Likkutei Torah · Parshas Tazria · Maamar 2
עולם לאכסדרה הוא דומה ורוח צפונית אינה מסובבת…
“The World Is Like an Exedra”
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
The Talmud’s picture of a world left open on its north side reflects the inter-inclusion of Chesed and Gevurah: the south, which is Chesed, burns with the concentrated heat of Gevurah, while the north, which is Gevurah, holds the cold and the water of Chesed; this blending of opposites is the tikkun that lets the world endure.
The maamar in brief
Rabbi Eliezer teaches in the Talmud that the world is like an exedra, walled on three sides, with its northern side left open. The Alter Rebbe begins with the physical world: the south is burning hot and largely unsettled, while the north holds the main settlement of the nations. In Kabbalah the south, on the right of one who faces east, is Chesed, and the north, on the left, is Gevurah. Yet Chesed and Gevurah are inter-included. The south’s heat is Gevurah within Chesed, produced by the tzimtzum of the firmament, which concentrates the sun’s light; the north’s cold is Chesed within Gevurah, though its own Gevurah shows in the cold’s power to freeze. So water, drawn from Chochmah, the source of the chasadim, is found in the north, while the dry south still has rivers and Gan Eden; and even the pairing of cold with Chesed and heat with Gevurah is an exchange. This mixing is the chief tikkun of the world, without which it could not endure. Hence the north is open: the enclosing partition of the firmament is made of gevuros, but in the north the chasadim of Chochmah spread out.
Outline
- The open north and the four directionsThe Talmud’s exedra with its open north; the burning south and the settled north; the south is Chesed and the north Gevurah, by the orientation of one who faces east.¶1
- Gevurah in the south, Chesed in the northChesed and Gevurah are inter-included: the south’s concentrated heat, produced by the firmament’s tzimtzum, is Gevurah within Chesed; the north’s cold is Chesed within Gevurah, yet its power to freeze and congeal is Gevurah.¶2
- Water, warmth and the tikkun of mixingWater, drawn from Chochmah, the source of the chasadim, is in the north; the dry south has rivers and Gan Eden; even cold in Chesed and warmth in Gevurah is an exchange; this mixing is the chief tikkun, without which the world could not endure.¶3
- Why the north is openThe firmament’s partition is from gevuros, but the chasadim of Chochmah spread in the north, so it is open and cold; a parenthesis gathers passages of the Zohar and other works on the north and on the exchange of the attributes.¶4
Key concepts
- Inter-inclusionהתכללות
- Each attribute contains something of the other: there is Gevurah within Chesed and Chesed within Gevurah, so the south bears Gevurah and the north Chesed.
- Chesed and Gevurahחסד וגבורה
- Kindness, which expands and gives, and restraint, which limits and defines; among the directions, the south and the north, the right and the left of one who faces east.
- The tzimtzum of the firmamentצמצום הרקיע
- The firmament that surrounds the world holds back the sun’s light and concentrates it on the place where it shines; every such contraction is the work of the gevuros, which set limits.
- The chasadim of Chochmahהחסדים דחכמה
- The kindnesses that flow from Chochmah, “the sea of Chochmah”; they bring water to the north and leave it open.
- Tikkunתיקון
- The order the Emanator set into His world, in which Chesed is mixed into Gevurah and Gevurah into Chesed, so that the world can endure.
- Exchangeחילוף
- The attributes trade qualities: cold belongs to Chesed and warmth to Gevurah; in the Zohar’s words, “they exchanged their places.”
The open north and the four directions ¶1
“The world is like an exedra, and the northern side is not enclosed by a partition” (Bava Basra, folio 25, end of side a). Now, in the south there is the intensity of the heat,
The maamar opens with Rabbi Eliezer’s teaching in the Talmud: the world is like an exedra, a porch enclosed on three sides and open on the fourth, for its northern side has no wall, and when the sun reaches the northwest corner it bends and rises above the firmament. The Alter Rebbe sets out to explain why the north is left open, and begins with the south, where the heat is at its strongest.
ולכן הכושים שחורים וגם אינו מיושב. אבל בצפון הם אנשים לבנים ובו עיקר הישוב3 של ע׳ אומות.
and therefore the Cushites are black, and [the south] is also not settled. But in the north the people are white, and in it is the main settlement of the seventy nations.
The text draws the physical consequences of that heat: in the south the people are dark-skinned and the land is largely unsettled, while in the north the people are fair and the main settlement of the seventy nations, the traditional count of the world’s peoples, is found. These visible effects are the starting point for the spiritual explanation that follows.
In Kabbalah the directions correspond to the Sefiros: the south is Chesed and the north is Gevurah, and Jeremiah’s “Out of the north the evil shall break forth” marks the north as the side of judgment. The reason is the orientation of one who faces east, the “front” (kedmah means both “eastward” and “forward”): the south is on his right, the side of Chesed, and the north on his left, the side of Gevurah.
The paragraph sets out the Talmud’s picture of a world open on the north, the physical contrast between the burning, largely unsettled south and the populous north, and the Kabbalistic pairing of the south with Chesed and the north with Gevurah, which follows from facing east.
According to the Kehot note, this maamar was said in 5572 (1811–12). The Zohar that the note cites for “the south is Chesed and the north Gevurah” (1:29b) speaks of a supernal “sea” whose waters freeze on the side of the north and are loosened to flow when the strength of the south draws near: the same pairing of the north with congealing restraint and the south with release that the maamar goes on to develop.
Marei mekomos
- 1עולם לאכסדרה · משנת תקע״ב — ראה אוה״ת בהעלותך ע׳ שמח.
- 2בדרום הוא תוקף החום · ראה אוה״ת נ״ך-ג ע׳ א׳שה. יהל אור ע׳ קפג.
- 3בצפון . . ובו עיקר הישוב · ראה גם מאמרי אדה״ז כתובים-א ע׳ נ. מאמרי אדה״א-ענינים ע׳ שלא ובהנסמן בהמ״מ שם. להלן במדבר ד, סע״ד. מאמרי אדה״א נביאים כתובים ע׳ קכא ואילך.
- 4דרום הוא חסד · מאו״א אות ד סעי׳ כ.
- 5דרום חסד וצפון גבורה · Zohar I, 29b
- 6מצפון תפתח · Jeremiah 1:14
- 7
Gevurah in the south, Chesed in the north ¶2
2ונודע שחו״ג מתכללים זמ״ז ויש גבורה בחסד וחסד בגבורה ולכן הדרום שהוא חסד יש בו גבורה
Now, it is known that Chesed (kindness) and Gevurah (restraint) are inter-included with one another, and there is Gevurah within Chesed and Chesed within Gevurah. Therefore the south, which is Chesed, has Gevurah in it,
It is a basic principle of Kabbalah that Chesed and Gevurah are inter-included: each contains something of the other. Applied to the directions, this means that the south, though it is Chesed, must have an element of Gevurah within it.
היינו תוקף החום [שהוא קשה לאדם ע׳ בגמ׳ פי״ח דשבת דקכ״ט א׳ וע׳ בתוס׳ פ״ג דכתובות דף ל׳ ד״ה הכל בשם המדרש רבה גבי תשתזיב משרבא]1
namely, the intensity of the heat (which is hard on a person; see the Gemara, chapter 18 of Shabbos, folio 129a; and see Tosafos, chapter 3 of Kesubos, folio 30, the passage beginning “Everything,” in the name of the Midrash Rabbah, regarding “May you be saved from the heat”).
That element is the south’s intense heat, which is hard on a person. In the Gemara cited, the sage Avlet finds Shmuel lying in the sun and asks him, “Can what is bad be good?” Tosafos on Kesubos brings the Midrash in which Rebbi blesses Antoninus to be spared the cold, and Antoninus answers that one more garment takes care of that; but when Rebbi blesses him to be saved from the heat, he agrees that this is a real prayer.
והוא בא מסיבת הצמצום של הרקיע המסבב העולם שמעכב ומונע מלהיות אור השמש מתפשט בכל העולם אלא שיאיר בתוקף אל מקום שזורח וכל צמצום הוא מחמת הגבורות המגבילים
And it comes about through the tzimtzum (contraction) of the firmament that surrounds the world, which holds back and prevents the light of the sun from spreading through the whole world, so that instead it shines with intensity on the place where it shines; and every tzimtzum is due to the gevuros, which set limits.
Physically, the south’s heat comes from the firmament that surrounds the world, which hems in the sun’s light so that, instead of spreading everywhere, it beats down with full force on the place where it shines. Every contraction (tzimtzum) of this kind is the work of the gevuros, the powers that limit and define.
וגם הכלים הם מבחי׳ גבורות וזהו בדרום דוקא לפי שעצמו חסד ע״כ נתכללה בו הגבורה המצמצמת כו׳.
The vessels, too, are of the level of gevuros. And this is in the south specifically: since in itself it is Chesed, therefore the contracting Gevurah is included in it, etc.
The vessels of Kabbalah, the forms that receive and contain light, likewise come from the gevuros, since a vessel is itself a limit. This concentrating Gevurah appears precisely in the south because the south in itself is Chesed, and so it takes in its opposite.
אבל בצפון שעצמו גבורה ע״כ נתכלל בו החסד ולכן הוא קר כי הקרירות הוא חסד אלא שאעפ״כ עצמו גבורה היינו תוקף הקרירות המגליד ומקריש.
But in the north, which in itself is Gevurah, Chesed is therefore included in it, and that is why it is cold, for coldness is Chesed. Yet even so, in itself it is Gevurah, namely the intensity of the cold, which freezes and congeals.
The north, conversely, is in itself Gevurah, so Chesed is included in it and shows as its cold, for coldness belongs to Chesed. Yet the north’s own Gevurah is still present in that cold, in the harsh intensity that freezes and congeals.
Because Chesed and Gevurah each contain the other, the south, which is Chesed, carries the Gevurah of concentrated heat produced by the firmament’s limiting tzimtzum, while the north, which is Gevurah, carries the Chesed of coldness, though its own Gevurah shows in the cold’s power to freeze.
The Tosafos cited raises the Midrash as a difficulty: the Gemara says that “everything is in the hands of Heaven except cold and heat,” which a person can guard against, yet the Midrash treats the heat as something no one can escape. Tosafos answers that the verse “nothing is hidden from its heat” speaks of travelers or armies on the road, whereas one who stays at home can shelter in a stone house or a cellar.
Marei mekomos
- 1תשתזיב משרבא · Tosafot on Ketubot 30a:8:1
Water, warmth and the tikkun of mixing ¶3
This is why water is found in the north: water, in Kabbalah, flows from Chochmah, the source of the chasadim, which is therefore called “the sea of Chochmah.” In a person, too, moisture comes from the brain, while warmth comes from the heart, its “flashes of fire,” and is tied to Binah, from which Gevurah stems: “I am Binah, Gevurah is mine.”
משא״כ בדרום יבישות ומ״מ יש בו נהרות והג״ע הוא בקו השוה4 כי עצמו חסדים כו׳, וגם זה גופא מה שהקרירות בחסד והחמימות בגבורה הוא ע״י חילוף.
whereas in the south there is dryness. Nevertheless there are rivers in it, and Gan Eden is on the equator, because in itself [the south] is chasadim, etc. And this itself, too, that coldness is in Chesed (kindness) and warmth in Gevurah, is through an exchange.
The south, by contrast, is dry, yet because its essence is chasadim it still has rivers, and Gan Eden lies on the equator. The Alter Rebbe adds that even the pairing of cold with Chesed and warmth with Gevurah is itself the result of an exchange between the attributes, a further case of their inter-inclusion.
כללא דמילתא שזהו עיקר התיקון שתיקן המאציל ית׳ בעולמו להיות עירוב חסד בגבורה וגבורה בחסד
The rule of the matter is that this is the chief rectification that the Emanator, blessed be He, instituted in His world: that there be a mixing of Chesed in Gevurah and Gevurah in Chesed,
To sum up: the mixing of Chesed into Gevurah and Gevurah into Chesed is the chief “rectification” (tikkun) that G‑d, the Emanator, set into His world. Tikkun is the Kabbalistic term for an ordered world in which the attributes are blended rather than each standing alone.
כדי שיתקיים העולם וזולת זה לא היה קיום לעולם כלל כי אם הצפון שהוא גבורה בעצם לא היה בו חסד כלל לא הי׳ מתקיים
so that the world may endure. Without this the world would have no endurance at all; for if the north, which is Gevurah in essence, had no Chesed at all in it, it would not endure.
This blend is what allows the world to exist at all. A north that was pure Gevurah, with no Chesed in it, could not endure.
ולכן הוטבע בו חסד וכמו אשה מזרעת תחלה יולדת זכר ואיש מזריע תחלה כו׳ כמ״ש במ״א.
Therefore Chesed was implanted in it; and it is like “a woman who emits seed first bears a male, and a man who emits seed first,” etc., as is explained elsewhere.
So Chesed was implanted in the north. The Alter Rebbe compares this to the Talmud’s teaching that when the woman’s seed comes first the child is male, and when the man’s comes first the child is female: each side brings forth its opposite, as he says is explained elsewhere.
The paragraph carries the principle further: water, drawn from Chochmah, the source of the chasadim, is found in the cold north, while the dry south still has rivers and Gan Eden, and even the pairing of cold with Chesed and heat with Gevurah comes from an exchange. This mixing of Chesed and Gevurah is the chief tikkun that lets the world endure.
The Zohar cited at the end of the maamar (2:24a, Va’eira) teaches the same exchange: fire stands on the north side and water on the south, yet the north is cold and moist and the south hot and dry, for the Holy One, blessed be He, blended them, so that water passes from the south into the north and fire from the north into the south, “each lending the other of its own.”
Marei mekomos
- 1שהמים . . הלחות במוח ומקור החמימות בלב · Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 3:11
- 2רשפי אש · Song of Songs 8:6
- 3אני בינה לי גבורה · Proverbs 8:14
- 4והג״ע הוא בקו השוה · ראה סה״מ תקס״ה ע׳ תתקס נעתק לקמן במ״מ לשמע״צ פד, ד. אוה״ת נ״ך-ג ע׳ א׳שז.
Why the north is open ¶4
4ולכן ג״כ רוח צפונית אינה מסובבת במחיצה כי המחיצה של הרקיע המצמצם הוא מגבורות דוקא ובצפון להיות שבו מתפשטים החסדים דחכמה לכן הוא פתוח וד״ל.
And therefore, too, the northern side is not enclosed by a partition: for the partition of the contracting firmament is specifically from gevuros, and in the north, since the chasadim of Chochmah (wisdom) spread forth in it, it is therefore open. This suffices for one who understands.
This also explains the Talmud’s open north. The partition of the firmament, which contracts and encloses, is made of gevuros, but the north is where the chasadim of Chochmah spread out, the same chasadim that bring it its water, and so it is left open; the Alter Rebbe leaves the rest to the reader’s understanding.
וע״כ הוא קר1 להיות כי השמש מתפשטת אנה ואנה ולא כבדרום (ועיין בזהר פ׳ וארא דכ״ד ע״א ובזהר הרקיע ובאשל אברהם ובמק״מ שם וע׳ באגה״ק בד״ה מה רב טובך אשר צפנת2 כו׳.
And therefore it is cold, since the sun spreads out this way and that, and not as in the south. (And see the Zohar, Parshas Va’eira, folio 24a, and the Zohar HaRakia, the Eshel Avraham and the Mikdash Melech there; and see Iggeres HaKodesh, in the discourse beginning “How great is Your goodness that You have hidden away,” etc.
Because the north is open, the sun’s light there is not concentrated but spreads this way and that, and so the north is cold. The parenthesis that follows cites the Zohar in Va’eira (2:24a), which places fire in the north and water in the south and says that the Holy One, blessed be He, made each lend the other of its own, together with the Zohar commentaries Zohar HaRakia, Eshel Avraham and Mikdash Melech on that passage, and a discourse in Iggeres HaKodesh that opens with “How great is Your goodness that You have hidden away” (tzafanta, from the same root as tzafon, “north”).
וע׳ עוד בזהר פ׳ במדבר דקי״ח ב׳ ודק״כ ע״א. ובפ׳ וישב דקפ״ו ב׳ ע״פ העירותי מצפון34 כו׳ ובפ׳ תרומה דקנ״ד ב׳5 בענין שלחן בצפון6 ודקל״ה א׳ כד״א מצפון זהב78 כו׳ וע״ש.
And see further the Zohar, Parshas Bamidbar, folio 118b and folio 120a. And in Parshas Vayeshev, folio 186b, on the verse “I have roused from the north,” etc.; and in Parshas Terumah, folio 154b, on the subject of the table in the north, and folio 135a, as it says, “From the north [comes] gold,” etc.; see there.
The Zohar on Bamidbar speaks of the north as included in the south, as the left hand is clasped in the right (3:118b), and of the Shechinah set between north and south, the north beneath her head and the south embracing her (3:120a); and in Vayeshev (1:186b) it reads “I have roused from the north” as an arousal from the side of the north that is answered by a holy soul sent from above. In Terumah it explains that the table stood on the north side because joy begins from there and water comes from the left (2:154b), and it applies “From the north comes gold” to Rosh HaShanah, the day of judgment (2:135a).
ועמ״ש במ״א בענין שם מ״ב וע״ב שבפ׳ שמע והיה אם שמוע9 שהוא ג״כ מענין מ״ש בזהר דאחליפו דוכתייהו10 כו׳. ועיין עוד מענין רוח צפונית אינה מסובבת בזהר פ׳ קרח דקע״ח ב׳11 והוא ענין אחר ממש״כ.
And see what is written elsewhere on the subject of the Name of forty-two and [the Name of] seventy-two in the passages of Shema and Vehayah im shamoa, which also belongs to the subject of what is said in the Zohar, that “they exchanged their places,” etc. And see further on the subject of “the northern side is not enclosed” in the Zohar, Parshas Korach, folio 178b; and it is a different matter from what is written [here].
The text also points to its discussion elsewhere of the Name of forty-two and the Name of seventy-two in the first two passages of the Shema, which it ties to the Zohar’s words “they exchanged their places”: the first passage, of love and so of Chesed, has forty-two words, though the Name of forty-two belongs to Gevurah, and the second, of warning and so of Gevurah, has seventy-two, though the Name of seventy-two belongs to Chesed. It then cites the Zohar in Korach (3:178b) on the open north, noting that the Zohar there makes a different point from the one made here.
וע׳ בלק״ת ביחזקאל ד״ה ענין יחזקאל ועמ״ש בפ׳ וישב בד״ה בכ״ה בכסליו בפי׳ צפונה לפני12 הוי׳ וע׳ בפי׳ הרמ״ז בזהר ר״פ צו):
And see the Likkutei Torah of the Arizal on Ezekiel, the passage beginning “The matter of Ezekiel”; and see what is written in Parshas Vayeshev, in the discourse beginning “On the twenty-fifth of Kislev,” on the meaning of “northward, before G‑d”; and see the commentary of the Ramaz on the Zohar, at the beginning of Parshas Tzav.)
The parenthesis closes with three more references: the Arizal’s Likkutei Torah on Ezekiel; the Chanukah discourse “On the twenty-fifth of Kislev” in Parshas Vayeshev, which explains the words “northward, before G‑d,” said of the burnt offering (Leviticus 1:11); and the Ramaz’s commentary on the Zohar at the beginning of Parshas Tzav.
The paragraph explains the Talmud’s open north: the enclosing partition of the firmament comes from gevuros, while the north, where the chasadim of Chochmah spread, stays open, so the sun’s light there disperses and the north is cold. A long parenthesis then gathers passages of the Zohar and other works on the north and on the exchange of Chesed and Gevurah.
In the Zohar in Korach, the Levites stand on the left side, and through their service the flaw left on that side when the world was created, “even that side of the north, which remained lacking,” is made whole and everything is included in the right. The text notes that this is a different idea from its own explanation of the open north.
Marei mekomos
- 1וע״כ הוא קר · Zohar, Vaera 3:34–43
- 2מה רב טובך אשר צפנת · Psalms 31:20
- 3העירותי מצפון · Zohar, Vayeshev 15:153–16:161
- 4העירותי מצפון · Isaiah 41:25
- 5ובפ׳ תרומה דקנ״ד ב׳ · נתבאר ביהל אור ע׳ קפג.
- 6שלחן בצפון · Zohar, Terumah 47:515–525
- 7מצפון זהב · Zohar, Terumah 13:153–14:164
- 8מצפון זהב · Job 37:22
- 9שם מ״ב וע״ב . . אם שמוע · ראה לקו״ת ואתחנן יג, ד.
- 10דאחליפו דוכתייהו · וע׳ ואתחנן יב, ד. [כ].
- 11בזהר פ׳ קרח דקע״ח ב׳ · נתבאר באוה״ת ויקרא-ב ע׳ תלג.
- 12צפונה לפני הוי׳ · Leviticus 1:11
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Questions for discussion
- Why is the south, which is Chesed, the place of the most intense heat, and the north, which is Gevurah, the place of cold?
- How does the tzimtzum of the firmament produce the heat of the south, and why is every tzimtzum the work of the gevuros?
- If the north is Gevurah, why is water, which is drawn from Chochmah, found there?
- What does it mean that the mixing of Chesed and Gevurah is the chief tikkun of the world, without which it could not endure?
- Why is the north left open, and how does that openness make it cold?
Key terms in this maamar
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving. ×12
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- Measure, limitation and judgment. ×12
- Tzimtzum (contraction)צמצום
- The self-concealment of the Infinite Light that makes room for finite worlds. ×2
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×3
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×1
- The kav (line of light)קו
- The thin ray of light drawn into the space left after the tzimtzum. ×1