Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shemini Atzeres · Maamar 7
טוב לחסות בה׳ וגו׳
It Is Better to Take Refuge in G‑d
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
Holding on to G‑d’s Torah and light requires first being “betrothed” and set apart by the mitzvos, and the deepest refuge is in G‑d Himself, beyond even the Torah. In the same way, the lower, more distant revelation of exile and of the Diaspora’s second day of Yom Tov carries a thirst and a joy that the higher revelation does not.
The maamar in brief
The maamar begins with the festival prayer: we ask to be sanctified by the mitzvos before we ask for our share in the Torah. Atzeres means “retaining”; a Jew can retain Torah and prayer only after G‑d’s betrothal gift, the mitzvos, has set him apart. That betrothal comes from sovev, the light beyond time, and contemplating it breaks the heart and “crumbles” evil, which has no real substance. The opening verse is then explained: “man” is the Torah and “nobles” are the Patriarchs, yet taking refuge in G‑d, through self-sacrifice in the Shema, is higher still. The second part asks why the Diaspora keeps a second day of Yom Tov. G‑d’s gaze comes “through the windows” in Temple times and “through the lattices” in exile; like Esther’s second feast for all the people, the lower revelation brings greater joy and a thirsting love. Finally, the two days correspond to the two lenses of prophecy and to the letter hei and its “filling”: the Land of Israel receives in one day what the Diaspora receives in two, yet revelation below is the purpose.
Outline
- Betrothal before Torah“Sanctify us with Your mitzvos” precedes “our share in Your Torah”: the mitzvos are a betrothal from sovev that sets a Jew apart so he can “retain” Torah and prayer.¶1–2
- The broken heart that crumbles evilSeeing that all worldly things pass with time gives a broken heart; evil is crumbled like smoke, and only then can one “hearken” (PaZeR KaSheV).¶3–6
- Refuge above the Torah and the Patriarchs“Man” is the Torah and “nobles” are the Patriarchs; taking refuge in G‑d, the encompassing light reached by self-sacrifice in the Shema, is higher and can revive the heart.¶7
- Seeing the King: windows and latticesEvery festival reveals the King, and seeing arouses love; in Temple times G‑d watched “through the windows,” in exile He peers “through the lattices.”¶8–10
- Windows and lattices in KabbalahFrom Etz Chaim: windows are channels within Atzilus, lattices are Malchus breaking the screen into Beriah; they are the higher and lower unity, the merit of the Patriarchs and of the Matriarchs.¶11–16
- Breaking the screen through teshuvah and joyTeshuvah with a broken heart breaks the screen of the sitra achra (the lattices); the joy that follows opens the windows.¶17–18
- The second feast: the second day of Yom TovLike Esther’s second feast for all the people, the second day brings the revelation to all Jews in exile, with greater joy and the thirsting love of the penitent.¶19
- Two lenses: Torah and prayerThe first day draws from the shining lens (Torah, revelation from above), the second from the non-shining lens, the mirror of prayer and teshuvah.¶20–22
- The letter hei and the Land of IsraelThe two days match the two hei’s of the Name, or the hei and its “filling”; the Land of Israel, near the source, receives in one day what the Diaspora needs two for, yet the revelation below is the purpose.¶23–29
Key concepts
- Atzeres (retention)עצרת / קליטה
- Holding the Torah and prayer within oneself, as a womb retains seed; possible only after being “betrothed” through the mitzvos.
- Kiddushin (betrothal)קדושין
- Being set apart for G‑d. The mitzvos are His betrothal gift, drawn from the encompassing light.
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- The level beyond time and change, symbolized by the ring of betrothal and by the chuppah that covers.
- Windows and latticesחלונות וחרכים
- Two modes of G‑d’s gaze: open revelation without a screen, and a glimpse through a hole broken in the screen.
- The higher and lower unityיחודא עילאה ויחודא תתאה
- Creation as nothing before G‑d, and creation existing yet nullified to Him; matched to the windows and the lattices.
- The shining and non-shining lensאספקלריא המאירה ושאינה מאירה
- Moshe’s clear vision and the other prophets’ reflected vision; in every Jew, Torah and prayer.
- The filling of the letterמילוי
- The spelled-out form of a letter, needed to speak it; an image for the extra day the Diaspora needs to receive the festival light.
For children · ages 9–13
Seeing the King through the lattice
The big idea
The mitzvos set us apart so that we can hold on to the Torah, and even in exile, when G‑d is seen only through small openings, the longing makes the joy greater.
In the festival prayer we first ask, “Sanctify us with Your mitzvos,” and only then, “give us our share in Your Torah.” Why in that order? Atzeres means “holding on.” To hold on to our Torah and prayer, we must first be set apart by the mitzvos, G‑d’s gift to us. When a person thinks about how everything in this world passes with time, the heart is humbled, and bad traits crumble like smoke. The verse “It is better to take refuge in G‑d” teaches that higher even than the Torah and the Avos is G‑d Himself, whom we reach when we give ourselves over in the Shema. The maamar then asks why Jews outside the Land of Israel keep a second day of Yom Tov. When the Beis HaMikdash stood, G‑d watched us “through the windows”; in exile He “peers through the lattices,” through small openings. In the Megillah the king made one feast for his princes and then a second feast for all the people, great and small. So the second day brings G‑d’s light to every Jew in exile, with greater joy and a thirsting love.
The mashal
When the Beis HaMikdash stood, G‑d watched over us like a king looking out through wide-open windows. In exile He peers through a lattice, through small openings in a wall. He still sees us, and that distance wakes in us a thirsting love and a greater joy.
Questions for the Shabbos table
- Why do we ask to be sanctified with mitzvos before we ask for our share in the Torah?
- What is the difference between G‑d watching “through the windows” and “through the lattices”?
- How can you make a day that feels ordinary this week, like the second day of Yom Tov, a day of real joy?
Explanation © likuteitorah.com, CC BY-NC 4.0: retold for children from our translation and explanation, with AI assistance; not yet reviewed by a human editor.
Betrothal before Torah ¶1–2
“It is better to take refuge in G‑d, etc.” Now, in the prayer of Shabbos and Yom Tov we say “Sanctify us with Your mitzvos” first, and afterwards “and grant us our share in Your Torah.”
The maamar opens with a verse from Hallel that it will interpret only later (paragraph 7). It starts instead from the order of a phrase in the Shabbos and Yom Tov Amidah: we first ask G‑d to sanctify us through the mitzvos, and only then ask for our portion in the Torah.
כי אי אפשר להיות חלק בתורת ה׳ בלתי אם יקיים מצותיו קדשנו במצותיך תחלה וביאור הענין כי ענין ותן חלקנו בתורתך הוא כדכתיב ביום השמיני עצרת תהיה לכם3.
For it is impossible to have a share in the Torah of G‑d unless one fulfills His mitzvos; [hence] “Sanctify us with Your mitzvos” [comes] first. The explanation of the matter: the theme of “grant us our share in Your Torah” is as it is written, “On the eighth day there shall be an atzeres for you.”
The order is not accidental: a real share in the Torah depends on first keeping the mitzvos. To explain what “a share in the Torah” means, the Alter Rebbe turns to the verse that names the festival of Shemini Atzeres.
פי׳ עצרת קליטה שכנס״י קולטת טיפת החכמה דהיינו התורה שירדה מרצונו וחכמתו ית׳ אלא שנתגשמה כמ״ש מוריד הגשם ובהיות כל איש ישראל לומד התורה וחוזר על לימודו ותופס בזכרונו היטב נק׳ בחי׳ זו בחי׳ קולטת
The meaning of atzeres is retention: the Community of Israel (Knesses Yisrael) retains the drop of Chochmah, that is, the Torah, which descended from His will and His wisdom, may He be blessed, except that it became physical (nisgashmah), as it is written, “He causes the rain (geshem) to descend.” And when every Jew studies the Torah, reviews his learning and holds it well in his memory, this level is called the level of “retaining.”
The word atzeres is read as “holding in” or retaining, like a womb that retains the seed. The Torah is a “drop” of G‑d’s wisdom that has come down into physical form, just as “geshem” (rain) shares its root with “gashmiyus” (physicality); a Jew who learns, reviews and remembers the Torah “retains” it.
וכן בענין התפלה שהיא ע״י הדעת והתקשרות במוחו ולבו שיתקע בחוזק במחשבתו בבחי׳ הרגשה וכענין שאמרז״ל הכר את בוראך456 שנתפס לתוך מוחו וגם לתוך לבו להיות לו רעותא דלבא מעומקא דלבא לה׳ לבדו
So too with prayer, which is through Daas and binding [oneself] in one’s mind and heart, so that it be fixed firmly in his thought, in a felt way; as in what our Sages said, “Recognize your Creator”: that it be grasped within his mind and also within his heart, so that he have “the desire of the heart,” from the depth of the heart, for G‑d alone.
Prayer is the second way of retaining: through Daas, deep attentive connection, the knowledge of G‑d is fixed in both mind and heart until it is felt. “The desire of the heart” is a phrase for a longing that comes from the heart’s depth and is directed to G‑d alone.
Now, by way of analogy: when a man takes a wife, he must first betroth her, giving her one perutah or the value of a perutah,
An analogy from marriage law: a betrothal (kiddushin) takes effect when the man gives the woman something of value, at least a perutah, the smallest coin.
רק שתהי׳ דבר שתוכל לקנות לה חיי נפשה כך א״א להיות כנ״י בבחי׳ קולטת כ״א כאשר ימשוך לה חיות אלקות מלמעלה.
only that it be something with which she can buy herself the sustenance of her life. So too, it is impossible for the Community of Israel to be in the state of “retaining” unless He draws down to her G‑dly life-force from above.
The perutah is, in principle, something that can buy the woman her sustenance. Likewise, the Jewish people can “retain” Torah and prayer only after G‑d first gives them a gift of G‑dly life-force from above, a kind of betrothal.
(ועמ״ש סד״ה וארשתיך לי9 כו׳ וידעת) וענין הקדושין הוא כמ״ש והייתם קדושים כו׳ ואבדיל אתכם לי כו׳
(See also what is written at the end of the section beginning “And I will betroth you to Me, etc.… and you shall know.”) And the concept of kiddushin (betrothal) is as it is written, “And you shall be holy, etc.… and I have separated you to Me, etc.,
The parenthesis refers the reader to another maamar on betrothal. Kiddushin is then defined by verses about holiness: to be holy is to be set apart by G‑d as His own.
to be Mine, etc.” And this is the meaning of “Behold, you are betrothed (mekudeshes) to me”: that you shall be set apart and separated for me, for my name.
The betrothal formula “you are mekudeshes to me” is read in the same light: it means that she is set apart exclusively for her husband. So too, the mitzvos set the Jew apart for G‑d.
וזהו ענין כוונת כל המצות כי מצות צריכות כוונה.12 פי׳ לדעת המכוון בהם והמכוון הוא להיות מובדל מן התאוות ומכל מדות הרעות.
And this is the intention of all the mitzvos, for “mitzvos require intention”: that is, to know what is intended by them; and what is intended is to be separated from the cravings and from all bad traits.
This is why the Sages say that mitzvos require kavanah (intention): one should know what they aim at. Their aim is to separate a person from cravings and bad character traits, which is what makes him “betrothed” and able to retain.
The paragraph explains why “sanctify us with Your mitzvos” precedes “grant us our share in Your Torah”: the mitzvos are G‑d’s betrothal gift that sets the Jew apart, and only then can he “retain” (atzeres) the Torah and prayer.
The image of Knesses Yisrael “retaining the drop of Chochmah” draws on the Kabbalistic picture of Malchus as the receiving partner of Z’eir Anpin; Shemini Atzeres is the day of that union. The betrothal gift “from above” anticipates the next paragraph, where the ring of kiddushin is identified with the encompassing light (sovev).
Marei mekomos
- 1טוב לחסות · שמע״צ תקנ״ז. ראה רשימת המאמרים שבסו״ס מאמרי אדה״ז — הקצרים ע׳ תריז הערה 73. ולהלן ברשימת הכת״י.
- 2טוב לחסות · Psalms 118:8
- 3
- 4הכר את בוראך · Sotah 10b:8–9
- 5הכר את בוראך · Bereshit Rabbah 85:11
- 6הכר את בוראך · Nedarim 32a:17–19
- 7שנותן לה א׳ פרוטה או שוה פרוטה · Kiddushin 2a:4–5
- 8פרוטה או שוה פרוטה · ריש קידושין.
- 9סד״ה וארשתיך לי · לעיל פ׳ במדבר ט, ד.
- 10והייתם קדושים כו׳ ואבדיל אתכם לי כו׳ להיות לי · Leviticus 20:26
- 11הרי את מקודשת לי · Kiddushin 5b:10
- 12מצות צריכות כוונה · Berakhot 13a:22–25
2ולכן תקנו חז״ל לומר אשר קדשנו במצותיו בברכות המצות ועי״ז יוכל להיות לו בחי׳ קליטה הנ״ל בתורה ותפלה משא״כ בלא בחי׳ קדושין הנ״ל א״א להיות לו בחי׳ קליטה הנ״ל ונק׳ פולטת ח״ו
Therefore our Sages instituted the saying of “Who has sanctified us with His mitzvos” in the blessings over the mitzvos; and through this one can have the above-mentioned “retention” in Torah and prayer. Without the above-mentioned level of kiddushin, however, it is impossible for him to have the above-mentioned “retention,” and he is called “one who expels,” G‑d forbid.
The blessing said before a mitzvah, “Who has sanctified us with His mitzvos,” expresses this betrothal. With it a person can “retain” the Torah and prayer; without it he is like a womb that cannot hold the seed and “expels” it, G‑d forbid.
והנה ענין המשכת בחי׳ קדושין הנ״ל הוא מלמעלה מבחינת סוכ״ע בחי׳ טבעת קדושין ששם שוה הכל אצלו היה
Now, the drawing down of the above-mentioned kiddushin is from above, from the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin), the level of the ring of kiddushin, where everything is equal before Him: “was,”
The betrothal comes from sovev, the light that surrounds all worlds and is not limited by them. The ring of kiddushin, a circle without beginning or end, symbolizes that encompassing light, for which past, present and future are all the same.
הוה ויהיה ברגע אחד ואין בו שום שינוי ח״ו וכמ״ש גדול ה׳ ומהולל מאד1 ולגדולתו אין חקר פי׳ שגדולת ה׳ היא מאד בלי שיעור והפסק
“is” and “will be” in one instant, and there is no change in Him whatsoever, G‑d forbid. As it is written, “Great is G‑d and exceedingly praised, and His greatness is unsearchable”: that is, the greatness of G‑d is “exceedingly” [great], without measure or interruption,
For that level there is no change and no before and after. The verse from Psalms is brought to distinguish two things: G‑d’s greatness as it extends without limit (“exceedingly”), and something beyond greatness altogether.
וכמו שאמרז״ל מן הארץ2 לרקיע כו׳ רגלי החיות כנגד כולם כו׳ אבל ולגדולתו אין חקר פי׳ ולגדולתו בעצמו אין שייך לשון גדולה
as our Sages said, “From the earth to the firmament, etc.… the feet of the Chayos are equal to all of them, etc.” But “and His greatness is unsearchable” means: to His greatness itself, the term “greatness” does not apply.
The Talmud describes the vast distances of the heavens, and the feet of the Chayos (angels of the Chariot) equal to all of them: that is greatness beyond measure. “His greatness is unsearchable” goes further: in G‑d’s own essence the very idea of “greatness” is out of place.
וזהו שארז״ל במקום שאתה מוצא גדולתו3 של הקב״ה שם אתה מוצא ענוותנותו שצלו ית׳ גדולה לענוה יחשב
And this is what our Sages said, “Wherever you find the greatness of the Holy One, blessed be He, there you find His humility”: for with Him, may He be blessed, greatness is reckoned as humility,
This is why the Sages link G‑d’s greatness with His humility: from His own perspective, to be “great” over the worlds is a lowering of Himself.
כי לשון גדולה נופל על התפשטות אורו בבחי׳ א״ס ואין קץ כו׳ ולא על מקור האור וחיי החיים שהוא מתגדל על דבר שהוא כאין ואפס ממש.
because the term “greatness” applies to the spreading forth of His light in the manner of the infinite and the endless, etc., and not to the Source of the light and the Life of all life, who [would thereby] be made great over something that is truly as nothing and naught.
“Greatness” describes His light spreading infinitely. The Source of that light is not made great by towering over creations, for next to Him they are nothing at all, and to be “great” in comparison with nothing is no greatness.
The betrothal drawn down by the mitzvos comes from sovev, the level beyond time and change, which the paragraph describes through the idea that true Divine greatness is beyond the term “greatness” itself.
The contrast between infinite “greatness” and G‑d’s essence parallels the Chassidic distinction between the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof) as it spreads forth and its Source. The Kehot note sends the reader to Likkutei Torah Va’eschanan for another discussion of greatness and humility.
Marei mekomos
- 1גדול ה׳ ומהולל מאד · Psalms 145:3
- 2מן הארץ עד לרקיע כו׳ רגלי החיות · Chagigah 13a:3–4
- 3במקום שאתה מוצא גדולתו · Megillah 31a:12–13
The broken heart that crumbles evil ¶3–6
3וז״ש לך הוי׳ הגדולה. פי׳ כי מדת גדולה היא רק הוי׳ שנתהוה ממך והיינו ע״י צמצום והתפשטות והמשכה שע״ז מורים אותיות שם הוי׳ יו״ד צמצום כו׳.
And this is what is written, “Yours, Havayah, is the greatness”: that is, the attribute of greatness is only Havayah, which came into being from You, namely through contraction, spreading forth and drawing down, which the letters of the Name Havayah indicate: the yud, contraction, etc.
The verse “Yours, Havayah, is the greatness” is read to mean that greatness belongs only to the level of the Name Havayah, the power that brings creation into being. The letters of the Name trace that process: the small yud is contraction (tzimtzum), and the following letters are expansion and extension.
וע״י התבוננות זו נמשך לאדם ג״כ לב נשבר ונדכה1 שיהיה שוה בעיניו כל עניני העולם שנופלים תחת הזמן עבר הוה ועתיד והוה ולא יתאוה להם ולא ישית לב אליהם כלל
And through this contemplation a person also comes to have a broken and crushed heart, so that all the matters of the world that fall under time, past, present and future, and are transient, will be equal in his eyes; he will not crave them and will not set his heart to them at all,
Contemplating that all of creation is only an outflow of G‑d, and nothing next to Him, breaks a person’s heart and humbles him. Everything bound by time then becomes equal and fleeting in his eyes, and he stops craving it.
כי יאמר ללבו הרי קודם זה כמה שנים לא עלתה על לבי לכל לחשוב ולהרהר בענין זה ואחר כמה שנים לא יהיה הדבר ולא יבא כלל.23456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930
for he will say to his heart: “Behold, several years ago it did not occur to me at all to think and ponder about this matter, and after several years the thing will not exist and will not come [to mind] at all.”
The practical reflection: a few years ago I never thought about this thing, and a few years from now it will be gone and forgotten. Why then should it capture my heart now?
From the idea that “greatness” is only Havayah’s act of creation, the paragraph draws a practical meditation: worldly matters, bound by time, are passing, and seeing this gives a broken heart that no longer craves them.
The link between the letters of Havayah and the stages of contraction, expansion and drawing down is a standard Kabbalistic teaching. The meditation mirrors the level of sovev described above, for which “was, is and will be” are one: a person who sees past and future as equal to the present reflects that timeless view in his own life.
Marei mekomos
- 1לב נשבר ונדכה · Psalms 51:19
- 2איזהו חכם הרואה את הנולד · Tamid 32a:7
- 3ואת רוח הטומאה אעביר · Zechariah 13:2
- 4אתה פוררת בעזך ים · Psalms 74:13
- 5ותשליך במצולות ים · Micah 7:19
- 6פז״ר קש״ב · Rosh Hashanah 4b:13–14
- 7אין אני והוא יכולין לדור · Sotah 5a:14
- 8מארבע הרוחות באי ופחי בהרוגים · Ezekiel 37:9
- 9אם ישים אליו לבו · Job 34:14
- 10ארור הגבר · Jeremiah 17:5
- 11אל תבטחו בנדיבים · Psalms 146:3
- 12אך הכוונה הוא על אדם העליון · ביהל אור ע׳ תנ כתב שכ״ה ביר״ק ערך בטחון סעי׳ ד בשם ציוני.
- 13ועל דמות הכסא · Ezekiel 1:26
- 14כיון שפירש טליתו עלי׳ שוב אינו יכול לבגוד בה · ראה קידושין יח, רע״ב. וש״נ.
- 15עוטה אור כשלמה · Psalms 104:2
- 16וע׳ עוד מענין עוטה אור · כל המ״מ מובאים ביהל אור עה״פ ע׳ שצז.
- 17להחיות לב נדכאים · Isaiah 57:15
- 18להושיבי עם נדיבים · Psalms 113:8
- 19נדיבים אלו האבות · ראה בהנסמן להלן בהוספות להערות וציונים.
- 20להושיבי עם נדיבים אלו האבות שהן הן המרכבה · ביהל אור ע׳ תנא הקשה שלכאורה זה אינו מובן, אך מאחר שגם פי׳ מבטוח באדם היינו באדם העליון, כמו״כ י״ל בענין מבטוח בנדיבים ע״ש בארוכה.
- 21האבות שהן הן המרכבה · Bereshit Rabbah 47:6
- 22נדיבי עמים נאספו · Psalms 47:10
- 23ע״פ כרוה נדיבי העם · ראה לעיל חקת סב, ד.
- 24ובפ׳ ויקהל ע״פ כל נדיב לבו · תו״א פט, ד. וראה שם קטו, ד.
- 25ובד״ה מה יפו פעמיך · לקמן שה״ש מד, ג.
- 26שבבחי׳ אדם ונדיבים יוכל להיות נפילה · מובא בביאוה״ז להצ״צ כרך ב ע תתפד.
- 27ומלתם את ערלת לבבכם · Deuteronomy 10:16
- 28ופחי בהרוגים ויחיו · Ezekiel 37:9
- 29שו״ה כו׳ — והוא בחינת טל · כאן הוא סיום המאמר בהכת״י שבלי הגהות הצ״צ. ובשני כת״י יש כאן שורה נוספת: טל וכו׳ והוא ע״י שידע להתבונן הטיב בדבר בעצמו כי כל גוים סבבוני אז ישוב וירחמהו ממקור הרחמי׳ כמ״ש במ״א. ע״כ.
- 30לך הוי׳ הגדולה · I Chronicles 29:11
4ולכן גם עתה יהיה דומה בעיניו כאלו הוא קודם הזמן הזה ואחריו. וזהו איזהו חכם הרואה את הנולד1 שרואה בבחי׳ ראיה
Therefore now too it will seem in his eyes as if it were before this time and after it. And this is [the meaning of] “Who is wise? One who sees what will be born”: who sees, in a manner of
Since the thing did not exist before and will not exist after, the person sees it now as if it were already gone. This is the Sages’ definition of a wise man: one who “sees” the outcome.
ממש מה שנולד אח״כ שלא יהיה הדבר הרע כמ״ש ואת רוח הטומאה אעביר מן הארץ וגו׳ וגם אחרית כל דבר הוא רמה ותולעה והוה ונפסד.2
actual seeing, what will be born afterwards: that the evil thing will not exist, as it is written, “And I will remove the spirit of impurity from the land, etc.”; and also that the end of every thing is worms and maggots, transient and perishing.
He sees, as vividly as with his eyes, that evil will be removed from the world in the future, and that every physical thing ends in decay. Seeing the end robs the temptation of its hold now.
The broken-hearted meditation is the wisdom of “seeing what will be born”: the wise person sees now that evil and worldly allure will pass away.
Marei mekomos
- 1איזהו חכם הרואה את הנולד · Tamid 32a:7
- 2
5וזהו אתה פוררת בעזך ים1. פי׳ ים נק׳ כמה בחי׳ שהם מצולות ים כמ״ש ותשליך במצולות ים כל חטאתם ואתה מפרר ומפזר אותם בעזך
And this is [the meaning of] “You crumbled the sea with Your might.” That is: several levels are called “sea,” namely “the depths of the sea,” as it is written, “And You will cast all their sins into the depths of the sea”; and You crumble and scatter them with Your might,
The verse “You crumbled the sea with Your might” is read as referring to sins, which are cast into “the depths of the sea.” G‑d crumbles and scatters them.
היינו ע״י בחי׳ התבוננות הנ״ל אין לו תפיסת מקום כלל להחשב בבחי׳ יש רק יפרר ע״י בחי׳ לב נשבר ונדכה וזהו סימן של שמיני עצרת פז״ר קש״ב.
that is, through the above-mentioned contemplation, [the thing] has no standing at all to be reckoned as a “something” (yesh), but he will crumble it through a broken and crushed heart. And this is the mnemonic of Shemini Atzeres: PaZeR KaSheV.
Through the contemplation above, evil loses its claim to be a real “something” (yesh), and the broken heart crumbles it. The Alter Rebbe finds this in the Talmud’s mnemonic for Shemini Atzeres, PaZeR KaSheV.
פי׳ מתחלה פזר בבחי׳ פירור הנ״ל ואח״כ קשב אמריה כי כשאין לו בחי׳ פיזור ופירור הנ״ל אמרז״ל אין אני והוא יכולין לדור בעולם אחד.2 פי׳ כשתופס מקום בעולם.3
That is: first “scatter” (pazer), in the manner of the above-mentioned crumbling, and afterwards “hearken (kashev) to His words.” For when one lacks the above-mentioned scattering and crumbling, our Sages said, “I and he cannot dwell in one world”: that is, when he takes up place in the world.
The mnemonic is read as two words: “pazer,” scatter, and “kashev,” hearken. First one must shatter one’s sense of self; only then can one listen to G‑d’s words, since G‑d says of the arrogant person, who fills up space in the world, that He and he cannot dwell together.
The broken heart “crumbles” sin and self-importance, and this is the order hinted in the mnemonic of Shemini Atzeres: first scatter (pazer), then hearken (kashev).
In the Talmud, PaZeR KaSheV is a mnemonic for the ways Shemini Atzeres is a festival in its own right. The Alter Rebbe reads its letters as a sequence of divine service. The Kehot note points to Likkutei Sichos for a discussion of the exact wording “kashev.”
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2אין אני והוא יכולין לדור בעולם אחד · Sotah 5a:14
- 3
6והנה כתיב וכל הרשעה כולה בעשן תכלה שבקל יוכל לדחות כמו העשן שהרוח בא ועוקרו אפי׳ הוא נושב
Now it is written, “And all wickedness will be entirely consumed like smoke”: that it can easily be driven away, like smoke, which the wind comes and uproots even when it blows
Evil is compared to smoke: it looks thick and real, but even a slight wind drives it away.
מעט כמ״ש מארבע הרוחות בואי ופחי בהרוגים האלה ויחיו1 מפני שבאמת אין בהם ממשות כלל רק אם ישים אליו לבו2 להתבוננות הנ״ל:
only a little, as it is written, “Come from the four winds, and breathe into these slain, that they may live”; because in truth they have no substance at all, provided only that he sets his heart to the above-mentioned contemplation.
Ezekiel’s call to the winds (the Hebrew “ruach” means both wind and spirit) shows that a breath of spirit is enough. Evil has no real substance, and it vanishes as soon as a person turns his heart to the contemplation described above.
The paragraph concludes the first theme: evil has no substance, and the contemplation of the passing nature of all worldly things drives it away easily, like wind blowing away smoke.
Marei mekomos
- 1מארבע הרוחות בואי ופחי בהרוגים האלה ויחיו · Ezekiel 37:9
- 2אם ישים אליו לבו · Job 34:14
Refuge above the Torah and the Patriarchs ¶7
7וזהו טוב לחסות בה׳ מבטחח באדם טוב לחסות בה׳ מבטוח בנדיבים.1 ופי׳ בזהר שאין הכוונה על האדם הגשמי ונדיבים הגשמיים שא״כ לא היה אומר טוב לחסות בה׳ וגו׳.
And this is [the meaning of] “It is better to take refuge in G‑d than to trust in man; it is better to take refuge in G‑d than to trust in nobles.” The Zohar explains that the intent is not to the physical man and physical nobles, for if so, it would not say “It is better to take refuge in G‑d, etc.,”
Now the maamar returns to its opening verse. A problem: if “man” and “nobles” meant ordinary people, the verse would be saying that trusting them is good, only that trusting G‑d is better.
דמשמע שגם לבטוח באדם ובנדיבים טוב הוא אלא שיותר טוב לחסות בה׳ דהא כתיב ארור הגבר אשר יבטח באדם2 וכתיב אל תבטחו בנדיבים3 וגו׳.
which implies that to trust in man and in nobles is also good, only that it is better to take refuge in G‑d; yet it is written, “Cursed is the man who trusts in man,” and it is written, “Do not trust in nobles, etc.”
That cannot be, since other verses curse the one who trusts in man and forbid trusting in nobles. So “man” and “nobles” here must mean something holy.
אך הכוונה הוא על אדם העליון והוא מ״ש ועל דמות הכסא דמות כמראה אדם4 והוא בחי׳ תורה שבכתב שיש בה רמ״ח מ״ע ושס״ה ל״ת כמראה אדם שיש בו רמ״ח אברין ושס״ה גידין
Rather, the intent is to the Supernal Man. This is what is written, “And upon the likeness of the throne, a likeness like the appearance of a man”; and this is the level of the Written Torah, which has 248 positive commandments and 365 prohibitions, “like the appearance of a man,” who has 248 limbs and 365 sinews.
“Man” is the Supernal Man, the human likeness Ezekiel saw upon the Divine throne. This “Man” is the Written Torah, whose 248 positive and 365 negative commandments correspond to the 248 limbs and 365 sinews of the human body.
(וכמ״ש מזה בד״ה ויאכילך את המן בפ׳ עקב) ובודאי טוב ויפה לדבק בתורתו ית׳ אך יותר טוב מזה לחסות בה׳.
(As is explained about this in the section beginning “And He fed you the manna,” in Parshas Eikev.) And certainly it is good and fine to cleave to His Torah, may He be blessed; but better than this is to take refuge in G‑d.
Cleaving to the Torah, the Supernal Man, is certainly good. Yet the verse says that “taking refuge in G‑d” is better still.
לחסות פי׳ מלשון מחסה ומסתור והוא כמו למשל ענין מכסה החופה שבמדינותינו מקדשין תחת יריעה ובכמה מקומות פורסין טלית על החתן וכלה.
“To take refuge” (lachasos) is from the term “shelter” (machseh) and “cover.” It is like, by way of analogy, the covering of the chuppah: in our countries they betroth under a canopy, and in several places they spread a tallis over the groom and bride.
“Refuge” (chasiyah) implies being covered and sheltered. The Alter Rebbe compares it to the canopy (chuppah) of a wedding: in his lands it was a sheet held over the couple, and elsewhere a tallis was spread over them.
And our Sages said, “Once he has spread his tallis over her, he can no longer betray her.” So too, of Him, may He be blessed, it is written, “He wraps Himself in light as in a garment.”
The Sages taught that once a man has spread his tallis over his bride he may not betray her, because the covering creates a permanent bond. G‑d too “wraps Himself in light as a garment,” and spreads it over His people.
ופורש טליתו מעטה לבושו מבחי׳ סוכ״ע להחיות לב נדכאים8 (ועמ״ש באגה״ק על פסוק זה דעוטה אור ועמ״ש בביאור ע״פ
And He spreads His tallis, the wrap of His garment, from the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin), “to revive the heart of the crushed.” (And see what is written in Iggeres HaKodesh on this verse, “He wraps Himself in light”; and see what is written in the explanation on the verse
This covering comes from sovev, the encompassing light, and its purpose is to revive the broken heart. The parenthesis that follows begins a list of places where the verse “He wraps Himself in light” is discussed.
כי ביום הזה יכפר בענין לבושיה כתלג חיור דקאי על התורה שהיא בחי׳ חשמל העליון מלמעלה מאצילות כו׳. וע׳ עוד מענין עוטה אור בשמות רבה) (פט״ו ור״פ י״ז) תרומה (פל״ג).
“For on this day He shall atone,” regarding “His garment is white as snow,” which refers to the Torah, which is the level of the supernal Chashmal, above Atzilus, etc. And see further on the theme of “He wraps Himself in light” in Shemos Rabbah) (chapter 15 and the beginning of chapter 17), Terumah (chapter 33),
In another maamar, G‑d’s garment “white as snow” (a phrase from Daniel’s vision) is the Torah, rooted in the “supernal Chashmal,” a level higher than Atzilus. The list of Midrash references begins with Shemos Rabbah.
ויקהל (פ״נ) אמור (פל״א) ובזח״ג (דרמ״ה ב׳ נ״ט ב׳. ח״א ל״א סע״ב. צ׳ ע״א. קמ״ב ב׳. ח״ב ט״ל ב׳ צ״ח סע״א קס״ד ב׳ ר״ט א׳).
Vayakhel (chapter 50), Emor (chapter 31); and in Zohar, volume III (245b, 59b; volume I, 31b at the end, 90a, 142b; volume II, 39b, 98a at the end, 164b, 209a).
The list continues with further chapters of the Midrash and with many passages of the Zohar that discuss G‑d’s garment of light.
ובספר עמ״ה שער עולם הבריאה פ״ג פי׳ עוטה אור כשלמה עולם המלבוש כו׳ והיינו אותיות התורה שהם בחי׳ לבושו ית׳.
And in the book Emek HaMelech, Gate of the World of Beriah, chapter 3, he explains “He wraps Himself in light as in a garment” as the World of the Garment, etc.; that is, the letters of the Torah, which are the level of His garment, may He be blessed.
The Kabbalistic work Emek HaMelech calls this garment “the World of the Garment,” which the Alter Rebbe identifies with the letters of the Torah: the Torah is how G‑d “clothes” Himself so as to be revealed.
ועמש״ל סד״ה ביום השמע״צ ובביאור ע״פ את שבתותי תשמרו וענין הנדיבים הוא מ״ש להושיבי עם נדיבים9 שכל ניצוצות נשמות ישראל מתעלים בי״ט.
And see what is written above, at the end of the section beginning “On the day of Shemini Atzeres,” and in the explanation on the verse “You shall keep My Shabbosos.” And the matter of “nobles” is what is written, “to seat me with nobles”: for all the sparks of the souls of Israel are elevated on Yom Tov.
After more cross-references, the Alter Rebbe explains the “nobles.” On Yom Tov the souls of Israel rise, and the verse “to seat me with nobles” describes that elevation.
“To seat me with nobles”: these are the Patriarchs, who are themselves the Chariot, as it is written, “The nobles of the peoples are gathered, the people of the G‑d of Abraham.”
The “nobles” are the Patriarchs, of whom the Midrash says “they are the Chariot”: they were wholly given over to G‑d’s will, as a chariot is to its rider. The verse from Psalms links “nobles” to “the G‑d of Abraham.”
(ועמ״ש ע״פ כרוה נדיבי העם ובפ׳ ויקהל ע״פ כל נדיב לבו. ובד״ה מה יפו פעמיך בענין בת נדיב) ואעפ״כ טוב יותר לחסות בה׳ כי
(And see what is written on the verse “which the nobles of the people dug,” and in Parshas Vayakhel on the verse “everyone whose heart is generous (nediv),” and in the section beginning “How beautiful are your steps,” regarding “O daughter of the noble.”) And nonetheless it is better to take refuge in G‑d, for
After pointing to three other maamarim on the word “noble,” the Alter Rebbe returns to the verse: even so, taking refuge in G‑d is better than the “nobles.”
הנה אמר דוד כל גוים סבבוני14 פי׳ שבבחי׳ אדם ונדיבים יוכל להיות בחי׳ נפילה להיות כל גוים סבבוני כו׳
behold, David said, “All nations surrounded me”: that is, in the level of “man” and “nobles” there can be a level of falling, so that “all nations surrounded me, etc.”
The reason is found in the next verse of the same psalm: “All nations surrounded me.” Even at the holy levels of “man” (Torah) and “nobles” (the Patriarchs) a person can fall, and the forces opposed to holiness can close in on him.
אבל בשם ה׳ שהוא בחי׳ סוכ״ע כי אמילם אכרות ואמול ערת הלב כמ״ש ומלתם את ערלת לבבכם15 וכמ״ש מחיה מתים כו׳
But “in the Name of G‑d,” which is the level of the light that encompasses all worlds, “I will cut them off” (amilam): I will cut off and circumcise the foreskin of the heart, as it is written, “And you shall circumcise the foreskin of your heart,” and as it is written, “He revives the dead, etc.,”
“In the Name of G‑d,” the encompassing light beyond these levels, one can “cut them off.” The Hebrew amilam is read as “I will circumcise them,” removing the heart’s coarse covering.
כמ״ש ופחי בהרוגים ויחו16 והוא בחינת טל (ועיין בויקרא רבה אמור פ״ל ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה ויאכילך את המן שע״ז נאמר אשר לא ידעון אבותיך17 כו׳ והוא למעלה מבחינת אדם העליון.
as it is written, “and breathe into the slain, that they may live”; and this is the level of dew. (And see Vayikra Rabbah, Emor, chapter 30; and see what is written about this in the section beginning “And He fed you the manna”: that of this it is said, “which your fathers did not know, etc.,” and it is above the level of the Supernal Man.
This level revives even the spiritually “dead,” like dew, which in Jewish tradition is the image of resurrection. A long parenthesis now opens: the manna, unknown to the Patriarchs, also comes from a level above the Supernal Man.
וענין לחסות בהוי׳ י״ל שזהו ענין פסוק ראשון דק״ש שמע ישראל18 הוי׳ אלקינו למסור נפשו באחד. שזהו למעלה מבחי׳ התורה. כמ״ש בד״ה מה יפו פעמיךהנ״ל ו בביאור ע״פ אחת היא יונתי.
And the matter of taking refuge in Havayah, it may be said, is the theme of the first verse of the Shema, “Hear, O Israel, Havayah is our G‑d…”: to give over one’s soul at [the word] “One,” which is above the level of the Torah, as is explained in the section beginning “How beautiful are your steps,” mentioned above, and in the explanation on the verse “My dove is but one,”
“Taking refuge in Havayah” is identified with the first verse of the Shema, where a Jew is ready to give up his life at the word “One.” That self-offering reaches higher than the Torah itself.
ובביאור ע״פ ונקדשתי בתוך בנ״י וסד״ה כי קרוב אליך הדבר מאד ועי״ז נקראו נש״י ראשית תבואתה19 שהם הממשיכים גילוי אור א״ס בחכמה עילאה שהיא התורה שהיא בחי׳ לבושיה.
and in the explanation on the verse “And I shall be sanctified among the children of Israel,” and at the end of the section beginning “For the matter is very near to you.” And through this the souls of Israel are called “the first of His harvest,” for they are the ones who draw down the revelation of the Infinite Light into the Supernal Chochmah, which is the Torah, which is the level of His garment.
By this self-sacrifice the Jewish souls are called “the first of His harvest”: they are prior even to the Torah, and they draw the Infinite Light into Chochmah, the Torah, which is G‑d’s “garment.”
וכמ״ש סד״ה ועשית בגדי קדש. ולעיל סד״ה ביום השמיני עצרת. בפי׳ שמחת תורה שהתורה שהיא בחי׳ אור כשלמה היא בשמחה ע״י שאור א״ס ב״ה נמשך ומלובש בה ע״ש.
And as is explained at the end of the section beginning “And you shall make holy garments,” and above, at the end of the section beginning “On the eighth day, an atzeres,” on the meaning of Simchas Torah: that the Torah, which is the level of “light as a garment,” is in joy because the Infinite Light, blessed be He, is drawn down and clothed in it; see there.
This is linked to Simchas Torah: the Torah, the “garment of light,” rejoices when the Infinite Light is drawn into it, and it is the Jewish people who draw it in.
ועמ״ש בפ׳ יתרו בד״ה זכור ושמור בדבור אחד. שהענין שנש״י ממשיכים ע״י מס״נ בק״ש שיהיה גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה שלמעלה מבחי׳ אדם שעז״נ
And see what is written in Parshas Yisro, in the section beginning “‘Remember’ and ‘Keep’ in a single utterance”: the matter is that the souls of Israel, through self-sacrifice (mesirus nefesh) in the Shema, draw down a revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, which is above the level of “man,” of which it is said,
Through self-sacrifice in the Shema the Jew draws down a light higher than “man,” higher than the Torah in its measured form. Scripture says of this level, “He is not a man.”
כי לא אדם הוא20 נמשך ומתלבש בעסק תורתם ועבודתם בקיום המצות שבבחינת אדם וזהו ענין על שלא ברכו בתורה21 כו׳ ועמ״ש בד״ה וכל בניך ובד״ה השמים כסאי בפי׳ לעשות ולקיים):
“for He is not a man”; it is drawn down and clothed in their occupation with Torah and in their service in fulfilling the mitzvos, which are in the level of “man.” And this is the matter of “because they did not recite the blessing over the Torah, etc.” And see what is written in the section beginning “And all your children,” and in the section beginning “The heavens are My throne,” on the meaning of “to do and to fulfill.”)
That higher light is then clothed in their Torah study and mitzvos, which belong to the level of “man.” This explains the Talmud’s saying that the Land was lost “because they did not bless over the Torah first”: they studied without first connecting to the Giver, who is above the Torah.
The paragraph explains the opening verse: “man” is the Torah (the Supernal Man) and “nobles” are the Patriarchs, both holy; yet “taking refuge in G‑d,” the encompassing light reached through self-sacrifice in the Shema, is higher still, for it can overcome any fall and revive the heart.
The Kehot note records that the reading of “man” as the Supernal Man is found in Yalkut Reuveni, quoting the Tziyoni. The chuppah image connects back to paragraph 1: the mitzvos are the betrothal, and the chuppah, the encompassing light, is the covering that makes the bond permanent. A note in paragraph 3 records that one manuscript ends the maamar at “this is the level of dew,” so the long parenthesis may be a later gloss.
Marei mekomos
- 1טוב לחסות בה׳ מבטחח באדם טוב לחסות בה׳ מבטוח בנדיבים · Psalms 118:8–9
- 2ארור הגבר אשר יבטח באדם · Jeremiah 17:5
- 3אל תבטחו בנדיבים · Psalms 146:3
- 4ועל דמות הכסא דמות כמראה אדם · Ezekiel 1:26
- 5כיון שפירש טליתו עליה שוב אינו יכול לבגוד בה · Kiddushin 18b:4
- 6
- 7עוטה אור כשלמה · Psalms 104:2
- 8להחיות לב נדכאים · Isaiah 57:15
- 9להושיבי עם נדיבים · Psalms 113:8
- 10האבות שהן הן המרכבה · Bereshit Rabbah 47:6
- 11האבות שהן הן המרכבה · Bereshit Rabbah 82:6
- 12האבות שהן הן המרכבה · Zohar, Pinchas 123:842–856
- 13נדיבי עמים נאספו עם אלקי אברהם · Psalms 47:10
- 14כל גוים סבבוני · Psalms 118:10
- 15ומלתם את ערלת לבבכם · Deuteronomy 10:16
- 16ופחי בהרוגים ויחו · Ezekiel 37:9
- 17אשר לא ידעון אבותיך · Deuteronomy 8:16
- 18שמע ישראל הוי׳ אלקינו · Deuteronomy 6:4
- 19ראשית תבואתה · Jeremiah 2:3
- 20כי לא אדם הוא · I Samuel 15:29
- 21על שלא ברכו בתורה · Nedarim 81a
Seeing the King: windows and lattices ¶8–10
8להבין ענין יו״ט שני של גליות. כי הנה כל יו״ט הוא בחי׳ שמחה התגלות הפנימית כמשל המלך שדרכו לישב בחדרי חדרים ובזמן שמחתו הוא מתגלה ומתראה וראייה זו היא גורמת האהבה וכמשל אהבת המלך
To understand the matter of the second day of Yom Tov of the Diaspora: every Yom Tov is a level of joy, a revelation of the inward. As in the analogy of a king whose way is to sit in innermost chambers, and at the time of his joy he reveals himself and is seen; and this seeing brings about love. As in the analogy of love for the king,
A new question: why does the Diaspora keep a second day of Yom Tov? Every festival is a time of joy, when G‑d’s inner self is revealed, like a king who normally stays hidden in his inner rooms but shows himself on his day of celebration.
שהיא באה מחמת ראיית פניו שעי״ז תיקר אהבתם אליו משא״כ ע״י שמיעה מרחוק הנה לשמע המלך נופל בחי׳ יראה ולא אהבה
which comes from seeing his face, through which their love for him grows precious; whereas through hearing from afar, upon hearing of the king there falls [upon one] a level of awe, and not love.
Seeing the king’s face awakens love; merely hearing about him from afar awakens awe. Sight brings closeness, hearing keeps distance.
וזהו פני אריה אל הימין1 אריה אותיות ראיה שמזה נמשך אל הימין שהוא בחינת אהבה (ועמ״ש בד״ה יהודה אתה גבי ראובן ושמעון)
And this is “the face of a lion to the right”: aryeh (lion) has the letters of re’iyah (seeing), from which [something] is drawn “to the right,” which is the level of love. (And see what is written in the section beginning “Yehudah, you,” regarding Reuven and Shimon.)
Among the faces of the Chariot, the lion is on the right, the side of love (Chesed). The letters of aryeh (lion) spell re’iyah (seeing): seeing leads to love.
והנה עיקר ענין גילוי זה שהמלך מתגלה ומתראה הי׳ בזמן בהמ״ק בעליית רגלים שאז היו מקבלים ישראל בחי׳ ראי׳ המלך
Now, the essence of this revelation, in which the King reveals Himself and is seen, was in the time of the Holy Temple, at the pilgrimages of the festivals, when Israel would receive the level of seeing the King,
This revelation happened most fully when the Temple stood and Jews went up for the three festivals, where they “saw” the King.
כדכתיב יראה כל זכורך2 ויראה יראה כדרך שבא לראות3 כו׳ שהיה בחי׳ ראיה והתגלות מלמעלה ומזה נמשך כל זכורך מדת האהבה כדכתיב זכר חסדו4 כו׳
as it is written, “All your males shall appear”; and “he shall see / he shall appear”: in the way he comes to see, etc. There was a level of seeing and revelation from above, and from this the attribute of love was drawn to “all your males,” as it is written, “He remembered His kindness, etc.”
The verse “All your males shall appear” can be read both “shall see” and “shall be seen”: the pilgrim came to see and to be seen. From that sight came love, since zachor (“your males”) is linked to “He remembered (zachar) His kindness”: male and remembering are tied to Chesed, love.
[ועמ״ש מענין שלש פעמים בשנה יראה בד״ה בשעה שהקדימו ישראל נעשה ובד״ה מה יפו פעמיך בנעלים ובד״ה מזמור שיר חנכת הבית גבי ואין אנו יכולים לעלות ולראות כו׳.
(And see what is written on the theme of “Three times a year… shall appear” in the section beginning “When Israel put ‘we will do’ first,” and in the section beginning “How beautiful are your steps in sandals,” and in the section beginning “A psalm, a song for the dedication of the House,” regarding “and we cannot go up and appear, etc.”
A long bracketed list of other maamarim on the theme of “appearing” before G‑d begins here, including one on the words of the festival prayer, “we cannot go up and appear.”
The second part of the maamar opens: every festival is a revelation of the King, and seeing Him arouses love; this happened most fully in Temple times, when the pilgrims came to see and be seen.
The play between zachor (male) and zachar (remember) and the link of “male” to Chesed, love, is developed in the next paragraph (“great love, which is called male”). The lion on the right is from Ezekiel’s Chariot, where the right side corresponds to Chesed.
Marei mekomos
- 1פני אריה אל הימין · Ezekiel 1:10
- 2יראה כל זכורך · Deuteronomy 16:16
- 3כדרך שבא לראות · Chagigah 2a:6
- 4זכר חסדו · Psalms 98:3
9ועמ״ש עוד מענין וה׳ עליהם יראה1 בד״ה שמאלו תחת לראשי בפ׳ כי תשא. ועמ״ש עוד בד״ה ואתחנן גבי אעברה נא ואראה2 כו׳.
And see further what is written on the theme of “And G‑d will appear over them” in the section beginning “His left hand is under my head,” in Parshas Ki Sisa. And see further what is written in the section beginning “Va’eschanan,” regarding “Let me cross over, please, and see, etc.”
The bracketed list of cross-references continues: other maamarim where G‑d “appearing” to Israel, and Moshe’s plea to “see” the Land, are explained.
ועמ״ש בד״ה בהעלותך את הנרות ובד״ה ועשית בגדי קדש בענין אהרן אותיות נראה3 כו׳ שמזה נמשך בחי׳ אור האהבה רבה כו׳.
And see what is written in the section beginning “When you kindle the lamps,” and in the section beginning “And you shall make holy garments,” regarding Aharon [having] the letters of nireh (“will be seen”), etc., from which the level of the light of great love is drawn, etc.
The name Aharon (אהרן) has the letters of nireh (נראה), “will be seen.” Aharon, whose attribute is love, shows that being seen by G‑d draws down “great love” (ahavah rabbah), the highest love.
וזהו ענין יראה כל זכורך4 שהיא אה״ר שנק׳ דכר כמ״ש בד״ה שוש תשיש בפ׳ תזריע וע׳ בזהר (בתחלתו דף ב׳ ע״א).
And this is the theme of “all your males shall appear”: it is great love, which is called “male,” as is explained in the section beginning “I will greatly rejoice,” in Parshas Tazria; and see the Zohar (at its beginning, page 2a).
In Kabbalistic language, great love is called “male,” because it is a love that gives and initiates. So “all your males shall appear” means that the “seeing” on the festivals produced this great love.
And see what is written in the section beginning “And it shall be for you as tzitzis,” regarding the meaning of “so that you shall remember”: that you shall be in the level of males. And this is through “and you shall see it,”
The mitzvah of tzitzis says “you shall see it… so that you shall remember (tizkeru).” Remembering (zachor) is linked to “male” (zachar): seeing leads to the level of great love.
כי ציצית ג״כ מלשון מציץ מן החרכים7 (דלקמן) ועמ״ש בד״ה ועשית ציץ זהב טהור ועמ״ש בד״ה עיני כל אליך ישברו וע׳ בזהר פקודי (דרכ״ה ע״ב)
for tzitzis also comes from the term “peering (metzitz) through the lattices” (below). And see what is written in the section beginning “And you shall make a plate (tzitz) of pure gold,” and see what is written in the section beginning “The eyes of all look hopefully to You,” and see the Zohar, Pekudei (225b),
The word tzitzis is related to metzitz, “peering,” the word that will be central below (“peering through the lattices”). The list continues with maamarim on the priest’s golden plate (tzitz) and on G‑d’s eyes.
ע״פ עיני8 ה׳ אל צדיקים9 ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה כי תשמע בקול ור״פ בחקתי (דקי״ב סע״א) ואשגח עלן10 כו׳ ובפי׳ הרמ״ז שם ושם]
on the verse “The eyes of G‑d are toward the righteous”; and see what is written about this in the section beginning “If you will listen to the voice,” and at the beginning of Parshas Bechukosai (112a, at the end): “and watch over us, etc.,” and in the commentary of the Ramaz there and there.)
The references end with passages about G‑d’s watchful “eyes” toward the righteous, and with Zohar passages and the Ramaz’s commentary on them. The long bracket that began in paragraph 8 closes here.
(ועיין מענין יראה כל זכורך ברבות בשה״ש בפסוק יונתי בחגוי שזהו ענין הראיני את מראיך זח״ב בא ל״ח א׳ ס״פ משפטים קכ״ד א׳ תצוה קפ״ג א׳ פ׳ שלח קס״ה סע״ב11 קס״ח א׳).
(And see on the theme of “all your males shall appear” in the Midrash Rabbah on Song of Songs, on the verse “My dove, in the clefts of the rock,” that this is the theme of “Show me your appearance”; Zohar volume II, Bo 38a; end of Mishpatim 124a; Tetzaveh 183a; Parshas Shelach 165b at the end, 168a.)
A further parenthesis: the Midrash links “all your males shall appear” with the verse “Show me your appearance” in Song of Songs, and several Zohar passages develop the theme.
והנה כתיב קול דודי הנה זה בא כו׳ משגיח מן החלונות מציץ מן החרכים.12
Now it is written, “The voice of my Beloved! Behold, he comes, etc.… watching through the windows, peering through the lattices.”
Now the main argument continues with a verse from Song of Songs, which describes the Beloved (G‑d) looking at His bride (Israel) in two ways: through “windows” and through “lattices.”
פי׳ קול דודי הוא המשכה ופי׳ משגיח היא המשכת הראיה שמלמעלה בא מן החלונות ע״י בחי׳ חלון שהוא פתוח והוא עד״מ בחי׳ השמחה פתיחת הלב כו׳.13
Meaning: “the voice of my Beloved” is a drawing down; and “watching” is the drawing down of sight, which comes from above “through the windows,” through the level of a window that is open. And this is, by way of analogy, the level of joy, the opening of the heart, etc.
“The voice of my Beloved” is G‑d’s influence drawn down. “Watching through the windows” is G‑d’s gaze coming through an open window: in human terms, joy, which opens the heart.
After a long run of cross-references on “seeing” and “great love,” the paragraph introduces the verse that frames the rest of the maamar: G‑d watches “through the windows” and peers “through the lattices,” and an open window is the image of joy.
A gloss in the Kehot note, copied from Likkutei Torah on Beha’aloscha, cites the Zohar (Emor 103a) for the letters of Aharon as nireh. Tanya chapter 26, cited by the note, explains that joy is what “opens the heart,” which fits the “open window” here.
Marei mekomos
- 1וה׳ עליהם יראה · Zechariah 9:14
- 2אעברה נא ואראה · Deuteronomy 3:25
- 3אהרן אותיות נראה · Zohar, Emor 42:260–269
- 4יראה כל זכורך · Deuteronomy 16:16
- 5למען תזכרו · Numbers 15:40
- 6וראיתם אותו · Numbers 15:39
- 7מציץ מן החרכים · Song of Songs 2:9
- 8וע׳ בזהר פקודי (דרכ״ה ע״ב) ע״פ עיני ה׳ אל צדיקים · Zohar, Pekudei 14:88–96
- 9עיני ה׳ אל צדיקים · Psalms 34:16
- 10ור״פ בחקתי (דקי״ב סע״א) ואשגח עלן · Zohar, Bechukotai 1:1–4
- 11פ׳ שלח קס״ה סע״ב · Zohar, Sh'lach 19:169–21:178
- 12קול דודי הנה זה בא כו׳ משגיח מן החלונות מציץ מן החרכים · Song of Songs 2:8–9
- 13
10וזהו בזמן שהיה בהמ״ק קיים שהיתה השמחה על מכונה והיו מקבלים בחינת הראיה בגילוי הלב בבחינת חלון פתוח
And this is [what took place] in the time when the Holy Temple stood, when the joy was in its proper place and they received the level of seeing with a revealed heart, in the manner of an open window.
When the Temple stood, the joy of the festivals was complete, and the Jewish heart was open like a window, so they received G‑d’s gaze in a revealed way.
וזהו עיניך יונים1 כמשל היונים שמסתכלים זה בזה וזהו תענוגן ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה אני ישנה כו׳ גבי יונתי.
And this is “your eyes are doves”: like doves, which gaze at one another, and this is their delight. And see what is written about this in the section beginning “I am asleep, etc.,” regarding “my dove.”
“Your eyes are doves”: doves gaze into each other’s eyes, and this mutual look is their pleasure. So too G‑d and Israel looked at one another openly.
אך בזמן שאין בהמ״ק קיים הוא מציץ מן החרכים ע״י נקב וסדק קטן שבכותל (וע׳ בזהר פ׳ בחקתי) (דף קי״ד ע״ב) על פסוק זה.
But in the time when the Holy Temple does not stand, He “peers through the lattices,” through a small hole and crack in the wall. (And see the Zohar, Parshas Bechukosai) (page 114b), on this verse.
In exile, without the Temple, G‑d’s gaze comes only through the “lattices,” small holes and cracks in a wall. There is still a gaze, but it passes through a barrier.
ומענין חלון הנה בזהר (ח״א ק״מ ע״ב) ע״פ וישקף כו׳ בעד החלון2 פי׳ באצטגנינותא דיליה. ור״פ בלק (דקפ״ד ב׳) מאי בעד החלון דא חלון דחכמתא.3
And on the theme of “window”: in the Zohar (volume I, 140b), on the verse “And he looked out, etc., through the window,” it explains: through his astrology. And at the beginning of Parshas Balak (184b): “What is ‘through the window’? This is the window of wisdom.”
The Alter Rebbe gathers Zohar passages on the image of a “window.” In one it is Avimelech’s astrology; in another it is “the window of wisdom.”
וע״ש במק״מ ובפי׳ הרמ״ז שם בשם הרמ״ק ומהתם נלמוד ג״כ לסט׳ דקדושה. ועד״ז פי׳ במ״א דחלון הוא חסדים שביסוד וחרכים גבורות שביסוד.
And see there in the Mikdash Melech, and in the commentary of the Ramaz there in the name of the Ramak; and from there we will learn [it] also for the side of holiness. And along these lines it is explained elsewhere that the window is the chasadim that are in Yesod, and the lattices are the gevuros that are in Yesod.
The commentators on the Zohar show that the image also applies in holiness. Elsewhere, the window is the chasadim (kindnesses) in Yesod, the channel of influence, and the lattices are the gevuros (severities) in Yesod.
ובפרדס בעה״כ בערך חלון ע״פ חלון התיבה4 פי׳ דחלון הוא הדעת שממשיך ומחבר חו״ב או שהוא בחי׳ תפארת כו׳
In Rabbi Moshe Cordovero’s Pardes, the “window” of Noah’s ark is Daas, which joins Chochmah and Binah, or else Tiferes. Both are connecting levels that let light pass from one level to another.
And see what is written on the verse “And I will make your windows (shimshosayich) of kadkod”: the meaning of shimshosayich is windows, and it is the revelation of the level of “sun (shemesh)… Havayah,” etc.
Isaiah’s “I will make your windows of kadkod” uses shimshosayich for “windows,” from shemesh, sun. A window lets in the sun, and the “sun” is Havayah, as the next paragraph shows.
The two gazes are tied to history: in Temple times G‑d’s gaze came through an open “window,” with joy; in exile it comes through the narrow “lattices.” The paragraph then collects the Kabbalistic meanings of “window.”
The pairing of chasadim and gevuros within Yesod, and of Daas or Tiferes as the connecting “window,” all describe a channel through which a higher light passes to a lower level. This prepares for the Etz Chaim passage that follows, which calls every such channel a “window.”
Marei mekomos
- 1עיניך יונים · Song of Songs 1:15
- 2וישקף כו׳ בעד החלון · Genesis 26:8
- 3ור״פ בלק (דקפ״ד ב׳) מאי בעד החלון דא חלון דחכמתא · Zohar, Balak 1:1–6
- 4חלון התיבה · Genesis 8:6
- 5ושמתי כדכד שמשותיך · Isaiah 54:12
- 6
Windows and lattices in Kabbalah ¶11–16
11ובע״ח בתחלתו שער הכללים רפ״א כ׳ וז״ל ודע כי שמש ומגן1 ה׳ צבאות וכמו שהשמש אור עליון גדול ואין יכולת להביט בו כ״א בהתמעטות דרך חלון או ע״י מסך כו׳ או ע״י נקב קטן כו׳.
And in Etz Chaim, at its beginning, Shaar HaKelalim, at the beginning of chapter 1, he writes, and this is his wording: “Know that ‘a sun and a shield is G‑d of Hosts’; and just as the sun is a great supernal light, and one cannot gaze at it except when it is diminished, through a window, or through a screen, etc., or through a small hole, etc.
The Alter Rebbe quotes the opening of Etz Chaim, the Arizal’s main work. The sun is too bright to look at directly; its light can only be received when it is diminished, through a window, a screen or a small hole.
The paragraph begins a quotation from Etz Chaim that uses the sun as a model for how Divine light is received: only in diminished form, through a window, a screen or a small hole.
The verse “G‑d is a sun and a shield” pairs the sun (the light) with the shield (what screens it). Etz Chaim builds its whole account of how light descends through the worlds on this image.
Marei mekomos
- 1שמש ומגן · Psalms 84:12
12והנה בעולם הצילות האור בא שלא ע״י מסך כלל כו׳ אבל בא ע״י חלון פי׳ מיסוד דא״א הנק׳ חלון שנתמעט האור מכמות
“Now, in the World of Atzilus the light comes not through any screen at all, etc., but it comes through a window, that is, from the Yesod of Arich Anpin, which is called a window, so that the light is diminished from the measure
In Atzilus, the highest world, there is no screen at all, only “windows.” The first window is the Yesod (channel) of Arich Anpin, the highest configuration, which lets through only part of its light.
שהוא גם מחכמה לבינה בא ע״י חלון פי׳ מיסוד אבא שהוא חלון אחר קטן כו׳
that it has. Also from Chochmah to Binah it comes through a window, that is, from the Yesod of Abba, which is another, smaller window, etc.
From Chochmah to Binah the light passes through a smaller window, the Yesod of Abba (Chochmah).
אח״כ מיסוד למלכות בא האור מחלון קטן וצר מאד פי׳ מיסוד דז״א הנקרא חלון ג״כ וצר מאד דוגמת נקב קטן כו׳ אך מבריאה ולמטה האור בא ע״י מסך גמור והאור עובר בתוכו ומאיר עכ״ל.
Afterwards, from Yesod to Malchus, the light comes from a window that is small and very narrow, that is, from the Yesod of Z’eir Anpin, which is also called a window and is very narrow, like a small hole, etc. But from Beriah downward the light comes through a complete screen, and the light passes through it and shines.” End of quote.
From Z’eir Anpin to Malchus the window is smaller still, like a small hole. Below Atzilus, from Beriah down, there is no window but a full screen: the light passes through a barrier.
וע׳ מזה ג״כ בע״ח היכל הז׳ (שער מ״א רפ״א וספ״ב. ובשער מ״ז פ״א) שהמל׳ דאצילות משברת ובוקעת את המסך שבין אצילות לבריאה ויורדת ומתלבשת בכתר דבריאה.
And see about this also in Etz Chaim, Heichal 7 (Shaar 41, beginning of chapter 1 and end of chapter 2; and Shaar 47, chapter 1): that the Malchus of Atzilus breaks and splits the screen between Atzilus and Beriah, and descends and is clothed in the Keser of Beriah.
Another passage in Etz Chaim says that Malchus of Atzilus breaks through the screen between Atzilus and Beriah, descends, and becomes the Keser (highest level) of Beriah.
ועפ״ז י״ל שזהו ענין מציץ מן החרכים שהוא מה שמשברים הכותל ונעשה חרך ונקב קטן וכך הוא שהמל׳ משברת המסך כו׳
And according to this it may be said that this is the meaning of “peering through the lattices”: it is when the wall is broken and a lattice-opening, a small hole, is made. And so it is that Malchus breaks the screen, etc.
This explains “peering through the lattices”: a lattice is a hole made by breaking through a wall. Malchus breaking the screen is such a hole.
ואין זה דומה לחלון שהוא גילוי האור ממש בלי מסך וכותל שיצטרכו לשוברו וכמש״ש ספ״א שכבר אין לה ערך עם אצילות כו׳ ע״ש באריכות.
And this is not like a window, which is an actual revelation of the light, without a screen and wall that would need to be broken; and as is written there at the end of chapter 1, that it no longer has any comparison with Atzilus, etc.; see there at length.
A “window” is different: there is no wall to break, and the light is revealed directly. Once Malchus is inside Beriah, it is no longer comparable to Atzilus.
Etz Chaim’s account gives the key: within Atzilus light passes through ever-narrower “windows,” while between Atzilus and Beriah there is a screen that Malchus must break through; the “windows” are the first, the “lattices” the second.
The Kehot notes correct the chapter numbers cited here: the gate the text calls Shaar 41 is the gate of Derushei ABYA, and in current editions the passages are at the beginning of chapter 13 and the end of chapter 14; “Shaar 47” is the Shaar ABYA of our editions, chapters 1–2, and “the end of chapter 1” should read chapter 6 there.
13ואפשר להבין מעט ענין זה עפמ״ש בביאור ע״פ כי תשמע בקול בפ׳ ראה שיש ב׳ השגחות.
And one may understand this matter a little in light of what is explained in the explanation on the verse “If you will listen to the voice,” in Parshas Re’eh: that there are two kinds of providence.
The Alter Rebbe offers a further way to understand the two gazes, from a maamar on Parshas Re’eh that speaks of two kinds of Divine providence.
הא׳ באופן כמו שהוא מלמעלה למטה דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב יחו״ע ולפעמים משגיח כמו שהוא בבי״ע כו׳
The first is in the manner as it is from above to below, where “all before Him is considered as nothing”: the higher unity (yichuda ila’ah). And at times He watches as it is in [the worlds of] Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, etc.
In the first, G‑d looks from His own perspective, where all creation is as nothing: the “higher unity.” In the second, He looks at the worlds as they appear from below, in Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, as existing things.
וזהו ענין חלונות וחרכים שבבחי׳ חלונות היינו כמו שהוא באצילות שהאור בא שלא ע״י מסך כלל והיינו הגילוי כמו דכולא קמיה כלא כו׳.
And this is the matter of windows and lattices. The level of windows is as it is in Atzilus, where the light comes without any screen at all; that is, the revelation as “all before Him is as nothing, etc.”
The “windows” are the first kind: as in Atzilus, where there is no screen, everything is nullified before G‑d.
משא״כ חרכים היינו נקב וסדק שבכותל שהכותל הוא ענין המסך המפסיק שהוא הגורם להיות בחי׳ יש ואע״פ שהמל׳ דאצי׳ בוקעת המסך ונעשה
Whereas lattices are a hole and crack in the wall, the wall being the separating screen, which is what causes there to be a level of “something” (yesh). And even though the Malchus of Atzilus splits the screen and there comes to be
The “lattices” are the second kind. The wall is the screen that makes creatures feel they exist on their own (yesh, a “something”).
כמו נקב וסדק ומזה נמשך ביטול היש מ״מ היינו יש ובטל יחו״ת וההשגחה שבבחינה ואופן זה נק׳ מציץ מן החרכים.
something like a hole and crack, from which the self-nullification of the “something” is drawn, nonetheless this is a “something” that is nullified: the lower unity (yichuda tata’ah). And the providence that is in this level and manner is called “peering through the lattices.”
Malchus breaks a hole in this screen, so that the created “something” becomes nullified before G‑d, but it remains a something. That is the “lower unity”: the world exists, yet it is bound to G‑d. G‑d’s gaze through this hole is “peering through the lattices.”
The windows and lattices are two modes of Divine providence: the higher unity, in which creation is nothing before G‑d, and the lower unity, in which creation exists but is nullified to Him.
The higher and lower unity (yichuda ila’ah and yichuda tata’ah) are a central pair in Chabad teaching: in the first, the world is nothing next to G‑d; in the second, G‑d is present within the world’s existence.
And according to this the Midrash on Song of Songs on this verse will be explained: “‘Watching through the windows’: this is the merit of the Patriarchs; ‘peering through the lattices’: this is the merit of the Matriarchs.”
The Midrash says that G‑d “watches through the windows” in the merit of the Patriarchs and “peers through the lattices” in the merit of the Matriarchs. The distinction between the two gazes now explains why.
כי הנה נתבאר בד״ה לבבתני כו׳ באחד מעיניך כתיב והקרי באחת.2 היינו כי בכנס״י שהחכ מים נק׳ עיני העדה3 שהם בבחי׳ לאסתכלא ביקרא דמלכא יש
For it is explained in the section beginning “You have captured my heart, etc.,” [that in] “with one of your eyes” it is written be’achad [masculine] and read be’achas [feminine]. That is: in the Community of Israel, whose sages are called “the eyes of the congregation,” who are in the level of “gazing at the glory of the King,” there are
In Song of Songs 4:9, “with one of your eyes” is written in the masculine form and read in the feminine. The “eyes” are the sages of Israel, whose task is to “gaze at the glory of the King.”
שהם בבחי׳ באחד ל׳ דכר שהם מסתכלים בביטול דיחו״ע כמו דקמיה כולא כלא כו׳ ויש שהם בבחי׳ ביטול דיחו״ת כו׳.
those who are in the level of be’achad, a masculine term, who gaze in the self-nullification of the higher unity, as “before Him all is as nothing, etc.”; and there are those who are in the level of the self-nullification of the lower unity, etc.
The masculine form stands for those whose self-nullification is that of the higher unity; the feminine for those of the lower unity. The Patriarchs correspond to the first, the Matriarchs to the second.
The Midrash that links the windows with the Patriarchs and the lattices with the Matriarchs is explained through two kinds of self-nullification among the “eyes” of Israel: the male, of the higher unity, and the female, of the lower unity.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2באחד מעיניך כתיב והקרי באחת · Song of Songs 4:9
- 3עיני העדה · Numbers 15:24
15וזהו ענין האבות והאמהות דכר ונוק׳ מלמעלה למטה ומלמטה למעלה ועד״ז נמשך ג״כ ההשגחה מלמעלה מן החלונות ע״י זכות אבות והם היסודות דאצילות כנ״ל ומן החרכים מה שהמל׳ שוברת המסך כו׳ ע״י זכות אמהות.
And this is the matter of the Patriarchs and the Matriarchs: male and female, from above to below and from below to above. And in this way the providence from above is also drawn: “through the windows,” through the merit of the Patriarchs, and these are the Yesods of Atzilus, as above; and “through the lattices,” which is Malchus breaking the screen, etc., through the merit of the Matriarchs.
The Patriarchs are “male,” a flow from above to below; the Matriarchs are “female,” an ascent from below to above. So the gaze “through the windows” (the channels of Atzilus) comes by the merit of the Patriarchs, and the gaze “through the lattices” (Malchus breaking the screen) by the merit of the Matriarchs.
וז״ש בזהר ויחי (דרמ״ז ע״א) ע״פ בנות צעדה עלי שור.1 ההוא עין דכתיב לעילא כו׳
And this is what is said in the Zohar, Vayechi (247a), on the verse “Daughters stepped upon the wall (shur)”: “That eye of which it is written above, etc.”
A Zohar passage supports this. It reads Jacob’s blessing, “daughters stepped upon the wall (shur),” as speaking of the Divine “eye.”
כי שור הוא לשון הבטה והסתכלות והשגחה זו נמשך ע״י המלאכים דהיכלות דבריאה וזהו ענין החרכים כו׳.
For shur is a term of looking, gazing and watching; and this watching is drawn through the angels of the chambers of Beriah, and this is the matter of the lattices, etc.
Shur can mean “to look.” The “daughters” are the angels of the chambers of Beriah, through whom the gaze passes below Atzilus, and that is the gaze “through the lattices.”
א״נ י״ל חלונות וחרכים יש ג״כ בהתלבשות בבי״ע ע״ד מ״ש בד״ה ארדה נא2 ואראה3 בענין ב׳ הבחינות דלפעמים כתיב עיני ה׳ המה משוטטים4 ולפעמים כתיב עיניו משוטטות56 לשון נוק׳.
Alternatively, it may be said that there are windows and lattices also in the enclothement in Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, along the lines of what is written in the section beginning “Let me go down, please, and see,” regarding the two levels: at times it is written, “the eyes of G‑d, they roam” [meshotetim], and at times it is written, “His eyes roam” [meshotetos], a feminine term.
A second approach: windows and lattices exist also within the lower worlds themselves. Scripture speaks of G‑d’s roaming eyes once in a masculine verb form and once in a feminine one, matching the two kinds of gaze.
וקרוב לזה איתא ברע״מ פ׳ משפטים (דקי״ז סע״א)7 עיניו על דרכי איש8 ובהון משגיח מן החלונות בז׳ נקבין דב״נ בתרין עיינין ותרין אודנין כו׳ ע״ש.
And close to this is found in the Ra’aya Mehemna, Parshas Mishpatim (117a, at the end): “His eyes are upon the ways of man,” and through them “He watches through the windows,” through the seven openings of a person: through the two eyes and two ears, etc.; see there.
The Ra’aya Mehemna (a section of the Zohar) similarly says that G‑d “watches through the windows” by means of the seven openings of the human head: the eyes, ears and so on.
ובזהר פקודי (דר״נ ע״א) תריסר גלגלין9 כו׳ ואינון אקרון שרפים כו׳ אלין אינון קיימין לאשגחא תדיר כו׳ ואקרון חלונות והיינו דכתיב משגיח מן החלונות כו׳.
And in the Zohar, Pekudei (250a): “Twelve wheels, etc., and they are called Seraphim, etc. These stand to watch constantly, etc., and they are called windows; and this is what is written, ‘watching through the windows,’ etc.”
Another Zohar passage describes twelve angelic “wheels,” called Seraphim, who watch constantly; they are called “windows.”
ושם ריש עמוד ב׳ מאלין נפקי ארבע סמכין10 לאינון תריסר דקאמרן כו׳ ואלין אקרון חרכים כד״א מציץ מן החרכים11 כו׳
And there, at the beginning of side b: “From these go out four supports to those twelve we mentioned, etc., and these are called lattices, as it says, ‘peering through the lattices,’ etc.
Beneath them are four “supports,” called “lattices.”
מציץ כמאן דאשגח מאתר דקיק דחמי ולא חמי כל מה דאצטריך ולבתר משגיח מן החלונות אתר אשגחותא יתיר.
‘Peering’: like one who watches from a narrow place, who sees and does not see all that is needed; and afterwards, ‘watching through the windows,’ a place of greater watching.”
The Zohar explains the difference: “peering” is looking through a narrow opening, seeing only in part; “watching through the windows” is a fuller view.
(ודרנ״א ע״א) לעילא כנסת הגדולה אית בה תריסר חלונות עילאין12 כו׳ וע״ש במק״מ שהם י״ב אותיות של שם אד׳ מלא.
(And 251a): “Above, the Great Assembly has twelve supernal windows, etc.” And see there in the Mikdash Melech, that they are the twelve letters of the Name Ado-nai spelled out in full.
Above them is “the Great Assembly” (Malchus of Atzilus) with twelve windows. The commentary Mikdash Melech identifies them with the twelve letters of the Name Ado-nai spelled out in full (alef-lamed-pei, dalet-lamed-tav, nun-vav-nun, yud-vav-dalet).
וע׳ במק״מ ר״פ בראשית סוף המאמר כשושנה בין החוחים מצאתי בדברי האריז״ל שנקודת המ׳ היורדת לבריאה נק׳ בשם אד׳.13141516171819202122232425262728
And see in the Mikdash Melech at the beginning of Bereshis, at the end of the passage “Like a rose among the thorns”: “I found in the words of the Arizal that the point of Malchus that descends to Beriah is called by the Name Ado-nai.”
Ado-nai is the Name of Malchus. The Mikdash Melech quotes the Arizal that the point of Malchus that descends into Beriah is called by this Name, which connects the “windows” to Malchus.
The paragraph links the two gazes to the merit of the Patriarchs (male, from above) and the Matriarchs (female, from below), and supports this with Zohar passages that call angelic levels “windows” and “lattices.”
The Zohar’s twelve “windows” of the Great Assembly, tied to the twelve letters of Ado-nai spelled out, point to Malchus as the channel of the gaze into the lower worlds. This is why the next paragraph connects them to the thirteen petals of the “rose.”
Marei mekomos
- 1בנות צעדה עלי שור · Genesis 49:22
- 2בד״ה ארדה נא · תו״א פ׳ וירא.
- 3אעברה נא ואראה · Deuteronomy 3:25
- 4עיני ה׳ המה משוטטים · Zechariah 4:10
- 5עיניו משוטטות · II Chronicles 9:9
- 6עיניו משוטטות · II Chronicles 16:9
- 7ברע״מ פ׳ משפטים (דקי״ז סע״א) · Zohar, Mishpatim 13:433–14:443
- 8עיניו על דרכי איש · Job 34:21
- 9ובזהר פקודי (דר״נ ע״א) תריסר גלגלין · Zohar, Pekudei 48:571–582
- 10ושם ריש עמוד ב׳ מאלין נפקי ארבע סמכין · Zohar, Pekudei 48:582–590
- 11מציץ מן החרכים · Song of Songs 2:9
- 12(ודרנ״א ע״א) לעילא כנסת הגדולה אית בה תריסר חלונות עילאין · Zohar, Pekudei 48:590–49:602
- 13אהרן אותיות נראה · ואדמו״ר כ׳ ע״ז בזה״ל כמ״ש בזהר פ׳ אמור דק״ג תחלת ע״א ובמק״מ ובהרמ״ז שם, עכלה״ט. (הועתק מח׳ במדבר [בהעלתך] (ל, א). [כ].
- 14ועיין מענין יראה . . קס״ח א׳) · ראה אוה״ת פ׳ משפטים ע׳ א׳קצג.
- 15קול דודי הנה זה בא · Song of Songs 2:8
- 16בד״ה ועשית ציץ · תו״א פג, א.
- 17בד״ה עיני כל אליך ישברו · לעיל פ׳ מטות.
- 18בחי׳ השמחה פתיחת הלב · ראה תניא פ׳ כו.
- 19עיניך יונים · Song of Songs 1:15
- 20פ׳ בחקותי (דף קי״ד ע״ב) · ראה אוה״ת שה״ש כרך א ע׳ רפב הטעם ע״ז.
- 21ובפרדס בעה״כ ערך חלון · ראה המשך וככה תרל״ז פרק כט. המשך מצה זו תר״מ סעי׳ לא. ד״ה צהר תרנ״ח ע׳ ז.
- 22שער מ״א רפ״א וספ״ב. ובשער מ״ז פ״א · כמ״ש כאן ל״מ. וידוע שש׳ דרושי אבי״ע קרא אדמו״ר ש׳ מ״א. ומ״ש רפ״א לפננו רפי״ג. ומ״ש ספ״ב כוונתו ל”ספי״ד” כצ״ל. ומ״ש כאן ובש׳ מ״ז פ״א וזהו ממש שער ס׳ אבי״ע שלפננו, והוא בפ״א ובפ״ב. [כ].
- 23וכמש״ש ספ״א · בש׳ מ״ז הנ״ל (פ״ו) כצ״ל, כי באופן אחר אין לישב, ופשוט. [כ].
- 24המדרש שה״ש · פ״ב, ט.
- 25בד״ה לבבתני · לקמן שה״ש.
- 26שהחכמים נק׳ עיני העדה · ע׳ ת״ז (תכ״א) ד״נ ע״ב. שהש״ר (פ״ז סי׳ ט [ד, ב]). וע״ל (ב, ד). [כ].
- 27לאסתכלא ביקרא דמלכא · ע׳ סש״ב ח״א רפ״ט. וש״נ. והוא בזח״ג קצט, א. לח, ב. [כ].
- 28
16ומזה יובן שייכות ענין זה למש״כ אח״כ בסמוך בענין כשושנה בין החוחים. כי הנה בזהר הרקיע שם ר״פ בראשית ד״ה מה שושנה1 כו׳
And from this will be understood the connection of this matter to what is written shortly afterwards regarding “like a rose among the thorns.” For in the Zohar HaRakia there, at the beginning of Bereshis, on the passage “What is the rose, etc.,”
The twelve windows also explain the verse that comes right after in Song of Songs, “like a rose among the thorns.” The Zohar HaRakia, a commentary on the Zohar, discusses the Zohar’s opening passage about the rose.
פי׳ שכינתא תתאה העומדת על י״ב בקר והים עומד עליהם מלמעלה2 הרי הם י״ג והם י״ג עלין דילה. אשר כעין זה ממש הוא ענין י״ב חלונות הנ״ל דכנסת הגדולה דלעילא כו׳ וד״ל.
he explains: the lower Shechinah, which stands upon the twelve oxen, with the sea standing upon them from above; thus they are thirteen, and they are its thirteen petals. And just like this, exactly, is the matter of the above-mentioned twelve windows of the Great Assembly above, etc.; and this suffices for the understanding.
The rose is the lower Shechinah (Malchus), pictured as the great “sea” in Solomon’s Temple that stood on twelve oxen: twelve plus one, like the rose’s thirteen petals. The twelve windows of the Great Assembly are the same structure.
The paragraph connects the twelve “windows” of Malchus to the thirteen petals of the “rose,” the Shechinah, so that the image of the lattices and the image of the rose describe one reality.
Marei mekomos
- 1ר״פ בראשית ד״ה מה שושנה · Zohar, Introduction 1:1–2:4
- 2העומדת על י״ב בקר והים עומד עליהם מלמעלה · I Kings 7:25
Breaking the screen through teshuvah and joy ¶17–18
17והנה אפשר להבין ענין זה דחלונות וחרכים שבבי״ע עצמן איך ידמה ענין זה לדרך שנת׳ לעיל דחלונות היינו באצילות שהאור נמשך שלא ע״י מסך וחרכים היינו שבירת המסך.
Now, one may understand this matter of windows and lattices within Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah themselves: how it resembles the manner explained above, that windows are in Atzilus, where the light is drawn without a screen, and lattices are the breaking of the screen.
The Alter Rebbe now explains how there can be “windows” and “lattices” inside the lower worlds, when above he said that windows belong to Atzilus and lattices to the breaking of the screen below it.
והענין דכמו שיש מסך בין אצי׳ לבי״ע שבאצילות הוא ביטול אמיתי ובבי״ע מחמת המסך נעשה בחי׳ יש אלא שאעפ״כ הוא ביטול היש.
The matter is that just as there is a screen between Atzilus and Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, so that in Atzilus there is true self-nullification, while in Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah, because of the screen, a level of “something” (yesh) comes into being, except that nonetheless it is a nullification of the “something,”
Between Atzilus and the lower worlds there is a screen: in Atzilus everything is truly nullified, while below it created things feel that they exist, yet they are still nullified to G‑d.
כך עד״ז יש מסך המפסיק בין קדושה לסט״א. שהוא מסך מבדיל גמור שמעלים ומסתיר האור עד שנעשה נפרד ממש
so too, in the same way, there is a screen that separates between holiness and the sitra achra: a completely dividing screen, which hides and conceals the light until it becomes actually separate,
In the same way there is a second, much thicker screen between holiness and the sitra achra (the “other side,” opposed to holiness). It hides the light so fully that what lies beyond it feels entirely separate from G‑d.
כמו היכלות החיצונים. וכמ״ש כ״ז בפ׳ לך לך בד״ה ולא יקרא עוד את שמך אברם.
like the outer chambers. And all this is explained in Parshas Lech Lecha, in the section beginning “And your name shall no longer be called Avram.”
This is the realm of the “outer chambers,” the chambers of kelipah. The Alter Rebbe refers to a maamar in Torah Ohr on Lech Lecha for the full explanation.
The paragraph sets up a second pair of levels: just as a screen divides Atzilus from the lower worlds, a stronger screen divides holiness from the sitra achra.
18והנה ע״י התשובה ולב נשבר ורוח נשברה123 משברים מסך הנ״ל שיהיו בחי׳ החולין ג״כ נעשים על טהרת הקדש כו׳
Now, through teshuvah, a broken heart and a broken spirit, one breaks the above-mentioned screen, so that the level of the mundane too comes to be done in the purity of holiness, etc.
Teshuvah (return to G‑d) with a broken heart breaks this second screen, so that even ordinary, permitted things are raised into holiness.
וזהו ענין החרכים דהיינו שבירת מסך הנ״ל אמנם החלונות זהו הגילוי כמו שהוא בבריאה למעלה מבחי׳ מסך המפסיק בין קדושה כו׳.
And this is the matter of the lattices, that is, the breaking of the above-mentioned screen. The windows, however, are the revelation as it is in Beriah, above the level of the screen that separates between holiness, etc.
Breaking the screen in this way is the “lattices.” The “windows” are a higher revelation, like that of Beriah, where there is no screen between holiness and its opposite at all.
וזהו ע״י פתיחת הלב דהיינו שמחה וטוב4 לב מרוב כל שלאחר בחי׳ לב נשבר כו׳ ועד״ז יתבאר מאמר הזהר דפ׳ בחקתי (דקי״ד ע״ב)5
And this is through the opening of the heart, that is, “joy and gladness of heart from the abundance of everything,” which comes after the level of the broken heart, etc. And in this way the saying of the Zohar in Parshas Bechukosai (114b) will be explained:
The “windows” come from an open heart, the joy that follows the broken heart. So the order of service is first a broken heart, then joy, echoing “scatter” and then “hearken” at the start of the maamar.
וסליק כותלין לאסתכלא ולאשגחא בין נקבי כותלא עלייהו ופי׳ סליק היינו שביו״ט ההמשכה נמשך ע״י עולם הבריאה ויצי׳ ועשייה עולות לשם כו׳.
“And He goes up the walls to look and to watch over them between the holes of the wall.” And the meaning of “goes up” is that on Yom Tov the drawing down is drawn through the World of Beriah, [for] Yetzirah and Asiyah rise there, etc.
The Zohar says that G‑d “goes up the walls” to watch through their holes. “Goes up” is read to mean that on Yom Tov the lower worlds rise into Beriah, so the gaze comes through Beriah.
וענין חלונות לשון רבים י״ל ע״ד מ״ש בזהר (ח״ב דל״ז ע״א) בפי׳ המשפילי לראות6 מכתרא לכתרא כו׳ מנהירו לנהירו כו׳ והיינו כנ״ל מיסוד דא״א לח״ע ומיסוד אבא כו׳ וכנ״ל. וע״ש במק״מ.
And the matter of “windows” in the plural may be understood along the lines of what is written in the Zohar (volume II, 37a), explaining “who lowers [Himself] to see”: “from crown to crown, etc., from light to light, etc.”; that is, as above, from the Yesod of Arich Anpin to Supernal Chochmah, and from the Yesod of Abba, etc., as above. And see there in the Mikdash Melech.
Why “windows” in the plural? Because, as the Zohar says, G‑d’s light descends “from crown to crown,” through several windows, as the Etz Chaim passage above described.
ובספר עמה״מ שער השני פ״א פי׳ החלונות ה׳ חלונות דהיינו ה׳ בחינות ההוי״ה ה׳ פרצופים עם הקוץ העליון של היו״ד והם ארובות השמי׳7 הנוזלי׳ חכמה כו׳ ועד״ז החרכים ה׳ חרכים ה״ג וע״ש דהיינו גם למעלה מהאצילות.8
And in the book Emek HaMelech, Second Gate, chapter 1, he explains the windows as five windows, that is, the five levels of Havayah, the five partzufim, with the upper tip of the yud; and they are “the windows of heaven,” which flow with wisdom, etc. And in the same way the lattices are five lattices, the five gevuros; and see there, that this is also above Atzilus.
Emek HaMelech counts five windows, the five partzufim (configurations) of the Name Havayah together with the tip of the yud, and five lattices, the five gevuros (severities). It places them even above Atzilus.
Teshuvah with a broken heart breaks the screen of the sitra achra, and this is the “lattices”; joy that follows the broken heart opens the “windows.” The paragraph then explains why the verse speaks of “windows” in the plural.
The sequence, a broken heart and then joy, repeats in another key the maamar’s opening theme of “scatter” and then “hearken.” The Kehot note sends the reader to several Zohar passages on the broken heart and spirit.
Marei mekomos
- 1ולב נשבר ורוח נשברה · Psalms 51:19
- 2ולב נשבר ורוח נשברה · Zohar, Vayikra 20:119–128
- 3ולב נשבר ורוח נשברה · Zohar, Vayikra 6:51–7:61
- 4שמחה וטוב לבב מרוב כל · Deuteronomy 28:47
- 5מאמר הזהר דפ׳ בחקתי (דקי״ד ע״ב) · Zohar, Bechukotai 9:36–11:44
- 6המשפילי לראות · Psalms 113:6
- 7ארובות השמי׳ · Genesis 7:11
- 8
The second feast: the second day of Yom Tov ¶19
19והנה בהתגלות המלך יש מדרגות רבות1 חלוקות כמ״ש על כסא מלכותו אשר בשושן הבירה כו׳ עשה משתה2 לכל שריו ועבדיו כו׳.
Now, in the revelation of the King there are many distinct levels, as it is written, “on his royal throne, which is in Shushan the capital, etc., he made a feast for all his princes and his servants, etc.
A new approach to the second day of Yom Tov, built on the Book of Esther. King Achashverosh’s celebration had stages: first a feast for his princes and servants.
and the princes of the provinces before him, etc.” And afterwards, “for all the people who were present in Shushan, from great to small, etc., in the court of the garden of the king’s palace, etc.”
Afterwards came a second feast, for all the people of Shushan, great and small, held in the outer court of the palace garden.
כך הוא בבחינת הראי׳ שמלמעלה שבחי׳ שריו ועבדיו [כמ״ש במ״א בענין מאמר רבי יוחנן בן זכאי על ר׳ חנינא בן דוסא שאני כשר לפני המלך והוא כעבד לפני המלך (בגמ׳ ספ״ה דברכות)
So it is with the level of seeing from above: the level of “his princes and his servants” (as is explained elsewhere regarding the saying of Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai about Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, “I am like a minister before the King, and he is like a servant before the King” (in the Gemara, end of chapter 5 of Berachos);
G‑d’s revelation likewise has stages. The “princes and servants” are the lofty souls; the parenthesis recalls the Talmud’s contrast between the “minister” and the “servant” who stand before the King in different ways.
ועמ״ש ע״פ באר חפרוה שרים7 כו׳ ובענין עבד בד״ה ועתה יגדל נא]8 הם בחינת נשמות הגבוהות שבזמן בית המקדש היו מקבלים בחי׳ ראייה מכסא מלכותו כו׳.
and see what is written on the verse “A well that princes dug, etc.,” and, on the matter of “servant,” in the section beginning “And now, please, let the strength be great”) is the level of the lofty souls, who in the time of the Holy Temple would receive the level of seeing from “his royal throne,” etc.
These lofty souls, in Temple times, received the “seeing” directly from the King’s throne, the highest level of revelation.
פי׳ בהגלות נגלות בבחי׳ כסא מלכותו בבית המלכות נכח פתח הבית9 כו׳ שהוא בחי׳ גבוה ומדרגה גבוה מאד נעלה (ע׳ בע״ח שער כסא הכבוד שהוא היכל קה״ק דבריאה וע׳ בסש״ב) (ח״א פנ״ג).
That is: in the revelation, he was revealed in the level of “his royal throne,” “in the royal house, opposite the entrance of the house,” etc., which is a lofty level, a very high and exalted rank. (See Etz Chaim, the Gate of the Throne of Glory, that it is the Chamber of the Holy of Holies of Beriah; and see Sefer shel Beinonim) (Part I, chapter 53).
The King sitting “in the royal house, opposite the entrance” is the first, exalted revelation. Etz Chaim calls the Throne of Glory the innermost chamber (the Holy of Holies) of Beriah, and Tanya is cited for the same idea.
א״נ שהמלכות דאצילות עצמה נק׳ כסא כמ״ש בביאור דפ׳ זכור וזהו אשר בשושן בחי׳ שושנת העמקים10 שושן עמק איומה11 כו׳
Alternatively, the Malchus of Atzilus itself is called a “throne,” as is explained in the explanation on Parshas Zachor. And this is “which is in Shushan”: the level of “the rose (shoshanas) of the valleys,” “Shushan, the valley of the awesome one,” etc.
Alternatively, the “throne” is Malchus of Atzilus itself. “Shushan” is linked to shoshanah, the rose: the higher “rose of the valleys.”
משא״כ בזמן שאין בהמ״ק קיים צריך גילוי בחינה ומדרגה השנית שהיא בחצר גינת ביתן המלך שהוא לכל העם הנמצאים בשושן
Whereas in the time when the Holy Temple does not stand, there is need for the revelation of the second level and rank, which is “in the court of the garden of the king’s palace,” which is “for all the people who were present in Shushan,”
Without the Temple there is need for the second, lower revelation, the one in the outer court, which is given to “all the people.”
דהיינו כל מי שיש לו ניצוץ אלקות ממקור כנס״י שהיא בבחי׳ כשושנה בין החוחים12 בגלות כו׳.
that is, everyone who has a spark of G‑dliness from the source of the Community of Israel, which is in the level of “like a rose among the thorns,” in exile, etc.
“All the people” are all Jews, everyone with a spark of G‑dliness from the source of the Jewish people, which in exile is “like a rose among the thorns.”
שהוא גילוי אחר גילוי במדרג׳ אחר מדרגה [עיין בזהר בתחלתו בגין דאית שושנה ואית שושנה13 כו׳ ובזהר הרקיע שם.14
It is a revelation after a revelation, a rank after a rank. (See the Zohar at its beginning, “because there is a rose and there is a rose, etc.,” and the Zohar HaRakia there;
So there is one revelation after another. The bracket lists places in the Zohar that speak of two “roses,” a higher and a lower one.
ובזהר ויחי (דרכ״א ע״א)15 ובמק״מ שם דשושנת העמקים זהו שושנה עילאה ובפ׳ כי תשא (דקפ״ט ריש ע״ב)
and the Zohar, Vayechi (221a), and the Mikdash Melech there, that “the rose of the valleys” is the supernal rose; and Parshas Ki Sisa (189b, at the beginning of side b),
In these passages “the rose of the valleys” is the higher rose, and the rose among the thorns is the lower one.
and in the commentary of the Ramaz there: “And know that the supernal rose, etc.”; and see Sefer Hadras Melech (section 156), and the Zohar, Parshas Pinchas, 233b.)
The Ramaz, a commentator on the Zohar, explains the higher rose in the same way; further references close the bracket.
וצריך לעשות י״ט שני לקבלת בחי׳ הראי׳ גם בבחי׳ זו שאין בהמ״ק קיים שאין אנו יכולים לעלות ולראות18 כו׳. וכמ״ש מי יעלה בהר19 ה׳ כו׳.
And one must make a second day of Yom Tov to receive the level of seeing also in this level, when the Holy Temple does not stand and “we cannot go up and appear, etc.,” and as it is written, “Who shall ascend the mountain of G‑d, etc.”
This is why the second day of Yom Tov is needed: to receive the “seeing” also on this lower level, in exile, when we cannot go up to the Temple to appear before G‑d.
והנה המשכיל יבין כמה תגדל השמחה ביתר שאת20 בגילוי המלך בגילוי אחר גילוי גם לכל העם כו׳
Now, the discerning will understand how much greater, with added eminence, the joy becomes at the revelation of the King in a revelation after a revelation, also to “all the people, etc.,”
Surprisingly, the joy of the second, lower revelation is greater than that of the first, because it reaches ordinary people too.
יותר מגילוי הראשון שהוא לכל שריו כו׳ דוקא וכמשל בן כפר שראה את המלך21 כו׳
more than at the first revelation, which is to “all his princes, etc.” alone; as in the parable of a villager who saw the king, etc.
The Talmud compares the prophet Ezekiel, who described his vision at length, to a villager who saw the king and cannot stop talking about it: the lower one’s excitement is greater.
(והוא כענין והאופנים ברעש גדול22 לגבי השרפים שלפי שהאופנים וחיות הם בעשיי׳ ויצירה תגדל הרעש שלהם יותר מהשרפים שבבריאה וכמ״ש במ״א בכמה דוכתי וע׳ מזה לעיל בד״ה האזינו השמים)
(And this is like the matter of “And the Ofanim, with a great noise,” compared with the Seraphim: because the Ofanim and the Chayos are in Asiyah and Yetzirah, their noise is greater than that of the Seraphim, who are in Beriah, as is explained elsewhere in several places; and see about this above, in the section beginning “Give ear, O heavens.”)
Likewise, the Ofanim, angels of the lower worlds, praise G‑d “with a great noise,” louder than the Seraphim of Beriah, because they are farther away.
And as is found in the Tikkunim: “Many waters cannot extinguish the love”: in exile, etc.; “they would utterly scorn him.”
The Tikkunei Zohar reads “many waters cannot extinguish the love” as the love of Israel in exile, which no hardship can put out.
והיינו מפני שאז האהבה היא בצמאון וחולת אהבה וכמ״ש (תלים סג) צמאה לך נפשי25 כו׳
And this is because then the love is in thirst and lovesickness, as it is written (Psalms 63), “My soul thirsts for You, etc.,
In exile the love is a thirst and a lovesickness, as King David wrote in the desert.
בארץ ציה ועיף בלי מים בלי מים דייקא שמחמת שאין מים גדלה בחינת הצמאון כו׳
in a parched and weary land without water.” “Without water,” precisely: because there is no water, the level of thirst grows, etc.
“Without water” is the point: the lack itself makes the thirst stronger.
(וע׳ על פסוק זה בזהר פ׳ ויקרא דכ״א ע״ב26 ובפ׳ תרומה דק״מ סע״א27 ועמ״ש לעיל בפ׳ נח בד״ה מים רבים) וזהו ואני אראה בשונאי28 דוקא היינו היצה״ר כד אתכפיא כו׳.29
(And see on this verse the Zohar, Parshas Vayikra, 21b, and Parshas Terumah, 140a at the end; and see what is written above, in Parshas Noach, in the section beginning “Many waters.”) And this is “And I shall see my foes,” precisely: that is, the evil inclination, when it is subdued, etc.
This is also the meaning of “I shall see my foes”: the evil inclination, when a person subdues it, reveals a greater light than was there before.
אך ע״ז התפלל דוד המע״ה כן בקדש חזיתיך30 (עיין בזהר תרומה דק״מ תחלת ע״ב) שיהיה אהבה כזו גם בקדש
But for this David, the king, peace be upon him, prayed, “So in holiness have I beheld You” (see the Zohar, Terumah, 140, the beginning of side b): that there be such a love also in holiness,
Yet David prayed, “So in holiness have I beheld You”: that such a love, born of distance, should exist also in holiness.
דהיינו במעלת ומדרגת הצדיקים כי הנה אהבה זו היא מבחי׳ בע״ת31 ובמקום שבע״ת32 עומדים אין צדיקים גמורים כו׳.
that is, in the virtue and rank of the righteous; for this love is from the level of penitents, and “in the place where penitents stand, the perfectly righteous do not [stand], etc.”
That thirsting love belongs to penitents (baalei teshuvah), and the Talmud teaches that they reach a place the perfectly righteous cannot. David asked that the righteous too have it.
Except that Moshe our teacher, peace be upon him, attained the level of teshuvah before his passing. And the virtue of Mashiach is “to bring the righteous to return in teshuvah,”
Moshe attained teshuvah before his passing. Mashiach’s special task, in the Zohar’s words, is to bring even the righteous to teshuvah.
דהיינו שתהי׳ מעלת ומדריגת התשובה מתגלה בצדיקים גמורים שזה תלוי בביאת משיח דוקא. וזהו כן בקדש חזיתיך35 שיהי׳ בחי׳ לאתבא צדיקייא כו׳.
that is, that the virtue and rank of teshuvah be revealed in the perfectly righteous, and this depends on the coming of Mashiach specifically. And this is “So in holiness have I beheld You”: that there be the level of “bringing the righteous to return, etc.”
That is, the special quality of teshuvah will be revealed in the perfectly righteous, and this depends on Mashiach’s coming. This is what David prayed for.
כי כללות ישראל צריכים לחזור בתשובה קודם ביאת המשיח וביאת המשיח תלוי בזה כמארז״ל אם ישראל36 עושים תשובה נגאלין כו׳. אבל צדיקים שיזכו למעלת התשובה יהי׳ אחר ביאת המשיח דוקא:37
For the Jewish people as a whole must return in teshuvah before the coming of Mashiach, and the coming of Mashiach depends on this, as our Sages said, “If Israel do teshuvah, they are redeemed, etc.” But that the righteous attain the virtue of teshuvah will be only after the coming of Mashiach.
The order matters: the Jewish people as a whole must do teshuvah before Mashiach comes, and the redemption depends on it; the teshuvah of the righteous will come only after he comes.
Through the two feasts of Esther, the paragraph explains the second day of Yom Tov as a second, lower revelation for all Jews in exile, whose joy and thirsting love exceed those of the first; it ends with David’s prayer that this love of the penitent reach the righteous too, which will happen through Mashiach.
The Kehot note says the Tikkunim passage meant is perhaps Tikkunei Zohar tikkun 21 (51a), where the words are missing. The note also records that the reading of “So in holiness have I beheld You” is quoted in several places from the Alter Rebbe in the name of the Baal Shem Tov. The “higher rose” and the “rose among the thorns” are two levels of Malchus: in Atzilus, and descended into exile.
Marei mekomos
- 1בהתגלות המלך יש מדרגות רבות · ראה ד״ה אנכי אנכי תרס״ט ע׳ כד.
- 2עשה משתה · בתרס״ט שם נוסף: די״ל שזהו בחי׳ המל׳ כמו שנעשה כתר לבריאה.
- 3על כסא מלכותו . . ושרי המדינות לפניו · Esther 1:2
- 4על כסא מלכותו אשר בשושן הבירה כו׳ עשה משתה לכל שריו ועבדיו כו׳. ושרי המדינות לפניו · Esther 1:2–3
- 5לכל העם הנמצאים · אסתר שם, (ה). [כ].
- 6לכל העם הנמצאים בשושן למגדול ועדקטן כו׳ בחצר גינת ביתן המלך · Esther 1:5
- 7באר חפרוה שרים · Numbers 21:18
- 8בד״ה ועתה יגדל נא · לעיל פ׳ שלח.
- 9בבית המלכות נוכח פתח הבית · Esther 5:1
- 10שושנת העמקים · Song of Songs 2:1
- 11שושן עמק איומה · לשון הפיוט תחילת מוסף של יו״כ. בי׳ ע״ז מ״ש כאן ע׳ מג״א [מגן אבות, ברדיטשוב תרס״ב] ד״ה יהודא בן תימא (במג״א ה). [כ].
- 12ממקור כנס״י . . בבחי׳ כשושנה בין החוחים · Song of Songs 2:2
- 13עיין בזהר בתחלתו בגין דאית שושנה ואית שושנה · Zohar, Introduction 1:1–2:4
- 14בזהר בתחלתו בגין . . ובזהר הרקיע שם · א, א.
- 15ובזהר ויחי (דרכ״א ע״א) · בענין שושנת העמקים דקיומא בעמיקתא דכולא . . במק״מ בינה שנק׳ שושנה עילאה — אוה״ת מג״א ע׳ כז (הוצאת הראשונה ע׳ ב׳רפו).
- 16ובפ׳ כי תשא (דקפ״ט ריש ע״ב) ובפי׳ הרמ״ז · ”ושושנה דסלקא ריחין כו׳ ההיא דסלקא בין החוחים כו׳ וכתב הרמ״ז . . ודע כי שושנה העליונה היא מל׳ דאצילות ושושנה בין החוחים היא מלכות התחתונה שהיא בין ע׳ שרים שלוקטת תוכיות הניצוצות שמובלעים ביניהם שהוא סוד רפ״ח ניצוצין וע״כ סלקא ריחין כו׳” — אוה״ת שה״ש כרך א ע׳ קפג.
- 17ובזהר פ׳ פנחס דרל״ג ע״ב · Zohar, Pinchas 57:348–350
- 18שאין אנו יכולים לעלות ולראות · מוסף דיו״ט.
- 19מי יעלה בהר ה׳ · Psalms 24:3
- 20השמחה ביתר שאת · ראה לקו״ש ח״ט ע׳ 235.
- 21וכמשל בן כפר שראה את המלך · Chagigah 13b:5
- 22והאופנים ברעש גדול · ברכת יוצר.
- 23וכמו דאיתא בתיקונים · אולי כוונתו ת״ז (תכ״א) נא, א ששם חסר. [כ].
- 24מים רבים לא יוכלו לכבות את האהבה · Song of Songs 8:7
- 25
- 26וע׳ על פסוק זה בזהר פ׳ ויקרא דכ״א ע״ב · Zohar, Vayikra 52:361–54:369
- 27ובפ׳ תרומה דק״מ סע״א · Zohar, Terumah 26:261–28:270
- 28ואני אראה בשונאי · Psalms 118:7
- 29כד אתכפיא כו׳ · Zohar II, 128b
- 30כן בקדש חזיתיך · Psalms 63:3
- 31אהבה זו היא מבחי׳ בע״ת · ראה לקו״ש חי״ט ע׳ 382. מובא בכ״מ בשם ארז״ל. ראה רבות שה״ש עה״פ. וראה בהערה במאמרי אדה״א פ׳ שלח במילואים לע׳ תתקצד. [ע׳ א׳רעט].
- 32ובמקום שבע״ת · Berakhot 34b:28
- 33לאתבא צדיקיא בתיובתא · Zohar III, 153b
- 34לאתבא צדיקייא בתיובתא · Zohar, Beha'alotcha 15:87–16:94
- 35וזהו כן בקדש חזיתיך · בכמה מקומות מובא זה מאדה״ז בשם הבעש״ט.
- 36אם ישראל עושין תשובה נגאלין · Sanhedrin 97b:14–15
- 37
Two lenses: Torah and prayer ¶20–22
20עוי״ל בענין יו״ט שני. דהנה ענין יראה כל זכורך כו׳ שיהיה בחי׳ ראיה והתגלות מלמעלה.
It may further be said regarding the second day of Yom Tov: the matter of “all your males shall appear, etc.” is that there be a level of seeing and revelation from above.
A second explanation of the second day of Yom Tov, again based on “all your males shall appear”: the pilgrimage was a revelation of G‑d’s “seeing” from above.
והיינו ע״י שהאדם בא לראות המקום בשתי עיניו של אדם כו׳ (רפ״ק דחגיגה1 ע״ש) והנה כל הנביאים ראו ע״י אספקלריא
And this is through a person coming to see the place with his two eyes, etc. (beginning of the first chapter of Chagigah; see there). Now, all the prophets saw through an aspaklaria (a lens),
The Talmud requires the pilgrim to see with both eyes. This leads to the two kinds of “seeing” in prophecy: all prophets saw through an aspaklaria, a lens or mirror.
אלא שמשה רבינו נתנבא באספקלריא המאירה23 ושאר הנביאים נתנבאו באספקלריא שאינה מאירה ועיין בשמונה פרקים להרמב״ם פ״ז מה שכתב בזה ע״פ דרך המחקר.
except that Moshe our teacher prophesied through a luminous aspaklaria, and the other prophets prophesied through an aspaklaria that does not shine. And see in the Eight Chapters of the Rambam, chapter 7, what he wrote on this according to the way of philosophical inquiry.
Moshe saw through a clear, shining lens; the other prophets through a dim one. Maimonides explains the difference philosophically in his Eight Chapters.
אך ע״פ הקבלה יש ממש ב׳ בחי׳ ראייה הנ״ל וכמ״ש מזה בד״ה ת״ר מצות נר חנוכה4 ב״ש אומרים כו׳
But according to the Kabbalah there are, in actual fact, two levels of the above-mentioned seeing, as is explained about this in the section beginning “Our Rabbis taught: The mitzvah of the Chanukah light… Beis Shammai say, etc.,”
In the Kabbalah these are two real levels of revelation, as the Alter Rebbe explains in a maamar on the Chanukah lights.
מענין ב׳ בחי׳ אספקלריא הנ״ל וזהו ענין שכל הנביאים נתנבאו בכה ומשה נתנבא בזה5 כמ״ש מזה סד״ה ראשי המטות6 ושאר דוכתי
regarding the two levels of aspaklaria mentioned above. And this is the matter that all the prophets prophesied with “thus” (koh), and Moshe prophesied with “this” (zeh), as is explained about this at the end of the section beginning “The heads of the tribes,” and in other places.
The other prophets said “Thus (koh) says G‑d,” while Moshe said “This (zeh) is the thing”: a direct, clear vision, as opposed to a likeness.
והנה מבואר שם בד״ה ת״ר הנ״ל איך בכל אדם בעבודת ה׳ יש ג״כ ב׳ בחינות אספקלריא הנ״ל והיינו כי עסק התורה ומצות זהו כענין בחי׳ אספקלריא דנהרא
And it is explained there, in the above-mentioned section beginning “Our Rabbis taught,” how in every person, in the service of G‑d, there are also the two levels of aspaklaria mentioned above. That is: occupation with Torah and mitzvos is like the level of the aspaklaria that shines,
Every Jew has both levels in his service of G‑d. Torah study and mitzvos correspond to the shining lens.
שהרי בעסק התורה נאמר ודברי אשר שמתי בפיך.7 שזהו ע״ד משה נתנבא בזה וכמ״ש בד״ה ראשי המטות בפי׳ לאמר זה הדבר.8
for regarding occupation with Torah it is said, “and My words which I have placed in your mouth.” This is like “Moshe prophesied with ‘this,’” and as is explained in the section beginning “The heads of the tribes,” on the meaning of “saying: This is the thing.”
When a Jew learns Torah, “My words which I have placed in your mouth,” G‑d’s own words are in his mouth, like Moshe, through whose throat the Shechinah spoke.
The paragraph introduces the two kinds of prophetic vision, the shining and the non-shining aspaklaria, and says that in every Jew Torah and mitzvos are the shining one.
In Kabbalah the shining aspaklaria is Z’eir Anpin and the non-shining one is Malchus, which has no light of its own but reflects. The next paragraph applies the non-shining lens to prayer and to the second day of Yom Tov.
Marei mekomos
- 1בשתי עיניו של אדם כו׳ (רפ״ק דחגיגה · Chagigah 2a:6
- 2שמשה רבינו . . באספקלריא המאירה · Yevamot 49b:10–11
- 3אספקלריא המאירה · Zohar, Yitro 19:324–20:333
- 4בד״ה ת״ר מצות נר חנוכה · תו״א לג, א. וראה לקמן בשה״ש כח, ב ובמ״מ לשם.
- 5שכל הנביאים נתנבאו בכה ומשה נתנבא בזה · Rashi on Numbers 30:3
- 6סד״ה ראשי המטות · לעיל פ׳ מטות.
- 7ודברי אשר שמתי בפיך · Isaiah 59:21
- 8לאמר זה הדבר · Numbers 30:2
21ובחי׳ ק״ש ותפלה בכל לבבך1 בשני יצריך2 זהו ענין אספקלריא שאינה מאירה שהוא ע״י כיסוי וצפוי מכסף דק שעי״ז נעשה אור חוזר כו׳ להיות בכל מאדך.
And the level of the Shema and prayer, “with all your heart,” with both your inclinations, is the matter of the aspaklaria that does not shine, which is through a covering and coating of thin silver, through which reflected light comes about, etc., so as to be “with all your might.”
Prayer and the Shema involve both of a person’s inclinations, the good and the evil, since one is to love G‑d “with all your heart.” This is the non-shining lens: a mirror, whose glass is backed with a thin coating of silver, gives no light of its own but reflects light back (or chozer, “returning light”), the effort that rises from below, “with all your might.”
ועמ״ש מזה בביאור ע״פ צאינה וראינה3 בענין ממושבותיכם תביאו4 כו׳ והנה עיקר בחי׳ זו דאספקלריא שאינה מאירה הוא עכשיו שאין בהמ״ק קיים
And see what is written about this in the explanation on the verse “Go out and see,” regarding “From your dwellings you shall bring, etc.” Now, the essence of this level of the aspaklaria that does not shine is now, when the Holy Temple does not stand,
This non-shining level, service that rises from below through effort, is the main mode of our time, when the Temple is not standing.
וכמ״ש מזה סד״ה יונתי בחגוי5 בפי׳ וענין הראיני את מראיך6 כו׳ ע״ש באריכות וכמ״ש סד״ה לא טוב היות האדם לבדו7 בפי׳ אעשה לו עזר כנגדו.8
and as is explained about this at the end of the section beginning “My dove, in the clefts of the rock,” on the meaning and matter of “Show me your appearance, etc.” (see there at length), and as is explained at the end of the section beginning “It is not good for the man to be alone,” on the meaning of “I will make him a helper opposite him.”
The Alter Rebbe refers to two maamarim: one on “Show me your appearance” in Song of Songs, and one on Eve as a “helper opposite” Adam, where the female, receiving side and its special quality are discussed.
Prayer, which engages both inclinations and rises from below, is the non-shining aspaklaria, the mirror that reflects light back; this is the chief mode of service in exile.
In Kabbalistic terms the mirror that reflects is Malchus, the “female,” and the reflected light (or chozer) is service that rises from below. The resolved passage in the Kehot note adds that one can “arouse” the higher levels only from below, in Beriah, and so the lower vantage point has its own power.
Marei mekomos
- 1בכל לבבך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 2בכל לבבך בשני יצריך · Mishnah Berakhot 9:5
- 3בביאור ע״פ צאינה וראינה · לקמן שה״ש כח, ב. וראה במ״מ לשם.
- 4ממושבותיכם תביאו · Leviticus 23:17
- 5סד״ה יונתי בחגוי · לקמן בשה״ש יז, ג.
- 6הראיני את מראיך · Song of Songs 2:14
- 7סד״ה לא טוב היות האדם לבדו · תו״א ה, א.
- 8אעשה לו עזר כנגדו · Genesis 2:18
22ועפ״ז י״ל שזהו ענין יו״ט שני כי יו״ט ראשון שהוא מדאורייתא נמשך בחי׳ יראה את פני מבחי׳ ומדרגת אספקלריא דנהרא
And according to this it may be said that this is the matter of the second day of Yom Tov: for on the first day of Yom Tov, which is from the Torah, the level of “shall appear before My face” is drawn down from the level and rank of the aspaklaria that shines;
Now the second day of Yom Tov is explained. The first day, commanded by the Torah, draws down the “appearing before G‑d” from the shining lens: revelation from above.
אבל י״ט שני עושים לקבלת בחי׳ ראיה מבחי׳ אספקלריא דלא נהרא כו׳ וכמ״ש ברבות דבחי׳ יראה כל זכורך1 זהו ענין הראיני את מראיך2
but the second day of Yom Tov is made to receive the level of seeing from the level of the aspaklaria that does not shine, etc. And as is written in the Midrash Rabbah, the level of “all your males shall appear” is the matter of “Show me your appearance.”
The second day, instituted by the Sages, receives the “seeing” through the non-shining lens. The Midrash links “all your males shall appear” to “Show me your appearance”: G‑d wishes to see Israel.
והרי מבואר סד״ה יונתי בחגוי הנ״ל דבחי׳ הראיני את מראיך זהו ע״ד תשובה שהיא בחי׳ מראה
And it is explained at the end of the above-mentioned section beginning “My dove, in the clefts of the rock,” that the level of “Show me your appearance” is in the manner of teshuvah, which is the level of a mirror (mar’eh),
In the maamar on that verse, “Show me your appearance” is explained as teshuvah, and the word mar’eh (appearance) also means “mirror.”
כמו (שפיג״על) הנק׳ אספקלריא דלא נהרא ויש בזה מעלה יתירה בבחי׳ אחת כו׳ וכמו והאופנים ברעש כו׳:
like (a “shpigel”), which is called the aspaklaria that does not shine. And in this there is a surpassing virtue in one respect, etc., like “And the Ofanim, with noise, etc.”
A mirror (the Yiddish shpigel) is the non-shining lens. Yet it has a special virtue, like the Ofanim whose noise is greater than the Seraphim’s: the second day has a quality the first lacks.
The first day of Yom Tov receives from the shining lens, revelation from above; the second day receives from the non-shining lens, the mirror of teshuvah, which has its own advantage.
This ties together the maamar’s strands: the lattices, the second feast in the outer court, the love of the penitent, and now the mirror all describe a lower level that nonetheless reaches something the higher level does not.
Marei mekomos
- 1יראה כל זכורך · Deuteronomy 16:16
- 2הראיני את מראיך · Song of Songs 2:14
The letter hei and the Land of Israel ¶23–29
23גם יש להעיר לענין יו״ט ראשון וי״ט שני ממ״ש חכמי האמת בפי׳ בית ראשון ובית שני1 שהם23 ה׳ עילאה וה׳ תתאה וכמ״ש מזה בד״ה יו״ט של ר״ה4 שחל להיות בשבת ע״ש אות ה׳.
It may also be noted, regarding the first day of Yom Tov and the second day of Yom Tov, what the sages of truth wrote explaining the First Temple and the Second Temple: that they are the upper hei and the lower hei. And as is explained about this in the section beginning “The Yom Tov of Rosh Hashanah that fell on Shabbos”; see there, letter hei.
A further hint: the Kabbalists (“the sages of truth”) say that the First and Second Temples correspond to the two letters hei in the Name Havayah, the upper hei (Binah) and the lower hei (Malchus). The first and second days of Yom Tov may correspond to them too.
The paragraph suggests that the first and second days of Yom Tov, like the First and Second Temples, correspond to the upper and lower hei of the Name Havayah.
In the Name Havayah the first hei is Binah and the final hei is Malchus. The Kehot note lists Zohar and Tikkunei Zohar passages on the two Temples as the two hei’s.
Marei mekomos
- 1בית ראשון . . שני · ע׳ זח״א (כז, ב). ובת״ז (תכ״א) מח, א. וריש תכ״ב. שם (קעב, ב). [תז״ח קיג, א]. (קעו, א). [תז״ח קטז, ג], יעו״ש. ד׳ זיטמיר. [כ].
- 2בית ראשון ובית שני שהם ה׳ עילאה וה׳ תתאה · Zohar, Bereshit 24:264–25:273
- 3בית ראשון ובית שני שהם ה׳ עילאה וה׳ תתאה · Tikkunei Zohar 48a:17–19
- 4בד״ה יו״ט של ר״ה · לעיל דרושים לר״ה.
24ולכן נק׳ בחי׳ זו שני כי אות ה׳ נכפלה ב׳ פעמים בשם הוי׳. ועד״ז יש לפרש בענין יו״ט שביו״ט ראשון מקבלים כנס״י מבחי׳ ה׳ עילאה וביו״ט שני מבחי׳ ה׳ תתאה.
And therefore this level is called “second,” because the letter hei is doubled, [appearing] twice in the Name Havayah. And in the same way one may explain regarding Yom Tov: that on the first day of Yom Tov the Community of Israel receives from the level of the upper hei, and on the second day of Yom Tov from the level of the lower hei.
The lower level is called “second” because hei appears twice in the Name. So on the first day the Jewish people receive from the upper hei, on the second from the lower hei.
או י״ל כי גם בבחי׳ ה׳ אחרונה יש מילוי ה׳ והיא בחי׳ ההכפלה כמ״ש בענין שדה המכפלה1 בד״ה יגלה לן טעמיה כו׳ ואפ״ל שזהו ענין יו״ט שני כו׳ ואפשר שהן הן ג״כ ב׳ בחי׳ אספקלריא הנ״ל.
Or it may be said that in the level of the last hei too there is the filling of the hei, and this is the level of the doubling, as is explained regarding “the field of Machpelah” in the section beginning “Let its reason be revealed to us, etc.” And it may be said that this is the matter of the second day of Yom Tov, etc.; and it may be that these are also the two levels of aspaklaria mentioned above.
Or: the final hei itself is “doubled,” since when spelled out (hei-alef or hei-hei) it has a second letter, its “filling” (milui). This doubling, like the “double” cave of Machpelah, may be the second day, and the two may match the two lenses.
The paragraph offers two ways to see the “second” day in the Name Havayah: as the second hei, or as the spelled-out “filling” of the final hei.
Marei mekomos
- 1שדה המכפלה · Genesis 49:30
25ועפ״ז י״ל שזהו מ״ש הרמ״ק בספר אור נערב שבח״ל אינם יכולים לקבל ההארה ביום אחד כמו שמקבלים בא״י
And according to this it may be said that this is what the Ramak wrote in the book Or Ne’erav: that in the Diaspora they cannot receive the illumination in one day as they receive it in the Land of Israel,
The Ramak (Rabbi Moshe Cordovero) wrote in Or Ne’erav that the Diaspora cannot receive in one day the light that the Land of Israel receives, and so needs a second day.
אלא צ״ל יום שני1 כו׳ כי כל יו״ט הוא המשכה והתגלות קדושה עליונה מלמעלה מהזמן בבחי׳ הזמן
but there must be a second day, etc. For every Yom Tov is a drawing down and revelation of supernal holiness from above time into the level of time,
The reason: a festival brings holiness that is above time down into time.
כמאמר מקדש ישראל והזמנים ולכן עושים אותו יו״ט ע״ד את האור כי טוב2 וע״ד שער החצר הפנימית3 כו׳ וביום השבת יפתח
as in the blessing, “Who sanctifies Israel and the times.” Therefore it is made a “good day” (yom tov), in the manner of “the light, that it was good,” and in the manner of “the gate of the inner court, etc., on the day of Shabbos it shall be opened.”
The blessing “Who sanctifies Israel and the times” shows this. That is why it is called Yom Tov, a “good day,” after the primordial light “that it was good,” and why the inner gate of the Temple opens on Shabbos and festivals.
And therefore it is said, “A psalm, a song for the day of Shabbos: It is good to give thanks.” And see what is written on the meaning of “good,” briefly, on the verse “Va’eschanan.”
The Shabbos psalm, “It is good to give thanks,” links Shabbos too with “good.” The meaning of “good” is explained in a summary of a maamar on Va’eschanan.
והנה בא״י שנאמר בה ארץ אשר7 ה׳ אלקיך דורש אותה יכולים לקבל ביום אחד אותו האור כי טוב ובח״ל צ״ל שני ימים ויש לפרש
Now, in the Land of Israel, of which it is said, “a land which the L‑rd your G‑d seeks out,” they can receive that light, “that it was good,” in one day; and in the Diaspora there must be two days. And it may be explained
The Land of Israel, on which G‑d’s eyes always rest, can receive this “good” light in one day. The Diaspora needs two, and the Alter Rebbe now explains why.
כי כל המשכת האור למטה הוא ע״י ה׳ אחרונה דשם הוי׳ ויש בה מילוי ה׳ כנ״ל
that every drawing down of the light below is through the last hei of the Name Havayah, and in it there is the filling of the hei, as above.
All light that comes down reaches us through the final hei of Havayah (Malchus), which has its “filling.”
והנה כמו המילוי של הה״א שכשכותבים האות בכתב א״צ כלל להמילוי כי משיגים בטוב את האות ע״י עצם האות לבד.
Now, as with the filling of the hei: when one writes the letter in writing, there is no need at all for the filling, for one grasps the letter well through the essence of the letter alone;
An analogy: when writing the letter hei, one writes only the letter itself; its spelled-out form is not needed to know it.
רק כשצריך לומר האות בדבור הוא ע״י המילוי של האות כו׳ דלא סגי בלאו הכי.
only when one needs to say the letter in speech is it through the filling of the letter, etc., for it is not possible without it.
Only to say the letter aloud must one pronounce its full name, “hei,” with its filling.
Following the Ramak, the paragraph explains that each festival brings timeless holiness into time; the Land of Israel receives it in one day, as a letter is grasped in writing by itself, while the Diaspora needs two, as a letter must be spelled out to be spoken.
The contrast between writing and speech prepares the next paragraph: the written word is from a higher world than the spoken one.
Marei mekomos
- 1שבח״ל . . צ״ל יום שני · ראה להלן בהוספות להערות וציונים.
- 2את האור כי טוב · Genesis 1:4
- 3שער החצר הפנימית · Ezekiel 46:1
- 4מזמור שיר ליום השבת טוב · Psalms 92:1
- 5מזמור שיר ליום השבת טוב להודות · Psalms 92:1–2
- 6בקיצור ע״פ ואתחנן · לעיל ג, א.
- 7ארץ אשר ה״א דורש אותה · Deuteronomy 11:12
26וידוע מענין קרי וכתיב1 שהכתיב הוא בעולם העליון2 יותר וכמשארז״ל ספ״ג דפסחים בענין זה שמי לעולם3 לא כמו שאני נכתב אני נקרא4 כו׳. וכך בא״י יכולים לקבל השפע מעצם אות ה׳ דשם הוי׳.
And it is known, regarding the matter of the read and the written, that the written is in a higher world; and as our Sages said at the end of chapter 3 of Pesachim on this matter: “‘My Name forever’: not as I am written am I read, etc.” And so in the Land of Israel they can receive the flow from the essence of the letter hei of the Name Havayah.
In the Torah some words are written one way and read another (kri and ksiv); the written form belongs to a higher world. The Talmud reads “This is My Name forever” as “not as I am written am I read”: the Name is written as Havayah but read as Ado-nai. So the Land of Israel receives from the letter hei itself, as in writing.
The written word is higher than the spoken one, as the Divine Name is written one way and read another; the Land of Israel receives from the written, essential letter.
Marei mekomos
- 1וידוע מענין קרי וכתיב · ראה אגה״ק סי׳ יט.
- 2שהכתיב הוא בעולם העליון · ראה לעיל תזריע כא, ד. תו״א צח, א.
- 3שמי לעולם · Exodus 3:15
- 4
And just as in the Temple they would say the Name as it is written, but in the Diaspora it is impossible to receive from this level alone, only through its enclothement in the filling of the hei.
In the Temple the priests pronounced the Name as written; outside it, only by its substitute. So the Diaspora can receive only through the “filling,” the spelled-out, spoken form.
וכמו עד״מ אור וזיו השמש שכל שהאור והזיו קרוב להמאור יותר אזי נראה מעט הכמות יותר ואחר שנמשך בריחוק מקום מהמקור אזי נראה רב יותר.
And as, by way of analogy, with the light and radiance of the sun: the nearer the light and radiance are to the luminary, the smaller its quantity appears; and once it has been drawn to a distance from the source, it appears greater.
Light near the sun seems small and concentrated; far from it, it seems spread over a larger area. Near the source the light is essential; far away it needs more “volume”: two days instead of one.
As the Name was said as written only in the Temple, the Diaspora receives only through the expanded “filling”; like sunlight, what is far from the source appears larger but is more diluted.
Marei mekomos
- 1שבמקדש היו אומרים את השם ככתבו · סוטה פ״ז, מ״ב.
- 2שבמקדש היו אומרים את השם ככתבו · Mishnah Sotah 7:6
28וכמו מעין ונהר שהמעיין לקרבתו אל מקורו הוא קטן יותר כו׳. ובאמת זה המועט של המעין הוא כמו כל הנהר ע״ד רגלי החיות כנגד כולן1 ולכן המעיין מטהר2 בכל שהוא34 כו׳.
And as with a spring and a river: the spring, because of its nearness to its source, is smaller, etc. And in truth this small amount of the spring is like the whole river, in the manner of “the feet of the Chayos are equal to all of them”; and therefore a spring purifies in any amount, etc.
A spring close to its source is small, but its little water contains the whole river, as the Chayos’ feet equal the whole heavens. This is why a spring purifies with any amount of water, while a mikveh of gathered water needs a full measure.
The analogy of the spring shows that what is near the source is small in size but complete in power, like the one day of the Land of Israel.
Marei mekomos
- 1רגלי החיות כנגד כולן · Chagigah 13a:4
- 2המעיין מטהר בכ״ש · מקואות פ״א, מ״ז. [חידושי הצ״צ למשניות שם]. רמב״ם הל׳ מקואות פ״ט ה״ו ואילך.
- 3המעיין מטהר בכל שהוא · Mishnah Mikvaot 1:7
- 4המעיין מטהר בכל שהוא · Mishneh Torah, Immersion Pools 9:6
29ועמ״ש סד״ה מים רבים בפ׳ נח ומ״ש בשה״ש סד״ה ששים המה מלכות בענין מעיין ונהר.
And see what is written at the end of the section beginning “Many waters,” in Parshas Noach, and what is written in Song of Songs at the end of the section beginning “There are sixty queens,” on the matter of spring and river.
References to other maamarim that discuss the spring and the river.
וז״ש ברבות בשה״ש ע״פ שמוני נוטרה את הכרמים1 אמרה כנ״י בא״י הייתי שומר יום אחד עכשיו שני ימים סבורה הייתי לקבל שכר על שניהן ואיני מקבלת
And this is what is said in the Midrash Rabbah on Song of Songs, on the verse “They made me keeper of the vineyards”: the Community of Israel said, “In the Land of Israel I kept one day; now, two days. I thought I would receive reward for both, but I receive [reward]
The Midrash puts words in the mouth of the Jewish people in exile: in the Land I kept one day, now I keep two, and I expected reward for both.
אלא על יום אחד שהרי באמת אותה ההארה המאיר בחו״ל בשני ימים מאיר בא״י ביום אחד לקורבתו אל מקורו וע׳ זח״א ס״פ נח (ע״ו ב׳) גם
only for one day.” For in truth that same illumination which shines in the Diaspora in two days shines in the Land of Israel in one day, because of its nearness to its source. And see Zohar volume I, end of Noach (76b). Also,
But I receive only for one, since the light of two days in the Diaspora equals the light of one day in the Land of Israel, which is closer to the source.
כמו בעצם האות ה׳ כלול ג״כ המילוי שלו שהיא ה׳ השנייה היא כלולה בהעלם ג״כ בעצם האות כו׳
just as in the essence of the letter hei its filling is also included, the second hei too is included, in concealment, in the essence of the letter, etc.
Likewise, the letter hei contains its filling hidden within it; the spelled-out form only reveals what the letter itself already holds.
ומ״מ מ״ש לעיל שיש מעלה יתירה בגילוי זה די״ט שני ג״כ נכון ע״פ מ״ש במ״א כה״ג בענין המלוי שזהו עיקר הכוונה להיות
And nonetheless, what was said above, that there is a surpassing virtue in this revelation of the second day of Yom Tov, is also correct, according to what is explained elsewhere in a similar way regarding the filling: that this is the main intent, that there be
Still, the earlier claim that the second day has an advantage stands. The purpose of creation is that G‑d be revealed below, and the “filling” is exactly that revelation.
הגילוי למטה2 וכמ״ש האריז״ל3 בפי׳ העונה אמן יהא שמיה רבא בכל כחו4 ופי׳ כח אד׳ היינו כח אותיות מלוי המלוי של השם כו׳:
the revelation below; and as the Arizal wrote explaining “One who answers ‘Amen, may His great Name be blessed’ with all his strength (koach)”: and the meaning of “koach” of Ado-nai is the strength of the letters of the filling of the filling of the Name, etc.
The Arizal explains that answering “Amen, may His great Name be blessed” “with all one’s koach (strength)” refers to the letters of the filling of the filling of the Name: the most drawn-out, lowest expansion carries great power.
The maamar closes with the Midrash that the two Diaspora days equal one day in the Land, yet affirms that the second day, as the “filling” that reveals G‑d below, has a virtue of its own, since revelation below is the purpose.
The Kehot note sources the Arizal’s words in Pri Etz Chaim, Gate of the Kaddeishim. The Talmud says that answering “Amen, may His great Name be blessed” with all one’s strength tears up an evil decree. The ending returns to the dwelling place among the lower realms: the lower, “spelled-out” revelation is the purpose of it all.
Marei mekomos
- 1שמוני נוטרה את הכרמים · Song of Songs 1:6
- 2עיקר הכוונה להיות הגילוי למטה · ראה לקו״ש חי״ט ע׳ 382.
- 3וכמ״ש האריז״ל · פע״ח ש׳ הקדישים.
- 4העונה אמן יהא שמיה רבא בכל כחו · Shabbat 119b:5
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
In one’s avodah
A person must first set himself apart through the mitzvos, with the intention of separating from cravings and bad traits, so that his learning and prayer are “retained.” He should contemplate how passing all worldly things are, until his heart is broken and evil crumbles; then open his heart with joy. In exile, the distance itself should kindle a thirsting love for G‑d, and the second day of Yom Tov is a real revelation with its own joy.
Questions for discussion
- Why must “Sanctify us with Your mitzvos” come before “grant us our share in Your Torah”? What does it mean to “retain” Torah and prayer?
- How does the meditation that “a few years ago this did not exist, and in a few years it will be gone” free a person from his desires?
- If the Torah (“man”) and the Patriarchs (“nobles”) are holy, why is it still “better to take refuge in G‑d”?
- What is the difference between G‑d watching “through the windows” and peering “through the lattices,” and why does the maamar link them to the Patriarchs and the Matriarchs?
- In what way can the second day of Yom Tov, a lower revelation, bring a greater joy than the first?
Key terms in this maamar
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×4
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Deep connection to an idea, bridging intellect and emotion. ×3
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×5
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- Divine light too great to enter the worlds; it 'surrounds' them and affects them from beyond.
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- Tzimtzum (contraction)צמצום
- The self-concealment of the Infinite Light that makes room for finite worlds. ×2
- The World of Atzilus (Emanation)אצילות
- The highest world, still one with G‑d. ×10
- The World of Beriah (Creation)בריאה
- The first world of separate existence. ×10
- The Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof)אור אין סוף
- G‑d's light as it is, beyond all limits, before any contraction.
- Self-sacrifice (mesirus nefesh)מסירות נפש
- Giving oneself over entirely to G‑d.
- Yesod (foundation)יסוד
- The channel that connects and transmits. ×8
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- Developing and grasping an insight in detail. ×1
- Tiferes (beauty)תפארת
- Harmony of kindness and restraint; associated with compassion. ×1
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- Kingship: the level through which G‑d's word creates and rules the worlds. ×4
- Keser (the Crown)כתר
- The level above intellect: divine will and delight. ×1
- The higher unity (yichuda ila'ah)יחודא עילאה
- The world is nothing next to G‑d.
- The World of Yetzirah (Formation)יצירה
- The world of the angels and emotions. ×1
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest world, including our physical one.
- The lower unity (yichuda tata'ah)יחודא תתאה
- G‑d is present within the world's existence.
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Setting aside one's own sense of self before G‑d. ×5
- The Shechinah (Divine Presence)שכינה
- G‑d's presence as it dwells in the world.
- The sitra achra (the other side)סטרא אחרא
- The realm opposed to holiness.
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning to G‑d; not only repentance. ×7