Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shelach · Maamar 10
ביאור ע״פ והיה לכם לציצית כו׳ הלב רואה כו׳
An explanation of the verse “And it shall be for you as tzitzis”: “The heart sees”
Biur · an explanation of maamar 9Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
The heart is where the light of the intellect comes to rest and endure: the Yesods of Chochmah and Binah reach it, so that it too sees, hears and understands, and a person’s work is to bring what the mind knows into the heart until the heart itself desires G‑d.
The maamar in brief
This short explanation, on the verse of tzitzis and the saying “the heart sees,” is about the heart. Following the Arizal, it teaches that the Yesod of Abba (Chochmah) and the Yesod of Imma (Binah) reach down to the chest, and their lights gather in the heart, whose number, thirty-two, spells lev. Yesod is the lowest point of a higher level, through which it gives life to a lower one; so we address G‑d as Baruch, at the Yesod of Abba, the only level at which we can take hold of Him. An analogy from the mind shows why the heart matters: an idea held only in the mind can be lost at once, but what is fixed in the heart endures. One who must keep subduing his heart is a tzaddik in Sha’arei Kedushah’s terms (a beinoni in Tanya’s); one whose heart is won over entirely is a chassid, like King David. Rachel and Leah are thought and speech, the hidden and revealed worlds, the “back” of the intellect. The heart, receiving from Chochmah and Binah, sees, hears and understands, and a person must always be diligent to conquer his inclination.
Outline
- The headingThe verse of tzitzis and the saying “the heart sees” set the theme: the heart.¶1
- Yesod and the heartYesod is the lowest point of a higher level, through which it gives life below; the Yesods of Abba and Imma reach the chest and their lights gather in the heart. An analogy begins: a new idea is hidden while still in the mind.¶2–3
- Mind and heart: tzaddik and chassidWhat is only in the mind can be lost, while what is fixed in the heart lasts; one who must keep conquering his heart is a tzaddik, one whose heart is won over is a chassid, like King David, whose love of G‑d nullified every natural attraction.¶4–6
- Baruch: where we take hold of G‑dWe address G‑d as Baruch, the Yesod of Abba, the level through which He gives us life; from the two Yesods the intellect of Z’eir Anpin is formed, and at the chest Rachel and Leah.¶7–8
- Rachel and Leah: thought and speechGranting that Rachel and Leah draw from above, the maamar identifies them with thought and speech, the hidden and the revealed worlds, which hold the same letters.¶9–10
- The heart sees, hears and understandsEmotion comes from contemplation and thought and speech from emotion; a matter fixed in the heart nullifies opposing emotion, as with Yaakov; the heart has sight, hearing and understanding, and one must always strive to conquer the inclination.¶11
Key concepts
- Yesodיסוד
- The lowest point of a higher level, through which it binds itself to a lower one and gives it life; the higher level as it is would be too great for the lower to grasp or bear.
- The Yesod of Abbaיסוד אבא
- The lowest point of Chochmah, enclothed within the Yesod of Imma; it reaches the chest, and the word Baruch in our blessings addresses G‑d at this level.
- The heartהלב
- Where the lights of the two Yesods gather; what is fixed in it endures, and it too sees, hears and understands.
- Tzaddik and chassidצדיק וחסיד
- In Sha’arei Kedushah, one who must keep conquering his heart with his mind, and one whose heart has been won over entirely; Tanya calls them the beinoni and the tzaddik.
- Rachel and Leahרחל ולאה
- Two feminine configurations formed from the lights at the chest of Z’eir Anpin; the maamar identifies them with thought and speech.
- The hidden world and the revealed worldעלמא דאתכסיא ועלמא דאתגליא
- Thought and speech, which hold the same letters, covered in thought and revealed in speech.
- The back (achorayim)אחוריים
- The outer extension of a level rather than the level itself; thought and speech are the back of the intellect.
The heading ¶1
An explanation of the verse “And it shall be for you as tzitzis,” etc.: “The heart sees,” etc.
This short piece explains the verse of tzitzis, which goes on “and you shall see it … and you shall not stray after your heart and after your eyes,” together with the Sages’ saying “The heart sees.” Its subject is the heart: how the light of the intellect reaches the heart, and why what is fixed there lasts.
The heading gives the verse of tzitzis and the saying “the heart sees” as the theme of this explanation, which is about the heart.
Rashi on the tzitzis verse calls the eye and the heart the body’s “spies”: “the eye sees and the heart covets.” The Midrash on Koheles says that the heart itself sees; the maamar will explain how sight, which belongs to Chochmah, reaches the heart (paragraph 11).
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2הלב רואה · Kohelet Rabbah 1:16
Yesod and the heart ¶2–3
2להבין ענין הלב.1 הנה איתא הלב מבין הלב שומע.2 ואיתא בכתבי האריז״ל שיסוד אבא3 הוא בחזה [ועמ״ש בד״ה עיני כל4 בשם המגיד איש האלקי נ״ע].
To understand the matter of the heart. Now, it is stated: “The heart understands; the heart hears.” And it is stated in the writings of the Arizal, of blessed memory, that the Yesod (foundation) of Abba is in the chest [and see what is written in the discourse beginning “The eyes of all,” in the name of the Maggid, the G‑dly man, whose soul is in Eden].
The maamar names its subject, the heart, and brings two teachings. The Sages say the heart understands and hears; and the Arizal teaches that the Yesod of Abba, the lowest point of Chochmah, reaches the chest of Z’eir Anpin, the place of the heart. The bracket sends the reader to the discourse “The eyes of all” in Parshas Matos, which brings a teaching of the Maggid of Mezritch, the Alter Rebbe’s teacher, about the chest.
ולהבין מהו יסוד הנה כל דבר המשפיע ומחיה למה שלמטה ממנו אינו מחיה רק במדרגה התחתונה שלו מאחר שהוא גדול מאד מהעלול ולא יכול העלול להשיג עילתו ולא יכול לסובלו.
And to understand what Yesod is: everything that bestows upon and gives life to what is below it gives life only through its lowest level, since it is very much greater than the effect, and the effect cannot grasp its cause and cannot bear it.
To explain what Yesod is, the maamar gives a general rule: whatever gives life to a lower thing does so only through its own lowest level. The cause is so far above its effect that the effect could neither grasp it nor bear it as it is.
ע״כ מוכרח לצמצם עצמו ולקשר א״ע בבחי׳ תחתונה שלו למה שלמטה ממנו כדי להחיות אותו וזו הבחי׳ שבה משפיע נק׳ יסוד אבא בתוך יסוד אמא ונעשה מהם מוחין לז״א.
Therefore it must contract itself and bind itself, by its lowest level, to what is below it, in order to give it life. And this level, through which it bestows, is called the Yesod of Abba within the Yesod of Imma; and from them the intellect (mochin) of Z’eir Anpin (the emotive attributes) is formed.
So the higher level must contract itself and connect to the lower one through its lowest point, and that point of contact is called Yesod, “foundation.” Among the Sefiros, the Yesod of Abba (Chochmah) is enclothed within the Yesod of Imma (Binah), and from the two of them the intellect of Z’eir Anpin, the configuration of the emotive attributes, is formed.
The paragraph introduces the heart as its subject and defines Yesod: the lowest point of a higher level, through which it connects to a lower one and gives it life.
In the discourse “The eyes of all” (Likkutei Torah, Matos 85b) the Alter Rebbe brings in the Maggid’s name that the chest is called chazeh, the Aramaic word for “seeing,” because Chochmah, the level of sight, extends down to the chest; being an outer part, it bears the Aramaic name, an outer form of sight. This is the background to the heading’s “the heart sees.”
Marei mekomos
- 1להבין ענין הלב · ראה לעיל יט, ב בהערות וציונים מכ״ק אדמו״ר. ולהלן ברשימת הכתב-יד.
- 2הלב שומע · Kohelet Rabbah 1:16
- 3ואי׳ בכתבי האריז״ל שיסוד אבא · ראה פע״ח שם ואילך.
- 4בד״ה עיני כל · לקמן פ׳ מטות פה, ב.
3והנה נראה מה שמבואר שם שמשתוין עד החזה ומתקבצין כל האורות בלב שהם ד׳ שמות מב׳ יסודות הנ״ל עולין לחשבון ל״ב [וע׳ בפי׳ הרמ״ז בזהר פ׳ אמור דצ״ג ע״ב].
Now, let us see what is explained there: that they are equal down to the chest, and all the lights gather in the heart; these are four Names from the two Yesods mentioned above, which add up to the number thirty-two [and see the commentary of the Ramaz on the Zohar, Parshas Emor, page 93b].
The Arizal’s writings explain that the two Yesods, of Abba and of Imma, extend equally down to the chest, and there all their lights gather in the heart. These lights are four divine Names, and their sum is thirty-two, written ל״ב, the letters of lev, “heart.” The text refers to the Ramaz’s commentary on the Zohar, Emor 93b, which the discourse “The eyes of all” also cites on the subject of the heart.
ולהבין הענין ד״מ הוא מכיון שיצא שכל מהמוח פתאום וכשהיה במוח הוא סתום מאד ואינו בהתגלות עד שאפילו הוא עצמו אינו משיגו.
To understand the matter, by way of analogy: it is when an idea comes forth from the mind suddenly. While it was in the mind it was very hidden and not revealed, to the point that even he himself did not grasp it.
The maamar now gives an analogy from a person’s mind. A new idea that comes to him suddenly is, while still in the mind, so hidden and undeveloped that even he does not yet grasp it.
The paragraph brings the Arizal’s teaching that the lights of the two Yesods gather in the heart, and begins an analogy from the way an idea comes forth from the mind.
Mind and heart: tzaddik and chassid ¶4–6
4ואחר כך כשמתחיל להתפשט מהמוח ולחוץ תיכף ומיד כשבא להתגלות מתלהב מאד ויכול לפעול בהתגלותו איזה דבר והלב הוא קיומו של הדבר שכיון שמתחזק איזה דבר בלב בחיזוק גדול לא יזוז ממנו לעולם.
And afterwards, when it begins to spread out from the mind and outward, at once, as soon as it comes to be revealed, he is filled with great fervor and can accomplish something through its revelation. And the heart is what makes the matter endure: once something takes hold in the heart with great firmness, he will never budge from it.
When the idea begins to move out of the mind and is revealed, it fills the person with fervor and can move him to act. But what makes it last is the heart: once a matter is firmly established in the heart, he will never move from it.
מה שאין כן כשעדיין אינו אצלו רק בשכל יכול לזוז ממנו תיכף מאחר שהלב עדיין מושרשת בתאוות גופניות מחמת
Whereas while it is still with him only in the intellect, he can budge from it at once, since the heart is still rooted in bodily desires, because
As long as the matter is only in his intellect, he can abandon it at once, because his heart is still rooted in bodily desires.
שהיא קרובה יותר אל הגוף, ואע״פ שמשיג בשכל שצריך לדבק א״ע בו ית׳ בכל נפשו וזהו תכלית הכל אעפ״כ יכול הלב להמשיך אותו אחר תאות גופניות.
it is closer to the body. And although he grasps with his intellect that he must cleave to Him, may He be blessed, with all his soul, and that this is the ultimate purpose of everything, nevertheless the heart can draw him after bodily desires.
The heart is closer to the body than the mind is. So even when a person understands clearly that he must cleave to G‑d with all his soul, and that this is the purpose of everything, his heart can still pull him after physical desires.
כמארז״ל הלב חומד12 כו׳ ועל כן צריך האדם להיות תמיד זריז ללחום מלחמת השכל עם הלב להטות אותה גם כן בכל כח התבוננותו בגדולתו ית׳ עד שתחפץ גם היא לדבק בו ית׳.
As our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “The heart covets,” etc. Therefore a person must always be diligent to wage the war of the intellect against the heart, to incline it too, with all the power of his contemplation of His greatness, may He be blessed, until it too desires to cleave to Him, may He be blessed.
The Sages describe the heart as the organ that covets. Therefore a person must always be diligent in the war of the intellect against the heart, using all the power of his contemplation of G‑d’s greatness to bend the heart too, until it also desires to cleave to Him.
The paragraph explains that an idea held only in the mind can be lost at once, while what is fixed in the heart lasts; so a person must bring the heart, through contemplation, to want what the mind knows.
Rashi on the tzitzis verse says that the heart and the eyes are the body’s spies: “the eye sees, the heart covets, and the body commits the sin.” The maamar’s answer is to bring the mind’s understanding down into the heart, until the heart itself comes to desire closeness to G‑d.
Marei mekomos
- 1כמארז״ל הלב חומד · Kohelet Rabbah 1:16
- 2הלב חומד · Rashi on Numbers 15:39
And this is the matter of the two levels, tzaddik and chassid. [One is] called a tzaddik because, as they said, “Who is mighty? He who conquers his inclination,” meaning that he must always conquer
The maamar applies this to two kinds of service, that of the tzaddik and that of the chassid. The Mishnah defines the mighty man as “he who conquers his inclination,” and the one called a tzaddik here is one who must always conquer his heart.
את הלב בשכלו מאחר שהלב מושרש מאד בעניני עוה״ז אלא שהשכל נוטה לדבקה בו ית׳ וע״כ צריך תמיד ללחום מלחמתו ונק׳ צדיק.
the heart with his intellect, since the heart is deeply rooted in the matters of this world, but the intellect inclines to cleave to Him, may He be blessed; therefore he must always wage its battle, and he is called a tzaddik.
He has to subdue his heart with his intellect constantly, because his heart is still deeply rooted in this world’s concerns while only his intellect inclines to cleave to G‑d. Since his life is a continual battle, he is called a tzaddik.
משא״כ כשמרגיל א״ע בהתבוננות כ״כ עד שתשרש הדבר בלב ג״כ וממילא הוא בטל מכל וכל
Whereas when he accustoms himself to contemplation so much that the matter becomes rooted in the heart too, then of itself he is utterly nullified
The higher level belongs to one who trains himself in contemplation until the matter takes root in his heart as well. Then, of itself, he is utterly nullified, with nothing left in him that resists.
ולא יזוז ממנה בשום אופן זהו נק׳ חסיד3 [כן כתב בשע״ק להרח״ו ח״א ש״ג. אכן בסש״ב פי׳4 דזהו נק׳ צדיק ובחי׳ הא׳ נק׳ בינוני5 ע״ש].
and will not budge from it in any way: this is called a chassid [so wrote Rabbi Chaim Vital in Sha’arei Kedushah, Part I, Gate 3. However, in Sefer Shel Beinonim it is explained that this is called a tzaddik, and the first level is called a beinoni; see there].
Such a person will never move from it, and he is called a chassid; the bracket names Rabbi Chaim Vital’s Sha’arei Kedushah as the source of these terms. It adds that Tanya (Sefer Shel Beinonim) uses other terms: the one who has reached this level is called a tzaddik, and the one who must keep fighting is called a beinoni, an “intermediate” person.
The paragraph names the two levels: one who must keep conquering his heart with his mind (a tzaddik in Sha’arei Kedushah’s terms, a beinoni in Tanya’s), and one whose heart has been won over entirely (a chassid, or in Tanya a tzaddik).
Sha’arei Kedushah calls one who keeps the mitzvos while still battling his evil inclination “a complete tzaddik who conquers his inclination,” and one in whom the good traits have become nature, so that he keeps the mitzvos with joy and love without any pull of the evil inclination, “a complete chassid,” citing David’s “And my heart is void within me,” the verse the next paragraph quotes. Tanya calls one who has driven the evil out of his heart a tzaddik (ch. 10), and describes the beinoni as one in whom the evil is subdued during prayer but reawakens afterward, while his mind, which rules the heart by nature, keeps it from acting (ch. 12).
Marei mekomos
- 1איזהו גבור הכובש · אבות ד, א.
- 2איזהו גבור הכובש את יצרו · Pirkei Avot 4:1
- 3זהו נק׳ חסיד · Sha'arei Kedusha, Part 1 3:3
- 4אכן בסש״ב פי׳ · פ״י ופי״ב.
- 5ובחי׳ הא׳ נק׳ בינוני · Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 12
6וזה שאמר דהע״ה תכלית שנאה שנאתים1 כו׳ כשראה שונאי ה׳ נעשה להם שונא גמור, ואף שהיה להם כמה מעלות גופניות שהיה ראוי לאהוב אותם מטבע הגוף
And this is what King David, peace be upon him, said: “I hate them with utmost hatred,” etc. When he saw those who hate G‑d, he became their complete enemy. And although they had several bodily virtues for which it would have been fitting to love them, by the nature of the body,
King David illustrates the higher level. When he saw those who hate G‑d he became their complete enemy, although they had bodily qualities that would ordinarily draw love.
דהיינו מצד יפים וחכמתם שדרך הגוף לאהוב דברים כאלו, אעפ״כ מפני שמושרשת אצלו כ״כ אהבתו ית׳ בלב גם כן הוא בטל מכל מדותיו נגדו והיה להם שונא גמור והוא ע״ד מה שכתוב ולבי חלל בקרבי.2
namely, on account of their beauty and their wisdom, for it is the way of the body to love such things, nevertheless, because the love of Him, may He be blessed, was so rooted in him, in the heart too, he was nullified before Him with respect to all his emotive attributes (middos), and he was their complete enemy. And this is along the lines of what is written: “And my heart is void within me.”
Beauty and wisdom are the kind of things the body naturally loves. But David’s love of G‑d was rooted in his heart as well as his mind, so all his natural feelings were nullified before G‑d and the attraction had no hold on him; this is what he meant by “my heart is void within me.”
King David’s “utmost hatred” shows the higher level: his love of G‑d was so rooted in his heart that the body’s natural attractions were nullified.
Tanya ch. 10, which the Kehot note on the previous paragraph cites, applies “I hate them with utmost hatred” to the complete tzaddik, who hates whatever comes from the sitra achra in the measure of his great love for G‑d. Sha’arei Kedushah brings “And my heart is void within me” as the mark of the chassid in whom the good traits have become nature.
Marei mekomos
- 1תכלית שנאה שנאתים · Psalms 139:22
- 2ולבי חלל בקרבי · Psalms 109:22
Baruch: where we take hold of G‑d ¶7–8
7וזהו מחמת שמתפשט מהמוח לחוץ ששם הוא סתום ביותר כנ״ל. נחזור לענינינו שכל המשפיע למטה נקרא אותה בחי׳ יסוד
And this is because it spreads out from the mind outward, for there it is most hidden, as mentioned above. Let us return to our subject: that in everything that bestows below, that level is called Yesod.
The heart’s strength comes from the idea’s having come out of the mind, where it was most hidden. The maamar now returns to Yesod: in anything that bestows downward, the level through which it bestows is called Yesod.
ולכן כשאנו קוראים להוי׳ ב״ה אנו קוראים אותו באותה בחי׳ דהיינו במלת ברוך שהוא יסוד אבא1 כנודע
Therefore, when we call upon Havayah, blessed be He, we call Him by that level, namely with the word “Baruch” (“Blessed”), which is the Yesod of Abba, as is known;
That is why, when we address G‑d (Havayah) in a blessing, we use the word Baruch, “Blessed,” which, as is known, corresponds to the Yesod of Abba; the Kehot note cites the Kabbalistic lexicon Me’orei Or for this.
דהיינו באותה בחי׳ שהוא מקושר אתנו להחיות אותנו באותה בחי׳ עצמה אנו יכולים לאחוז בו
that is, by the level at which He is bound to us to give us life: by that very level we are able to take hold of Him,
We address Him at the level through which He is bound to us to give us life, and that is the very level at which we are able to take hold of Him.
ולא יותר מאחר שלאותה בחי׳ הוא מצמצם א״ע להשפיע למטה כנ״ל ע״כ באותה הבחי׳ יש לנו אחיזה כמו שכתוב כולם בחכמה עשית.2
and no more, since it is to that level that He contracts Himself to bestow below, as mentioned above. Therefore at that level we have a hold, as it is written: “You have made them all with wisdom.”
We can grasp no more than that, because that is the level to which He contracts Himself in order to bestow below. So the verse says “You have made them all with wisdom”: all creation is joined to Him through Chochmah, and there we have our hold.
The paragraph returns to Yesod and explains that the word Baruch in our blessings addresses G‑d at the Yesod of Abba, the level through which He gives us life and the only level at which we can grasp Him.
Likkutei Torah’s discourse “Go out and see,” cited in the next paragraph, explains Baruch as drawing down: the holiness that gives the worlds their life is “blessed,” drawn down anew from the supernal holiness that is beyond the worlds altogether.
Marei mekomos
- 1ברוך שהוא יסוד אבא · ראה מא״א אות ב, סל״ט.
- 2כלם בחכמה עשית · Psalms 104:24
8והנה אותן ב׳ היסודות מהם נעשים מוחין לז״א דהנה ז״א נקרא מלשון זעיר שהשכל הוא קטן יותר ממה שלמעלה
Now, from these two Yesods the intellect (mochin) of Z’eir Anpin (the emotive attributes) is formed. For Z’eir Anpin is so called from the word ze’eir, “small,” because the intellect is smaller than what is above,
From the two Yesods, of Abba and of Imma, comes the intellect of Z’eir Anpin. Its name, from ze’eir, “small,” reflects that its intellect is smaller than the levels above it.
והוא חיות המתפשט לחיות העולמות [ועמ״ש בד״ה באתי לגני ובד״ה צאינה וראינה1 גבי שאו ידיכם קדש2 כו׳] ואחר כך כשמתפשט עד החזה נעשה שם אורות הרבה ומשם נעשה בחי׳ רחל ולאה.
and it is the life-force that spreads out to give life to the worlds [and see what is written in the discourse beginning “I have come into My garden,” and in the discourse beginning “Go out and see,” concerning “Lift up your hands in holiness,” etc.]. And afterwards, when it spreads down to the chest, many lights are formed there, and from there the levels of Rachel and Leah are formed.
Z’eir Anpin is the life-force that spreads out to give life to the worlds; the bracket points to the discourses “I have come into My garden” and “Go out and see,” on “Lift up your hands in holiness,” which explain how that life is drawn down. When the light spreads down to the chest, many lights arise there, and from there the levels of Rachel and Leah, two feminine configurations that receive from Z’eir Anpin, are formed.
The paragraph follows the light of the two Yesods: it forms the intellect of Z’eir Anpin, the life-force of the worlds, and at the chest gives rise to Rachel and Leah.
Marei mekomos
- 1ובד״ה צאינה וראינה · לקו״ת שה״ש כא, ג.
- 2שאו ידיכם קדש · Psalms 134:2
Rachel and Leah: thought and speech ¶9–10
9ואע״פ שלכאורה מובא בכתבי האריז״ל שבחי׳ לאה יונקת ממה שלמעלה דהיינו מבינה ותבונה וגם בחי׳ רחל
And although, at first glance, it is brought in the writings of the Arizal that the level of Leah draws nourishment from what is above, namely from Binah (understanding) and Tevunah, and the level of Rachel too
The maamar raises a point from the Arizal’s writings, which seem to say that Leah draws her nourishment from the levels above her, from Binah and Tevunah (the lower part of Binah), and that Rachel likewise draws from above.
יונקת משם שעל זה נאמר בחכמה יסד ארץ1 היינו בחי׳ רחל הנ״ל אבא יסד ברתא2345 שהכל מחכמה נפקא זהו גם כן אמת.
draws nourishment from there, for of this it is said, “With wisdom He founded the earth,” that is, the level of Rachel mentioned above: “Abba founded the daughter,” for everything issues from Chochmah (wisdom); this too is true.
For Rachel the Arizal brings “With wisdom He founded the earth,” which the Zohar reads as “Abba founded the daughter”: Chochmah, called Abba, founded Malchus, the “daughter” and the “earth,” for everything issues from Chochmah. The maamar grants that this is true.
אבל נראה דהנה ב׳ בחי׳ רחל ולאה הנ״ל הם נקראי׳ מחשבה ודבור [וכמ״ש בפ׳ שלח ע״פ טובה הארץ מאד מאד ובפ׳ ויצא ע״פ וללבן שתי בנות ובפ׳ תזריע בד״ה קא מפלגי במתיב תא דרקיעא כו׳
But it appears that the two levels of Rachel and Leah mentioned above are called thought and speech [as is explained in Parshas Shelach on the verse “The land is very, very good,” and in Parshas Vayeitzei on the verse “And Lavan had two daughters,” and in Parshas Tazria in the discourse beginning “They were disputing in the Heavenly Academy,” etc.;
Yet it proposes another way to see them: Rachel and Leah are called thought and speech. The bracket refers to three discourses where this is explained, in Shelach, Vayeitzei and Tazria.
ע״ש] עלמא דאתכסיא ועלמא דאתגליא והם נק׳ בחי׳ אחוריים של השכל שאינו השכל בעצמו כשבא להתפשטות מחשבה ודבור.
see there]: the hidden world (alma de’iskasya) and the revealed world (alma de’isgalya). And they are called the level of the back (achorayim) of the intellect, which is not the intellect itself, when it comes to spread out into thought and speech.
Thought and speech are “the hidden world” and “the revealed world.” They are called the “back” (achorayim) of the intellect: not the intellect itself, but its outer extension as it spreads into thought and speech.
The paragraph grants the Arizal’s teaching that Rachel and Leah draw from above, and proposes that they are thought and speech, the hidden and the revealed worlds, which are the outer “back” of the intellect.
The Tikkunei Zohar reads the verse letter by letter: through Abba, the yud of the Name, He founded the daughter, the lower hei, while through Imma, the upper hei, “He established the heavens,” the vav. So the earth, Malchus, has its foundation in Chochmah.
Marei mekomos
- 1בחכמה יסד ארץ · Proverbs 3:19
- 2אבא יסד ברתא · Zohar III, 248a
- 3אבא יסד ברתא · Zohar, Pinchas 121:822–831
- 4אבא יסד ברתא · Tikkunei Zohar 61b:4–5
- 5אבא יסד ברתא · Tikkunei Zohar 105b:2–3
10וזהו שהם מאחוריים יסוד או״א. ולהבין מהו אתכסיא ואתגליא דהנה במחשבה יש גם כן אותן האותיות עצמן מה
And this is [the meaning of] their being from the back of the Yesod of Abba and Imma. And to understand what “hidden” and “revealed” mean: in thought, too, there are the very same letters as what
This is why Rachel and Leah are said to come from the “back” of the Yesod of Abba and Imma. To explain “hidden” and “revealed,” the maamar notes that thought already holds the very letters a person will later speak.
שהוא מדבר שהנה מה שמחשב זהו מדבר אלא ששם הם מכוסים ואינו יודע רק הוא בעצמו ואח״כ יכול להבין אפי׳ אחר.
he speaks; for what he thinks is what he speaks, except that there they are covered, and no one knows [them] but he himself; and afterwards even another can understand.
What a person thinks is what he speaks; the difference is that in thought the letters are covered and known to him alone, while once they are spoken even someone else can understand them.
The paragraph explains why thought is the hidden world and speech the revealed world: both hold the same letters, hidden in one and revealed in the other.
The heart sees, hears and understands ¶11
11והנה מחשבה ודבור יוצאים מהמדות כי מה שאוהב זהו מחשב ומדבר והמדות נמשכים מהתבוננות השכל שמתחלה נופל לו בשכלו איזה דבר ואחר כך בהתבוננותו באותו
Now, thought and speech issue from the emotive attributes (middos), for what he loves is what he thinks and speaks about. And the emotive attributes are drawn from the contemplation of the intellect: first some matter occurs to him in his intellect, and afterwards, as he contemplates that
Thought and speech come from the emotive attributes: a person thinks and speaks about what he loves. The emotions in turn come from the intellect’s contemplation: first an idea occurs to him, and then he dwells on it.
דבר מתפשטים ללב ומשם נמשכים המדות לרצות הדבר או שלא לרצות והלב היא קיומה של דבר שלפעמים השכל מחייב לאהוב איזה דבר וטבע הגוף אינו מניחו
matter, [these] spread to the heart, and from there the emotive attributes are drawn, to want the thing or not to want it. And the heart is what makes a matter endure; for sometimes the intellect requires one to love something, and the nature of the body does not let him.
As he contemplates, the matter spreads into the heart, and there the emotions arise that make him want it or not want it. The heart is what gives a matter permanence; for sometimes the intellect says that one should love something, and the body’s nature does not let him.
אבל כשמדבק שכלו כ״כ עד שגם בלבו נקבע הדבר לעשותו ממילא הוא בטל מכל המדות
But when he binds his intellect so strongly that the matter becomes fixed in his heart too, to do it, then of itself he is nullified with respect to all the emotive attributes.
When he binds his intellect so strongly that the resolve to act is fixed in his heart too, he becomes nullified as a matter of course, and his natural emotions no longer stand in the way.
ועל כן נאמר ביעקב וישק יעקב לרחל1 שהיה מותר לו בודאי מאחר שהיה בטל מכל תאוות גופניות מחמת התדבקותו בו ית׳ ואחר כך כשמתפשטים אותיות המחשבה לאותיות הדבור שם הוא יותר התגלות
Therefore it is said of Yaakov, “And Yaakov kissed Rachel,” which was certainly permitted to him, since he was void of all bodily desires because of his cleaving to Him, may He be blessed. And afterwards, when the letters of thought spread into the letters of speech, there it is more revealed.
That is why Yaakov could kiss Rachel: it was surely permitted to him, because his cleaving to G‑d left him void of every bodily desire. The maamar then returns to thought and speech: when the letters of thought spread into the letters of speech, they become more revealed.
ולכן מאחר שהשכל יוצא מהמוח ללב שהכל מחכמה נפקא ע״כ יש בלב כל הבחי׳ דהיינו ראיה [וכמ״ש ולבי ראה הרבה חכמה2 כו׳]
And so, since the intellect goes out from the mind to the heart, for everything issues from Chochmah (wisdom), therefore the heart has all the levels, namely: seeing [as it is written, “And my heart has seen much wisdom,” etc.],
Since the intellect goes out from the mind into the heart, and everything comes from Chochmah, the heart has all the intellect’s levels. The first is sight, as Koheles says: “my heart has seen much wisdom.”
שמיעה והבנה, וכמ״ש ברבות בקהלת ע״פ דברתי אני עם לבי34 והיינו שיש בלב גם כן בחינת בינה כנ״ל שהם יסודות משתווין שם שבהם מתקשרים לחיות כל העולמות
hearing and understanding, as is written in [Midrash] Rabbah on Koheles, on the verse “I spoke with my heart.” That is, the heart also has the level of Binah (understanding), as mentioned above, for they are the Yesods that are equal there, through which they bind themselves to give life to all the worlds.
The heart also hears and understands, as the Midrash on Koheles lists the heart’s powers on the verse “I spoke with my heart.” This means the heart has the level of Binah too, because the Yesods of Abba and Imma end there equally, and through them the light connects to give life to all the worlds.
אך אדם צ״ל תמיד זריז ונלבב לכבוש את יצרו ולעקור אותו ממחדו״מ לדבקה בו ית׳ כנ״ל:
But a person must always be diligent and wholehearted, to conquer his inclination and uproot it from thought, speech and action, in order to cleave to Him, may He be blessed, as mentioned above.
The maamar closes with what it asks of a person: he must always be diligent and wholehearted, conquering his inclination and uprooting it from his thought, speech and action, so that he may cleave to G‑d.
The paragraph traces the chain from intellect to emotion to thought and speech, shows that a matter fixed in the heart nullifies the opposing emotions, and concludes that the heart, receiving from Chochmah and Binah, sees, hears and understands; so a person must keep working to win it over.
The discourse “The eyes of all” (Likkutei Torah, Matos), which this maamar cites at its start, joins this Midrash to the saying “Binah is the heart, and with it the heart understands,” and explains the “gates of Binah” as the light of contemplation going out from the mind into the heart.
Marei mekomos
- 1וישק יעקב לרחל · Genesis 29:11
- 2ולבי ראה הרבה חכמה · Ecclesiastes 1:16
- 3וכמ״ש ברבות בקהלת ע״פ דברתי אני עם לבי · ראה אוה״ת בראשית כרך-ו דף תתרצב, א.
- 4דברתי אני עם לבי · Kohelet Rabbah 1:16
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
Understanding in the mind that one must cleave to G‑d is not enough, for the heart is close to the body and can pull a person after bodily desires. One must wage the intellect’s war with the heart, contemplating G‑d’s greatness with all one’s strength until the heart itself desires to cleave to Him, and must always be diligent and wholehearted to conquer the inclination and uproot it from thought, speech and action.
Questions for discussion
- Why can an idea held only in the mind be abandoned at once, while one fixed in the heart lasts?
- How do Sha’arei Kedushah and Tanya differ in what they call a tzaddik, and what does each usage stress?
- Why does calling G‑d Baruch mean addressing Him at the level through which He gives us life, and why can we grasp no more than that?
- In what sense are thought and speech the hidden and the revealed worlds, and the “back” of the intellect?
- What does it mean that the heart, too, sees, hears and understands?
Key terms in this maamar
- Yesod (foundation)יסוד
- The channel that connects and transmits. ×7
- The intellect (mochin)מוחין
- Chochmah, Binah and Daas as a whole. ×2
- Z'eir Anpin (the emotive attributes)ז״א
- The six emotive Sefiros as one configuration.
- The emotive attributes (middos)מדות
- Love, awe, compassion and the rest. ×4
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×5
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×5
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×2
- Abba and Imma (Chochmah and Binah)אבא ואמא
- The intellectual configurations.