Likkutei Torah · Parshas Sukkos · Maamar 4
ביום השמיני עצרת תהיה לכם
On the Eighth Day, There Shall Be an Atzeres for You
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
G‑d hides Himself on Rosh Hashanah the way a father hides from a wise son, only so that we will seek Him and the revelation of Sukkos will bring Him greater joy; on Shemini Atzeres He gives us His own crown, the Torah, and the acceptance of His kingship is gathered in for the whole year with a joy so deep it stays inward.
The maamar in brief
The Torah calls Sukkos “a festival to G‑d,” a festival that brings joy to G‑d Himself. To explain how G‑d can rejoice, the Alter Rebbe uses the verse “A wise son makes a father rejoice”: a father hides to see whether his son understands that the hiding is only so that he will be sought. So G‑d conceals Himself on Rosh Hashanah, the day of judgment, so that we seek His face and His revelation on Sukkos brings greater joy. Sin can hide only G‑d’s inner dimension, His inner will, not the outer life-force that sustains everything. Man too has an outer and an inner dimension: “bending the knee” is mere acknowledgment, while “bowing down” is the nullification of the whole self. The days from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur raise us from the first to the second; through teshuvah G‑d’s inner love is revealed on Yom Kippur and shines openly on Sukkos, as the sukkah, the esrog and the lulav show. Shemini Atzeres, Simchas Torah, goes higher still: G‑d gives His crown, the Torah, and the acceptance of His kingship is gathered in for the year with an inward joy (gilah) held within awe. An abridgment closes the maamar.
Outline
- Joy for G‑d: the wise sonSukkos brings joy to G‑d; like a father who hides from his wise son, G‑d conceals Himself on Rosh Hashanah so that He will be sought and revealed with greater joy on Sukkos; the Priestly Blessing read in this light.¶1–3
- What sin hides, and two kinds of submissionSin hides only G‑d’s inner dimension; in man, too, bending the knee (acknowledgment, Hod) differs from bowing down (nullification of the self, Netzach), and bowing itself can be outer or inner.¶4–6
- From the days of awe to SukkosThe service from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur raises us to full bowing; through teshuvah G‑d’s inner love is revealed, and the sukkah, esrog and lulav bring it into open joy.¶7
- Shemini Atzeres: the crown of TorahOn Simchas Torah G‑d gives His crown, the Torah, higher than the revealed face; the acceptance of His kingship is gathered in for the year, and its joy is inward gilah that holds awe and love together.¶8–9
- AbridgmentA summary of the whole maamar, adding the nesirah of Rosh Hashanah, the joy of revealed mochin on Sukkos, the crown above the intellect, and the three crowns of kingship, priesthood and Torah across the season.¶10–16
Key concepts
- The inner and outer dimensions (pnimiyus and chitzoniyus)פנימיות וחיצוניות
- G‑d’s outer dimension sustains all things and nothing can hide it; His inner dimension, His inner will and love, is what sin conceals. In a person, too, outer service is behaviour and inner service is the will itself.
- Bending the knee and bowing down (kri’ah and hishtachavayah)כריעה והשתחואה
- Bending the knees, which are “outside the body,” is acknowledgment that leaves the self standing; bowing the stature and the head, the seat of Daas, is the nullification of one’s whole will before G‑d.
- Concealment for the sake of revelationהסתר בשביל הגילוי
- G‑d’s hiding on Rosh Hashanah is not true anger but a means, like the father who hides from his wise son, so that we seek Him and the revelation brings greater joy.
- The crown of Torahכתר תורה
- The Torah’s root is above divine wisdom, in Keser; on Simchas Torah G‑d gives this crown to Israel, as a king gives his crown to one he loves.
- Simchah and gilahשמחה וגילה
- Simchah is joy revealed outwardly, the joy of Sukkos; gilah is joy held within, out of awe of the King, the joy of Shemini Atzeres.
- Atzeresעצרת
- Rendered by the Targum as “gathering”: on Shemini Atzeres the acceptance of G‑d’s kingship is gathered and kept for the whole year, and the joy is held within.
For children · ages 9–13
The father who hides
The big idea
G‑d hides on Rosh Hashanah only so that we will look for Him, and on Shemini Atzeres He gives us His crown, the Torah, to keep all year.
The Torah calls Sukkos “a festival to G‑d”: a festival that brings joy to G‑d Himself. How can G‑d rejoice? The verse says, “A wise son makes a father rejoice.” A father sometimes hides from his son to see whether the son understands that the hiding is only so that he will search. In the same way, G‑d seems hidden on Rosh Hashanah, the day of judgment, so that we will seek His face. When we find Him on Sukkos, His joy is greater. The maamar teaches two ways of serving G‑d. “Bending the knee” means only agreeing that G‑d is King. “Bowing down” means giving over our whole self. From Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur we climb from the first to the second, and through teshuvah, returning to G‑d, His inner love is revealed. On Sukkos it shines openly, in the sukkah, the esrog and the lulav. On Shemini Atzeres, Simchas Torah, G‑d gives us His crown, the Torah. We gather in our acceptance of Him as King for the whole year, with a quiet joy that stays deep inside.
The mashal
A father who wants to see how wise his son is hides from him. A wise son understands that his father has not really gone away; he is hiding only so that the son will look for him and find him. When the son searches with all his heart and finds him, the father’s joy is great. So G‑d hides on Rosh Hashanah so that we will seek Him.
Questions for the Shabbos table
- Why would G‑d hide from us if He wants us to be close to Him?
- What is the difference between “bending the knee” and “bowing down”?
- What is one thing you can do this week to carry the quiet joy of Simchas Torah into an ordinary day?
Explanation © likuteitorah.com, CC BY-NC 4.0: retold for children from our translation and explanation, with AI assistance; not yet reviewed by a human editor.
Joy for G‑d: the wise son ¶1–3
1ביום השמיני עצרת12 תהיה לכם. ובכל המועדים כתיב ועשית פסח3 לה׳ אלקיך ועשית חג שבועות לה׳ אלקיך.4 ובסוכות כתיב בפ׳ אמור וחגותם אותו חג לה׳.5
“On the eighth day, there shall be an atzeres (assembly) for you.” Now, regarding all the festivals it is written, “You shall make the Pesach to Havayah your G‑d,” [and] “You shall make the festival of Shavuos to Havayah your G‑d.” But regarding Sukkos it is written, in Parshas Emor, “And you shall celebrate it as a festival to G‑d.”
The maamar opens with the Torah’s verse for Shemini Atzeres and then notes a difference in wording. For Pesach and Shavuos the Torah says “You shall make” the festival “to Havayah your G‑d,” but for Sukkos it says “you shall celebrate it (oso) as a festival to G‑d,” which the maamar will read as making a festival, a celebration, for G‑d Himself.
פי׳ שמביאין שמחה בהקב״ה כמאמר וישמחו בך ישראל מקדשי שמך שישראל מקדשי שמך מביאין השמחה בך ואין שמחה אלא ביין6 כמש״ גבי יין המשמח אלקים ואנשים7 כו׳
This means that [we] bring joy to the Holy One, blessed be He, as in the saying, “And Israel, who sanctify Your Name, will rejoice in You”: that Israel, who sanctify Your Name, bring the joy into You. And there is no joy except with wine, as it is written regarding wine, “which gladdens G‑d and men,” etc.
The Alter Rebbe explains the Sukkos wording: on this festival we bring joy to G‑d Himself. The prayer “Israel ... will rejoice in You” is read as “Israel bring joy into You,” and the Talmudic rule that joy comes through wine is linked to the verse about wine that “gladdens G‑d and men.”
ולהבין זה איך הוא השמחה למעלה בו ית׳ שאין לו דמות הגוף8 וכו׳ (ועמ״ש ע״פ שוש אשיש9 בהוי׳. וגבי פורים בפי׳ רננו צדיקים10 בהוי׳) הנה כתיב בן חכם ישמח אב.11
And [we need] to understand this: how is there joy above, in Him, may He be blessed, who has no bodily form, etc.? (See also what is written on the verse “I will greatly rejoice in Havayah,” and, regarding Purim, in the explanation of “Sing joyfully, you righteous, in Havayah.”) Now, it is written, “A wise son makes a father rejoice.”
The question: how can one speak of joy “in” G‑d, who has no body and no emotions like ours? The parenthesis points to two other discourses on joy in G‑d, and the answer begins with the verse “A wise son makes a father rejoice.”
פי׳ עד״מ אב שרוצה להבין12 חכמת בנו אזי מסתיר א״ע ממנו בכדי לידע ולהכיר חכמת הבן שיבין שההסתר וההעלם הזה אינו
Meaning, by way of analogy: a father who wishes to understand his son’s wisdom hides himself from him, in order to know and recognize the son’s wisdom: [whether] he will understand that this hiding and concealment is not
The analogy: a father hides from his son to test his wisdom. The test is whether the son grasps that the hiding is not real distance.
אלא בכדי שיבקשנו הבן וימצאנו ואז תגדל השמחה באביו בשביל חכמת בנו והכרתו בזה כי יחפשנו בחפש מחופש לרדוף אחריו.
[for any purpose] except that the son should seek him and find him. And then the father’s joy grows great because of his son’s wisdom and his recognition of this, for he will search for him with a thorough search, to pursue him.
A wise son understands that his father hid only in order to be sought and found, so he searches for him with all his effort. The father’s joy is then greater than if he had never hidden, because it is joy in his son’s wisdom and understanding.
So too, it is written, “In the concealment (bakeseh), for the day of our festival”: that He hides and conceals Himself on Rosh Hashanah so that the joy will grow great at the festival of Sukkos.
The analogy is applied to the calendar. The verse about the shofar on Rosh Hashanah, “in the concealment (bakeseh), for the day of our festival,” is read as saying that G‑d conceals Himself on Rosh Hashanah (the new moon is still hidden) for the sake of the festival of Sukkos two weeks later, so that the joy then will be greater.
The opening asks how Sukkos can be a festival that brings joy to G‑d Himself, and answers with the parable of the father who hides from his wise son: G‑d’s concealment on Rosh Hashanah exists for the sake of the greater joy of Sukkos.
The Kehot note on the opening words records that the Rebbe’s source notes connect this discourse with Sefer HaMaamarim Eschalech Liozna, that the listing of the Alter Rebbe’s short maamarim suggests it may date from 5558, and that it is sometimes cited by the name “On the day of Shemini Atzeres: A wise son makes a father rejoice.” Its theme of joy (simchah) as revealed gladness returns at the end of the maamar, where Shemini Atzeres is described as inward joy (gilah).
Marei mekomos
- 1ביום השמיני עצרת · ראה בהערות וציונים מכ״ק אדמו״ר ללקו״ת כאן מציין לסה״מ אתהלך לאזניא ע׳ נב. ובסה״מ הנ״ל ע׳ רסג מציין ”ראה בלקו״ת ד״ה זה (פא, ד) בתוספת ביאור הערות וכו׳”. וע״פ המבואר ברשימת המאמרים שבסו״ס מאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ תריט הערה 100 — מאמר זה אולי משנת תקנ״ח. קיצורים וביאור נדפסו באוה״ת שמע״צ כרך ה ע׳ ב׳קנה. שם נתבארו הענינים שמובאים בסה״מ אתהלך הנ״ל. בכמה מקומות מצויין לד״ה זה בשם ”ביום השמע״צ בן חכם ישמח אב”. וראה ההתחלה בסה״מ אתהלך שם.
- 2ביום השמיני עצרת · Numbers 29:35
- 3ועשית פסח לה״א · Deuteronomy 16:1
- 4ועשית חג שבועות לה׳ אלקיך · Deuteronomy 16:10
- 5וחגותם אותו חג לה׳ · Leviticus 23:41
- 6ואין שמחה אלא ביין · Pesachim 109a:5
- 7המשמח אלקים ואנשים · Judges 9:13
- 8שאין לו דמות הגוף · תפלת יגדל.
- 9ע״פ שוש אשיש · לעיל מז, א ואילך.
- 10וגבי פורים בפי׳ רננו צדיקים · תו״א צט, ג.
- 11בן חכם ישמח אב · Proverbs 10:1
- 12פי׳ עד״מ אב שרוצה להבין · בסה״מ עזר״ת ע׳ ט מציין לכאן. וראה בסה״מ תרס״ו ע׳ רמח המשל בארוכה.
- 13בכסה ליום חגנו · Psalms 81:4
- 14
2וביאור הענין הזה כי הנה ר״ה הוא יום הדין ומשפט1 לאלהי יעקב שמראה א״ע כאלו מסתלק השראתו ואינו רוצה כ״א להיות דין ומשפט על אלהותו ית׳ איך לשכון ביעקב ומדקדקין על כל מעשי האדם
And the explanation of this matter: Rosh Hashanah is the day of judgment, “a judgment for the G‑d of Yaakov,” when He shows Himself as though His indwelling departs, and He wishes only that there be judgment and justice concerning His G‑dliness, may He be blessed, [as to] how [it is] to dwell in Yaakov. And all of a person’s deeds are scrutinized,
Rosh Hashanah is the day of judgment, and the verse calls it “a judgment for the G‑d of Yaakov.” The Alter Rebbe reads this as a judgment about G‑d’s own presence: He appears to withdraw it, and the question judged is whether and how His G‑dliness should dwell among the Jewish people.
להביא במשפט כל המשכות אלהותו שהמשיך כל אחד ואחד על נפשו לפי בחי׳ מדרגתו בשנה העבר׳ וכל מה שימשיך עליו עוד על להבא בשנה זוואם הוא ראוי לכך והרי הוא כאלו מסתיר א״ע ממנו כו׳
to bring into judgment all the drawings-down of His G‑dliness that each and every one drew down upon his soul, according to the level of his standing, in the past year, and all that he will yet draw down upon himself in the future, in this year, and whether he is worthy of it. And so it is as though He hides Himself from him, etc.
What is judged is how much G‑dliness each person drew into his soul during the past year, according to his level, and how much he will draw in the coming year, and whether he deserves it. Holding back His presence until this judgment is made is what makes it seem that G‑d is hiding.
אבל ואנכי הסתר אסתיר2 פני ביום ההוא כתיב בפ׳ וילך שבחי׳ ההסתר וההעלם בזה אינו בבחי׳ הסתר והעלם אמיתי על צד עצם ההעלם לומר שהוא תכלית כוונת המכוון ח״ו להיות כמו רוגז אמיתי ח״ו.
However, [regarding] “And I will surely hide My face on that day,” written in Parshas Vayeilech: the hiding and concealment in this is not a true hiding and concealment, for the sake of the concealment itself, as if to say that it is the ultimate aim of what is intended, G‑d forbid, like true anger, G‑d forbid.
The verse from Parshas Vayeilech, “I will surely hide My face,” might suggest real anger and real distance. The Alter Rebbe says this concealment is not an end in itself and not true anger, G‑d forbid.
אלא שכדי שיבקש פניו3 ולהתגלות גילוי אלקות ית׳ בחג הסוכות עשה כן שיהא שמחתנו שתתגדל השמחה בהתגלות מההעלם אל הגילוי.
Rather, it is so that one will seek His face, and so that a revelation of G‑dliness, may He be blessed, will be revealed on the festival of Sukkos, that He did so: so that it be [the time of] our joy, that the joy grow great through the revealing from concealment to revelation.
The hiding has a purpose: that we should seek G‑d’s face, so that on Sukkos His G‑dliness will be revealed. Joy is greatest when something hidden becomes revealed, and so Sukkos is “the time of our joy.”
This paragraph applies the parable: on Rosh Hashanah G‑d seems to withdraw His presence for judgment, but the concealment is only a means, so that we seek Him and He is revealed with greater joy on Sukkos.
The Kehot note on “so that one will seek His face” records that Or HaTorah on Vayeilech quotes this line and compares it to the verse “On Your behalf my heart said, ‘Seek My face’; Your face, Havayah, I will seek,” which the maamar itself will quote later in section 3.
Marei mekomos
- 1ר״ה הוא יום הדין ומשפט לאלקי יעקב · Psalms 81:5
- 2ואנכי הסתר אסתיר · Deuteronomy 31:18
- 3אלא שכדי שיבקש פניו · מובא באוה״ת פ׳ וילך ע׳ א׳תנו ושם מציין ע״ז ”(נ׳ ע״ד מ״ש לך אמר לבי בקשו פני את פניך ה׳ אבקש)”. וראה באוה״ת נ״ך כרך ב ע׳ תתקכב.
3וזהו ואנכי הסתר אסתיר פני ביום ההוא1 דהיינו בחי׳ ועבד הלוי הוא2 שהוא בחינת יין המשמח אלקים ואנשים3 כמ״ש במ״א.
And this is “And I will surely hide My face on that day”: that is, the level of “And the Levite, he (hu), shall perform [the service],” which is the level of “wine that gladdens G‑d and men,” as is explained elsewhere.
The hidden face is linked to the verse “And the Levite, he (hu), shall perform the service,” where the word “he” can suggest the hidden aspect of G‑d. The Levites’ song is associated with the “wine that gladdens G‑d and men,” so the hidden level is the very source of joy.
ולכן אנו מבקשים פניו בכל התפלות ותחנונים שמראש השנה ועד יו״כ במלכיות זכרונות ושופרות וצועקים מלך מלך להמשיך מלכותו עלינו מראש השנה ועד יוכ״פ
Therefore we seek His face in all the prayers and supplications from Rosh Hashanah until Yom Kippur, with Malchiyos, Zichronos and Shofaros, and we cry out, “King, King,” to draw His kingship upon us, from Rosh Hashanah until Yom Kippur;
Because G‑d’s face is hidden, the ten days from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur are spent seeking it. Malchiyos, Zichronos and Shofaros are the three central sections of the Rosh Hashanah Musaf prayer, and in them we proclaim G‑d King and ask Him to draw His kingship over us.
דהיינו התגלות רצונו כמ״ש יאר ה׳ פניו אליך שהוא עד״מ כמו כאשר יחטא איש לאיש הרי הוא ברוגז עמו וכאשר הו מבקש פניו מוחל לו
that is, the revelation of His will (ratzon), as it is written, “May G‑d make His face shine upon you.” By way of analogy, it is like when a man sins against another man: [the other] is angry with him, and when he seeks his face, he forgives him
What we ask for is the revelation of G‑d’s will, His favor, as in the Priestly Blessing, “May G‑d make His face shine upon you.” The human parallel: a person who was wronged is angry, but when the offender seeks his face, he forgives.
ומעביר ממנו פניו של זעם ומראה לו פנים של אהבה ורצון להגלות לו אהבתו כך השי״ת מוחל עוונות עמו ומעביר מהם הפנים של הרוגז וההסתר
and removes from him his face of wrath and shows him a face of love and favor (ratzon), to reveal his love to him. So too G‑d, may He be blessed, forgives the sins of His people and removes from them the face of anger and concealment,
Forgiveness means more than cancelling the debt: the angry face is replaced by a face of love and favor. So too G‑d forgives His people’s sins and removes the face of anger and concealment.
בהגלות נגלות עליהם אור פניו4 כמ״ש יאר ה׳ פניו אליך5 עד שבחג הסוכות נגלה כבוד ה׳ מההעלם אל הגילוי ולכן הוא זמן שמחתנו וז״ש ישא ה׳ פניו אליך.
openly revealing to them the light of His face, as it is written, “May G‑d make His face shine upon you,” until on the festival of Sukkos the glory of G‑d is revealed from concealment to revelation; and therefore it is “the time of our joy.” And this is what is written, “May G‑d lift up His face to you.”
Instead He shows them the light of His face, and this revelation reaches its height on Sukkos, when G‑d’s glory comes out of concealment into revelation; that is why Sukkos is “the time of our joy.” The Alter Rebbe then turns to the next line of the Priestly Blessing, “May G‑d lift up His face to you.”
ישא מלשון הסתלקות ונשיאות פניו למעלה כלומר שמסלק ע צמו כב יכול ממנו ומתראה בפניו של רוגז ודין וכל כך למה בשביל אליך
“Lift up” (yisa) is from the term for withdrawal and lifting His face upward; that is to say, He withdraws Himself, as it were, from him, and appears with His face of anger and judgment. And why all this? For the sake of “to you”:
The word “lift up” (yisa) is read here as “lift away”: G‑d withdraws His face upward and shows a face of anger and judgment. The question is why, and the answer is in the next words, “to you.”
דהיינו שיומשך גילוי אלקוךו ית׳ מההעלם אל הגילוי ואז תהיה השמחה ביתר שאת [ועיין מ״ש
that is, so that the revelation of His G‑dliness, may He be blessed, be drawn down from concealment to revelation; and then the joy will be all the greater. [See also what is written
The withdrawal is “to you,” that is, for your sake, so that G‑dliness will be drawn down and revealed after being hidden, with far greater joy. The bracketed reference that begins here sends the reader to other places on the same theme.
בד״ה ושאבתם מים מענין בן חכם ישמח אב כו׳ ובזהר ח״א כ״ב א׳ ודף ס׳ ע״ב6 ח״ג ע״ד ב׳. ודף רע״ט סע״ב]:
in the discourse beginning “You shall draw water,” on the matter of “A wise son makes a father rejoice,” etc., and in the Zohar, Part I, folio 22a and folio 60b; Part III, folio 74b, and folio 279, end of side b.]
The discourse “You shall draw water” (on Sukkos) discusses “A wise son makes a father rejoice.” The Alter Rebbe also refers the reader to several passages in the Zohar.
This paragraph shows how the days of awe are a search for G‑d’s hidden face, like an offender seeking forgiveness, and reads the Priestly Blessing so that even G‑d’s withdrawal (“lift up His face”) is “to you,” for the sake of the greater revelation and joy of Sukkos.
The reading of yisa as withdrawal turns the second verse of the blessing into a description of the process itself: first the face withdraws, and only then is it revealed “to you.” The same word yields both meanings, so the concealment already contains the purpose of the revelation.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2ועבד הלוי הוא · Numbers 18:23
- 3יין המשמח אלקים ואנשים · Judges 9:13
- 4יאר ה׳ פניו אליך · Numbers 6:25
- 5ישא ה׳ פניו אליך · Numbers 6:26
- 6ודף ס׳ ע״ב · Zohar, Noach 1:12–4:23
What sin hides, and two kinds of submission ¶4–6
4ב והנה סיבה הגורמת ההעלם וההסתר הוא מ״ש עונותיכם מבדילים ביניכם1 כו׳ וצריך להבין דהא כתיב גם חשך לא יחשיך2 ממך ולילה כיום יאיר כחשיכה כאורה ואיך העון שהוא חושך יהי׳ הבדל נגד אור ה׳.
2. Now, the cause that brings about the concealment and hiding is what is written, “Your iniquities separate between you, etc.” And [we need] to understand this, for it is written, “Even darkness is not dark for You, and night shines like day; darkness is as light.” So how can sin, which is darkness, be a separation over against the light of G‑d?
Section 2 asks what causes the concealment, and answers with Isaiah: “Your iniquities separate between you and your G‑d.” But this raises a difficulty: to G‑d, darkness is like light, so how can sin, which is spiritual darkness, block His light?
אך יש ב׳ בחי׳3 היינו בחי׳ חיצוניות ובחינת פנימיות. חיצוניות הוא שמהווה כל הנבראים מאין ליש ומחיה את כולם שהוא מבחי׳ חיצוניות מלכותו ית׳ כמ״ש במ״א.
But there are two levels: the level of the outer dimension (chitzoniyus) and the level of the inner dimension (pnimiyus). The outer dimension is what brings all the created beings into being from nothing to something and gives life to all of them, which comes from the level of the outer dimension of His kingship (Malchus), may He be blessed, as is explained elsewhere.
The answer begins with a distinction between two dimensions of G‑d’s relation to the world. The outer dimension is the life-force that creates every being from nothing and keeps it alive; it comes from the outer aspect of G‑d’s Malchus, His kingship, and this dimension, as the next paragraph says, nothing can block.
The paragraph asks how sin can hide G‑d, since darkness does not darken Him, and introduces the distinction between G‑d’s outer dimension, which creates and sustains everything, and His inner dimension.
The creative power that sustains all things is described as coming from the outer aspect of Malchus, the lowest of the Sefiros, which relates to the world as a king to his subjects. The inner dimension, G‑d’s inner will, is what sin can obstruct, as the following paragraph explains.
Marei mekomos
- 1עונותיכם מבדילים ביניכם · Isaiah 59:2
- 2גם חשך לא יחשיך · Psalms 139:12
- 3אך יש ב׳ בחי׳ · ראה אוה״ת בשלח ע׳ תקכא.
And on this level there is no separation or concealment that hides and conceals His light, may He be blessed, as it is written, “The whole earth is full of His glory,” and it is written, “And His kingship rules over all.”
On the outer level, the life-force that creates and sustains all things, nothing can separate or hide G‑d’s light. That is why “the whole earth is full of His glory” and “His kingship rules over all”: even a sinner is kept in existence by it.
אך בחי׳ פנימית הוא ענין המשכות אלקותו וקדושתו עלינו מבחי׳ פנימיות רצונו ית׳ ובבחי׳ זו עוונותיכם מבדילים ביניכם3 דוקא שלא יתגל׳ ויאיר ביניכ׳ בתוך פנימי׳ נקודת הלב
But the inner level is the matter of the drawings-down of His G‑dliness and holiness upon us from the level of the inner dimension of His will, may He be blessed; and it is specifically on this level that “your iniquities separate between you,” so that it is not revealed and does not shine among you, within the innermost point of the heart.
The inner level is different: it is G‑d’s holiness drawn down to us from His inner will, His true desire. Here sin does separate: it prevents that inner light from being revealed within the innermost point of a person’s heart.
(ע׳ באגרת התשובה פד״ה ועמ״ש בפ׳ תצוה ע״פ ועשית ציץ4 בפי׳ וענין מחיצה של ברזל המפסקת בין ישראל כו׳ ועמ״ש סד״ה למנצח על השמינית) כי הנה כתיב פנים בפנים5 וכו׳.
(See Iggeres HaTeshuvah, chapters 4–5; and see also what is written in Parshas Tetzaveh on the verse “And you shall make a tzitz,” in the explanation, and the matter of the iron partition that separates between Israel, etc.; and see also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “For the conductor, on the Sheminis.”) For it is written, “Face to face, etc.”
The parenthesis gives further reading: Iggeres HaTeshuvah (the third part of Tanya; the abbreviation apparently means chapters 4–5), the Torah Ohr discourse on the tzitz with its theme of the “iron partition” that separates Israel from their Father, and the end of the discourse “For the conductor, on the Sheminis.” The verse “Face to face [G‑d spoke with you]” shows that what is above corresponds to what is in man: G‑d’s inner face meets man’s inner face.
שגם באדם יש בחינות פנימיות וחיצוניות. חיצוניות הוא מ״ש כי פנו אלי עורף6 כו׳ וכמ״ש במ״א ופנימיות נקרא מה
[This means] that in a person, too, there are levels of the inner dimension (pnimiyus) and the outer dimension (chitzoniyus). The outer dimension is what is written, “For they have turned their back to Me, etc.,” as is explained elsewhere; and the inner dimension is the name for what
A person also has an outer and an inner dimension. The prophet’s complaint “they have turned their back to Me” describes serving G‑d with the outside only, like showing one’s back; the inner dimension is what a person truly wants.
שהוא עיקר רצונו ומגמתו וחפצו ויש ב׳ בחי׳ אלו הן בסור מרע הן בועשה טוב כי בסור מרע כתיב עונותיכם מבדילים כו׳ ובועשה טוב
is the essence of his will, his aim and his desire. And these two levels exist both in “turning from evil” and in “doing good.” For regarding turning from evil it is written, “Your iniquities separate, etc.”; and regarding doing good,
A person’s inner will is what counts. The difference between outer and inner applies both to avoiding sin and to doing good: in avoiding sin, the verse about iniquities that separate applies; in doing good, the prayer quoted next shows two levels.
הנה אומרים כל ברך לך תכרע7 וכל קומה לפניך תשתחוה שיש ב׳ בחי׳ בחי׳ כריעה ובחינת השתחואה כי הנה כולם מקבלים עליהם עול מלכות שמים ומייחדים אותו בק״ש.
we say, “Every knee shall bend to You, and every stature shall bow down before You”: that there are two levels, the level of bending the knee (kri’ah) and the level of bowing down (hishtachavayah). For all of them accept upon themselves the yoke of the kingdom of Heaven and declare His oneness in the Shema.
The prayer Nishmas says “Every knee shall bend to You, and every stature shall bow down before You.” These are two levels of submission: bending the knee (kri’ah) and full bowing (hishtachavayah). Everyone who says the Shema accepts G‑d’s kingship, but not everyone reaches the same depth.
אך לא כל אפין שוין שיש מי שאינו נתפס כ״כ בלבו מקרב איש ולב8 עמוק עד
But not all faces are alike: there is one who is not so gripped in his heart, “in the inward part of a man and a deep heart,” to the point of
“Not all faces are alike”: people differ. Some accept G‑d’s kingship without being gripped by it in the depths of the heart, the “inward part of a man and a deep heart.”
כלות הנפש לבטל רצונו ממש עד שלא יהי׳ לו רצון אחר כלל זולת עבודתו ית׳ ותורת ה׳ להיות חפצו9 רק הוא על עמדו ומצבו יעמוד
the soul’s expiring (klos hanefesh), to nullify his will completely, until he has no other will at all apart from His service, may He be blessed, and the Torah of G‑d, [so] that his desire be only [in it]; rather, he stays where he stood, and in his [former] state he remains,
Such a person does not reach klos hanefesh, the soul’s longing that gives itself over entirely, to the point that he wants nothing but G‑d’s service and Torah. After the Shema he is the same person he was before it.
כמו קודם ק״ש ואינו אלא בחינת הודאה שמודה ומסכים בלבו שאין עוד מלבדו10 ואפס זולתו וכולא קמיה כלא חשיב11
as before the Shema; and it is only the level of acknowledgment (hodaah), in which he acknowledges and agrees in his heart that there is nothing else besides Him and nothing apart from Him, and that “everything before Him is considered as nothing.”
His Shema is hodaah, acknowledgment: he agrees in his heart that nothing exists apart from G‑d and that before Him everything is as nothing. This is real, but it is agreement, not transformation.
אך אל אתכפייא סט״א להיות כל רצון הגוף וכחותיו נכנעים לעשות רצון נפשו האלהית באמת לאמיתו ונקרא בחי׳ זו כריעה (וז״ש בזהר) (בראשית דמ״ב ע״ב) הכא הכרעה
But the sitra achra (the other side) is not subdued, such that all the will of the body and its powers would be subjugated to do the will of his G‑dly soul in absolute truth. And this level is called bending the knee (kri’ah). (And this is what is said in the Zohar) (Bereishis, folio 42b), “Here is bending,”
The text reads “אל אתכפייא,” which is apparently a misprint for “לא אתכפייא,” “is not subdued”: acknowledgment alone does not force the sitra achra (the side opposed to holiness) and the body’s desires to submit fully to the G‑dly soul. This level is called kri’ah, bending the knee, and the Zohar’s words “here is bending” refer to it.
והיינו בהיכל ההוד שהוא12 בחינת הודאה שכורע על ברכיו שהם לבר מגופא13 שהגוף עומד על עמדו משא״כ ביטול רצונו לגמרי וכלות הנפש אליו ית׳
that is, in the Chamber of Hod, which is the level of acknowledgment (hodaah): he bends on his knees, which are “outside the body,” for the body stays standing in its place. By contrast, the complete nullification of his will and the soul’s expiring toward Him, may He be blessed,
In the Zohar’s account of the Chambers (Heichalos) of prayer, bending belongs to the Chamber of Hod, a word related to hodaah, acknowledgment. One bends the knees, which the Zohar calls “outside the body”: the body itself stays upright, as the self stays intact.
לדבקה בו בפנימיות נקודת לבו זה הוא בחי׳ השתחוואה שכופף קמותו וראשו ששם מקור הדעת שרעותא דליבא נמשך מחמת שמקשר דעתו בחוזק בגדולת ה׳
to cleave to Him in the innermost point of his heart: this is the level of bowing down (hishtachavayah), in which he bends his stature and his head, where the source of Daas is. For the desire of the heart (re’usa deliba) is drawn forth because he binds his mind (daas) firmly to the greatness of G‑d,
Full bowing is the complete nullification of one’s will and the longing to cleave to G‑d from the innermost point of the heart: one bends the whole stature and the head, the seat of Daas. The heart’s desire (re’usa deliba) comes from binding one’s Daas, one’s focused awareness, firmly to G‑d’s greatness.
ואזי נכנס בעומקא דליבא ונגע עד הנפש בחי׳ פנימית נקודת לבבו ממש עד שאתכפייא סט״א ואין לו רצון אחר כלל. וזהו וכל קומה לפניך תשתחוה שהקומה זקופה תלוי בנשיאת ראש שהוא ענין הדעת.
and then it enters into the depth of the heart and touches the soul, the level of the very innermost point of his heart, until the sitra achra is subdued and he has no other will at all. And this is “And every stature shall bow down before You”: for an upright stature depends on the lifting of the head, which is the matter of Daas.
When Daas is bound to G‑d’s greatness, the awareness enters the depth of the heart and touches the soul’s innermost point, until the sitra achra is truly subdued. That is why the verse says “every stature” bows: a person stands tall because his head is raised, and the head is Daas, so bowing the head is bowing the self.
(ועיין ממעלת השתחואה ברבות וירא פנ״ו14 ועמ״ש סד״ה והיה ביום ההוא15 יתקע16 בענין ו השתחוו לה׳ וסד״ה והיה מדי חדש17 בענין להשתחוות לפני.18 וצ״ל מ״ש בזהר) (בראשית דמ״ג ב׳) הכא השתחואה
(And see on the virtue of bowing down in [Bereishis] Rabbah, [Parshas] Vayeira, chapter 56; and see also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And it shall be on that day, [a great shofar] shall be blown,” on the matter of “and they shall bow down to G‑d,” and at the end of the discourse beginning “And it shall be, from one new moon [to the next],” on the matter of “to bow down before Me.” And [we need] to explain what is said in the Zohar) (Bereishis, folio 43b), “Here is bowing down,”
The parenthesis refers to the Midrash on the great virtue of bowing, and to two other discourses: one on the verse about the great shofar, when the lost “will bow down to G‑d,” and one on the verse “from one new moon to the next ... all flesh will come to bow down before Me.” The Alter Rebbe then turns to the Zohar’s words “here is bowing down.”
דהיינו בהיכל הנצח19 ואפ״ל כי נצח הוא ענף החכמה שהוא בחי׳ ראיה שמזה נמשך השתחואה וביטול כי אינו דומה שמיעה לראיה20
that is, in the Chamber of Netzach. And it can be explained that Netzach is a branch of Chochmah, which is the level of sight, from which bowing down and self-nullification (bittul) are drawn, for hearing is not comparable to seeing.
The Zohar places bowing in the Chamber of Netzach. The Alter Rebbe suggests why: Netzach branches from Chochmah, which is like sight, and seeing something brings a far deeper self-nullification than hearing about it, as the Sages say, “hearing is not like seeing.”
והיינו כי הוד ענף הבינה שהיא בחי׳ שמיעה כו׳ וז״ש בפע״ח בכוונת תפלת ערבית דשבת כי בחול איהי בהוד ובערבית דשבת גם איהי בנצח
And this is because Hod is a branch of Binah, which is the level of hearing, etc. And this is what is written in Pri Etz Chaim, on the kavanah of the evening prayer of Shabbos: that on weekdays she is in Hod, and in the evening prayer of Shabbos she is also in Netzach.
Hod branches from Binah, which is like hearing: grasping by explanation, which yields acknowledgment. Pri Etz Chaim teaches that on weekdays Malchus (“she”) is in Hod during the evening prayer, but on Shabbos evening she rises to Netzach as well.
והיינו לפי כי בשבת כתיב ויברך אלקים את יום השביעי21 וכנודע דברכה היא למעלה מבחי׳ הודאה וכמ״ש ע״פ ציון במשפט תפדה22 ע״ש.2324
And this is because regarding Shabbos it is written, “And G‑d blessed the seventh day,” and, as is known, blessing is higher than the level of acknowledgment (hodaah); as is written on the verse “Zion shall be redeemed with justice”; see there.
Shabbos reaches Netzach because it was blessed (“And G‑d blessed the seventh day”), and blessing, drawing down from above, is higher than acknowledgment. A discourse on “Zion shall be redeemed with justice” explains this further.
The paragraph explains that sin blocks only G‑d’s inner light, and that in man too there is an outer and an inner service: kri’ah, acknowledgment that leaves the self standing (Hod), and hishtachavayah, the bowing of the head and the whole self (Netzach).
The pairing of Hod with Binah (hearing) and Netzach with Chochmah (sight) follows the rule that the lower Sefiros are branches of the higher ones. The Kehot note on bowing in the Chamber of Netzach records that a later discourse (Kol Dodi, 5668) questioned why bowing is placed in Netzach and suggested that this Likkutei Torah passage means inner bowing, perhaps linked to Netzach as a branch of Chochmah, sight.
Marei mekomos
- 1מלא כל הארץ כבודו · Isaiah 6:3
- 2ומלכותו בכל משלה · Psalms 103:19
- 3עוונותיכם מבדילים ביניכם · Isaiah 59:2
- 4ע״פ ועשית ציץ · תו״א פג, א.
- 5פנים בפנים · Deuteronomy 5:4
- 6כי פנו אלי עורף · Jeremiah 2:27
- 7כל ברך לך תכרע · תפלת נשמת.
- 8
- 9ותורת ה׳ להיות חפצו · Psalms 1:2
- 10שאין עוד מלבדו · Deuteronomy 4:35
- 11וכולא קמי׳ כלא חשיב · Zohar I, 11b
- 12והיינו בהיכל ההוד שהוא בחי׳ הודאה · ראה סה״מ תרס״ח ע׳ קנב. סה״מ תרפ״ד ע׳ רפא. סה״מ תש״ט ע׳ קט.
- 13שכורע . . לבר מגופא · ראה לקו״ש ח״ה ע׳ 212 הערה 45.
- 14ברבות וירא פנ״ו · ”ע״פ ונשתחוה ונשובה אליכם כו׳ הכל בזכות השתחואה כו׳ התורה לא ניתנה אלא בזכות השתחואה שנאמר והשתחויתם מרחק כו׳” — אוה״ת פ׳ תרומה ע׳ א׳תכו. נזכר גם לעיל ר״ה נח, א.
- 15סד״ה והיה ביום ההוא · לעיל ר״ה ס, א.
- 16
- 17וסד״ה והיה מידי חדש · לקמן ברכה צח, א.
- 18והיה מדי חדש ... להשתחוות לפני · Isaiah 66:23
- 19השתחואה דהיינו בהיכל הנצח · ראה בד״ה קול דודי תרס״ח ע׳ קנח שם מציין מ״ש דהשתחואה בנצח מוסיף ”ונראה בלקו״ת שם [— הכוונה לכאן] דהיינו השתחואה פנימית כו׳ וצ״ע. ואפשר זה מקושר עם מ״ש לפני זה דנצח ענף החכמה בחי׳ ראי׳” ע״ש.
- 20אינו דומה שמיעה לראיה · מכילתא יתרו יט, ט. פס״ז שלח יג, יח.
- 21ויברך אלקים את יום השביעי · Genesis 2:3
- 22ציון במשפט תפדה · Isaiah 1:27
- 23
- 24
6ויותר נראה עפמ״ש בד״ה מזמור שיר חנוכת הבית1 שיש ב׳ בחינות בהשתחואה דהיינו השתחוואה חיצוניות שמכניע את הגוף שלא ימרוד במלך בפועל ממש
And it seems more [correct to explain this] according to what is written in the discourse beginning “A psalm, a song of the dedication of the House”: that there are two levels in bowing down. That is, an outer bowing down, which subdues the body so that it will not rebel against the King in actual deed,
The Alter Rebbe offers a better explanation, from the discourse on “A psalm, a song of the dedication of the House”: bowing itself has two levels. Outer bowing subdues the body so that it does not rebel against the King in deed.
אבל עיקר רצון ופנימית הנפש אינה מבוטלת כו׳ משא״כ ההשתחואה בבחי׳ פנימיות הוא בחי׳ בטל רצונך מפני רצונו23 שאין לו רצון וחפץ אחר כלל:4
but the essence of the will and the inner dimension of the soul are not nullified, etc.; whereas bowing down on the level of the inner dimension is the level of “Nullify your will before His will,” so that he has no other will or desire at all.
But outer bowing leaves a person’s real will and inner soul untouched. Inner bowing fulfils the Mishnah’s “Nullify your will before His will”: one has no other will or desire at all.
The paragraph refines the previous distinction: rather than contrasting bending and bowing, it distinguishes an outer bowing that controls behaviour from an inner bowing that nullifies the will itself.
This refinement may resolve the Zohar’s placing of bowing in Netzach: the bowing of Netzach, rooted in sight, would be the inner bowing that transforms the will, while outer bowing only restrains the body.
Marei mekomos
- 1בד״ה מזמור שיר חנוכת הבית · לקמן צח, ב.
- 2בטל רצונך מפני רצונו · אבות ב, ד.
- 3בטל רצונך מפני רצונו · Pirkei Avot 2:4
- 4
From the days of awe to Sukkos ¶7
7ג וזהו ענין כל סדר עבודה שמר״ה ועד יוהכ״פ במלכיות זכרונות ושופרות ותפלות ותחנונים שמר״ה עד יוהכ״פ לעלות מבחינת כריעה לבחי׳ השתחואה
3. And this is the matter of the whole order of service from Rosh Hashanah until Yom Kippur, with Malchiyos, Zichronos and Shofaros, and the prayers and supplications from Rosh Hashanah until Yom Kippur: to rise from the level of bending the knee to the level of bowing down.
Section 3 applies the distinction to the ten days from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur. All their prayers, including the three sections of the Rosh Hashanah Musaf, aim to move us from kri’ah, mere acknowledgment, to hishtachavayah, the full bowing of the self.
ואזי מתגלה ביום הכפורים פנימיות רצונו ואהבתו ית׳ ויאיר פניו1 אלינו אל תוך פנימיות נקודת הלב כמ״ש לך אמר לבי בקשו פני2 את פניך ה׳ אבקש פניך דייקא
And then, on Yom Kippur, the inner dimension (pnimiyus) of His will and His love, may He be blessed, is revealed, and He makes His face shine toward us, into the innermost point of the heart; as it is written, “On Your behalf my heart said, ‘Seek My face’; Your face, G‑d, I will seek”: “Your face” specifically,
When we reach that inner bowing, G‑d’s inner will and love are revealed on Yom Kippur and shine into the innermost point of our heart. The verse “Your face I will seek” is read with emphasis: we seek G‑d’s “face,” His inner dimension, not only His outer, sustaining power.
שהוא בחי׳ פנימיות אהבתו ית׳ ורצונו ית׳ והיינו על ידי התשובה כי עיקר התשובה3 היא חרטה בלב
which is the level of the inner dimension of His love, may He be blessed, and of His will, may He be blessed. And this is through teshuvah (return), for the essence of teshuvah is regret in the heart,
G‑d’s “face” is the inner dimension of His love and will. It is revealed through teshuvah, whose essence is heartfelt regret.
that is, to uproot the will, so that he will no longer want at all to return to his folly. And through this the sitra achra (the other side) is subdued, and “the glory of G‑d is revealed”: “May G‑d make His face shine,”
True regret uproots the will to sin, so that one no longer wants to return to folly at all. When the will itself is changed, the sitra achra is subdued, and G‑d’s glory is revealed, as in the blessing “May G‑d make His face shine.”
כי רוצה6 ה׳ בעמו כמשל האדם שמוחל לחבירו אחר שמתחרט ומראה לו שאין לו רצון וחפץ עוד בדבר אשר זדה לו ועי״ז ירצה פניו וישוב וירחמהו.
for “G‑d desires His people”; as in the parable of a person who forgives his fellow after [the other] regrets and shows him that he no longer has any will or desire for the thing in which he wronged him; and through this he will win his favor, and he will again have compassion on him.
The human parable: a person forgives someone who has wronged him once he sees true regret and that the offender no longer wants what he did. Then he is reconciled and shows him compassion again.
וזהו כל האזרח בישראל ישבו בסוכות.7 פי׳ האזרח מה שזורח ומאיר בישראל בתוך פנימיות נקודת הלב
And this is “Every native (ezrach) in Israel shall dwell in sukkos.” Meaning: “the native” is that which shines (zore’ach) and gives light in Israel, within the innermost point of the heart.
The verse commanding every “native” (ezrach) to dwell in the sukkah is read through wordplay: ezrach is related to zore’ach, “shining.” It is the inner light that shines in the innermost point of a Jew’s heart.
(עמ״ש ע״פ ראה אנכי8 בפי׳ לאיתן האזרחי9 ובאגה״ק בסופו ע״פ וצדקה כנחל איתן)10 ישבו בסוכות זמן שמחתנו על ידי הארה והתגלות שנתגלה ביום הכפורים כנ״ל.
(See also what is written on the verse “See, I [set before you],” in the explanation of “Of Eisan the Ezrachite,” and in Iggeres HaKodesh, at its end, on the verse “And charity like a mighty (eisan) stream.”) “Shall dwell in sukkos,” “the time of our joy,” through the illumination and revelation that was revealed on Yom Kippur, as mentioned above.
The parenthesis refers to explanations elsewhere of “Eisan the Ezrachite” and of “a mighty (eisan) stream,” which also connect ezrach with an inner, enduring light. Dwelling in the sukkah in joy comes from the light revealed on Yom Kippur.
וזהו ענין סדר נטילת לולב והאתרוג. כי הנה ארז״ל (במדרש רבה פ׳ אמור פרשה שלשים)
And this is the matter of the order of taking the lulav and the esrog. For our Sages, of blessed memory, said (in Midrash Rabbah, Parshas Emor, chapter thirty):
The same theme is now found in the mitzvah of taking the lulav and esrog, beginning with the Midrash on the four species in Parshas Emor.
“‘The fruit of a beautiful tree (pri etz hadar)’: this is the Holy One, blessed be He, etc.” And they also said, “‘The fruit of a beautiful tree’: [a fruit] that dwells (hadar) in its tree, etc.”; for “man is a tree of the field.”
The Midrash reads “the fruit of a beautiful tree” as an allusion to G‑d, and the Sages also read hadar as “that dwells” in its tree: the esrog stays on its tree from year to year. The verse “man is a tree of the field” links the tree with man.
פי׳ האדם זה הקב״ה14 כמ״ש ועל דמות הכסא דמות כמראה אדם15 נמשל לעץ השדה והוא ענין עץ החיים כמ״ש במ״א (ועיין מזה בזהר אמור דצ״ו ע״ב ודצ״ז ע״א).
Meaning: “man” — this is the Holy One, blessed be He, as it is written, “And upon the likeness of the throne, a likeness like the appearance of a man”; He is likened to a tree of the field, and this is the matter of the Tree of Life, as is explained elsewhere. (And see on this in the Zohar, Emor, folio 96b and folio 97a.)
“Man” here refers to G‑d, as in Ezekiel’s vision of “the appearance of a man” upon the throne, the divine form as it relates to the world. That is the “tree of the field”: the Tree of Life. The text refers to the Zohar on Emor.
והדר באילנו. הוא בחינת פנימיות האילן16 שהוא ענין פנימיות האהבה שיש להוי׳ עלינו כמ״ש לבבתני אחותי כלה17 כו׳ שהאהבה הוא עד״מ בבחי׳ פנימית נקודת הלב ישראל בתוונא דלבא יתבי18 ונפלאה אהבתו להם
And “dwells in its tree”: this is the level of the inner dimension of the tree, which is the matter of the inner dimension of the love that Havayah has for us, as it is written, “You have captured my heart, my sister, [my] bride, etc.” For the love is, by way of analogy, on the level of the innermost point of the heart: “Israel dwell in the chamber of the heart,” and His love for them is wondrous.
The fruit “that dwells in its tree” represents the inner dimension of the tree: G‑d’s inner love for Israel, as in “You have captured my heart, my sister, my bride.” The Jewish people dwell, as it were, in the innermost chamber of G‑d’s heart.
(וזה הוא מ״ש במ״ח מסכת אורות ז״א פ״ג משנה ז׳ ובפנימיותו19 כו׳ ונת׳ מזה לעיל בשה״ש ע״פ ששים20 המה כו׳ אחת היא יונתי תמתי21 ע״ש ביאור דברי המ״ח הנ״ל ותמתי תאומתי2223 ע״ז מרמז ג״כ התיומת דלולב)
(And this is what is written in Mishnas Chassidim, Tractate Oros Z’eir Anpin, chapter 3, mishnah 7: “And in its inner dimension, etc.” This was explained above in Song of Songs, on the verse “There are sixty, etc.; one is my dove, my perfect one”; see there the explanation of the words of the Mishnas Chassidim cited above. And “my perfect one” (tamasi) [is read] “my twin” (teomasi): to this the twin leaf (tiyomes) of the lulav also alludes.)
The abbreviation מ״ח apparently refers to Mishnas Chassidim, a Kabbalistic work arranged as tractates and mishnayos; the Kehot note quotes it: within Z’eir Anpin there is a feminine configuration called Knesses Yisrael, equal to its Tiferes. The Song of Songs discourse explains this, and the Midrash reads tamasi, “my perfect one,” as teomasi, “my twin,” which the double central leaf of the lulav also alludes to.
והאתרוג מחברים אותו עם הלולב שהוא גבוה במינו דהיינו השרש המושרש למעלה העושה פרי למטה בישראל בחי׳ לו לב24 להיות לב
And the esrog is joined with the lulav, which is the tallest of its kind; that is, the root that is rooted above, which makes fruit below in Israel: the level of lo lev (“a heart for Him”), to be one heart
The esrog, the fruit, is joined to the lulav, the tallest of the species, which stands for the root above that bears fruit below in Israel. “Lulav” is read as lo lev, “a heart for Him”: a heart devoted to G‑d alone.
א׳ לו ית׳ לבד ולדבקה בו דהיניו לבחינת עצמותו ומהותו ית׳ בדביקה וחשיקה מעומקא דלבא לקרא אליו לבי כמ״ש צור לבבי25
for Him alone, may He be blessed, and to cleave to Him, that is, to the level of His very Essence and Being, may He be blessed, with cleaving and passionate desire from the depth of the heart, to call Him “my heart,” as it is written, “the Rock of my heart”:
This devotion reaches G‑d’s very Essence, not only His revealed attributes. The person calls G‑d “my heart,” as in the verse “the Rock of my heart.”
שהוא הוא כביכול פנימיות נקודת לבו ואין לו לב אחר אלא צור לבבי ומנענעים את הלולב לששה קצוות26 שהנענוע הוא ענין התעוררות
for He is, as it were, the innermost point of his heart, and he has no other heart but “the Rock of my heart.” And we wave the lulav to the six directions, for the waving is the matter of arousal
For such a person G‑d is the innermost point of his heart. The lulav is waved in six directions, and the waving means arousal.
(כמ״ש בספר עמק המלך שער שעשוע המלך27 ועמ״ש בפ׳ שלח ע״פ אני כו׳ דפ׳ ציצית28 בפי׳ ענין מארז״ל בשעה שישראל אומרים אמן יהא שמיה רבה מברך הקב״ה מנענע ראשו29 כו׳)
(as is written in the book Emek HaMelech, Sha’ar Sha’ashuei HaMelech; and see also what is written in Parshas Shelach on the verse “I [am Havayah your G‑d], etc.,” of the section of tzitzis, in the explanation of the matter of the saying of our Sages, of blessed memory, “When Israel say, ‘Amen, yehei shmei rabba mevarach,’ the Holy One, blessed be He, nods His head, etc.”)
The parenthesis cites Emek HaMelech, a Kabbalistic work, and a Likkutei Torah discourse on the verse at the end of the section of tzitzis that explains the Talmud’s image of G‑d “nodding His head” when Israel respond “Amen, yehei shmei rabba”: movement expresses arousal.
והוא לעורר בהליכה לבחי׳ פנימית הדעת שהוא שורש המדות וקיומן המתגלים בלב שהם נמשכי ם ממנה ובהובאה לחזה של אדם לפנימיות נקודת הלב של האדם בעצמו להיות לה האזרח בישראל שיהא זורח ומאיר בהתגלות לבו.
And [the waving] is to arouse, in the extending outward, the level of the inner dimension of Daas, which is the root and sustenance of the emotive attributes (middos) that are revealed in the heart, for they are drawn from it; and in the bringing back to a person’s chest, [to arouse] the innermost point of the heart of the person himself, so that it have “the native in Israel,” that it shine and give light in the revelation of his heart.
The two movements of the waving have two effects. Extending the lulav outward arouses the inner dimension of Daas above, the root of the emotions; bringing it back to the chest arouses the innermost point of the person’s own heart, so that the “native” inner light shines openly in him.
וזהו ענין המועדים לשמחה שיהא שמחה לפניו ית׳ בהתגלות אהבתו מהעלם אל הגילוי וכמ״ש וחגותם אותו חג לה׳ כנ״ל:30
And this is the matter of “festivals for joy”: that there be joy before Him, may He be blessed, in the revelation of His love from concealment to revelation; and as it is written, “And you shall celebrate it as a festival to G‑d,” as mentioned above.
This is why the festivals are “for joy”: G‑d’s hidden love is revealed, and that revelation is joy before Him. The paragraph returns to the opening verse, “celebrate it as a festival to G‑d.”
Section 3 shows how the service of the days of awe raises a person from acknowledgment to full self-nullification through teshuvah, so that on Yom Kippur G‑d’s inner love is revealed; Sukkos, the sukkah and the lulav with the esrog then bring that inner love into open revelation and joy.
The pairing of esrog and lulav mirrors the inner love from both sides: the esrog “dwelling in its tree” is G‑d’s inner love for Israel, and the lulav as lo lev is Israel’s heart given wholly to G‑d. The waving’s two movements then connect the Daas above with the point of the heart below.
Marei mekomos
- 1יאר ה׳ פניו · Numbers 6:25
- 2לך אמר לבי בקשו פני · Psalms 27:8
- 3כי עיקר התשובה · Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 29:13–14
- 4לשוב לכסלה · Psalms 85:9
- 5ונגלה כבוד ה׳ · Isaiah 40:5
- 6כי רוצה ה׳ בעמו · Psalms 149:4
- 7כל האזרח בישראל ישבו בסוכות · Leviticus 23:42
- 8ראה אנכי · Deuteronomy 11:26
- 9
- 10וצדקה כנחל איתן · Amos 5:24
- 11פרי עץ הדר זה הקב״ה · Vayikra Rabbah 30:9
- 12פרי עץ הדר הדר באילנו · Sukkah 31b:10–12
- 13כי האדם עץ השדה · Deuteronomy 20:19
- 14פי׳ האדם זה הקב״ה · ראה אוה״ת שמות כרך ז ע׳ ב׳תקלד.
- 15ועל דמות הכסא דמות כמראה אדם · Ezekiel 1:26
- 16והדר באילנו . . פנימית האילן · מובא באוה״ת בראשית כרך ג תקמו, ב.
- 17לבבתני אחותי כלה · Song of Songs 4:9
- 18בתוונא דלבא יתבי · Niddah 20b:8
- 19במ״ח מסכת אורות . . ובפנימיותו · ”ובפנימיותו יש לו פרצוף נוקבא אחת הנקראת כנסת ישראל והיא שוה לת״ת שלו כי היא גדולה כמוהו ממש” עכ״ל.
- 20ונת׳ מזה לעיל בשה״ש ע״פ ששים · הכוונה לקמן בשה״ש לט, ג ואילך. [מציון זה רואים שמתחילה סבר הצ״צ לסדר המאמרים באופן אחר, ואכמ״ל]. וראה לעיל עג, ד.
- 21אחת היא יונתי תמתי · Song of Songs 6:9
- 22ותמתי תאומתי · שהש״ר (פ״ה עה״פ אני ישנה). [כ].
- 23ותמתי תאומתי · Shir HaShirim Rabbah 5:3
- 24בחי׳ לו לב · נסמן לעיל נז, ד.
- 25צור לבבי · Psalms 73:26
- 26ומנענעים את הלולב לששה קצוות · רמ״א בשו״ע או״ח סתרנ״א, ס״ט. סידור אדה״ז קודם הלל. וראה שם רסד, ב ואילך. ראה לקמן פז, ב.
- 27שער שעשועי המלך · בפ״ב ופ״ג. [כ].
- 28ע״פ אני כו׳ דפ׳ ציצית · Numbers 15:41
- 29בשעה שישראל אומרים אמן יהא שמיה רבה מברך הקב״ה מנענע ראשו · Berakhot 3a:14
- 30
Shemini Atzeres: the crown of Torah ¶8–9
8ד אך ביום השמיני עצרת1 תהיה לכם2 כי יום השמיני הוא שמחת תורה. והתורה נקרא כתר כמאמר רז״ל כתר תורה34 וכן תרי״ג מצות דאורייתא וז׳ מצות דרנן עולים תר״ך.5
4. But “On the eighth day, there shall be an atzeres for you”: for the eighth day is Simchas Torah. And the Torah is called a crown (keser), as in the saying of our Sages, of blessed memory, “the crown of Torah.” And likewise, the 613 mitzvos of the Torah and the seven mitzvos of the Rabbis add up to 620 [the numerical value of keser].
Section 4 turns to Shemini Atzeres, which in the Diaspora includes Simchas Torah, the day of rejoicing with the Torah. The Torah is called a “crown” (keser), and the 613 Torah commandments plus the 7 Rabbinic ones make 620, the numerical value of keser (כתר).
וכן אמרו רז״ל דאשתמש בתגא חלף67 זה המשתמש במי ששונה הלכות8 שנקראת תגא דמלכא והיינו עד״מ כמו המלך שאוהב אחד מאד ובשביל אהבתו נטול כתרו מעל ראשו ונותן לאוהבו כך
And so too our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “One who makes use of the crown (taga) passes away”: this refers to one who makes use of someone who studies halachos, which is called “the crown of the King.” And this is, by way of analogy, like a king who loves someone very much, and because of his love he takes his crown off his head and gives it to the one he loves. So too,
The Sages speak of Torah scholarship as “the crown” and “the crown of the King.” The parable: out of great love a king takes the crown off his own head and gives it to the one he loves.
הנה באהבת ה׳ ובשמחתו ששמח נוטל כתרו כביכול מעל ראשו ונתן להם (ועמ״ש סד״ה יביאו לבוש מלכות9) והיינו כתר תורה דאורייתא מחכמה נפקת אבל שרשה היא למעלה מעלה ממדריגת חכמה עילאה.
in G‑d’s love, and in His joy with which He rejoices, He takes His crown, as it were, off His head and gave it to them (and see also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “Let them bring royal garments”). And this is the crown of Torah: the Torah comes forth from Chochmah, but its root is far, far higher than the level of the supernal Chochmah.
So too, in His love and joy, G‑d gives Israel His own crown, the Torah. The Torah as we have it “comes from Chochmah,” divine wisdom, but its root is far higher, in Keser, the level above wisdom.
וזהו וירם קרן10 כו׳ שנותן התרוממות גדולה עד אין קץ למעלה מעלה מבחי׳ גילוי אור פניו כו׳
And this is “And He has raised up a horn, etc.”: that He gives a great exaltation, without end, far, far above the level of the revelation of the light of His countenance, etc.
The verse “He has raised up a horn for His people” describes this gift: an exaltation beyond the revelation of G‑d’s “face” that came on Yom Kippur and Sukkos.
(שבחי׳ הארת פנים הוא הארה בעלמא הנמשך מבחי׳ זו דכרת תורה עמ״ש במ״א בביאור ע״פ אלה מסעי כו׳ ויכתוב משה.11 שבחי׳ אור פניו נקרא תיקון ואמת שנקרא חותמו של הקב״ה והחותם הוא בחי׳ עשיי׳ לגבי עצמיות שמו הגדול.24
(For the level of the shining of the countenance is a mere glimmer, drawn from this level of the crown of Torah. See what is written elsewhere in the explanation on the verse “These are the journeys, etc.,” [on] “And Moshe wrote”: that the level of the light of His countenance is called the tikkun “and truth,” which is called “the seal of the Holy One, blessed be He”; and the seal is the level of Asiyah (action) relative to the essence of His great Name.
The printed text reads דכרת, apparently a misprint for דכתר, “of the crown.” The parenthesis explains that the shining of G‑d’s face is only a glimmer of the crown of Torah: it is called “truth,” G‑d’s “seal,” and a seal is only an outer impression (like Asiyah, the level of action) compared with the essence of His Name.
ועד״ז שמיני עצרת הוא למעלה מבחי׳ החותם דהו״ר. וכמ״ש במ״א ע״פ צדקת פרזונו1213 כו׳ ועמ״ש בפ׳ וישב בד״ה בכ״ה בכסלו14 בחי׳ כובע ישועה15 להמשיך בחי׳ הדרת פנים.
And in this way, Shemini Atzeres is above the level of the seal of Hoshana Rabbah; as is written elsewhere on the verse “The righteous acts of His open cities, etc.” And see also what is written in Parshas Vayeishev, in the discourse beginning “On the twenty-fifth of Kislev,” [on] the level of “a helmet of salvation,” to draw down the level of “the splendor of the countenance.”
Hoshana Rabbah is the day when the judgment begun on Rosh Hashanah is sealed. Shemini Atzeres reaches above that “seal,” to the essence it only imprints; the parenthesis also refers to the discourse on “a helmet of salvation” as the source of “the splendor of the countenance.”
והיינו שבחי׳ כובע ישועה זהו מקור הדרת פנים ונק׳ עטרת תפארת שיבה16 כו׳ עטרת הוא בחי׳ כתר ועטרה) והיינו לפי שישראל עם קרובו.
That is, the level of “a helmet of salvation” is the source of the splendor of the countenance, and it is called “A crown of glory is old age, etc.”; a crown (ateres) is the level of keser and atarah.) And this is because Israel are “the people near to Him.”
The “helmet of salvation,” worn on the head, is identified with the “crown of glory” and so with Keser, the crown. The reason Israel receive such an exalted gift is that they are “the people near to Him,” as the same verse in Psalms ends.
וזהו עצרת תהיה לכם פי׳ עצרת כתרגומו כנישו שמתאסף ומתקבץ להיות לכם למשמרת לכל השנה קבלת מלכותו ית׳ בכתר תורה
And this is “there shall be an atzeres for you.” Meaning: atzeres, as its Targum [renders it], kenishu (gathering): that the acceptance of His kingship, may He be blessed, through the crown of Torah, is gathered and collected to be for you a keeping for the whole year.
The Targum renders atzeres as “gathering.” On Shemini Atzeres the acceptance of G‑d’s kingship through the crown of Torah is gathered and stored up, to be kept by us through the whole year.
And this is as it is written, “You shall surely set a king over yourself”: which is through the Torah and the mitzvos, for it is the King’s command.
This is the mitzvah to “set a king over yourself”: we crown G‑d as King by keeping the Torah and mitzvos, which are His commands. (The printed הומצות apparently reads והמצות, “and the mitzvos.”)
(וע׳ בזהר אמור דצ״ו סע״ב19 וע׳ לקמן ע״פ ביום השמיני שלח20 כו׳) ותהיה השמחה גדולה לאלהים יותר משמחת הנפש בדבקותה באלהים חיים עד שאין השמחה נקרא
(And see the Zohar, Emor, folio 96, end of side b; and see below, on the verse “On the eighth day he sent away, etc.”) And the joy for G‑d will be great, greater than the joy of the soul in its cleaving to the living G‑d, until the joy is called
The parenthesis refers to the Zohar and to a later discourse on the verse from the dedication of Solomon’s Temple. The joy of Shemini Atzeres, for G‑d, is greater than the soul’s own joy in cleaving to Him, and precisely for that reason it is inward.
אלא בשם גילה (ע׳ בזהר ס״פ פנחס דרנ״ט ע״ב) פי׳ שמחה היא מלשון התגלות החדוה וגילה הוא ענין שמחה אשר בקרבו.
only by the name gilah (see the Zohar, end of Parshas Pinchas, folio 259b). Meaning: simchah is from the term for the revealing of gladness, while gilah is the matter of the joy that is within him.
Two kinds of joy are distinguished: simchah is joy that shows outwardly, while gilah is joy held within. The joy of Shemini Atzeres is called gilah.
וכמ״ש בני ציון יגילו במלכם21 כי מפני אימת המלך נאסף השמחה בקרבו ולא תתראה החצוה (ועמ״ש ע״פ שוש אשיש כו׳ תגל נפשי22 כו׳ ועמ״ש סד״ה ויהי בשלח פרעה):2325
As it is written, “The children of Zion will exult (yagilu) in their King”: for out of the awe of the king the joy is gathered within him, and the gladness is not seen. (And see also what is written on the verse “I will greatly rejoice, etc.; my soul will exult, etc.”; and see also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And it was, when Pharaoh sent.”)
“The children of Zion will exult (yagilu) in their King”: before a king, awe keeps the joy inside, and the gladness does not show (the printed החצוה apparently reads החדוה, “the gladness”). The parenthesis refers to the discourse on “I will greatly rejoice” and to a Torah Ohr discourse on Beshalach.
Section 4 explains that Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah bring down the crown of Torah, which is higher than the revealed “face” of Sukkos, and that the acceptance of G‑d’s kingship is gathered and kept for the year, with a joy so deep that it is inward gilah rather than outward simchah.
The progression of the maamar is now clear: Rosh Hashanah is concealment, Yom Kippur and Sukkos are the revelation of the inner face, and Shemini Atzeres reaches Keser, the crown above the face. The same verse, “He has raised up a horn for His people ... the people near to Him,” supplies both the exaltation and its reason.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2
- 3כתר תורה · אבות ד, יג. וראה בתו״א סט, ב בפי׳ כתר תורה.
- 4כתר תורה · Pirkei Avot 4:13
- 5תרי״ג . . וז׳ דרבנן . . תר״ך · פרדס ש״ח, פ״ג.
- 6דאשתמש בתגא חלף · אבות א, יג.
- 7דאשתמש בתגא חלף · Pirkei Avot 1:13
- 8זה המשתמש במי ששונה הלכות · Megillah 28b:14–15
- 9
- 10וירם קרן · Psalms 148:14
- 11ויכתוב משה · Numbers 33:2
- 12וכמ״ש במ״א ע״פ צדקת פרזונו · סה״מ תקס״ה ח״ב ע׳ תתקפט.
- 13
- 14בד״ה בכ״ה בכסלו · תו״א כט, ד.
- 15כובע ישועה · Isaiah 59:17
- 16עטרת תפארת שיבה · Proverbs 16:31
- 17וזהו עצרת תהי׳ לכם . . כמ״ש שום תשים עליך מלך · מובא משיחת ליל שמח״ת תשל״ד הערה 11.
- 18שום תשים עליך מלך · Deuteronomy 17:15
- 19וע׳ בזהר אמור דצ״ו סע״ב · Zohar, Emor 31:147–32:155
- 20ביום השמיני שלח · I Kings 8:66
- 21בני ציון יגילו במלכם · Psalms 149:2
- 22שוש אשיש כו׳ תגל נפשי · Isaiah 61:10
- 23ויהי בשלח פרעה · Exodus 13:17
- 24ואמת שנק׳ חותמו של הקב״ה · Shabbat 55a:12–13
- 25סד״ה ויהי בשלח · תו״א סא, ד.
9וזהו וכל הלבבות ייראוך1 וכל קרב וכליות יזמרו לשמך מחמת שהלבבות ייראוך ומקבלים עול מלכותך עליהם אין שמחה וזמר רק בקרבו וכליות לבד (ועמ״ש מזה בפ׳ ואתחנן ע״פ וידעת היום)2
And this is “And all hearts shall fear You, and all innards and kidneys shall sing to Your Name”: because the hearts fear You and accept Your kingship upon themselves, there is joy and song only in the innards and kidneys. (See also what is written on this in Parshas Va’eschanan, on the verse “And you shall know this day.”)
The Nishmas prayer says the hearts will fear G‑d while the innards and kidneys sing. Because the heart is filled with awe of the King, the joy and song are hidden deep inside, in the “innards and kidneys,” not openly expressed.
וזהו עצרת שנקלטת ומסתתרת השמחה וגילה בתוך בחי׳ אימת עול מלכות שמים שמקבל עליו כל השנה לקיום תר״ך מצות המלך באהבה וברצון
And this is atzeres: that the joy and gilah are absorbed and hidden within the level of the awe of the yoke of the kingdom of Heaven, which one accepts upon oneself for the whole year, to fulfill the 620 commandments of the King with love and good will.
That is atzeres, “holding in”: the joy is absorbed within the awe of accepting G‑d’s kingship, the yoke one takes on for the whole year, to keep all 620 commandments with love and willingness.
(והמשכת היראה מבחי׳ כתר תורה יובן עוד ממ״ש בפ׳ מקץ בביאור ע״פ כי אתה נרי.3 וגבי שבועות בד״ה וידבר אלקים4 כו׳. וממ״ש בד״ה תקעו בחדש5 בפי׳ כי עמך הסליחה למען תורא.6
(And the drawing down of awe from the level of the crown of Torah will be understood further from what is written in Parshas Mikeitz, in the explanation of the verse “For You are my lamp,” and regarding Shavuos, in the discourse beginning “And G‑d spoke, etc.,” and from what is written in the discourse beginning “Blow the shofar on the new moon,” in the explanation of “For with You is forgiveness, so that You may be feared.”
The parenthesis explains how awe, not only joy, flows from the crown of Torah, pointing to discourses on “For You are my lamp,” on the Giving of the Torah, and on “with You is forgiveness, so that You may be feared,” where forgiveness itself leads to awe.
והנה צ״ל דלעיל ע״פ שוש אשיש נתבאר דבחי׳ גילה תגל נפשי זהו בחינת ראש השנה. אך המעיין בזהר) (פ׳ פנחס דרי״ד ע״ב)7 יבין הענין
Now, it must be explained: above, on the verse “I will greatly rejoice,” it was explained that the level of gilah, “my soul will exult,” is the level of Rosh Hashanah. But one who studies the Zohar) (Parshas Pinchas, folio 214b) will understand the matter:
A difficulty: the earlier discourse on “I will greatly rejoice” identified gilah, inward joy, with Rosh Hashanah, while here it is identified with Shemini Atzeres. The Zohar resolves it.
כי לפי דבעשי״ת הוא בחינת שמאלו תחת לראשי8 מזה נמשך חרדה ויראה להיות גילו ברעדה9 ובסוכות לפי שהוא בחינת ימינו תחבקני ע״כ הוא בחי׳ שוש אשיש10 ושמחה
for since the Ten Days of Teshuvah are the level of “His left hand is under my head,” from this there is drawn trembling and awe, so that it is “exult with trembling”; and Sukkos, since it is the level of “and His right hand embraces me,” is therefore the level of “I will greatly rejoice” and simchah.
During the Ten Days of Teshuvah G‑d’s “left hand,” severity, is under our head, so the inner joy is mixed with trembling: “exult with trembling.” On Sukkos His “right hand,” kindness, embraces us, so the joy is revealed simchah.
אמנם שמיני עצרת דהא כדין זיווגא דגופא הוא בחי׳ תפארת וכולל חו״ג שהן תרין דרועין וכמ״ש בזהר תרומה (קע״ה ב׳)
On Shemini Atzeres comes a deeper union, at the level of Tiferes, “the body,” which includes both arms, Chesed and Gevurah.
דאחיד להאי ואחיד להאי וע״כ מצד היותו כולל ב׳ הבחי׳ יחד השמחה היא בחי׳ גילה כו׳ כענין וכל הלבבות ייראוך וכל קרב וכליות יזמרו לשמך וכנ״ל
that it “holds on to this one and holds on to that one.” And therefore, because it includes the two levels together, the joy is the level of gilah, etc., like “And all hearts shall fear You, and all innards and kidneys shall sing to Your Name,” as mentioned above.
Because Tiferes holds both sides together, the joy of Shemini Atzeres is gilah that includes awe: the heart fears while the innermost self sings. So gilah on Rosh Hashanah comes from awe alone, while on Shemini Atzeres it includes both awe and love.
(ועיין בזהר ח״א ס״ד ב׳11 מענין ביום השע״צ ודף ר״ח ב׳ ובסוף ח״א סס״י כ״ד וכ״ה. ח״ב קל״ה א׳ ח״ג צ״ו ב׳ ק״ד ב׳ רנ״ט ב׳ וד׳ רי״ד ע״ב):12
(And see the Zohar, Part I, 64b, on the matter of “On the day of Shemini Atzeres,” and folio 208b; and at the end of Part I, sections 24 and 25; Part II, 135a; Part III, 96b, 104b, 259b, and folio 214b.)
The Alter Rebbe lists further places in the Zohar that discuss Shemini Atzeres and these themes.
The paragraph defines the joy of Shemini Atzeres as inward gilah held within the awe of G‑d’s kingship, and reconciles this with the link of gilah to Rosh Hashanah: Shemini Atzeres, as Tiferes, unites the awe of the left with the love of the right.
The three stages follow the Song of Songs verse: the left hand under the head (Rosh Hashanah and the Ten Days), the right hand’s embrace (Sukkos), and the full union of the “body,” Tiferes (Shemini Atzeres), which includes both.
Marei mekomos
- 1וכל הלבבות ייראוך · תפלת נשמת.
- 2וידעת היום · Deuteronomy 4:39
- 3כי אתה נרי · II Samuel 22:29
- 4וידבר אלקים · Exodus 20:1
- 5תקעו בחדש · Psalms 81:4
- 6כי עמך הסליחה למען תורא · Psalms 130:4
- 7(פ׳ פנחס דרי״ד ע״ב) · Zohar, Pinchas 7:26–9:34
- 8שמאלו תחת לראשי · Song of Songs 2:6
- 9גילו ברעדה · Psalms 2:11
- 10שוש אשיש · Isaiah 61:10
- 11ועיין בזהר ח״א ס״ד ב׳ · Zohar, Noach 14:110–15:121
- 12
Abridgment ¶10–16
10קיצור ע״פ ביום השמע״צ כו׳ ובכל המועדים
An abridgment on [the verse] “On the eighth day, an atzeres, etc.,” [beginning] “And regarding all the festivals.”
Here begins a kitzur, an abridgment of this discourse, giving its main points in brief, with some additions.
A heading introducing the abridgment of the maamar.
(1) The explanation of “A wise son makes a father rejoice”: when the son understands that the hiding in which his father hides himself from him is only so that he will search for him.
Point (1) of the abridgment restates the parable: the wise son understands that his father hides only so that the son will search for him.
וזהו בכסא ר״ה2 יום הדין והוא ענין הנסירה בר״ה3 שהוא הסתלקות פנימיות המוחין4 מהמדות. אבל כוונת ההתכסות בשביל ליום חגנו הוא הגילוי בחג הסוכות
And this is “in the concealment”: Rosh Hashanah, the day of judgment. And this is the matter of the nesirah (sawing apart) on Rosh Hashanah, which is the withdrawal of the inner dimension of the intellect (mochin) from the emotive attributes (middos). But the purpose of the covering, “for the day of our festival,” is the revelation on the festival of Sukkos,
The abridgment adds the Kabbalistic term nesirah, the “sawing apart” on Rosh Hashanah, when the inner intellect (mochin) withdraws from the emotive attributes (middos) of Z’eir Anpin. That withdrawal is the concealment, and its purpose is the revelation of Sukkos.
והיינו ע״י שמחפשים ומבקשים פניו בעשי״ת וזהו ישמח אב שמביאים שמחה בהקב״ה כמ״ש חג לה׳.5
that is, through searching for and seeking His face during the Ten Days of Teshuvah. And this is “makes a father rejoice”: that [we] bring joy to the Holy One, blessed be He, as it is written, “a festival to G‑d.”
The revelation comes through our seeking G‑d’s face in the Ten Days of Teshuvah, and that is the joy we bring to the “Father,” a “festival to G‑d.”
ועל דרך זה נאמר וחכיתי לה׳ המסתיר פניו6 מבית יעקב:(ב) והגורם ההסתר הוא בחינת עוונותיכם מבדילים7 שלגבי בחי׳ הגילוי מפנימיות זהו מסך מבדיל וכעין משארז״ל בענין אור שנברא8 ביום ראשון וכיון שנסתכל במעשה כו׳
And in this way it is said, “And I will wait for G‑d, who hides His face from the house of Yaakov.” (2) And what causes the hiding is the level of “your iniquities separate”: relative to the level of revelation from the inner dimension, this is a separating screen. It is something like what our Sages, of blessed memory, said regarding the light that was created on the first day: since He looked at the deeds, etc.,
Isaiah’s “I will wait for G‑d, who hides His face” expresses the same waiting and seeking. Point (2): sin is a screen that blocks only the revelation of the inner dimension, like the primordial light of the first day, which G‑d hid when He saw that the wicked would misuse it.
עמד וגנזו מהן ומעין זה יובן בגילוי פנימיות. שצ״ל ע״ד פנים בפנים9 דבר שגם באדם יש חיצוניות ופנימיות.
He arose and hid it away from them. And something similar will be understood regarding the revelation of the inner dimension. For it must be in the manner of “Face to face He spoke”: that in a person, too, there are an outer dimension and an inner dimension.
As that light was hidden, not destroyed, so too the inner light is hidden because of sin. “Face to face” teaches that man too has an inner and outer dimension, and G‑d’s inner dimension answers man’s.
The abridgment restates the first two sections: the concealment of Rosh Hashanah (the nesirah) exists for the sake of the revelation and joy of Sukkos, and sin hides only G‑d’s inner light, as the primordial light was hidden away.
Nesirah, “sawing,” is the Arizal’s term for the separation on Rosh Hashanah of Malchus from Z’eir Anpin so that she can be rebuilt face to face; the abridgment describes it here as the withdrawal of the inner mochin, the concealment the maamar speaks of.
Marei mekomos
- 1בן חכם ישמח אב · Proverbs 10:1
- 2בכסא ר״ה · Psalms 81:4
- 3והוא ענין הנסירה בר״ה · וע׳ בסש״ב באגה״ק סי׳ יד). וש״נ. [כ].
- 4הסתלקות פנימיות המוחין · ראה אוה״ת נ״ך כרך ב ע׳ תתקכג. אוה״ת למג״א ע׳ ב׳שא.
- 5חג לה׳ · Leviticus 23:41
- 6וחכיתי לה׳ המסתיר פניו · Isaiah 8:17
- 7עוונותיכם מבדילים · Isaiah 59:2
- 8משארז״ל בענין אור שנברא · Chagigah 12a:5–6
- 9פנים בפנים · Deuteronomy 5:4
That is, even in “doing good.” And this is the difference between the level of “And every knee shall bend to You,” which is only the level of acknowledgment (hodaah),
The abridgment continues: the outer and inner levels apply even to doing good. Bending the knee is only acknowledgment.
וכורע על ברכיו שהן לבר מגופא. ובין וכל קומה לפניך תשתחוה. שכופף קומתו וראשו ששם מקור הדעת.
and he bends on his knees, which are “outside the body”; and “And every stature shall bow down before You,” in which he bends his stature and his head, where the source of Daas is.
In bending, only the knees, “outside the body,” are bent; in bowing, the stature and the head, the seat of Daas, are bent, so that the whole self submits.
ועד״ז ארז״ל שאין השכינה שורה אלא על בעלי קומה2 המכוון שיהיה בו בגילוי כל ע״ס שבנפש בבחינת וכל קומה לפניך תשתחוה:(ג) וזהו סדר העבודה שמראש השנה עד יום הכפורים לעלות מבחינת כריעה לבחינת השתחואה.
And in this way our Sages, of blessed memory, said that the Shechinah (Divine Presence) rests only on people of stature: the intent is that all ten Sefiros of the soul be revealed in him, on the level of “And every stature shall bow down before You.” (3) And this is the order of service from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur: to rise from the level of bending the knee to the level of bowing down.
The Sages’ teaching that the Shechinah rests only on people of “stature” is read spiritually: a person in whom all ten powers of the soul are revealed and all of them bow to G‑d. Point (3) restates that the days from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur raise us from bending to bowing.
וזהו ענין השתחוואות שבסדר עבודה במוסף דיום הכפורים ועי״ז נמשך יאר ה׳ פניו אליך.3 לפני הוי״ה תטהרו4 פנימיות שם הוי׳.
And this is the matter of the prostrations in the order of the [Temple] service in the Musaf of Yom Kippur; and through this there is drawn down “May G‑d make His face shine upon you.” “Before Havayah you shall be purified”: the inner dimension of the Name Havayah.
The abridgment adds that this is why the High Priest’s service in the Yom Kippur Musaf includes full prostrations. Through them the shining of G‑d’s face is drawn down, and the verse “before Havayah you shall be purified” refers to the inner dimension of the Name Havayah.
The abridgment restates the difference between bending the knee and bowing, and adds that the prostrations of Yom Kippur express the ascent to full bowing that draws down the inner dimension of the Name Havayah.
“Before Havayah” is read as reaching the inner dimension of the Name itself, matching the maamar’s claim that on Yom Kippur G‑d’s inner will is revealed.
Marei mekomos
- 1וכל ברך לך תכרע · Isaiah 45:23
- 2שאין השכינה שורה אלא על בעלי קומה · Shabbat 92a:8
- 3יאר ה׳ פניו אליך · Numbers 6:25
- 4לפני הוי״ה תטהרו · Leviticus 16:30
And this is “And you shall take for yourselves on the first day the fruit of a beautiful tree”: this is the Holy One, blessed be He, etc.; and also “a beautiful tree” is the level of “man is a tree of the field.”
The abridgment restates the four species: the “fruit of a beautiful tree” alludes to G‑d, and the tree is the “man” who is a “tree of the field,” the Tree of Life.
ופרי עץ הוא מקור נשמות הצדיקים שהוא בחינת הדר באילנו והלולב לו לב בחינת צור לבבי וחלקי אלקים לעולם3 וגם זאת קומתך דמתה לתמר4 בחינת וכל קומה לפניך תשתחוה.
And the fruit of the tree is the source of the souls of the tzaddikim, which is the level of “dwelling in its tree.” And the lulav: lo lev (“a heart for Him”), the level of “the Rock of my heart and my portion is G‑d forever.” And also “This, your stature, is like a palm tree” is the level of “And every stature shall bow down before You.”
It adds that the fruit “dwelling in its tree” is the source of the souls of the tzaddikim. The lulav is “a heart for Him,” and its tall, upright form, like the palm in “your stature is like a palm tree,” stands for the whole stature that bows to G‑d.
ושמחתם לפני5 ה׳ השמחה ע״י גילוי המוחין חב״ד כו׳ כי בן חכם ישמח אב6 שגם מוחין דאבא באים בגילוי כו׳. וזהו ושמחתם כמו בהשכיל שכל חדש מתמלא תענוג ושמחה:7
“And you shall rejoice before G‑d”: the joy through the revelation of the intellect (mochin), Chochmah, Binah and Daas, etc., for “A wise son makes a father rejoice”: that the mochin of Abba also come into revelation, etc. And this is “And you shall rejoice,” as when one grasps a new idea he is filled with delight and joy.
The joy of Sukkos comes from the revelation of the mochin, Chochmah, Binah and Daas. “A wise son makes a father (Abba, Chochmah) rejoice” means that even the mochin of Abba are revealed, and a new insight always fills a person with delight and joy.
The abridgment restates the meaning of the four species and adds that the joy of Sukkos is the joy of revealed mochin, even of Abba, like the delight of a new insight.
This addition links the opening parable to the Kabbalistic structure: the “father” who rejoices is Abba, Chochmah, and the joy of Sukkos is the revelation of Chochmah itself.
Marei mekomos
- 1פרי עץ הדר זה הקב״ה · Vayikra Rabbah 30:9
- 2האדם עץ השדה · Deuteronomy 20:19
- 3צור לבבי וחלקי אלקים לעולם · Psalms 73:26
- 4זאת קומתך דמתה לתמר · Song of Songs 7:8
- 5ושמחתם לפני ה׳ · Leviticus 23:40
- 6בן חכם ישמח אב · Proverbs 10:1
- 7לפני ה׳ תטהרו · Leviticus 16:30
(4) But “On the eighth day, an atzeres,” which is Simchas Torah: that is, the level of the crown of Torah, which is above the intellect (mochin), shines,
Point (4): on Shemini Atzeres, Simchas Torah, the crown of Torah shines, a level above the intellect (mochin) revealed on Sukkos.
כמו גלגלתא דחפיא על מוחא ע״י שהוא מבחינה שלמעלה מהשכל המושג. עמ״ש בביאור ע״פ אני ה׳ אלקיכם דפרשת ציצית.2
like the skull (gulgalta) that covers the brain, since it is from a level that is above graspable intellect. See what is written in the explanation on the verse “I am Havayah your G‑d,” of the section of tzitzis.
The crown is compared to the skull (gulgalta) that surrounds the brain: it is above graspable intellect and encloses it from above. The Alter Rebbe refers to the discourse on the last verse of the section of tzitzis.
The abridgment restates that Shemini Atzeres reveals the crown of Torah, which is above intellect as the skull encloses the brain.
Gulgalta, the “skull,” is the Kabbalistic name for the outer aspect of Keser (Arich Anpin) that encompasses the intellect, a precise image for a level above understanding that still surrounds and governs it.
Marei mekomos
- 1ביום השמיני עצרת · Numbers 29:35
- 2אני ה׳ אלקיכם דפרשת ציצית · Numbers 15:41
15וזהו וירם קרן.1 ואזי עצרת תהיה לכם כניסת ואסיפת המוחין תחת גלגלתא וכתר החופף עליהם בבחי׳ בטל רצונך23 לגמרי.
And this is “And He has raised up a horn.” And then, “there shall be an atzeres for you”: the entering and gathering of the mochin under the skull (gulgalta) and the crown that hovers over them, on the level of “Nullify your will” completely.
This is the exaltation of “He has raised up a horn.” Atzeres, “gathering,” is read as the gathering of the mochin under the skull, the crown that hovers over them, in complete nullification of one’s own will.
And see also what is written in the discourse beginning “You shall keep My Shabbosos,” on the matter of keser as in the term “Wait (kaser) for me a little”; and what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And [G‑d] spoke, etc., in the wilderness of Sinai,”
Two discourses are cited: one explains keser, crown, through the Aramaic kaser, “wait,” as in “wait for me a little,” and the other, at the beginning of Bamidbar, speaks of the census.
בענין שאו את ראש כו׳ לגלגלתם7 מבן עשרים שנה8 כו׳ ע״ש ופי׳ עצרת שנקלטת ומסתתרת השמחה בתוך בחי׳ אימת עול מלכות שמים עד שאין השמחה נקרא
on the matter of “Lift up the head, etc.,” “by their skulls, from twenty years old, etc.”; see there. And the meaning of atzeres is that the joy is absorbed and hidden within the level of the awe of the yoke of the kingdom of Heaven, until the joy is called
The census counted people “by their skulls” (legulgelosam), which that discourse reads as the gulgalta, the crown, and G‑d’s will above understanding. The abridgment then restates that atzeres means the joy is absorbed and hidden within the awe of accepting G‑d’s kingship.
אלא בשם גילה ע״ד וכל הלבבות ייראוך וכל קרב וכליות יזמרו ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה וידעת היום והשבות.9
only by the name gilah, in the manner of “And all hearts shall fear You, and all innards and kidneys shall sing”; and see also what is written on this in the discourse beginning “And you shall know this day and take to [your heart].”
So the joy of Shemini Atzeres is called gilah, inward joy: the heart fears while the innermost self sings. The discourse on “And you shall know this day” is cited again.
The abridgment restates that atzeres is the gathering of the intellect under the crown in complete nullification of self, and that its joy is inward gilah hidden within awe.
The passage from the Bamidbar discourse given in the Kehot note connects legulgelosam with “Nullify your will” and the gulgalta, the supernal will that is not grasped at all even by Chochmah, which is exactly the level Shemini Atzeres reaches here.
Marei mekomos
- 1וירם קרן · Psalms 148:14
- 2בטל רצונך · אבות ב, ד.
- 3בטל רצונך · Pirkei Avot 2:4
- 4כתר לי זעיר · Job 36:2
- 5סד״ה וידבר כו׳ במדבר סיני · לעיל פ׳ במדבר ב, א.
- 6וידבר כו׳ במדבר סיני · Numbers 1:1
- 7שאו את ראש כו׳ לגלגלתם · Numbers 1:2
- 8מבן עשרים שנה · Numbers 1:3
- 9וידעת היום והשבות · Deuteronomy 4:39
And it can be explained that from Rosh Hashanah until Shemini Atzeres there are three crowns. That is: on Rosh Hashanah, “Say before Me [verses of] kingship (Malchiyos)”: this is the drawing down of the crown of kingship.
A new suggestion: the season from Rosh Hashanah to Shemini Atzeres corresponds to the three crowns of the Mishnah. On Rosh Hashanah G‑d says, “Say before Me verses of kingship,” so Rosh Hashanah draws down the crown of kingship.
וביוהכ״פ כתר כהונה שנכנס הכה״ג לפני ולפנים3 וממשיך להיות וכל קומה לפניך תששחוה. ועליות הנשמות ע״ד בהעלותך את הנרות4 אל מול פני כו׳
And on Yom Kippur, the crown of priesthood, for the High Priest enters the innermost sanctum and draws down [the level of] “And every stature shall bow down before You.” And the ascents of the souls, in the manner of “When you raise up the lamps, toward the face of [the menorah], etc.”;
Yom Kippur is the crown of priesthood: the High Priest enters the Holy of Holies and draws down the full bowing of “every stature.” The souls then ascend, like the lamps of the menorah that the priest raises.
ואח״כ כתר תורה בשמע״צ הוא ההמשכה מלמעלה למטה. וגדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה5 בחינת כתר שם טוב.
and afterward the crown of Torah, on Shemini Atzeres, is the drawing down from above to below. And “Study is great, for it leads to action”: the level of the crown of a good name.
Shemini Atzeres is the crown of Torah, which draws down from above to below. Because “study is great, for it leads to action,” Torah that leads to deeds brings the fourth crown, “the crown of a good name.”
And one may note, regarding the matter of “There are three crowns, etc.,” and the crown of a good name, something similar to what was explained in the discourse beginning “Who can count, etc.,” regarding the explanation of “the fourth part of Israel.”
The Mishnah says there are three crowns, while the crown of a good name rises above them all. The Alter Rebbe notes a parallel in a discourse on “Who can count ... the fourth part of Israel,” where a fourth element likewise stands above three.
The abridgment closes by mapping the festival season onto the crowns of the Mishnah: kingship on Rosh Hashanah, priesthood on Yom Kippur, Torah on Shemini Atzeres, and the crown of a good name that comes through Torah leading to action.
The first two crowns describe ascents (accepting kingship, the souls rising like the lamps), while the crown of Torah on Shemini Atzeres is a drawing down from above to below, into action.
Marei mekomos
- 1בר״ה אמרו לפני מלכיות · טז, א.
- 2בר״ה אמרו לפני מלכיות · Rosh Hashanah 16a:15
- 3שנכנס הכה״ג לפני ולפנים · ראה לקו״ש ח״ד ע׳ 1216.
- 4בהעלותך את הנרות · Numbers 8:2
- 5וגדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה · Kiddushin 40b:8–9
- 6שלשה כתרים הן · Pirkei Avot 4:13
- 7מי מנה · Numbers 23:10
- 8כתר מל׳ . . כהונה . . תורה . . שם טוב · ראה אבות ד, יג.
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
Seek G‑d’s “face” during the days of awe through teshuvah that uproots the will to sin, not only by acknowledging Him but by bowing one’s whole self and will; then carry the acceptance of His kingship, gathered on Shemini Atzeres through the Torah, into the whole year, keeping the commandments with love and willingness and with a joy held within awe.
Questions for discussion
- How does the parable of the father who hides from his wise son change the way one might experience the solemnity of Rosh Hashanah?
- Why can sin hide G‑d’s inner dimension but not the outer life-force that keeps every creature in existence?
- What is the difference between acknowledging that “there is nothing besides Him” and bowing one’s whole will to Him, and where do you see each in your own prayer?
- Why is the joy of Shemini Atzeres, which is higher than that of Sukkos, described as inward gilah rather than open simchah?
- How does reading atzeres as “gathering” for the whole year shape the way one leaves the festival season?
Key terms in this maamar
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- The outer dimension (chitzoniyus)חיצוניות
- The external, expressive aspect. ×7
- The inner dimension (pnimiyus)פנימיות
- The innermost core of a level. ×19
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- Kingship: the level through which G‑d's word creates and rules the worlds. ×5
- Willרצון
- Desire; in G‑d, the level above intellect. ×10
- The sitra achra (the other side)סטרא אחרא
- The realm opposed to holiness.
- The G‑dly soulנפש האלקית
- The soul that is 'a part of G‑d above'.
- Hod (splendor)הוד
- Acknowledgment and yielding. ×3
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Deep connection to an idea, bridging intellect and emotion. ×4
- Netzach (victory)נצח
- Perseverance, the drive to overcome. ×4
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×3
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Setting aside one's own sense of self before G‑d. ×2
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×1
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning to G‑d; not only repentance. ×3
- Z'eir Anpin (the emotive attributes)ז״א
- The six emotive Sefiros as one configuration.
- The emotive attributes (middos)מדות
- Love, awe, compassion and the rest. ×2
- Keser (the Crown)כתר
- The level above intellect: divine will and delight. ×15
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest world, including our physical one.
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving.
- Tiferes (beauty)תפארת
- Harmony of kindness and restraint; associated with compassion. ×2
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- Measure, limitation and judgment.
- The intellect (mochin)מוחין
- Chochmah, Binah and Daas as a whole. ×5
- The Shechinah (Divine Presence)שכינה
- G‑d's presence as it dwells in the world. ×1
- The Sefirosספירות
- The ten divine attributes through which G‑d relates to creation.
- Delightתענוג
- Pleasure; the inner root of will. ×1
- The Name Elokimאלקים
- G‑d as concealed within nature, measuring and limiting. ×5