar grows very tall, which is the highest level within the vegetative, etc., far, far above the level of the inanimate, which has no addition or growth at all.
The boards were of cedar, which grows exceptionally tall and so represents the highest form of the vegetative. The inanimate, by contrast, never adds to itself or grows at all.
The Mishkan’s wooden walls rising over a floor of earth mirrored the present order, in which what grows ranks above what is inanimate.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on the Rambam’s ruling that the Mikdash stood on rising ground and not on level ground, the Rebbe sets out “in the style of Chassidus” how the Mishkan differs from the Mikdash, citing this maamar (note 39).
Retelling the Mishkan as this maamar describes it, the Rebbe notes: „כ״ה בתו״א. וצ״ע שלא נזכרו שם האדנים שהיו דומם” (“So it is in Torah Ohr, and it needs investigation that the sockets, which were inanimate, are not mentioned there”). Torah Chaim does mention „אדני הקרשים דמשכן מדומם דכסף” (the silver sockets under the boards), and in his own retelling the sockets and the earth floor together are the Mishkan’s inanimate level, below the wooden boards („קרשי המשכן”).
The Alter Rebbe
ולכן כותלי המשכן היו מקרשים שהן בחי׳ צומח. ורק קרקע המשכן הי׳ מעפר
The Rebbe
כ״ה בתו״א. וצ״ע שלא נזכרו שם האדנים שהיו דומם
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כט, p. 76, note 40 (Re’eh, sicha 1; the sicha begins p. 71) · ש״פ מסעי תשד״מ
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5746
The Rebbe points to a detail he says goes unnoticed. The earth of the Mishkan floor is the earth of the sotah law, and that applied in the Mikdash as well (Mishnah Sotah). So the completion of avodah also contains lower bittul. He resolves this through the sotah theme. Sin comes from a “spirit of folly,” yet through teshuvah the lower bittul of the floor’s earth leads to the higher bittul of the roof, beyond the level held before the descent (“she will conceive seed”). He connects this to Chana, to Shmuel, and to Shmuel anointing David with a horn, the source of his eternal kingship.
The Alter Rebbe
ורק קרקע המשכן הי׳ מעפר
The Rebbe
שגם במקדש (שלימות העבודה) יש בחי׳ עפר אשר בקרקע המשכן
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaberHishtalshelus
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
6והמכסה על המשכן היה מיריעות ומעורות אילים ותחשים כו׳ שהוא בחינת החי שלמעלה במדרגה גם מבחי׳ הצומח.
And the covering over the Mishkan was of curtains and of rams’ and tachash skins, etc., which is the level of the animal, which is higher in rank even than the level of the vegetative.
The Mishkan’s coverings were curtains and animal skins, from the animal kingdom, which ranks higher still than the vegetative.
לפיכך היריעות שהם בחי׳ המקיפים שהיו פרושי׳ [פרושים] על כותלי המשכן היו מבחי׳ חי שהוא למעל׳ [למעלה / למעלת] מבחי׳ צומח שממנו נעשו כותלי המשכן.
Therefore the curtains, which are the level of the makifim (the encompassing) and were spread over the walls of the Mishkan, were from the level of the animal, which is above the level of the vegetative, from which the walls of the Mishkan were made.
The curtains spread over the walls are called makifim, “encompassing” elements, the term Chassidus uses for what surrounds and transcends. Fittingly, they came from the animal kingdom, the level above the vegetative boards they covered.
נמצא שכ״ז [שכל זה] נעש׳ כפי סדר מעלת ומדרגת ההשתלשלות בהשתלשלותן ובריאותן מלמעלמ״ט [מלמעלה למטה] שהוא בחי׳ שמים קדמו כו׳.
It follows that all this was made according to the order of rank and level of the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus), as they descend and are created from above to below, which is the level of “the heavens preceded,” etc.
The Mishkan was thus arranged like the worlds themselves, from the top down: animal over vegetative over inanimate, the order of “the heavens preceded.”
אבל במקדש היה נמצא בו תכלית השלימות כי היה דירת קבע1 של הקב״ה כמ״ש זאת מנוחתי עדי עד2 שהי׳ [שהיה] מעין עוה״ב [עולם הבא] מה שיהי׳ [שיהיה] באלף השביעי כשיהי׳ [כשיהיה] מנוחה לחיי העולמים3 שאז תתעלה הארץ עליונה שהיא בחי׳ מל׳ דאצי׳ להיות למעלה מכולם.
But in the Mikdash the ultimate perfection was present, for it was a permanent dwelling of the Holy One, blessed be He, as it is written, “This is My resting place forever,” for it was a foretaste of the World to Come, of what will be in the seventh millennium, when there will be “rest for life everlasting”; for then the supernal earth, which is the level of Malchus (sovereignty) of the World of Atzilus (Emanation), will be elevated to be above them all.
The Beis HaMikdash, by contrast, was G‑d’s permanent dwelling and reached the ultimate perfection; the verse “This is My resting place forever,” said of Zion, marks it as permanent. It was a foretaste of the seventh millennium, the era of complete rest, when the “supernal earth,” Malchus of Atzilus, the last of the divine attributes, will be raised above all the others.
The Mishkan’s layers of earth, wood and skins followed the present order of the worlds, while the Beis HaMikdash, G‑d’s permanent home, foreshadowed the future, when Malchus, the “earth,” will rise above all.
A Kehot note quotes Likkutei Sichos: the Mishkan was a temporary dwelling and the Beis HaMikdash a permanent one because a revelation drawn only from above does not penetrate inwardly to the same degree, and an arousal from above that is not followed at once by service from below does not endure. Another note cites Hemshech Mayim Rabbim 5636, which asks how a building of stones and lime can be called a “rest” and an inheritance for the living G‑d.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In the same sicha on the bricks of Egypt, the Rebbe asks why the Mishkan was built of the vegetative (צומח) at all, since it too had earth and G‑d dwelt in it, and answers by explaining the two orders this paragraph describes.
The Rebbe explains why the Mishkan ran „בדרך מלמעלה למטה” (from the top down) and the Mikdash made the inanimate (דומם) its main substance. When G‑dliness reaches the lowest it can show in two ways: „תוקף בלתי מוגבל” (the boundless power) of the light, which reaches even the lowest, like „איש החסד” (a man of kindness) whose good reaches the lowliest; or the lowest itself becoming a vessel that „מכיר גדולתו ית׳” (recognizes G‑d). The Mishkan showed the first, so the light came down level by level and the earth received last; the Mikdash showed the second, so the inanimate came first.
The Alter Rebbe
נמצא שכ״ז נעש׳ כפי סדר מעלת ומדרגת ההשתלשלות בהשתלשלותן ובריאותן מלמעלמ״ט
The Rebbe
איז דאָך מובן, אַז דער עיקר החשיבות איז אין דעם תחתון וואָס „אין תחתון למטה ממנו”. און דערפאַר איז אין ביהמ״ק געווען דומם דער עיקר
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 18–21 (Shemos, sicha 2, sections ו–ט; the sicha begins p. 6) · ש״פ בלק תשכ״ד וש״פ שמות תשכ״ו
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsOlam HaBaDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaberOr MakifHishtalshelus+2
- Olam HaBa עולם הבא
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
- Malchus מלכות
- Atzilus אצילות
Marei mekomos
- 1במקדש — כי הי׳ דירת קבע · באוה״ת פ׳ ויגש כרך ב שנ, א. באוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ לה פי׳ קבע ע״ד אהל בל יצען הנזכר בלקו״ת סד״ה שובה ישראל עד דרוש השני. ע״ש בארוכה. ראה גם אוה״ת בלק ע׳ א׳לז. ובלקו״ש לפ׳ שמות ח״ו ע׳ 21 הערה 66 כ׳: ”וזהו גם הטעם מה שהמשכן הי׳ דירת עראי של הקב״ה וביהמ״ק דירת קבע, כי כשהגילוי נמשך רק מלמעלה, אינו חודר בפנימיות כ״כ (ולהעיר מלקו״ת ויקרא (ב, ג-ד), שאתערותא דלעילא מצד עצמה — כשאין אחרי׳ מיד עבודה מלמטלמ״ע — אין לה קיום)”. ראה ד״ה ודוד עבדי תשל״ב הנ״ל.
- 2זאת מנוחתי עדי עד · Psalms 132:14
- 3מנוחה לחיי העולמים · Mishnah Tamid 7:4
The Beis HaMikdash and the future order ¶7–8
7וכמ״ש אשת חיל עט״ב [עטרת בעלה]1 שתהי׳ [שתהיה] עטרת לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] לז״א דאצילות. והיינו מצד שרשה שעלתה במחשבה הקדומה תחלה ארץ קדמה לשמים.
And as it is written, “A woman of valor is the crown of her husband”: in the Time to Come she will be a crown to Z’eir Anpin (the emotive attributes) of Atzilus. And this is by virtue of her root, which arose first in the Primordial Thought: “the earth preceded the heavens.”
In the language of Kabbalah, the “woman of valor” is Malchus, the receiving attribute, and her “husband” is Z’eir Anpin, the emotive attributes that now give to her; in the Time to Come she will be a crown above him. This reversal comes from her root, which preceded everything in the Primordial Thought.
לכן אף בבהמ״ק [בבית המקדש] שהי׳ [שהיה] מעין עוה״ב [עולם הבא] נעשה עיקר הבית מאבנים ועפר שהם בחי׳ דומם שאף הגג והמעזיבה שהיא בחי׳ המקיף נעשה מאבנים ועפר ולא מארזים
Therefore, even in the Beis HaMikdash, which was a foretaste of the World to Come, the main part of the House was made of stones and earth, which are the level of the inanimate, so that even the roof and the roof-plaster (ma’azivah), which is the level of the makif (the encompassing), were made of stones and earth, and not of cedars.
Because the Beis HaMikdash foreshadowed that future, it was built mainly of stone and earth, the inanimate. Even its roof and the plaster layer on top, which surround the building from above like a makif, were of stone and earth, not of cedar.
שהוא כפי מה שיהיה לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] שבחי׳ ארץ קדמה א״ח [אשת חיל] עט״ב [עטרת בעלה] מצד שרשה כו׳
This is in keeping with what will be in the Time to Come, when the level of “the earth preceded” [will be] “a woman of valor, the crown of her husband,” by virtue of her root, etc.
This reflected the future order, in which the “earth,” rooted first in thought, becomes the crown.
רק שכלונסאות של ארז שהיה בהתקרה הם היו בחי׳ תמכין לבד לעיקר התקרה הנעשה מבחי׳ דומם וכענין תמכין דאורייתא. (ועמ״ש במ״א ע״פ מחר חדש2 במ״ש יהונתן לדוד ואנכי אהיה לך למשנה כו׳):3
Only, the cedar beams that were in the ceiling were merely the level of supports (tamchin) for the main ceiling, which was made from the level of the inanimate, like the concept of “the supporters of the Torah” (tamchin de’Oraisa). (And see what is written elsewhere, on the verse “Tomorrow is the New Moon,” on what Yehonasan said to David, “and I will be second to you,” etc.)
The few cedar beams in the ceiling only supported the stone roof, like “the supporters of the Torah,” a term for what upholds the Torah without being the Torah itself. The parenthesis points to another discourse, on Yehonasan’s words to David, “and I will be second to you,” in which the heir of King Shaul accepts second place to David of the tribe of Yehudah.
The Beis HaMikdash, a foretaste of the future, was built of stone and earth because in the Time to Come Malchus, the “earth,” will become the crown; its cedar beams served only as supports.
The cross-reference to Yehonasan and David appears again in paragraph 13, among the discourses on the future union of Yosef and Yehudah.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In the maamar “Vayigash” of 5736 (edited, with the Rebbe’s notes), explaining „שעכשיו תלמוד גדול הוא לפי שתלמוד מביא לידי מעשה” (that study is “greater” now only because it leads to deed), the Rebbe points in a note to this paragraph.
The Rebbe notes that in the Mikdash „הצומח (כלונסאות של ארז) הי׳ טפל להדומם” (the vegetative, the cedar beams, was subordinate to the inanimate) because the Mikdash was „מעין עוה״ב” (“a foretaste of the World to Come”), when the advantage of the inanimate will be revealed. This subordination, he writes, is not like „גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה” (“study is greater, for it leads to deed”), where the higher serves the lower, but like „מעשה גדול” (“deed is greater”), the rule of the future.
The Alter Rebbe
לכן אף בבהמ״ק שהי׳ מעין עוה״ב נעשה עיקר הבית מאבנים ועפר שהם בחי׳ דומם
The Rebbe
והרי זה שבביהמ״ק הי׳ הצומח טפל להדומם הוא (לא ע״ד גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה, כי אם) ע״ד מעשה גדול
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. ריז, note 29 · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשל״ו
A question the Rebbe raises
In the same sicha, having said that in the Mikdash the cedar was only secondary (טפל) to the stone, the Rebbe raises a difficulty in a note.
The Rebbe asks: the ceiling of the Mikdash had „גבים ושדרות בארזים” (beams and planks of cedar; I Kings 6:9), which is the vegetative. He points toward the answer from the Mishnah (Middos 4:6), that over them lay a plaster (מעזיבה) of stones and lime, and from this paragraph and Torah Chaim, that „הכלונסאות של ארז שהי׳ בתקרה הם היו תמכין לבד לעיקר התקרה הנעשה מבחי׳ דומם” (the cedar beams were “only supports for the main ceiling, which was made of the inanimate”), holding up the plaster alone.
The Alter Rebbe
רק שכלונסאות של ארז שהיה בהתקרה הם היו בחי׳ תמכין לבד לעיקר התקרה הנעשה מבחי׳ דומם
The Rebbe
ולכאורה צע״ק מתקרת ביהמ״ק שהי׳ גבים ושדרות בארזים (מ״א ו, ט) — צומח
Likkutei Sichos, vol. ו, p. 20, note 62 (Shemos, sicha 2; the sicha begins p. 6) · ש״פ בלק תשכ״ד וש״פ שמות תשכ״ו
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5746
The Alter Rebbe states that even the encompassing roof of the Mikdash was inanimate. The Rebbe reads this as avodah in all its details joined with bittul, and asks how the two can coexist, since bittul denies one’s existence while avodah requires “all your heart.” Drawing on Hemshech 5666, he answers with the complete servant and the highest level of shlichus. The servant’s pleasure, will, intellect and emotions all remain, but they are the master’s. True bittul therefore does not negate the powers.
The Alter Rebbe
שאף הגג והמעזיבה שהיא בחי׳ המקיף נעשה מאבנים ועפר
The Rebbe
איך אפשר שתהי׳ עבודת ה׳ יחד עם ענין הביטול
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsEshes chayil ateres baalahMachshavah hakedumahOlam HaBaDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaber+6
- Eshes chayil ateres baalah אשת חיל עטרת בעלה explained hereShe will crown Z’eir Anpin of Atzilus by virtue of her root, which arose first in the Primordial Thought: “the earth preceded the heavens.” So the Beis HaMikdash, a foretaste of the World to Come, was built chiefly of stones and earth, even its roof, with cedar beams only as supports.
והיינו מצד שרשה שעלתה במחשבה הקדומה תחלה ארץ קדמה לשמים
- Machshavah hakedumah מחשבה הקדומה
- Olam HaBa עולם הבא
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Anochi אנכי
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Z’eir Anpin זעיר אנפין
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Atzilus אצילות
Also Torah
Marei mekomos
- 1אשת חיל עט״ב · Proverbs 12:4
- 2מחר חדש · I Samuel 20:18
- 3
8והנה נראה בעליל ג״כ בחי׳ זו שיש בהארץ מעלה יתירה והוא בחי׳ הבטול שיש בה שהיא מדרס תחת כפות רגלי הכל1 משא״כ הצומח שגדלים בגובה והתנשאות כו׳.
Now, this quality too is plainly visible: the earth has an added superiority, namely the self-nullification (bittul) that is in it, for it is trodden beneath the soles of everyone’s feet; which is not so with the vegetative, which grows in height and elevation, etc.
The earth’s advantage can be seen with the eyes: it lies beneath everyone’s feet, a picture of complete self-nullification. Plants, by contrast, grow upward and stand tall.
ובטול זה נמשך מצד שרשה הנעלה במחשבה שהמחשבה היא בחי׳ חשב מ״ה [מה] שהוא תכלית מד, אהבטול כמ״ש מרע״ה [משה רבינו עליו השלום] ונחנו מ״ה [מה].2
And this self-nullification is drawn from its exalted root in thought, for thought (machshavah) is the level of chashav mah, which is the ultimate self-nullification, as Moshe Rabbeinu, peace be upon him, said, “And what (mah) are we?”
The earth’s self-nullification comes from its root in thought. The letters of machshavah, “thought” (מחשבה), can be read as chashav mah (חשב מה), the “what?” of utter self-effacement, the same mah with which Moshe and Aharon said of themselves, “And what are we?”
ומשם נמשך ומתלבש בחי׳ הבטול בארץ ומצד זה תתעלה לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] להיות עט״ב [עטרת בעלה] לכן היה בהמ״ק [בית המקדש] מאבנים דוקא
And from there the quality of self-nullification is drawn down and enclothed in the earth, and because of this it will be elevated in the Time to Come to be “the crown of her husband.” Therefore the Beis HaMikdash was of stones specifically.
The self-nullification of thought flows down and is clothed in the earth, and because of it the earth will be raised in the future to be a crown. It is also why the Beis HaMikdash had to be built of stone.
(וכמ״ש ג״כ במ״א ע״פ מזמור שיר חנוכת הבית34 דלכך אמרו בגמרא על כורש שהחמיץ במה שחזר וצוה לערב בחי׳ צומח בבהמ״ק [בבית המקדש] נדבכין די אבן גלל5 תלתא ונדבך די אע חדת כו׳ כי צ״ל כולו באבנים דוקא מטעם הנ״ל.7
(As is also written elsewhere, on the verse “A psalm, a song for the dedication of the House”: this is why they said in the Gemara about Koresh (Cyrus) that he soured, in that he went back and commanded to mix the level of the vegetative into the Beis HaMikdash, “three rows of great stones and a row of new wood,” etc. For it had to be entirely of stones specifically, for the reason stated above.
The parenthesis cites a discourse on the psalm for the dedication of the House. The Gemara says that Koresh (Cyrus), who permitted the building of the Second Temple, later “soured,” and the discourse explains the fault: he ordered a row of wood laid among the rows of stone, mixing the vegetative into a building that had to be entirely of stone.
ובתפלה הוא בחי׳ השתחואות שבשמ״ע [שבשמונה עשרה] קול דממה דקה.6 בחי׳ דומם ואותיות התפלה הם בחינת דומם)
And in prayer, this is the level of the bowings in the Shemoneh Esreh, “a still, small voice” (kol demamah dakah), the level of the inanimate (domem); and the letters of prayer are the level of the inanimate.)
The same holds in prayer: the bowing in the Shemoneh Esreh, a prayer said in “a still, small voice,” belongs to the inanimate level of self-nullification, and so do the letters of prayer. The Hebrew for “still,” demamah, shares its root with domem, “inanimate.”
משא״כ בהמשכן שנעשה כפי סדר ההשתלשלות דעכשיו שבחי׳ צומח למעלה מהדומם שמים קדמו כו׳ לכן היו הכותלי׳ [הכותלים] מעצי שטים והעפר היה בקרקע המשכן וכנ״ל:
This is not so with the Mishkan, which was made according to the order of the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) as it is now, in which the level of the vegetative is above the inanimate, “the heavens preceded,” etc. Therefore the walls were of acacia wood, and the earth was in the floor of the Mishkan, as stated above.
The Mishkan, by contrast, followed the present order, in which the vegetative ranks above the inanimate, so its walls were of wood and only its floor was earth.
The earth’s lowliness under every foot reveals its root in the self-nullification of divine thought; this is why the Beis HaMikdash, like the bowing of prayer, belongs to the inanimate, while the Mishkan followed the present order.
A Kehot note identifies the discourse on “A psalm, a song for the dedication of the House” as probably the maamar of that title from 5565, said before this one on Friday night of Shabbos Parshas Vayigash, “on the dedication of the House”; the maamar “The beams of our houses” is marked as said on that same dedication, in Parshas Vayechi. Another note points to the Midrash’s image of dust as something that is trodden, which the commentary Matnos Kehunah explains: everyone treads on it.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In the maamar “VeDavid avdi” of Shabbos Vayigash 5732 (edited, with the Rebbe’s notes), explaining why Malchus is self-nullified, the Rebbe begins from this paragraph’s reason for the earth’s bittul (ביטול).
The Rebbe quotes this paragraph: the earth’s bittul, „שהיא מדרס תחת כפות רגלי הכל” (being trodden beneath everyone’s feet), comes from its root, since „במחשבה ארץ קדמה לשמים” (in thought the earth preceded the heavens); so too the inanimate’s bittul comes from a root above the vegetative’s. In a note he separates the two: „הביטול דדומם הוא שאינו גדל בגובה כהצומח” (the bittul of the inanimate is that it does not grow tall like a plant), it has no quality to show; „הביטול דארץ הוא שהיא מדרס תחת רגלי הכל” (the bittul of the earth is that it is trodden under everyone’s feet).
The Alter Rebbe
והוא בחי׳ הבטול שיש בה שהיא מדרס תחת כפות רגלי הכל משא״כ הצומח שגדלים בגובה והתנשאות כו׳
The Rebbe
הביטול דדומם הוא שאינו גדל בגובה כהצומח (היינו שאין בו מעלה), והביטול דארץ הוא שהיא מדרס תחת רגלי הכל
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רי–ריא, note 26 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5748
The Alter Rebbe links the inanimate’s bittul to the bowings of the Shemoneh Esreh. The Rebbe moves the Yosef–Yehudah pair into the person’s own prayer. The Amidah, total bittul, is Yehudah (‘this time I will thank… and she stopped bearing’). The blessing of redemption before it is Yosef, ‘addition,’ especially when the redemption comes ‘in peace.’ Joining the two is the union of Yehudah and Yosef.
The Alter Rebbe
ובתפלה הוא בחי׳ השתחואות שבשמ״ע קול דממה דקה
The Rebbe
וזהו ענין סמיכת גאולה לתפלה, דהיינו יחוד וחיבור יהודה ויוסף
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsChinuchRomemusDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaberMah and Ban+6
- Chinuch חינוך
- Romemus רוממות
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Mah and Ban מ״ה וב״ן
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Tefillah תפלה
- Osiyos אותיות
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
Also HislabshusBittul
Marei mekomos
- 1שהיא מדרס תחת כפות רגלי הכל · Bereshit Rabbah 41:9
- 2ונחנו מ״ה · Exodus 16:7
- 3ע״פ מזמור שיר חנוכת הבית · כנראה הכוונה לד״ה זה משנת תקס״ה שנאמר קודם מאמר זה ורשום עליו ליל ש״ק פ׳ ויגש על חנוכת הבית — ונדפס שם ע׳ קלב ואילך. ועל ד״ה קורות בתינו רשום: ”על חנוכת הבית הנ״ל פ׳ ויחי”. וראה לקו״ת ברכה צט, ד. סידור עם דא״ח כא רע״ג.
- 4מזמור שיר חנוכת הבית · Psalms 30:1
- 5נדבכין די אבן גלל · Ezra 6:4
- 6קול דממה דקה · I Kings 19:12
- 7אמרו בגמ׳ על כורש · Rosh Hashanah 4a:4
Yosef and Yehudah ¶9–12
9והנה זהו ג״כ ענין יוסף ויהודה. שהוא ג״כ בחי׳ ומדרגת שמים וארץ ובחי׳ צומח ודומם כו׳.
Now, this is also the matter of Yosef and Yehudah, which is likewise the level and rank of the heavens and the earth, and the level of the vegetative and the inanimate, etc.
The same contrast, between the heavens and the earth, between what grows and what is inanimate, also describes Yosef and Yehudah.
כי יוסף לשון תוספת ורבוי1 שמתוסף והולך בהגדלה והגבהה למעלה והוא ענין בחי׳ צומח ובפרט בחי׳ הארז שגדל והולך למעלה מעלה ברום המעלות.
For “Yosef” is a term of addition (tosefes) and increase, of what keeps on adding, growing larger and rising higher. This is the matter of the level of the vegetative, and in particular the level of the cedar, which keeps on growing higher and higher, to the loftiest heights.
The name Yosef means “addition”: he is the one who keeps increasing and rising, like the vegetative, and above all like the cedar that keeps on growing taller.
וכמ״ש צדיק כתמר יפרח כארז בלבנון ישגה2 (והיינו בחי׳ ז״א דאצי׳ שנק׳ צומח לגבי המל׳ שנק׳ דומם כמ״ש במ״א באריכות3 שהמדות יש בהם צמיחה וגידול אבל האותיות הן בחי׳ דומם כו׳ ובמדות יש בחי׳ קטנות וגדלות.
As it is written, “The tzaddik will flourish like a palm tree; like a cedar in Lebanon he will grow tall.” (That is, the level of Z’eir Anpin of Atzilus, which is called “vegetative” in relation to Malchus, which is called “inanimate,” as is written elsewhere at length: that the emotive attributes (middos) have sprouting and growth, but the letters are the level of the inanimate, etc. And in the emotive attributes there are the levels of smallness (katnus) and greatness (gadlus).
The verse compares the tzaddik to a palm and a cedar, and Yosef is known as “the tzaddik.” The parenthesis explains that Z’eir Anpin, the divine emotions, is “vegetative” because emotions develop and grow, while Malchus, expressed in letters and speech, is “inanimate”; the emotions also have an immature and a mature stage, “smallness” and “greatness.”
וזהו בחי׳ עץ ארז ואזוב4 שהאזוב הוא בחי׳ הקטנות5 והארז בחי׳ הגדלות כו׳. וז״ש [וזהו שכתוב] כארז בלבנון ישגה כו׳ ויוסף בפרט הוא בחי׳ יסוד שעולה עד הדעת ודעת עולה עד הכתר כו׳. וכשמבריח מעלה מעלה נק׳ ארז בלבנון כו׳)
And this is the level of “cedar wood and hyssop”: the hyssop is the level of smallness and the cedar the level of greatness, etc. And this is [the meaning of] what is written, “like a cedar in Lebanon he will grow tall,” etc. And Yosef in particular is the level of Yesod (foundation), which rises up to Daas (knowledge), and Daas rises up to Keser (the Crown), etc. And when it extends higher and higher, it is called “a cedar in Lebanon,” etc.)
Hyssop, a lowly plant, stands for the immature stage of the emotions, and cedar for their mature stage. Yosef corresponds to Yesod, the attribute that unites and transmits, which rises to Daas and through Daas to Keser; when it rises that high it is called “a cedar in Lebanon.”
ויהודה הוא בחי׳ ארץ מל׳ דאצילות שהיא בחי׳ הדומם דאצי׳. ולכן יהודה ל׳ [לשון] הודאה ובטול שהדומם יש בו בחי׳ הבטול ביותר כנ״ל:
And Yehudah is the level of “earth,” Malchus of Atzilus, which is the level of the inanimate of Atzilus. Therefore “Yehudah” is a term of acknowledgment (hoda’ah) and self-nullification, for the inanimate has the quality of self-nullification most of all, as stated above.
Yehudah is Malchus of Atzilus, the “earth,” the inanimate of that world. His name comes from hoda’ah, acknowledgment and yielding (at his birth Leah said, “This time I will thank Havayah,” Genesis 29:35), the self-nullification that the inanimate has most of all.
Yosef and Yehudah embody the two levels: Yosef, “addition,” is the growing cedar, Z’eir Anpin and Yesod; Yehudah, “acknowledgment,” is the self-nullified earth, Malchus.
A Kehot note records that in the Tzemach Tzedek’s handwritten notebook (the “Buch” of Vayeshev), the verse “The tzaddik will flourish like a palm tree” is not cited. Other notes point to Likkutei Torah, Chukas, for the longer discussion of the emotions as “vegetative” and the letters as “inanimate,” and of hyssop as the level of smallness.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
Continuing in “VeDavid avdi” 5732, the Rebbe compares Malchus to speech, which exists „בשביל הזולת” (for another), and finds this bittul in this paragraph’s explanation of Yehudah’s name.
The Rebbe finds the bittul of Malchus hinted in this paragraph’s words that Yehudah, Malchus, is „לשון הודאה וביטול” (a term of acknowledgment and self-nullification): „שהביטול דהודאה הוא שמבטל את עצמו לזה שהוא מודה אליו” (the bittul of hoda’ah is that one sets oneself aside before the one he acknowledges). It is like speech, Malchus of the soul, in which a person goes out of himself for another’s sake; so Malchus „יורדת להחיות ולהוות את הנבראים” (descends to give life to and bring into being the creatures).
The Alter Rebbe
ולכן יהודה ל׳ הודאה ובטול שהדומם יש בו בחי׳ הבטול ביותר
The Rebbe
ויש לומר, דביטול זה שבמלכות מרומז במ״ש בתו״א שיהודה (מלכות) הוא לשון הודאה וביטול, שהביטול דהודאה הוא שמבטל את עצמו לזה שהוא מודה אליו
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רי–ריא · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
A question the Rebbe raises
At the farbrengen of Shabbos Vayigash, 9 Teves 5746 (unedited), right after saying the maamar “Vayigash” built on this one, the Rebbe raised a general question about this discourse and others like it.
The Rebbe asks „מה ניתוסף בהבנת הענינים כאשר יודעים שענינם של יוסף ויהודה מתאימים לענינם של המשכן וביהמ״ק” (what a reader gains from learning that Yosef and Yehudah match the Mishkan and the Mikdash). In the discourses on „יפה שיחתן של עבדי אבות” (“the talk of the fathers’ servants”), which find the union of Mah and Ban in the marriage of Yitzchak and Rivkah, the details of the story teach details of that union; here, he says, the pairing seems to add nothing to the idea itself, „החילוק שבין סדר השתלשלות דעתה לגבי לעת״ל” (the present order against the future). So why explain the details of the Mishkan and the Mikdash in the discourses of Vayigash, when „מקומם בדרושי הפרשיות תרומה תצוה” (their place is in Terumah and Tetzaveh), or in the discourses on the dedication of the House at the end of Likkutei Torah?
The Alter Rebbe
והנה זהו ג״כ ענין יוסף ויהודה. שהוא ג״כ בחי׳ ומדרגת שמים וארץ ובחי׳ צומח ודומם כו׳
The Rebbe
מה מקום לבאר את פרטי החילוק דמשכן וביהמ״ק בדרושי פ׳ ויגש — בדרושי פ׳ ויגש מתאים לבאר את ענינם של יוסף ויהודה
Toras Menachem – Hisvaaduyos 5746 (unedited), vol. ב, p. 268–269, section יט · ש״פ ויגש, ט׳ טבת, ה׳תשמ״ו
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5748
The Alter Rebbe defines Yosef as growth (the vegetative, the cedar, Z’eir Anpin) and Yehudah as hoda’ah and bittul (the inanimate, Malchus). The Rebbe carries these definitions into avodah: Yosef is Torah study, which adds through understanding, and Ephraim (‘hifrani’) means increase and addition. Yehudah is action: the king rules on practice, and David is ‘My servant’ because service belongs to deed.
The Alter Rebbe
כי יוסף לשון תוספת ורבוי שמתוסף והולך בהגדלה
The Rebbe
שעניני יהודה ויוסף הם ב׳ הענינים דתלמוד (או לימוד) ומעשה
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsHoda’ahShamayim va’aretzKatnus and gadlusYesod+9
- Hoda’ah הודאה
- Shamayim va’aretz שמים וארץ
- Katnus and gadlus קטנות וגדלות
- Yesod יסוד
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Tzaddik צדיק
- Daas דעת
- Keser כתר
- Z’eir Anpin זעיר אנפין
- Osiyos אותיות
- Atzilus אצילות
- Middos מדות
Also Bittul
Marei mekomos
- 1יוסף לשון תוספת ורבוי · עי׳ לעיל לא, א.
- 2צדיק כתמר יפרח כארז בלבנון ישגה · Psalms 92:13
- 3לגבי המל׳ שנק׳ דומם כמ״ש במ״א באריכות · ראה לקו״ת פ׳ חקת נז, ד ואילך.
- 4עץ ארז ואזוב · Numbers 19:6
- 5שהאזוב הוא בחי׳ הקטנות · מאו״א א, נד. לקו״ת חקת ס, ד.
10והנה בסדר ההשתלשלות עתה יוסף הוא למעלה מיהודה שהרי המל׳ מקבלת שפעה וחיותה מן הז״א
Now, in the order of the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) as it is now, Yosef is above Yehudah, for Malchus receives her flow and her life-force from Z’eir Anpin.
In the present order Yosef ranks above Yehudah, since Malchus receives all its flow and life-force from Z’eir Anpin.
ולכן יוסף היה המלך במצרים שהוא בחי׳ צומח בחי׳ גידול והתנשאות והוא היה המשביר והמשפיע לכולם.
And therefore Yosef was the king in Egypt, for he is the level of the vegetative, the level of growth and elevation; and he was the provider of grain and the one who bestowed upon all.
Yosef ruled in Egypt because he is the growing, rising level, and he supplied grain and sustenance to everyone, his brothers included.
In the present order the giver ranks above the receiver, so Yosef, who is Z’eir Anpin, ruled and sustained everyone.
TermsRomemusDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaberZ’eir AnpinHishtalshelus+1
- Romemus רוממות
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Z’eir Anpin זעיר אנפין
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
Also Chayus
11ויהודה הוא המקבל. וז״ש [וזהו שכתוב] ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדני.1 פי׳ שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק2 וכמבואר בזוהר דויגש3 היינו תקרובתא עלמא בעלמא.4
And Yehudah is the recipient. And this is [the meaning of] what is written, “And Yehudah approached him and said, ‘In me (bi), my lord.’” This means that in him the flow from Yosef the tzaddik will be drawn down. And as is explained in the Zohar, “vayigash” (he approached) means “the drawing near of world to world.”
Yehudah, as Malchus, is the one who receives. The words bi adoni, usually understood as “please, my lord,” are read literally, “in me, my lord”: in Yehudah the flow from Yosef will be drawn down. The Zohar explains “he approached” as the drawing near of one world to another.
דהיינו עלמא תתאה בחי׳ מל׳ מתייחדת ונגשת לגבי עלמא עלאה בחי׳ ז״א לקבל השפע כו׳.
That is, the lower world, the level of Malchus, unites with and approaches the upper world, the level of Z’eir Anpin, to receive the flow, etc.
The “lower world,” Malchus, unites with and draws near to the “upper world,” Z’eir Anpin, in order to receive its flow.
וזהו ע״ד שהיה במשכן הצומח למעלה מהדומם כנ״ל. אבל לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] יתעלה יהודה להיות למעלה מבחי׳ יוסף כמ״ש א״ח [אשת חיל] עט״ב [עטרת בעלה] מצד שרשו שעלה במחשבה תחלה כנ״ל.
And this is like what was in the Mishkan, where the vegetative was above the inanimate, as stated above. But in the Time to Come Yehudah will be elevated to be above the level of Yosef, as it is written, “A woman of valor is the crown of her husband,” by virtue of his root, which arose first in thought, as stated above.
The order of the Mishkan, with the giver above the receiver, is the present order. In the Time to Come it will be reversed and Yehudah will rise above Yosef, as the “woman of valor” becomes her husband’s crown, because his root arose first in thought.
כי הנה מחשבה הוא חשב מ״ה [שם מ״ה] דהיינו תכלית הבטול שהוא בחי׳ חכ׳ [חכמה] דאצי׳ כח מ״ה [מה].5
For thought (machshavah) is chashav mah, that is, the ultimate self-nullification, which is the level of Chochmah (wisdom) of Atzilus, koach mah (the power of “what”).
Thought is chashav mah, complete self-nullification, which is Chochmah of Atzilus. The word Chochmah (חכמה) is read as koach mah (כח מה), “the power of ‘what’”: wisdom begins in a mind that regards itself as nothing.
Yehudah approaching Yosef is Malchus drawing near to Z’eir Anpin to receive, the present order; in the future the receiver will rise above the giver, because its root is in the self-nullification of Chochmah.
A Kehot note cites the Rebbe’s maamar “VeDavid Avdi” 5732, which asks why the text says the flow will be drawn “in him”: since Yehudah was the one making the request of Yosef, one would expect him to ask that Yosef draw the flow down to him.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In “VeDavid avdi” 5732 the Rebbe raises the question on this sentence that our commentary records from Kehot’s note, and answers it.
The question: Yehudah was asking Yosef, so he should have asked that Yosef draw the flow to him; why „שבו יומשך השפע” (“that in him the flow will be drawn”)? The Rebbe answers from lights and vessels: „ששורש הכלים הוא למעלה משורש האורות” (the vessels’ root is above the lights’), and the giver senses this. Usually Z’eir Anpin gives to Malchus so that its own giving be complete; Yehudah’s „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni”) asked that the flow be drawn for Malchus’s own sake, “in me,” and through this alone Yosef becomes „כמוך כפרעה, עליית ז״א לעצם הכתר” (“like Pharaoh,” rising to the essence of Keser).
The Alter Rebbe
וז״ש ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדני. פי׳ שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק
The Rebbe
אמר יהודה ליוסף בי אדוני, שהמשכת השפע מז״א למלכות תהי׳ (לא בכדי שההמשכה דז״א תהי׳ בשלימות, אלא) בכדי שבהמלכות יומשך השפע
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. ריא–רבי, section ז and note 33 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
The Rebbe explainsThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
“VeDavid avdi” 5732 opens by asking how the haftorah, where David of Yehudah rules („ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם”), fits Vayigash, where Yosef stands above Yehudah; in section ב the Rebbe answers from the structure of this maamar.
The Rebbe asks: since “Vayigash” means Yosef above Yehudah, a maamar opening with Vayigash would not seem the place to explain „שביהמ״ק הי׳ מדומם” (why the Mikdash was of stone). That this maamar does so shows, he says, that though outwardly Vayigash means Z’eir Anpin above Malchus, within it, „בפנימיות ובהעלם, המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א” (inwardly and hidden, lies Malchus’s superiority), like what will be revealed in the future.
The Alter Rebbe
וזהו ע״ד שהיה במשכן הצומח למעלה מהדומם כנ״ל. אבל לע״ל יתעלה יהודה להיות למעלה מבחי׳ יוסף
The Rebbe
דהגם שבגילוי ענין ויגש אליו יהודה הוא שז״א הוא למעלה ממלכות, יש בו (בויגש אליו יהודה), בפנימיות ובהעלם, המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רז–רח, section ב and notes 11–12 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
Background from the RebbeThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
The maamar “Vayigash” of Shabbos Vayigash 5736 (edited; published 5 Teves 5750) opens with the Zohar’s teaching at the start of Vayigash (I, 205b) that Yehudah’s approach is „סמיכת גאולה לתפלה” (“joining redemption to prayer”), as the Rebbe Maharash and the Rebbe Rashab explain it. Our paragraph cites another statement of the Zohar there ("תקרובתא עלמא בעלמא", Kehot: 206a), which this maamar does not take up.
The Zohar calls Yehudah’s approach to Yosef „סמיכת גאולה לתפלה” (“joining redemption to prayer”): redemption is Yesod, Yosef, and prayer is Malchus, Yehudah, as the Rebbe Maharash (5629) and the Rebbe Rashab (5666, 5668, 5675) explain. The Rebbe asks: in Vayigash Yosef is higher, yet when redemption is joined to prayer „שתפלה היא העיקר” (the prayer is the main thing), so „גם בהגשת יהודה ליוסף ניכר המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א” (even Yehudah’s approach shows Malchus’s superiority). He answers that Z’eir Anpin gains by giving to Malchus, as study grows „שמביא לידי מעשה” (by leading to deed), so Malchus’s advantage already shines in part, a prelude to the future.
The Alter Rebbe
אבל לע״ל יתעלה יהודה להיות למעלה מבחי׳ יוסף
The Rebbe
דממ״ש בזהר שהגשת יהודה ליוסף הו״ע סמיכת גאולה לתפלה, משמע, שגם בהגשת יהודה ליוסף ניכר המעלה דמלכות לגבי ז״א
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רטו–ריט, sections א–ה (pp. רטו–ריח) and the closing paragraph (p. ריט); the quote on p. רטז · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשל״ו
Background from the RebbeThe Rebbe says this in more than one place
The maamar “Vayigash” of Shabbos Vayigash 5725 (edited by the Rebbe and published for 5 Teves 5751) opens with the same question as “VeDavid avdi” 5732: since the haftorah’s „ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם” (“My servant David will be king over them”) is read with Vayigash, Yehudah’s superiority must be in Vayigash too. It quotes this paragraph and answers from the Tzemach Tzedek’s explanation of the verse’s final letters („הסופי תיבות”).
The final letters of "ויגש אליו יהודה" spell „שוה” (shaveh, “equal”; Baal HaTurim), which the Tzemach Tzedek explains as Malchus and Z’eir Anpin, Yehudah and Yosef, being joined as equals, the higher and the lower knowledge „למהוי אחד באחד” (as one). From this the Rebbe draws that Yehudah’s approach holds two things: openly, the receiver coming to the giver, „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni”); and hinted, the future union, and even Malchus rising above Z’eir Anpin, „אשת חיל עטרת בעלה” (“a woman of valor is the crown of her husband”). This, he adds, is what the Zohar means by calling the approach „סמיכת גאולה לתפלה” (“joining redemption to prayer”), where prayer is the main thing.
The Alter Rebbe
ויהודה הוא המקבל. וז״ש ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדני
The Rebbe
ועפ״ז יש לומר, שבויגש אליו יהודה מרומז גם העלי׳ דמלכות שיהי׳ לע״ל, שהמלכות תהי׳ למעלה מז״א, אשת חיל עטרת בעלה
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. ה, p. קכז–קכח · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשכ״ה
Background from the Rebbe
At the farbrengen of Shabbos Vayigash, 7 Teves 5711 (unedited), as the eleven months of kaddish for the Rebbe Rayatz came to an end, the Rebbe spoke of the chassidim’s bond (התקשרות) with the Rebbe Rayatz and found it hinted in Yehudah’s approach to Yosef.
Quoting this sentence, „שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק” (“in him the flow from Yosef the tzaddik will be drawn”), the Rebbe reads Yehudah’s approach as giving himself over to Yosef, „צדיקו של עולם” (“the tzaddik of the world”), to be united with him, and “bi adoni” as asking „שיוסף הוא האדון שלו” (that Yosef be his master), so that all of Yosef’s flow is drawn into him. That is why Yehudah opens with “bi adoni”: only one who is „מקושר אליו ומאוחד עמו” (bound and united) with someone so far above him can ask anything of him at all. He reads „ואל יחר אפך בעבדך כי כמוך כפרעה” (“let your anger not flare … for you are like Pharaoh”) the same way: as G‑d, the Pharaoh of holiness in the Zohar’s reading, is good by nature and does not resent being asked, so too the tzaddik.
The Alter Rebbe
פי׳ שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק
The Rebbe
ולכן מקדים ”בי אדוני”, שתוכנה של הקדמה זו היא שיוסף הוא האדון שלו, היינו, שמקושר אליו ומאוחד עמו
Toras Menachem – Hisvaaduyos 5711 (unedited), vol. א, p. 161–162 · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשי״א
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5748
The Alter Rebbe reads Yosef’s inability to restrain himself as the union of Yosef and Yehudah, and reads בי אדוני as Yehudah receiving from Yosef. The Rebbe asks why Yehudah’s speech moved Yosef so, when Yosef already knew most of what he recounted. He answers that Yehudah’s bittul lifted the events, including the sale, to their source. It drew down a light beyond even Yosef’s level, which is higher than the Patriarchs. The tears came from an excess of mochin that the mind could not contain. Here the receiver’s bittul brings a new revelation to the giver.
The Alter Rebbe
וז״ש ולא יכול יוסף להתאפק כו׳ בהתודע יוסף אל אחיו
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsKoach mahDomem, tzomeach, chai, medaberMah and BanLe’asid lavo+5
- Koach mah כח מ״ה
- Domem, tzomeach, chai, medaber דומם צומח חי מדבר
- Mah and Ban מ״ה וב״ן
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Tzaddik צדיק
- Z’eir Anpin זעיר אנפין
- Atzilus אצילות
Marei mekomos
- 1ויגש אליו יהודה ויאמר בי אדני · Genesis 44:18
- 2ויאמר בי אדוני פי׳ שבו יומשך השפע מיוסף הצדיק · בד״ה ודוד עבדי תשל״ב מדייק בתי׳ שבו דלכאורה כיון שיהודה ביקש זה מיוסף הרי היה צריך לבקשו שהוא (יוסף) ימשיך השפע אליו, ע״ש באריכות. וראה שם הערה 29 והערה 33.
- 3וכמבואר בזהר דויגש · רו, א.
- 4ויגש היינו תקרובתא עלמא בעלמא · Zohar, Vayigash 2:15–3:26
- 5
12והנה אבא יסד ברתא1 כי ח״ע [חכמה עילאה] נק׳ ירא׳ עלאה. וח״ת [וחכמה תתאה] שהיא המל׳ היא יראה תתא׳ [תתאה] וזהו אבא יסד ברתא שמבחי׳ יראה עלא׳ [עלאה] דחכ׳ [דחכמה] נמשכ׳ [נמשכת] המל׳ יראה תתאה.
Now, “Abba (the Father) founded the Daughter.” For the higher Chochmah is called “higher awe” (yirah ila’ah), and the lower Chochmah, which is Malchus, is “lower awe” (yirah tata’ah). And this is “Abba founded the Daughter”: from the level of the higher awe of Chochmah, Malchus, the lower awe, is drawn forth.
“Abba founded the Daughter” is a saying of the Zohar: Abba, the Father, is Chochmah, and the Daughter is Malchus. Since Chochmah is called “higher awe” and Malchus “lower awe,” the saying means that Malchus is drawn from Chochmah and founded upon it.
ולע״ל [ולעתיד לבוא] תתעלה בחי׳ יראה תתאה ביראה עלאה מקורה ע״כ תהי׳ [תהיה] אז עט״ב [עטרת בעלה] כי הבטול הוא למעלה במדרגה מאהוי״ר [מאהבה ויראה] דמדות הנמשכי׳ [הנמשכים / הנמשכין] מבחי׳ חו״ג [חסד וגבורה] דז״א.
And in the Time to Come the level of lower awe will be elevated into the higher awe, its source; therefore she will then be “the crown of her husband.” For self-nullification is higher in rank than the love and awe of the emotive attributes, which are drawn from the level of Chesed (kindness) and Gevurah (restraint) of Z’eir Anpin.
In the future, Malchus will rise into its source, the higher awe, and so become the crown. Self-nullification ranks above love and awe, which are emotions drawn from Chesed and Gevurah, the kindness and restraint of Z’eir Anpin.
ולכך גם עכשיו יש בהארץ בחי׳ הבטול יותר וכנ״ל. ובחי׳ בטול דיראה עלאה היא בחינת ומדרגת משרע״ה [משה רבינו עליו השלום] ונחנו מה2 כו׳
And therefore even now the earth has more of the quality of self-nullification, as stated above. And the level of the self-nullification of higher awe is the level and rank of Moshe Rabbeinu, peace be upon him: “And what are we?” etc.
The earth, rooted in Chochmah, has more self-nullification even now. The self-nullification of higher awe is the level of Moshe Rabbeinu, who said, “And what are we?”
(וע׳ לקמן ע״פ יהודה אתה34 ומ״ש ע״פ מאמר הזהר פ׳ אמור5 ע״פ וגם אמנה אחותי בת אבי6 כו׳ מענין בחכמה יסד ארץ כונן שמים בתבונה.7 ועמש״ל [ועיין מה שכתוב לעיל] פ׳ בראשית ד״ה להבין הטעם שנשתנה יצירת):8
(And see below, on the verse “Yehudah, you…,” and what is written on the statement of the Zohar in Parshas Emor, on the verse “And indeed she is my sister, the daughter of my father,” etc., on the matter of “With Chochmah He founded the earth; He established the heavens with understanding (tevunah).” And see what is written above in Parshas Bereishis, in the discourse beginning “To understand the reason why the formation of … was different.”)
The parenthesis points to three related discourses: one later in Torah Ohr, on “Yehudah, you”; one on a passage of the Zohar in Parshas Emor about Avraham’s words concerning Sarah, “she is my sister, the daughter of my father,” and the verse “With Chochmah He founded the earth”; and one in Parshas Bereishis on why the human body was formed differently from other creatures.
Malchus is founded on Chochmah, “higher awe”; in the future it will rise to its source and crown Z’eir Anpin, because the self-nullification it receives from Chochmah ranks above the emotions of love and awe.
The verse “With Chochmah He founded the earth,” cited in the parenthesis, says the same as “Abba founded the Daughter”: the “earth,” Malchus, is founded by Chochmah. A Kehot note identifies the discourse on the Zohar in Parshas Emor as the one printed in the Mitteler Rebbe’s Biurei HaZohar.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5746
The Alter Rebbe treats higher and lower awe as Chochmah and Malchus in the Sefiros. The Rebbe applies the pair to a person’s avodah and to the two buildings. The Mishkan’s earth is lower bittul, a preparation that comes before avodah. The Mikdash’s stone roof is higher awe, a bittul that comes after avodah is complete and stands above it. He proves the sequence from the verse “to do all these statutes, to fear Hashem.”
The Alter Rebbe
כי ח״ע נק׳ ירא׳ עלאה. וח״ת שהיא המל׳ היא יראה תתא׳
The Rebbe
משא״כ במקדש הי׳ ענין יראה עילאה, הביטול שלמעלה מהעבודה
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
TermsAbba yasad brataLower and higher aweTevunahRa’aya Mehemna+10
- Abba yasad brata אבא יסד ברתא explained hereChochmah is the higher awe and Malchus, the lower Chochmah, the lower awe; Malchus is drawn from the higher awe. In the Time to Come the lower awe will rise into its source, and so will be “the crown of her husband,” since self-nullification is above the love and awe of the middos.
שמבחי׳ יראה עלא׳ דחכ׳ נמשכ׳ המל׳ יראה תתאה
- Lower and higher awe יראה תתאה ויראה עלאה explained hereChochmah Ila’ah is called higher awe and the lower Chochmah, Malchus, is lower awe; “Abba founded the daughter” means Malchus, lower awe, is drawn from the higher awe of Chochmah. The bittul of higher awe is the level of Moshe (“and we are mah”); in the future lower awe will rise into its source.
שמבחי׳ יראה עלא׳ דחכ׳ נמשכ׳ המל׳ יראה תתאה
- Tevunah תבונה
- Ra’aya Mehemna רעיא מהימנא
- Emunah אמונה
- Ahavah v’yirah אהבה ויראה
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Higher Chochmah and the lower Chochmah חכמה עלאה וחכמה תתאה
- Binah בינה
- Z’eir Anpin זעיר אנפין
- Abba and Imma אבא ואמא
- Middos מדות
Marei mekomos
- 1אבא יסד ברתא · Zohar III, 248a
- 2ונחנו מה · Exodus 16:7
- 3לקמן ע״פ יהודה אתה · מה, ב.
- 4יהודה אתה · Genesis 49:8
- 5ע״פ מאמר הזהר פ׳ אמור · ביאורי הזהר לאדה״א ע, ב.
- 6וגם אמנה אחותי בת אבי · Genesis 20:12
- 7בחכמה יסד ארץ כונן שמים בתבונה · Proverbs 3:19
- 8ועמש״ל . . להבין הטעם שנשתנה יצירת · לעיל ג, ד ואילך.
The two sticks, Yeravam and the spies ¶13–15
13וזהו מ״ש בהפטרה1 דפ׳ ויגש קח לך עץ אחד וכתוב עליו ליהודה2 כו׳ ולקח עץ אחד וכתוב עליו ליוסף עץ אפרים כו׳ וקרב אותם אחד אל אחד3 כו׳
And this is [the meaning of] what is written in the Haftorah of Parshas Vayigash: “Take for yourself one stick (etz) and write upon it, ‘For Yehudah,’” etc., “and take one stick and write upon it, ‘For Yosef, the stick of Ephraim,’” etc., “and bring them near, one to the other,” etc.
The Haftorah of Parshas Vayigash, from Ezekiel, describes two sticks, one inscribed for Yehudah and the other for Yosef, “the stick of Ephraim,” which the prophet is told to bring together.
“Behold, I am taking the stick of Yosef,” etc., “and I will place them upon it, with the stick of Yehudah,” etc., up to “And My servant David will be king over them.”
G‑d declares that He will take the stick of Yosef and place it with the stick of Yehudah, and the prophecy goes on to the reign of “My servant David,” a king of the tribe of Yehudah, over the reunited people.
פי׳ כי עתה יוסף הוא למעלה מיהודה שהוא נמשל לארז אשר מד, בגדל בגובה ומתוסף והולך.
The explanation: now, Yosef is above Yehudah, for he is likened to the cedar, which grows tall and keeps on increasing.
At present Yosef is above Yehudah, like the cedar that keeps on growing taller.
כך יוסף אליו שייכים עשרת השבטים. כמ״ש שם ושבטי ישראל חביריו נמצא הוא מרובה בשבטים יותר מיהודה.
So too Yosef: to him belong the ten tribes, as it is written there, “and the tribes of Israel, his companions.” It follows that he is more abundant in tribes than Yehudah.
Yosef’s greatness shows in numbers: the verse calls the tribes of Israel “his companions,” so the ten tribes belong to him and he has more tribes than Yehudah.
שע״ש [שעל שם] זה נק׳ יוסף כי הוא הדעת עליון כו׳.
For it is on account of this that he is called Yosef, for he is the supernal Daas, etc.
Yosef’s name, “addition,” reflects his increase, for he is the supernal Daas.
אך לעתיד לבא כשיתחברו שניהם יוסף ויהודה ביחד בתכלית היחוד האמיתי דהיינו מ״ש ויגש אליו יהודה וכמ״ש (איוב מ״א)7 אחד באחד יגשו8 וזה יהיה לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] אז יתעלה יהודה למעלה מיוסף כנ״ל ע״פ א״ח [אשת חיל] עט״ב [עטרת בעלה].
But in the Time to Come, when the two of them, Yosef and Yehudah, will be joined together in the ultimate true unity, which is [the meaning of] what is written, “And Yehudah approached him,” and as it is written (Job 41), “One with another they approach” — and this will be in the Time to Come — then Yehudah will be elevated above Yosef, as stated above on “A woman of valor is the crown of her husband.”
In the Time to Come, however, Yosef and Yehudah will be joined in complete and true unity. That union is the inner meaning of “And Yehudah approached him” and of the verse in Job, “One with another they approach,” and in it Yehudah will rise above Yosef, as the “woman of valor” becomes her husband’s crown.
ולכן אז ועבדי דוד מלך על כל ישראל. וז״ש [וזהו שכתוב] ולא יכול יוסף להתאפק9 כו׳ בהתודע יוסף אל אחיו דהיינו שנתחברו יוסף ויהודה בתכלית החבור והיחוד למיהוי אחד באחד כו׳.
And therefore then “My servant David [will be] king over all Israel.” And this is [the meaning of] what is written, “And Yosef could not restrain himself,” etc., “when Yosef made himself known to his brothers”: that is, Yosef and Yehudah were joined in the ultimate bond and unity, to be one with one, etc.
The prophecy therefore ends with David, of the tribe of Yehudah, as king over all Israel. When Yosef could no longer restrain himself and revealed himself to his brothers, Yosef and Yehudah were joined in complete unity.
(וע׳ ע״פ והיה מספר בנ״י [בני ישראל]1011 כו׳ בענין ונקבצו בני יהודה ובני ישראל יחדו ושמו להם ראש אחד12 כו׳. וע׳ בדרוש ברכת הזמון13 בענין שדהע״ה [שדוד המלך עליו השלום] יברך על כוס יין המשומר שלע״ל [שלעתיד לבוא] כו׳ וע׳ ע״פ מחר חדש בענין יהונתן ודוד:)14
(And see on the verse “And the number of the Children of Israel shall be,” etc., on the matter of “And the children of Yehudah and the children of Israel shall be gathered together, and they shall appoint for themselves one head,” etc. And see the discourse on Birkas HaZimun, on the matter that King David, peace be upon him, will recite the blessing over the cup of the preserved wine in the Time to Come, etc. And see on the verse “Tomorrow is the New Moon,” on the matter of Yehonasan and David.)
The parenthesis points to three related discourses: on the prophecy that the children of Yehudah and the children of Israel will gather together under one head; on the teaching that in the Time to Come King David will recite the blessing over the cup of the preserved wine; and on Yehonasan and David. The Gemara (Berachos 34b) explains the hidden reward that “no eye has seen” as wine preserved in its grapes since the six days of creation. The reference fits here because it shows David leading everyone in the future, the same theme as all of them gathering under one head.
ובכל הנ״ל יובן ויבואר מ״ש בלקוטי הש״ס [הששה סדרים] מהאר״י [מהאלקי רבי יצחק] ז״ל [זכרונו לברכה / זכרונם לברכה] בביאור מארז״ל [מאמר רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] בחלק (דק״ב סע״א [סוף עמוד א]) שתפשו הקב״ה לירבעם בן נבט15 ואמר לו חזור בך16 כו׳ א״ל [אמר ליה] מי בראש א״ל [אמר ליה] בן ישי בראש א״ל [אמר ליה] אי הכי לא בעינא.
And through all the above will be understood and explained what is written in Likkutei HaShas of the Arizal, of blessed memory, in explanation of the saying of our Sages, of blessed memory, in [the chapter] Chelek (folio 102, end of side a): that the Holy One, blessed be He, seized Yeravam ben Nevat and said to him, “Repent,” etc. He said to Him, “Who will be at the head?” He said to him, “The son of Yishai will be at the head.” He said to Him, “If so, I do not want [it].”
The Arizal’s Likkutei HaShas explains a passage of the Talmud: G‑d took hold of Yeravam ben Nevat, the first king of the tribes that broke away from the house of David, and urged him to repent. When Yeravam heard that David, the son of Yishai, would be at the head, he refused.
¶14 Paragraph 14 explains Yeravam’s reply.
שהוא ממש הענין הנ״ל שהקב״ה רצה שירבעם יחזור בתשובה ואז יאיר בו מבחי׳ ומדרגת יוסף בחי׳ עץ אפרים כו׳.17
This is exactly the matter stated above: the Holy One, blessed be He, wanted Yeravam to do teshuvah (return), and then there would shine in him from the level and rank of Yosef, the level of “the stick of Ephraim,” etc.
Yeravam’s story fits the maamar’s theme: had he repented, the level of Yosef, “the stick of Ephraim,” would have shone in him, for Yeravam came from the tribe of Ephraim.
Ezekiel’s prophecy of the two sticks shows the present order, Yosef above Yehudah, giving way in the future to their complete union under the kingship of David; Yeravam’s refusal to accept David at the head illustrates the same theme.
A Kehot note cites Sefer HaSichos 5752, which explains the link between “My servant David” and “And Yehudah approached him” and refers to the Zohar on this verse. Another note points to the Rebbe’s maamar “VeDavid Avdi” 5732, whose whole subject is the joining of Yehudah and Yosef.
The Rebbe on this paragraph AI research
The Rebbe explains
In “VeDavid avdi” 5732, having explained „בי אדוני” (“bi adoni,” see ¶11), the Rebbe asks how Yehudah could move Yosef, whose nature is revelation, to give „בשביל המלכות” (for the receiver’s own sake).
He answers from Yehudah’s guarantee, „כי עבדך ערב את הנער” (“for your servant became surety for the boy”). „ערבים לשון מעורבים” (guarantors, arevim, are “intermingled,” me’oravim), but Yehudah’s surety came from something deeper: „שכל ישראל הם עצם אחד ממש” (all Israel are truly one essence). That is why the guarantee was Yehudah’s, for Malchus is rooted in the inwardness of Keser, above all division; and when Yehudah spoke it, this oneness was drawn into Yosef too, „ולכן לא יכול יוסף להתאפק” (“and so Yosef could not restrain himself”).
The Alter Rebbe
וז״ש ולא יכול יוסף להתאפק כו׳ בהתודע יוסף אל אחיו דהיינו שנתחברו יוסף ויהודה בתכלית החבור והיחוד
The Rebbe
נמשך ענין זה (בבחינת מקיף עכ״פ) גם ביוסף, ולכן לא יכול יוסף להתאפק גו׳ והתוודע אל אחיו
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat (new edition), vol. ב (כסלו–שבט), p. רבי–ריג, section ח · ש״פ ויגש, ז׳ טבת, ה׳תשל״ב
The Rebbe explains
In the sicha of Shabbos Vayigash 5747 (see ¶1), after quoting this maamar that now Yosef is above and „לע״ל יתעלה יהודה” (in the future Yehudah will rise), the Rebbe quotes the haftorah as this paragraph does.
Quoting the haftorah that this paragraph quotes, „ונתתי אותם עליו את עץ יהודה” (“and I will place them upon it, with the stick of Yehudah”), the Rebbe glosses “upon it” as „למעלה ממנו” (“above it”), so that the verse itself sets Yehudah’s stick above Yosef’s. He brings the haftorah, „סיום וחותם הקריאה” (“the end and seal of the reading”), as stressing what this maamar says, that now Yosef is above and in the future Yehudah will rise above him.
The Alter Rebbe
הנה אני לוקח את עץ יוסף כו׳ ונתתי אותם עליו את עץ יהודה כו׳
The Rebbe
הנה אני לוקח את עץ יוסף גו׳ ונתתי אותם עליו (למעלה ממנו) את עץ יהודה ועשיתים לעץ אחד גו׳
Sefer HaSichos 5747, vol. א, p. 221 · ש״פ ויגש ה׳תשמ״ז
A question the Rebbe raises
In “Tziyon bemishpat tipadeh” of Shabbos Chazon 5735 (edited), the Rebbe quotes Ezekiel’s prophecy of the two sticks as the future rise of Yehudah, the inanimate, above Yosef („יתעלה יהודה (בחי׳ דומם) להיות למעלה מיוסף”), and notes how this maamar quotes it.
In a note the Rebbe observes that Torah Chaim and other places quote the prophecy through „ודוד עבדי נשיא להם לעולם” (“David My servant will be their prince forever”), but this paragraph quotes it only „עד ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם” (“up to ‘and My servant David will be king over them’”). He leaves it as a question: „שזה כבר הי׳ משא״כ נשיא להם לעולם” (David was already king over all Israel, while “their prince forever” is what is new).
The Alter Rebbe
עד ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם
The Rebbe
כן הוא בתו״ח ועוד, אבל בתו״א (מד, סע״א) : קח כו׳ עד ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם. וצ״ע שזה כבר הי׳, משא״כ „נשיא להם לעולם”
Sefer HaMaamarim Melukat, vol. א, p. קסב, note 23 · ש״פ דברים, שבת חזון, תשל״ה
A question the Rebbe raises
In a sicha on Yosef’s dreams and his brothers’ jealousy („ויקנאו בו אחיו”), explaining that a sign from above showed „יתרון מעלת העבודה של יוסף” (the advantage of Yosef’s way of service), the Rebbe cites this maamar in a note.
Citing this maamar for „בסדר השתלשלות עתה יוסף הוא למעלה מיהודה” (Yosef standing above Yehudah in the present order), the Rebbe adds that Torah Ohr speaks there of the level of Yosef as against Yehudah, and that is why the ten tribes belong to Yosef; but „בפרטיות הרי בבחי׳ זו ישנן כמה מדריגות (עשר)” (within that level there are, in detail, several grades, ten). So „אליו שייכים עשרת השבטים” (“to him belong the ten tribes”) names a level, within which the tribes still differ.
The Alter Rebbe
כך יוסף אליו שייכים עשרת השבטים
The Rebbe
אלא דשם מדובר בבחי׳ יוסף לגבי יהודה, ולכן עשרת השבטים שייכים ליוסף; אבל בפרטיות הרי בבחי׳ זו ישנן כמה מדריגות (עשר)
Likkutei Sichos, vol. כה, p. 209, note 62 (Vayeshev, sicha 1; the sicha begins p. 204) · ש״פ וישב תשט״ו; ש״פ מקץ תש״מ
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5746
The Alter Rebbe uses the haftorah to contrast the present order with the future union of Yosef and Yehudah. The Rebbe adds that Yehudah approaching Yosef belongs to the beginning of avodah, while the haftorah, as the conclusion of the parshah, gives its completion: “David My servant will be their prince forever.” He also notes that the haftorah itself was instituted because of exile and a royal decree. Since the nations have no real dominion over Israel, that descent exists only for the sake of the ascent to this completion.
The Alter Rebbe
וזהו מ״ש בהפטרה דפ׳ ויגש קח לך עץ אחד
The Rebbe
בההפטרה שהיא סיום וחותם הפרשה
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5748
The Alter Rebbe cites the haftorah of the two sticks as Yosef and Yehudah united under David. The Rebbe explains why the stick of Yosef is called Ephraim: Ephraim is Yosef’s main tribe (‘his younger brother will be greater’), and he headed the banner that included Menasheh. He adds that because the Torah is eternal, this prophecy of the future is a present instruction to each Jew.
The Alter Rebbe
קח לך עץ אחד וכתוב עליו ליהודה כו׳
The Rebbe
דאפרים הוא עיקר שבטו של יוסף
From the Rebbe’s maamar ד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה גו׳, 5748
In the Alter Rebbe the union mainly means that in the future Yehudah will rise above Yosef. The Rebbe gives the union a two-way content. Action affects study: when the learner knows practice depends on his learning, he becomes fully nullified and aims at the true halachah. Study affects action: one cannot rule in practice without knowing the details and reasons of the halachos.
The Alter Rebbe
יתחברו שניהם יוסף ויהודה ביחד בתכלית היחוד האמיתי
The Rebbe
שתהי׳ פעולת התלמוד בהמעשה ופעולת המעשה בהתלמוד
Found by AI in the Rebbe’s works and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail. How it was made
TermsDaas elyon and daas tachtonAchdus HashemLe’asid lavoTeshuvah+3
- Daas elyon and daas tachton דעת עליון ודעת תחתון
- Achdus Hashem אחדות השם
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Teshuvah תשובה
- Yichud יחוד
- Daas דעת
- Berachah ברכה
Marei mekomos
- 1וזהו מ״ש בהפטרה · ראה ד״ה ויגש תשמ״ו. לקו״ש חט״ו ע׳ 413.
- 2קח לך עץ אחד וכתוב עליו ליהודה · Ezekiel 37:16
- 3וקרב אותם אחד אל אחד · Ezekiel 37:17
- 4הנה אני לוקח את עץ יוסף · Ezekiel 37:19
- 5בהפטרה דפ׳ ויגש . . ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם · Ezekiel 37:24–25
- 6ועבדי דוד מלך עליהם · Ezekiel 37:24
- 7איוב מ״א · פסוק ח.
- 8
- 9ולא יכול יוסף להתאפק · Genesis 45:1
- 10ע״פ והי׳ מספר בנ״י · לקו״ת במדבר ו, ג.
- 11והיה מספר בנ״י · Hosea 2:1
- 12ונקבצו בני יהודה ובני ישראל יחדו ושמו להם ראש אחד · Hosea 2:2
- 13בדרוש ברכת הזימון · סידור שער ברהמ״ז קב ב. ובאוה״ת פ׳ עקב הגהות ע״ז.
- 14ע״פ מחר חדש בענין יהונתן ודוד · לק״ת ברכה צז, א. וראה אוה״ת בראשית ו, ב. ואילך.
- 15שתפשו הקב״ה לירבעם בן נבט · ראה אוה״ת פ׳ שלח ע׳ תנ.
- 16שתפשו הקב״ה לירבעם בן נבט ואמר לו חזור בך · Sanhedrin 102a:17
- 17כי — יוסף נמשל לארז · ראה משיחת ש״פ בשלח סה״ש תשמ״ט הערה 27.
14וזהו אני ואתה ובן ישי נטייל בג״ע [בגן עדן]1 שיהי׳ [שיהיה] מאיר בהם א״ס ב״ה בהאר׳ [בהארה] רבה. וזהו אנ״י כו׳
And this is [the meaning of] “I and you and the son of Yishai will stroll in Gan Eden”: that the Infinite One (Ein Sof), blessed be He, will shine in them with a great illumination. And this is “I” (Ani), etc.
In the Talmud’s account G‑d tells Yeravam, “I and you and the son of Yishai will stroll in Gan Eden.” The maamar explains that the Infinite One would shine in all three with a great light; its closing words, “And this is ‘I,’ etc.,” point to a further meaning in G‑d’s “I” that is not spelled out here.
א״ל [אמר ליה] מי בראש כי הוא רצה כמו שהיה עכשיו שבחינת ומדרגת יוסף הוא למעלה מבחי׳ יהודה לכך רצה הוא להיות בראש לגבי דוד
He said to Him, “Who will be at the head?” For he wanted [it to be] as it is now, when the level and rank of Yosef is above the level of Yehudah; therefore he wanted to be at the head in relation to David.
Yeravam asked who would lead because he wanted the present order to remain, in which Yosef, the root of his own tribe, stands above Yehudah; so he wanted to be at the head, above David.
¶13 This explains the saying about Yeravam from paragraph 13.
אבל הקב״ה אמר לו שלע״ל [שלעתיד לבוא] יתעלה יהודה לכן בן ישי בראש כו׳ א״ל [אמר ליה] אי הכי לא בעינא שלא היה בו בחי׳ בטול ושפלות זה.
But the Holy One, blessed be He, told him that in the Time to Come Yehudah will be elevated; therefore “the son of Yishai will be at the head,” etc. He said to Him, “If so, I do not want [it],” for he did not have this quality of self-nullification and lowliness.
G‑d answered that in the Time to Come Yehudah will rise, so David, the son of Yishai, will lead. Yeravam refused, because he lacked the self-nullification and lowliness that would let him accept Yehudah’s rise.
Yeravam wanted the present order, Yosef above Yehudah, to remain; G‑d’s answer that David would lead reflects the future order, and Yeravam’s refusal came from a lack of humility.
TermsAnavahGan EdenLe’asid lavoEin Sof+1
- Anavah ענוה
- Gan Eden גן עדן
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Ein Sof אין סוף
Also Bittul
Marei mekomos
- 1אני ואתה ובן ישי נטייל בג״ע · Sanhedrin 102a:17
15וזשארז״ל [וזהו שאמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] גסות הרוח שבירבעם טרדתו1 כו׳. ומעין זה נתבאר ג״כ במ״א בענין המרגלים2 שלא היה בהם ג״כ שפלות זו לגבי בחי׳ ארץ העליונה שדימו בעצמם שא״צ [שאין צריך / שאינו צריך] לזה להיותן מעלמא דדכורא כולם אנשים3 כו׳.
And this is what our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “The arrogance that was in Yeravam drove him away,” etc. And something similar is also explained elsewhere concerning the spies, that they too did not have this lowliness in relation to the level of the supernal earth, for they imagined that they had no need for this, since they were from the masculine world (alma dedechura), “all of them men,” etc.
The Sages say that Yeravam’s arrogance drove him from the world. The Gemara (Sanhedrin 102a) tells that G‑d took hold of Yeravam by his garment and urged him to repent, so that He, Yeravam and the son of Yishai would stroll together in Gan Eden. Yeravam asked who would be at the head, and when told the son of Yishai, he answered that then he did not want it. This is the arrogance that could not accept David, of Yehudah, above him. Elsewhere the same is explained of the spies whom Moshe sent to scout the Land: they too lacked lowliness toward the “supernal earth,” Malchus, and felt no need for it, because they were rooted in the “masculine world,” the giving side, which is why the Torah calls them “all of them men.”
אבל יוסף הצדיק ויהודה יתחברו לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] בתכלית היחוד למיהוי אחד באחד כנ״ל:
But Yosef the tzaddik and Yehudah will be joined in the Time to Come in the ultimate unity, to be one with one, as stated above.
Yosef the tzaddik and Yehudah, by contrast, will be fully united in the Time to Come, “one with one.”
Like Yeravam, the spies lacked humility toward the “earth,” Malchus; but Yosef and Yehudah will be fully united in the future.
In Kabbalah “masculine” stands for the giver and “feminine” for the receiver. The spies, rooted in the giving side, felt no need for the receiving “earth,” the very level the maamar shows will rise highest.
Explained elsewhere AI research
Explained by the Alter Rebbe and the Tzemach Tzedek
„ומעין זה נתבאר ג״כ במ״א בענין המרגלים” (“Something similar is also explained elsewhere concerning the spies”) gives no place.
The “elsewhere” is probably the Alter Rebbe’s discourse in Likkutei Torah, Shelach (“In the passage of the libations”): the spies, „כולם אנשים” (“all of them men”), came from the „עלמא דדכורא” (“masculine world”) that draws down from above, and to lift the land, as one bends down to lift a load, „צריך להשפיל א״ע למטה” (they had to lower themselves); „והם לא היה בהם שפלות זו” (this lowliness they lacked). The Tzemach Tzedek (Or HaTorah, Shelach) adds that the princes, “the tribes of Kah,” stood above Malchus, the land, and could raise it only „ע״י שישפילו א״ע למטה מטה מהארץ” (by lowering themselves beneath it), and he says this is „הכל ענין א׳” (one matter) with Yeravam here, who would not accept David at the head.
the Alter Rebbe: Likkutei Torah, Shelach, dibbur hamaschil "בפ׳ נסכים כתיב כי תבאו" (on the site: Likkutei Torah, Sh’lach 5 ¶18), p. מא, ב
כשצריכים להגביה איזה דבר שהוא ענין המ״נ צריך להשפיל א״ע למטה כדי להגביהו והם לא היה בהם שפלות זו
the Tzemach Tzedek: Or HaTorah, Bamidbar vol. 2 (Shelach), p. תנ
ודוגמא זה נת׳ בת״א סד״ה ויגש אליו יהודה בענין ירבעם גבי מי בראש בן ישי בראש א״כ לא בעינא כו׳ ע״ש דהכל ענין א׳
Where the maamar leaves something unexplained, found by AI in the library and checked against each source; not yet reviewed by a person, so check the place before relying on a detail.
TermsGasus haruachKoach hatzomeachAnavahLe’asid lavo+2
- Gasus haruach גסות הרוח
- Koach hatzomeach כח הצומח
- Anavah ענוה
- Le’asid lavo לעתיד לבא
- Tzaddik צדיק
- Yichud יחוד
Marei mekomos
- 1גסות הרוח שבירבעם טרדתו · Sanhedrin 101b:13
- 2במ״א בענין המרגלים · ראה אוה״ת שלח ע׳ תנ ואילך.
- 3כולם אנשים · Numbers 13:3
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Each Rosh Chodesh the names of those learning here are brought to the Ohel. Add your name, and mark what you learn so it is counted.
In one’s avodah
The maamar draws its lesson from the earth, trodden under everyone’s feet yet first in G‑d’s thought: the deepest level is self-nullification and lowliness. In prayer this is the bowing of the Shemoneh Esreh and its “still, small voice,” the inanimate level, and the letters of prayer themselves. Yeravam’s arrogance, which kept him from accepting David at the head, and the spies’ sense that they had no need for the “earth,” show what is lost without this humility.
Questions for discussion
- Why does the earth, the lowest of the four kingdoms, have the power to bring forth growth, and what does “last in deed, first in thought” mean?
- How did the materials of the Mishkan and of the Beis HaMikdash reflect two different orders of creation?
- What does the earth’s being trodden under everyone’s feet have to do with Moshe’s words “And what are we?”
- Why will Yehudah, the receiver, rise above Yosef, the giver, in the Time to Come?
- What did Yeravam and the spies lack, and how does the maamar connect it to the “earth”?
Key terms in this maamar
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The descent of levels from cause to effect, linked like the rings of a chain, from Chochmah downward; each reveals what was hidden in the one above. Or Ein Sof itself is above this order. ×6Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- Aramaic, “the Holy One, blessed be He”: G‑d as holy, set apart from the worlds, paired with Shechinteh, His indwelling; read as sovev kol almin, Z’eir Anpin, Atzmus, and sometimes memalei kol almin. ×5Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- G‑d’s kingship: the lowest Sefirah, His “speech” and the revealed world, through which all worlds come into being from nothing and live, without touching His essence (“there is no king without a people”).Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The World of Atzilus (Emanation)אצילות
- The first revelation in the chain of worlds (vayaetzel, “drew off”): the ten Sefiros, where Or Ein Sof rests and lights and vessels are one with Him; Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah are created from nothing. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Z'eir Anpin (the emotive attributes)ז״א
- The partzuf of the six middos of Atzilus (Chesed to Yesod), born from Imma and filled out by the mochin of Abba and Imma; Nukva’s masculine partner, through which the light reaches her. ×5Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Self-nullification before G‑d, the condition for the Or Ein Sof to rest. Its lower degree is a “something” that bows; its higher, Chochmah’s “what are we,” takes up no place at all.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The emotive attributes (middos)מדות
- The emotive powers (in the soul: love, fear, mercy). Born from the intellect and matching its measure, they are rooted above it, in the will; above, the middos of Z”A, emanated to conduct the worlds. ×3Where it’s explained
- Yesod (foundation)יסוד
- The Sefirah of binding: a giver’s lowest level, through which it ties itself to the receiver and draws its flow to it. Called kol (all), chai (living), tzaddik and bris (covenant); linked to Yosef. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Knowledge as felt recognition: the intellect bound into the soul until it is felt as if seen. Daas unites Chochmah with Binah and spreads into the middos as their inner life; the middos follow it. ×3Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Keser (the Crown)כתר
- The Crown over the Sefiros: intermediary between Or Ein Sof and the emanated, holding the lowest level of the Infinite; the Supernal Will and source of delight, beyond grasp; Chochmah emerges from it. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Life-forceחיות
- Life-force: the G‑dly vitality that brings each creation into being and keeps it alive, drawn to each according to its level and renewed from nothing, as the soul enlivens the body.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first Sefirah of revelation: a single point of insight (koach mah, the yud of Havayah) that comes from the “nothing” above it; being bittul, Or Ein Sof rests in it, and Binah expands it. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- Love, the soul’s longing to cleave to G‑d, and awe, its self-nullification before Him: opposites born of the mind (“son and daughter”), called the two “wings” that lift one’s service on high.Where it’s explained, stated differently, Sefer HaErchim
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- The Sefirah of kindness (the right arm; Avraham): giving that comes from its nature to do good, spreading from highest to lowest like water. Gevurah, its opposite, limits it; in tikkun each includes the other.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- The Sefirah of might (the left; Yitzchak), opposite Chesed: described as what limits and contracts Chesed’s flow, and as the life-force in greater intensity, which becomes judgment; included in Chesed, it gives life.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning the soul, which descended into physical things, to its source and root, to cleave to G‑d; not only leaving sin. Its two levels are the return of the lower and the higher hei. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Infinite One (Ein Sof)אין סוף
- The name for G‑d as without end or limit, beyond all grasp; what is drawn from Him is Or Ein Sof, only a radiance; all revelation comes from Malchus of Ein Sof.Where it’s explained, stated differently