Torah Ohr · Parshas Ki Sisa · Maamar 1
שמאלו תחת לראשי וימינו תחבקני
His Left Hand Is Under My Head, and His Right Hand Embraces Me
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
G‑d’s “left hand,” the rejection that a person’s failings arouse above, is itself what lifts him up: from distance comes the boundless love of “with all your might,” and then G‑d’s “right hand,” the Torah and mitzvos, embraces him so that he does not fall.
The maamar in brief
Reading “His left hand is under my head, and his right hand embraces me” together with the opening of Ki Sisa, the Alter Rebbe teaches that the “visitation” Israel’s deeds arouse above never rejects completely: it ends by lifting their head. He carries this into divine service through two voices, prayer and Torah. Prayer rises from below: contemplating that G‑d is the life of everything, a person comes to love Him, and that love must be constant, not only during prayer. The vision that brings this love is drawn from above, and it explains why embodied, distracted Israel are greater than the angels: angels are only channels for G‑dly life, while Israel draw a light that transforms the body itself, like light that emerges from darkness. Torah, in contrast, descends from above. Beyond the love “with heart and soul” lies “with all your might,” the love of the soul’s essence for G‑d’s essence, reached above all by the baal teshuvah, whose former distance intensifies his yearning. This is the left hand under the head. Then the right hand, Torah, mitzvos and above all charity, embraces him, and “a ransom for his soul” repairs what was lacking.
Outline
- The left hand that lifts the headG‑d’s rejection, aroused by Israel’s deeds, is never complete; the census verse of Ki Sisa promises that the very “visitation” lifts their head. Two voices, Torah and prayer, bring the theme into divine service.¶1–2
- Prayer and the love of G‑dPrayer rises from below and Torah descends from above. Seeing that G‑d is the life of all things brings love, which must be constant; the vision itself is drawn from above and requested in the prayers before the Shema.¶3–9
- Why Israel surpass the angelsAngels are only channels for the G‑dly life-force; Israel, by nullifying the body, draw a light that makes “Holy” meaningful and turns the body itself into a chariot for G‑d. This light, though only a “foot,” is “our G‑d,” as a son is his father’s foot.¶10–16
- Love from above and Torah from aboveLove and awe come from above, drawn down by first humbling the body with a broken heart; Torah, drawing G‑d’s wisdom into every faculty, is the arousal from above.¶17–18
- With all your might: the love of teshuvahLove with heart and soul responds to G‑d’s revealed radiance; “with all your might” is the soul’s essence reaching His essence. The baal teshuvah attains it through his former distance: the left hand under the head.¶19–23
- The right hand’s embraceTorah and mitzvos descend from G‑d’s highest attributes into physical life and hold a person after prayer; charity, equal to all the mitzvos, is the “ransom” that repairs and uplifts.¶24–26
Key concepts
- The left pushes away, the right draws nearשמאל דוחה וימין מקרבת
- G‑d’s severity and kindness work together: even His rejection is never complete, and it becomes the means of a greater closeness.
- Sensory sightראיה חושית
- An understanding of G‑d as one’s life so vivid that it is like seeing with the eyes; it brings a love strong enough to overpower the evil inclination.
- From below upward and from above downwardמלמטה למעלה ומלמעלה למטה
- Prayer is the person’s arousal rising toward G‑d; Torah is G‑d’s own wisdom and will descending into the person’s thought, speech and action.
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Having no standing of one’s own before G‑d. The angels are wholly batel, and so are mere channels; a Jew who nullifies his body makes even the body a vehicle for G‑d’s unity.
- With all your might (me’od)בכל מאדך
- Love beyond measure: the service of the soul’s essence, its “head,” pouring itself out toward G‑d’s essence, above the love that responds to His radiance in creation.
- Spark and essence of the soulניצוץ הנשמה ועיקר הנשמה
- Only a spark of the soul is enclothed in the body (the “foot”); its essence remains above as makif (the “head”).
- Return (shov)שוב
- The movement back down after the soul’s surge upward: Torah and mitzvos, descending from on high into physical life, embrace a person so that he does not fall.
The left hand that lifts the head ¶1–2
1שמאלו תחת לראשי12 וימינו תחבקני. הנה בענין העולמות3 כן דרך השם לבני ישראל עם קרובו4 כשמתעורר למעלה בחי׳ שמאל דוחה מחמת מעשה התחתונים ויהי להם למושיע5 וגורם שאדרבה עי״ז יהיה להם נשיאות ראש.6
“His left hand is under my head, and his right hand embraces me.” Now, as in the matter of the worlds, so is the way of G‑d with “the children of Israel, the people near to Him”: when the level of “the left [hand] that pushes away” is aroused above because of the deeds of the lower beings, “He becomes their Savior,” and brings it about that, on the contrary, through this they will have an uplifting of the head.
The maamar opens with the verse of the Song of Songs in which the beloved’s left hand supports her head while his right hand embraces her. In Chassidus the left hand is G‑d’s attribute of severity, which “pushes away,” and the right hand is His kindness, which draws near. The Alter Rebbe states his theme: when Israel’s deeds arouse this “pushing away” above, G‑d makes the rejection itself the means of their salvation and of an “uplifting of the head,” by the same pattern through which He conducts the worlds.
The paragraph sets out the theme of the whole maamar: the “left hand” of rejection, which Israel’s deeds arouse above, ends by lifting up their head.
“Uplifting of the head” (nesi’us rosh) is the language of the census verse that opens Parshas Ki Sisa, “When you lift up the head” (Exodus 30:12); the next paragraph reads that verse in this light.
Marei mekomos
- 1שמאלו תחת לראשי · ראה לעיל בציונים לכ״ק אדמו״ר זי״ע. המאמר (בשינוים) עם הגהות באוה״ת פ׳ כי תשא ע׳ א׳תתנד מתחיל ”כי תשא”. קיצור והמשך כללות הענין ע׳ א׳תתסג. קיצור מהדרוש ע׳ א׳תתסד. ביאור ע׳ א׳תתסח. אודות מאמר זה ראה בתורת שלום — ס׳ השיחות ע׳ 169.
- 2שמאלו תחת לראשי · Song of Songs 2:6
- 3בענין העולמות · באוה״ת שם א׳תתנד: בענין הנהגת העולמות כן: דרך.
- 4לבני ישראל עם קרובו · Psalms 148:14
- 5ויהי להם למושיע · Isaiah 63:8
- 6באחד מהכת״י בא המאמר עם כותרת · ”חוקת דובראוונא תקס״א”.
2וזהו כי תשא את ראש בנ״י לפקודיהם1 פי׳ על ידי איזה פקידה שיפקד עליהם לרעה ח״ו וכל׳ רז״ל אין לך כל פקידה שאין בה מעון העגל.234
And this is [the meaning of] “When you lift up the head of the children of Israel lifkudeihem (according to their numbering)”: that is, through some visitation (pekidah) that is visited upon them for ill, G‑d forbid, as in the expression of our Sages, of blessed memory: “There is no visitation at all that does not contain [something] of the sin of the Calf.”
The Alter Rebbe now reads the opening verse of Parshas Ki Sisa, “When you lift up the head of the children of Israel lifkudeihem,” through another sense of the root pakad: a “visitation,” a reckoning for sin. The Sages said that every such reckoning includes something of the sin of the Golden Calf, so the verse speaks of the head being lifted through a visitation for ill.
הנה עי״ז אדרבה תשא את ראש בנ״י כי בחי׳ השמאל דוחה אינה דחי׳ לגמרי ח״ו אלא וימין מקרבת. וזהו וימינו תחבקני56 אשר כי יפול לא יוטל7 ח״ו.
Now, through this, on the contrary, “you lift up the head of the children of Israel”; for the level of “the left [hand] pushes away” is not a complete pushing away, G‑d forbid, but rather “and the right [hand] draws near.” And this is “and his right hand embraces me”: that “though he fall, he shall not be cast down,” G‑d forbid.
That very visitation lifts their head, because G‑d’s left hand never rejects completely: the left pushes away while the right draws near. This is “his right hand embraces me”: a Jew who falls is not cast down for good, as the psalm says.
ולהבין ענין זה בעבודת ה׳ כתיב הקל קול יעקב8 ב׳ פעמים קול א׳ בלא וא״ו וא׳ בוא״ו כי ב׳ קולות הם א׳ לתורה וא׳ לתפלה.
To understand this matter in the service of G‑d: it is written, “The voice is the voice of Yaakov,” [the word] “voice” twice, one without a vav and one with a vav; for there are two voices, one for Torah and one for prayer.
To bring the theme into a person’s own service of G‑d, the Alter Rebbe cites Yitzchak’s words, “The voice is the voice of Yaakov,” where the first “voice” (הקל) is spelled without a vav and the second (קול) with one. The doubled word points to two voices of Yaakov, Torah and prayer, which the next paragraphs compare.
The census verse of the parsha is read as a promise that the “visitation” itself lifts Israel up, since the left hand’s rejection is always joined by the right hand’s embrace; the theme is then carried into divine service through the two voices of Torah and prayer.
“The left pushes away and the right draws near” is the Sages’ counsel for how to treat one who must be rebuked: never to reject him with both hands. Here it describes G‑d’s own way with Israel.
Marei mekomos
- 1כי תשא את ראש בנ״י לפקודיהם · Exodus 30:12
- 2אין לך כל פקידה שאין בה מעון העגל · Sanhedrin 102a:15
- 3אין לך כל פקידה שאין בה מעון העגל · Rashi on Numbers 19:22
- 4אין לך כל פקידה שאין בה מעון העגל · Jerusalem Talmud Taanit 4:6
- 5
- 6וזהו וימינו תחבקני · Song of Songs 2:6
- 7כי יפול לא יוטל · Psalms 37:24
- 8הקל קול יעקב · Genesis 27:22
Prayer and the love of G‑d ¶3–9
Now, at one time [the Sages] said that “the study of Torah is equal to them all,” and at another time they went to very great lengths in praise of the virtue of prayer, and [said] that it corresponds to the sacrifices.
Two teachings of the Sages seem to compete. The Mishnah says that the study of Torah “is equal to them all,” outweighing every other mitzvah, while the Talmud praises prayer highly and says that the prayers were instituted to correspond to the daily offerings.
אך שניהם אמת כי הם חלוקים בענינים שהתפלה היא בבחי׳ מלמטה למעלה והתורה היא בבחי׳ מלמעלה למטה.
But both are true, for they differ in their nature: prayer is on the level of “from below upward,” and Torah is on the level of “from above downward.”
Both are true because Torah and prayer move in opposite directions. In prayer a person rises from below upward toward G‑d; in Torah, G‑d’s wisdom comes down from above to the person.
ובאור ענין זה כי הנה ענין התפלה היא קיום המצות ק״ש ואהבת וגו׳ כמ״ש במ״א ועד״ז תקנו ג״כ כל סדר התפל׳ קודם ק״ש כדי שיקבל עליו בק״ש ואהבת באמת וכמשי״ת לקמן.
The explanation of this matter: the substance of prayer is the fulfillment of the commandments of the Shema, “And you shall love,” etc., as is explained elsewhere. And along these lines they also instituted the whole order of prayer before the Shema, so that in the Shema one will take upon himself “And you shall love” in truth, as will be explained below.
The heart of prayer is fulfilling the command of the Shema, “And you shall love Havayah your G‑d.” The prayers before the Shema were arranged to bring a person to accept that love sincerely when he reaches it, a point the maamar returns to in paragraph 9.
The paragraph reconciles the Sages’ praise of Torah and of prayer by assigning them opposite directions, and defines the goal of prayer as the love commanded in the Shema.
Marei mekomos
- 1דת״ת כנגד כולן · פאה פ״א מ״א.
- 2דתלמוד תורה כנגד כולן · Mishnah Peah 1:1
- 3התפלה . . כנגד הקרבנות · Berakhot 26b:5–6
4והנה הדרך1 המביאה את האדם לידי אהבה זו היא מ״ש ראה נתתי לפניך היום2 את החיים ואת הטוב ואת המות ואת הרע ובחרת בחיים.3 לאהבה את4 ה׳ אלקיך כי הוא חייך וגו׳.
Now, the way that brings a person to this love is what is written: “See, I have set before you today life and good, and death and evil,” “and you shall choose life”; “to love Havayah your G‑d, for He is your life,” etc.
The way to love G‑d is found in Moshe’s charge: G‑d has set life and good, death and evil before us, and commands us to choose life, “to love Havayah your G‑d... for He is your life.” The Alter Rebbe joins these verses: choosing life means recognizing that G‑d is our life, and that recognition brings love.
כי בכל דבר בעוה״ז יש גשמיות ורוחניות והרוחניות והחיות אלהי הוא חיים וטוב והגשמי׳ הוא מות ורע שהוא כלה ונפסד.
For in everything in this world there is physicality and spirituality. The spirituality and the G‑dly life-force (chayus) are “life” and “good,” and the physicality is “death” and “evil,” for it comes to an end and decays.
He explains “life” and “death” in every created thing. Its spiritual side, the G‑dly life-force that sustains it, is “life and good”; its physical side is “death and evil,” because it wears out and passes away.
The paragraph begins to show how a person comes to love G‑d: by seeing that in everything the G‑dly life-force is “life,” while the physical shell is “death.”
“Evil” here does not mean moral wickedness but transience: whatever is only physical comes to an end.
Marei mekomos
- 1והנה הדרך · חלק נעתק באוה״ת ויקרא כרך ב ע׳ תנד.
- 2ראה נתתי לפניך היום · Deuteronomy 30:15
- 3ובחרת בחיים · Deuteronomy 30:19
- 4לאהבה את ה׳ אלקיך כי הוא חייך · Deuteronomy 30:20
5ומזה יראה האדם שכשם שהגשמיות כל דבר בטל לגבי הרוחני׳ המחייהו וכן באדם עצמו הנה הגוף טפל ובטל לגבי הרוחניו׳ והחיו׳ שבו לכן אוהב את חיי נפשו במאד מאד.
From this a person will see that just as the physicality of every thing is nullified before the spiritual [force] that gives it life—and so too in man himself, the body is secondary and nullified before the spirituality and life-force within it, and therefore he loves the life of his soul very, very greatly—
A person can see for himself that the physical side of everything is batel, subordinate and of no account, before the spiritual force that keeps it alive. The same is true in man: the body is secondary to the soul that animates it, which is why everyone loves his own life so intensely.
כן ויותר מכן יש לאדם לאהוב את ה׳ כאשר יסתכל בעין שכלו בראי׳ חושית כי הוא חייך ממש שהוא מקור וחיי החיים.1
so, and even more than that, a person ought to love G‑d, when he looks with the eye of his intellect, with sensory sight, [and sees] that “He is your life,” truly, for He is the source and the Life of all life.
If a person loves his own life so much, he should love G‑d even more, once he sees with his mind, as clearly as with his eyes, that G‑d is literally his life, the source and Life of all life. “Sensory sight” here means an understanding so vivid that it is like seeing.
From the love everyone has for his own life, the Alter Rebbe argues for an even greater love of G‑d, Who is the life within that life.
Marei mekomos
- 1שו״ה התפלה — כמ״ש במ״א · בבוך 1824 ליתא.
6וזהו ענין וכל צבא השמים לך משתחוים1 כמארז״ל שהחמה שוקעת במערב ומשתחוה לקונה2 וכן כל המזלות בעבור שרואים ומשיגים חיותם וקיומם המהוה ומחי׳ אותם ומקיימם.
And this is the meaning of “And all the host of heaven bow down to You,” as our Sages, of blessed memory, said: the sun sets in the west and bows to its Maker, and so do all the constellations, because they see and apprehend their life-force and existence, which brings them into being, gives them life and sustains them.
The verse “and all the host of heaven bow down to You” is explained by the Sages: the sun sets in the west, where the Shechinah rests, and so bows to its Maker, and so do all the stars and constellations. They bow because they perceive the G‑dly force that creates, enlivens and sustains them.
וזהו ראה נתתי לפניך וגו׳ שזה יראה האדם לעינים בראי׳ חושיי׳ שהרי רואה חיותו וקיומו
And this is “See, I have set before you,” etc.: that a person will see this with his eyes, with sensory sight, for he sees his own life-force and existence,
This is the meaning of “See, I have set before you”: a person can actually see it, for he sees his own life and existence.
וכן רואה ההשתחואה של צבא השמים ועי״ז יבא למדרגת ואהבת את3 ה׳ אלהיך בכל לבבך בשני יצריך4 שאפי׳ היצה״ר הוא נכנע ובטל נגד אהבת ה׳
and likewise sees the bowing of the host of heaven. And through this he will come to the level of “And you shall love Havayah your G‑d with all your heart”—“with both your inclinations,” so that even the evil inclination is subdued and nullified before the love of G‑d,
Seeing also how the heavenly bodies bow, he can reach “You shall love Havayah your G‑d with all your heart,” which the Mishnah explains as “with both your inclinations.” A love born of such clear sight is strong enough to subdue even the evil inclination.
as our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “Nullify your will before His will.” The explanation: because this love, which comes from such sensory sight, has nothing comparable to it, nor is
The Sages’ “Nullify your will before His will” describes this. Nothing physical compares with this love, so every other desire gives way before it.
נמצא דוגמתה כלל בענינים גשמים וכמאמר מי ידמה לך ומי ישוה לך ומי יערך לך.
its like found at all in physical things, as it is said, “Who can be likened to You, who is equal to You, and who can be compared to You?”
The words from the Shabbos morning prayers, “Who can be likened to You, who is equal to You, and who can be compared to You?”, express that nothing physical can be set beside G‑d. So no physical love can rival the love of Him.
Seeing the G‑dly life in oneself and in the heavens leads to a love that overpowers even the evil inclination, because nothing physical compares to it.
Tanya chapter 42, to which Kehot points, uses the same image of the sun, moon and stars bowing westward as they set, and adds a parable: even one who has never seen the king is seized with awe on seeing many great ministers bow before one man.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2כמארז״ל שהחמה שוקעת במערב ומשתחוה לקונה · Bava Batra 25a:6–7
- 3ואהבת את ה׳ אלהיך בכל לבבך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 4בכל לבבך בשני יצריך · Mishnah Berakhot 9:5
- 5בטל רצונך מפני רצונו · אבות פ״ב מ״ד.
- 6בטל רצונך מפני רצונו · Pirkei Avot 2:4
7ובחי׳ ראי׳ זו צריך להיות נצחית ותמידי׳ ומי שאינו מסתכל בזה תמיד עליו נאמר והכסיל בחושך הולך.
This level of sight must be enduring and constant; and of one who does not look at this constantly it is said, “And the fool walks in darkness.”
This “seeing” must not be a passing moment; it must be lasting and constant. Of one who does not keep it constantly before him, Koheles says, “the fool walks in darkness.”
מה שאין כן החכם עיניו בראשו1 שיהיה תמיד לנגד עיניו חיותו וקיומו מאור אין סוף ב״ה וככה תהי׳ אהבת הוי״ה תקועה בלבו תמיד ותהיה נפשו קשורה באלהי׳ חיים קשר נפלא וחזק לעד ולעולמי עולמים.
Not so “the wise man, whose eyes are in his head”: his life-force and existence from the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, will always be before his eyes. And thus the love of Havayah will be fixed in his heart always, and his soul will be bound to the living G‑d with a wondrous and strong bond, forever and to all eternity.
The wise man, “whose eyes are in his head,” keeps always in view that his life and existence come from the Infinite Light. Then the love of G‑d stays fixed in his heart, and his soul is bound to the living G‑d with a lasting bond.
The love that comes from seeing G‑d as one’s life must be constant; the wise man keeps this sight always before his eyes.
Marei mekomos
- 1והכסיל בחושך הולך . . החכם עיניו בראשו · Ecclesiastes 2:14
8וזהו ענין חילא דתיובתא יתיר ותדיר הנזכר בזה״ק לתקון פגם הברית1 כי ברית הוא ענין התקשרות2 ובקדושה הוא ענין התקשרות נפשו בשרשו וחיותו ובהפך זלע״ז הוא ההתקשרות בתאוות עוה״ז ותענוגות בנ״א
And this is the meaning of “the greater and constant strength of teshuvah (return)” mentioned in the holy Zohar for repairing the blemish of the covenant (bris). For bris (covenant) means a bond: in holiness, it is the binding of one’s soul to its root and its life-force; and in the opposite [realm], “one opposite the other,” it is the binding to the desires of this world and the pleasures of human beings.
The Zohar speaks of a “greater and constant” strength of teshuvah needed to repair “the blemish of the covenant” (pegam habris), the tradition’s term for sins involving the procreative faculty, on which the covenant of circumcision is sealed. The Alter Rebbe explains why: bris means a bond. In holiness it binds the soul to its source; its counterpart on the opposite side binds a person to worldly desires and pleasures.
ולכן התיקון הוא להפך לבו מהפוך להפוך מן הקצה אל הקצה ממש לדבקה נפשו בשרשו וחיותו הנמשך ממנו ית׳
Therefore the repair is to turn his heart over from one opposite to the other, truly from one extreme to the other extreme, to make his soul cleave to its root and its life-force, which is drawn from Him, may He be blessed,
Since the damage was a bond in the wrong direction, the repair is a complete reversal: turning the heart from one extreme to the other. The same capacity for attachment now binds the soul to its root and source in G‑d.
שהוא אל חי וקים בחי׳ ברית המקשר וממשיך החיות מבחי׳ סוכ״ע להיות ממכ״ע להחיות נפש כל חי ורוח כל בשר איש3 שתהי׳ דבקות אמתי ותמידי
Who is “the living and enduring G‑d,” the level of the covenant (bris) that binds and draws the life-force from the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin) to become the light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin), to give life to “the soul of every living thing and the spirit of all human flesh”; so that there will be a true and constant cleaving.
G‑d as “the living and enduring G‑d” corresponds to the level of bris, the bond that draws life downward: it brings the transcendent light that encompasses all worlds into the light that fills each world, giving life to every living being, in the words of Job. The goal is a true and constant cleaving (deveikus) to that source.
וזהו יתיר ותדיר ולא די בזה שהוא מעורר את האהבה בשעת התפלה וכיו״ב ואח״כ חולפת ועוברת
And this is “greater and constant”: it is not enough that he arouses the love at the time of prayer and the like, and afterwards it passes and goes away,
This is what the Zohar means by “greater and constant”: it is not enough to feel love for G‑d during prayer and similar times if it then fades. The bond must last.
as it is written, “G‑d is near to all who call upon Him, to all who call upon Him in truth”; and it is written, “The lip of truth shall be established forever,” which is not so of “but for a moment,” etc.
The psalm says G‑d is near to those who call upon Him “in truth,” and Proverbs says that “the lip of truth shall be established forever,” whereas the false tongue lasts “but for a moment.” A love that passes after prayer belongs to the passing moment; the true love endures.
The paragraph explains the Zohar’s call for a “greater and constant” teshuvah: a misplaced bond must be reversed into a lasting bond with G‑d, not a love felt only during prayer.
In the Kabbalah the divine Name E-l Chai (“the living G‑d”) is associated with Yesod, the Sefirah of the covenant, which joins the higher levels to the lower and transmits life to them. This is why the text calls the living G‑d “the level of the covenant that binds and draws down the life-force.”
Marei mekomos
- 1הנזכר בזה״ק לתקון פגם הברית · ראה אגה״ת פ״ד והנסמן בליקוט פירושים ומ״מ — חיטריק.
- 2כי ברית הוא ענין התקשרות · ראה אוה״ת שה״ש ע׳ תקמד.
- 3נפש כל חי ורוח כל בשר איש · Job 12:10
- 4קרוב ה׳ לכל קוראיו · Psalms 145:18
- 5ושפת אמת תכון לעד . . ועד ארגיעה · Proverbs 12:19
9והנה בחי׳ ראי׳ חושיית1 זו המביא׳ לידי אהבה זו נמשך לישראל מלמע׳ כמ״ש וה׳ עליהם יראה ויצא כברק חצו2 זה הוא המשכה והארה שמאיר ובא לישראל להיות
Now, this level of sensory sight, which brings one to this love, is drawn down to Israel from above, as it is written, “And G‑d will be seen over them, and His arrow will go forth like lightning.” This is a drawing-down and illumination that shines and comes to Israel, so that
The “sensory sight” that leads to love is not something a person produces alone; it is drawn to Israel from above. Zechariah’s words, “G‑d will be seen over them, and His arrow will go forth like lightning,” describe this illumination flashing down upon Israel.
עליהם יראה לראות באור ה׳ חיי החיים ית׳ בראי׳ חושית ולדבקה בו וע״ד זה תקנו לפני ק״ש כל סדר התפלה וברכות השחר ברוך אתה כו׳
“over them [He] will be seen”: to see, by the light of G‑d, the Life of all life, may He be blessed, with sensory sight, and to cleave to Him. And along these lines they instituted before the Shema the whole order of prayer and the morning blessings, “Blessed are You,” etc.,
Its purpose is that “G‑d will be seen over them”: that Jews should see the Life of all life by G‑d’s own light, as vividly as with the eyes, and cleave to Him. For this reason the Sages placed the morning blessings and the whole order of prayer before the Shema.
שאנו מבקשי׳ שיאיר לנו אור הוי׳ בהתגלות כדי שיקבל עליו בק״ש מצות ואהבת באמת וזהו הוי׳ אלהינו. כי הנה ארז״ל גדולים ישראל יותר ממלאכים שממתינים לומ׳ קדוש עד שישראל3 אומרי׳ למטה.
in which we ask that the light of Havayah shine for us openly, so that in the Shema one will take upon himself the commandment “And you shall love” in truth. And this is “Havayah our G‑d.” For our Sages, of blessed memory, said: Israel are greater than the angels, for [the angels] wait to say “Holy” until Israel say it below.
In those prayers we ask that the light of Havayah shine openly upon us, so that in the Shema we can accept the command to love G‑d sincerely; this is “Havayah our G‑d,” the light of Havayah becoming “ours.” The Talmud says Israel are greater than the angels, for the angels do not sing above until Israel sing below.
The vision that brings love is a gift from above, requested in the prayers before the Shema; the paragraph then cites the Sages’ statement that Israel are greater than the angels, which the next paragraphs examine.
Marei mekomos
- 1והנה בחי׳ ראי׳ חושיית · קטע מכאן נעתק באוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ תקיט.
- 2וה׳ עליהם יראה ויצא כברק חצו · Zechariah 9:14
- 3שממתינים לומ׳ קדוש עד שישראל אומרים למטה · Chullin 91b:16–18
Why Israel surpass the angels ¶10–16
10ולכאורה אינו מובן שיהיה יתרון זה לאדם בהיותו בעוה״ז מלובש בגוף גשמי ואין לך אדם שאין נופלים לו מחשבות זרות עכ״פ מחשבה
At first glance it is not understood how man could have this advantage while he is in this world, clothed in a physical body. And there is no person to whom alien thoughts do not come—at any rate, a thought
The Alter Rebbe raises a difficulty with the Talmud’s statement that Israel are greater than the angels. A human being lives in this world inside a physical body, and no one is free of stray thoughts.
שהיא זרה אצלו לפי״ע הגדול לפי גדלו והקטן לפי קטנו והמלאכי׳ כולם עומדים ברום עולם מופשטים מחומר הגוף הגשמי וכולם עושים באימה וביראה רצון קונם מו׳ ימ״ב בלי שום בטול והפסק אפי׳ רגע אחד:
that is alien for him relative to his level: the great one according to his greatness, and the small one according to his smallness. Whereas the angels all stand in the heights of the world, divested of the matter of a physical body, and all of them do the will of their Maker in dread and awe, from the six days of Creation, without any cessation or interruption, even for a single moment.
Everyone has thoughts that are “alien” by his own standard: a great person by his high standard, a lesser person by his. The angels, by contrast, have no body and have served their Maker in awe without pause since Creation, so how can man surpass them?
The paragraph sharpens the question: how can embodied, distracted man be greater than angels who serve G‑d without interruption?
The description of the angels standing “in the heights of the world” and doing “the will of their Maker in dread and awe” echoes the blessing before the Shema in the morning prayers.
But the angels do not say “Holy” on their own account, but only by virtue of the life-force (chayus) that spreads forth and is drawn into them; only
The answer begins: the angels do not say “Holy” on their own. Their praise comes from the G‑dly life-force flowing through them.
שהם אינם תופסים2 מקום לפני חיות אלהות השורה בתוכם והמשכות והתפשטות החיות שבהם הוא הוא האומר והעושה בהם כרצונו באין מונע.
that they take up no room before the G‑dly life-force that rests within them, and the drawing-down and spreading forth of the life-force within them is itself what speaks and acts in them according to its will, without hindrance.
The angels have no sense of self that “takes up room” before the G‑dliness within them. So the divine life-force in them is what actually speaks and acts through them, unhindered.
The angels’ praise is not their own achievement: it is the G‑dly life-force acting through beings who are wholly transparent to it.
Marei mekomos
- 1אך הנה המלאכים · ראה לעיל ג, א גבי והנה נודע עבודת המלאכים.
- 2שהם אינם תופסים . . הדיבור והפעולה למטה · נעתק באוה״ת יתרו ע׳ תשמח עם הגהות. ובע׳ תשסג.
12ולכן כתיב בהגר ותקרא שם1 ה׳ הדובר אליה והוא המלאך שדיבר עמה2 וכן במלאכים שבאו אצל אברהם כתיב ויאמר שוב אשוב אליך3 ובשליחותו של מקום אמר לו כן4 כאלו אמר הקב״ה בכבודו ובעצמו5
Therefore it is written of Hagar, “And she called the Name of G‑d who spoke to her,” and it was the angel who spoke with her. And likewise of the angels who came to Avraham it is written, “And he said, ‘I will surely return to you’”; and it was as the emissary of the Omnipresent that he said this to him, as though the Holy One, blessed be He, had said it in His own glory and Person.
Scripture itself shows this. When an angel spoke to Hagar, she named “G‑d who spoke to her”; and the angel who told Avraham “I will surely return to you” spoke, as Rashi says, as the emissary of the Omnipresent, as though the Holy One Himself had spoken.
והיינו לפי שאין תופסים מקום נגד חיות אלהות המדבר בהם ואינם רק מעבר שעל ידיהם יומשך הדבור והפעולה למטה.7
That is, because they take up no room relative to the G‑dly life-force that speaks within them, and they are only a passageway through which the speech and the action are drawn down below.
The reason is that the angels have no independent standing before the G‑dliness that speaks through them. They are only a channel through which divine speech and action pass to the world below.
והמשכה והשפעה זו היא דרך השתלשלות כמ״ש וקרא זא״ז ואמר קדוש ותרגומו ומקבלין דין מן דין6 אלא שבלשון מקרא נאמר אל המשפיעים שקורא וממשיך שפע זה לזה ובלשון תרגום נאמר על המקבל בחי׳ נוקבא.8
This drawing-down and flow is by way of the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus), as it is written, “And one called to another and said, ‘Holy,’” and its Targum [reads], “And they receive from one another.” But the language of Scripture is said of the givers, for one calls and draws down the flow to the other; and the language of the Targum is said of the recipient, the level of Nukva (the feminine / Malchus).
This flow passes down level by level through the chain of worlds, as Isaiah describes the seraphim: “one called to another.” The Targum renders it “they receive from one another”: the verse speaks of the giver, who calls and passes on the flow, and the Targum of the receiver, which in Kabbalistic terms is Nukva, the feminine, receiving aspect.
Scripture calls an angel’s words G‑d’s own because angels are only channels for the divine life-force, which flows down through them from level to level.
Kehot’s notes record a question of the Tzemach Tzedek: Torah Ohr elsewhere teaches that only in Atzilus are “He and His vessels one,” while the angels’ worlds are a realm of separation. In Biurei HaZohar he answers that when an angel serves as G‑d’s emissary it is raised to the level of “He and His vessels are one,” but not when it is not an emissary.
Marei mekomos
- 1ותקרא שם ה׳ · Genesis 16:13
- 2והוא המלאך שדיבר עמה · Bereshit Rabbah 20:6
- 3ויאמר שוב אשוב אליך · Genesis 18:10
- 4ובשליחותו של מקום אמר לו כן · Rashi on Genesis 18:10
- 5כאלו אמר הקב״ה בכבודו ובעצמו · באוה״ת יתרו ע׳ תשמח יש הג״ה: ”(כ״כ רש״י שם וז״ל לא בישרו המלאך שישוב אליו אלא בשליחותו של מקום אמר לו כן כמו ויאמר לה מלאך ה׳ הרבה ארבה, בפ׳ לך לך י״ז יו״ד, והוא אין בידו להרבות אלא בשליחותו של מקום אף כאן בשליחותו של מקום אמר לו כן, מד״ר)”.
- 6ומקבלין דין מן דין · Targum Jonathan on Isaiah 6:3
- 7חיות אלקות המדבר בהם . . והפעולה למטה · באוה״ת יתרו שם יש הג״ה. ”ולכאורה צ״ע בזה ממ״ש בת״א פ׳ בראשית בהביאור ע״פ כי כאשר השמים החדשים ושם דף ה׳ עמוד ד׳ [=ג, א], גבי והנה נודע עבודת המלאכים כו׳ איהו וגרמוהי חד, משא״כ עולמות בי״ע כו׳ עכ״ל. וממ״ש בפ׳ בא בד״ה בעצם היום הזה ושם ד״ק ע״א [=ס, ב] משא״כ בבי״ע אין הגילוי כלל בהכלים כו׳, ועיין מענין המלאכים בסידור שער הק״ש בד״ה להבין ההפרש בין ק״ש לתפלה, ולפ״ז הוא ע״ד שאמר משה ונתתי עשב שהקשו ע״ז דהל״ל ונתן ה׳ אלא היינו משום ששכינה מדברת מתוך גרונו של משה, ועיין מזה בלק״ת פ׳ ואתחנן סד״ה ואהבת את. קיצור. בת״א פ׳ תשא פי׳ מה שהמלאך נק׳ בשם אלקים זהו מפני גודל ביטולו אליו ית׳ ואינו תופס מקום נגד חיות אלקות המדבר בהם ואינם רק מעבר שעל ידיהם יומשך הדיבור והפעולה למטה”. ע״כ. וראה שם ע׳ תשסג. בביאוה״ז להצ״צ — כרך ב ע׳ תתקנו מציין וז״ל ”וצ״ע בת״א פ׳ תשא בד״ה שמאלו תחת לראשי דף קמ״ג ע״ב במ״ש בענין המלאכים שאין תופסים מקום נגד חיות האלקות המדבר בהם, וצ״ל בשעה שהמלאך הוא שליח מהקב״ה אז מתעלה ע״ד איהו וגרמוהי חד כמ״ש בת״א פ׳ בא בפי׳ הוי׳ צבאות בד״ה בעצם היום הזה, משא״כ בשעה שאינו שליח, וכן נת׳ החילוק באגה״ק קרוב לסופו”. עכ״ל. והוא בקו״א ד״ה להבין מ״ש בפע״ח (קנט, א). וראה באוה״ת יתרו ע׳ תשסג. ובפ׳ תשא ע׳ א׳תתעד ”ולכאורה קשה דהא דוקא באצי׳ איהו וגרמוהי חד דהיינו שגם הכלים הם אלקות ממש משא״כ עולמות בי״ע הוא בבחי׳ פירוד טורי דפרודא”. ע״ש. ובאוה״ת יתרו ע׳ תשמח ”ולכאורה צ״ע בזה ממ״ש בתו״א פ׳ בראשית בהביאור ע״פ כי כאשר השמים החדשים . . גבי והנה נודע עבודת המלאכים כו׳ איהו וגרמוהי חד. משא״כ עולמות בי״ע כו׳ עכ״ל. וממ״ש בפ׳ בא בד״ה בעצם היום הזה ושם . . משא״כ בבי״ע אין הגילוי כלל בהכלים כו׳, ועיין מענין המלאכים בסידור שער הק״ש בד״ה להבין ההפרש בין ק״ש לתפלה”. ע״ש. ראה באוה״ת עקב ע׳ תקצו. תקצט.
- 8וקרא זה אל זה ואמר קדוש · Isaiah 6:3
13והנה מצד החיות לא שייך לומר על הקב״ה שהוא קדוש ומובדל דמשמע שיש עוד דבר נפרד ויש זולתו אלא שהוא קדוש ומובדל ממנו.
Now, from the standpoint of the life-force, it is not applicable to say of the Holy One, blessed be He, that He is holy and separate; for that implies that there is another separate thing, something existing besides Him, only that He is holy and separate from it.
From the side of the divine life-force itself, calling G‑d “holy,” in the sense of separate, makes no sense. Separateness implies that something else exists apart from Him, and from that standpoint nothing does.
ובאמת אומרים איה מקום כבודו כו׳ כמ״ש במ״א עד שנמשך החיות למטה לישראל המלובשים בגוף הגשמי שהוא דבר נפרד ויש בפ״ע ומכסה ומסתיר קדושת החיות ואז
And indeed they say, “Where is the place of His glory?” etc., as is explained elsewhere—until the life-force is drawn down below to Israel, who are clothed in the physical body, which is a separate thing and an entity in its own right, and which covers and conceals the holiness of the life-force. And then,
Indeed, the angels say, “Where is the place of His glory?” (in the words of the Kedushah). “Holy and separate” first becomes meaningful when the life-force reaches Jews in physical bodies, which experience themselves as separate entities and conceal the holiness within them.
ע״י אתעדל״ת בביטול גוף הגשמי לגבי הרוחניות ומקור החיות שבו בהגלות אור ה׳ למטה במה שאומרים ברוך אתה וכו׳
through an arousal from below (isarusa dilesata), in the nullification of the physical body before the spirituality and the source of the life-force within it, when the light of G‑d is revealed below as we say “Blessed are You,” etc.,
Then, when a Jew makes “an arousal from below,” nullifying his body to the spiritual life-force within it, G‑d’s light is revealed below, as when we say “Blessed are You” in a blessing.
ומצד הגוף שייך לומר אליו ית׳ שהוא קדוש ומובדל ולכן גם המלאכים אומרי׳ קדוש וגו׳
from the standpoint of the body it is applicable to say of Him, may He be blessed, that He is holy and separate. And therefore the angels too say, “Holy,” etc.,
From the body’s standpoint it now makes sense to call G‑d “holy,” separate and beyond it. That is why the angels too say “Holy.”
שהארה והמשכה זו שישראל ממשיכים למטה עוברת דרך המלאכים וג׳ פעמים קדוש כנגד ג׳ צמצומים שיש דרך כלל עד שיומשך ויתפשט למטה הארה זו להיות נק׳ בשם ה׳ צבאות שבכל אלו הצמצומים הוא קדוש ומובדל.
for this illumination and drawing-down that Israel draw below passes through the angels. And “Holy” three times corresponds to the three contractions (tzimtzumim) that there are in general, until this illumination is drawn down and spreads below so as to be called by the Name “Havayah Tzeva’os”; for in all these contractions He is holy and separate.
The light that Israel draw down passes through the angels on its way. Their threefold “Holy” corresponds to three general contractions (tzimtzumim) through which the light descends until it is called “Havayah Tzeva’os” (“of Hosts”), and through all of them G‑d remains holy and separate.
Holiness as separateness has meaning only from the standpoint of a physical being; Israel, by nullifying the body, draw down the light that gives “Holy” its meaning, and the angels’ praise passes on what Israel draw down.
This explains why the angels wait for Israel before they sing: their “Holy” presupposes a separateness that exists only in the physical world, and the light that gives it meaning is drawn down by Israel’s service below.
14והנה הארה והמשכה1 שמתפשט למט׳ בישראל לבטל הגוף אליו ית׳ יש לו יתרון על האור וחיות המתפשט במלאכים כיתרון אור הבא מן החשך2 שיש לה תוספת אורה ושמחה שגם הגוף נעשה מרכבה ליחודו ית׳.
Now, the illumination and drawing-down that spreads below into Israel, to nullify the body to Him, may He be blessed, has an advantage over the light and life-force that spreads into the angels, like “the advantage of light that comes from darkness”: it has added light and joy, for the body too becomes a chariot (merkavah) for His unity, may He be blessed.
The light Israel draw down into the body, which makes the body itself nullified to G‑d, is greater than the light that flows into the angels. Like “the advantage of light that comes from darkness,” light that has overcome darkness shines more and brings added joy. Even the body becomes a “chariot,” a vehicle with no will of its own, wholly given over to G‑d’s unity.
This answers the question of paragraph 10: Israel’s light, which transforms the body itself, surpasses the angels’ as light that emerges from darkness surpasses ordinary light.
Marei mekomos
- 1והנה הארה והמשכה . . כך הנה הארה והמשכה .ֿ. והיא בחי׳ רגל לעיקר האור של מעלה · באוה״ת פ׳ שמות ע׳ לו מציין לכאן.
- 2כיתרון אור הבא מן החשך · Ecclesiastes 2:13
15ולכן אומרים ה׳ אלהינו שלנו ממש כמו ע״ד משל האדם מתפאר את עצמו בשלו אף בבחי׳ רגל שבו
Therefore we say “Havayah our G‑d”: ours, truly. Just as, by way of analogy, a person prides himself on what is his own, even on the level of the foot that is in him,
This is why we call Havayah “our G‑d”: He is truly ours. A person takes pride in what belongs to him, even his foot, the lowest part of his body.
משא״כ בשל אחרים אינו מתפאר אפי׳ ביד שהיא חשובה יותר כיון שאינו שלו כך הנה הארה והמשכה זו אף שהיא רק זיו והארה בעלמא שירדה מטה מטה
whereas in what belongs to others he takes no pride, even in a hand, which is more important, since it is not his—so too, this illumination and drawing-down, although it is only a mere radiance and illumination that has descended very far down,
He takes no pride in what belongs to someone else, even a hand, which is more valuable. Likewise, the light that reaches Israel is only a faint radiance that has descended very low.
והיא בחי׳ רגל לעיקר האור של מעלה שאינה יכולה להתפשט בתוך הגוף שאותו האור נק׳ בחי׳ ראש לגבי זה מ״מ הנה אלהינו זה ממש שלנו כדכתיב בנים אתם לה׳1 אלהיכם.
and it is the level of a foot relative to the main light above, which cannot spread into the body, that light being called the level of the head relative to this one—nevertheless, behold, this is “our G‑d,” truly ours, as it is written, “You are children to Havayah your G‑d.”
Compared with the main light above, which cannot enter the body, this radiance is like a “foot” to a “head.” Yet precisely this is “our G‑d,” truly ours, as the Torah says, “You are children to Havayah your G‑d.”
Though the light that enters Israel’s bodies is only the “foot” of the divine light, it is G‑d’s own and so “ours,” just as a person prides himself on his own foot more than on another’s hand.
Marei mekomos
- 1בנים אתם לה׳ אלקיכם · Deuteronomy 14:1
And “a son is his father’s foot” (bera kar’a da’avuha), for he becomes like the level of a foot relative to the person, which is one essence [with him]. And therefore our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “Nullify your will before His will”:
The Aramaic saying “a son is his father’s foot” means that a child is an extension of his father, like a foot of the same body, one essence with him. As G‑d’s children, Israel are His “foot,” and so the Sages taught, “Nullify your will before His will.”
דהיינו להיות בחי׳ רגל אצל הקב״ה ולהיות בטל אצלו ולעשו׳ רצונו שכמו שהרג׳ בטל לגבי האד׳ שלכל אשר יחפוץ יטנו3 ואין לה רצון וחפץ אחר כלל.
that is, to be the level of a foot to the Holy One, blessed be He, and to be nullified before Him and to do His will; for just as the foot is nullified before the person—“wherever he wishes, he turns it”—and it has no other will or desire at all.
To be a “foot” to G‑d means to have no will of one’s own and to do His will, as a foot obeys the person. The words “wherever he wishes, he turns it” come from the verse in Proverbs about a king’s heart in G‑d’s hand.
Israel are G‑d’s “foot,” one with Him as a son with his father, and their service is to be as given over to His will as a foot is to its owner.
Marei mekomos
- 1וברא כרעא דאבוה · נסמן לעיל א, ב.
- 2בטל רצונך מפני רצונו · Pirkei Avot 2:4
- 3שלכל אשר יחפוץ יטנו · Proverbs 21:1
Love from above and Torah from above ¶17–18
And this is what we say at the beginning of the morning blessings: “Who gives the rooster (sechvi) understanding to distinguish between day and night.” For the arousal
The first morning blessing thanks G‑d “Who gives the rooster understanding (binah) to distinguish between day and night.” The Alter Rebbe reads it as describing how love and awe arise in a person.
בחי׳ האהבה והיראה שבא לאדם אינם מצד עצמם כ״א שבא לו מלמעלה ע״י בחי׳ שכוי רוחניות שיש למעלה שהוא המבחין בין יום ובין לילה
of the level of love and awe that comes to a person does not come of itself; rather, it comes to him from above, through the level of a spiritual “rooster” that exists above, which is what distinguishes between day and night,
Love and awe do not arise in a person by his own power; they come to him from above, through a spiritual “rooster” that distinguishes between “day” and “night.”
דהיינו בין חסדים לגבורות ע״י המשכת בינה עלאה וכן עד״ז כל שאר הברכות וכל סדר התפלה למתבונן בהם ומשכיל על דבר ימצא.2
that is, between the chassadim (kindnesses) and the gevuros (severities), through the drawing-down of the higher Binah (Binah Ila’ah). And so too, along these lines, all the rest of the blessings and the whole order of prayer: one who contemplates them “and considers the matter will find.”
The “day” and “night” of the blessing are the chassadim (kindnesses, the source of love) and the gevuros (severities, the source of awe), distinguished through the drawing-down of the higher Binah; this is why the blessing speaks of the rooster’s binah. All the other blessings and prayers can be understood in the same way by one who reflects on them.
אך כדי להמשיך לו האהבה שיבא לו מלמעלה צריך מתחלה לבטש את הגוף ולהכניעו ולהשפילו במרירות
However, in order to draw down to himself the love that will come to him from above, one must first crush the body, subdue it and humble it with bitterness,
But to draw that love down from above, a person must first break the coarseness of the body, subduing and humbling it through bitterness over his distance from G‑d.
as is explained elsewhere; as it is written, “Havayah is near to the brokenhearted, and saves those crushed in spirit”; and as it is written, “The sacrifices of Elokim are a broken spirit.”
Two verses support this: G‑d is near to the brokenhearted, and “the sacrifices of Elokim are a broken spirit.”
כי בכדי שיומשך בחי׳ הוי״ה לבחי׳ אלהים שלנו צריך מתחלה לעשות זבחי אלהים שדרך ההוא נמשך בחי׳ הוי״ה.
For in order that the level of Havayah be drawn down into the level of our Elokim, one must first make “the sacrifices of Elokim,” for by that way the level of Havayah is drawn down.
The Names matter here. To draw Havayah, the Name of G‑d as He transcends the world and brings it into being, into “our Elokim,” the Name of His concealment within nature, one must first bring “the sacrifices of Elokim,” a broken spirit; by that path Havayah is drawn down.
The love and awe kindled in prayer come from above, and one draws them down by first humbling the body with a broken heart.
Marei mekomos
- 1הנותן לשכוי בינה להבחין בין יום ובין לילה · Berakhot 60b:5
- 2ומשכיל על דבר ימצא · Proverbs 16:20
- 3קרוב ה׳ לנשברי לב · Psalms 34:19
- 4זבחי אלקים רוח נשברה · Psalms 51:19
18והנה כל זה נקרא אתערותא דלתתא מלמטה למעלה והוא ענין התפלה. אבל ענין התורה היא בחי׳ מלמעלה למטה.
Now, all this is called an arousal from below (isarusa dilesata), from below upward, and it is the matter of prayer. But the matter of Torah is the level of “from above downward.”
All the service described so far, prayer included, is an “arousal from below,” rising from below upward. Torah works the other way, from above downward.
והוא בחי׳ ובכל נפשך דהיינו שיומשך ויתפשט בכל כחות הנפש במחשב׳ דבור ומעשה ונק׳ אתעדל״ע שעי״ז מעורר למעלה בחי׳ חכמתו ורצונו חכים
And it is the level of “and with all your soul”: that is, that it be drawn down and spread through all the powers of the soul, in thought, speech and action. And it is called an arousal from above (isarusa dile’eila), for through it one arouses above the level of His wisdom and will, “[He is] wise,
Torah corresponds to “with all your soul,” because it draws G‑d’s wisdom into all the soul’s powers: thought, speech and action. It is called an “arousal from above” because Torah study arouses G‑d’s own wisdom and will, which is “wise, but not with a known wisdom,” beyond any wisdom we can grasp.
ולא בחכמה ידיעא שהתורה היא חכמתו ורצונו ית׳ אלא שמלובשת בענינים גשמיים. וזהו ענין קורא בתורה כמ״ש במ״א:
but not with a known wisdom”; for the Torah is His wisdom and will, may He be blessed, only that it is clothed in physical matters. And this is the matter of reading (korei) in the Torah, as is explained elsewhere.
The Torah is G‑d’s wisdom and will itself, though clothed in physical matters. The Hebrew korei means both “reads” and “calls”; the text refers to an explanation of “reading in the Torah” given elsewhere.
Prayer is the arousal from below; Torah, which draws G‑d’s own wisdom into all the soul’s faculties, is the arousal from above.
With all your might: the love of teshuvah ¶19–23
19ובכל מאדך1 הוא ענין התשובה כי גדולה תשובה2 שמקרבת את הגאולה. ומאד הוא לשון רבוי הרבה יותר מכדי מדתו
“And with all your might (me’odecha)” is the matter of teshuvah (return), for “great is teshuvah, for it brings the redemption near.” And me’od is a term of abundance, much more than its proper measure.
The third phrase of the Shema’s command, “with all your might (me’odecha),” is teshuvah, which the Talmud calls great because it brings the redemption near. Me’od means “very much,” beyond the normal measure, and so describes a love without limits.
כי אהבת בכל לבבך ובכל נפשך הוא נמשך מהתפשטו׳ גילוי אלהותו השוכן בתחתונים שאינו אלא זיו והארה בלבד. כמ״ש ויצא כברק חצו3 שאינו אלא מחשבה אחת בלבד. כמ״ש היוצר יחד לבם4 וגו׳.
For the love “with all your heart and with all your soul” is drawn from the spreading-forth of the revelation of His G‑dliness that dwells in the lower beings, which is nothing but a radiance and illumination alone; as it is written, “And His arrow will go forth like lightning,” for it is nothing but a single thought; as it is written, “He fashions their hearts together,” etc.
Love “with all your heart and soul” comes from the G‑dliness revealed within creation, which is only a radiance, like a single flash of lightning. Zechariah’s “arrow like lightning” and the psalm’s “He fashions their hearts together” show that all creation comes from a single divine “thought.”
Love “with all your might” is teshuvah, a love beyond measure, unlike the love with heart and soul, which responds to the limited radiance of G‑dliness within creation.
Marei mekomos
- 1ובכל מאדך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 2גדולה תשובה · Yoma 86b:1–2
- 3ויצא כברק חצו · Zechariah 9:14
- 4היוצר יחד לבם · Psalms 33:15
20וע״ד משל כשם שמחשב׳ אחת אינה נחשבת לכלום לגבי מהותו ועצמותו של האדם שיכול לחשוב מחשבות אין קץ ומספר.
By way of analogy: just as a single thought counts for nothing relative to the being and essence of a person, who can think thoughts without end or number,
An analogy: a single thought is nothing compared with the person who thinks it, since he can think endless thoughts.
כך על אחת כמה וכמה שאין המחשבה זו נחשבת לכלום נגד עצמותו ית׳ כי אתה הוא קודם שנברא העולם ואתה הוא כו׳.
so, how much more so, this thought counts for nothing compared with His essence, may He be blessed; for “You are He before the world was created, and You are He,” etc.
How much more is the single “thought” from which all creation comes as nothing compared with G‑d’s essence. The prayer says, “You are He before the world was created, and You are He” after it was created: creation changes nothing in Him.
Creation, however vast, is like one passing thought, as nothing beside G‑d’s essence, which remains unchanged.
21ואני הוי״ה לא שניתי1 וכל ימות עולם הזה ועולם הבא וג״ע התחתון והעליון וימות המשיח ותחיית המתים אינו נחשב אצלו
and “I, Havayah, have not changed.” And all the days of this world and of the World to Come, the lower and the higher Gan Eden, the days of Mashiach and the Resurrection of the Dead, are accounted by Him
Malachi’s “I, Havayah, have not changed” completes the thought. All eras, this world and the World to Come, the lower and the higher Gan Eden, the days of Mashiach and the Resurrection, are only a brief moment for Him.
אלא כרגע קטן וכמ״ש במ״א וזו היא עבודת ניצוץ הנשמה2 המתפשט ומתלבש בגוף הגשמי כי לא כל הנשמה כולה מתלבש׳ בתוך הגוף
as no more than a brief moment, as is explained elsewhere. And this is the service of the spark of the soul that spreads forth and is clothed in the physical body; for not all of the soul, in its entirety, is clothed within the body,
Love with heart and soul is the service of the “spark” of the soul that is enclothed in the body. Only a spark of the soul actually enters the body.
רק נצוץ והארה ממנה בלבד ועיקרה ושרשה נשאר למעלה בבחי׳ מקיף והנצוץ המתפשט למטה נק׳ רגל לגבי בחי׳ עליונה שלמעלה שנק׳ בחי׳ ראש
but only a spark and illumination from it, while its main part and its root remain above, on the level of makif (encompassing). And the spark that spreads below is called a “foot” relative to the higher level above, which is called the level of the “head,”
The soul’s essence and root stays above as makif, encompassing the person without entering him. The spark below is called the “foot,” and the essence above the “head.”
משא״כ בחי׳ בכל מאדך הוא בחי׳ עבודת עיקר הנשמה בחי׳ הראש שבה והיינו בטול הנפש במציאות ממש להשתפך אל חיק אביה ממש מצד מהותו ועצמותו
whereas the level of “with all your might” is the level of the service of the main part of the soul, the level of the head within it: that is, the self-nullification (bittul) of the soul in its very existence, to pour itself out into the bosom of its Father, truly, from the standpoint of His being and essence,
The love “with all your might” is the service of the soul’s essence, its “head”: a self-nullification so complete that the soul’s very existence dissolves, pouring itself into its Father’s bosom. It reaches toward G‑d as He is in His own being and essence.
שהוא רם ונשא לאין קץ ולא שייך עליו לאמר מצד עצמו לא ממלא כל עלמין ולא סוכ״ע שאינו בגדר עלמין כלל וכמ״ש במ״א:
Who is exalted and uplifted without end; and of Him, from His own standpoint, it is not applicable to say either [that He is] the light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin) or the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin), for He is not within the category of worlds at all, as is explained elsewhere.
G‑d in His essence is infinitely exalted. In relation to Himself one cannot even call Him “filling all worlds” or “encompassing all worlds,” since both terms describe Him only in relation to worlds.
The love “with all your might” belongs to the soul’s essence above the body and reaches toward G‑d’s essence, beyond both the light that fills and the light that encompasses the worlds.
Likkutei Torah on Vayikra, to which Kehot points, cites this passage for the difference between the service of the soul’s spark in the body (“with all your heart”) and that of its essence (“with all your might”).
Marei mekomos
- 1ואני הוי״ה לא שניתי · Malachi 3:6
- 2וזו היא עבודת ניצוץ הנשמה · בלקו״ת ויקרא ג, ד. מציין לכאן.
22והנה הזוכה לבחי׳ אהבה רבה ועצומה כזו הוא הבעל תשובה כי להיות שהיה בהפוך והיתה נפשו בארץ ציה ועיף.1 ויזעקו אל הוי״ה וגו׳.
Now, the one who merits such a great and mighty level of love is the baal teshuvah (one who returns): for since he had been in the opposite [state], and his soul was “in a parched and weary land,” “and they cried out to Havayah,” etc.,
This immense love belongs especially to the baal teshuvah, the one who returns. Having been far from G‑d, his soul thirsting “in a parched and weary land,” he cries out to Him.
אזי יתגלה אהבה רבה ועצומה כזו להיות בכלות נפשו ממש. וזהו ופרעה הקריב ואמרו רז״ל שהקריב את לבם של ישראל2 לאביהם שבשמים.3
then such a great and mighty love will be revealed, to the point of his soul’s very expiring. And this is [the meaning of] “And Pharaoh drew near,” of which our Sages, of blessed memory, said that he drew the hearts of Israel near to their Father in Heaven.
From that distance a love bursts forth so strong that the soul all but expires. The Sages read “And Pharaoh drew near,” said when Pharaoh pursued Israel to the sea, as Pharaoh drawing Israel’s hearts near to their Father in Heaven: the oppressor’s threat became the cause of their return.
ולכן נק׳ בחי׳ אהבה זו מאד כמארז״ל והנה טוב זה מלאך החיים.4 מאד זה מלאך המות56 שעי״ז יתרבה ויתגדל תשוקת האהבה ביתר שאת ויתר עז7 ויוסף אומץ דבקותו:
Therefore this level of love is called me’od (“very”), as our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “‘And behold, it was good’—this is the angel of life; ‘very’—this is the angel of death.” For through this the yearning of the love will increase and grow, “with greater exaltation and greater power,” and the strength of his cleaving will increase.
Therefore this love is called me’od. The Midrash on “very good” says that “good” is the angel of life and “very” is the angel of death; the “very” that comes from the side of death, here the penitent’s former distance, makes the yearning grow far stronger, and his attachment to G‑d firmer.
The penitent, having been far from G‑d, reaches the boundless love of “with all your might”; his former distance itself, like the “angel of death” in the Midrash, intensifies the yearning.
Likkutei Torah on Bechukosai, to which Kehot points, quotes the same Midrash and explains that after death the soul can grasp the level of me’od without limit, once the body’s “vessel” has been fully refined.
Marei mekomos
- 1והיתה נפשו בארץ ציה ועיף · Psalms 63:2
- 2ופרעה הקריב . . שהקריב את לבם של ישראל · Exodus 14:10
- 3ופרעה הקריב ואמרו רז״ל שהקריב את לבם של ישראל לאביהם שבשמים · Midrash Tanchuma, Beshalach 8:2–3
- 4והנה טוב זה מלאך החיים · Bereshit Rabbah 9:9
- 5והנה טוב זה מלאך החיים. מאד זה מלאך המות · Bereshit Rabbah 9:10
- 6והנה טוב זה מלאך החיים. מאד זה מלאך המות · Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 16:11
- 7ביתר שאת ויתר עז · Genesis 49:3
23וזהו שמאלו תחת לראשי שע״י בחי׳ שמאל דוחה שהיה בו מתחלה על כן ירום ראש1 ומתנשא בבחי׳ עבודת הראש2 של הנשמה כנ״ל. וזהו ענין מעלת הזהב על הכסף הנזכר בלקוטי אמרים.3
And this is “His left hand is under my head”: through the level of “the left [hand] pushes away” that was in him at first, “therefore [his] head is lifted up,” and he is raised up in the level of the service of the “head” of the soul, as mentioned above. And this is the matter of the superiority of gold over silver mentioned in Likkutei Amarim.
Now the opening verse is explained: “His left hand is under my head.” The earlier “pushing away” is what raises the person to the service of the soul’s “head,” the love “with all your might.” The Tanya calls this higher love “gold,” surpassing the “silver” of the ordinary love.
The opening verse is resolved: the left hand of rejection, placed “under the head,” lifts the person to the highest love, the “gold” of which the Tanya speaks.
In Tanya chapter 50 the love that surpasses all others “as gold surpasses silver” is a love like flames of fire, coming from the supernal Gevuros of Binah: from the “left” side. Kehot quotes the Tzemach Tzedek’s suggestion that the verse can also be read the other way, the raising of the head through contemplation leading a person afterwards to humble himself.
Marei mekomos
- 1על כן ירום ראש · Psalms 110:7
- 2שע״י בחי׳ שמאל דוחה . . ומתנשא בבחי׳ עבודת הראש · באוה״ת פ׳ בשלח ע׳ תסג כתב ע״ז וז״ל: ”ויש לפרש גם כן להפך שעל ידי הרמת ראש שהוא ענין ההתבוננות במוחו ותבונתו אחדות ה׳ עי״ז אח״כ יהי׳ משפיל א״ע ע״ד לעולם ירגיז אדם יצ״ט על יצה״ר וזהו השמאל דוחה”. עכ״ל, ע״ש.
- 3הנזכר בלקו״א · פרק נ.
The right hand’s embrace ¶24–26
24והבחינה שוב שאחר זה הוא בחי׳ וימינו תחבקני.1 שימינו הם תורה ומצות בחי׳ חסד ומים שיורדים ממקום גבוה למקום נמוך והם מחבקין את האדם כדרך שמחבק האדם את חבירו מאחוריו ואינו מניחו ליפול.
And the level of “return” (shov) that comes after this is the level of “and his right hand embraces me.” For “his right hand” is Torah and mitzvos, the level of Chesed (kindness) and of water, which descend from a high place to a low place; and they embrace the person, the way a person embraces his fellow from behind and does not let him fall.
After the soul’s surge upward comes “return” (shov), the movement back into life: the right hand’s embrace, which is the Torah and the mitzvos. They are Chesed, kindness, and are like water, which flows from high to low; they hold a person from behind, as one holds a friend so that he does not fall.
כך ע״ד משל התורה והמצות הם יורדים לבחי׳ אחוריים להתלבש בענינים גשמיים להאחז את האדם שלא יפול כשפונה אחר תפלה לעסקיו ויהיה סור מרע ועשה
So too, by way of analogy, the Torah and the mitzvos descend to the level of the back (achorayim), to be clothed in physical matters, to hold on to the person so that he will not fall when he turns after prayer to his affairs, and he will “turn from evil and do
Torah and mitzvos descend to the “back” (achorayim), the outer level, by being clothed in physical matters. They hold a person when he turns from prayer to his daily affairs, so that he will “turn from evil and do good.”
טוב והם יורדים ממקום גבוה ציצית קבלת עול מלכות שמים וארבע פרשיות של תפלין כנגד חכמה ובינה וחסד וגבורה של הקב״ה. פ׳ ראשונה קדש לי כל בכור2 רמז לחכמה.3
good.” And they descend from a high place: tzitzis, accepting the yoke (kabbalas ol) of the Kingdom of Heaven, and the four sections of the tefillin, corresponding to the Chochmah (wisdom), Binah (understanding), Chesed and Gevurah (restraint) of the Holy One, blessed be He. The first section, “Sanctify to Me every firstborn,” alludes to Chochmah;
They come from a very high place: tzitzis, the acceptance of G‑d’s sovereignty, and the four sections of the tefillin, which correspond to G‑d’s Chochmah, Binah, Chesed and Gevurah. The first section, “Sanctify to Me every firstborn,” alludes to Chochmah, which the Kabbalah calls kodesh, “holy.”
פ׳ שניה כי ישאלך בנך מה זאת4 שהוא ענין התבוננות דקיימא לשאלה. פ׳ שמע מפורש בה ואהבת. פ׳ והיה אם שמוע מפורש בה השמרו לכם5 וגו׳.
the second section, “When your son asks you, ‘What is this?’,” is the matter of contemplation, which “stands to be asked” (dekayma lishe’eilah); the section of Shema states explicitly, “And you shall love”; the section “And it will be, if you listen” states explicitly, “Beware for yourselves,” etc.
The second section, “When your son asks you, What is this?”, concerns contemplation, which “stands to be asked” and investigates: Binah. The Shema section commands love, Chesed, and “And it will be, if you listen” warns, “Beware,” Gevurah.
After the upward love comes the right hand’s embrace: the Torah and mitzvos, which descend from G‑d’s highest attributes into physical acts and hold a person steady in his daily life.
Torah Ohr on Vayishlach, to which Kehot points, explains that the tefillin section “Kadesh” is the level of Chochmah, the mochin of Abba, which is why it speaks of remembrance.
Marei mekomos
- 1וימינו תחבקני · Song of Songs 2:6
- 2קדש לי כל בכור · Exodus 13:2
- 3פ׳ ראשונה קדש . . רמז לחכמה · ראה לעיל כו, ב.
- 4כי ישאלך בנך מה זאת · Exodus 13:14
- 5השמרו לכם · Deuteronomy 11:16
And for this we say, “Who has sanctified us with His commandments,” as is explained elsewhere. And this is [the meaning of] “And Mount Sinai was all in smoke, because G‑d descended upon it in fire.”
Because the mitzvos descend from so high a place, the blessing over them says, “Who has sanctified us with His commandments.” So too at Sinai, “the mountain was all in smoke because G‑d descended upon it in fire”: the giving of the Torah was G‑d’s descent.
And of Mount Sinai our Sages, of blessed memory, said that hatred descended [upon it] toward the idolaters, which is the level of evil, of which it is said, “I hate them with utmost hatred,” and “despising evil.”
The Talmud says the mountain is called Sinai because hatred (sin’ah) came down upon it toward the idolaters. The Alter Rebbe identifies this as the level of evil itself, the object of the verses “I hate them with utmost hatred” and “despising evil.”
נמשך מפני כי ירד ה׳ עליו שירד והמשיך למטה באש כמ״ש מימינו אש דת למו5 והוא לחול על ראש רשעים. כהמס דונג מפני אש6 יאבדו וגו׳.
This is drawn from “because G‑d descended upon it”: He descended and drew down below “in fire,” as it is written, “From His right hand, a fiery law for them”; and it is to come down upon the head of the wicked: “As wax melts before fire, they shall perish,” etc.
This rejection of evil flows from the fire in which G‑d descended: the Torah is “a fiery law” from His right hand. The same fire that is Torah consumes evil, “as wax melts before fire.”
The Torah’s descent at Sinai brought holiness down and, with it, the fire that rejects and consumes evil.
The fire comes “from His right hand”: the Torah, which the previous paragraph identified with the right hand of kindness, is itself the fire that drives out evil.
Marei mekomos
- 1והר סיני עשן כולו מפני אשר ירד עליו ה׳ באש · Exodus 19:18
- 2שירדה שנאה · Shabbat 89a:7
- 3והר סיני . . שירדה שנאה להעכו״ם · Shabbat 89b:1
- 4תכלית שנאה שנאתים · Psalms 139:22
- 5מימינו אש דת למו · Deuteronomy 33:2
- 6כהמס דונג מפני אש · Psalms 68:3
26וע״ד זה הם כל המצות הן בסור מרע הן בועשה טוב וצדקה כנגד כולם כי צדקה תרומם גוי1 להיות בבחי׳ חבוק שלא יפרד ולא ישוב אחור רק להיות עמו פב״פ
And in this manner are all the mitzvos, both in “turn from evil” and in “do good.” And charity (tzedakah) is equal to all of them, for “charity uplifts a nation,” to be in the level of an embrace, so that he will not be parted and will not turn back, but will only be with Him face to face,
All the mitzvos, prohibitions and positive commands alike, work in this way, and charity equals them all. “Charity uplifts a nation”: it lifts a person into G‑d’s embrace, so that he does not drift away or turn his back, but stays “face to face” with Him.
as it is written, “May Havayah make His face shine to you,” etc., as is explained elsewhere. And this is [the meaning of] “And each man shall give a ransom for his soul when you number (bifkod) them.”
As in the Priestly Blessing, “May Havayah make His face shine to you.” This is the meaning of the verse in our parsha, “each man shall give a ransom for his soul when you number them”: the ransom given at the census is charity.
כלומר אשר יפקד ויחסר פגם האות שלהם אזי התקון הוא ע״י צדקה שעי״ז מקשר ומעלה נפשו להוי״ה. ועמ״ש במ״א ע״פ שאו את ראש כו׳ לגלגלתם:45
That is to say: when there is something missing and lacking (yipaked veyechsar), a blemish of their sign (os), then the repair is through charity, for through it he binds and raises his soul to Havayah. And see what is written elsewhere on the verse “Lift up the head,” etc., “by their polls.”
Bifkod, “when you number,” is read as “when something is missing”: when there is a lack, a blemish of their “sign” (os), the repair is charity, which binds the soul and raises it to Havayah. The “sign” recalls the covenant, called a sign (os bris), whose blemish paragraph 8 discussed. Kehot notes that the closing reference, to “Lift up the head... by their polls,” was added by the Tzemach Tzedek.
The maamar returns to its opening verse: charity, which outweighs all the mitzvos, is the “ransom” that repairs what was lacking and lifts the soul, so that the “visitation” ends in a lifting of the head.
Torah Ohr on Bereshis, to which Kehot points, explains that the practical mitzvos, whose general and collective expression is charity, raise the Congregation of Israel, the “foot,” from below upward: “charity uplifts a nation.”
Marei mekomos
- 1צדקה תרומם גוי · Proverbs 14:34
- 2יאר ה׳ פניו אליך · Numbers 6:25
- 3ונתנו איש כפר נפשו · Exodus 30:12
- 4ע״פ שאו את ראש כו׳ לגלגלתם · זה הוספה מכ״ק הצ״צ, ובבוך 1824 ליתא. ראה לקו״ת במדבר א, ב.
- 5שאו את ראש כו׳ לגלגלתם · Numbers 1:2
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
Keep the awareness that G‑d is your very life before your eyes always, so that love of G‑d does not fade when prayer ends. Before asking for that love, humble the body with a broken heart. One who has fallen far should know that his distance can become the strongest love of all; and after prayer, the Torah, the mitzvos and especially charity hold a person steady in his daily affairs.
Questions for discussion
- How can G‑d’s “left hand,” the rejection aroused by a person’s deeds, become the cause of his being lifted up?
- Why must the love that comes from “seeing” G‑d as one’s life be constant, and what does the Alter Rebbe say about a love felt only during prayer?
- If angels serve G‑d without interruption, in what sense are Israel greater than they are?
- What is the difference between love “with all your heart and soul” and love “with all your might,” and why does the baal teshuvah reach the latter?
- How do Torah and mitzvos, and charity in particular, act as the “right hand” that embraces a person after prayer?
Key terms in this maamar
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being. ×2
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×12
- The Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof)אור אין סוף
- G‑d's light as it is, beyond all limits, before any contraction. ×1
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning to G‑d; not only repentance. ×3
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- Divine light too great to enter the worlds; it 'surrounds' them and affects them from beyond.
- The light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin)ממלא כל עלמין
- Divine light that enters each world and gives it life according to its measure. ×1
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- ×4
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The step-by-step descent of divine light from the highest level down to this world. ×1
- Nukva (the feminine / Malchus)נוקבא
- Malchus as the receiving configuration. ×1
- An arousal from belowאתערותא דלתתא
- Human initiative that draws down a divine response. ×1
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×3
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- The two 'wings' of divine service.
- The Name Elokimאלקים
- G‑d as concealed within nature, measuring and limiting.
- An arousal from aboveאתערותא דלעילא
- Divine initiative, unprompted by us.
- Willרצון
- Desire; in G‑d, the level above intellect. ×2
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Setting aside one's own sense of self before G‑d. ×1
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving. ×2
- Accepting the yoke (kabbalas ol)קבלת עול
- Submission to G‑d's will beyond understanding. ×1
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×3
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- Measure, limitation and judgment. ×1
- The Infinite One (Ein Sof)אין סוף
- G‑d's own boundless essence. ×1