Torah Ohr · Parshas Va’eira · Maamar 1
וארא אל אברהם אל יצחק ואל יעקב באל…
“And I appeared to Avraham, to Yitzchak and to Yaakov as Kel Sha-dai”
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
The revelation the Avos received as Kel Sha-dai lives on in every Jew: in exile our faculties are like those of a fetus, formed but inactive, and by revealing G‑d’s unity in the heart we come to “birth” and to the “milk” of joy that makes love and awe grow. Higher still is the Torah, given through Moshe’s complete self-nullification, which reveals G‑d’s very Self, the level the Avos did not know.
The maamar in brief
G‑d tells Moshe that He appeared to the Avos as Kel Sha-dai but was not known to them by His Name Havayah. The Alter Rebbe reads “I appeared” also as a continuing present: the Avos are the root of every Jewish soul, so their level is in every Jew. Exile is pregnancy. Like a fetus whose organs are formed but whose head is folded and breath absent, Israel keeps the mitzvos, yet their nourishment does not reach heart and mind, and service becomes cold and rote. Redemption is birth, and it depends on our service now: revealing G‑d’s unity, “Havayah is One,” within the divided world and within our own emotions. Love then grows into anger at evil (Yitzchak), then compassion for one’s own soul (Yaakov), and finally true joy, the “milk” that makes love and awe grow; this is Kel Sha-dai, from shadayim, “breasts.” Above all of this is the Torah, given through Moshe’s complete self-nullification. One who speaks Torah voices the King’s own word and draws down G‑d as Single, His very Self, which “was not known” to the Avos.
Outline
- Va’eira in every generation“I appeared” is also a present tense: the level of the Avos, the root of all souls, is every Jew’s inheritance, unlike the levels of the tribes.¶1–2
- Exile as pregnancyLike a fetus whose organs are formed but idle, Israel in exile keeps the mitzvos without vitality; the birth of redemption depends on revealing the love hidden in the heart.¶3–6
- Havayah is One“One” is G‑d’s unity revealed within the divided world, not His essence, which is Single; Israel has the power to draw this unity down, and from it comes love with both inclinations.¶7–9
- Joy as milkService out of love is joy, which is compared to milk; milk comes from blood, and blood from food.¶10–11
- From offerings to joyPrayer and mitzvos draw G‑d’s light down like food; it becomes one with the person like blood, leading to anger at evil, compassion for the soul, and finally true joy.¶12–13
- Kel Sha-daiSha-dai, from shadayim, is the milk of joy that makes love and awe, the qualities of the Avos, grow.¶14
- “My Name was not known to them”The Avos served as devoted servants; Moshe’s complete self-nullification brought the Torah, through which G‑d’s very Self, the level of Single, is revealed.¶15–18
Key concepts
- Pregnancy and birth (ibbur and leidah)עיבור ולידה
- Exile is like pregnancy, when every faculty exists but does not function; redemption is birth, when G‑d’s light is openly revealed in the heart.
- One and Single (echad and yachid)אחד ויחיד
- “One” is G‑d’s unity revealed within a world of many parts, all nullified before Him; “Single” is His essence, beyond any world or dimension.
- Kel Sha-daiאל שדי
- The Name in which G‑d appeared to the Avos, read here as related to shadayim, “breasts”: the milk of joy that makes love and awe grow.
- The service of a servantעבודת עבד
- Serving G‑d with love and awe, even with delight, while remaining a self who serves; this was the service of the Avos.
- Complete self-nullification (bittul)ביטול לגמרי
- Moshe’s quality of feeling no self at all, through which the Torah was given and G‑d’s very Self is revealed.
- Compassion before joyרחמנות ושמחה
- Seeing one’s soul far from G‑d’s light arouses compassion, which is the beginning of true joy, as a newborn first cries and then is given milk.
- “I, who I am” (Anochi mi she’anochi)אנכי מי שאנכי
- G‑d’s own Self, above the Name Havayah: the level from which the Torah is drawn.
Va’eira in every generation ¶1–2
1וארא אל אברהם12 אל יצחק ואל יעקב באל שדי ושמי הוי״ה לא נודעתי להם. הנה וארא יש בו ב׳ פירושים3 א׳ לשון עבר שנתגלה לאבות4 והב׳ לשון עתיד
“And I appeared to Avraham, to Yitzchak and to Yaakov as Kel Sha-dai, but [by] My Name Havayah I was not known to them.” Now, [the word] va’eira (“and I appeared”) has two meanings. One is the past tense: that He was revealed to the Avos (the Patriarchs). The second is the future tense,
The maamar opens with G‑d’s words to Moshe: He appeared to the Avos as Kel Sha-dai, but they did not know Him through His Name Havayah. The Alter Rebbe notes that the verb va’eira can be read two ways, and the first is the plain past tense: G‑d was once revealed to Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov.
which is [also] a term for the present: that this level is always there, at every time, in every person. For “only three are called Avos.”
Read as a future form, va’eira describes something ongoing, so the revelation the Avos had is present at every time in every Jew. The Talmud’s rule that only these three are called Avos (fathers) leads into the next paragraph, which explains why their level belongs to all their children.
The paragraph introduces the verse and proposes that “I appeared” describes not only a past revelation to the Avos but a continuing one, present in every Jew at all times.
Maamarim of the Rebbe cited in the Kehot note (Va’eira 5738 and 5734) explain that the two readings belong together because they are one word: the revelation of va’eira took place in Moshe’s time too, exists now as well, and in the very way it took place with the Avos it takes place always in every Jew. The note also records that the words “at every time” appear in manuscript 633 but are absent from the version printed in Or HaTorah from the Tzemach Tzedek’s manuscript.
Marei mekomos
- 1וארא אל אברהם · הנחת כ״ק אדמו״ר האמצעי בסה״מ תקס״ב ע׳ קלד. ביאור בע׳ קלז. ושם ע׳ רצא קיצור לכ״ק אדמו״ר הצ״צ [על הנחת כ״ק אדה״א]. ראה לעיל בציונים לכ״ק אדמו״ר זי״ע. המאמר עם הגהות באוה״ת וארא ע׳ קלט, וע׳ קמ. כרך ז ע׳ ב׳תקמט. עוד הגהות בע׳ ב׳תקפד. כרך ח ע׳ ב׳תתסה. ד״ה דודי לי ואני לו בסה״מ תרכ״ז ע׳ רכב. לכללות מאמר זה ראה ד״ה ועברתי בארץ מצרים תרמ״ד סעי׳ ו (הוצאת תשס״ב ע׳ שלז ואילך). ובד״ה וארא תשכ״ז. תשל״ט. תשמ״ה. ד״ה כי כאשר תשמ״ז.
- 2וארא אל אברהם · Exodus 6:3
- 3וארא יש בו ב׳ פירושים · תחילת המאמר נתבאר בארוכה בספר השיחות תשמ״ט ע׳ 189.
- 4א׳ לשון עבר שנתגלה לאבות · כפשוטו של מקרא בפרש״י — ד״ה וארא תשל״ט.
- 5והב׳ . . שתמיד יש בחינה זו · ראה לקו״ש ח״י ע׳ 97. בד״ה וארא תשל״ח ”והיינו שהענין דוארא הי׳ (לא רק אצל האבות, כ״א גם) בזמן משה רבינו וגם ישנו עתה בזה״ז”. ”ומאחר ושני הפירושים ה״ה בתיבה אחת וענין אחד הרי מובן שיש להם שייכות זה לזה. והיינו שבאותו האופן שהי׳ הענין דוארא אצל האבות, באותו האופן הוא גם תמיד בכל אחד מבני ישראל” — ד״ה וארא תשל״ד (מהנחה בלתי מוגה).
- 6שו״ה זו בכל — בכל זמן · כ״ה בבוך 633. אבל באוה״ת וארא כרך ח ע׳ ב׳ תתסה (שנדפס מגוכתי״ק הצ״צ עם הגהות) ליתא תי׳ אלו.
- 7אין קורין אבות · Berakhot 16b:13–14
The explanation is that the level of the Avos is an inheritance for their children after them in every generation, “to each one according to his measure.”
The level of the Avos passes to their descendants as an inheritance in every generation. The Aramaic phrase “to each one according to his measure” means that each person receives it according to his own capacity.
Therefore we say, “the G‑d of our fathers, the G‑d of Avraham,” etc. But the other levels and the high standing of the tzaddikim, such as the Tribes, Reuven, Shimon, Levi,
The first blessing of the Amidah calls on the “G‑d of our fathers, G‑d of Avraham”: every Jew calls on the G‑d of the Avos because their level is his own inheritance. The levels of the tribes, the sons of Yaakov such as Reuven, Shimon and Levi, are different, as the next part explains.
שהם ודאי בחינות אורות עליונים יש לך אדם שאין בו כלל בחי׳ ומדרגות אלו6 משא״כ בחי׳ האבות7 צריך להיות בכל אדם שהם שרש ומקור כל נשמות ישראל.
which are certainly levels of supernal lights: you may find a person who has none of these levels and ranks at all. The level of the Avos, however, must be in every person, for they are the root and source of all the souls of Israel.
The tribes stand for high spiritual lights, yet a particular Jew may lack them entirely. The Avos, by contrast, must be present in every Jew, since they are the root and source of all the souls of Israel.
The paragraph explains why the revelation to the Avos is present in everyone: the Avos are the root of all Jewish souls, so their level is every Jew’s inheritance, unlike the levels of the tribes.
A Kehot note, citing Likkutei Sichos, clarifies the point: a person may lack the levels of all the tribes, whereas the levels of all three Avos must be present in each Jew. Likkutei Torah, Bamidbar, uses the same Zohar phrase for knowing G‑d: each person knows Him as far as he contemplates His greatness in his heart, according to the depth of his understanding.
Marei mekomos
- 1שבחי׳ האבות היא ירושה לבניהם · ראה לקו״ש ח״י ע׳ 97.
- 2לכל חד לפום שיעורא דילי׳ · Zohar I, 129b
- 3לכל חד לפום שיעורא דיליה · Zohar, Vayera 9:153–164
- 4ולכן אומרים אלקי אבותינו אלקי אברהם · ראה בספר השיחות תשמ״ט ח״א ע׳ 189 הערה 13.
- 5
- 6יש לך אדם שאין בו כלל בחי׳ ומדריגות אלו · הכוונה, שאין בו הבחי׳ של כל השבטים. ודלא כהאבות, שבחי׳ כל ג׳ האבות צ״ל בכ״א. — לקו״ש ח״ו ע׳ 11 הערה 39. חט״ו ע׳ 360.
- 7משא״כ בחי׳ האבות · ע׳ לקו״ש ח״ד ע׳ 1068 הערה יב.
Exile as pregnancy ¶3–6
To understand this revelation, in every generation, of the level and rank of the Avos that is in every person of Israel: the exile is likened to pregnancy (ibbur).
To explain how the level of the Avos is revealed in every Jew in every generation, the Alter Rebbe turns to an image: exile is like pregnancy (ibbur), a state in which a child exists but is still hidden.
וגאולת ימי המשיח שיהיה במהרה בימינו נמשל ללידה כמ״ש כי חלה גם ילדה3 ציון את בניה וכשישראל נתונים בצרה ח״ו כתיב כי באו בנים
And the redemption of the days of Mashiach, which will come speedily in our days, is likened to birth, as it is written, “For Zion labored and also gave birth to her children.” And when Israel are in distress, G‑d forbid, it is written, “For children have come
Redemption is likened to birth, as in Yeshayahu’s prophecy that Zion “labored and gave birth to her children.” Times of distress are described in the same language: King Chizkiyahu’s message to Yeshayahu compared the crisis of his day to children who have reached the birthstool when there is no strength to give birth.
to the birthstool, and there is no strength to give birth.” Likewise the pangs of the days of Mashiach are called birth pangs, as it is written, “For birth pangs will come upon you.”
The suffering that comes before Mashiach is called “birth pangs.” In each of these images the redemption is a birth: what has been forming in hiding comes out into the open.
The paragraph introduces the central analogy of the maamar: exile is pregnancy and redemption is birth, as the prophets describe it.
Later in this parsha (Torah Ohr, Va’eira, 58d, cited in the Kehot note) the exile in Egypt is explained as Z’eir Anpin in a state of pregnancy, and the Exodus as birth: the emotive attributes coming out of contemplation into revelation. Two manuscripts add a remark here linking the image to a Talmudic play on words: “even at the time that You are filled with wrath (evrah) against them, like a pregnant woman (ubarah).”
Marei mekomos
- 1ולהבין ענין גילוי זה · בבוך באב׳ 17 כו, א נוסף: (דוארא כו׳).
- 2הגלות נמשל לעבור · Zohar III, 50a
- 3כי חלה גם ילדה · Isaiah 66:8
- 4כי באו בנים עד משבר · Isaiah 37:3
- 5וכח אין ללידה · בבוך באב׳ 17. 170 נוסף: (וכ״מ במשנה פ״ד דברכות אפילו בשעה שאתה מתמלא עליהם עברה כאשה עוברה כו׳): וכן.
4וכן בגאולת מצרים המשיל בנבואת יחזקאל כל הענין לולד ביום הלידה כמ״ש ומולדותיך ביום הולדת אותך1 לא כרת שרך וגו׳. ולהבין משל ומליצה צריך להבין מהו ענין העיבור.
So too regarding the redemption from Egypt: in the prophecy of Yechezkel he likens the whole matter to a newborn on the day of its birth, as it is written, “And as for your birth, on the day you were born your navel was not cut,” etc. To understand the analogy and the figure of speech, we must understand what pregnancy is.
In Yechezkel’s prophecy, Israel at the time of the Exodus is pictured as a newborn on the day of its birth, whose navel had not yet been cut. To understand this image of birth, the Alter Rebbe first examines the state that comes before it: pregnancy.
כי הנה אמרו רז״ל דרש2 ר׳ שמלאי3 למה הולד דומה במעי אמו לפינקס מקופל ראשו בין ברכיו4 ועקבותיו על עגבותיו ואוכל ממה שאמו אוכלת5 וכו׳
For our Sages, of blessed memory, said: Rabbi Simlai expounded: What does the fetus in its mother’s womb resemble? A writing tablet (pinkas): folded, its head between its knees and its heels against its buttocks, and it eats from what its mother eats, etc.;
The Talmud records Rabbi Simlai’s description of the fetus: folded like a writing tablet, its head between its knees and its heels against its buttocks, nourished by the food its mother eats. Each detail will be applied to Israel in exile.
ופיו סתום וטבורו פתוח וכשיצא לאויר העולם נפתח הסתום ונסתם הפתוח כו׳ דהיינו שיש להעובר כל חתוך האברי׳ ראש ועינים ואזנים כו׳
its mouth is closed and its navel open; and when it comes out into the air of the world, the closed opens and the open closes, etc. That is to say, the fetus has the full formation of the limbs, head, eyes and ears, etc.,
In the womb the mouth is closed and the navel open; at birth this reverses. The Alter Rebbe stresses that the fetus already has every organ, including head, eyes and ears.
אלא שראשו מקופל ומונח בין ברכיו שאינו משמש כלום שאינו מחשב ומהרהר וכן עינים לו ולא ירא׳ ואזנים ולא ישמע
only its head is folded and resting between its knees, for it does not function at all: it does not think or reflect. Likewise it has eyes but does not see, and ears but does not hear.
Though the organs exist, they do not work: the folded head does not think, the eyes do not see and the ears do not hear.
וגם המאכל שלו אף שאוכל ממה שאמו אוכלת אינו הולך לו דרך הפה רק דרך הטבור6 לבני מעיים בלבד להגדיל הגוף
Its food too, although it eats from what its mother eats, does not go to it by way of the mouth, but only by way of the navel, to the intestines alone, to make the body grow,
The fetus is fed, but its food bypasses the mouth and goes through the navel straight to the digestive organs, serving only to build up the body.
כמו שנראה בחוש שבתשעה ירחי לידה נגדל גופו אבל להיות המאכל עובר דרך הפה דהיינו לשלוח חיות ללב ומשם למוח
as is plainly seen, that during the nine months until birth its body grows. But for the food to pass by way of the mouth, that is, to send life-force to the heart and from there to the brain,
The body’s growth during the nine months shows that this nourishment works. What it does not do is pass through the mouth, the route by which food would send life-force to the heart and from there to the brain.
שהם אברי הנשימה אף שנגמרו כל אבריו ויש בו אברי הנשימה ג״כ מכל מקום הרי אין לו נשמת רוח חיים עד שיצא לאויר העולם שאז מוציא הקול
which are the organs of breathing: although all its organs are complete and it has organs of breathing as well, it nevertheless has no breath of the spirit of life until it comes out into the air of the world, when it lets out its voice,
The heart and brain are counted here among the organs of breathing. The fetus has them fully formed, but it has no breath of life until it is born and lets out its first sound.
כמ״ש רז״ל7 שהוא סימן הלידה דשמעי לולד דצויץ משום שהוציא ראשו ולכן אינו שולח חיות לאברי הנשימה אלא לאברי המזון בלבד דרך טבורו ששם הוא משכן הבני מעיים אברי המזון
as our Sages said that this is the sign of birth: when one hears the baby cry out, it is because it has put out its head. Therefore it sends life-force not to the organs of breathing but only to the organs of nourishment, by way of its navel, where the intestines, the organs of nourishment, are housed;
The Talmud treats a baby’s cry as a sign that its head has emerged, that is, that it has been born. Until then life-force goes only to the organs of nourishment, which are fed through the navel.
משא״כ ראשו עם כל אברי הנשימה אין משמשין כלום והרי הם כמתים ולכן ראשו מוטל בין ברכיו מפני שאין לו חיות.
whereas its head, with all the organs of breathing, does not function at all, and they are as if dead. Therefore its head lies between its knees, because it has no life-force.
In the womb the head and the organs of breathing are idle, as if lifeless. This is why the head lies folded between the knees.
The paragraph sets out the details of the analogy: in pregnancy every organ is present, but only the body grows, fed through the navel, while the head, heart and breathing stay inactive until birth.
In a maamar of the Alter Rebbe on this same teaching of Rabbi Simlai, cited in the Kehot note, it is added that the fetus eats what its mother eats and not milk, which comes only after the food has been refined and made pure. Milk, as this maamar goes on to explain, is the joy that comes after birth. Beside Niddah 42b the Kehot note points to Chullin 72a, where a decree of the Sages assumes that a fetus that has put its head out beyond the vestibule already counts as born.
Marei mekomos
- 1ומולדותיך ביום הולדת אותך · Ezekiel 16:4
- 2אמרו רז״ל דרש · בבוך הנ״ל נוסף: (בפ״ג דנדה) בשם ר׳ שמלאי.
- 3דרש ר׳ שמלאי · Niddah 30b:18
- 4ראשו בין ברכיו · ראה ד״ה בלילה ההוא תשד״מ. ראה תו״ח שמות מד, סע״ב. ספהמ״צ להצ״צ עז, סע״א ואילך. אוה״ת שמיני ע׳ לה ובכ״מ.
- 5ואוכל ממה שאמו אוכלת · (ולא החלב שהוא לאחר הבירור הזך והנקי) — מאמרי אדה״ז על מארז״ל ע׳ קלא.
- 6רק דרך הטבור · ראה לקמן קכד, ב.
- 7כמ״ש רז״ל · Niddah 42b
5והנה ככל הדברים האלה וככל המשל הזה1 כך נמשלו בני ישראל בעת הגלות דכתיב ה׳ ממרום ישאג2 פי׳ כמ״ש בזהר דסליק קוב״ה לעילא34 וכתי׳ רחל מבכה על בניה5 כו׳ כי איננו
Now, according to all these words and according to all this analogy, so are the children of Israel likened in the time of exile. For it is written, “G‑d roars from on high,” meaning, as the Zohar says, that the Holy One, blessed be He, has ascended on high. And it is written, “Rachel weeps for her children,” etc., “for he is not,”
Every detail of the fetus applies to Israel in exile. “G‑d roars from on high” is read, following the Zohar, as describing the Holy One, blessed be He, ascending on high, away from the world; Rachel’s weeping “for he is not” is read the same way.
ופי׳ בזהר דקאי על הקב״ה כי איננו בגו בנהא דסליק כו׳ פי׳ שסילק שכינתו וגילוי אלהותו מהתחתונים ודומה לעיני בשר כאלו העולם דבר בפני עצמו והשמן לב העם6 ועיניו השע עינים להם
and the Zohar explains that this refers to the Holy One, blessed be He: “for He is not” among her children, for He has ascended, etc. That is, He has withdrawn His Shechinah (Divine Presence) and the revelation of His G‑dliness from the lower realms, and to eyes of flesh it seems as though the world were a thing in itself. “Make the heart of the people fat, and seal its eyes”; “they have eyes,”
The Zohar reads the singular “he is not” as referring to G‑d: He is no longer present among Rachel’s children. This means that G‑d has withdrawn the open revelation of His presence, so that to human eyes the world seems to exist on its own, as in Yeshayahu’s words about a people whose heart is dulled and whose eyes are sealed.
ולא יראו אור ה׳ כי בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד7 ואפי׳ השפעת מצות ומעשים טובים
but they do not see the light of G‑d: that “in the heavens above and on the earth below there is nothing else.” And even the influence of mitzvos and good deeds,
Like the fetus, the people have eyes but do not see G‑d’s light: the truth that “in the heavens above and on the earth below there is nothing else.” The same is true of the spiritual nourishment that comes from mitzvos and good deeds.
שהם מזון לנפש אינו עובר להם דרך הנשימה לשלוח חיות ללב ולמוח למען דעת ה׳ ולאהבה אותו ולעבדו בכל לבבם בלב שלם ונפש חפצה ותשוקה מורגשת בלב כרשפי אש שלהבת8 וצמאון כו׳
which are food for the soul, does not pass to them by way of the breath, to send life-force to the heart and the brain, so as to know G‑d, to love Him and to serve Him with all their heart, with a whole heart and a willing soul, and with a longing felt in the heart like flashes of a fiery flame, and thirst, etc.,
Mitzvos are food for the soul, but in exile this food does not pass “through the breath” to the heart and mind. It does not produce knowledge of G‑d, love, or a felt longing like flames of fire, just as a fetus’s food does not pass through its mouth and breathing organs.
כי אם כענין שנאמר ותהי יראתם אותי9 מצות אנשים מלומדה דהיינו בבחי׳ עשיה גשמית בלבד ובקרירות כו׳. וזהו עיקר הגלות ברוחניות.
but only as it is said, “Their fear of Me has become a commandment of men learned by rote”: that is, on the level of physical action alone, and with coldness, etc. And this is the essence of the exile in spiritual terms.
Instead the commandments are kept as Yeshayahu describes, “a commandment of men learned by rote”: physical action alone, done coldly. This, the Alter Rebbe says, is the core of exile in the spiritual sense.
The paragraph applies the analogy: in exile G‑d’s presence has withdrawn, the world seems independent, and the mitzvos nourish only the “body” of action without bringing life and feeling to the heart and mind.
A maamar of Va’eira 5739 cited in the Kehot note observes that the analogy mentions the organs of breathing while the application does not explain them. It explains them from Torah Ohr, Miketz: neshamah (soul) comes from neshimah (breathing), which is running and returning (ratzo vashov); in exile, as in the womb, these powers exist but do not act, so service lacks vitality and becomes rote.
Marei mekomos
- 1וככל המשל הזה · בד״ה וארא תשל״ט (מהנחה בלתי מוגה): שבהמשל מובא גם ע״ד אברי הנשימה, אך בהנמשל אינו מבארם. ומבאר זה ע״פ המבואר בתו״א מקץ לו, ב כי נשמה הוא מלשון נשימה שבאדם שהיא בחי׳ רצוא ושוב. ועד״ז באדם צ״ל העבודה בבחי׳ רצוא והעבודה בבחי׳ שוב, וזהו שהגלות נמשל לעיבור בענין אברי הנשימה, דכמו שבעיבור ישנו חתוך כל האברים גם אברי הנשימה, אך אינם פועלים פעולתם, עד״ז הוא גם בזמן הגלות (הנמשל לעיבור) דהכחות אינם פועלים פעולתם, ועד שהעבודה אינו בחיות כ״א כענין שנאמר ותהי יראתם אותי מצות אנשים מלומדה. ע״ש בארוכה.
- 2ה׳ ממרום ישאג · Jeremiah 25:30
- 3כמ״ש בזהר דסליק קוב״ה לעילא · Zohar I, 210a
- 4דסליק קוב״ה לעילא · Zohar, Achrei Mot 54:332–56:340
- 5רחל מבכה על בני׳ · Jeremiah 31:15
- 6והשמן לב העם · Isaiah 6:10
- 7בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד · Deuteronomy 4:39
- 8כרשפי אש שלהבת · Song of Songs 8:6
- 9ותהי יראתם אותי · Isaiah 29:13
6והנה תכלית השלימות של ימות המשיח שהוא בחי׳ לידה והתגלות אור ה׳ בקרב איש ולב עמוק1 כמ״ש ונגלה כבוד2 ה׳ וראו כל בשר וגו׳.
Now, the ultimate perfection of the days of Mashiach, which is the level of birth and the revelation of the light of G‑d within a person and in the depths of the heart, as it is written, “And the glory of G‑d shall be revealed, and all flesh shall see,” etc.,
The goal of the days of Mashiach is the “birth”: G‑d’s light openly revealed within each person, deep in the heart. Yeshayahu foretells that G‑d’s glory will be revealed and “all flesh shall see.”
וכתיב כי עין בעין יראו3 וגו׳ הוא תלוי במעשינו ובעבודתנו4 בימי הגלות ע״י התעוררות אהבה המסותרת ודאי בלבו של אדם עד שתחפוץ בחפצה ותשוקה ונפש שוקקה ולהיו׳ אהבת ה׳ בהתגלות לבו.
and it is written, “For they shall see eye to eye,” etc., depends on our deeds and our service during the exile, through arousing the love that is surely hidden in a person’s heart, until it desires with desire and longing and a yearning soul, and the love of G‑d comes to be revealed in his heart.
Yeshayahu adds that they will see “eye to eye.” This revelation depends on what we do during the exile: arousing the love of G‑d that is hidden in every Jewish heart until it becomes a felt, revealed longing.
The paragraph draws the practical point: the future “birth,” the revealed light of G‑d, depends on our service now, turning the hidden love in the heart into revealed love.
Or HaTorah, quoted in the Kehot note, explains that pregnancy here corresponds to Netzach, Hod and Yesod: the fetus eats through the navel and has no taste in its food, “for the palate tastes food,” and in service this is action alone. Tanya opens chapter 37 with almost the same words as this passage, and a sichah of Shabbos Va’eira 5749 traces the phrase “our deeds and our service” to the wording of the Rambam in the Laws of Repentance.
Marei mekomos
- 1בקרב איש ולב עמוק · Psalms 64:7
- 2ונגלה כבוד ה׳ · Isaiah 40:5
- 3כי עין בעין יראו · Isaiah 52:8
- 4הוא תלוי במעשינו ובעבודתנו · באוה״ת שה״ש כרך ב ע׳ תרד מבאר שכאן הכוונה: ”עיבור הוא נה״י שהולד ראשו בין ברכיו ואוכל דרך הטבור ואין טעם במאכל כי חך אוכל יטעם, וענין בחי׳ זו בעבודה היינו רק בחי׳ מעשה שהוא נו״ה, כן נתבאר בד״ה וארא”. וכן הלשון בתניא רפל״ז. וראה משיחת ש״פ וארא תשמ״ט סה״ש תשמ״ט ע׳ 197 הערה 70 שהמקור לדיוק לשון אדה״ז מעשינו ועבודתינו הוא מדיוק לשון הרמב״ם בפ״י מהלכות תשובה ע״ש.
Havayah is One ¶7–9
7וזהו שמע ישראל ה׳ אלהינו ה׳ אחד. ואהבת וגו׳.1 כי הנה2 צריך להבין מלת אחד שאינו מורה לכאורה על אמתית יחודו ית׳
And this is [the meaning of] “Hear, O Israel, Havayah is our G‑d, Havayah is One,” and “And you shall love,” etc. For we need to understand the word “One” (echad), which seemingly does not express the true nature of His unity, blessed be He:
The Shema declares that G‑d is “One” and then commands love. The Alter Rebbe asks why the word chosen is “One” (echad), since it does not seem to express G‑d’s true unity.
שהוא לבדו הוא ואפס זולתו ואין מלת אחד מורה על זה שהרי יש אחד המנוי ג״כ
that He alone is, and there is nothing besides Him. The word “One” does not express this, since there is also a “one” that is counted [among others],
G‑d’s true unity is that He alone exists and nothing exists besides Him. “One” cannot convey this, because “one” is also used for a single item counted among others.
ע״ד משל יעקב היה לו י״ב שבטים ואעפ״כ נק׳ ראובן אחד.3 אך יצחק נק׳ בנך יחידך4 וגם כאן הוי ליה למימר5 ה׳ יחיד.
as for example: Yaakov had twelve tribes, and even so Reuven is called “one.” Yitzchak, however, is called “your son, your only one (yechidecha).” Here too, then, it should have said, “Havayah is Single (yachid).”
Reuven is “one” of Yaakov’s twelve sons, as Yechezkel names the gates of the city “the gate of Reuven, one,” and so on: one of many. Yitzchak, by contrast, is called yechidecha, “your only one,” with no others beside him; so the Shema might have used yachid, “Single.”
אך הענין שבאמת לגבי קוב״ה מצד עצמותו ומהותו ית׳ לא שייך עליו מלת אחד כלל
But the explanation is that in truth, with regard to the Holy One, blessed be He, as He is in His own essence and being, the word “One” does not apply to Him at all,
The answer begins here: the word “One” is not meant to describe G‑d as He is in His own essence, where it does not apply at all.
שהרי הוא יחיד ומיוחד6 והוא לבדו הוא אלא כמאמר רז״ל שהוא אחד בשבעה רקיעים7 ובארץ ובד׳ רוחות העולם ר״ל שגם בשמים ובארץ ובד׳ רוחות העולם
for He is Single and Unique (yachid umeyuchad), and He alone is. Rather, [it means] as our Sages said, that He is One in the seven heavens, in the earth and in the four directions of the world. That is to say: even in the heavens, in the earth and in the four directions of the world,
In His essence G‑d is Single and Unique, alone with nothing beside Him, so calling Him “one” says too little. “One” refers instead to the Sages’ teaching that He is One in the seven heavens, the earth and the four directions, that is, within creation.
שהם בחי׳ ו״ק העולם בחי׳ התחלקות ופירוד אעפ״כ שורה ומתגלה יחודו ואחדותו ית׳ ואינון מתיחדין באחד8 שכולם בטלים לגבי אור ה׳ השורה ומתגלה בהם
which are the six extremities of the world, the level of division and separateness, His unity and oneness, blessed be He, nonetheless rest and are revealed, and “they are united in One,” for they are all nullified before the light of G‑d that rests and is revealed in them.
Heaven, earth and the four directions make up the six dimensions of the world, a realm of division and plurality. “One” means that G‑d’s unity rests and is revealed even there, because all these things are nullified before His light within them and so become one.
וכמ״ש וצבא השמים9 לך משתחוים והם ו״ק גשמיים וששה קצוות רוחניים דהיינו בחי׳ מעלה ומטה10 שיש בכל העולמות למעלה עד אין קץ ולמטה עד אין תכלית כי גבוה מעל גבוה וגו׳11
As it is written, “And the host of the heavens bow down to You.” These are six physical extremities and six spiritual extremities, that is, the level of above and below that exists in all the worlds, upward without end and downward without limit, for “one higher than the high,” etc.;
Nechemyah describes the heavenly hosts bowing before G‑d, a picture of creation nullified before Him. The six directions are both physical and spiritual: in every world there is higher and lower without end, as Koheles says, “one higher than the high.”
דהיינו מה שהוא נתפס ומושג בשכל והשגת הנבראים שבכל העולמות נק׳ מטה לגבי העליון שאינו נתפס ומושג בשכל והשגת הנבראים שלמטה ממנו ולית מחשבה דלהון תפיסא ביה
that is: what is grasped and comprehended by the intellect and comprehension of the created beings in all the worlds is called “below” relative to the higher, which is not grasped and comprehended by the intellect and comprehension of the created beings beneath it, and “no thought of theirs grasps it.”
Spiritual “above” and “below” are defined by comprehension: whatever the creatures of a world can grasp is “below” relative to a higher level that they cannot grasp at all.
וכן ד׳ רוחות העולם כי חסד דרועא ימינא12 שהוא דרום וגבורה דרועא שמאלא שהוא צפון כו׳ וכולם מתייחדים ונעשים אחד ליחודו ית׳ השוכן בתוכם
The four directions also have spiritual counterparts: in the Kabbalistic picture Chesed is the right arm, the south, and Gevurah the left arm, the north. All these dimensions are united and become one through G‑d’s unity that dwells within them.
משא״כ לגבי קוב״ה בכבודו ובעצמו שהוא יחיד ומיוחד הרי הוא רם ונשא רבבות מדרגות עד אין קץ וסוף מגדר הקצוות גשמיות ורוחניות
This is not so with regard to the Holy One, blessed be He, in His glory and His very Self, who is Single and Unique: He is exalted and lofty, myriads of degrees without end or limit, beyond the bounds of the extremities, physical and spiritual.
G‑d Himself, Single and Unique, is infinitely beyond all of this, beyond every dimension, physical or spiritual. So the word “One,” which describes unity within the dimensions, does not reach Him.
וכמ״ש לך ה׳ הגדולה והגבורה וכו׳ פי׳ שבחי׳ גדולה וגבורה וכו׳ בטלים לו ית׳ שאינם נקראים בשם גדולה וגבורה כלל
As it is written, “Yours, G‑d, are the greatness and the might,” etc. This means that the levels of greatness and might, etc., are nullified to Him, blessed be He, so that they are not called “greatness” and “might” at all,
David’s blessing, “Yours, G‑d, are the greatness and the might,” is read to mean that these attributes are so nullified before G‑d that, in relation to Him, they cannot even be called greatness and might.
“for all in the heavens and on the earth”: meaning that everything is nullified to Him, blessed be He. Before Him “darkness is as light,” and above and below are equal. For His being and essence
The verse continues, “for all in the heavens and on the earth,” meaning that everything is nullified before Him. As the psalm says that before Him “darkness is as light,” so above and below are equal to Him.
נמצא למטה כמו שנמצא למעלה ממש בלי שום חילוק ושינוי כלל ולא שייך לפניו ית׳ בחינת מעלה ומטה כלל ובחי׳ שמים וארץ כלל לא בבחינת ממלא כל עלמין ולא בבחי׳ סובב כל עלמין
are found below just as they are found above, without any distinction or change whatsoever. Before Him, blessed be He, the level of above and below does not apply at all, nor the level of heaven and earth at all: not at the level of the light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin), nor at the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin),
G‑d’s essence is present below exactly as it is above, without any difference. Even the two ways His light relates to the worlds, filling them from within and encompassing them from beyond, do not describe Him Himself.
כי אינו בבחי׳ וגדר עלמין כלל15 וכדכתיב כי נשגב שמו לבדו16 רק הודו על ארץ ושמים הודו בלבד בחי׳ זיו והתפשטות והארה ממנו בלבד
for He is not within the category and bounds of worlds at all. As it is written, “For His Name alone is exalted,” only “His splendor is upon earth and heaven”: His splendor alone, the level of a radiance, an extension and a glow from Him alone.
Both of those ways concern worlds, and G‑d is not within the category of worlds at all. The psalm says that His Name alone is exalted, and only His “splendor,” a radiance that extends from Him, is upon earth and heaven.
ואף גם בבחי׳ זו ארץ קדמה לשמים כו׳ כמ״ש במ״א ולכן אומרים מלא כל הארץ כבודו17 והמלאכים אומרים איה מקום כבודו להעריצו כו׳.18
And even at this level, “earth precedes heaven,” etc., as is explained elsewhere. Therefore we say, “The whole earth is full of His glory,” while the angels say, “Where is the place of His glory, to adore Him?” etc.
Even within that radiance “earth precedes heaven,” as in the verse just quoted, which names earth first; the point is explained elsewhere. That is why we below say, “The whole earth is full of His glory,” while the angels above ask, “Where is the place of His glory?”
The paragraph explains “Havayah is One”: the word refers not to G‑d’s essence, which is Single and beyond all dimensions, but to His unity revealed within the divided world, where everything is nullified before Him and so becomes one.
Or HaTorah, quoted in the Kehot note, answers why the verse does not say “Havayah is Single”: from the seven heavens, the earth and the four directions, of which He is Master, we recognize His power, and so the Shema says “One.” The note also observes that this distinction between “One” and “Single” is not mentioned in the Mitteler Rebbe’s transcript of the maamar. The Tzemach Tzedek, quoted in another note, explains “above and below are equal” to mean that G‑d is not even higher in rank, since rank applies only to created things and the ten Sefiros.
Marei mekomos
- 1שמע ישראל . . ואהבת וגו׳ · Deuteronomy 6:4
- 2כי הנה צ״ל מלת אחד · ראה לקו״ת תזריע כג, ג. בלק ע, א. ואתחנן ד״ה שמע ישראל. מאמרי אדה״ז על מארז״ל ע׳ קי. מאמרי אדה״א בראשית ע׳ תק. תו״ח שמות (אותיות מרובעות) מז, א ואילך. אוה״ת פ׳ ואתחנן ע׳ ריא וע׳ תכט ההפרש בין אחד ליחיד. בראשית כרך ז תתנד, ב. תתשנט, א ואילך. תתרלא, א. שבועות ע׳ רב. אמרי בינה שער הק״ש פ״ח. שרש מצות התפלה פי״א קכד, א. סה״מ תרכ״ז (הוצאת תש״ס) ע׳ קע. סה״מ תרנ״ד ע׳ נו. סה״מ תש״ח ע׳ 244. ד״ה על שלשה דברים תרנ״א. וראה בסה״מ תקס״ב ע׳ רמט בשם חובת הלבבות. ד״ה דודי לי פ׳ אחרי תשכ״ז. ד״ה אתה אחד תשכ״ט (סה״מ מלוקט ח״ד ע׳ סט). לקו״ש חי״א ע׳ 11. חי״ב ע׳ 66. המבואר כאן בין אחד ויחיד — אינו נזכר בהנחת כ״ק אדה״א בסה״מ תקס״ב.
- 3ראובן אחד · Ezekiel 48:31
- 4בנך יחידך · Genesis 22:2
- 5הוי לי׳ למימר ה׳ יחיד · Zohar III, 7b
- 6לגבי קוב״ה מצד עצמותו ומהותו . . שהרי הוא יחיד ומיוחד · מובא באוה״ת שה״ש כרך ב ע׳ תרכו.
- 7שהוא אחד בשבעה רקיעים · ראה שו״ע אדה״ז או״ח סי׳ סא סעי׳ ו. לקו״ת תזריע צג, ג.
- 8ואינון מתיחדין באחד · Zohar, Terumah 13:153–14:164
- 9וצבא השמים · Nehemiah 9:6
- 10דהיינו בחי׳ מעלה ומטה · מובא באוה״ת וירא כרך ד תשלט, א.
- 11כי גבוה מעל גבוה וגו׳ · Ecclesiastes 5:7
- 12חסד דרועא ימינא · Tikkunei Zohar 17a:16–17
- 13כחשיכה כאורה · Psalms 139:12
- 14ומעלה ומטה שוין · ראה ד״ה ציון במשפט תפדה תש״מ בדיוק הלשון מעלה ומטה. באוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ תו, ובספר החקירה עו, א, ובאוה״ת יחזקאל ע׳ תו מפרש כ״ק אדמו״ר הצ״צ וז״ל: ”ור״ל אף לא מעלה ומדרגה ולא כמ״ש המו״נ שנק׳ הוא ית׳ מקום ע״ש המעלה ומדרגה, כי בחי׳ מעלה ומדרגה שייך רק בהנמצאים וע״ס, אבל אצלו ית׳ שוה המעלה עם המטה כנ״ל ועמ״ש מענין זה בלק״ת גבי פסח בד״ה מצה זו כו׳”. ע״ש בארוכה. ולקמן סה, ב.
- 15משא״כ לגבי קוב״ה . . וגדר עלמין כלל · הלשון נעתק באוה״ת נ״ך כרך ג ע׳ א׳שצה ומציין ללקו״ת פ׳ בהעלותך כט, ד. וראה גם סה״מ תר״ל ע׳ קצז.
- 16כי נשגב שמו לבדו · Psalms 148:13
- 17מלא כל הארץ כבודו · Isaiah 6:3
- 18לך ה׳ הגדולה · I Chronicles 29:11
8והנה בחי׳ עיבור דהיינו בימי הגלות סליק קוב״ה1 לעילא לעילא דהיינו לגבי בחי׳ מהותו ועצמותו2 בחינת יחיד ומיוחד שאינו בגדר עלמין כלל ואינו שורה ומתגלה יחודו ואחדותו בתחתונים
Now, in the state of pregnancy, that is, in the days of exile, “the Holy One, blessed be He, has ascended on high, on high”: that is, to the level of His being and essence, the level of Single and Unique, which is not within the bounds of worlds at all; and His unity and oneness do not rest and are not revealed in the lower realms.
In exile, the “pregnancy,” G‑d has, in the Zohar’s words, ascended on high: to His essence, where He is Single and beyond all worlds. His unity is then not revealed in the lower realms.
As it is written, “On that day (that is, in the time to come) Havayah will be One and His Name One,” as the Gemara says, “Is He then not One now?” etc.
Zechariah’s prophecy that G‑d will be One “on that day” implies that He is not openly One now, and the Talmud asks, “Is He then not One now?” The parenthesis adds that “that day” means the time to come.
והיינו משום שבזמן הגלות אינו נראה יחודו ית׳ בהתגלות ונראה כאלו העולם הוא דבר ויש בפני עצמו5
This is because in the time of exile His unity, blessed be He, is not seen openly, and it seems as though the world were a thing and an entity (yesh) in itself.
The answer is that in exile G‑d’s unity is not openly seen, and the world appears to be a self-standing thing (yesh).
אלא שאף בגלותנו לא עזבנו ה׳ אחד ונותן לנו הכח להיותנו בני ישראל עם קרובו6 להיות יכולים להמשיך בחינת יחודו ואחדותו ית׳ למטה בתחתונים להיות שם ה׳ אחד בגילוי גם בבחי׳ התחלקות הקצוות מעלה ומטה כו׳
Yet even in our exile the One G‑d has not forsaken us. He gives us the power, since we are the children of Israel, “the people near to Him,” to be able to draw His unity and oneness, blessed be He, down below into the lower realms, so that the Name Havayah will be One, in revelation, even at the level of the division of the extremities, above and below, etc.,
Yet G‑d has not abandoned us. Because Jews are “the people near to Him,” He gives them the power to draw His unity down into the lower world, so that His Name is openly One even amid the divisions of space, physical and spiritual.
בגשמיות ורוחניות (וכן להמשיך על נפש האדם בבחי׳ ששה קצוות שלו שהם המדות אהבה ויראה כו׳ שיהיו בהתגלות לבו)
physical and spiritual (and likewise to draw [it] down upon a person’s soul, at the level of his six extremities, which are the emotive attributes (middos), love and awe, etc., so that they be revealed in his heart).
The parenthesis applies the same idea to a person: his own six “extremities” are his emotions, love, awe and the rest, and the task is to draw G‑d’s unity into them so that they are openly felt in his heart.
וזהו שמע ישראל פי׳ שישראל עם קרובו לכן ניתן להם הכח להמשיך בחי׳ הוי״ה למטה שיהא אחד ומתיחד בתחתונים
And this is [the meaning of] “Hear, O Israel”: because Israel are “the people near to Him,” they have therefore been given the power to draw the level of Havayah down below, so that it be One and united in the lower realms.
This is the meaning of “Hear, O Israel”: Israel, the people near to Him, is given the power to draw the Name Havayah down so that it is One and united in the lower realms.
וזהו תכלית כל העבודה מפני שנתאוה הקב״ה להיות לו דירה בתחתונים7 דייקא לאתכפיא סט״א ואסתלק89 יקרא דקוב״ה10 כו׳ וזהו וידעו מצרים11 כי אני ה׳ ולכן במקום שבעלי תשובה12 עומדים צדיקים גמורים13 כו׳.
And this is the purpose of all the [divine] service, because the Holy One, blessed be He, desired to have a dwelling place among the lower realms specifically: “to subdue the sitra achra (the other side), and the glory of the Holy One, blessed be He, is exalted,” etc. And this is [the meaning of] “And Egypt shall know that I am Havayah.” And therefore, “in the place where baalei teshuvah (those who return) stand, perfect tzaddikim,” etc.
This is the purpose of all service: G‑d desired a dwelling among the lowest realms, where subduing the sitra achra exalts His glory. Hence “Egypt shall know that I am Havayah,” and hence the Sages’ teaching that baalei teshuvah stand where even perfect tzaddikim cannot.
The paragraph applies the analogy to the Shema: in exile G‑d’s unity is hidden, but Israel has the power to draw it down and reveal it in the lower world, which is the purpose of creation.
A Kehot note quotes Sefer HaChakirah: G‑d’s “ascent” is not a physical removal but a concealment. The Torah Ohr passage on baalei teshuvah to which another note points explains that turning fiery bad traits back to G‑d brings about great delight above, and that this delight will be revealed in the time to come.
Marei mekomos
- 1בימי הגלות סליק קוב״ה · מובא באוה״ת פ׳ וירא כרך ד תשס, א.
- 2סליק קוב״ה . . לגבי בחי׳ מהותו ועצמותו · באוה״ת מג״א ע׳ ג׳ מציין לכאן.
- 3ביום ההוא יהי׳ ה׳ אחד · Zechariah 14:9
- 4אטו האידנא לאו אחד · Pesachim 50a:16–17
- 5והנה בחי׳ עיבור . . ויש בפני עצמו · הקטע מובא ביהל אור ע׳ שמד.
- 6בני ישראל עם קרובו · Psalms 148:14
- 7שנתאוה הקב״ה להיות לו דירה בתחתונים · Midrash Tanchuma, Nasso 16:1
- 8לאתכפיא סט״א ואסתלק · Zohar II, 122b
- 9ואסתלק · ואין זה סילוק גשמי אלא העלם — ספר החקירה ע׳ 272.
- 10לאתכפיא סט״א ואסתלק יקרא דקוב״ה · Zohar, Terumah 6:38–7:45
- 11וידעו מצרים · Exodus 7:5
- 12במקום שבעלי תשובה · נסמן לעיל כא, ג.
- 13במקום שבעלי תשובה עומדים צדיקים גמורים · Berakhot 34b:22–23
9וזהו ישמח ישראל בעשיו1 לשון רבים כי עושיו הם המשכותיו בבחי׳ רבוי והתחלקות כדי לקשרם וליחדם אליו ית׳ ועי״ז ממילא בא לבחי׳ ומעלת ואהבת את ה׳ וגו׳
And this is [the meaning of] “Let Israel rejoice in its Makers (be’osav),” in the plural: for “its Makers” are the extensions He draws forth at the level of multiplicity and division, in order to bind them and unite them with Him, blessed be He. And through this one comes, of itself, to the level and virtue of “And you shall love G‑d,” etc.,
The psalm says that Israel rejoices in its “Makers,” in the plural. These are the many ways G‑d extends Himself into multiplicity and division, which are to be bound and united with Him; from this, love of G‑d follows of itself.
בכל לבבך בשני יצריך2 דהיינו שתהיה אהבת ה׳ תקועה בלבו בהתגלות כרשפי אש שלהבת כל כך עד שירגיז יצר טוב על יצר הרע3 כאדם
“with all your heart (levavcha)”: with both your inclinations. That is, the love of G‑d will be fixed in his heart openly, like flashes of a fiery flame, so much so that he will rouse the good inclination to anger against the evil inclination, like a person
The Sages read “with all your heart” as “with both your inclinations,” the good and the evil. Love of G‑d becomes so fixed and open in the heart that a person rouses his good inclination to anger against the evil one.
שהוא ברוגז על הפוך רצונו התקוע לו בלבו ונוגע לעצמותו ומהותו כך כשתהיה אהבת ה׳ בקרב איש ולב עמוק ונגעה עד הנפש עד עצמותה ומהותה ממילא יהיה ברוגז מאד על ההפוך.
who is angry at whatever opposes a desire that is lodged in his heart and touches his very essence and being. So too, when the love of G‑d is within a person and in the depths of the heart, and it reaches the soul, its very essence and being, he will of himself be very angry at what opposes it.
Just as a person is angered by anything that goes against a desire touching his very self, a love of G‑d that reaches the core of the soul makes him angry, of itself, at whatever opposes it.
The paragraph shows how revealing G‑d’s unity below leads to love with both inclinations, a love so deep that it turns into anger against the evil inclination.
This anger at what opposes G‑d is the stage the maamar later identifies with Yitzchak, which in turn leads to Yaakov’s compassion and then to joy (paragraph 13).
Marei mekomos
- 1ישמח ישראל בעושיו · Psalms 149:2
- 2ואהבת . . בכל לבבך בשני יצריך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 3שירגיז יצר טוב על יצר הרע · Berakhot 5a:2
Joy as milk ¶10–11
10והנה עיקר העבודה מאהבה היא שמחת הנפש בה׳ עושה וקיום המצות בשמחה וכמ״ש עבדו את1 ה׳ בשמחה וכתיב תחת אשר לא עבדת את2 ה׳ אלהיך בשמחה ובטוב לבב3 מרוב כל וכמ״ש האריז״ל פי׳ פסוק זה.
Now, the essence of service out of love is the soul’s joy in G‑d, its Maker, and fulfilling the mitzvos with joy, as it is written, “Serve G‑d with joy,” and it is written, “Because you did not serve Havayah your G‑d with joy and with gladness of heart, out of the abundance of everything,” and as the Arizal wrote in explaining this verse.
Service out of love is above all joy: the soul’s joy in G‑d and doing the mitzvos gladly. Two verses show this, the psalm’s call to serve with joy and the Torah’s rebuke for not serving with joy and gladness of heart; the Alter Rebbe alludes to the Arizal’s explanation of the second verse without spelling it out.
The paragraph identifies joy as the heart of service out of love, preparing for the analogy of milk.
Tanya, chapter 26, to which the Kehot note points, likewise cites “Because you did not serve... with joy” and refers to “the Arizal’s well-known interpretation of this verse.” The chapter teaches that the evil inclination cannot be overcome with sluggishness born of sadness, only with alacrity born of joy.
Marei mekomos
- 1עבדו את ה׳ בשמחה · Psalms 100:2
- 2תחת אשר לא עבדת את ה׳ אלהיך בשמחה ובטוב לבב מרוב כל · Deuteronomy 28:47
- 3תחת אשר לא עבדת . . בשמחה ובטוב לבב וכמ״ש האריז״ל · Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 26:4–5
Now, joy is likened to milk, as it is written, “Honey and milk are under your tongue,” and as it is written, “As a man whom his mother comforts,” etc.
Joy is compared to milk. The Song of Songs speaks of “honey and milk under your tongue,” and Yeshayahu likens G‑d’s comfort to a mother comforting her child.
דהיינו כשם שהאם רוצה לשעשע את הילד מניקתו בחלב וזהו שעשועים שלו כי ע״י זה מתגדלים אבריו3 עד שיכול להלך
That is: just as a mother who wants to delight her child nurses it with milk, and this is its delight, for through it its limbs grow until it can walk.
A mother delights her child by nursing it, and the milk is both its pleasure and what makes its limbs grow until it can walk. The maamar will apply this to joy, which makes love and awe grow.
והנה החלב מתהוה מדם כי דם נעכר ונעשה חלב4 והדם הוא נעשה מן אכילה ושתיה שאוכלת האם שנהפך בקרבה ונעשה דם:
Now, milk comes into being from blood, for “blood decomposes and becomes milk”; and the blood is made from the food and drink that the mother eats, which is transformed within her and becomes blood.
Milk is not a separate substance: as the Talmud says, it is blood transformed, and the blood itself comes from the mother’s food and drink. This chain, food to blood to milk, is applied to divine service in what follows.
The paragraph introduces milk as the image of joy and traces milk back to blood and food, preparing for the stages of service that follow.
Likkutei Torah, Bamidbar, cited in the Kehot note, explains this image: the blood itself, which is Gevuros (severities), is turned into milk, white Chasadim (kindnesses); severities that are themselves sweetened become finer than before.
Marei mekomos
- 1דבש וחלב תחת לשונך · Song of Songs 4:11
- 2כאיש אשר אמו תנחמנו · Isaiah 66:13
- 3כי ע״י זה מתגדלים אבריו · ראה אוה״ת שה״ש כרך ב ע׳ תרפג ואילך.
- 4דם נעכר ונעשה חלב · Niddah 9a:10–11
From offerings to joy ¶12–13
12ולהבין ענין זה בעבודת ה׳. הנה כתיב את קרבני לחמי לאשי1 שהקרבן נעשה לו ית׳ בחינת לחם ומזון כביכול שעולה ריח ניחח לה׳ ע״ד ישראל מפרנסין לאביהם שבשמים.23
To understand this in the service of G‑d: it is written, “My offering, My bread, for My fires”: the offering becomes for Him, blessed be He, bread and food, so to speak, for it rises as a pleasing fragrance to G‑d, in the manner of “Israel sustain their Father in heaven.”
The analogy of food, blood and milk is now applied to divine service. The Torah calls the offerings G‑d’s “bread”: they are, so to speak, His food, rising as a pleasing fragrance, in line with the Sages’ saying that Israel “sustain” their Father in heaven.
וענין הקרבן להקריב גם נפש4 הבהמי׳ שבאדם בשעת הבאת קרבנו מן הבהמה בכוונה וברעותא דלבא למסור נפשו לה׳ להעביר רוח הטומאה מן הארץ5 וכל מחשבות והרהורין בישין יבטלון והיו לשרפת אש כליל על מזבח ה׳.
The point of the offering is to offer up also the animal soul that is in a person, at the time he brings his offering from the animals, with intent and with the heart’s desire (re’usa deliba) to give over his soul to G‑d, to remove the spirit of impurity from the land, so that all evil thoughts and musings be nullified and become a burning of fire, wholly [consumed] upon the altar of G‑d.
Bringing an animal was meant to offer up the person’s animal soul as well, giving it over to G‑d with sincere intention. The aim was to remove the spirit of impurity, so that evil thoughts would be consumed like the offering on the altar.
The paragraph begins applying the analogy to divine service: the offerings are G‑d’s “food,” and their inner point is the offering up of the animal soul.
Torah Ohr, Miketz, cited in the Kehot note, explains “Israel sustain their Father in heaven” as drawing the Infinite Light down, chiefly through the Torah, which is called “My bread.” Another note says that offering the animal soul means that even the will of the body’s matter is transformed.
Marei mekomos
- 1את קרבני לחמי לאשי · Numbers 28:2
- 2ישראל מפרנסין לאביהם שבשמים · נסמן לעיל לג, ד.
- 3ישראל מפרנסין לאביהם שבשמים · Zohar, Vayikra 13:97–16:104
- 4וענין הקרבן להקריב גם נפש הבהמית שבאדם · ראה לקמן קיא, ג דהיינו שמתהפך גם רצון חומר הגוף. אוה״ת פ׳ כי תשא ע׳ א׳תתפו. לקו״ת פ׳ כי תצא בתחלתו.
- 5רוח הטומאה מן הארץ · Zechariah 13:2
13ועכשיו שאין בהמ״ק קיים בטלו הקרבנות ואין אנו יכולים לבטל ולהעביר ממשלת הנפש הבהמית מכל וכל לכן תקנו לנו תפלות כנגד תמידין.1
Now that the Holy Temple does not stand, the offerings have ceased, and we are not able to nullify and remove the rule of the animal soul entirely. Therefore [the Sages] instituted for us prayers corresponding to the daily offerings (temidin).
Without the Temple there are no offerings, and we cannot fully remove the rule of the animal soul. So the Sages instituted prayers in place of the daily offerings.
וזהו שאומרים ברוך אתה ה׳ כו׳. כלומר שאף שאין אנחנו יכולים לעשות חובותינו באתערותא דלתתא שלנו אעפ״כ יהא אתערותא דלעילא מחמת
And this is why we say, “Blessed are You, Havayah,” etc. That is to say: although we are not able to fulfill our obligations through our own arousal from below, nevertheless may there be an arousal from above, because
The opening of every blessing, “Blessed are You, Havayah,” expresses this: though our own arousal from below cannot fulfill our obligations, we ask that G‑d respond with an arousal from above.
כי חפץ חסד הוא2 ויוברך ויומשך מלעילא ברכת ה׳ להיות שמו נקרא עלינו בבחינת אלהינו שנהיה בטלים אליו למשוך אחריו בכל לב ונפש כו׳
“He desires kindness,” and the blessing of G‑d will be “blessed” and drawn down from above, so that His Name be called upon us at the level of “our G‑d” (Elokeinu): that we be nullified to Him, to be drawn after Him with all heart and soul, etc.,
The reason, in Michah’s words, is that G‑d “desires kindness.” “Blessed” is read as “drawn down”: G‑d’s blessing descends so that His Name is called upon us as “our G‑d,” and we become nullified to Him and drawn after Him with all our heart.
כמ״ש במ״א ועד״ז הוא ענין כל רמ״ח מצות עשה רמ״ח המשכות גילוי אלהותו ית׳ להיות שורה בתחתונים והוא נחשב לו ית׳ עד״מ
as is explained elsewhere. And in the same way, all 248 positive commandments are 248 drawings-down of the revelation of His G‑dliness, blessed be He, to rest in the lower realms. And this is considered for Him, blessed be He, by way of analogy,
The same applies to the 248 positive commandments, each a channel that draws G‑dliness down to rest in the lower realms. To G‑d, the Alter Rebbe says, this is, so to speak, like eating.
כמו אכילה שע״י מאכל האדם תחזק נפשו בגופו להיות משכן לנפש בתוך הגוף וכן ע״י מצות ומע״ט נעשה כסא ומכון לשבתו להיות לו דירה בתחתונים כשיומשך ויתגלה בהם בחי׳ ה׳ אחד
like eating: through a person’s food his soul is strengthened in his body, so that there be a dwelling for the soul within the body. So too, through mitzvos and good deeds a throne and a place for His dwelling is made, so that He has a dwelling place among the lower realms, when the level of “Havayah is One” is drawn down and revealed in them.
Food keeps the soul joined to the body so the body can house it; mitzvos and good deeds likewise make a “throne” and dwelling for G‑d below, when His unity, “Havayah is One,” is drawn down and revealed there.
וגם ישראל למטה מקבלים הארה מבחי׳ אכילה זו לשלוח חיות ללב ולמוח כדי לאהבה את ה׳ ולעבדו בכל לב ונפש
And Israel below also receive a glow from this “eating,” to send life-force to the heart and the brain, so as to love G‑d and serve Him with all [their] heart and soul.
Israel also benefits from this “eating”: like food that sends life to heart and brain, it gives them the vitality to love and serve G‑d fully. This is the first stage of service.
ואח״כ יעלו ויבאו מזה לקבל הארת והשפעת בחי׳ הדם הוא הנפש3 כמו המזון שנהפך בקרבו ונעשה דמו
Afterwards they will rise and come from this to receive the glow and the influence of the level of “the blood is the soul,” like food that is transformed within a person and becomes his blood,
Next comes a deeper stage, “the blood is the soul”: as food becomes blood, and blood is a person’s very life, so G‑d’s light can become part of the person’s own being.
וזהו חיותו וקיומו כך ע״י המשכת אור ה׳ על נפשו בקיום המצות בסור מרע ועשה טוב נעשה כסא ומכון לשבתו עד שאור ה׳ אחד שורה ומתגלה בו בתוך נקודת לבבו ונגעה עד הנפש ממש להיות
and this is his life and existence. So too, through drawing the light of G‑d upon his soul by fulfilling the mitzvos, by “turning from evil and doing good,” he becomes a throne and a place for His dwelling, until the light of “Havayah is One” rests and is revealed in him, within the innermost point of his heart, and it reaches the very soul, to be
By keeping the mitzvos, turning from evil and doing good, the person becomes a throne for G‑d, until His unity is revealed at the innermost point of his heart and reaches the soul itself.
כמו עצמיות אחד ממש וממילא ירגז על הרע שבקרבו כמו רוגז האדם על הפוך בדבר שנוגע לעצמותו ומהותו שבא מרתיחת הדמים
truly like one essence. And then, of itself, he will be angered at the evil within him, like a person’s anger at the opposite of something that touches his essence and being, [anger] that comes from the boiling of the blood,
G‑d’s light and the person become, as it were, one essence. Then he is angered by the evil within him, as anyone is angered by what threatens his very self, an anger that comes from the boiling of the blood.
for “the blood is the soul.” And this is the level of Yitzchak, and the level of “The offerings of G‑d are a broken spirit,” etc., that is, the spirit of the sitra achra (the other side), etc.
Since the blood is the soul, this anger is the level of Yitzchak. The verse “the offerings of G‑d are a broken spirit” is read as the breaking of the spirit of the sitra achra.
ומזה יבא לבחי׳ ומדרגת יעקב מדת הרחמנות על נפשו כאשר יראה בה שהיא בתוך ההפכה ואזי ויצעק אל ה׳ בצר לו שממדת הרוגז על הרע בא למדת הרחמנות
From this he will come to the level and rank of Yaakov, the attribute of compassion for his soul, when he sees that it is in the midst of the overthrow. And then “he cries out to G‑d in his distress”: from the attribute of anger at evil he comes to the attribute of compassion.
From anger at evil a person moves on to Yaakov’s level, compassion: seeing his soul caught in a place of overthrow, he cries out to G‑d. Anger at evil turns into pity for his own soul.
משא״כ כשיש דרך ישר לפני איש לא שייך ונופל עליו לשון רחמנות והרחמנות הוא התחלה והכנה לשמחה שתבוא אח״כ כאשר ישיב ללבו הן אמת כו׳.
Whereas when “a way seems right before a man,” the term “compassion” does not apply or fit him. And compassion is the beginning of, and the preparation for, the joy that will come afterwards, when he takes to heart, “Indeed it is true,” etc.,
Someone whose way seems right in his own eyes feels no need for such compassion. Compassion is the beginning of, and the preparation for, the joy that follows, when he reflects, “Indeed it is true...” as Tanya explains.
as is written in the Tanya. And through this, the joy will be great, [joy] in G‑d “who has sanctified us with His commandments,” with the supernal holiness, etc., like “the advantage of light” that comes from darkness,
Tanya describes how, after the bitterness, a person comforts himself and comes to true joy. Here the joy is in G‑d “who has sanctified us with His commandments,” and it is all the greater because it comes out of darkness, as light is valued most after darkness.
כמ״ש במ״א וזהו בבכי יבאו ובתחנונים אובילם8 וכתיב הלוך ובכה ילכו9 ואת ה׳ אלהיהם יבקשו כי הבכיה לעתיד תתעורר מחמת בחי׳ ראיה וראו כל בשר10 וגו׳
as is explained elsewhere. And this is [the meaning of] “With weeping they will come, and with supplications I will lead them,” and it is written, “They will walk, weeping as they go, and they will seek Havayah their G‑d.” For the weeping in the time to come will be aroused by the level of seeing: “and all flesh shall see,” etc.
Yirmeyahu describes the returning exiles as weeping and seeking G‑d. In the future, the Alter Rebbe says, this weeping will be aroused by seeing, when “all flesh shall see” G‑d’s glory.
ואז יתעורר הרחמנות במאד על העבר והיא התחלת השמחה לשמוח באלהים חיים וקרבת ה׳ יחפץ
And then compassion will be greatly aroused over the past, and this is the beginning of the joy of rejoicing in the living G‑d, and he will desire nearness to G‑d,
That sight will arouse great compassion over the past, and this compassion is the beginning of joy in the living G‑d and of the desire to be near Him.
כמ״ש ואת ה׳ אלהיהם יבקשו ולכן אומרים בתפלת שמונה עשרה סלח לנו כי חטאנו ולא קודם התפלה לפי שעדיין לא קבל עליו מלכות שמים בק״ש11
as it is written, “and they will seek Havayah their G‑d.” Therefore we say in the Shemoneh Esreh prayer, “Forgive us, for we have sinned,” and not before the prayer, because he has not yet accepted upon himself the kingship of Heaven in the reading of the Shema;
This is why “Forgive us, for we have sinned” is said in the Shemoneh Esreh and not before it: until he has accepted G‑d’s kingship in the Shema, a person does not yet feel his sin.
משא״כ כשאומר בק״ש ה׳ אחד דהיינו שיחודו ואחדותו ית׳ מתגלה בתחתונים ואזי רואה בנפשו חטאו וחסרונו שחסר לו אור ה׳ ובהבל בא ובחשך ילך12 ע״כ המו מעיו לו רחם13 ירחמנו
whereas when he says in the Shema, “Havayah is One,” that is, that His unity and oneness, blessed be He, is revealed in the lower realms, then he sees in his soul his sin and his lack: that he lacks the light of G‑d, and “he came in futility and goes in darkness.” Therefore “his innards stir for him; he will surely have compassion on him.”
After saying “Havayah is One,” recognizing G‑d’s unity revealed below, he sees how he lacks G‑d’s light and that he “came in futility and goes in darkness.” Then compassion stirs in him, in Yirmeyahu’s words, “my innards stir for him.”
ואח״כ יוכל לבא לידי שמחה אמיתית ואין לך שמחה אמיתית יותר מזה שכאשר לא נולדה תחלה הרחמנות בנפשו אין זו שמחה אמיתית14 וכמשל התינוק הנולד שבצאתו לאויר העולם הוא צועק תחלה ואח״כ נותנים לו החלב.
And afterwards he can come to true joy, and there is no truer joy than this. For when compassion has not first been born in his soul, it is not true joy. It is like the analogy of a newborn infant: when it comes out into the air of the world it first cries out, and afterwards they give it milk.
Only then can he reach true joy; joy that is not preceded by compassion is not true joy. A newborn, likewise, first cries and only then is given milk.
והנה עיקר השמחה והתענוג הוא מהתבוננות בגדולת ה׳ ואשר בחר בנו מכל העמים וקרבנו לעבודתו ולכן ארז״ל שהדדים הם במקום בינה:15
Joy and delight come mainly from contemplating G‑d’s greatness and His choosing us. That is why the Alter Rebbe cites the Talmud’s remark that the breasts are “in the place of binah (understanding)”: milk, the image of joy, is placed where contemplation is.
The paragraph maps the stages of service onto food, blood and milk: prayer and mitzvos draw G‑d’s light down, the light becomes one with the person, and this leads to anger at evil (Yitzchak), to compassion (Yaakov), and finally to true joy.
Manuscript 17, quoted in the Kehot notes, adds that the first stage, life-force reaching heart and mind to love G‑d, is the level of Avraham, and the food turning into blood, anger at what opposes, is Yitzchak. It also links this to the maamar on “Oseri lagefen” in Vayechi: one cannot reach “the wine that gladdens” without first “the wine that intoxicates,” bitterness over one’s distance from G‑d, since delight in anything depends on a prior desire for it.
Marei mekomos
- 1תפלות כנגד תמידין · Berakhot 26b:4–5
- 2כי חפץ חסד הוא · Micah 7:18
- 3הדם הוא הנפש · Deuteronomy 12:23
- 4זבחי אלקים רוח נשברה · Psalms 51:19
- 5דהיינו רוח הסט״א כו׳ · בבוך באב׳ 17 כז, ב נוסף: (ובחי׳ אברהם היינו בחי׳ אהבה שקודם בחי׳ לעולם ירגיז כו׳ שהרי מתחלה ע״י אכילה דמצות ומע״ט נמשך חיות ללב ומוח לאהבה את ה׳ ולעבדו זהו בחי׳ אברהם ומה שאח״כ נהפך המזון לדם בחי׳ רוגז על ההיפוך זהו ובחי׳ יצחק כנ״ל).
- 6כמ״ש בתניא · פרק לא. בבוך 633: כמ״ש בלק״א.
- 7כיתרון האור · Ecclesiastes 2:13
- 8בבכי יבאו ובתחנונים אובילם · Jeremiah 31:9
- 9הלוך ובכה ילכו · Jeremiah 50:4
- 10וראו כל בשר · Isaiah 40:5
- 11מלכות שמים בק״ש · בבוך באב׳ 17 נוסף: (הי׳ דרכו ישר בעיניו ולא הרגיש שהוא חוטא).
- 12ובהבל בא ובחשך ילך · Ecclesiastes 6:4
- 13המו מעיו לו רחם ארחמנו · Jeremiah 31:20
- 14אין זו שמחה אמיתית · בבוך באב׳ 17 כח, א נוסף: (וכה״ג נת״ל פ׳ ויחי ע״פ אסרי לגפן שא״א לבוא לבחי׳ יין המשמח שהיא שמחה מגדולתו ית׳ ואנחנו עם קרובו כו׳ בלתי יוקדם תחלה בחי׳ יין המשכר שהוא המרירות על ריחוקו מה׳, כי לא שייך תענוג מאיזו דבר אם לא יוקדם רצון לזה ולפי ערך הרצון והתשוקה להדבר כך יהי׳ התענוג כשנתמלא לו אותו הדבר כו׳ ע״ש).
- 15שהדדים הם במקום בינה · Berakhot 10a:16–18
Kel Sha-dai ¶14
14וזהו וארא אל אברהם אל יצחק ואל יעקב באל שדי.1 פי׳ בבחי׳ והמשכות בחי׳ שדי מל׳ ברכות שדים23 שהם בחי׳ דדים וחלב להגדיל המדות4 אהבה ויראה כו׳
And this is [the meaning of] “And I appeared to Avraham, to Yitzchak and to Yaakov as Kel Sha-dai”: that is, at the level of, and through the drawings-down of, the level of Sha-dai, from the expression “blessings of the breasts (shadayim),” which are the level of breasts and milk, to make the emotive attributes (middos) grow, love and awe, etc.,
Now the opening verse is explained: G‑d appeared to the Avos as Kel Sha-dai, a Name read as related to shadayim, “breasts.” This is the flow of “milk,” joy, that makes the emotive attributes, love and awe, grow.
שהן הם בחי׳ האבות אחר שה׳ אחד בהתגלות לבו בבחי׳ לידה והתגלות לשמח נפשם בתוספת אורה ושמחה להתענג על ה׳ בשמחה ובטוב לבב מרוב כל:
which are the level of the Avos, after “Havayah is One” is revealed in his heart at the level of birth and revelation: to gladden their souls with added light and joy, to delight in G‑d with joy and with gladness of heart, out of the abundance of everything.
These attributes are the level of the Avos, love being Avraham and awe Yitzchak. After the “birth,” when “Havayah is One” is revealed in the heart, Kel Sha-dai nourishes them with added light and joy, so that a person delights in G‑d with gladness of heart.
The paragraph ties the analogy back to the verse: “I appeared... as Kel Sha-dai” is the “milk” of joy that nurtures love and awe, the qualities of the Avos present in every Jew, once G‑d’s unity is revealed in the heart.
Or HaTorah, cited in the Kehot note, says that this reading of Sha-dai as breasts appears also in Shaarei Orah, and raises a difficulty from the maamar “Va’eira” of 5568, which explains Kel Sha-dai as the attribute of tzimtzum. Likkutei Torah, Shir HaShirim, refers back to this maamar for its explanation of pregnancy, birth and nursing in the service of G‑d.
Marei mekomos
- 1וארא אל אברהם אל יצחק ואל יעקב באל שדי · Exodus 6:3
- 2בחי׳ שדי מל׳ ברכות שדים · באוה״ת פ׳ וארא ע׳ קנז כ׳ שכ״ה גם בספר שערי אורה שער ב׳ לה״ר יוסף גיקטליא והקשה שבד״ה וארא תקס״ח מבאר שבחי׳ אל שדי זהו ענין מדת הצמצום, ע״ש בארוכה. באוה״ת כי תצא ע׳ תתקכה מציין לכאן.
- 3ברכת שדים ורחם · Genesis 49:25
- 4וחלב להגדיל המדות · בלקו״ת שה״ש לג, ב מציין: ”ושם [בתו״א] נתבאר ענין עיבור ולידה ויניקה בעבודת ה׳ ועיין בפרדס בערכי הכינוים ערך חלב ובשער ח׳ פ״ו ובזהר משפטים (דקכ״ב ע״ב) בענין רוחצות בחלב ובאדרא רבא דקל״ו ע״ב” ע״ש.
“My Name was not known to them” ¶15–18
15אך ושמי ה׳ לא נודעתי להם. כי הנה אמרו רז״ל שקיים אברהם אבינו ע״ה את כל התורה1 עד שלא נתנה2 והיינו שקיים מעשה המצות מאהבה
But “[by] My Name Havayah I was not known to them.” For our Sages said that Avraham our father, peace be upon him, fulfilled the entire Torah before it was given; that is, he fulfilled the deeds of the mitzvos out of love,
Now the second half of the verse: “My Name Havayah I was not known to them.” The Sages say that Avraham kept the whole Torah before it was given, which the Alter Rebbe explains as performing the mitzvos out of love.
וכמאמר רז״ל אברהם תיקן תפלת שחרית3 והיינו בחינת המשכת אור ה׳ להיות ה׳ אחד שורה ומתגלה בתחתונים לאהבה את ה׳ אהבה בתענוגים ולעבדו בלב ונפש
as in the saying of our Sages, “Avraham instituted the morning prayer.” This is the level of drawing down the light of G‑d, so that “Havayah is One” rests and is revealed in the lower realms, to love G‑d with a love of delights and to serve Him with heart and soul.
The Sages also say that Avraham instituted the morning prayer. This is drawing down G‑d’s light so that His unity rests in the lower realms, and loving G‑d with a love full of delight.
אבל מ״מ כל זה נק׳ עדיין בשם עבודת עבד ששומע בקול רבו ועושה ציוויו מאהבה ובשמחה ובטוב לבב וכן יצחק מיראה ופחד יצחק4 כו׳.
Nevertheless, all this is still called the service of a servant, who obeys his master’s voice and carries out his command out of love, with joy and with gladness of heart. And likewise Yitzchak, out of awe, “the Fear of Yitzchak,” etc.
For all its greatness, this is still the service of a servant, who obeys his master gladly but remains a separate self who serves. Yitzchak served likewise through awe, as the Torah calls G‑d “the Fear of Yitzchak.”
אבל משה רבינו ע״ה מדה אחרת היתה בו שאמר ונחנו מה5 בחי׳ בטול לגמרי6 לפיכך זכה שנתנה תורה על ידו בבחי׳ דבור
But Moshe our teacher, peace be upon him, had a different quality in him, for he said, “And what are we?”, the level of complete self-nullification (bittul). Therefore he merited that the Torah was given through him, at the level of speech.
Moshe had a different quality, complete self-nullification, expressed in his words “And what are we?” For this reason the Torah was given through him, in the form of speech.
ואמרו רז״ל שהיתה שכינה מדברת מתוך גרונו של משה7 כי לא שייך בחי׳ אהבה ותענוג רק בבחי׳ התגלות נגלות אור ה׳ להיות השראתו בתחתונים שהם בגדר עלמין מעלה ומטה כו׳
And our Sages said that the Shechinah (Divine Presence) spoke from within the throat of Moshe. For love and delight apply only at the level of the revelation of the revealed light of G‑d, so that it dwells in the lower realms, which are within the bounds of worlds, above and below, etc.
The Sages say that the Shechinah spoke from Moshe’s throat. Love and delight belong to the revealed level of G‑d’s light, the light that dwells within the worlds, where there is above and below.
אבל דבר ה׳ זו הלכה8 ואורייתא וקוב״ה כולא חד9 שהוא יחיד ומיוחד ולית מחשבה תפיסא ביה לא שייך בזה שום הרגשת אהבה או תענוג שאינו מרגיש את עצמו כלל
But “the word of G‑d: this is halachah,” and “the Torah and the Holy One, blessed be He, are all one,” He who is Single and Unique and whom “no thought can grasp.” In this, no feeling of love or delight applies, for he does not feel himself at all;
The Torah is different: “the word of G‑d” is halachah, and the Torah is one with G‑d, who is Single and beyond the grasp of thought. In conveying it there is no feeling of love or delight, because the speaker does not feel himself at all.
רק הוא בטל במציאות ואינו תופס מקום לעצמו כלל10 אלא שהוא נמשך אחריו לדבר מה שהוא מדבר
rather, he is nullified in his very existence and takes up no place for himself at all, only he is drawn after Him to speak what He speaks.
He is nullified in his very existence, occupying no place of his own, and is simply drawn after G‑d to say what G‑d says.
וכמ״ש ואשים דברי בפיך11 ובזה הוא ממשיך המשכת יחודו ואחדותו ית׳ בכבודו ובעצמו כמו קודם שנברא העולם שיתגלה למטה שגם עכשיו העולם כאין ואפס והי׳ כלא היה ואין כאן לא מעלה ולא מטה כו׳.
As it is written, “And I have put My words in your mouth.” Through this he draws down His unity and oneness, blessed be He, in His glory and His very Self, as before the world was created, so that it be revealed below that even now the world is as nothing and naught, and it is as though it had never been, and there is here neither above nor below, etc.
As Yeshayahu says, “I have put My words in your mouth.” Through this the person draws down G‑d’s own unity, as it was before creation, revealing that even now the world is as nothing and there is neither above nor below.
The paragraph contrasts the service of the Avos, love and awe that still leave a self who loves, with Moshe’s complete self-nullification, through which the Torah, one with G‑d’s essence, was given.
A sichah cited in the Kehot notes calls Moshe’s self-nullification higher than that of the Avos. Another, quoted in full, explains that such bittul is not within a person’s own power, as “a prisoner cannot free himself”; it comes through G‑d’s revelation from above, specifically the revelation of the Name Havayah, G‑d’s essence as He is above the limits of the world. The note also lists several places in the Zohar for “the Shechinah spoke from Moshe’s throat.”
Marei mekomos
- 1שקיים אברהם אבינו ע״ה את כל התורה · משנה סוף קידושין.
- 2שקיים אברהם אבינו ע״ה את כל התורה עד שלא נתנה · Mishnah Kiddushin 4:14
- 3אברהם תיקן תפלת שחרית · Berakhot 26b:5–6
- 4ופחד יצחק · Genesis 31:42
- 5ונחנו מה · Exodus 16:7
- 6בחי׳ ביטול לגמרי · למעלה מהביטול דאבות (לקו״ש לכ״ד טבת ח״ו ע׳ 38 הערה 29). ראה סה״מ תרכ״ט ע׳ רכט ואילך.
- 7שכינה מדברת מתוך גרונו של משה · Zohar II, 115b
- 8דבר ה׳ זו הלכה · Shabbat 138b:11–12
- 9ואורייתא וקוב״ה כולא חד · נסמן לקמן נז, ג.
- 10תפיסא — שאינו מרגיש את עצמו כלל . . ואינו תופס מקום לעצמו כלל · ”שביטול כזה אין ביכולתו של אדם לפעול בכח עצמו (ע״ד אין חבוש מתיר עצמו כו׳), אלא בא על ידי התגלות ה׳ מלמעלה, ובזה גופא — גילוי שם הוי׳, היינו עצמותו של הקב״ה כפי שהוא למעלה מגדרי העולם” — לקו״ש לפ׳ וארא חל״א ע׳ 25.
- 11ואשים דברי בפיך · Isaiah 51:16
16ומזה אינו נמשך על נפש האדם בחי׳ אהבה או תענוג רק בחי׳ בטול לגמרי וזהו לשון דבור מלשון ידבר עמים תחתנו1 שהוא ל׳ הנהגה והמשכ׳
From this, what is drawn upon a person’s soul is not love or delight but only the level of complete self-nullification (bittul). And this is the term “speech” (dibbur), from the expression “He leads (yadber) peoples under us,” which is a term for leading and drawing,
What this draws upon the soul is not love or delight but total self-nullification. This is why the Torah came as dibbur, “speech,” a word the Alter Rebbe connects with yadber in the verse “He leads peoples under us,” meaning leading and drawing down.
דהיינו שממשיך שיתגלה למטה בבחי׳ היותו יחיד2 שהוא בחי׳ עצמותו ומהותו כביכול ולא בבחי׳ אחד בלבד
that is, he draws [Him] down to be revealed below as He is Single (yachid), which is the level of His essence and being, so to speak, and not only as One (echad).
Speaking Torah draws G‑d down to be revealed below as He is Single (yachid), His very essence, and not only as One (echad) within the worlds.
והיינו ע״י התורה דכתיב בה וידבר ה׳ אל משה וגם אינה נקראת בשם עבודת עבד כי כשלומד הדין זה ומדבר דין זה הוא כמלך שמצוה לעשות משפט עמו.
And this is through the Torah, of which it is written, “And G‑d spoke to Moshe.” Nor is it called the service of a servant: for when one studies this law and speaks this law, he is like a king who commands that judgment be executed for his people.
This happens through the Torah, whose laws are introduced again and again with “And G‑d spoke to Moshe.” Such study is not a servant’s service: one who learns and states a law is like a king issuing a decree for his people.
The paragraph explains why Torah study draws down G‑d as Single, above His unity within the worlds, and why it is the act of a king rather than of a servant.
Torah Ohr, Yisro, cited in the Kehot note, reads “Moshe would speak” in the same way: yedaber means drawing down and leading, and Moshe, through his self-nullification, drew the Infinite Light down, since wisdom comes from ayin, nothingness.
Marei mekomos
- 1ידבר עמים תחתינו · Psalms 47:4
- 2בבחי׳ היותו יחיד · ראה ספר קיצורים והערות לס׳ התניא ע׳ קה. סה״מ תרס״ו ע׳ רסט.
17ולכן אמרו מאן מלכי רבנן1 ואמרו מתניתא מלכתא2 שהרי הוא כאומר דבר המלך בלבד ואינו עושה כלום ואינו מדבר דברי עצמו כלל
Therefore they said, “Who are kings? The Rabbis,” and they said, “The Mishnah is a queen.” For he is like one who only states the word of the king: he does nothing and does not speak his own words at all.
This is why the Talmud calls the Rabbis “kings” and the Mishnah a “queen.” One who states Torah law is like one who announces the king’s word: he adds nothing of his own.
כמו העבד העושה צווי רבו שהרי הוא העושה והמקיים דבר המלך ודתו ואפילו עושה מאהבה בתענוגים אעפ״כ יש מי שאוהב3 כו׳ ולפי שלא נתנה תורה להאבות עדיין
[He is not] like the servant who carries out his master’s command, for [the servant] is the one who does and fulfills the king’s word and his decree; and even when he does it out of a love of delights, nevertheless there is one who loves, etc. And because the Torah had not yet been given to the Avos,
A servant, by contrast, is the one who carries out the king’s decree, so even when he serves out of delight he remains a self who loves. Because the Avos lived before the Torah was given, their service, however lofty, was of this kind.
לכן כתיב ושמי ה׳ לא נודעתי להם לא הודעתי אין כתיב כאן4 אלא נודעתי5 שאלו כתיב הודעתי היה משמע דקאי על שמי ה׳
therefore it is written, “[by] My Name Havayah I was not known (noda’ti) to them.” It does not say here “I did not make known (hoda’ti),” but “I was not known.” For had it said “I did not make known,” it would imply that it refers to “My Name Havayah.”
Hence the verse: “My Name Havayah I was not known (noda’ti) to them.” It does not say “I did not make known (hoda’ti),” which would mean only that the Name Havayah was not taught to them.
אבל עכשיו דכתיב לא נודעתי פי׳ שאני בעצמי לא נודעתי להם דהיינו בבחי׳ אני בעצמי בחי׳ יחיד.
But now that it says “I was not known,” it means that I Myself was not known to them: that is, the level of “I Myself,” the level of Single (yachid).
The passive “I was not known” means that G‑d Himself, His essence, was not known to them. This is the level of yachid, which was revealed through the Torah given by way of Moshe.
The paragraph completes the reading of the verse: the Avos knew G‑d as Kel Sha-dai through love and awe, but G‑d’s very Self, the level of Single, became known only with the giving of the Torah.
Rashi on the verse makes the same point about the wording, but explains “I was not known” as G‑d not having been recognized through His attribute of faithfulness, keeping His promises. Manuscript 17 adds here that one who studies Torah is above the level of love, for it is the King’s word that is spoken in his mouth.
Marei mekomos
- 1מאן מלכי רבנן · Gittin 62a:14
- 2מתניתא מלכתא · ביצה כא, וש״נ. ראה לעיל מט, ב.
- 3יש מי שאוהב · Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 35
- 4הודעתי אין כתיב כאן · רש״י שמות ו, ג.
- 5לא הודעתי אין כתיב כאן אלא נודעתי · Rashi on Exodus 6:3:3
18וזהו והיו הדברים האלה אשר אנכי מצוך היום1 פי׳ אנכי מי שאנכי דהיינו בחי׳ יחיד2 משא״כ אצל ואהבת כתיב ואהבת את3 ה׳ אלקיך
And this is [the meaning of] “And these words which I (Anochi) command you today shall be”: Anochi means “I, who I am,” that is, the level of Single (yachid). Whereas with “And you shall love,” it is written, “And you shall love Havayah your G‑d.”
The command “these words which I (Anochi) command you” uses Anochi, read as “I, who I am”: G‑d’s own Self, the level of yachid. The command to love, by contrast, speaks of “Havayah your G‑d.”
אבל התורה היא נמשכה למעלה מבחי׳ הוי״ה דהיינו בחינת לפני ה׳ וכו׳ הוא בחינת אנכי מי שאנכי4 כמ״ש במ״א:
But the Torah is drawn from above the level of Havayah, that is, the level of “before Havayah,” etc., which is the level of “I, who I am,” as is explained elsewhere.
Love is tied to the Name Havayah, but the Torah comes from above that Name, from “before Havayah,” the level of “I, who I am.” So the maamar ends where it began: the Torah reveals what even the Avos did not know.
The closing paragraph finds the same distinction within the Shema: love relates to the Name Havayah, while the words of the Torah come from Anochi, G‑d’s essence, which is above that Name.
Rabbeinu Bachya, quoted in the Kehot note, likewise learns from the wording “I was not known” rather than “I did not make known” that He and His Name are one. Likkutei Torah, Pekudei, quotes the end of this maamar on “I Myself, the level of Single,” and explains that this level of “My Name Havayah I was not known” is drawn down and revealed through keeping the prohibitive commandments.
Marei mekomos
- 1והיו הדברים האלה אשר אנכי מצוך היום · Deuteronomy 6:6
- 2בחי׳ יחיד · Numbers 2:4
- 3ואהבת את ה׳ אלקיך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 4אנכי מי שאנכי · נסמן לעיל א, א.
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
Arouse the love of G‑d that is hidden in every Jewish heart until it is felt and revealed, rather than keeping the mitzvos coldly, by rote. Let that love grow until it becomes anger at the evil within you, and then compassion for your own soul when you see how far it is from G‑d’s light, as we ask “Forgive us” only after accepting G‑d’s kingship in the Shema; that compassion opens the way to true joy in G‑d. And when you study and speak Torah, speak it as the King’s own word, without a sense of self.
Questions for discussion
- Why does the Alter Rebbe ask why the Shema says “One” rather than “Single,” and what does each word express?
- In what ways is a Jew in exile like a fetus that has every organ but does not use them, and what turns this into “birth”?
- Why must compassion for one’s own soul come before true joy, and how is this reflected in the order of the prayers?
- What is the difference between serving G‑d out of love, as the Avos did, and the self-nullification through which the Torah was given?
- How does speaking words of Torah make a person like a king rather than a servant?
Key terms in this maamar
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×5
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- ×2
- The Shechinah (Divine Presence)שכינה
- G‑d's presence as it dwells in the world. ×1
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving. ×2
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- Measure, limitation and judgment. ×4
- The light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin)ממלא כל עלמין
- Divine light that enters each world and gives it life according to its measure. ×1
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- Divine light too great to enter the worlds; it 'surrounds' them and affects them from beyond. ×1
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- The emotive attributes (middos)מדות
- Love, awe, compassion and the rest. ×2
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- The two 'wings' of divine service. ×2
- A dwelling place among the lower realmsדירה בתחתונים
- The purpose of creation: that G‑d be at home in this world. ×2
- The sitra achra (the other side)סטרא אחרא
- The realm opposed to holiness.
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning to G‑d; not only repentance. ×1
- The animal soulנפש הבהמית
- The soul that animates the body and its drives. ×1
- An arousal from aboveאתערותא דלעילא
- Divine initiative, unprompted by us. ×1
- Delightתענוג
- Pleasure; the inner root of will. ×4
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×1
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Setting aside one's own sense of self before G‑d.
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Deep connection to an idea, bridging intellect and emotion. ×1
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- Kingship: the level through which G‑d's word creates and rules the worlds. ×1
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest world, including our physical one. ×1